ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ต.ค. 2012
- Dog whisperer Cesar Millan has defended himself against claims that he is cruel to animals.
The allegations were made recently in a TV interview with presenter Alan Titchmarsh after tweeting animal-lover critics said the Mexican-born trainer used violence and even electric shocks to train the dogs.
But, Millan told Sky News, he made physical contact with the dog to distract the dog from the action it was about to take - for instance, stop the dog from going into fighting mode.
SUBSCRIBE to our TH-cam channel for more videos: / skynews
Follow us on Twitter: / skynews and / skynewsbreak
Like us on Facebook: / skynews
Follow us on Instagram: / skynews
For more content go to news.sky.com and download our apps:
Apple itunes.apple.com/gb/app/sky-n...
Android play.google.com/store/apps/de...
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.76[2/2] เดินมาสิบกว่าป่า วันนี้รู้แล้วว่าโจโฉกลัวอะไร!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/R7Yor-t2Au0/mqdefault.jpg)
People who thinks he is being abusive here are the same people that will end up on his show.
...and who are the first to call for euthanasia when a badly lead dog finally attacks s.o. ... hypocrites
They're alo the ones putting down dogs that can actually be helped if they were more willing to recognize that treats and smiles don't solve everything.
And even if people think he is bad and fake, they might just be some of the people who dont watch his vids.
If the dog felt it was being abused, it would try to leave.
th-cam.com/video/Pw3glB4qQPY/w-d-xo.html
LOL "My clients are Harvard graduates but they can't walk a Chihuahua" :D
+ZettaiBaka :)) Lol ... exactly.
I read this at the exact moment he said that and it was crazy
Wtf? How is that cruel at all? That's like the human equivalent of tapping someone on the shoulder. Man, it scares me how pussified people are becoming.
Lithostoic IKR! Soon every living thing will need to wrapped up in bubble wrap!
@@gcollz_ tbf being wrapped up in bubble does sound fun lol but yeah totally agree.
@@gcollz_ like Ur mother'
Imty Ray great come back, was your 7th birthday party good?
@Steven H puss-c
First off: If the kick hurt the dog, the dog would let out a quick yelp. Ever step on a dog's foot accidentally? Second: The kick force needed to hurt a dog would send the dog flying or off it's balance at least. When being "kicked", I've never seen a dog on these episodes do anything other than look at Cesar for a split second, then return to whatever it is that originally held their attention. I've never so much as seen a dog yelp at any of Cesar's moves, at all. I could go on. My point here is, people are way too emotional about this. Nothing suggests cruelty here.
d rodriguez
Okay, so your calling me stupid, yet, your the one talking against what every expert says.
Cesar is very Respectful just ppl don't see that and act stupid
Fluffy Waffles agreed the kick is more of a firm touch not a kick. PDT's have to lighten up.
Fluffy Waffles u couldn't be more right Man even tho I don't suggest that on a chihuahua haha many reasons for that but yeah big dogs and a quick foot touch is not hurting the dog because the dog is in the now and not in the past or in the future we as human beings could solve a lot of problems that ways if we have a lot of bad experiences with different kind of things
Go learn how wolfs teaches their packs or young ones respect. a little touch is nothing compared :)
I think yanking back harshly on the leash to control the animal is even worse... Cesar's methods work, this is how my dad raised his pack of seven dogs in the past and all of them were very loyal and respectful. They were never ever leashed either!
Soumi they obeyed cause they were scared to disobey.
Do they love him?
@@aBunnyThatWillChewOnYourCables These methods aren’t scare tactics.
@@aBunnyThatWillChewOnYourCables They absolutely do love him. He even takes in dogs when their owners can't control them, and they were going to be put down. Follow up and see those danger dogs licking his face and part of a happy family. A tap with your foot can stop a bloody dog fight!
My god, if they think a soft kick to the side of a dog is cruel, just wait till they see how their chickens died to feed them on thanksgiving. I don't make animal cruelty accusations, because as someone who eats meat, I know not to be a hypocrite.
Is this a joke? Miserable people always find something to complain about. This man respects dogs to a level that most people couldn't comprehend. He takes in and loves/helps the most dangerous dogs. He's wonderful, he should be thanked. If you think that was painful in any way to the dog you know NOTHING about dogs.
