Considering the sh*t he went through... I''m almost glad he passed. Arthur had a tremendous amount of pain bellowing inside of him. Seeing him pass on that rocky mountain was devastating yet a relief. To finally have him rest permanently and be done will it all is was probably the best option he could have taken.
My dear Arthur, You never showed up, and now, after looking at the newspapers I understand why. I don't imagine you will receive this letter but I nonetheless must send it. Arthur, oh, Arthur. I was just starting to dream the silliest and softest of dreams. I miss you, and I will always miss you but I cannot live like that, and it seems you cannot live any other way. When I'm with you, the world makes sense; but when we are apart, I see clearly that your world is not a world from which one can escape. I'm so sorry, for everything, for everything long ago and for starting up that business again. There's a good man within you, Arthur, but he is wrestling with a giant. And the giant... wins, time and again. You've broken my heart, again, and I fear I have broken yours. For that, I will never forgive myself but you must let me go now. I enclose a ring you gave me many years ago, when we were both young, not because I don't like it, but because I care for it far too much and it reminds me too much of you. I hope, one day... you will find some people in love who can use this, for it kept me thinking of you all these years, and I hope by returning it to you I can finally be free. Goodbye Mary
"Got a letter from Mary. What did I expect? What did I want? Weren't never meant to be and never really was, and yet somehow, in the end, I discovered I had a heart because it was broken. Oh, you fool. You sad, deluded fool. Torn in two by different ideas of who you were, and it turns out you weren't neither of them."
Mary was right. She said “use this for people who are in love” and that ring was given to John Marston. And then John married Abigail with that ring. This game really is the best game ever.
I’m still a man, but I’ll be honest when Arthur died I cried, this is the first and last game that gave me exciting emotions. After Arthur's death I feel empty.
THIS CONVERSATION COMES TO MY MIND EVERY TIME I SEE HIM. We talked to him once and then we stopped talking but I think we both still want to talk but neither of us dare. And every time I see him, I stop what I'm doing and look at him. And I silently say, Ebrar, you never came, I missed you and I always missed you. His name was Ebrar and he had red hair, I think I will never forget him.
Some people don't understand is that, Arthur's death wasn't peaceful. In Arthur's last moment he couldn't breath and he was in pain from being beat half to death.
This game is my favorite and it’s so good, but kind of depressing and relatable. If you haven’t played this game I highly recommend it. It will change the way u think of video games and the way you think of life.
i might felt broken when dutch was becoming crazy i might felt a strong depression watching arthur dying but reading that letter from mary is just heartbreaking :/.
Met a gal like Mary once sweet, sharp, had a way about her. Chased after her so hard back in school, but I wasn't what she was looking for. Tried to keep in touch, but guess I came on too strong, always sending messages and whatnot. She's got herself a fella now, or so she said i was devastated and i still am. Just hope she's out there doing alright.
my friend, you will be a happy man. If this happened, then your destiny, which will welcome you in the future, will be much better than this. you should not give up dude, i believe in you
I got the low honor ending, it felt as if it were more fitting for him, in the ending he reached for the gun as he crawled and when he saw Dutch he gave up, I think it really showed how much pain Arthur is in, it was much more fitting in my opinion for Arthur to be a man wrestling with his morals and his lawless nature.
Cope. High honour is so much better. A true redemption. It is literally in the name of the game. One of the most gorgeous, jaw dropping, stunning endings I’ve ever seen.
@@hamza_clipz_699 Respectfully you're honestly just generic, you prefer the boring bad guy becomes the good guy story. You follow the game cover. Low honor expresses a better sense of reality, showing how Arthur struggles with his pain, showing how human he is and no matter how strong or skilled you are, you can never escape the reality of your actions. It is much more relatable in terms of the real life of an outlaw. Literally if you look it up. Low Honor gameplay gives you more of the outlaw experience. And I believe at heart Arthur Morgan is an outlaw.
