People are mad at Sm‘s way of training their trainees because they say it’s too hard but it’s also obviously working. Their vocals make me feel a lot of feelings. Don’t even know hot to describe it. It’s too beautiful
Honestly they know what they’re doing and I love that they always want to improve in skill not in appearance like other groups ( not saying that æspa isn’t beautiful)
Karina and Giselle Im so proud, i knew you two are great vocalist, Winter and ningning never dissapoint us. Im crying your voices feels like Im in heaven. Thankyou for giving us such a good song. "FOREVER MY"
Sometimes, NingNing's voice gives me Tiffany vibes and I really don't know why. Also I don't see many people appreciating Karina's vocals. I already knew about giselle's soft vocals since she was in a choir before but for Karina I felt it was more shocking since the only time we listened her singing properly was her pre debut video and there she showed her high notes but this really showed how soft her voice is and that she's great at vibrato kinda stuff, she really surprised me the most! And I think she has my favourite voice for now, it's very deep and soothing to listen to, even her talking voice is satisfying to listen to!
After listening to Karina’s voice I already knew who my bias is. No kidding, I love ballad songs and her vocals just give me chills, esp her last line its different and just beautiful.
Danggg Karina has such full and rich vocal tone with a bit of husky and deep voice. She sounds so attractive and eargasm. I really love her voice. Everyone really can sing huh damn. Cannot wait for more projects from them and what else they can deliver us.
This is not the actual comeback of aespa. Forever is a song by Yoo Young-jin which was originally released in 2000 and now aespa made their own version. Forever is a great song. It showcases their vocals. Wait for their actual comeback. There is a rumor that aespa will comeback with their first mini album. And in their comeback we can already hear Karina and Giselle rapping. I hope you can wait! MYs, let's be with aespa forever!
With Kariselle's deep voices, choir experience and rap skills and Winning's top-notch vocals I think SM has enough material to work with! I can't wait for their mini album
When Giselle and Karina started singing my mouth dropped wide open, I was so shook by their talent... SM doesn’t miss when it comes to vocal groups but wbk :)
omg their voice wow! I'm surprised with Karina and Giselle, the main dancer and main rapper can do runs? Wow aespa really said ✨ TALENT ✨ Karina makes me inlove more 😩
@K-Pop Stan idk is because she's a alto, kpop companies hate altos. Alto idols are the most of Time rappers Example: Dreamcatcher Dami Mamamoo Moonbyul G-idle Yuqi(sub-rapper)
@@Swandaylight She's not alto, she's mezzo, just like all the other names you've mentioned. But yes, kpop always prefers sopranos and still makes them strain even higher
It shows how sm vocal traning can improve your singing skills, just hear the difference b4 and aftet debut, crazy Aespa vocal queen you cant say otherwise😂
ngl, they all sang like they didn’t try really hard. Like they sound so at ease! I love black mamba and forever cuz we can see two sides of the song. one be badass and aggressive and the other being soft and beautiful.
I am flattered by Karina’s vocals. She really fits well with Aespa vocals and this song. This proves Giselle is not just a rapper and she can sing too!
Karina seems like a ace catagory...like aren’t they all? But she caught my eyes most. Love from a blink Also,winter.... She is my fav in the grp after karina. As expected from sm,all r main vocal material
This is not the actual comeback of aespa. Forever is a song by Yoo Young-jin which was originally released in 2000 and now aespa made their own version. Forever is a great song. It showcases their vocals. Wait for their actual comeback. There is a rumor that aespa will comeback with their first mini album. And in their comeback we can already hear Karina and Giselle rapping. I hope you can wait! MYs, let's be with aespa forever!
this isn’t a song that’s i think i’d revisit but damn are these girls vocal powerhouses. they all are distinctive and have range to be able to go from Black Mamba to this. It’s great that they can appeal to so many different ppl too since this really reminds me of an ost.
