@@RichtofensLittleGirl that's because of the curse. No teacher could teach defense against the dark arts more than a year because of Voldemort's magic.
Well this is a curious one tbh because there are references in the first book of quirrel being a multi year teacher, because on holiday from hogwarts is when he met Voldemort. So did he take over from another DADA teacher or did having Voldemort in him reset the curse as he wasn’t technically the same man (edit: ignore this, just read he was muggle studied and took over the job)
*saying as a Slytherin myself* Quirrell was an idiot. plus, he was also the host for Voldemort. iguanas aren't scary, they're cool. i like them, i'd even go as far to say, they're cute :)
Wow, never even thought of THAT. It's so out there that it actually makes it even more intriguing. I can surely imagine the author pouring this little tid bit in with a simple smirk on her face. Just like Delores had to be a writing delight in the same way. 😊😅
( 1) Remus Lupin ( 2) Severus Snape ( 3) Dolerus Umbrige ( 4) Gilderoy Lockhart ( 5) Professor. Quirill ( 6) Mad- eye moody/ Barty Crouch Junior Any ranking different than that is a total misunderstanding of the role of a professor .
“The fact that Lockhart is number 4 on this list says a lot about the teachers” And the fact that Umbridge is the worst says nothing about the other teachers
Lupin is just the greatest most likeble person in the whole world. And i am saying that knowing Carlise Cullen, Gandalf or Captain America. He shall be rememberd forever. Not only as a Teacher, but also as a Person
lupin was not the only teacher seen on the train, slughorn was. most likely there is a teacher's area. lupin probably wanted to sit in his old compartment where he would ride to school with the marauders
that wasnt the original marauders compartment it was the compartment where RON sat at RANDOM basically and harry joined him because he couldnt think of where else to sit.
I always loved how Crouch Jr. was such a mad genius that he had to attempt to play the role of Moody as perfect as he could. When he turns Draco into an animal is a good moment because it’s stated several times earlier that moody has a bad tendency to transfigure people into small animals. Also how much he just plays the role in all the other small details it’s crazy but really neat.
He also, probably, had no qualms about transfiguring Draco as he would've known that Lucius wasn't under the imperius curse in the first Wizarding war. A little revenge with "what are you going to do about it"
And Slughorn had too many collectors items to travel any other way lol would have been a few trunks full that needed the train. Lupin is easier to answer - anywhere near a full moon he is too weak to do magic, (or fly on a broom) ministry doesn't like his kind so he wouldn't be able to be set up to the floo network... So train was the only way to travel.
random girlyness the thing is like we understood why voldemort did what he did. while it was terrible we knew where he was coming from. but with umbridge she was just evil for the sake of being evil. at least voldemort thought he was doing the right thing for the greater good. umbridge just wanted to torture the kids. I hate umbridge
I like that I hate her. For me, she's a more interesting villain than Voldie. Just the fact that her actions give reactions to viewer/readers is what makes a good villain. Belatrix is next in line for clearly enjoying what she does. Voldermort is just... there. He's the type of villain that lets his minions do most of the work. And that makes him less intimidating in my eyes. Umbridge is VERY hands on even when she had Team Draco helping her.
Ben: Goes on a tangent about Professors sleeping at the school Also Ben: What I’m trying to say is WHO IS THE BEST DEFENCE AGAINST THE DARK ARTS TEACHER
Harry had the worst dada teachers possible, so a guy that is actually a good teacher needs to be number one yes. If i had Remus as a teacher id even put him as number 1 and i cant really complain.
“Lupin is the only teacher we see on the train.” Slughorn: “am I a joke to you.” Fred and George were hitting quirrel in the back of the head with enchanted snowballs, sooo..... Fred and George were hitting Voldemort in the face! 😂 Fred and George are legends!!
( 1) Remus Lupin ( 2) Severus Snape ( 3) Dolerus Umbrige ( 4) Gilderoy Lockhart ( 5) Professor. Quirill ( 6) Mad- eye moody/ Barty Crouch Junior Any ranking different than that is a total misunderstanding of the role of a professor .
