How & why Myanmar military is retreating, under attack from multiple ethnic armies
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- #Myanmar
Ever since the country’s independence, ethic groups seeking autonomy were suppressed, bribed and corrupted by the ruling junta. But the ethnic armies enriched themselves just as the Generals did, and now the Army is in retreat. We examine how things got here, and who the players now are
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
A very comprehensive program on Myanmar! Congratulations!
While i genuinely appreciate what Praveen Swami does @theprint. Can i request the use of maps to simple which area is affected and where the insurgency is, after all its a geopolitical issue as well. For example where these 3 ethnic military is based and which areas have they captured, are these areas closer to NE India,............. just a Humble opinion.
You can google the maps and liveua.map gives the lastest updates on the position of the front.
Kachin and chin is closer to india.
1❤qqqqqqqqqqqq ¹q1qqqqqqq1qq2q❤
India was lucky to come out of ethnic conflicts post independence.
Yeah, Manipur.
Is this a joke? We always suffer from ethnic communal and caste riots.
As state is weak. Due to lack of capacity govt never interfere and uses monopoly of state violence to control them. Instead political parties uses these to win election. Govt only steps in when shit hits the fan and some of these antisocial becomes seperatist in nature.
Only because of our constitution and great jawahar lal nehru
India stayed in the common wealth
No India has many ethnic conflicts.......don't lie.
This is not an ethnic war. This is a revolution. Hundreds of thousands of Burmans also took up arms against the Burmans-majority regime military in Myanmar's heartland central regions.
It is a revolutionary drug war.
Still wrong Megan
They still gona lose
Yes NUG and Ethnic Groups are also Dictators in reality
That's another brilliant episode in the Explorer series. Your picking of historical events and weaving them into ongoing turmoil and contestations is marvellous. Your subtle reminder to people that nonviolent democratic independence movement saved India from the much anticipated doom is extremely timely and relevant. As from Americans to Britishers, all were counting on India's Balkanization.
Thank you very much for doing this, sir. Your voice was telling that you were perhaps under the grip of cold. I hope and pray, may you get better soon. Thank you.
China has been funding civil wars in Myanmar for over 40 years, often both or multiple sides. Perhaps more important than the CIA’s unenviable contribution.
Sir a kind request to please put Maps to mark places talked about in the video. Excellent video nonetheless!
Nice report and analysis! Looking forward for more
Very good comprehensive, and well written... Need to listen to it multiple times to understand everything
Wow! This detailed explanation of current & historical facts concerning the complex varying dynamics that led this country into chaos & instability gives a glimpse of the challenges that must be endured by fellow Myanmarese aspiring for peace & stability....thank you, sir....
Highly researched history! Fantastic story gives the background to the present situation. Remarkable!😂😂😂😂
You are the best storyteller I have ever known. I wish all our History teachers can be as good a storyteller as you are. If that happens no student will ever need history textbooks.
We need to help other countries. Save Myanmar
And they want to invad indian territory mainly north east india.
We know they are organising Somthing like Opium business development society. And this print media is also foreign funding media speak only for money. Doesn't care for humanity
Thankyou SIR updates cresis News under Myanmar
Thank you print and Mr Swamy for this great information
A excellent explanation of Myanmar. I really enjoyed it
The older presentation format was more polished/fluent. Not sure why they changed it. PS seems to struggle through the video!
Excellent sir.
You overlooked the fact that, Military Dictatorship in Burma was implanted together with Egypt, Pakistan
Philippines, Indonesia with the blessing of USA.
The dictatorship was not in USA's best interest though
It's because the first leader's name is U Nu. With a thick Burmese accent, it sounds like Oh, No!
Means - Mr. Soft.
Brilliant analysis 👏
Thanks for crisp reporting
Is this the full episode?
Very interesting.many thanks.
Jai Neheru, for keeping India a democratic republic.
India should support three brotherhood Alliance
Very informative
Very informative episode
18:07 is not 1998. It's 1988
Need more templated n high end presentation like Nitish Rajput.... Really helps connect with word to image
You didn't even mention about the Rohyngas!!
Have you ever been to Myanmar? Do you understand Burmese? How come you are an expert of Myanmar, suddenly?
Sir if you know all of this, i think you will understand the current situation in Manipur and the reason the central government is not really trying to stop the conflict. Since this conflict is continuing for so long,many innocent civilians have died and many thousands of people have lost their home . Please make a video on the internal and external factors continuing the conflict and the possible ways to stop the conflict. Thanks Sir
Prayers and cries of rohingyan people ❤.
2:05 vəhy Dont other islamic countries accomodte they.india is not dharamshala anymore
It's amazing India has survived in the midst of chaos around it....
