Yup. They keep releasing the same ole reddish browns, tans, champagne shimmers, with one or two pops of blue/purple/green. It’s so ridiculous 🙄 I don’t know why people keep buying these same recycled shades
She did do a holiday palette last year (actually 2) but they were 9-pans with 2 blushes. I didnt get either of those, because I had all the blushes. Great looks, Steff!
The big different with the previous palettes is that even not specialty shadows , it is made in Italy which makes the quality of this one is much better than the previous ones
I enjoy watching you style your eye look. You're so good at it, so creative. ❤ I haven't worn PM eye shades. This pallet looks festive enough for the holidays or every day.
This large palette looks really nice, I like how colourful it is with the shimmers, it is much better than last years one that wasted space with the blushes, I like the green duo palette she released as there aren't many green shadows around
Loved the 1st look ❤ You have such an ethereal beauty about you and soft colours look amazing on you, definitely emphasise your beauty. I liked the look better without the lashes tbh, too harsh but that's just personal opinion of course.😊 Great review!!
Beautiful looks Steff! I feel like I have these shades in my Mothership palettes, so I will pass. On a random note, I am loving my Gourmande Girls Calavera palette; today I recreated your yellow/orange look, and I received so many compliments! 💛🧡
I agree, I have a few things from Pat but the colors are basically the same and for the price I can get indie brands and be wowed every time. Plus supporting an indie brand makes me feel like I’m helping others as well as getting phenomenal products.
I bought a Mothership pallete years ago on her good sales - which I'm not sure if she does anymore. But i didn't care for the consistency. Since then I've purchased face palettes which were incredible, and the 5 pan pallettes that were incredible. I've heard this formula is like those 5 pans too.
You look awesome, I have 2 of her holiday pallets did not purchase last years, to be honest I forget I have them have only done one look with the first one, they are nice but have used other shadows I like more. Looks beautiful on you, take care and stay safe. Have a great day at work.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I will end up having this palette but only bc my husband buys them every year for me for Christmas. I don’t think it’s as pretty this year as years past but bc it’s a tradition for us, I let him buy it lol. But if not for that, I don’t think I would have bothered honestly
I’ve heard soooo many people say that about pm holiday palettes. They usually say “they are really good/nice, but I don’t reach for them.” And that’s exactly what has happened with mine. Idk what it is about them. Like I really like it too. But I just never want to use it lol. I think everyone should give one a try but there’s no need for a new one every year unless you actually to use it all the time.
Thanks for reviewing this. Do you know if this palette was made in Italy? I know the holiday palettes are usually made in China but a couple of creators said this one was made in Italy this year.
Both looks were beautiful! I’d love to see comparison swatches of this years palette next to the other holiday palettes. It looks like a lot of shades are repeats.
16:10 I picked that one up in tj maxx. It’s nice, but I have to force myself to use it in a capsule eyeshadow rotation because it’s so shimmery. Though the shimmers were pretty, they aren’t that different from many others. I feel after the motherships, the expectation for her releases is very high, but a let down.
I believe she is not longer behind the brand! I feel at some point if they don't change something,they will go bankrupt, people are already super disappointed,at least is what i've seen towards them lately!
I have a mix 6 PMG eyeshadow palettes but I dont use them as much. The mattes are powdery for me, lots of fallout. Some of her reds and pinks irritate my eyelids. So I decluttered 2 of them. That said I'm always interested in watching reviews on her latest releases.
Thank you for the review! I have 4 of her holiday quints from 2022 and 2023 so I think this one is redundant… also, there are repeat shades like the silver that’s also in one of her quints. Which is a fantastic silver I must say!! I adore the quints, it’s made in Italy so the quality does not disappoint. But yeah it’s not unique at all! Always the same matte shades as well. The quint from last year with the burgundy matte and green shimmer is the most unique I have from Pat. So I think I’m going to pass on it, maybe if Pat gets a good sale haha.