The first 3 from my list are the only actual professors. The other 3 lack motive or were corrupt/working for voldemort rather than hogwarts somehow @@2p-blog-thing
Best Defense Against the Dark Arts Teacher:Remus Lupin Worst Defense Against The Dark Arts Teacher: Toad-Like Face Umbridge SO NOW THE RANKING 6th=Toad Face 5ty=Lockhart 4th=Alastor Mad Eye Moody (Imposter) Joint 2nd=Quirrell And Snape Honourable Mentions=Harry Potter (that's it) 1st=Remus Lupin!!
Erwin Pasamanero (For notes, I’m talking about the documented classes we know about. Nothing beyond what is shown to us in the books, nor from the other books.) I looked at the title, and immediately crossed off Lockhart and Umbridge. Crossed off Quirrel, although he might’ve shown potential if he wasn’t Voldemort’s puppet. So that leaves Lupin, Mad-Eye, and Snape. For future reference, I am talking about Barty Crouch Jr impersonating Mad-Eye, not the real one, due to the real one not actually being the teacher. I am also leaving him in, partly due to the whole ferret incident, but also due to the fact that he actually did teach things, such as showing them the unforgivable curses, and even teaching the class how to throw off the Imperious Curse. But I’m still placing him at third. Leaving Snape and Lupin. Lupin was a good teacher, and taught them how to combat some of the magical monsters in their world, and literally, *1*, curse, which was only useful against boggarts. He might’ve taught them other curses, but when your enemy tells you that you’re behind on curses with knowledge of what Lupin taught them, well that doesn’t bode well for you. So (I’m gonna start WW3 aren’t I by saying this,) I’m rating Lupin second. Now people are definitely going to hate me for this, but I’m placing Snape first. While he wasn’t a good person in general, he was a good teacher, and taught them somewhat in self defense. Yes, part of what he taught was taught to them by Harry in 5th year, but that doesn’t change the fact that he taught it nonetheless, and even that some of the class didn’t know any of it. Snape also taught them how to distinguish inferi from ghosts or other magical creatures. So yes, I’m rating Snape as the best Hogwarts teacher, not because of character, but because of what he taught
1) Lupin - He was their best DADA teacher, taught them a lot, let them practice and was very helpful 2) Snape - Second only because of his approach. I truly think he taught Harry the most, by far, about defence against dark arts. He kept giving him lesson even during their duel after Dumbledores death. He also is the most knowledgeable about the subject. The thing is, he truly is too socially awkward, demanding and bitter to make a good teacher. 3) Crouch Jr. - too bad Barty didnt chose academic career instead of, well, world dominance. He was a natural. 4) Quirrell - He at least tries to teach, even while willingly possessed by the darkest wizard of all time... I dont want to even imagine his headaches 5) Lockhart - useless self-centered idiot. 6) Umbridge - Useless, doesnt even intend to teach, just there to torture everybody...
Your #1 on my list of the D.A.D.A teachers ranked, Also, Lily was forced to date James, Lily loved you, and she watches over you as a ghost, R.I.P Lily Potter/Evans
@@LOVEMUFFIN_official Well other than using the imperius curse on the students, yeah, I agree. Sure, it helps Harry specifically resist the imperius curse when it's cast on him by Voldemort, but Harry seemed to be a special case. Everybody else was just puppeteered by Barty jr. for the shi*s and giggles.
Before watching the video, I have one thing to say: Clearly it was Harry. He taught the entire fifth year (excluding Slytherins) Defense Against the Dark Arts, and they actually LEARNED from him. And he was FIFTEEN.
I never even thought about Harry, but he might be the best. (As much as I love Remus). He was fair and helped those who needed help, which is what a teacher is suppose to do. But if we're going with the adults then it would be Remus.
Mephostopheles Harry didn't only teach fifth-years!! Luna an Ginny were fourth years for example, and Fred and George seventh, and I believe Cho, Marietta and Katie Bell were even sixth year students!!