@@mr.batmancalzony7941 It is a lot more accurate to redeem Arthur after he gets diagnosed with tuberculosis. Also its not what i like or not, but objectively speaking side quests of high honor are just so fucking beautiful. Plus, the end scene is just absolutely gorgeous. This is my personal opinion, you can have yours. The "I am afraid line" alone is much better than the entire low honor ending ngl. That scene deserved Oscar. Maybe low honor ending is suits Arthur better (I personally don't think so because I see good in him as Mary said in her letter) but high honor ending especially getting it for the first playthrough just causes more emotions in people. I personally cried after getting the ending, but i cant find anyone who did after getting the low honor one. I think redemption and kindness are more beautiful in any situation than vengeance and anger. Maybe second option is more suited but first one is more beautiful and emotional. And that's why we play games / read books / watch movies, right? Anything that causes emotion is well written ( didn't word this well but hopefully you get my point) Therefore getting high honor is just a better option/ending for most people. Maybe not for you and that's okay, because we have different tastes, but generally speaking, getting high honor ending is more touching and meaningful for most people. When Arthur climbs the mountain and takes his last breath, watching the sunset, I don't understand how you choose low honor one over that. It's also said that while making that ending Dutch's voice actor broke down crying so much so to the point were he couldn't continue voice acting hence why Dutch doesn't say anything in the end. Also, I am not generic. in fact, i am not a huge fan of "happy ends" I do in fact find them very boring and generic. So there's that.
@@hamza_clipz_699 This is all in respect so do not take it as a hostile reply. First of all you claim ''its not what i like or not'' when the entirety of your argument is based on your opinion about why you like the high honor ending, your just talking about how beautiful the ending is. Instead of acknowledging the real meaning of the character and as to why the low honor ending fit him more. The whole reason Mary's letter existed was because he couldn't change. Her letter is the definition of Actions do not give rewards. I made my argument based upon the realism of the low honor ending, comparing it to real life circumstances of living the life of an outlaw. You're just using words to describe what you like about the High honor ending. I understand the objective beauty of the High Honor ending. But it just doesn't define the character enough. It's almost like, Low Honor is reality, and High Honor is what we would've wanted to happen. I believe Low Honor is better. because it's better to live in the reality of the pain and appreciate it, than live in a dream. Arthur Morgan was a good man but he had flaws. You don't spend most of your life as an outlaw and have a happy ending.
@@mr.batmancalzony7941 I understand what you are saying and I value objective value of the low honor ending. But the whole point of the video game is to get joy out if it. In case of rdr2, most value can be taken if you develop emotional connections with a lot of the characters and that includes Arthur himself. My point is that the game can be enjoyed for most people when they get the high honor ending. It really does not matter objectively what fits the character and what does not. High honor is just superior ending because it truly causes emotion in most of the people therefore getting the most joy out of it. You can physically not argue with this argument. Just google "reacting to arthurs death". Most people who show any sort of emotion are the ones who got the high honor ending. Not to mention the fact it is just the most satisfying ending. You really have no argument in your reply. What you already said i clarified. Even in high honor ending, Arthur is still not a good man. He really isn't. Satisfying part about high honor is how he is trying to do everything that he can so his sins are not as big of a burden anymore. High honor ending is not a dream lmao. You can clearly choose it and live with it and it is just as realistic as high honor one since it is mentioned that game does not have a cannon ending. You say Arthur was a good man but he had flaws. (This actually just makes what I said true but I do not think this is true) I say Arthur was a BAD MAN who had good within him. That is what makes high honor ending so good. If you understand objective beauty of high honor, really you have no reason to argue that low honor one is better since game has no cannon ending hence you argument that it is just a dream is not true. Low honor ending is just as real as the high one, high one is just more beautiful therefore better. What you said in the last sentence just shows that your mindset of life is quite pessimistic and sad. It is better to have beliefs that make you feel better than beliefs that make you more depressed. The fact that high honor ending even exists (and is realistic as I said) shows you can get a happy ending. LITERALLY THE ENTIRE POINT OF THIS ENDING IS TO SHOW that redeeming is possible. Please, if you haven't listen to what sister told Arthur
Even if i am sad about arthur's end it makes me realise that even if he escaped with john to new austin his tuberculosis would still catch up to him, at least he had his redemption, in the end
@@Mrhazzx No buddy, that's at the end of the epilogue. John mentioned to Sadie that him and his family moved up to the Yukon after Arthur's death to try to strike it rich in gold, but got no luck and came back to the US at the start of the epilogue
i might felt broken when dutch was becoming crazy i might felt a strong depression watching arthur dying but reading that letter from mary is just heartbreaking :/.