Thanks for reviewing this year's holiday palette. It's a pretty one, but I have these shades from the brand. I didn't get last year's either. No MTHRSHP release this year. The last one didn't have special shades but had the same $$$ price point. The brand is slipping into bland. 😢
Absolutley nove the second look. Those colors look stunning on you. I definitely won't be picking this up. I feel like Pat McGratch constantly releases the same things in different packaging and I think that, though her quality can be really nice on her shimmers, I feel like it's to the point we're paying for the name and not the quality--especially since Indie brands do it better than anyone else.
I liked this palette but I’ll wait for a sale. I stay at my Dad’s for two weeks of every month so an all purpose palette makes sense. I’ll just leave it there.
I love it but wish they had a bone shade. She does too many pinks for me. 2 of those mattes look basically the same. Why not give us a lighter bone to tone down the darker shades.
I stopped buying PM holiday palette because they just look the same every year. I will still buy the Mothership palettes. My issue with indie brands are that their stuff are mostly made in China, and I don’t use makeup, skincare, and food products made in China.
This is not a knock at anyone, but i have never really gotten the hype behind PMG. The price for standard shimmers is so high. I would rather stick with my indie palettes (i know PMG is probably considered indie, i mean smaller brands) with the special shades and more mattes. I prefer fewer shimmers
The rumor I’ve heard is Pat is no longer the creative director for the band 🤷🏻♀️ I remember when she first started her brand and they were single shadows in a bag with gold confetti. I’ve never had anything PM because I always thought that it was overpriced and nowadays it’s to repetitive and expensive for what you get. Hard pass for me. Appreciate the review.
All the Pat McGrath products I have gotten were through BoxyCharm or Ipsy. Knowing it is on there for much more reasonable prices, makes me not eager to purchase anything. I have a few Pat McGrath small palettes and they just aren’t worth the high price tag imo
I have 3 mother ships and a couple of holiday palettes . Even your beautiful looks doesn't make me want to pick this up ..haha ... Pat's brand has become so repetitive. I wish she hadn't of sold out . I am not sure how much say she has at the brand anymore ....
This is a easy pass.....indi does it SO much better and for less most of the time 😂 I bought the one from last year and honestly wish I could get my money back 😢
Pat McGrath keeps recycling the same reddish brown shades, tan shades, and champagne shimmers 🙄 How ridiculous. I got a palette at TJMaxx about a year ago and I took it back because it was so similar to the one I already have
Ok I am NOT a PM fan I think she’s super over priced. These shades appeal to me but it looks like shadows just on a magnetized palette. Super underwhelmed with the packaging 😑
To me, PM is like Charlotte Tilbury. They both release the same shades/products over and over in different packaging.
Yup. They keep releasing the same ole reddish browns, tans, champagne shimmers, with one or two pops of blue/purple/green. It’s so ridiculous 🙄 I don’t know why people keep buying these same recycled shades
Yes!!🙌
She used to do better
She did do a holiday palette last year (actually 2) but they were 9-pans with 2 blushes. I didnt get either of those, because I had all the blushes. Great looks, Steff!
I think I got the blushes! Omg I seriously don’t remember lol 😂
The big different with the previous palettes is that even not specialty shadows , it is made in Italy which makes the quality of this one is much better than the previous ones
That’s a good thing!
I enjoy watching you style your eye look. You're so good at it, so creative. ❤ I haven't worn PM eye shades. This pallet looks festive enough for the holidays or every day.
Thank you so much!!☺️
This is the first time that she's made the big palette in Italy.
Totally why I like it!
This large palette looks really nice, I like how colourful it is with the shimmers, it is much better than last years one that wasted space with the blushes, I like the green duo palette she released as there aren't many green shadows around
It’s definitely nice if you like shimmer heavy palettes!
Loved the 1st look ❤ You have such an ethereal beauty about you and soft colours look amazing on you, definitely emphasise your beauty. I liked the look better without the lashes tbh, too harsh but that's just personal opinion of course.😊 Great review!!
Thank you so much!!
I loved the first look.
Thanks 😊
First look is gorgeous.
Thank you!!
Beautiful looks Steff! I feel like I have these shades in my Mothership palettes, so I will pass. On a random note, I am loving my Gourmande Girls Calavera palette; today I recreated your yellow/orange look, and I received so many compliments! 💛🧡
Yay!! So happy to hear that!! Yes, you have these shades already in those palettes!