India didn't survive.. north eastern Indian states are burning by kukis and kukis are part this opium business team
very interesting.
The Peaceful compelled the real real peaceful to pick up sword imagine the atrocities they would have inflicted which compelled buddhist to pick weapon...
You have to ask the Bamar tribes. Being a self designated supreme tribe and despising others tribes being uncivilised. This is what you get. Remember the 1960-1962 expulsion of Indians from Burma back to India n Ceylon?
Barmars aren't tribes. They mainstream general people who have been ruling Burma for several centuries.
@@homelesslavie_vlogs9600 well the bamars don't think so. The Bamars regard themselves as a distinct ruling class tribe in Burma. That sparked all these wars
There's no "private black market" for firearms and other such weapons on such a scale in any part of PRC territory, I can tell you that much. That's not at all possible. No need to speculate.
Amsterdam, calling 📞
Thanks, l always wondering how the Golden Triangle came to be
So little is known about this side of history
Why can't you support your narration with proper maps and other visuals?
shud have sped up the teleprompter
.
good episode
Some fact were wrong. e.g two army jeeps . . killing Myanmar leaders , were NOT from army. They were followers of U Saw, an ex PM of Burma.
But , anyone has given a thought .. what comes after the amry falls ???
Will the ethnic armies will settle in a point or will the fighting continue between one another without any law and order
❤❤❤❤❤
Requesting next to please cover Bangladesh and "boycott indian products", and what can india do to strengthen relations...
MANIPUR REFUGEE PROBLEM IS DUE TO NEGLIGENCE OF INDIA GOVERNMENT . WHY INDIA GOVERNMENT IS NOT SPEAKING ANY SINGLE WORD TO MYANMAR GOVT. WHY INDIAN EMBASSY IN MYANMAR IS SILENT..
Military subjugated democracy in Myanmar. This was great mistake of unu and his regime they had accepted harmony of Army which constituted 50 % of parliament. No govt could work Sui was caged not free to discharge her duty as a democratic head of the state
Everyone knows aung san was a liar later
Swami Superb
Hatred leads to hatred only
Yes..
#Since day one (Independence from UK) Burma was unable to put into a strong Constitution reflecting ‘Social Values’ listed as:
1. ‘Social Values’ (Equality, Brotherhood Spirit) among multi ‘Ethnic Races’ are not addressed by Army Dictators since day one:
2. Army Dictators (mostly “Burman” Race) behave like they are supreme towards multi ‘Ethnic Races’ living in the country:
3. A strong Constitution (Social Contract between Citizens & Govt) to reflect these social values do not exist till to date 2024.
# Due lack of such a strong Constitution, conflicts broke out between the Army & multi ‘Ethnic Races’
# Now Army coup (Feb ’21) has caused a huge “Social Upheaval” which become too hard to fix back since it become a war between total population (all National Races) against the Army.
# Citizens lost trust in the Army, thru reality, that its intention is to grip onto power anyway, anyhow no matter what.
# With this Army’s mindset (using “force” as only option) and opposition forces who are determined to close Army’s chapter in Burma - that could end up in a Civil War; that is what happens NOW.
Brit love leaving behind poison cherry as a farewell gift 😢
Thanks for using correct map of India 🙏
Wa state ,Kachin state and Karin state have arms factory and Thai border illegal arms market❤
Too much information in very short time, I would suggest you give a concise story at the beginning and then go for details, there is no hook in your presentation
Reason why manipur is burnining
9:57 I don't think Burma/Myanmar was going for a Confederal system. A Confederation is a union of sovereign states as opposed to a Federation which is a union of autonomous states which neither Burma/Myanmar nor India is.
It is written as KYAT but pronounced as CHAT. Got to be strong on research before speaking.
The main culprit is the colonial power that is Britain.They did not give freedom for Burma at par with India misguiding them to be a separate state.
Myanmar isn't India
You such a fabulous fabricator.. where is your left handbag .. please report on Manipur, chakma people
Thoughts expressed are so jumbled up, confusing and all over the place.
And India support one of groups called chin army which is not fighting with junta...and now burma will be controlled by original bhamah ...and chin/kuki will be left out that for sure
Lol,the chins are literally fighting the Junta .
@@minatonamikaze6587 yah but in small scale not like 3 brother alliance of China right hand.,..Chin group can't joined ...now 3bro alliance junta along with China blessing is doing ceasefire agreement......so Chin are left out and can't fight openly with junta or arakan army..so india is always in loosing end...so kuki want land inside india 🤣🤣🤣...which also not possible at all
@Praveen
India got independence not because of "Gandhian" non violence but because of INA bulk whose troops were British India Army soldiers who had surrendered to the Axis powers and several mutinies in the British India military immediately with the end of world war two. Most notable were the Bombay naval mutiny and mutinies in air force.
