Former president Hu Jintao was responsible for the economic growth of China and friendly relations with other countries. He practised collective leadership and concensus-based rule. Hu Jintao was known for technocratic competence rather than persona. Unlike Xi Jinping, he voluntarily retired from all his positions after his second term and earned praises for it. The two are worlds apart.
The quality of Chinese leaders is different from PM Lee, Liz Truss, Joe Biden and the like. Think of what China has achieved in the past 20 years under the leaderships of Hu and Xi. The achievements of the past 20 years can be summarised as 胡习之治。 Do you know what are the periods of heyday/盛世 in China's long history? There is a 500-year gap between the Great Asia and mini-BBC. Ha ha ha!
@@fredricksmith-something.2125 So you are one of those common clowns who thinks you can make clever repartee. Do you also like to get to the comment section quickly so you can say "FIRST" !?
🤣🤣🤣 I didn't understand what he said, so I watched this video again turning the auto-caption on. What I found finally was the fact that I wasted my time twice...
If Mr. Hu had been unwell and was guided outside to recover or for medical treatment, then the other party members had greeted him, looked at him and wished him well. This is how you would treat a former president and friend. Mr. Xi did not look at him even when Mr. Hu directly spoke to him. There is no way they would all be sitting there with stone-faces, if this was the real reason.
Adults in Chinese culture behave differently than what most Americans are used to. In this setting, everyone was acting appropriately. No surprises whatsoever.
@@Caocao8888 Just to say, I am not American, I lived in China, and now live a long time in Singapore. In Asia elderly are treated with more respect than to be seen here.
@@capp11295 sounds like you really know someone in the inner circle of the politburo of China, (or someone who knows someone who knows someone, etc.). Do you also want to hear about the Brooklyn Bridge I'm selling? 😂
Show the full clip n not cut clips. The front show how xi communicated with HU. Last Hu came back when he is better n voted. Pls see whole not just the part
That idea that Hu came back to vote when he’s better was fake news. They voted before the meeting took place. Meaning someone lied to cover up for CCP by stating Hu being sick when he’s not.
@Ditsy Girl Don't they have a dinner party after the meeting, like in the west, to give each other the proverbial pat up the backside? BTW, the USA did not blow up Nordstream 1 & 2.
Hu didn't come back. All the news agency fsaw him being removed, nobody saw him come back. This another thing the government media made up for damage control.
Disappointed with CNA, there were earlier footage showing clearly Mr Hu was not behaving normally. He seems lost and Mr Xi has spoken to some aids to resolve the matter. It seems all the media were western driven to the extent of omitting the earlier footage. I used to believe SG main stream media, now I am not sure anymore.
Hu Jin tao had stroke 5 years back. have you deal with stroke patient, they can always look confused all the time. Most often very hard to understand what is told to them
This time CNA is more objective in its coverage of the "event." This is unlike the previous one where it already concluded what happened without evidence to support it...and it did not explore the various possibilities...
Hardly objective when using words like "fiercely loyal to XJP". Such speculative narratives should not be used in an objective media. I would challenge them to use words like "So and so in PAP is fiercely loyal to LHL" if speculations is their style when reporting on Singapore politics.
@@testusersg How about using the same type of language when describing the USA or UK. CNA is a disgusting channel, regurgitating Western bias. I don't see Joe Biden appointing Lindsay Graham or anyone who is not his supporter to any position, nevermind position of power. To say Xi appointed people loyal to him is such a ridiculously twisted way of saying this - Joe Biden appointed people opposed to him to high positions - Oh, that didn't happen? CNA didn't highlight that? Morons.
You conveniently leave out the parts where prior to being seated Hu Jintao acted like a senile Joe Biden unsure of what to do. Xi actually lightly touched Hu's hand/elbow and motioned for Hu to be seated.
From what i've been seeing in the comments. This was no Bernie sanders from the 2016 Democratic primary elections. Where he was reluctant to concede. Later returned to the stage with bruises on his face and in tears from his eyes, reluctantly, conceding before the primary was finalized.
I have taken care of old folks before and this is how they behave when they are not feeling well. The video is incomplete. There is another video that feature the beginning of the session where the members were moving into their seats, there we can clearly see that Mr Hu is already being help to get to his seat and already looking muddled.
You need to catch up! 😂 There’re thousands of members, all seniors are ushered to their seats on the first day. We are more interested on why Hu alone was escorted out on the last day. 🤦♂️
@@jovimathews lol thousands ushered to their seats....?!?!? OMG 😆😆😆 you living in another world.....being help to get to his seat~~~ is very different from ushered~~~you need to stop twisting facts. Anyway your type will never learn.
I am so disappointed with our news media. When I have to look for comments from lay person for the truth. What do you think of the culture of our news reporting agency?
Their looks in this video when he was taken out were super SUS. Saw the comments in this video. Please kindly show the whole video and report base on that….
The Western MSM is making a Mountain out of a grain of sand. Chinese Political Decisions and Choice is their rights and choice. Just like that enjoyed by the Singapore Government to whom and who are to be selected as the Ministers and Prime Minister of Singapore.🤔😂😂
Anglo Saxons and other Western Imperialist countries raped, plundered, enslaved, humiliated, massacred and looted India for hundreds of years to fund their own economic development and industrialization. They were responsible for the deaths of hundreds of millions of Indians. Yet, Indians love the West and hate China who suffered the same fate at the hands of the Western Imperialist powers. It's mind boggling, and hilarious.
Just focus on taking over Europe/West. You already have sunak as "king" of UK and another Indian varadkar whatever's his name as chief of Ireland. Try Italy next, lots of Indians in Italy. I also know that Indians are buying up lots of property in Czechia and other parts of Europe and bragging about it. Esp the Patel clan.