For me personally @ $76 price point I’ll go Ensley Reign but that’s me
Good choice!
Looking beautiful Steff. Hope you're well. 👋
Thank you! You too!🥰
Thank you for your videos 💙💛❤💚💜
I agree, I have a few things from Pat but the colors are basically the same and for the price I can get indie brands and be wowed every time. Plus supporting an indie brand makes me feel like I’m helping others as well as getting phenomenal products.
It’s a nice palette, but yeah, just way too repetitive.
I’ve seen soo many people say that PM is getting poopy for the price so I love this honest review!
Beautiful I like the second look❤
Thank you 😊
Love both looks Steff 💕
Thank you! 😊
I bought a Mothership pallete years ago on her good sales - which I'm not sure if she does anymore. But i didn't care for the consistency. Since then I've purchased face palettes which were incredible, and the 5 pan pallettes that were incredible. I've heard this formula is like those 5 pans too.
Yes, this mega palette is the Italian formula like her quints.
2nd look is gorgeous 😍
Thanks!
❤very pretty 😊
I like the Danessa Myrick’s palette over Pats this year. Also can you please review Makeup by Mario’s Etheral Moonlight palette. Releases next week ❤
You look awesome, I have 2 of her holiday pallets did not purchase last years, to be honest I forget I have them have only done one look with the first one, they are nice but have used other shadows I like more. Looks beautiful on you, take care and stay safe. Have a great day at work.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I know exactly what you mean!
Stephanie, last year there were two smaller palettes , with 9 pans and 2 blushes
I will end up having this palette but only bc my husband buys them every year for me for Christmas. I don’t think it’s as pretty this year as years past but bc it’s a tradition for us, I let him buy it lol. But if not for that, I don’t think I would have bothered honestly
Wow!!! Awesome husband!!! 😊
I’m glad it’s become a tradition for you all! Cute!🥰
@@SteffsBeautyStash I’m glad too, lord knows I won’t say no to makeup lol
I’ve heard soooo many people say that about pm holiday palettes. They usually say “they are really good/nice, but I don’t reach for them.” And that’s exactly what has happened with mine. Idk what it is about them. Like I really like it too. But I just never want to use it lol. I think everyone should give one a try but there’s no need for a new one every year unless you actually to use it all the time.
I know! It’s so weird! It’s a nice palette but it’s nothing special. I think it’s definitely for those that have maybe never tried the brand.
Thanks for reviewing this. Do you know if this palette was made in Italy? I know the holiday palettes are usually made in China but a couple of creators said this one was made in Italy this year.
Both looks were beautiful! I’d love to see comparison swatches of this years palette next to the other holiday palettes. It looks like a lot of shades are repeats.
These shades are definitely not new!
16:10 I picked that one up in tj maxx.
It’s nice, but I have to force myself to use it in a capsule eyeshadow rotation because it’s so shimmery.
Though the shimmers were pretty, they aren’t that different from many others.
I feel after the motherships, the expectation for her releases is very high, but a let down.
Thanks for sharing where you found the older ones!
If you're really interested, I'd wait until after the holidays. They almost always show up at TJ Maxx and Marshalls...
Last year she had the two palettes with the blushes also. And several 5 pans I believe
I think I got the blushes! Man I seriously don’t remember lol 😂
Finally, one of my favorite influencers reviews this palette. It feels like Pat McGrath is not as popular anymore. What do you think?
I believe she is not longer behind the brand! I feel at some point if they don't change something,they will go bankrupt, people are already super disappointed,at least is what i've seen towards them lately!
I have a mix 6 PMG eyeshadow palettes but I dont use them as much. The mattes are powdery for me, lots of fallout. Some of her reds and pinks irritate my eyelids. So I decluttered 2 of them. That said I'm always interested in watching reviews on her latest releases.
