Who Sang it Better: Camila Cabello or Halsey? 🤔💃🏻
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ธ.ค. 2023
- Camila Cabello's demo version of Closer by The Chainsmokers featuring Halsey has surfaced online!
Initially, Camila was meant to sing Closer, but she ended up ghosting The Chainsmokers so the song ended up going to Halsey. Which version do you prefer?
Thank you Earthfueled for the animations and help with the edit! - เพลง
![[ NP ] NGC BATTLE SHOWDOWN S3 | FINAL DAY 5 | FT - @rashmay_casts #drs #horaa #t2k #raw #hkm](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ou0LVc4h_8g/mqdefault.jpg)
Absolutely LOVE Camila 🩵 But I Think It Suited Halseys Voice More.
Yeah, that’s exactly what I said. No disrespect to Cami, but Halsey wins this one
I liked halseys emotion in her voice...idk why Camillas tone reminded me of Carly Rae Jepsen in call me maybe
Couldn't agree more ❤
Sammeeeee
same thing with God Is a Woman going to ari
halsey carried honestly. her vocal tone is so unique its gives the song so much
Exactlyyyy it made it so artsy and unique
thank God camila ghosted them
@@niroopotsav so true
lol unique. She sounds like every girl with a ukulele lmao
@@navinavi1062 can you shut your mouth, as a singer she has a really unique vocal tone and singing style. u can cry all u want it wont change that fact
Closer is one of those songs you listen to on repeat for a month, forget about it for a year and listen to it on repeat again
So true
2016 was 8 years ago 😢
Fr
Nope
So damn True.! I'm still Listening to it through
the song actually fits halsey's raspy voice more, it added dyanmics and i think its one of the reasons why it's not easily forgotten and is really a Hit. No tea w camilla, luv her. But her version made it sound more of a typical popsong , so yep
Gyatt
I was in Ohio before I met you
I rizzed too much and that's an issue
But I’m grimace shake
Gyatt
Tell your friends it was nice to rizz them
But I hope I never edge again
I know it breaks your Fanum
Taxing in Ohio and I’m still not sigma
Four years no Livvy
Now you’re looking pretty on Adin Ross’ Twitchy
And I-I-I-I-I can’t rizz
No I-I-I-I-I can’t mew
So Baby Gronk me closer
In the back skibidi toilet
That I know you can’t afford
Kai Cenat tatted on my shoulder
Pull the gyatt right off the corner
From that fanum that you taxed
From your roommate back in ohio
We ain’t ever not the rizzler
@@harmabeimhungryidk wether to be Impressed at the fact u made this or be cringed by the lyrics😭
@@yujiamane I can sing the brainrot version by heart now
@@harmabeimhungry oh! Wow..!😭😭😭 yk what great job great job!
@@harmabeimhungrybro bars actually fire 🔥
They’re so different 🤯 Hasley’s voice is sadder meanwhile Camila’s is full of passion, they both show completely different emotions
I wouldn’t say Halsey’s voice is sadder. I would say it’s deeper
@@Luffy-du7bhtonally halseys voice is more clear, bright and camilas more passionate and stylistic
I didn’t hear the passion 😅😂😂
Yea its amazing how different singers have different styles when they sing.
@@user-ik4zx8cr9f yeah. Talent and skill dont make a pop star, because all of these women are incredible, its the other unique things they bring. No matter if its lady gaga, camila, halsey, ariana or dua lipa, theyre easily regognizable by their signature style in both singing a music
Deffo the song made for Halsey. Halsey always sounds depressed when she sings somehow and it works so well for this song.
It’s a sad song, lyrically at least. The characters have both hurt each other before and are going to keep hurting when they part ways again. They can’t get over each other but can’t or won’t let themselves be together. Camilla’s voice and lyrics are too hopeful
@@amyrodman3752 definitely
It also really harmonizes with the chainsmokers voice because they have the same kind of vibe
Literally its a sad song. Is it suitable for her to use a happy and energetic tone?? 💁🏽♂️
@@andengtui her tone in general is sad. Even if she’s singing happier songs her vocal color and techniques don’t always match the song like it does when she does sad songs
The thing about Halsey is that she doesn't feel like she's singing, it's like she's talking to us. Which I personally really like.
Yeah it works for the song because it’s supposed to be like a nostalgic reunion. Feels more like she’s a normal person telling her side of the story
i actually like both. would love to hear the full version with camilla
Why is no one talking about Camilla ghosting the Chainsmokers 💀
Fr 💀
i would too 😭
@@JDUCSUDMU38948 I’m I missing something? What did the chainsmokers do ? 😭
they were supposed to perform with Camilla at Coachella,but she ghosted them without any prior notice or any specific reason so I guess they didn't do anything, it was her @@Cassie_88
I really don't think this is the full story, don't forget that these collabs are not* made by artists only, two whole ass companies are involved. A big chunk of this story is missing for sure.