Preach👏
yes girl
th-cam.com/video/Pw3glB4qQPY/w-d-xo.html
All he's doing is trying to emulate how dogs discipline each other. And dogs don't inflict serious pain to teach discipline, so neither does Cesar. And everyone who's not completely unfit to be a dog owner will see that he only uses physical corrections when the dog is too excited to pay attention to him, so that he won't have to use force anymore. The goal is to never need anything but your presence and posture to instill respect in your dog.
I would say that it's much worse with owners who pull their dogs around in their leashes their whole lives, straining their muscles and joints, rather than just showing who's boss right from the get-go and eliminating the need for physical corrections.
th-cam.com/video/Pw3glB4qQPY/w-d-xo.html
Yes and dogs can’t speak and reason with each other like humans can.
Completely agree.
That's a tap, not a kick.
Astralis Lux Tap? What is your definition of a tap then? I’d like to know. That is most certainly a kick.
@@thotchocolate8503 My definition of "to tap": to hit something with little enough force to do no damage to the receiving party.
I agree that this looks like a tap.
im a hardcore animal lover and i cry and get pissed when i see animals in harm cesar is not hurting any animal what so ever you guys are dumb you people must not see real people abusing animals cuz this sure aint abuse
That was not a kick. There are enough TRULY ABUSED dogs in this world for people to KNOW THE DIFFERENCE. Use all this time on your hands to help those dogs, rather than take Cesar Milan to task for his methods. TURN THE CHANNEL.
Dogs and horses really appreciate strong leadership. Cats are a different story, lol.
nameofthepen while cats are somewhat different, they still respond positively to a pack leader and some expectations. Had dogs and cats together for about 50 years now, and the cats are part of the pack!
Cesar is the best,only idiots think he "abuses" animals.
only idiots who abuse dogs thinks he is not cruel
Only sheep follow the mass and refuse to find error in others ways darlin'
I am not saying he's over here beating a dog and skinning it alive but it is abusive to cause unneeded strain and stress as well as choke a dog
yes agreed
Ahh, I see darlin' no problem~ 😝
Dog abuse is a dog not well trained. Nothing more sad than watching a dog walk its owner around the block. Some dogs are difficult and stubborn and tough love is necessary. We have a rescue lab mix that is aggressive and needs to be sternly corrected. No time to give treats when they lunge out at another animal or person walking a dog. They need to be taken hold of by the scruff or given a firm tap on the rump so they know certain behaviors are not allowed. Milan is great and his techniques work.
Hi Lunar, your comment is based on ignorance and stupidity. Caesar on has dogs that have problems that the owners CANNOT fix. He just uses common sense to retrain these owners.
That kick was so quick and powerful it could've broke the dog and Chuck Norris's ribcages into million pieces, obviously.
This man trained daddy and junior, 2 huge Pitbulls to be the most gentle dogs. He loves dogs and has saved so many.
Junior has bitten people & killed a dog after ceaser rescued him
@@debbietaylor5183bs
Cesar millan is the best dog trainer EVER! >~
No he isn't, a good animal trainer doesn't need to use choke or prong collars and good trainer certainly doesn't kick a dog. Lightly or not.
He rehabilitates dogs, he TRAINS people. He is: the dog whisperer
+raj bist he brainwashes people, he kicks dogs, he is: the dog abuser
***** Age doesn't define knowledge.
+Sumthinsfishie aquatics it doesn't take an expert search "are dogs pack animals" on google.
I have watched Millan's shows and he does seem genuinely compassionate towards the dogs and he gets results. His work is more subtle and more carefully timed than most people can manage, so what is a touch or a tap from Cesar can turn into a blow or a kick when someone else tries to do it. I have also noticed that he does not use food, which is the main motivator for many positive reinforcement dog trainers.
he uses force and shuts dogs down and setting them up for failure he failed the german test he is a joke to dog trainers
I wouldn't say that he uses force and what has failing the German test to do with this situation
He got results using his method and that s what got him famous in the first place......no need for all those theories.....
I feel the reason why he won't use treats or food for positive reinforcement is because the dog might become conditioned to always receiving treats before or after the appropriate behaviour is shown... the dog might think " if i do this behavior, i get food" and the dog might be hiding the real behavior in his true intentions
He is not even a dog trainer, to start with lol.