The song was already out when I woke up this morning and let me just tell y'all, hearing these ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS VOCALS first thing in the morning was a wonderful start to my Friday 🥺😌
Why isn't anyone talking about Ninnin? No one notices such a talented and charming girl. Why is she being pushed to the background everywhere.. She's like onda everglow, chaeyoung twice, seulgi red velvet. Most underrated girls in groups. Please take care of them.
I love karina's voice the most. It big, deep, rich tone, strong and clear. I wanna hear more of her vocal
I heard her singing highnotes before debuting she’s such a good singer
Thanks u >
KARINA😊💖💖
Giselle sang in choir for many years so don't be surprised at her vocals!!!
I agree.
Mhm 💕 She did amazing
Giselle slay so much!
@æspa winter fanboy but when?
@æspa winter fanboy and? Do you think we care???
People are mad at Sm‘s way of training their trainees because they say it’s too hard but it’s also obviously working. Their vocals make me feel a lot of feelings. Don’t even know hot to describe it. It’s too beautiful
_✨OMG YES it’s just SM things✨_
agree w u
Honestly they know what they’re doing and I love that they always want to improve in skill not in appearance like other groups ( not saying that æspa isn’t beautiful)
@@Evelyn-bu1hc LOL SURE
@@slayer-dj3dc w h a t
Karina and Giselle Im so proud, i knew you two are great vocalist, Winter and ningning never dissapoint us. Im crying your voices feels like Im in heaven. Thankyou for giving us such a good song. "FOREVER MY"
i'm currently inlove with Giselle's voice!😭😭
Me too 😢
My fav voice in aespa 🥺
I started stanning her in black mamba and that is the best decision I ever made
@æspa winter fanboy winter only sings and dances while giselles can sing dance and rap
@æspa winter fanboy stop being solo stan, stan aespa stan all members.
Sometimes, NingNing's voice gives me Tiffany vibes and I really don't know why. Also I don't see many people appreciating Karina's vocals. I already knew about giselle's soft vocals since she was in a choir before but for Karina I felt it was more shocking since the only time we listened her singing properly was her pre debut video and there she showed her high notes but this really showed how soft her voice is and that she's great at vibrato kinda stuff, she really surprised me the most! And I think she has my favourite voice for now, it's very deep and soothing to listen to, even her talking voice is satisfying to listen to!
omg yess i was wondering cause ningning voice is just familiar
I love both of their voices. Ningning is higher while Fany is lower.
Yaaas I am surprised at Karina's vibrato. It wasn't era. during BM era. She sounds so good. She'll be a high note belter soon. :) i can feel it.
After listening to Karina’s voice I already knew who my bias is. No kidding, I love ballad songs and her vocals just give me chills, esp her last line its different and just beautiful.
Danggg Karina has such full and rich vocal tone with a bit of husky and deep voice. She sounds so attractive and eargasm. I really love her voice. Everyone really can sing huh damn. Cannot wait for more projects from them and what else they can deliver us.
This comeback proved us that aespa's vocal line is ALL MEMBERS!!!
This is not the actual comeback of aespa. Forever is a song by Yoo Young-jin which was originally released in 2000 and now aespa made their own version. Forever is a great song. It showcases their vocals. Wait for their actual comeback. There is a rumor that aespa will comeback with their first mini album. And in their comeback we can already hear Karina and Giselle rapping. I hope you can wait! MYs, let's be with aespa forever!
@@jannadalipesabijon9093 lol Google
The rap line is Karina and Giselle and the vocal line is Winter and Ningning
no one speaking about karina, her vocals are amazing!❤️ her tone is deep and personality i think she doesn't deserve the 'sub vocalist' position
True! They're all so good... At this point I just consider Ningning and Winter main vocals, Giselle and Karina lead vocals
Exactly 💙
Wait i search their position and Karina is not 'sub vocalist' it only say 'vocalist' and Gisselle is the one who have sub vocalist position
@@stfitsme._gigi vocalist and sub vocalist is basically the same-
Karina can really sing well.. But maybe Ningning and Winter got singing skills which makes them the main and lead vocal
5 minute ballad song full with endearing vocals from all the members. Stan aespa before its too late.