Halsey absolutely ate it... No one would have sung it better than her
Nah
@@ShedlerShedlerAgreed
i say thank you as im eating some food
@@emmastoyreviews7400
@@ShedlerShedlerNah
Eating something normally refers to failing at something.
Halsey's voice suits the song's calmness better. Camila's voice adds a bit of chaos.
Not you again!!!
OKAY what !!!!!
Wtf they are both AMAZING
"Closer" and "i hate u, i love u" DEFINED 2016! Literally unforgettable
I remember those two being google's top searches for the longest time in 2016, they'd come up whenever I went to search up something. Man, those days were good.❤
sad Gnash didn't blow up as much tho. I like his other songs too.
i disagree respectfully
Gyatt
I was in Ohio before I met you
I rizzed too much and that's an issue
But I’m grimace shake
Gyatt
Tell your friends it was nice to rizz them
But I hope I never edge again
I know it breaks your Fanum
Taxing in Ohio and I’m still not sigma
Four years no Livvy
Now you’re looking pretty on Adin Ross’ Twitchy
And I-I-I-I-I can’t rizz
No I-I-I-I-I can’t mew
So Baby Gronk me closer
In the back skibidi toilet
That I know you can’t afford
Kai Cenat tatted on my shoulder
Pull the gyatt right off the corner
From that fanum that you taxed
From your roommate back in ohio
We ain’t ever not the rizzler
I'm still trying to process in my head that this song was released in 2016 😅
Their voices would work really good together I feel
Camila killed it
Damn
Halsey was awesome but I think they should do a remix with the both of them on the same track
Camila's version is good but hasley's version is an emotion... Brings back so many memories 😌
Calmness of Halsey's voice suits
Camilla's voice is a bit chaotic compared to Halsey
I love Camilla's singing but for Closer Halsey definitely killed it..
Camila nailed it
Halsey on another level
Camila keeps missing out on hits! god is a woman and closer ☹️
I don't this those would've been such big hits if she performed them. their success is a lot about the artist too
M crying rn but yeah she has many other bops.....so yeah it's ok and her new album is coming.....2024 is our year 🥂💌
Yeah but god is a woman Ariana version is much better and has challenging vocals
she was also supposed to sing The Middle too. she just had a lot of contractual issues and there's a lot of controversy surrounding her getting too much solo projects whilst in the group
It's ok, some of the songs she ended up with by other artists were also hits, like Havana originally by Sia
istg i blasted this song everyday in 2016
I honestly could listen to both ❤
i enjoy camila's lyrics much more, they're definitely more interesting than halsey's. but i do think that halsey's voice suits this song/genre better
Perfectly expressed!
Halsey's lyrics are superior. Four years, no calls, now you looking pretty in a hotel bar is better stringed together than old flame young star, now you're looking pretty in a hotel bar. Not to mention timeless. Anybody can sing four years, no calls relatably and wholeheartedly while feeling it with their whole chest practically forever, no matter what age you are or whether you've been some kind of star or not. How long will you be able to sing "old flame young star" without feeling like the lyric has passed you? If you were 34, 22 during the song's release you're 42, 30 now, definitely not a young star anymore. It's a recipe for a song to age badly. Halsey's lyric completely eliminates that. You look as good as the day I met you, I forget just why I left you is also a far more cohesive and structurally sensible lyric than You remind me of a sunset, color my sky so I forget. On top of that, it complements the Chainsmokers' first verse, "Hey, I was doing just fine before I met you", and the meeting storyline is kept alive. Halsey's lyrics tell a flowing story about longing for a past fling. Camilla's lyrics are attempting to use cliche things that are commonplace in most songs to describe a long-lost romance. "Pull the sheet off the corner of the mattress that you stole from your roommate back in Boulder" seals it all, and is a lot more original than trying to describe sunsets and coloring. If she wanted to the sky to describe the romance, she could've taken a leaf out of Taylor Swift's book. She's sang a lot about painting skies and she actually does it well every single time.
Camilla 🔥🔥🔥
I was about to comment this and you described perfectly what I wanted to say😅
No you did not🌝
i like camila’s version but i prefer halsey’s version more. her voice suited the song the most
Why this is so nice
i will remember this song till i die even tho its not all my fav song because right on the year they became the biggest hits i moved overseas and started to work as a fresh graduated student in overseas for the first time is tough and winter feels so hard for me and my hands and nose bleeding due to coldness
and i heard this song played everywhere
theres one early morning i walk pass an unopened restaurant and they blast out this song like so early in the morning when i was walking to work and makes me hated the song at that time
They both sound good
Camila's label back then was fucked up man...
Camila and Halsey both bring something unique to the song.
This song raised me as a teen☹️ it reminds me of the first international vacation I went to… times were so good back then. Now my dad is broke lol
Omg Camila’s lyrics were so bad 😭
Not even the lyrics. The voice is so bad.