Ok ok, so even if it were a kick... would it be better for them to be trained with maybe two kicks or be constantly getting into trouble? Realistically? The best way to know if it was a kick or not is to see the dog's reaction. There was no whining and no show of pain... it was obviously not a kick.
People project too much of the human on dogs.
+ou cecilia positive reiforcement
+Subs1338 agreed
The kick is making the dog afraid of cesar. He's not really fixing the problem the dog has. Stupid uneducated people take his advice too seriously.
+thehannaawsome your A fuckin dumbass lmfao
dogs are not slot machines of food (Victoria Stilwell), all dogs do not like rewards. I do not see this woman work with an aggressive 120 lb rottweiler... when people tell cesar "... 3 or 4 trainers try to work with my dog an fail... is this type of training... " thats the reality beyond a tv show... cesar rules!!!!!!!!!
Cesar is awesome. A natural trainer. His dogs love him. Listen to Cesar.
People who think that was a "kick" should get one to know the difference.
As an animal lover who owns dogs, if I ever thought that an animal was being mistreated in anyway I would be the first to contact the authorities. The clip shown here is not Cesar abusing a dog, it is Cesar training a dog very well. The dog did not yelp or whimper or look unhappy at anytime. If feel sorry for people that find a conspiracy in everything.
Looks not even a kick like a lil tap
People are gullibt
Kick? Is this a joke? That was a small nudge with the flat part of the shoe, in what universe does that count as a kick?
so I have spent a lot of time watching this man and how he works with dogs and people. What I see is his patience, love and consideration for the animal he is working with. I have also seen him been bitten on more than one occasion and yet he has never reacted in anger towards the dog involved. Love this guy and all he give for the greater good of our planet.
Totally agree with Ceasers methods. He gets results people want. Hence why he upholds his reputation as a successful dog whisperer
Marc Gray Nobody said it doesn’t work. I know that if I kick, shock, prong, choke and alpha roll my dog when he misbehaves he’s not going to do it again... does that mean I should do it though when there are other options?
@@thotchocolate8503 He didn't kick the dog though, what's your point
These "cruelty claims" merely prove that people generally don't understand stuff they are commenting on.
kick? more like a light nudge
Many people don't try to think that maybe he didn't kick as hard as it may looked.
People are idiots.. no harm to the dog, just giving the dog a different direction to focus his energy one..vrs getting dog aggressive.. I don't see abuse
***** he picked the puppy up the same way a other dog would pick yup their young.
Ceser is not cruel I use Cesers techniques myself and my dog loves me. I give her affection,discipline and exercise.
www.dogbreedinfo.com/articles/dominanthumans.htm
TheHiddenTiger 07 dominant human...oh bullshit everywhere...
So the owners are alphas of dogs...HAHAHA HAHAH THAT ....is the most stupid thing I have ever heard...no one ...NO ONE called owners of a dog a alpha human
they need a leader just like wolf need a pack and a leader. The leader is a guide.
Rofl that's cruelty ? Wtf is wrong with people
I tried the nudge and the tsst sound to my rescued staff/boxer, she was really difficult to take out on a walk and pulled like a train when on the lead or harness. It was amazing, she now walks out on a collar and loose lead.
Oh my god, Really - how the hell can anyone say that Cesar Millan is cruel to dogs? Really??????? How incrediably ignorant.
I'm from the uk and I have seen cesars show he knows what hes doing, people who say hes mean they are stupid simple either they don't know how train a dog which clearly he does. No wounder we have some dogs ban from our country because of lack of knowledge.
Been there, seen it, worn the T shirt, violence just be gets violence. Just because it works short term doesn't mean it solves the problem. Just because he wins the battle doesn't mean he wins the war. Do your research, and you will see.
It's bad dog owners not the dog that gets them banned here.
True I agree its defiantly the owners
that was a light tap to the ribs. PULLING ON YOUR DOGS NECK BY THE LEASH IS MORE ABUSE THEN THAT.
Damn Cesar Millan, he almost broke the dogs hips & send it to the hospital. Put him in jail.................