I really love this song
With Kariselle's deep voices, choir experience and rap skills and Winning's top-notch vocals I think SM has enough material to work with! I can't wait for their mini album
we all know SM is a power vocal house
Normalise kpop songs to be atleast 5mins instead of 3 mins
Now i feel satisfied 😭🎉
i didn't even realized it was 5 minutes
Same here @@kimjunkyu7123
Yo exactly, my most favourite songs usually end up being under 3 minutes and I always wish they were longer so I totally agree with this
what tf?? this is 5 minutes? i just knew it haha!
@@kimjunkyu7123 same lol until their comment
When Giselle and Karina started singing my mouth dropped wide open, I was so shook by their talent... SM doesn’t miss when it comes to vocal groups but wbk :)
멤버들이 다 메인 보컬 ㄷㄷㄷ 천상지희 이후로 감동이다
맞아요 ㅠㅠ 천상지희 너무 그리워요 ㅠ
엇 그러고보니 천상지희 더그레이어스의 모습이 보이네요 카리나가 옛날 스테파니랑 이미지가 비슷하네요
카리나와 지젤이 랩퍼야 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
젤이 선데이랑 느낌 비슷하네요 ㅎㅎ
에스파들 넷다 잘하는 건 맞는데 천상지희는 어나더임
i cannot believe karina and giselle's voice are so freaking good. giselle's voice are so clear while karina's husky voice gives so much eargasm 🥺
I think they can pull of every concept
Yes, EXACTLY
Agree, like their sunbae, Red velvet
SM thingz
i mean, they're from SM. ✨
SM Groups are really versatile and always coming back fresh and different
Versatility= smgg
omg their voice wow! I'm surprised with Karina and Giselle, the main dancer and main rapper can do runs? Wow aespa really said ✨ TALENT ✨ Karina makes me inlove more 😩
Giselle's voice made me shocked
@K-Pop Stan idk is because she's a alto, kpop companies hate altos.
Alto idols are the most of Time rappers
Example:
Dreamcatcher Dami
Mamamoo Moonbyul
G-idle Yuqi(sub-rapper)
@@Swandaylight She's not alto, she's mezzo, just like all the other names you've mentioned. But yes, kpop always prefers sopranos and still makes them strain even higher
why is no one talking about Winter's voice? it's the most beautiful voice i've ever listened to in the world
no one they always sleep on my girl
the most popular girls usually gets less attention in comments
THOSE RUNS AND RIFFS OF WINTER AND NINGNING IS INSANE. THEIR 4 YEARS OF TRAINING IS ABSOLUTELY SHOWING. ✨✨✨
오랜만에 듣는 SM표 정통 발라드. 좋다~
i swear i didn’t know karina had vocals like THAT. i wanna hear more from her
so glad everyone notice Giselle's vocal. She deserves this
They all sound so good! ㅠㅠㅠ I like Karina's vocal color the most.
Winter's voice is heaven
Karina's singing voice aaaaaaaaa yes
It shows how sm vocal traning can improve your singing skills, just hear the difference b4 and aftet debut, crazy
Aespa vocal queen you cant say otherwise😂
lol snsd has 7/9 members who are good in singing while rv has 3/5 in singing
@@eternal6257 no, all of them can sing.
@@bitchesstantheboyzrightnow7293 i mean like good
Bot ofc all of them can sing
Giselle's vocals is so amazing 💞💞💞
ngl, they all sang like they didn’t try really hard. Like they sound so at ease! I love black mamba and forever cuz we can see two sides of the song. one be badass and aggressive and the other being soft and beautiful.
노래틀자마자 순간 확 행복해지는 느낌!