Lots of Indians are already king of Western IT and other corporations, deans at ivy league schools, increasingly dominant in western civil service and politics. Now that sunak is king, he should open up immigration into Uk to all Indian nationals with little requirements needed. UK Civil service minimum quotas to Indians, quotas in private commerce, housing etc. Good Times ahead 😏
Is it possible for lip-readers to make out what Li Zhanshu said to Hu at the beginning of the released footage? The man Xi summoned to escort Hu out of the hall appeared to be the same guy who escorted Hu in at the opening ceremony a few days ago.
The same video can have many interpretations depending on each media's predetermined narrative about Xi and China. However it is interpreted, the fact is Xi in 10 years' time will be Hu's current age.
But Xi won't be in power by then. He is collapsing the Chinese economy with his unscientific Covid lock-down of the country which includes the shut-down of business and travel bans along with his destruction of corporations by too quickly shutting down the credit markets. People need to eat. They went through a period of prosperity where their lives improved and they won't forget it. People are already getting restive and Xi will not survive their response to his ancient style of rule.
Useless interview asking the wrong person who has no clue at all. All he knows is hard fact. Obviously, nobody hears what they say and he can only speculate.
*Watch the video closely theres no way that Hu was unwell at all cos if Hu was sick then Xi who sat beside him will utter some kind words or put his hand on his shoulder or be the one to usher him out instead Xi did not once strike any conversation with Hu but Xi summoned security officials to deal with Hu and yanked him out of his seat even when Hu resisted delicately and also its Hu who started the brief conversation with Xi who did not even look Hus in the eye and thats seems cold*
I think Hu was not sick. It seems to me that Hu was denied the documents because he didn't satisfy with the seven members of the Standing Committee of the Political Bureau of the CPC Central Committee printed on the documents (七個中共中央政治局常委名單). Then he was persuaded to leave the hall by the assistant.
Its clearly the case that Hu JinTao was helped by his grandson to his seat earlier on. HuJinDao is 79. He suffers feom Parkinson and Alzheimer. The camera shows clearly Hu was unwell and was being helped first to his seat and then encouraged to rest. It's shocking CNA is making a meal out of an old man's Parkinson's tremors. It's a slur on the impeccable running of the PRC ' s 5 days Congress. It's a bloody insult to XI and the CCP that in her wild speculation , the Reporter , (Jane ?) used such despicable accusations to blacken China's reputation . She's. made many unverified cuts on Xi "gets involved... Hu's infamous exit.. Chinese politics which was always tightly - ( bad construction ) choreographed -- what does she mean ??? What does she really mean with her nasty with the word,"Tellingly..." ? and " given the opaque nature of the inner working of the Communist party... What abusive language she hurls at Xi and the CCP! This rude reportér mistakenly told the world its a singular red folder, dumping sinsister speculations on the summit red document, clearly visible on everyone's table, stressing inappropriate ely, her own petty suspicions over an apparently innocuous handout. She goes on with heavier emphasis on the word 'camera', in a sentence a provincial troll would pronounce GUILT -" The very fact that this was caught on camera..." The implication that the Chinese Congress only meet behind closed doors is blatantly obvious in her crappy tone of voice. I object to the highly subjective report full of bias and intentional slander as given here by the reporter standing at the corner of the CNA screen. She's totally unprofessional, politically weaponised and slanderous... mainly misinformed. Her report is truly offensive . With this low grade reporting sentence is on Xi and the CCP Congress before the jury and th judge make their verdict.!
Hu Jintao appeared disoriented. Those who have close contact with senile senoirs are used to this. Don't make a mountain out of a molehill. CNA ,be non judgemental please.
CNA should do a piece on whether the Singapore regime as it stands today needs to fear a regime change by the democratic west led by the USA. And if so, how would it pan out? After all, it is an Asian news channel for Americans, isn't it?
We all just seat still, china are in good hand. Under the leadership of president xi, we believe that china will soon be our worlds no.1. As president xi has achieve many success, in making china great and powerfull?? Xi has a very good set of ways on how to made china become very advance and moderm and very very powerfull. As we see how more and many nations want to join china in sco, brics, even europe want to work with china and ditch usa....
I think 胡锦涛 felt unwell in the midst of the meeting. It's' quite normal for elderly person to feel unwell (at any moment) .... initially, it seemed like he's hesitant to leave (perhaps he felt confused or that it's impolite to do so) ... but after some sympathetic advice and persuasion, he finally agreed to leave (most likely for medical attention) ... and it seemed like he's apolgising or conveying his best regards to 习主席 & 李克强 .... and, for the others, who are the national & military leaders and the people's representatives, they must have the presence of mind and discipline to remain calm and dignified .... to ensure the session could proceed as scheduled without any unnecessary interruption.
Xi has been undergoing a power struggle for ages. He was not sick. This is an excuse. Xi now has more power than ever in the party. You can say he was sick. We all know that’s not why he was taken away.
Stop pretending to be stupid. Just like Singapore and the PAP regime, has LKY not been in power until he died? Didn't Goh Chok Tong forced to abdicate his seat to LHS? Have LHS not been in power for almost 2 decades? Didn't LKY placed all his retired army general buddies in seat of power? What is the difference between all the facade in Singapore and all the facade in China? They all use the same playbook, just different in scope. If CNA doesn't know what this all means, then they should go back to school.
Lol! Sentiment shared by yours truly. All was not well as was evidenced by the forceful ejection he endured, and by no means did he take it well thus not feeling well about the whole affair. Otherwise he is well in health and all is well that ends well.