This game has such a special place in my heart. It was the first and last game that made me cry
Considering the sh*t he went through... I''m almost glad he passed. Arthur had a tremendous amount of pain bellowing inside of him. Seeing him pass on that rocky mountain was devastating yet a relief. To finally have him rest permanently and be done will it all is was probably the best option he could have taken.
Real
@manofthesky514 you are not him 💀
@@KiLLeRb2o106-Mrm How do you know what he's been through?
@SpeaksYourWord what are you saying no one can be like arthur he literally killed folk and died
@@KiLLeRb2o106-Mrm Anyone can be like Arthur, but they will not be able to write in this comment section.
the best game character
My dear Arthur,
You never showed up, and now, after looking at the newspapers I understand why. I don't imagine you will receive this letter but I nonetheless must send it. Arthur, oh, Arthur. I was just starting to dream the silliest and softest of dreams. I miss you, and I will always miss you but I cannot live like that, and it seems you cannot live any other way.
When I'm with you, the world makes sense; but when we are apart, I see clearly that your world is not a world from which one can escape. I'm so sorry, for everything, for everything long ago and for starting up that business again. There's a good man within you, Arthur, but he is wrestling with a giant. And the giant... wins, time and again. You've broken my heart, again, and I fear I have broken yours.
For that, I will never forgive myself but you must let me go now. I enclose a ring you gave me many years ago, when we were both young, not because I don't like it, but because I care for it far too much and it reminds me too much of you. I hope, one day... you will find some people in love who can use this, for it kept me thinking of you all these years, and I hope by returning it to you I can finally be free.
Goodbye
Mary
Saddest message ever, poor Arthur😞
"Got a letter from Mary. What did I expect? What did I want? Weren't never meant to be and never really was, and yet somehow, in the end, I discovered I had a heart because it was broken.
Oh, you fool. You sad, deluded fool. Torn in two by different ideas of who you were, and it turns out you weren't neither of them."
3 Years Ago. i finished Red Dead 2 crying and going to sleep crying.
Mary was right. She said “use this for people who are in love” and that ring was given to John Marston. And then John married Abigail with that ring. This game really is the best game ever.
I’m still a man, but I’ll be honest when Arthur died I cried, this is the first and last game that gave me exciting emotions. After Arthur's death I feel empty.
Don’t ever delete this no matter what
Stuff like this… really make me appreciate old couple’s😴
THIS CONVERSATION COMES TO MY MIND EVERY TIME I SEE HIM. We talked to him once and then we stopped talking but I think we both still want to talk but neither of us dare. And every time I see him, I stop what I'm doing and look at him. And I silently say, Ebrar, you never came, I missed you and I always missed you. His name was Ebrar and he had red hair, I think I will never forget him.
A lot of us can remotely relate to Arthur, losing the people we love is unfortunately, a vital part of life.
Literally just finished the game. What. A. Fucking. Game. Never thought a video game could make me so... emotional.
Getting this letter on my first run killed me man
real
Can't stop listening to this. Really well made !
You are good man, Arthur Morgan
Some people don't understand is that, Arthur's death wasn't peaceful. In Arthur's last moment he couldn't breath and he was in pain from being beat half to death.
This game is my favorite and it’s so good, but kind of depressing and relatable. If you haven’t played this game I highly recommend it. It will change the way u think of video games and the way you think of life.
If Arthur thought just once for himself and his own benefit would have gone with her.
he only started to think for himself when it was too late
@KeyUploadstoo late as in him showing signs of tuberculosis
@KeyUploadsunless you already knew and your just saying he saved the game
She broke my heart so bad she got me listening to this shi
real
i love this audio so much it’s crazy looll
i might felt broken when dutch was becoming crazy
i might felt a strong depression watching arthur dying
but reading that letter from mary is just heartbreaking :/.