Charles Yeager he was being sarcastic
Antonio Martin that was funny .. your sarcasm went right over his ? head.lol
Korey Lightning Didn't notice :/
Me either lol
Look at my before comm
I had a 3 year old dog who was very aggressive and trainers were going to put him down so I came across ceased millan and his methods work in 4 months my dog goes every were with me and he is very loyal and hardly growls at any thing
Pulling the leash continuously when your dog is out of control is much more painful for your dog than just a quick "touch" like Cesar did.
Big facts!
I love how everyone is like "omg the touch hurts the dog" .. I mean, have you ever watched a few dogs play? They are so much rougher than a leg in front of them or a human poking their butt. Bubblewrapping dogs just makes them unstable.
that wasnt even a kick wtf it was just a nudge.... and besides, he explained it very thoroughly why he have taken that action... wtf is wrong with those people who are claiming that he is cruel to animals???
+정희제 (ChubbyHub) Cesar is very strong. If he wanted to kick that dog, the dog would have flown over the fence!
Honestly, pulling the dog would be hurting them more than a tap by the foot
People who think that a gentle tap of a heel to the side of a dog is a "kick" should NEVER own a dog.
I see no problem with what he did, I think it is quite brilliant the way he handles dogs. He's not instilling fear and he doesn't abuse them. There is always a reason behind his actions.
Wow, ppl are ridiculous. He's one of the few ppl who actually put all their lives into helping dogs and ppl alike. He never sugar coats things but does what's best for the dogs. Even taking in dogs who may otherwise be put to sleep. Smh for ppl who do good. Need to focus on those who are actually abusing animals.
+Raphsody86
Yes please! Very good point, thanks for that. Folks rise up against "cruelty" and forget the real cruelty we, so called humans, inflict on animals. Eg. Earthlinks in a hurry...
I don't think that sort of little kick could be worst that pulling repeatetly his neck using the leash. I don't think either a dog to be such susceptible to pain or supposed "humiliations". People who think that are thinking at their dogs like childrens.
Food in your pocket, no I was poor i couldn't afford food in my pocket 😂 he's great comedian and great guy smart, and saved countless dogs from being put to sleep 🐶🐕🐩
That tap kick is call "snap out of it" A pure simple technique for a redirection. People with no experience handling a dog will call that a kick.
Some people are just idiots. I love this guy! He's the freaking dog whisperer! sometimes I wish I knew at least half of what he knew on how to train your dog.
I have tried several "styles" of how to train my dog and Cesar Millan training style is the only one that works for me. The relationship between me and my dog is of mutual respect, trust and love. (Blue is his name, he is a labrador/great Dane ).
I never really understood this controversy. Claims of Ceasar abusing dogs. I know that his methods have shown to work, especially with the more aggressive type of dogs. Like I dunno... =_=
Every single thing that Cesar has shown on his show that I have used has worked! It didn't change my dog either! He's happy all the time! I love Cesar Milan! I would never believe anything about cruelty from him because on his shows he is very humble and if he is wrong he will admit it. A person like that is a rare person. A person like that would never abuse an animal.
Thanks Beatrice, soooo very true too.
to me, a kick is forceful, sharp (uses toes often), and intended to hurt the dog. this was him putting his foot behind him, and crossing around his own back to bump the dog with the side of his foot. in that movement, it's practically impossible to get enough force to really hurt an animal, and he is clearly not using much force. the dog did not yelp or cower or look for reassurance, the dog just turned around like "what was that?!" i do not interpret this action as abuse.
People think that light kick that he did was bad? ....really?
loll i dont even have dogs but Cesar got my respect and support 👌
that wasn't even a kick like he said it was a touch but of course all the haters see is his foot "kicking" the dog the dog didn't wine either so all his haters need to snap to reality and get a life
i like cesars methods more because its a mor natural state that the dog is in, other than a treat because imo, the treats make the dog a robot to commands
AngryPOV correct my aunt always give my dog treats but before she gives him his treats he has to give right paw, left paw, both paws then gets his treats and now everytime she wants to give him his treats she doesn't have to say anything he already know what to do.
Kinda sad actually he is such a robot that he starts to give me a paw when i want to give him a treat and i didn't even wanted to ask for his paw
Smoker 1404 No, the dog just wants a treat and is doing something he knows has gotten him a treat in the past. 😂 He’s not a robot.
Cesar is a fantastic person who has acres of knowledge and experience of how to correct and raise dogs the RIGHT way intended for them. I think that people who are interpreting him as 'cruel' really should watch an episode of the dog whisperer and actually ask themselves if they can control a pack of 30+ dogs like Cesar so calmly does.