I think Hu was exhausted after days of meeting. His brain was in a state of confusion. I worked in nursing homes for many years. I understand how old people behave when their mind got confused. They would refuse any help from the nurse and put up resistant. Hu appeared to struggling but he was actually resisting any help in a confused mind. But soon his mind was back to normal and he tap Xi and Li and was escorted out by his aid for a rest. You can ask any nurse, this kind of scenario happened in nursing home very often.
@@kwokholuk8723 you can interpret what you want, but someone here says our million dollar news agency miss out the clips infront which shows Hu needs to be helped into his seat.
Look at Xi's face in the video . Does not need a body language expert to interprate his thoughts and behaviour. Surely you can tell what he is thinking.
So many jokers. I think you guys are ridiculous. Why do you foreigners care so much about China's affairs and the rights of we Chinese people? Are you a government official or a political scientist? Are you world citizens? You want to get a Nobel Price? Just mind your own business, he's 80 years old. Please read more books and feed your own family by hardworking.😮😮😮
This CNA, Channel News Asia is a Singapore media. Who told you it is Chinese media or China-friendly media? I think a wise man should realize what role Singapore plays between China and America. I just want to say Know things in your own mind from multiple angles and ways. Do not let many kinds of media lead you by the nose.
👌👌There are different types "jokers" here: ⏺those who are paid to spread China's "competitor's propaganda. They are the ones who will use phrases like ccp, winnie the pool. Quite easy to spot. ⏺Those who are useful idiots, the ones who believed Saddam Hussein had WMD. These people never learn.
Thank u CNA for releasing the true news , u have all the world full support , even our Strait Time did not release the same video . We need a full explanation from Strait time editor
THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED. Xi needed Hu Jintao's support to change the constitution. For this he gave signed commitments to Hu. After Hu signed off on change of constitution, the snake Xi went back on this commitment and took back the signed document by force. One of the commitments was not to prosecute Hu, his contacts and family members in future. And Hu asked Xi if he will keep his promise, to which Xi nodded while Hu was dragged out. You will see Hu desperately trying to take a paper from that file but was forced not to.
If Mr. Hu was booted out by a Tyrant, he would not have been invited in the first place, Tyrant would have cancelled him long ago. Hu looked like Biden, a little Senile is all I can see, probably good to be escorted out instead of causing a mockery to the entire congress.
Whatever happened during the incident, the Chinese government has no obligation to tell anyone, certainly not you or me or anyone who has nothing to do with Chinese government or Communist Party's affairs. There is no need to speculate. Life must go on, with or without Hu.
So does all this matter us? Don't meddle with other's politics with assumptions and speculations, or you will end up as a tool by the hostile parties. Results matter and we will see the next five years performance.
"People can't think for themselves because of fake news" This US marine break it down for us here. China: What Happened to Hu Jintao?, Just as the Western media spread lies about China before the Communist Party of China's (CPC) Congress including fabrications about a "coup" that never took place - the Western media is now lying about what happened during the Congress itself - including stories of former Chinese President Hu Jintao being "dragged" out of the event. In reality - and by looking at footage of Hu Jintao being escorted in - it is clear that he was frail, ill, and disoriented and his departure from the event was health-related. Source The New Atlas 😮
Please show Mr. Hu Jintao entering the Great Hall ... video is available! Entering the Hall, Mr. Jintao appears confused or disoriented. Why leave this part out?
The frail elder stateman , age 79, Hu Jintao, had been expected to step down for a long time. So we must not look too much into it. ,. Harris Ng YM 🇨🇳💜🇨🇳💜🇨🇳 The value in a respectful retirement in the new world order.
There’re thousands delegates, all seniors are ushered to their seats on the first day. We are more interested on why Hu alone was escorted out on the last day. 🤦♂️
Please CNA, don't follow the West media news and you only show Mr. Hu Jintao escorted out the room but did you watch how he was assisted to walk in the hall? He wasn't feeling well when he was walking into the hall. Watch the real video from the beginning. Mr. Hu Jintao is a very well-respected leader in China. Please learn how to report the other side of the real story or different from others.
You are right. And Xi personally make sure Hu was seated down. CNA only plays the ugly scene of escorting out and not other gestures of care and concerns for HU. I think there are some ulterior motives.
I believe there is the scene the young man trying to lift Hu up in his chair.. Hu to Xi : power is not forever , karma is waiting for you too. Hu , Wen and their era of stability and peaceful prosperity will be missed greatly.
CNA, please watch all the video footage available, including how he was escorted into the hall at the beginning of the proceedings. Clearly he was not well and not entirely lucid
@@waynegoh2295 of course , Hu does not 100% agree to Xi . That's what politicians do , always asking for bigger slice of cake. Compare to Biden raid Trump's Florida home , this is nothing.😅
@ Swee Tiag Quek , western brainwash China ha-te has no brain , they just want to fault China to satisfy . People with so much hate , I doubt they respect their elder 😅
Hu Jintao is a PAST TENSE. Even if he were to make a fuss, it would change nothing. The new Chinese Leadership will carry on regardless of this episode. Those that are anti-China for no good reason will be more so with this episode. No fact & reality will change them a bit.
Well said. Some people hope a conspiracy theory will somehow weaken China. No gossip is going to stop China from rising; it also won't stop the echo chamber from making more noise.
Now it is a known fact why this CNA video are getting a large following on Twitter. It's basically an "anti-China" video of criticizing the CPC for being unkind to a frail old person.
The old man didn't like what's in the red folder pissed him off. Made a huge stink about it on live television. XI order him removed. He's letting HU know and the rest of the party "I'm in charge don't f*** with me or you'll be end up in an unmarked grave"
CNA does not provide in-depth analysis. Just words from the reporter and "experts. Watch the foreign press. They provide in-depth analysis and better coverage.