Shut up @@BrianaMon
@@BrianaMonas if you can sing yourself
Yes! I was very thrown off. Especially by her singing, and I like the music by her I’ve heard but that was not it
@@BrianaMon yes! thank you! she sings too up front and her tone is too wide, my vocal coach would actually scream at her for singing like that
I love camila, but I would go with halsey
Its like camilla is expressing how madly in love she is even though its been a few weeks since they have met. Halsey is like saying i love you with all my entirety, always have, and always will...I personally prefer Halsey...Camilla's style takes away from the calmer undertone of the song
Camila Cabello 🔥🔥🔥
It's hard to choose whose voice suits more bc imo they both suit it really well!
Halsey, Yoh!! It suits her
Camila es tan genial ❤
camila for sure
Definitely Halsey
They both sing in cursive haha
True, two cursive singer that are super famous in music industry
Both amazing in their own way ❤️
Camilaaaaaaa
When teachers say you can’t just change every second word to not get copyrighted in an essay, me:
This song brings nostalgia ❤
During pandemic i was so glued to computer all the time , i used to play online games and a friend there. He was literally the bestest online friend I could ever ask for.
One day he was singing (typing lol) the lyrics of these songs and that all wrong 😂
I searched the lyrics and memorised the song. Next time whenever he used to sing it wrong I'd always complete the lyrics with right words 💓💓💓
I hope I'll someday get to face the same situation again
Halsey's voice brings a different vibe to the song. Camila adds a unique energy to it.
you cant beat nostalgia
Halsey for sure my fav musican
Love them both. Different vibes.
Ugh both are great
Closer has a special place in my heart. 2016 was when I got into music, starting with Closer and then went on to other songs and even now, Closer is just. In my heart. Forever.
Camila’s voice sounds more beautiful and romantic
she sounds good but I’m so glad the lyrics changed
The autotune becomes more obvious and annoying sorry to say
Yeah and I feel like that's what makes it so out of place in the song. Closer feels a lot more about reminiscing about the good times you had with someone you've fallen out with and her version just kinda makes it sound like someone in love thinking back on the early days in their current relationship.
Halsey's version wins bc Camila's lyrics were 😬
Super cringe
Right and so many ppl saying it's better. Some of those lyrics sound like random statements put together 😭
The Halsey lyrics are just so good and atmospheric. Like you can seen the scene.
@@RiggClem_14 frfr
Love both camila hlthoguh
If we mixed it together it will be crazy 😮!!
Love both ❤ they give similar vibes but just different which perfect depend on the day we can listen to one of them to fit the mood
I literally used to love this song although i was 3 years old when it was released 😂 it was my best song from 2019 till 2021😂😂
Are you 10 years old?!!??! my god
@@user-vv7hc7kb5o you have a problem
Such a crisp voice
My favourite is Camilla
I love camilas
That was how the song went, I never knew the original.
Camila, her voice sounds perfect with the melody ❤
it sounds good😮
both are good, but halsey's cover fits more and since Camila ghosted them...
Halsey was the best choice her voice suits the song better
this song is so nostalgic
C^2 of course ❤
idk whats better
I perfur Halsey
SOMEBODY MERGE THE TWO OML THEY BOTH SOUND GOOD
Camila ❤❤❤❤
woah
I can’t be the only one who finds camilas voice annoying. So happy Halsey ended up with the song.
Same! It feels like she's overdoing it all the time
I think you and your friend are the only ones who think like that🤨
I honestly like both versions
Halsey. Nostalgia.
HALSEY don’t get me wrong, love Camilla but Halsey just works perfectly with this song
Camila chose to not eat, then the song lasted longer in the top 5 charts than her second chance at a relationship with Shawn mendez.
Summer 2017 was just Closer on repeat 😂.
Oop
Both sound amazing
CAMILA
So glad she didn’t get the song. It is interesting how she was supposed to sing a lot of huge hits but ultimately ended up passing on most of them. 😅
She got a big head thinking she was the best of 5th harmony. Maybe she was but once she went solo she got slapped in the face with reality that she's pretty mid on her own.
I wouldn't have had listened to Camila's version
They both sounded good singing it lowkey
Loved both ❤
Halsey!! Duah
GIRL CAMILLA HAS HER OWN VERSION OF EVERY SONG ON GOD
Camila Cabello version sounds like a high school movie performance 😅
I think Camilla's is my fav❤️💗
When I heard Hasleys voice for the first time I was like her voice rocks and It made me in a better mood but Camila is too perfect
She hits the right note and kills it with that high pitch voice
Halsey duh
I love both. At this moment in time I can relate to Camila though xo
camillaaaa >>>
Halsey deserves that recondition. Camila's version didn't sound that good. Also...why is nobody talking how she ghoted them?
I love camilas version better then the other one
Literally one of the most popular songs of that year, people had been listening to it for almost 8 years now
And he seriously asked 'Which version would you prefer?'😅
Imagine ghosting the chainsmokers, then having to hear the song everywhere you go for the next 5 months.
Camila sounds much better lol she should've been on it
Ok no hate to anyone here but, Halsey's my absolutely favorite but Camila's voice suited the song better as she has a very soft and polite voice.
the babies born after 2016 will never get the nostalgia of this somg
i like camila's version aaaak