She was hired as a teacher, so she was a teacher. She didn't _do_ any teaching, but that's like saying a soldier who hasn't had to fight for a while is no longer a soldier.
I think even though Voldemort committed more atrocities, there are two reasons people hate Umbridge more: 1) She is relatable. Almost everyone has had a bitch of a teacher or boss or neighbor etc. We know how it feels to be on the receiving end of that abuse. She represents every authority figure who was an asshole to us for no apparent reason. In that way you could say she is similar to Severus Snape. However unlike Snape, she had another trait that made her unbearable. 2) She played innocent. She was obviously a sociopathic monster, but she had an act that everything was gumdrops and rainbows and that she was just doing her duty. The most aggravating part was that she knew that everyone knew how much of a bitch she was, but she still pretended. It was condescending and annoying.
chloe white and also crouch junior impersonating madeye he was practical and truthful in defense against the dark arts... In order to defend urself u must face wat threatens u... Same as life
Well, Snape actually bullied nearly all his students for no reason, so even if he teached Harry really usefull stuff - In reality Dumbledore should have fired this guy long before Harry started school :P I think that's why he isn't No 1 or 2 ^^
Nooo, not my toad D': I love it so much, even though it's borring and stupid and dirty and useless and probably toxic and...uhm...why exactly do I own a toad? Oh yeah, I hadn't enough money with me to buy an owl and my cat was eaten by an acromantula...T_T
Quirrel : We didnt really see what he taught to 1st years Lockhart : Set up the dueling club which help them learn Expelliarmus Remus : Literally everything...Expecto Patronum the most important Barty Moody : The Unforgivable curses Umbridge : Taught how to survive torture Snape : Non-verbal spells...Sectumsempra...Potions book
I have been wondering… Voldemort wanted to teach DADA. So imagine one day he makes Quirrell také off his turban, turns around in his chair and starts teaching. And everyone is super confused, but Tom turns out to be a very good teacher.
C3PO Robotic no he taught the class a number of things actually including the knockback jinx and how to identify the curse of the bogies. It’s also implied that he taught the class petrificus totalus. Lockhart taught nothing. So Quirrell was definitely a better teacher than Lockhart.
The full moon was the night before September 1st in 1993, so maybe that has something to do with why Lupin was on the train? He's my all time favorite character, though, he's great.
Britt in Wonderland wasn't the ministry tracking apparation? could lupin have been trying to keep a low profile? while it wasn't necessary for him to keep a low profile until year 5, maybe he was just paranoid. also, that's a great theory as well. maybe he was too weak to apparate to hogsmeade.
That was also the year dementors were at Hogwarts they likely planted the teacher on the train in case since the patronous charm which protects against them was advanced magic. They even said it was when Lupin was teaching it to Harry.
I love the way lupin never gave up on harry when he was trying to teach harry how to conjure a patronus most teachers will just give up on the student.
( 1) Remus Lupin ( 2) Severus Snape ( 3) Dolerus Umbrige ( 4) Gilderoy Lockhart ( 5) Professor. Quirill ( 6) Mad- eye moody/ Barty Crouch Junior Any ranking different than that is a total misunderstanding of the role of a professor .
yes, she is definetely the worse out of the 3 actual professors. (Gilderoy lockhart is a fraud, Quieill and Barty Crouch Jr were death eaters infiltrated, which is even worse)@@saulgoodman4219
I think Harry actually based his stuff on what Lupin taught him. Yes he taught more, but Lupin gave him what he needed really. Not saying Harry ISN'T a good teacher, he is, just that he learned from Lupin in the first place. :)
I feel like the case against Quirill given isn't very compelling. If we're going to excuse Barty Crouch Jr. for being a double agent then Quirill should be the same. Nothing from the books indicate he was incompetent or not teaching properly so I'd say he's better than Lockhart.