Former president Hu Jintao was responsible for the economic growth of China and friendly relations with other countries. He practised collective leadership and concensus-based rule. Hu Jintao was known for technocratic competence rather than persona. Unlike Xi Jinping, he voluntarily retired from all his positions after his second term and earned praises for it. The two are worlds apart.
Rip that one off of wiki huhh 😅
@@RamcesOlivaZepeda And where did you learn yours? A movie most likely.
I am always impressed by such "experts" who could speak for 20 mins to mean : I don't know. Thank you CNA for wasting time on the interview
Thanks for the heads up. Saves me 10 min.
Loll
The quality of Chinese leaders is different from PM Lee, Liz Truss, Joe Biden and the like. Think of what China has achieved in the past 20 years under the leaderships of Hu and Xi.
The achievements of the past 20 years can be summarised as 胡习之治。
Do you know what are the periods of heyday/盛世 in China's long history?
There is a 500-year gap between the Great Asia and mini-BBC.
Ha ha ha!
LOL Well said
Read elsewhere for truths, read this one to have a feel of what's cooking.
*转发
栗战书：“别看了，涛哥。没咱们的人。”
胡锦涛：“一个•••一个都没有？”
栗战书：“一个都没有，连我都下去了。”
胡锦涛：“那克强呢？”
栗战书：“••••••”
胡锦涛：“当初说好的，我全退，他干完之后，交给小胡干，给咱们团派和太子派轮流坐庄。他•••他•••他这不讲武德啊！”
栗战书：“还小胡呢，他连政治局都没进。”
胡锦涛：“什么？”
习近平：“时间差不多了，请涛哥回去吃药。”
胡锦涛：“我•••我就算走也要看一眼名单再走！”
栗战书：“别看了，涛哥。团派完••••••”
王沪宁：“别再说了，再说，是不是你也想去吃药啊！”
栗战书：“••••••”
胡锦涛：“小习啊，这事儿还能再商量商量不？”
习近平：“涛哥都开始说胡话了，还不快请回去吃药！”
胡锦涛：“等等！让我再跟克强说句话••••••”
李克强：“涛哥，别•••别说了，再说，我就该陪您一起吃药了！”
胡锦涛：“••••••”
很明顯胡不滿意七個政治局常委名單啦!
胡肯定不是病了， 如果胡真的病了， 為何習一句問候說話都没說便直接叫保安把胡扶走了。
How enlightening! And expert telling us what we already know and that he doesn’t know what we also don’t know. Enlightening!
This is what we called waffling in university oral exam
And yet you still watched and commented.
Brilliant!!!
@@fredricksmith-something.2125 to seek enlightenment
why did you still call him "expert" ?? Please check your dictionary.
@@fredricksmith-something.2125 So you are one of those common clowns who thinks you can make clever repartee. Do you also like to get to the comment section quickly so you can say "FIRST" !?
the doctor's substance-to-word ratio is amazing
Dr Lim is the kind of guy that uses a lot of words to say nothing😂
🤣🤣🤣
I didn't understand what he said, so I watched this video again turning the auto-caption on. What I found finally was the fact that I wasted my time twice...
No wonder Jamus Lim shares the same surname, same family of people who likes to use a lot of words saying nothing
thank you for saving my time
I think I have to agree. All I hear is blah blah blah blah blah 😂
I din allow him to talk.... Lol
If Mr. Hu had been unwell and was guided outside to recover or for medical treatment, then the other party members had greeted him, looked at him and wished him well. This is how you would treat a former president and friend.
Mr. Xi did not look at him even when Mr. Hu directly spoke to him.
There is no way they would all be sitting there with stone-faces, if this was the real reason.
Hu did led and transformed China to prosperity, despite human rights record, and it was Hu who pushed to elect Xi 10 years ago 😢
Xi has response, said some words to Hu, it seems to me just a health issue
Adults in Chinese culture behave differently than what most Americans are used to. In this setting, everyone was acting appropriately. No surprises whatsoever.
@@Caocao8888 Just to say, I am not American, I lived in China, and now live a long time in Singapore.
In Asia elderly are treated with more respect than to be seen here.
@@krollpeter folls always will find an excuse, dont mind them.
Any way I'd love to connect with you if you currently living in China.
"He is not feeling well" everyone think he is not feeling well while Hu is the only one think otherwise.
Like Joe Biden.
@@capp11295 where? Mind to share the link?
@@capp11295 I also would like to read that article, if you don't mind sharing the link.
@@capp11295 sounds like you really know someone in the inner circle of the politburo of China, (or someone who knows someone who knows someone, etc.). Do you also want to hear about the Brooklyn Bridge I'm selling? 😂
This presenter did not look very happy when Dr, LIm did not give her the answers she expected to hear.
Why is this a discussion? CNA should know better that the west are manipulating this piece of insignificant event.
Show the full clip n not cut clips. The front show how xi communicated with HU. Last Hu came back when he is better n voted. Pls see whole not just the part
hahaha how do you know he was better?
@@Pato-ck8ez HE came back and voted. What is missing?
That idea that Hu came back to vote when he’s better was fake news. They voted before the meeting took place. Meaning someone lied to cover up for CCP by stating Hu being sick when he’s not.
@Ditsy Girl Don't they have a dinner party after the meeting, like in the west, to give each other the proverbial pat up the backside? BTW, the USA did not blow up Nordstream 1 & 2.
Hu didn't come back. All the news agency fsaw him being removed, nobody saw him come back. This another thing the government media made up for damage control.
U guys are reading too much, making baseless assumptions.
Came off none the wiser watching this piece of news analysis and interview.
Disappointed with CNA, there were earlier footage showing clearly Mr Hu was not behaving normally. He seems lost and Mr Xi has spoken to some aids to resolve the matter. It seems all the media were western driven to the extent of omitting the earlier footage. I used to believe SG main stream media, now I am not sure anymore.