Beautiful litke Steff 💚
Thank you for the review! I have 4 of her holiday quints from 2022 and 2023 so I think this one is redundant… also, there are repeat shades like the silver that’s also in one of her quints. Which is a fantastic silver I must say!! I adore the quints, it’s made in Italy so the quality does not disappoint. But yeah it’s not unique at all! Always the same matte shades as well.
The quint from last year with the burgundy matte and green shimmer is the most unique I have from Pat. So I think I’m going to pass on it, maybe if Pat gets a good sale haha.
Hello beautiful Steff 😍
Hola 👋
Thanks for reviewing this year's holiday palette. It's a pretty one, but I have these shades from the brand. I didn't get last year's either. No MTHRSHP release this year. The last one didn't have special shades but had the same $$$ price point. The brand is slipping into bland. 😢
I see Natasha Denona and Danessa Myricks doing cool things, PM needs to keep up!
😅your lucky you got yours. Waiting for mine 4 weeks. When I email them I get scolded!😅
Wai
OMG!! That’s too long!
Absolutley nove the second look. Those colors look stunning on you.
I definitely won't be picking this up. I feel like Pat McGratch constantly releases the same things in different packaging and I think that, though her quality can be really nice on her shimmers, I feel like it's to the point we're paying for the name and not the quality--especially since Indie brands do it better than anyone else.
I couldn’t agree more! We have these shades 5x over already!
I liked this palette but I’ll wait for a sale. I stay at my Dad’s for two weeks of every month so an all purpose palette makes sense. I’ll just leave it there.
I've got one holiday palette and never use it im an indie palette fan xx
Indie is the way to go!
I love it but wish they had a bone shade. She does too many pinks for me. 2 of those mattes look basically the same. Why not give us a lighter bone to tone down the darker shades.
True!
Last years had face products and some shadows on the other side.
I stopped buying PM holiday palette because they just look the same every year. I will still buy the Mothership palettes. My issue with indie brands are that their stuff are mostly made in China, and I don’t use makeup, skincare, and food products made in China.
This is not a knock at anyone, but i have never really gotten the hype behind PMG. The price for standard shimmers is so high. I would rather stick with my indie palettes (i know PMG is probably considered indie, i mean smaller brands) with the special shades and more mattes. I prefer fewer shimmers
The rumor I’ve heard is Pat is no longer the creative director for the band 🤷🏻♀️ I remember when she first started her brand and they were single shadows in a bag with gold confetti. I’ve never had anything PM because I always thought that it was overpriced and nowadays it’s to repetitive and expensive for what you get. Hard pass for me. Appreciate the review.
Oh wow didn’t know that! Thanks for sharing!
All the Pat McGrath products I have gotten were through BoxyCharm or Ipsy. Knowing it is on there for much more reasonable prices, makes me not eager to purchase anything. I have a few Pat McGrath small palettes and they just aren’t worth the high price tag imo
I have 3 mother ships and a couple of holiday palettes . Even your beautiful looks doesn't make me want to pick this up ..haha ... Pat's brand has become so repetitive. I wish she hadn't of sold out . I am not sure how much say she has at the brand anymore ....
Very repetitive unfortunately
This is a easy pass.....indi does it SO much better and for less most of the time 😂 I bought the one from last year and honestly wish I could get my money back 😢
Your looks were gorgeous....but I am not picking this one up❤
I am a pass. It looks beautiful on you. Have a great weekend ❌️ ⭕️
Thank you! You too!❤️❤️
Pat McGrath keeps recycling the same reddish brown shades, tan shades, and champagne shimmers 🙄 How ridiculous. I got a palette at TJMaxx about a year ago and I took it back because it was so similar to the one I already have
It’s a shame! There could have been so many possibilities with this!
I see so many PM at TJMAX, and everything is pink. Not for me.
Thanks for sharing!!
Ok I am NOT a PM fan I think she’s super over priced. These shades appeal to me but it looks like shadows just on a magnetized palette. Super underwhelmed with the packaging 😑
I watched Patty Alonzo and she had a lot of fallout from this pallet.
I think it's a boring looking palette! But it looks pretty on you.
Thanks!!
Easy skip
Pat McGrath is so boring. Watching just because it’s you. Lol
😘😘😘