Agreed. Actually, in OotP Umbridge mentiones that only Quirrell's classes were age-appropriate and Ministry-approved. I know I shouldn't quote Umbridge on anything but at least Quirrell tried to teach them something and I think he was actually a decent teacher though all nervous and stuttering. It's Lockhart who didn't teach them anything except for one spell and of course Umbridge who's more evil than Voldemort himself.
Me: I can't wait to see what they rank in the SuperCarlinBros opinion! Also Me: *Sharpens knives in case Lupin isn't in first and Umbridge isn't in last
Jordan Draws people who say that are the dumb ones. I hate how huffleputh (and slytherin) have bad reputations. I'd probably be a huffleputh if I wasn't ravenclaw and honestly, gryffindor is the house I like the least (which apparently is normal for ravenclaws xD)
Voldemort: AVADA KIDA- Hermione: Slow down. Your going to pop someone's eyes out. Besides, your saying it WRONG. Voldemort: How dare you criticize! AVADA KIDA- Hermione: WHAT DID I SAY? Oh well I'll show you how it's done. Avada kidavra. Voldemort: *dies Hermione: my know-it-all instincts has never failed me 😏
@@ShadowDaNet I mean.. It is at the beggining, when it's Voldemort (Him saying "Kidevra" is the prounonciation mistake. Hermione should say it right, tho, I agree. So an edit of the joke would be appreciated?? 🤷♂️ Someday 😂
There are actually 7 teachers.ill rank them 1.lupin 2.mad eye moody aka barty crouch Jr 3.harry (he did teach 30+ students) 4.snape 5.quirrel 6.lockhart 7.umbridge aka the devil
I have always had a soft spot for Severus Snape. I wish Rowling gave him someone who loved him as much as he deserved. Underneath a hardened exterior beat a lover's heart. Lily chose poorly....but I hope in death she was able to see how much Snape truly loved her.😢❤
@HQ Night I understand where you're coming from. I think Lily loved Snape in her own way. He lashed out at her due to her horrid sister, Petunia. He also dealt with a lot of bullying from those who welcomed Lily but didnt deserve her kindness in his eyes. You are right though...Snape was a Slytherin through and through as he was obviously taught early about The Pureblood Doctrine and thus corrupted by it. Remember- Sirius Black was raised to believe the same and only changed due to his joining Hogwarts and Gryffindor House, seeing how different but worthy his friends were (except Pettigrew, the rat) and changed his way of thinking. Thanks for replying!🙋🏿♀️❤
@@shantellakaladypersephone8671 It comes down to different upbringing. But Sirius was estranged from all family members. He hated his family from early on as they all were cold and did not treat him with love, but demands, criticism and expectations. Snape, however was close to his mother, who was a pureblood witch, while hated his abusive father who happened to be a muggle. Its this situation that shaped Snapes views.
If you ask me, Snape was incompetent as a teacher. I mean, think about it, his book he wrote as a baby boy is even today still better than what is used - used even by himself in class!! He's literally using it in his very own class Books that he knows are highly inferior to the school books! He cares so freaking little about basically everything, that he never bothered to tell anyone, even during talking about the very subject! That's like a doctor knowing how to cure cancer, and he talks twice a week with another doctor about cancer, but he never botheres to mention that he knows how to cure it! Not just at all but not even during talking about the subject! Maybe he's just so much better in Potions than anyone else because he strongly monopolizes everything? Who knows, maybe he's even like Lockhart using magic to make others dumper!
Umbridge isn't "as bad as voldemort" she's way worse, like, she's too obsessed with cats, like seriously. And at least Voldemort smiles at some point, I don't even think Umbridge knows how
In defense of Voldemort (yea, I'm going there), Harry had to put up with Umbridge for a whole school year while we only saw good 'ol Voldy at the end of every year....except for Harry's third year. So we saw a whole lot more of Umbridge's evilness than the dark lord's.
Yeah, Voldy was kind of fair with Harry, giving him a chance to learn stuff before trying to kill him. Although, it is the worst thing when your enemy is as dumb as cabbage, or so the saying goes, so there is that. (PS: Not really my thought, heard it somewhere, possibly this channel.)