Hu Jin tao had stroke 5 years back. have you deal with stroke patient, they can always look confused all the time. Most often very hard to understand what is told to them
The moment Hu finds out he's not feeling well.
The moment Hu realizes that he is not the top dog in China. (Hint: Dementia)
This time CNA is more objective in its coverage of the "event." This is unlike the previous one where it already concluded what happened without evidence to support it...and it did not explore the various possibilities...
CNA is pro west on most issues that involve China.
Objective? OMG... CNA just regurgitated Western media bullcrap... that's not being "objective'
Agree
Hardly objective when using words like "fiercely loyal to XJP". Such speculative narratives should not be used in an objective media. I would challenge them to use words like "So and so in PAP is fiercely loyal to LHL" if speculations is their style when reporting on Singapore politics.
@@testusersg How about using the same type of language when describing the USA or UK. CNA is a disgusting channel, regurgitating Western bias. I don't see Joe Biden appointing Lindsay Graham or anyone who is not his supporter to any position, nevermind position of power. To say Xi appointed people loyal to him is such a ridiculously twisted way of saying this - Joe Biden appointed people opposed to him to high positions - Oh, that didn't happen? CNA didn't highlight that? Morons.
Reading too much into all these unless you actually know what is going on.
Its not necessary to know the detail.
CNA's credibility slides away.
CNA , Channel news Asia. So late to air to Asia? Is already all over the world's channel. CNA can just closed this channel for good.
You conveniently leave out the parts where prior to being seated Hu Jintao acted like a senile Joe Biden unsure of what to do. Xi actually lightly touched Hu's hand/elbow and motioned for Hu to be seated.
You are correct. MSM deliberately leave out to pandered their anti China rhetorics.
where can i see the full version?
This analyst agrees with you…
th-cam.com/video/FDQ-M0WJRfo/w-d-xo.html
not supprise at all to those media hoohaa bout this, especially western. take care ur own business 1st.
Much ado over nothing. So much speculating, wth.
Why didn't CNA show how Hu Jintao walking into the hall? Pure speculation.
To view a concise and accurate analysis of this incident search for the TH-cam channel named Lei’s Real Talk.
Media describes Putin paralysised right arm.. Mr.Hu being dragged out from ”capit-al hill“. how wonderful r those paper experts.
From what i've been seeing in the comments. This was no Bernie sanders from the 2016 Democratic primary elections. Where he was reluctant to concede. Later returned to the stage with bruises on his face and in tears from his eyes, reluctantly, conceding before the primary was finalized.
CNA almost daily speculative about this news nonstop? Keeping fingers crossed for tomorrow.
Admirable for their cut and paste ability
CNA is going to milk this episode for all there is, salami slicing to get all the clicks possible. this is raw meat to China haters.
I have taken care of old folks before and this is how they behave when they are not feeling well. The video is incomplete. There is another video that feature the beginning of the session where the members were moving into their seats, there we can clearly see that Mr Hu is already being help to get to his seat and already looking muddled.
good point, but "seats" and not "sits."
@@darvidkoh2707 thanks =D
You need to catch up! 😂
There’re thousands of members, all seniors are ushered to their seats on the first day. We are more interested on why Hu alone was escorted out on the last day. 🤦♂️
@@jovimathews lol thousands ushered to their seats....?!?!? OMG 😆😆😆 you living in another world.....being help to get to his seat~~~ is very different from ushered~~~you need to stop twisting facts. Anyway your type will never learn.
I am so disappointed with our news media. When I have to look for comments from lay person for the truth. What do you think of the culture of our news reporting agency?
Their looks in this video when he was taken out were super SUS. Saw the comments in this video. Please kindly show the whole video and report base on that….
The Western MSM is making a Mountain out of a grain of sand.
Chinese Political Decisions and Choice is their rights and choice.
Just like that enjoyed by the Singapore Government to whom and who are to be selected as the Ministers and Prime Minister of Singapore.🤔😂😂
Only Modiji has the power to eliminate Emperor Xi from power.
HOW ? RIDICULOUS AND UNWARRANTED COMMENT
Anglo Saxons and other Western Imperialist countries raped, plundered, enslaved, humiliated, massacred and looted India for hundreds of years to fund their own economic development and industrialization.
They were responsible for the deaths of hundreds of millions of Indians.
Yet, Indians love the West and hate China who suffered the same fate at the hands of the Western Imperialist powers.
It's mind boggling, and hilarious.
Just focus on taking over Europe/West. You already have sunak as "king" of UK and another Indian varadkar whatever's his name as chief of Ireland.
Try Italy next, lots of Indians in Italy.
I also know that Indians are buying up lots of property in Czechia and other parts of Europe and bragging about it. Esp the Patel clan.
Lots of Indians are already king of Western IT and other corporations, deans at ivy league schools, increasingly dominant in western civil service and politics. Now that sunak is king, he should open up immigration into Uk to all Indian nationals with little requirements needed. UK Civil service minimum quotas to Indians, quotas in private commerce, housing etc. Good Times ahead 😏
@@kenlee1416 they are because of English language ,their colonial master language !
Is it possible for lip-readers to make out what Li Zhanshu said to Hu at the beginning of the released footage? The man Xi summoned to escort Hu out of the hall appeared to be the same guy who escorted Hu in at the opening ceremony a few days ago.
I tried. that guy's mouth is so weird which makes it difficult to interpret.
@@jbond5834 🤣🤣🤣
He said: all dictators have expiry date. Yours is today.
@@jbond5834 😂😂😂 But of course , Hu does not 100% agree to Xi . That's what politicians do , always asking for bigger slice of cake.
@@xxoo-lp6vc … and to their peril too !
CNA - why don't you fact check before your 'opinion piece' Disappointed with your reporting. We need to call you out for misinformation.
