@@Iavcxoxo No, baby doll, I read the comment correctly. Winter’s voice is ALSO prominent in the chorus. You can CLEARLY hear her and Ningning harmonizing together. They saying Ningning’s voice is so “prominent in the chorus” is a discredit to other members. In this case Winter.
Reminds me of Bae from NMIXX. Both are not the strongest vocalists of their groups, but their voices play an important roll during the whole song, in my opinion.
The thing that I kinda dont like with SM is that their harmonies and even iconic adlibs at hidden vocals are produced to sound very quiet. While there are times that you can hear them but most of the time they can sound less noticeable. Sometimes you need a very good pair of earphones to hear it while other groups have a very noticeable harmonies. I hope they flaunt it next time because they kill on harmonies and vocals.
One time i saw a comment about that some radios and some earphones just cannot handle that much so they had to lower it so you can actually listen to it
Ningning reminds me of Wendy so much in terms of octaves, diversity, being able to harmonize with each member. She is truly a gem. I cannot wait to see how she grows and dominated in the industry.
Winter’s “yeah im coming” part is absolutely mind blowing. The way she sings is so powerful, and she adds such a special quality to all of aespa’s music. she truly is gifted 🩷
2:39 i came to hear karina high note clearer tbh she slays wish they made it more prominent in the song her tone is the best rlly pleasant to the ears😭
It doesn’t sound like any of them it’s probably another back vocal or many even the vocals from the original demo. Cuz it kinda sounds like voice from the original demo
It will be all of them and then ning2 layered over top or in the backround. Like spicy post chorus and then she would've been singing underneath that for example
It is isn’t it? Like they lead the parts in the chorus where they are centre. So the first chorus goes: Karina NingNing Winter Giselle Second Chorus: Winter Giselle Third Chorus: Karina NingNing
@@WAFFLE747 I feel like the producers meant to put Karina + Giselle as leads in the choruses but it definitely sounds like Ning2 is overpowering them in the back
either main vocal get the most or least line, SM main vocalist usually have many hidden vocal and adlib. can't wait to hear ningning's vocal in the recording session. the vocal in this song is craxy
Now i understand why Giselle has the least line. She's leading the whole chorus similar to Black Mamba. Edit: I apologize, It was not giselle. The producer needs to acknowledge her talents and give my girl a solo rap part. We know how powerful she is.
for anyone wanting to hear the backing vocals only, just look up : aespa drama dolby atmos stems, and go to the top rear overhead chapter :) they are heavenly, and most of them are done by the demo singer (with some hidden adlibs from our girls)
all my favorite parts 0:21 to 0:29 "I li-li-like" OMGG SO HARMONIZING 0:49 "I'm coming" A different voice (isn't aespa) literally scream IM COMING SO GOOOOOOD 1:08 "Drama-ma-ma-ma-ma" Ningning singing in a different tone and there's another voice singing in an octave lower hits me harder 1:14 to 1:22 someone is slaying here singing in an octave HIGHER 1:37 to 1:44 HEAVEN 1:51 HEAVEN AGAIN 2:05 "I'm coming (one more time)" THIS IS SO GOOD I CANT 2:28 "durio o, hajima, you and I, this is the most beautiful melisma I ever heard 2:56 "oooh, oooh" 3:11 my favorite favorite part, "you know I'm savage, 거침없는 baddest" there's no aespa, again it's another girl, maybe a SM trainee? I don't know, I just know that I LOVE THIS PART, I KEEP REPLAYING AND REPLAYING NONSTOP 3:18 this is DRAMAAAAA DRAMA MA MA DRAMAAAAAAAAA DRAMA MA MA
I love how chorus sounds ok this version. It sounds more human like, you hear the actual voice of the girls, not the combination that sounds kinda different. The same in spicy pre-chorus
these things are what set sm apart from everyone else. they never miss any details, perfect production since the 90s and still hold themselves to the standards that they set
i love how big and sweeping the pre-choruses and outro sound with the hidden vocals turned up. it makes the song sound even more like a powerful action movie
Idk why there are so many people hating ningning😢 as the main vocalist, she does serve a lot for background music. She’s literally the girl in the back. Honestly, ningning has so many haters just cuz she’s a foreigner, especially she’s Chinese😅
Ningning is doing the harmony part in the chorus. the other members are doubling the main melody line too. 0:54 you can also hear karina doubling the main melody line in another version that removes all the instrumentals. 1:01 winter also is the chorus harmonizing. you can hear at least three members' voices.