( 1) Remus Lupin ( 2) Severus Snape ( 3) Dolerus Umbrige ( 4) Gilderoy Lockhart ( 5) Professor. Quirill ( 6) Mad- eye moody/ Barty Crouch Junior Any ranking different than that is a total misunderstanding of the role of a professor .
@@TiaguinhoMu I mean actually barty crotch did teach them quite a lot of stuff he helped Neville gain confidence which is kinda screwed up considering he tortured his family but still he teaches the kids about the unforgivable curses and more than likely a good amount of dark spells or defense against the dark arts spells he actually teaches them some pretty useful stuff Umbridge literally taught them nothing useful as they never even practiced magic in her class at least that she taught
Yes, she is definetely the worst out of the 3 actual professors (the very next one on the list is a fraud but at least intend to do the job and the other 2 are voldemort's men with corrupted intentions) @@williampaulsinghharika2627
@@TiaguinhoMu Have you gone mad? The job of a professor is to teach. Umbridge didn't do that. Barty Crouch Jr. actually taught them a great deal of valuable knowledge. Anything Lockhart taught was by accident. You can argue about two and three, but the tiers are obvious. Lupin is a head above the rest, and the other three are clearly at the bottom.
I think Crouch edges him out as a teacher. Preparing Harry to fight the Unforgivables was a HUGE step forward for him. Crouch made a massive difference in Harry's ability to triumph in the 7th book. So did Lupin, but the patronus only had niche applications while nearly every Death Eater Harry ever encountered was capable of the Unforgivables.
But what did Quirell even teach Harry that Harry uses later? At least Umbridge taught him how to use defensive magic in an oppressive dictatorship situation, however unintentional that was.
This is slightly unrelated, but if you notice that Snape always writes potion instructions on the board himself instead of using the book, and Hermione always succeeds following his instructions. However, once Slughorn takes over, he has the students follow the book, which leads to Hermione struggling, while Harry succeeds using Snape’s instructions in his book. Just a cool little detail that Snape may have been a bully teacher, but he was a good potions teacher.
why was Lupin on the train: - because Dumbledoor knew the dementors would be checking the carriages - or in case Serious Black attacked (before he knew he was innocent)
And in book 5 when Sirius is talking to them about Umbridge it says, ‘She drafted a bit of anti-werewolf legislation two years ago that makes it almost impossible for him to get a job.’ (Two years ago being around POA time) so, since he can’t Apparate to Hogwarts and has very little money (because he can’t keep/ get a job for very long) he takes the train instead?
I honestly am very upset that Barty Crouch Jr as Moody couldn't stay as the teacher (under some... Unbreakable Vow or whatever), because he was so GOOD as a teacher. He treated the students with respect for their experiences instead of trying to constantly coddle them like the other adults, and he also took a more proactive stance against idiotic bullying and disrespectful students (even if we would consider a teacher turning a student temporarily into a ferret as abuse, the wizarding world is much different and we must remember that the Forbidden Forest is considered appropriate for detention). I would have loved to see exactly how much Barty-Moody would have taught the kids over the years, since he was the only one to really expose them to the magic that Death Eaters and Voldemort would actually use. I was so upset when he was revealed to be the villain.
we all knew Lupin would be number one and "Mad Eye" number two XD it is interesting where you put lockheart though, honestly i usually put him under Quirrell, then again theyre kinda at the same level for me, and if i remember correctly, the book doesnt talk much about year 1 DADA, so Quirrell might have been doing a decent job
That likeable villain who will torture you so much that you wouldn't recognise yourself and straight up murder you! Unlike Umbridge doesn't have guts to actually harm someone physically.
Philipizmo the thing with Umbridge is that she is banal evil- most of us have met someone like her- who gets off on control, and who is nasty and bigoted. Don’t forget- she was more than happy to head the Muggle Registration office- without being imperiused. Voldemort, being basically a wizard Hitler is that evil that is far off- we’ve heard of it, but we don’t know it personally- not like we do with Umbridge.