The same video can have many interpretations depending on each media's predetermined narrative about Xi and China. However it is interpreted, the fact is Xi in 10 years' time will be Hu's current age.
But Xi won't be in power by then. He is collapsing the Chinese economy with his unscientific Covid lock-down of the country which includes the shut-down of business and travel bans along with his destruction of corporations by too quickly shutting down the credit markets. People need to eat. They went through a period of prosperity where their lives improved and they won't forget it. People are already getting restive and Xi will not survive their response to his ancient style of rule.
Useless interview asking the wrong person who has no clue at all. All he knows is hard fact. Obviously, nobody hears what they say and he can only speculate.
PhD in time wasting .
Took him 5 minutes saying "I don't know" .
I think Jintao is a thorn in JinPing side.
*Watch the video closely theres no way that Hu was unwell at all cos if Hu was sick then Xi who sat beside him will utter some kind words or put his hand on his shoulder or be the one to usher him out instead Xi did not once strike any conversation with Hu but Xi summoned security officials to deal with Hu and yanked him out of his seat even when Hu resisted delicately and also its Hu who started the brief conversation with Xi who did not even look Hus in the eye and thats seems cold*
Right.
@@ingenuity168 Yup this is so right
I think Hu was not sick. It seems to me that Hu was denied the documents because he didn't satisfy with the seven members of the Standing Committee of the Political Bureau of the CPC Central Committee printed on the documents (七個中共中央政治局常委名單). Then he was persuaded to leave the hall by the assistant.
@GONG TAU MASTER Thats U and not Hu cos Hu is sober strong alert
@@kwokholuk8723 Its obvious Hu was hoodwinked and denied the documents
It is at least immoral to use the patient as the subject of the article.
Its clearly the case that Hu JinTao was
helped by his grandson to his seat earlier on. HuJinDao is 79.
He suffers feom Parkinson and Alzheimer. The camera shows
clearly Hu was unwell and was being helped first to his seat and then encouraged to rest.
It's shocking CNA is making a meal out of an old man's Parkinson's tremors. It's a slur on the impeccable running of the PRC ' s 5 days Congress. It's a bloody insult to XI and the CCP that in her wild speculation , the Reporter , (Jane ?) used such despicable accusations to blacken China's
reputation . She's. made many unverified cuts on Xi "gets involved... Hu's infamous exit..
Chinese politics which was always tightly - ( bad construction ) choreographed -- what does she mean ???
What does she really mean with her nasty with the word,"Tellingly..." ? and " given the opaque nature of the inner working of the Communist party...
What abusive language she hurls at Xi and the CCP!
This rude reportér mistakenly told the world its a singular red folder, dumping sinsister speculations on the summit red document, clearly
visible on everyone's table, stressing inappropriate ely, her own petty suspicions over an apparently innocuous handout.
She goes on with heavier emphasis on the word
'camera', in a sentence a provincial troll would pronounce GUILT -" The very fact that this was caught on camera..." The implication that the Chinese Congress only meet behind closed doors is blatantly obvious in her crappy tone of voice.
I object to the highly subjective report full of bias and intentional slander as given here by the reporter standing at the corner of the CNA screen. She's totally unprofessional, politically weaponised and slanderous... mainly misinformed. Her report is truly offensive . With this low grade reporting sentence is on Xi and the CCP Congress before the jury and th judge make their verdict.!
The event was a tiny pebble, and the Western media blew it up to be a huge boulder.
Hu Jintao appeared disoriented. Those who have close contact with senile senoirs are used to this. Don't make a mountain out of a molehill. CNA ,be non judgemental please.
CNA should do a piece on whether the Singapore regime as it stands today needs to fear a regime change by the democratic west led by the USA. And if so, how would it pan out? After all, it is an Asian news channel for Americans, isn't it?
We all just seat still, china are in good hand. Under the leadership of president xi, we believe that china will soon be our worlds no.1. As president xi has achieve many success, in making china great and powerfull?? Xi has a very good set of ways on how to made china become very advance and moderm and very very powerfull. As we see how more and many nations want to join china in sco, brics, even europe want to work with china and ditch usa....
Spin spin and spin as if you were at the scene. All of us are experts in one way or the other.
Well for something with dementia he walked pretty fast out of there. And he didn't want to go.
Why CNA cut the video when Mr. Hu Jintao walked thru the only way where we can see his small pace foot steps to show his sickness.
I think 胡锦涛 felt unwell in the midst of the meeting.
It's' quite normal for elderly person to feel unwell (at any moment) .... initially, it seemed like he's hesitant to leave (perhaps he felt confused or that it's impolite to do so) ... but after some sympathetic advice and persuasion, he finally agreed to leave (most likely for medical attention) ... and it seemed like he's apolgising or conveying his best regards to 习主席 & 李克强 .... and,
for the others, who are the national & military leaders and the people's representatives, they must have the presence of mind and discipline to remain calm and dignified .... to ensure the session could proceed as scheduled without any unnecessary interruption.
wumao pls go back to your dear PRC
Xi has been undergoing a power struggle for ages. He was not sick. This is an excuse. Xi now has more power than ever in the party. You can say he was sick. We all know that’s not why he was taken away.
you missed the shuffling of the paper and folder
@@NewmaticKe when hu is up, he is trying to pick up xi's paper, it seems he is unwell
If it’s medical attention, wouldn’t the usher comes in with a wheelchair, it’s faster and safer?
Stop pretending to be stupid. Just like Singapore and the PAP regime, has LKY not been in power until he died? Didn't Goh Chok Tong forced to abdicate his seat to LHS? Have LHS not been in power for almost 2 decades? Didn't LKY placed all his retired army general buddies in seat of power? What is the difference between all the facade in Singapore and all the facade in China? They all use the same playbook, just different in scope. If CNA doesn't know what this all means, then they should go back to school.