Guys ik that the rest of the members like gigi, ningning, and winter are amazing..but can we appreciate Karina for a minute? I’ve only seen 2 comments (so far) talking about Karina’s little highnote at the 2:41. She only ever gets talked about for her visuals but never her singing. Like, it’s almost like ppl are saying she has no talent in this song without saying she has no talent in this song. So like, can we appreciate her just for a little bit? She deserves more.
I think it fits even better than the original. The hidden vocals sound AI and robotic yet harmonizing, which really fits the songs aura and the groups concept. I wished hidden vocals could be heard louder by any group, because some groups layering is very impressive but it’s sad you can’t really hear them
noobs read this = Most of the backing vocals is just an unknown vocalist, probably the singer of the demo, a bit weird for aespa but it sounds great regardless
i can never shut up about how impressive this song is. the rent was DUE. they straight up graduated from university of servington with a degree of cuntology and this was their first day of their job. the harmonizations here... holyyyyy it's giving rise of a dark femme goddess level idk wth am i saying but i hope you get me
Sometimes, the hidden vocals need to shine more in the song! I’ve ascended listening to this. Made the song even better than it already is. They’re truly vocalists through and through! My fav song just got even better! 💖✨🫶🏽
here u can hear all the hidden vocal layers perfectly- i also hear an r&b voice, is it EJAE's? th-cam.com/video/nusY4gld3aw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=xNvkbWDsRW2Q8_Ci
I don't really know how people only hear nigning in the chores 😂 shes the supported vocal for the first part while winter is in the second part and actualy its as shown in there stages all of them sang the chours actually and that's something you can't hear here which is wired
80% of the the background vocals and harmonies are done by the producers in this case EJAE. It happened with Black mamba the chorus during the high note people always thought it was Giselle but it was actually the producers.
i alwaus wait for their hidden vocals..literally the best..top..i can never get bored...10000/10 its so addictive no wonder its so easy to fall for them
This song is so well produced its crazy. The amount of detail they put into this song is impressive
aespa’s production never disappoints.
It's crazy to me the demo version was for planting trees 💀
@@thats_not_breezyshes_soo_windy oh wait I didn't know that was THIS song. I'm glad they didn't go that route lol
@@nothingbutmadnessFRR AHA
@@zxcvbnm04fr
3:17 I love this part because the voices harmonizing in the back singing "dramaaaa" "traumaaa" are amazing omggg
YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH 😭😭
ikr! It sounds so good
If I’m not mistaken, based off of the recording bts I think those harmonies are Giselle
My fav part
@@leahpeachieyess
Ningning's voice is so prominent in the choruses. It's almost like she's singing the entire song.
It isn’t only Ningning tho. You literally hear Winter in the chorus harmonizing with her.
@@superbluerock8327they didn’t say that .. reread the comment
@@superbluerock8327LOL, read again!