행복한 하루보내게 해줘서 고마워유 ㅠㅠ 에스파도 행복한 하루만 보냇으면 좋겟어 ❤️❤️
Aespa proved thy have 4 vocalist ! Thy Al are so good
I am flattered by Karina’s vocals. She really fits well with Aespa vocals and this song. This proves Giselle is not just a rapper and she can sing too!
I'm not shocked that giselle has a good voice knowing she's a choir member. I'm more shocked with Karina's voice. Aespa is really a vocal group.v
You can search Karina/yoo jimin singing here in youtube.. She can really hit high notes even since school days
winter's vocal are so fresh and blessing to the ear✨
winter's voice is AMAZING!
Omg I love you Karina😭😭😭your voice is so beautiful!!!❤️❤️❤️
Winter's voice is soooooooooo goooood.
How mony love karina voice 💜💙
Karina mine 💙
karina our baby girl
aespa our goddesses
@@love_aespa3856 yeeeeeeeees💙
@@dstrbdboy 😂😂
i'll have this song for my wedding it's so perfect from the instrumental, music, vocal and lyrics *sobs*
Same
진짜 수만옹 걸그룹 다 합친 느낌 진짜 짱스파 사랑한다ㅏ
I'm in love with Ningning's voice and high note and the control
Jaeguchi is faster than my wifi-
im starting to think Jaeguchi is a robot-
Me too 👁👄👁
she has many competitors when it comes to color coded lyrics, that's why she need to upload as fast as she can
@@kimjunkyu7123 oh...
@@kimjunkyu7123 but she is the one 🥴
Me too
OKAY BUT KARINA'S VOICE
I love how Ningning and Winter have lighter and higher voice colour while Karina and Giselle have deeper tone.. They compliment eachother beautifully
I really LOVE Giselle's voice. But others are icredible too
sm 특유의 발라드갬성이 확실한 곡이다..
특히 스엠쪽 팬이라면 확실히 호감인 곡
1:18 free button to repeat Karina’s insane vocals
지젤 음색 미쳤다..
i love giselle's voice 🥺
Karina seems like a ace catagory...like aren’t they all? But she caught my eyes most.
Love from a blink
Also,winter.... She is my fav in the grp after karina. As expected from sm,all r main vocal material
아니 6년주기 진짜 맞나봐..
노래 너무 좋은데?
이럼 샤이니랑 슈주 컴백도 기대할 수밖에 없자나..스엠아..ㅠㅠ
그니까요 노래 레전드 ..
2000년 발매곡 리메이크인데요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@hdh020406 알아요.그래도 뭐 편곡도 잘했고..블랙맘바보단 낫잖아요?
@@최동준-g8x 블랙맘바가 별로였나요? 전 갠적으로 블랙맘바 중독성 있고 좋다고 생각했는데요..
@@루나징 아 저는 기대했던 것보다 대중을 저격하기에는 아쉽다고 생각했거든요..팬으로서는 중독성 있고 너무 좋은 노래였지만!대중들이 다가가기에는 포에버가 좀 더 낫지 않을까 생각해서..
Ningning's voice strongly resembles bada from ses. Her voice is so beautiful!!! Hoping to see more of her talent in the future
Her voice really reminds me of Bada
Let's look forward to seeing how NingNing use her voice to blessing everyone❤️
Let's look forward to seeing how NingNing use her voice to blessing everyone❤️
근데 진짜 에스엠스럽다,, ses랑 레드벨벳 데뷔초 느낌
이미 노래부터 20년전 곡이라..