I lost it when Arthur died..
Wait Arthur die?
@@gabo-im4kjnope it’s just a mod
@@gabo-im4kj No, bro it's a joke. Continue playing the game! Great game.
@@gabo-im4kj Nah its a popular cinematic mod
Met a gal like Mary once sweet, sharp, had a way about her. Chased after her so hard back in school, but I wasn't what she was looking for. Tried to keep in touch, but guess I came on too strong, always sending messages and whatnot. She's got herself a fella now, or so she said i was devastated and i still am. Just hope she's out there doing alright.
my friend, you will be a happy man. If this happened, then your destiny, which will welcome you in the future, will be much better than this. you should not give up dude, i believe in you
Bro this is so good Im surprised it only has 103 views but on sum rs keep up the work it’ll all pay off in the end
Ty for the support!
Just pain...
Dont "Oh, Arthur" me like that again😢
best women... best man ... best game...
can't be more cooked
made me fucking cry man
I got the low honor ending, it felt as if it were more fitting for him, in the ending he reached for the gun as he crawled and when he saw Dutch he gave up, I think it really showed how much pain Arthur is in, it was much more fitting in my opinion for Arthur to be a man wrestling with his morals and his lawless nature.
Cope. High honour is so much better. A true redemption. It is literally in the name of the game. One of the most gorgeous, jaw dropping, stunning endings I’ve ever seen.
@@hamza_clipz_699 Respectfully you're honestly just generic, you prefer the boring bad guy becomes the good guy story. You follow the game cover. Low honor expresses a better sense of reality, showing how Arthur struggles with his pain, showing how human he is and no matter how strong or skilled you are, you can never escape the reality of your actions. It is much more relatable in terms of the real life of an outlaw. Literally if you look it up. Low Honor gameplay gives you more of the outlaw experience. And I believe at heart Arthur Morgan is an outlaw.
@@mr.batmancalzony7941 It is a lot more accurate to redeem Arthur after he gets diagnosed with tuberculosis. Also its not what i like or not, but objectively speaking side quests of high honor are just so fucking beautiful. Plus, the end scene is just absolutely gorgeous. This is my personal opinion, you can have yours.
The "I am afraid line" alone is much better than the entire low honor ending ngl. That scene deserved Oscar.
Maybe low honor ending is suits Arthur better (I personally don't think so because I see good in him as Mary said in her letter) but high honor ending especially getting it for the first playthrough just causes more emotions in people. I personally cried after getting the ending, but i cant find anyone who did after getting the low honor one.
I think redemption and kindness are more beautiful in any situation than vengeance and anger. Maybe second option is more suited but first one is more beautiful and emotional.
And that's why we play games / read books / watch movies, right? Anything that causes emotion is well written ( didn't word this well but hopefully you get my point)
Therefore getting high honor is just a better option/ending for most people. Maybe not for you and that's okay, because we have different tastes, but generally speaking, getting high honor ending is more touching and meaningful for most people.
When Arthur climbs the mountain and takes his last breath, watching the sunset, I don't understand how you choose low honor one over that. It's also said that while making that ending Dutch's voice actor broke down crying so much so to the point were he couldn't continue voice acting hence why Dutch doesn't say anything in the end.
Also, I am not generic. in fact, i am not a huge fan of "happy ends" I do in fact find them very boring and generic. So there's that.
@@hamza_clipz_699 This is all in respect so do not take it as a hostile reply. First of all you claim ''its not what i like or not'' when the entirety of your argument is based on your opinion about why you like the high honor ending, your just talking about how beautiful the ending is. Instead of acknowledging the real meaning of the character and as to why the low honor ending fit him more. The whole reason Mary's letter existed was because he couldn't change. Her letter is the definition of Actions do not give rewards. I made my argument based upon the realism of the low honor ending, comparing it to real life circumstances of living the life of an outlaw. You're just using words to describe what you like about the High honor ending. I understand the objective beauty of the High Honor ending. But it just doesn't define the character enough. It's almost like, Low Honor is reality, and High Honor is what we would've wanted to happen. I believe Low Honor is better. because it's better to live in the reality of the pain and appreciate it, than live in a dream. Arthur Morgan was a good man but he had flaws. You don't spend most of your life as an outlaw and have a happy ending.