NingNing debut solo when
@@Iavcxoxo No, baby doll, I read the comment correctly. Winter’s voice is ALSO prominent in the chorus. You can CLEARLY hear her and Ningning harmonizing together. They saying Ningning’s voice is so “prominent in the chorus” is a discredit to other members. In this case Winter.
i wanna hear studio recording session for all these hidden vocals ahhhh
Some are from the demo singer
@@gbxt2249idk why that was even kept if theirs 4 different girls in this group
@@gbxt2249actually most/ a lot are from the demo singer
@@gbxt2249yess
they should release the recording bts soon so you’ll be able to see
I feel like no matter what giselle is such an integral pillar in their vocal stacking, like in any song her vocals are so malleable
True
just like with chaeyoung of twice
Reminds me of Bae from NMIXX. Both are not the strongest vocalists of their groups, but their voices play an important roll during the whole song, in my opinion.
role*
true but i hope she will get more rap lines just like kwangya era
1:16 - 1:22 THE LAYERING!!!! SM Ent. groups are still unrivalled when it comes to vocals and vocal production, and no one will convince me otherwise.
also when it comes to experimental songs.
The thing that I kinda dont like with SM is that their harmonies and even iconic adlibs at hidden vocals are produced to sound very quiet. While there are times that you can hear them but most of the time they can sound less noticeable. Sometimes you need a very good pair of earphones to hear it while other groups have a very noticeable harmonies. I hope they flaunt it next time because they kill on harmonies and vocals.
Fr! And the harmonies/Backing vocals are soooo amazing and heavenly. I don‘t get SME.
I think this might be the case with aespa but clearly not with Rv, their harmonization is usually at a forefront
One time i saw a comment about that some radios and some earphones just cannot handle that much so they had to lower it so you can actually listen to it
Omg I also don't like SM with their harmonies.
Especially in RV
@@Seeityoonwas just gonna comment about this! if there’s one thing about rv is they’re gonna HARMONIZE. and it never fails either.
Ningning reminds me of Wendy so much in terms of octaves, diversity, being able to harmonize with each member. She is truly a gem. I cannot wait to see how she grows and dominated in the industry.
ur so incredibly real for this
except shes been singing in her headvoice for the past year
@@poopers197except her technique anywhere else is amazing, gtfo here
Agree
@@poopers197 cause that’s how their songs go?
Ningning was MAD in the recording studio
2:56 This harmony is simply divine 🛐🛐
Giselle is a hidden gem
FOR REALLLLL
kak gem
Hahaha kak 😭@@alinajaevm
Yet sm still hides her
1:40 snatched my wig so FAST
HELP
BRO DKABSKAJXKAJSKAJS
LMAO
😭
😭😭
Damn I love the “It’s coming” part. It gave me goosebumps even more than the original one did. Good works 👍
What ????? Where is it
@@blinkyyLDsri2 i think that's the "i'm coming" line before the chorus hits
@@blinkyyLDsri2 0:49
@@BaoTinTranuc oooo ❤ thanks for correction
frrr
Forget "slow reverb" or "sped up" versions of songs... I need SM to start dropping a "Cranked up backing vocals" version of songs!!
fr
this song is so cinematic in itself, and hearing the background vocals with the main vocals make it so much more DRAMAtic. it's so crazy.
Winter had me crushing over her so hard this comeback like damn girlie has THE THING that keeps obssessing over her .
the fits, her hair/look, her talent, her vocals, her lines 😩
1:52 NO ONE’S TALKING ABOUT THIS??!
IKR it's so heavenly
🤩
FR THAT MADE MY TEAR UP
2:40 karina's adlib sounds so good but sadly it can go unnoticed
Fr
I can hear it in the original audio I can even hear giselles "story yeah"
THE VOICES FROM INSIDE ARE FUCKING DEEP, FUCKING REALLY GOOD
Winter’s “yeah im coming” part is absolutely mind blowing. The way she sings is so powerful, and she adds such a special quality to all of aespa’s music. she truly is gifted 🩷
3:11 this part is so good.