Dr., whats really going on? A: We really dont know!. Thank you for watching! Now a word from our sponsors!
Well, at least, unlike all the Western mainstream media's talking point, he is propagating the same conspiracy theory.
May it be filled with love and get better
Ask and it is given.
Even the wildest dream come true.
Well Hu Jintao “not feeling well” is technically not a lie. I’m sure he wasn’t in a joyous mood.
Lol! Sentiment shared by yours truly. All was not well as was evidenced by the forceful ejection he endured, and by no means did he take it well thus not feeling well about the whole affair. Otherwise he is well in health and all is well that ends well.
rumours said that he is still continue to be dragged till today
Dr Lim well said ! You are very knowledgeable,compare to the other comments thinking negatively!👍😧🙏
One of the rare guest of CNA who did not echo the west's narrative.
They may not invite him as a guest again.
Nah this Dr view is just so general cos any common people can think better than him
@@lonewolf7992 How you know about his mindset West or East or not you God is it ?
What is CNA trying to do?
@@limang-yong8673 Telling the truth to the world
I'm now as lost as I was before. All we know is that we don't know!
It's interesting that you guys edited out the most forceful part, with both hands under armpits which is in the original video.
seems like abuse
Hu jintao looks disoriented.
The week long party Congress must be tiring.
Thanks for the balanced analysis addressing multiple possible interpretations!
they didn't address how Hu looked Senile like Biden...kinda sad news these days
This is not balanced, they missed a clip.
I think Hu was exhausted after days of meeting. His brain was in a state of confusion. I worked in nursing homes for many years. I understand how old people behave when their mind got confused. They would refuse any help from the nurse and put up resistant. Hu appeared to struggling but he was actually resisting any help in a confused mind. But soon his mind was back to normal and he tap Xi and Li and was escorted out by his aid for a rest. You can ask any nurse, this kind of scenario happened in nursing home very often.
So Dr Mahathir is amazing…
Please watch 1:42, Hu's eyes looked surprised when he heard Xi was telling the assistant what to do. Hu seemed to have a clear-minded head.
@@kwokholuk8723 you can interpret what you want, but someone here says our million dollar news agency miss out the clips infront which shows Hu needs to be helped into his seat.
@@kwokholuk8723 I think he looked confused instead. You can asked the opinion of doctor, nurse or care workers.
so he's like biden's current state
I didnt hear a gun shot when he stepped outside the room so I think he's okay.
Wow... every slight incident become something big ..Xi is getting rid of Hu in such a manner .... Xi is indeed petty !
Look at Xi's face in the video . Does not need a body language expert to interprate his thoughts and behaviour. Surely you can tell what he is thinking.
You poor sheerp
When there is no news this is what you get. Trying to read too much into the situation.
So many jokers. I think you guys are ridiculous. Why do you foreigners care so much about China's affairs and the rights of we Chinese people? Are you a government official or a political scientist? Are you world citizens? You want to get a Nobel Price? Just mind your own business, he's 80 years old. Please read more books and feed your own family by hardworking.😮😮😮
This CNA, Channel News Asia is a Singapore media. Who told you it is Chinese media or China-friendly media? I think a wise man should realize what role Singapore plays between China and America. I just want to say Know things in your own mind from multiple angles and ways. Do not let many kinds of media lead you by the nose.
👌👌There are different types "jokers" here:
⏺those who are paid to spread China's "competitor's propaganda. They are the ones who will use phrases like ccp, winnie the pool. Quite easy to spot.
⏺Those who are useful idiots, the ones who believed Saddam Hussein had WMD. These people never learn.
The man looked sick, exhausted, and lost your propaganda is sickening too. Stay away from lying.
Thank u CNA for releasing the true news , u have all the world full support , even our Strait Time did not release the same video . We need a full explanation from Strait time editor
@@greatasia606 其实对我们外国人来说老胡也是活该，他也不是什么好鸟，他手里也是沾满了西藏人的血，他也是带头的刽子手，他今天是死前藏人送他的开路程
He forgot to bring his camera lah!.
THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED. Xi needed Hu Jintao's support to change the constitution. For this he gave signed commitments to Hu. After Hu signed off on change of constitution, the snake Xi went back on this commitment and took back the signed document by force. One of the commitments was not to prosecute Hu, his contacts and family members in future. And Hu asked Xi if he will keep his promise, to which Xi nodded while Hu was dragged out.
You will see Hu desperately trying to take a paper from that file but was forced not to.
If Mr. Hu was booted out by a Tyrant, he would not have been invited in the first place, Tyrant would have cancelled him long ago. Hu looked like Biden, a little Senile is all I can see, probably good to be escorted out instead of causing a mockery to the entire congress.
Perhaps I am mishearing, but you keep saying "our" cameras. The cam is, in fact, a pool cam feed from the CCTV.
What about the scene Hu was trying to take the file fron of Xi and Xi pulled it back ?
@Hong Yan That was the later cut off scene. Early report can be seen Hu tried to take the red folder in front of Xi and Xi pulled it back.
@Hong Yan You did not see the scene I talked about. It was censored.
Whatever happened during the incident, the Chinese government has no obligation to tell anyone, certainly not you or me or anyone who has nothing to do with Chinese government or Communist Party's affairs. There is no need to speculate. Life must go on, with or without Hu.
So does all this matter us? Don't meddle with other's politics with assumptions and speculations, or you will end up as a tool by the hostile parties. Results matter and we will see the next five years performance.
why interview the professor- he does not "know" the CCP mechanism. He is an outsider.
I think he was given a script to answer those questions
"People can't think for themselves because of fake news"
This US marine break it down for us here.