Pfft who would think thats a kick? He barely touched the dog.
People really are too sensitive nowadays. That was a tap for crying out loud. There was no anger or aggression behind it. The purpose was exactly what Cesar said "To snap the dog out of it". He does that with many dogs.
What a travesty. The amount of force in that kick must have shattered the internal organs of that poor dog. It amazes me that this man has the audacity to even attempt such a technique.
nice troll, but internal organs don't shatter they rupture 😂😂😂
+Lucahz ... :)) Good point brother :) But actually it was a "dog-dim-mak" and the dog died after making 5 steps, shhhht please!
R u 4 real ? If the dog was in pain u would have heard the dog crying ! Was it afraid of Cesar ... hell No, only more respectful and at the end much happier doggy. Ur uneducated vue on animal kingdom rules in a pack blinds u. U r an animal lover with no logic what so ever ... just a softy !
Top 10 Lists chill it's sarcasm 😂😂😂
I don't get why people would be crying about this. Dogs may even bite each other to clear out fights...
That was just a little love tap.....
I have never seen him be cruel at all, If anything too lenient.
He is a man who respects this beautiful breed, understands them, and the same time is fearless....He is amazing. There are serious issue to take care of in this world leave Dog whisperer alone.....
didn’t think I’d hear Eamonn when I clicked on this haha
it was not bad... did the dog cry? no!!!! It did not hurt him!!!
Pff MMA fighters kick; Cesar only tapped the aggression out of that dog :-)
Yeah it's true like today I was taking my dog for a walk she constantly is sniffing the grass . She would spend all day sniffing around if I let her . She would walk for a neno second and start sniffing again so I gave her a little tap. And it worked there is nothing mean about it at all . If people really want to get upset they need to confront the real animal abusers the ones who intentionally hurt there dogs ..
here we see an excellent example of the wind god kick where cesar is able to kick behind himself and land a hit on the infant dog with a force of 2000 pounds per square inch, effectively exploding the dog
LOL :P
😂
🤣🤣
As Cesar says, he doesn't "train dogs". He trains people. He rehabilitates dogs.
The only dog I have seen him actually kick is the yellow lab Holly, who had the food aggression issues. But that dog was literally chewing on his hand, and correcting something like that is completely justified.
Agreed. I saw that episode and Cesar had no choice.
if there are ppl calling that touch (with a feet ) a kick or abuse, seriously, i have to stop tapping on ppl's shoulder to say hello or else someone going to sue me for physical abuse. I guess some ppl just can't tell the differences between touch or kick. lastly, thank Lord for sending Cesar to this world to help save and educate lives. God Bless Cesar.
I love what Cesar Millan does with the dogs, who else on the Planet can control a vicious dog in such a short amount of time ??? Answer.... NO ONE.
He breaks dogs.
Try watching Sophia Yin.
Service Dog Nova how
wow... some people really think that's a kick??? LOL... try watching a movie/tv show of people punching and kicking, it will give them a better understanding of what a KICK means.
what Cesar did was a touch / tap using his feet, thats all. ahahaha
na the people who think that was a kick need to feel how a real kick feels
The problem with a lot of American TV and all around the world, is you simply cannot believe what you see. Just today I read that his team get the dogs worked up into this state etc so he can act this way with them. I've had a reactive dog and his methods do not work long term, they infact make it worse. What does work, patience, love and a gentle hand.
Who would you work for the bully boss or the one who treats you with respect. Dogs arent stupid.
omg people get with it I think I have watched almost every video of Cesar's and I ve never once thought he was cruel this guy is amazing
People getting crazy over a ridiculous thing like that is literally an extension of the 'offended by anything' society we live in today.
It was a touch, not a kick!
My clients are Harvard graduates but they can't walk a Chihuahua. HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
I just got a dog, and I am using Cesar's methods... and my dog is a puppy and he is behaving wonderfully. I haven't used the heel tap yet, because he's quite small, but getting the focus off of other dogs and on me, just works. A calm submissive dog is the kind of dog every owner should want. Mine doesn't bark, doesn't whine or cry at night, still shits and pisses in the wrong places, but I am pretty happy with the progress so far. Only had him 2 days so far.
so, how is the puppy today?