0:23 DAMN THE HARMONIES HIT ME HARD AF
3:11 Gigi working behind the screens aespa's backbone indeed 🔥🔥
That’s not Giselle
@@blueorangeade712it’s her, watch the video on their channel how they recorded it
@@marylevy7659its the main producer/composer, EJAE afaik
@@vousmevyzNah they stated Giselle did most of the adlibs the producer was just prominent in the chorus
2:39 i came to hear karina high note clearer tbh she slays wish they made it more prominent in the song her tone is the best rlly pleasant to the ears😭
its winter and ningning high note
Huh? Karina did a high note? I think you might have confused karina with winter
@@thenorthremembers5978she did
@@winwinter_she does have a high note you just have to have good headphones
@@thenorthremembers5978 she does have a high note you just have to have good headphones
YOU MADE THIS SONG EVEN MORE PERFECT THAT IT ALREADY WAS 😭
the production behind every aespa title track is in another level.
who took the lower notes during winter’s outro “u know i’m savage” because it just added to the spice
Maybe the producer.
It doesn’t sound like any of them it’s probably another back vocal or many even the vocals from the original demo. Cuz it kinda sounds like voice from the original demo
it's winter harmonizing herself
it's giselle
2:24 the bridge OMGGGG
Ningning vocal is so powerful yet so subtle. She knows where to be stronger and where to be softer. Best vocalist for a reason
2Ning and Giselle vocals combination at the chorus is impressive 💪💖
2Ning? 💀
@@urfavchicken_chicken2ning = ningning
@@trutrusrnTuning?
Wow I thought for every chorus each of them were in the lead, like for each chorus I could hear each member, but it's mostly n2 in the back too!
It will be all of them and then ning2 layered over top or in the backround. Like spicy post chorus and then she would've been singing underneath that for example
It is isn’t it? Like they lead the parts in the chorus where they are centre. So the first chorus goes:
Karina
NingNing
Winter
Giselle
Second Chorus:
Winter
Giselle
Third Chorus:
Karina
NingNing
@@WAFFLE747 I feel like the producers meant to put Karina + Giselle as leads in the choruses but it definitely sounds like Ning2 is overpowering them in the back
Ningning is literally that “girl in the back”!😮
1:51 I love this part in the video but damn you can barely hear Karina cause everyone else is belting in the hidden vocals lmao
Well that’s why it’s HIDDEN vocals. In the actual song, Karina’s voice is the prominent one.
@@gustereewow, REALLY????? thats so crazy
the “yeah” part at the end of the chorus omg it’s amazing
3:05 "DRAMA-MA-MA" 👹👹👹
It sounds even more epic
3:22 this part is soooo good I repeat it every time I hear drama
same
either main vocal get the most or least line, SM main vocalist usually have many hidden vocal and adlib. can't wait to hear ningning's vocal in the recording session. the vocal in this song is craxy
Now i understand why Giselle has the least line. She's leading the whole chorus similar to Black Mamba.
Edit: I apologize, It was not giselle. The producer needs to acknowledge her talents and give my girl a solo rap part. We know how powerful she is.