GISELLE LITERALLY SNATCH MY WIG OFF WHEN SHE STARTED SINGING SJSIGDKWIWHS
Winter the most beautiful voice❤❤❤
The devil works fast but Jaeguchi works faster, god damn
Ikr
🤣🤣🤣
We know it plss stop saying that its Annoying 🙏🙏🙏
omg! winter voice my heart is melting😍😍
결혼식 축가같애...되게 뭉클해지고...그런 뭔지 알지
KARINA'S VOICEEEE IM CRYING!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭
개인적으로 블랙맘바 넥스트레벨 다좋은데 이게 가장 좋은듯
1:41 after hearing this part I wanna hear NingNing cover an r&b song 😅
This is not the actual comeback of aespa. Forever is a song by Yoo Young-jin which was originally released in 2000 and now aespa made their own version. Forever is a great song. It showcases their vocals. Wait for their actual comeback. There is a rumor that aespa will comeback with their first mini album. And in their comeback we can already hear Karina and Giselle rapping. I hope you can wait! MYs, let's be with aespa forever!
I have a feeling that Karina and Giselle are really good at rapping
@@naina2419 you are correct 👌
아직도 포에버 못 잊어... 지젤 보이스 꿀임 그냥
3:43 is ningning
인트로부터 미쳤음 진짜..
this isn’t a song that’s i think i’d revisit but damn are these girls vocal powerhouses. they all are distinctive and have range to be able to go from Black Mamba to this. It’s great that they can appeal to so many different ppl too since this really reminds me of an ost.
카리나 저음 너무 취향저격!
I'm inlove with their vocals 😭❤
aespa should do more songs like this and ICU
Their vocals melted my heart💕🦋
kim winter has become my life since i listened to the song 💛💛
Karina's voice like Taeyeon and sunny omg
The song was already out when I woke up this morning and let me just tell y'all, hearing these ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS VOCALS first thing in the morning was a wonderful start to my Friday 🥺😌
I’m very impressed by Giselle’s vocals. She has such a beautiful voice
even I'm not fan of this group
I really love this song
It can wipe all your problem if you start listening to this song😭💪❤️
This is one of the best covers of Kpop idols covering other Kpop idols songs 😭 it’s so beautiful my heart I am litterly crying
닝닝 음색에서 바다 향기가 나는군~
kim winter 자랑스런 스엠상 우리 민정이 정말 예쁘다 목소리도 예쁘구 사랑스럽다 민정이가 젤 조아 ^^
ÆSPA: so our new song is-
Jaeguchi: æspa - ' forever ' lyrics
Lmao
LMAO IM CRYING 🤣🤣🤣
Wow karina. Just wow.
Why isn't anyone talking about Ninnin? No one notices such a talented and charming girl.
Why is she being pushed to the background everywhere.. She's like onda everglow, chaeyoung twice, seulgi red velvet. Most underrated girls in groups.
Please take care of them.
Seulgi is one of the most popular in RV what you mean 💀
seulgi is litteraly ....
바보
Y'all vocals sounds amazing I love it keep it up ladies I can't wait for your album to drop very excited
3:23 this part !! I’m inlove with giselle’s voice
me too. it changes the mood of the songs awhile, then karina continues the mood, and later our cutie pie maknae changes back the mood to the original.
유지민 사랑해ㅜㅜㅜㅜ음색개좋다진짜
I wish that Doyoung do a cover of this song. It would sound really good in his voice.
닝닝 목소리 미쳤다
이언니들 정체가 뭐야.... 블랙맘마 넥슽레블 만보다가...
말도 안되게 이쁘긴 하다
This is so calming their voice are so soft and beautiful totally a vocal queens
this song is so beautiful 😢
This isn't an offical comeback but im telling you this is Giselle and Karina's era^^
From snsd, rv, then aespa, they always have those songs that stabs you right on the feels...
giselle's voice 😍😍😍
올드한 느낌 리메이크 엿군 역시 글두 다들 잘해서 반전
winter has become my ultimate bias 😍😍😍😍
*Omg Karina is so beautifulll*
I fall in love with this song, literally !
와 이 노래가 최애곡됏ㅜ음 에스파 짱이야 사랑해.. 🫶❤️
All of them get to do adlibs and have each part for bridges. aespa talent domination ;;--;;
All Aespa member vocal are so unique and so special. This song conclude it all 💙🌙✨🦋