China: What Happened to Hu Jintao?, Just as the Western media spread lies about China before the Communist Party of China's (CPC) Congress including fabrications about a "coup" that never took place - the Western media is now lying about what happened during the Congress itself - including stories of former Chinese President Hu Jintao being "dragged" out of the event.
In reality - and by looking at footage of Hu Jintao being escorted in - it is clear that he was frail, ill, and disoriented and his departure from the event was health-related.
Source
The New Atlas
😮
@@condorX2 🤭😂
😂😂😂
What else. It's China. Everything is fake.
@@steven3626 it's Singapore also
Because Hu started to shake hand with thin air!!! He is escorted out so that he can continues the hand shake backstage.
Please show Mr. Hu Jintao entering the Great Hall ... video is available! Entering the Hall, Mr. Jintao appears confused or disoriented. Why leave this part out?
Dr Lim, what say you?
Dr Lim is very wordy, doesn't shed any light
Hasn't any.. to shed
Is it possible to lip read? Would be interesting to know what they say.
Does CNA think that this is newsworthy? Were those 'interpretations" meaningful? What is CNA doing?
Can you get Xi to explain why he ordered Hu to be escorted out ?
name list is changed without prior notice?
Shame, shame and terrible shameful for the way to get Ex-President Hu out!!?
The frail elder stateman ,
age 79, Hu Jintao, had been expected to step down for a long time.
So we must not look
too much into it.
,. Harris Ng YM
🇨🇳💜🇨🇳💜🇨🇳
The value in a respectful
retirement in the new world order.
is is not possible to lipread what these guys are actually saying? That would be a big help. Or is Chinese not lip-readable?
Show the full video' that former president escorted to enter and out.
There’re thousands delegates, all seniors are ushered to their seats on the first day. We are more interested on why Hu alone was escorted out on the last day. 🤦♂️
@@jovimathews because he is so old' like Biden lost in directions.
You did not show the clip where Hu Jintao mistakenly grabbed Xi’s notes.
It seemed more like he was interested in the contents of Xi's folder. Not confused grabbing
hahaha how do you know its mistakenly?
@@Pato-ck8ez He was looking obviously for his notes because it was taken from him. He thought Xi’s notes was his.
@@Pato-ck8ez By the way he approached to it
Li took Hu's folder of notes. Hu wanted to read Xi's notes instead. But Xi held his notes.
Did your reporters had the full picture? Hu later came back to vote!
*I am more surprised to see that almost all politicians were stone faced when Hu was whisked off*
The face of fear
You don’t know the Chinese culture. People will try to control their emotions during the official occasions
@@smithrachel8383 yea I too would control my emotions if I knew that it would get my ass hauled into 're-education'
maybe they know Hu was not feel good!
@@kimchan2335 How will they know when they dont even bother looking at him ?
He didn't really say anything?
Please CNA, don't follow the West media news and you only show Mr. Hu Jintao escorted out the room but did you watch how he was assisted to walk in the hall? He wasn't feeling well when he was walking into the hall.
Watch the real video from the beginning. Mr. Hu Jintao is a very well-respected leader in China. Please learn how to report the other side of the real story or different from others.
You are right. And Xi personally make sure Hu was seated down. CNA only plays the ugly scene of escorting out and not other gestures of care and concerns for HU.
I think there are some ulterior motives.
On which part of this video you saw was followed the western media report?
Won't CCP pressurised PAP for these clips begin sent around the world.
cna u need to talk to someone with chairvoyant power n not a PhD
Hilarious, Singapore, an authorian country criticized China? 🤣🤣🤣
I believe there is the scene the young man trying to lift Hu up in his chair..
Hu to Xi : power is not forever , karma is waiting for you too.
Hu , Wen and their era of stability and peaceful prosperity will be missed greatly.
The making of a brutal dictator there. The world is much more dangerous with him around.
Watch the entire unedited video ! It’s available now. The western media has badly edited the first released video.
Retard inventing your own story
@Chia Chee Seng were you that fly underneath Hu’s seat, overhearing what he actually said?
And the premier caught in a karma
Nah. That guy didn't HELP him to his feet. He forced him up and escorted him out.
And they absolutely wanted this caught on camera.
CNA, please watch all the video footage available, including how he was escorted into the hall at the beginning of the proceedings. Clearly he was not well and not entirely lucid
Correct , the person escort him out was the same escort in 😅
clearly it showed is related to the content of the red folder
Hu was well all along.
@@waynegoh2295 of course , Hu does not 100% agree to Xi . That's what politicians do , always asking for bigger slice of cake.
Compare to Biden raid Trump's Florida home , this is nothing.😅
@ Swee Tiag Quek , western brainwash China ha-te has no brain , they just want to fault China to satisfy . People with so much hate , I doubt they respect their elder 😅
No longer need his service any longer
Hu Jintao is a PAST TENSE. Even if he were to make a fuss, it would change nothing. The new Chinese Leadership will carry on regardless of this episode.
Those that are anti-China for no good reason will be more so with this episode. No fact & reality will change them a bit.
Well said. Some people hope a conspiracy theory will somehow weaken China. No gossip is going to stop China from rising; it also won't stop the echo chamber from making more noise.
Now it is a known fact why this CNA video are getting a large following on Twitter. It's basically an "anti-China" video of criticizing the CPC for being unkind to a frail old person.
The old man didn't like what's in the red folder pissed him off. Made a huge stink about it on live television. XI order him removed. He's letting HU know and the rest of the party "I'm in charge don't f*** with me or you'll be end up in an unmarked grave"
It’s none of Singapore problem.
CNA does not provide in-depth analysis. Just words from the reporter and "experts. Watch the foreign press. They provide in-depth analysis and better coverage.