Giselle is not last in this song
@@koizoraraira5847yes she is actually
@@Nayeon_stan385karina is
@@Nayeon_stan385she isn’t Karina is
@@haerin_ziif you remove sublines it's Giselle she just says random lines in between
for anyone wanting to hear the backing vocals only, just look up : aespa drama dolby atmos stems, and go to the top rear overhead chapter :)
they are heavenly, and most of them are done by the demo singer (with some hidden adlibs from our girls)
all my favorite parts
0:21 to 0:29 "I li-li-like" OMGG SO HARMONIZING
0:49 "I'm coming" A different voice (isn't aespa) literally scream IM COMING SO GOOOOOOD
1:08 "Drama-ma-ma-ma-ma" Ningning singing in a different tone and there's another voice singing in an octave lower hits me harder
1:14 to 1:22 someone is slaying here singing in an octave HIGHER
1:37 to 1:44 HEAVEN
1:51 HEAVEN AGAIN
2:05 "I'm coming (one more time)" THIS IS SO GOOD I CANT
2:28 "durio o, hajima, you and I, this is the most beautiful melisma I ever heard
2:56 "oooh, oooh"
3:11 my favorite favorite part, "you know I'm savage, 거침없는 baddest" there's no aespa, again it's another girl, maybe a SM trainee? I don't know, I just know that I LOVE THIS PART, I KEEP REPLAYING AND REPLAYING NONSTOP
3:18 this is DRAMAAAAA DRAMA MA MA DRAMAAAAAAAAA DRAMA MA MA
The octave higher and lower is both giselle
pls that mystery voice at 3:11 IS SOO GOODDDDD like the growl is GIVING
the mystery voice is most likely from the demo they kept the vocals maybe
The mistery voice is the songwriter! I think she's called EJAE or something like that
@@goodbyewithkarleyoutnowbestiesis ningning too
I love how chorus sounds ok this version. It sounds more human like, you hear the actual voice of the girls, not the combination that sounds kinda different. The same in spicy pre-chorus
1:37, 1:41 and 2:05 are so good the harmonies should be louder in the finished product because they sound so good....
i want to listen to all songs this way from now on... the harmonies and layering sound so angelic
ningning backbone of the bg vocals
Her voice is only prominent in the chorus, the rest of the background vocals are an unknown vocalist/ the singer of the demo… so not really
yap@@Aezpa
Well actually, it's giselle, go listen to savage and literally all their other songs.
No. Its the songwriter singing 90 % of it.
Ningning's role reminds me of yeri's in red velvet
these things are what set sm apart from everyone else. they never miss any details, perfect production since the 90s and still hold themselves to the standards that they set
The prechorus is such a slay ngl
i love how big and sweeping the pre-choruses and outro sound with the hidden vocals turned up. it makes the song sound even more like a powerful action movie
Idk why there are so many people hating ningning😢 as the main vocalist, she does serve a lot for background music. She’s literally the girl in the back. Honestly, ningning has so many haters just cuz she’s a foreigner, especially she’s Chinese😅
Wtf is wrong with being Chinese lmao, ppl are RACIST
I don't know why but I'm obsessed with singing like the hidden vocals range.
I never noticed the voices in Gigi's part in the second verse, it's beautiful
the bridge sounds SOO GOOD OMG 😭
this song is like actually a masterpiece i might consider it the best song ever created dude
this version sounds so much more powerful and dynamic than the original and i absolutely love it.
and i thought this song couldnt get any better
Ningning is doing the harmony part in the chorus. the other members are doubling the main melody line too.
0:54 you can also hear karina doubling the main melody line in another version that removes all the instrumentals.
1:01 winter also is the chorus harmonizing. you can hear at least three members' voices.
It sounds even more powerful than before!! I love this so much!! Thank you to aespa for this masterpiece 🫶🏻✨!!
Ningning is so loud in the chorus! That’s our main vocalist!
i keep falling in love with ningning in a artistically way, i can't even explain
my goshh their vocals are just everything
ningning mad as hell
This comeback literally everything, Drama carried too much❤
The producers were having fun
Guys ik that the rest of the members like gigi, ningning, and winter are amazing..but can we appreciate Karina for a minute? I’ve only seen 2 comments (so far) talking about Karina’s little highnote at the 2:41. She only ever gets talked about for her visuals but never her singing. Like, it’s almost like ppl are saying she has no talent in this song without saying she has no talent in this song. So like, can we appreciate her just for a little bit? She deserves more.
Wow this version sounds more... dramatic 😅 Kinda opera-like/church chorus
2:40 THE ADLIBS OMG
I want to hear everyone involved in this perform an acapella chorus version of this.