@@mr.batmancalzony7941 I understand what you are saying and I value objective value of the low honor ending.
But the whole point of the video game is to get joy out if it. In case of rdr2, most value can be taken if you develop emotional connections with a lot of the characters and that includes Arthur himself. My point is that the game can be enjoyed for most people when they get the high honor ending.
It really does not matter objectively what fits the character and what does not. High honor is just superior ending because it truly causes emotion in most of the people therefore getting the most joy out of it. You can physically not argue with this argument.
Just google "reacting to arthurs death". Most people who show any sort of emotion are the ones who got the high honor ending. Not to mention the fact it is just the most satisfying ending.
You really have no argument in your reply. What you already said i clarified.
Even in high honor ending, Arthur is still not a good man. He really isn't. Satisfying part about high honor is how he is trying to do everything that he can so his sins are not as big of a burden anymore.
High honor ending is not a dream lmao. You can clearly choose it and live with it and it is just as realistic as high honor one since it is mentioned that game does not have a cannon ending.
You say Arthur was a good man but he had flaws. (This actually just makes what I said true but I do not think this is true) I say Arthur was a BAD MAN who had good within him. That is what makes high honor ending so good.
If you understand objective beauty of high honor, really you have no reason to argue that low honor one is better since game has no cannon ending hence you argument that it is just a dream is not true. Low honor ending is just as real as the high one, high one is just more beautiful therefore better.
What you said in the last sentence just shows that your mindset of life is quite pessimistic and sad. It is better to have beliefs that make you feel better than beliefs that make you more depressed. The fact that high honor ending even exists (and is realistic as I said) shows you can get a happy ending. LITERALLY THE ENTIRE POINT OF THIS ENDING IS TO SHOW that redeeming is possible. Please, if you haven't listen to what sister told Arthur
I miss you...
hearing this letter on my first playthrough: “womp womp womp go away lady let me rob sum shit bang bang”
hearing it after : 🗿
Real
@@outlawvibesreal is crazy
Chest day(my heart is broken like arthur morgan)
Real
Real(mine is legs day)
Arthur, oh, Arthur
I was just starting to dream the silliest and softest of dreams
perdi ela ontem a noite, mas tudo vai correr bem
i love it
I wish my mother would just tell me that I'm a good man...
The endless spiral downward ends in Hell. If we don’t find change soon, it would be better had we never been born. This endless cycle has me frozen.
I’m about to cry 😞
I'm Afraid.
Arthur didn’t deserve this.
Nadie te preparo para lo que tuviste que pasar...
real
Real
Is it too late for us, Arthur?
the best game I've ever played in my
Fcking life😪
W
Rdr Games 🔛🔝
So true
it makes it sadder if you have low honor
How
@@ratty786 kinda fucking question was that
@@guy-mp50 I was just asking I haven’t gotten that far into the game :(
@@ratty786 then get into the game instead of me spoiling it
@@guy-mp50 I have I’m just asking how, does it change the dialogue
galaxy
Arthur❤
Por que me pesa tanto decir un simple "te quiero mama" por que...
It’s not a game i can tell
😅😅
Even if i am sad about arthur's end it makes me realise that even if he escaped with john to new austin his tuberculosis would still catch up to him, at least he had his redemption, in the end
Fr, you get sad but at the same time you feel happy for his redemption
John escaped up to Canada in 1899, not New Austin
@@MrJangofett66 oh you're right, he only came back in 1907, but Arthur would still go kaput because the climate wouldn't help his TB
@@MrJangofett66 that’s Charles John lived in new Austin
@@Mrhazzx No buddy, that's at the end of the epilogue. John mentioned to Sadie that him and his family moved up to the Yukon after Arthur's death to try to strike it rich in gold, but got no luck and came back to the US at the start of the epilogue
i might felt broken when dutch was becoming crazy
i might felt a strong depression watching arthur dying
but reading that letter from mary is just heartbreaking :/.
Real