I always wondered about the curse that no DAtDA teacher lasts more than one year because of Quirrel... I've just started listening to book 1 again and Hagrid speaks of Quirrel, outside the Leaky Cauldron, as if he has already been a teacher - "scared of his students" "scared of his own subject" - also implying that it's DAtDA that he already teaches.... any thoughts?
I agree as well. This is almost identical to the rankings in the list, except places 4 & 5 are swapped, and it makes more sense. Let's face it, Quirrell may have been a bad professor, but at least he knew what he was talking about, something that can't be said about Lockheart. *Umbridge is placed last because, as said in the video, she actually went out of her way to make sure the students DON'T learn what she's supposed to teach them... Plus she tortured Harry almost as badly as the Dursleys did.
Snape is the best defense against the dark arts wizard of this list, idk about teacher. Snape knew more curses when he arrived at school than half of the kids in seventh years. He understood them and made counter curses for them.He created his own dark magic and also made counter spells for those. And his knowledge as an adult, was so great that even Albus Dumbledore came to him for help on the subject multiple times. He also created a resistance potion to a curse invented and cast by Voldemort himself, keeping it at bay for an extraordinarily long time, given that it was such an extremely powerful curse. He brewed Mandrake Restorative Draught, which cured all victims of the Badilisk petrification which was described by dumbledore as “Dark Magic of the most advanced kind”. So powerful occlumency was so strong he kept Voldemort believing his loyalty for 17 years, Voldemort was considered the most powerful legilimence. His knowledge in healing was so great that Dumbledore once quoted to Harry that Snape was more experienced in healing against Dark magic than poppy pomfrey was. He also saved Katie bell form a cursed neck less. For his teaching I would say: “His encyclopaedic understanding of the dark arts made so that Snape taught the class at N.E.W.T level to such an effect that even Harry Potter could not help but be enchanted by his knowledge.” That’s something…. Ps. I just have to say the logic of “these spells were the most useful so the teachers who taught them are the best teachers is flawed to say the least. Just because it were the most useful for 1 person doesn’t mean it was useful for any of the other students.
For me it is 1. Lupin (Easy) 2.Snape (Always) 3. Barth Crouch Jr. (They ARE Illegal!) 4. Quirell (I mean Iguanas and dark arts! do they mix?) 5. Lockhart (at least the OTHER teachers except Umbridge teach them) 6. Umbridge (do I have to explain?)
Y'know, I've always thought Harry should've become Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher after Voldemort's death. Not immediately, of course, but like a few years after. We already see that he's really good at teaching Defense in his fifth year, and Hogwarts always felt like his home. Plus, I think it would have been really fun to see him do the boggart lesson in the same manner as Lupin and Dumbledore.
Who was your favorite Defense Against The Dark Arts Teacher?
SuperCarlinBrothers Lupin!
SuperCarlinBrothers Lupin!
SuperCarlinBrothers Lupin
SuperCarlinBrothers Lupin!!!
Lupin 110%
I wish the job wasn’t cursed so Remus could stay as the teached
Even then He couldn't, because the parents (Like the Malfoys) found out that He was a Werwolf and didn't want him to be around their Kids. Sadly
@@RichtofensLittleGirl that's because of the curse. No teacher could teach defense against the dark arts more than a year because of Voldemort's magic.
That same curse was the main reason why Dumbledore never placed Snape on that position btw. He wanted to have Snape with him
Well this is a curious one tbh because there are references in the first book of quirrel being a multi year teacher, because on holiday from hogwarts is when he met Voldemort. So did he take over from another DADA teacher or did having Voldemort in him reset the curse as he wasn’t technically the same man (edit: ignore this, just read he was muggle studied and took over the job)
MemeLord ikr
"He showed them an iguana,i mean,that's more than umbridge did."
I died laughing at that part!
Hayzy Horses so true :D
Yeah I still have a scar on my hand from the demented quill
Iguanas are terrifying you shouldn't go near them. Quirrell said so.