Giselles vocals are hidden… throwback to black mamba
Thank you so much ❤I can keep hearing ningning’s voice 😂
3:11 THIS PART IS INCREDIBLE IM ASCENDING, GRIPPING THE SHEETS, ROLLING ON THE FLOOR AND KICKING MY FEET
I think it fits even better than the original. The hidden vocals sound AI and robotic yet harmonizing, which really fits the songs aura and the groups concept. I wished hidden vocals could be heard louder by any group, because some groups layering is very impressive but it’s sad you can’t really hear them
noobs read this =
Most of the backing vocals is just an unknown vocalist, probably the singer of the demo, a bit weird for aespa but it sounds great regardless
ningning dominates
i can never shut up about how impressive this song is. the rent was DUE. they straight up graduated from university of servington with a degree of cuntology and this was their first day of their job. the harmonizations here... holyyyyy it's giving rise of a dark femme goddess level idk wth am i saying but i hope you get me
This music is just...epic.
I have nothing but the biggest admiration and gratitude for the producer(s) outstanding work on this song.
the "la-la-LIKE me when im savage" at 0:25 already let me know this was gonna be fire
Wow realizing the dance break part after the bridge on their performance at MBC Gayo 2023 come from 02:56 😮😮😮
2:32 transcended
Ahh Karina’s part pre chorus the 1 2 it’s time to goooo and the rest 😭😍
Sometimes, the hidden vocals need to shine more in the song! I’ve ascended listening to this. Made the song even better than it already is. They’re truly vocalists through and through! My fav song just got even better! 💖✨🫶🏽
OMG ningning does serve a lot ❤❤❤
ningning and giselle, both are the key here
2:39 that Karina high note should have been louder 🛐
Its winter part
@@ginahvargas4441 it's karina, after winter did the run, karina sang a high note right after but it echoed a bit so it can really go unnoticed.
The background vocals made the song more powerful. Just loved it right after it had released💜💜
Ningningggg vocals🔥😭
✨Dramaaa✨Traumaaa✨With the hidden vocals louder,
It makes it more dramatic! I luv it❤🖤
Most of the hidden vocals are EJAE btw
Who is EJAE?
@@Trebinhas composer for Drama
@@atne3484EJAE's voice not like that.. LOL😅 EJAE just composed this song, but Ningning and Winter lead chorus and etc
@@snsdgivemetwice I said most not all
here u can hear all the hidden vocal layers perfectly- i also hear an r&b voice, is it EJAE's? th-cam.com/video/nusY4gld3aw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=xNvkbWDsRW2Q8_Ci
idk who is doing the backvocals but they are so goooood
It’s a mix of the group. Mostly Ningning is in the chorus!
3:11 IS BREATHTAKINGLY BEAUTIFUL I LITERALLY CANNOT STOP REPEATING IT 😍
Drama’s bridge gotta be one of the best bridges to exist
I don't really know how people only hear nigning in the chores 😂 shes the supported vocal for the first part while winter is in the second part and actualy its as shown in there stages all of them sang the chours actually and that's something you can't hear here which is wired
I thin its both of them in all choruses but ning’s vocal is louder. You can here both but ning sounds louder
WIN-NING FOREVER MY FAVE MONSTER VOCAL, THE HARMONY?! Immaculate.
80% of the the background vocals and harmonies are done by the producers in this case EJAE.
It happened with Black mamba the chorus during the high note people always thought it was Giselle but it was actually the producers.
Watch the recording video its mostly aespa
@@aedoaa902and ejae, it’s both aespa and ejae you can hear her voice
you can hear her as clear as day all throughout the song too lol. a lot of people in these comments are confusing her for the members
3:10 my favorite part became even more of my favorite
3:11 to 3:23 sounds so good woah
Karina "Drama" is always slayed
The hidden vocals are AMAZING 😭😭😭🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩😜😜😜😜💗💗💗😼😼✌🏻😼💅💅🔛🔝🔛🔝🔛🔝🔛🔝
the squad being obedient with this 🤧
i alwaus wait for their hidden vocals..literally the best..top..i can never get bored...10000/10 its so addictive no wonder its so easy to fall for them