This was compounded by the fact that 30 lakh Indian troops had returned to India after the 2nd world war. The British knew they could no longer hold on to India with the help of British India Army which is why they left India much earlier than they planned to.
U mean to say Gandhi struggle was useless.
Modi didn't get my vote in 2014 because he said he will develop India. He got my vote because he said I will have 15 lakhs in my bank account. Explain this.
@joramnikam4063 do you struggle when you're non violent??
Gandhi is the reason people of different cultures trusted the Delhi-Govt.
For example Gandhi had posted his followers even in the South, so there was no opposition to Delhi-rule, because they trusted Gandhi.
Biggest lie of our independence struggle was we got independence by non violence protest 😂😂
I think it only need logic to understand that British left india because of INA .
How to join print? Is there any job oppurtunities?
are*.. disqualified.
Hi,
Please write to us at careers@theprint.in
Its not what went wrong with them….. the fault line is their creation. Both of these countries are holding an important strategic locations but they are as much fragile. Pakistan is being created in a way that half of its balochistan is given to pakistan and half to iran. Half of its pashton areas r given to afghanistan and half are cut to put in pakistan. Half punjab in Pakistan half in india and so as sindh and what left behind is also the disputed territories. What you will expect from such a country to have done good? It is small in area as well. India is way more bigger than pakistan. With more secure territories.
Watch the video with 2x speed
As an American war vet in Myanmar for past 10 years; 99% on target with 1 terrible mistake.
The online crime against Chinese is conducted in Special Economic Zones that Tatmadaw has no control. They are controlled by Triads and pay the CCP.
Chinese "anger" over this is an information operation meant to legitimize more direct Chinese control in Myanmar.
I and most I talk to HERE think that China intends to attack and (1) seize more direct control over the terrain that their pipeline travels to and (2) position forces in Chin state to flank India.
Where are the Bhakts in these kinds of vedio..😂
You can't even write video correctly. That's the outcome of the reservation. It makes our brain dead.
@@boulevard7863 lol,👌
@@boulevard7863😅
kya karoge bakhts ka😂
*ETHENIC CHARECTERISTC OF HINDI IMPERIALIST STATE OF INDIA IS SAME...SAME WILL HAPPENED TO INDIA, BENGALIS, PANJABIS, TAMILS WILL RISE*
18:09 1988
What about ,ice, drug production coming through from China
Is Arakan a muslim state in Myanmar?
Please give some historical evidence.
As expected this narrative doesn't explain how the Kuki Kumi became the 12 tribes of Jews. This seems to be a story fabricated, so was the rift between various tribes, divided and ruled by British and later Americans.
Hindi ni aata kya inko..koun se country ka hai
When Burmese will live in peace
The day u fixing your lips.
Monotonous reading of written Poetic Scripts. Need illustration and to be in simple English.
Extremely simple. Arakan Army is suported by Bangladesh. You just needs the guts to say it.
You said nothing about the tragedy of the Rohyngas.
Thank you very much Sir.❤Zara pani pee lejiye ga
Very sick nation.
Macaulay Putra blah blah blah
Poor presentation
Jai Hind
Ohhh now indians such as this guy talking about our country conflicts all experts lol
They didn't even mention about the actual of reasons of the conflict MILITARY and straight up went to ethnicity 😂
I always find it's interesting that these expert indian doesn't even know what really happening and still trying to cover military ass
@@Nyugget510because the army will win
How u can call them insurgents??? !!!!
19K views...even a cat video has better views than this. This guy is so boring.
I disagree with sir here, India and Myanmar cannot be compared India has existed as a civilizational state has existed for thousands of year while Myanmar came into existence as a colonial Frankenstein, these two are not comparable
India yes, but not the Indian-Union which has different cultures joined by the Brits.
For example Nepal is part of cultural India, but most of the North-East are not.
Just that Nepal was not annexed by the Brits.
Burma existed before British rule, and no, it was not a part of the civilization state of Bharat. Being a patriot does not mean putting blinkers on history.
The first civilization was Dravidan before Indo-European in India/bharat, then who was the first human in Bharat if you know guys?!
which is older in existence if the bharat is compared to the indigenous population of Australia / Africa.
At any time, the oldest civilization on earth will not really exist, because it will definitely be replaced by another.
😂😂😂😂 india kaladan project finish😂😂😂
You should state about India' s support to Chin Rebels who are operating in the border with India other wise it looks more of China Bashing of the current crisis
Who are you 😂😂😂😂
You were all over the place with those events... Hard to understand even for someone with some knowledge on the subject.