Peoplevare jalous of him succes that is the real problem!!! This men loves dogs helps dogs we need a lot of people like this and some people are jalous of him that 's it!
People can be so soft and hyper emotional. Cesar is a master and his results speak for themselves. How many people do u know have a pack of 40 or so dogs full of powerful breeds living in harmony? Enough said! The proof is in the pudding!
man these people should just leave cesar alone he knows what hes doing
oh god that is barely a kick lmao
I understand the grief that Cesar gets from people who lack appropriate knowledge about dogs. We had a Canadian Sled Dog or Inuit Sled Dog for 16 years until we had to put her down when she suddenly developed a huge tumor which caused total paralysis and blindness. Mandy moved when my sister moved- her new neighbors reported her to the Humane Society for having her sled dog outside in below 0 degree Fahrenheit weather ( with a proper shelter available) The officer came to the door and started an official report. Mandy's vet was in charge of the local Humane Society and couldn't believe it. He made the officer apologize to Diane. He gave education about this ancient breed that took explorers to the North Pole and were used as working dogs by the Eskimos.
people used to say the same thing about Steve Irwin too -that he was torturing the animals picking them up and showing them to the camera,this shows how little people know not only about animals but also about people who deal with them
Cesar's fans are as loyal as dogs. WE LOVE YOU CESAR!!!
He doesn't hit them. He taps them lightly to get them out of a certain frame of mind.
I have a toy fox terrier/pomeranian mix. The pomeranian in him makes him nervous and the terrier part of him makes him domineering. If I hadn't used what I learned from Cesar to understand this little fella, he would have been an unmanageable little nutcase. Before I started training him, he was snappy and scared all the time. It took some work, but now he's the cuddliest, cutest little dog in the world. Because he trusts me and respects me, he can relax now.
He's simply interrupting what they're doing, which is reconditioning the brain to change old patterns to new ones. Not abusive at all and something we as humans should do as mental exercises ourselves
In fact, parents could take some lessons from Cesar. He never raises his voice or yells at a dog from afar or acts frantically at a dog. I've seen plenty of people yell frantically and loudly at their children and their dogs exactly the same way. The only message that the children and dogs get is that you are emotionally unstable, not in leadership or control and they can't trust you.
I have seen dog owners mistreating their dog much more often than I would see him snapping the dog out of its bubble!
there's no sound??
it's a touch not a kick a kick is in soccer or football not in dog training it's a touch with the foot to get the attention
A correction pure and simple. Just distracts the dog. I wish people who have no fuckin clue would just piss off.
So, what about the one where he hangs a dog until it almost passes out? We all just going to ignore that abuse?
which one is that
Shadow -- the dog was actually removed from the original owners as a result of taking him to Cesar Millan too.
+Zeros & Ones Thanks I'll look him up
Usaya Owo
No probs :)
Oh come on, he didn't do that. The dog snapped and tried to hurt him so he grabbed the collar and tried to keep him away from him. Then the dog did that to himself because he was going crazy, it wasn't Cesar. Or was he supposed to let him go after him?
People who think that this is abuse they don't know what abuse is...
You are my dog. Finally, someone real that I can worshop.
How in this world was that a kick. Wtf
An Canadian Sled Dog also known as Canadian Eskimo Dog or Inuit Sled Dog was used to this type of weather and native to the Arctic.We were given Mandy as a puppy by Diane's coworker who couldn't care for her anymore . They are required for transportation in areas of the Arctic where there are wolves or bears because they can detect them from a distance.They look similar to a wolf but show no recent ancestry. I remember that Mandy howled instead of barking. We had to put an egg/ oil in her diet and had to vigorously brush her coat. She would rather pull kids on a cart than take a walk. We had to cut and thin out her coat in summer and she swam to stay cool.She would come in the house once a year to receive her Christmas stocking and presents and could only handle the warmth for 30 minutes before having to go outside.We lived in the country and she had a lot of room to run. This wouldn't be the dog to have if you live in an apartment or in the city . This isn't the dog to have if you expect an inside dog and, don't have time to give it a lot of intense exercise- they love to run and jump high. Owners who have more than one of these dogs usually keep them in large outdoor kennels and sometimes have to keep them separated , although they are a pack dog.