*saying as a Slytherin myself* Quirrell was an idiot. plus, he was also the host for Voldemort. iguanas aren't scary, they're cool. i like them, i'd even go as far to say, they're cute :)
As a woman who also undergoes painful physical occurrences once a month, I can see why Lupin agrees that chocolates really do help.
Me too girl
Underrated comment
Understatement of the century, right there
I have NEVER thought of it that way...
Wow, never even thought of THAT. It's so out there that it actually makes it even more intriguing.
I can surely imagine the author pouring this little tid bit in with a simple smirk on her face. Just like Delores had to be a writing delight in the same way. 😊😅
“Lupin was the only time we saw a professor on the train.”
Slughorn be like
Slughorn was in the Slug Club he doesn't count
( 1) Remus Lupin
( 2) Severus Snape
( 3) Dolerus Umbrige
( 4) Gilderoy Lockhart
( 5) Professor. Quirill
( 6) Mad- eye moody/ Barty Crouch Junior
Any ranking different than that is a total misunderstanding of the role of a professor
.
@@TiaguinhoMu not exactly,Barty crouch jr actually did a pretty good job.
Except by the fact that his goal there was to have his students murdered and enjoy their suffering like Neville ye sure thing... @@tinazhangg
@@TiaguinhoMu but he was still good at teaching the subject ?
JK Rowling : 'Umbridge is as evil as Voldemort himself'
Harry: Woah woah woah I wouldn't go that far to insult Voldemort
Harry: that hag is much worse than him
@@thedragonwarrior5861 True XD
True
Got em
Poor voldy, even he doesn’t deserve that hate. I mean he does. But uh…ok he does.
(No he doesn’t XD)
I swear if it's not Lupin.....
Yes!
That was my first thought too
Grant Paylago Ok good. I couldn't choose between him and Ron. (I have a book-crush on both.)
It's got to be Lupin, I mean come on!
Grant Paylago: I could survive with Lupin or Faux-Moody.
“The fact that Lockhart is number 4 on this list says a lot about the teachers”
And the fact that Umbridge is the worst says nothing about the other teachers
@@hiplsnols4394 I mean, Dumbledore didn't hire her though, that was ministry interference.
@@hiplsnols4394 it's inevitable when you have a ministry getting involved in affairs they're completely ignorant of.
@@hiplsnols4394you can rag on dubledore for hiring lockhart though
sorry guys i forgot about that
500 attacks by dementors
Lupin: FREE CHOCOLATE FOR EVERYONE!!!!!
I can actually imagine him doing that tho😂
Chocolate helps in bad situations
I see it..... Can I dream about this instead of my best friend telling me that a friend of mine might like me?
Lupin is just the greatest most likeble person in the whole world. And i am saying that knowing Carlise Cullen, Gandalf or Captain America. He shall be rememberd forever. Not only as a Teacher, but also as a Person
He has my vote.
I completely agree, but Lupin forgot one creature
The Umbitch
Great roast
I so agree
Yes, but that would be too dangerous for the children
Destruction:100 l o l f u c c
Yay
Lupin. No buts. Lupin was THE BEST DEFENSE AGAINST THE DARK ARTS PROFESSOR THE WORLD HAS EVER SEEN
lupin was more defense against dark creatures
yeah lol
YES WE STAN
Dolores Umbridge CRUCIO
Dolores Umbridge begone demon
BEN: Lupin is the only time we see a proffesor take the train
SLUGHORN: Am I a joke to you
Yes slughorn you are a joke to me DEAL WITH IT
"He did show them an iguana" had me dead XD
And its more that what Umbridge did 🤣🤣🤣
Literally
"He's the only teacher we ever see on the Hogwarts train" *sad Slughorn noises*
yut
We only ever *read* about Slughorn being on the train. So I guess this guy didn't read the books. Which honestly doesn't surprise me...
He has read them both paper and Audio, I am so disappointed in him 🤦🏻♀️.
I can’t believe that they missed Slughorn!
Iv only read them once and I remembered him :(
lupin was not the only teacher seen on the train, slughorn was. most likely there is a teacher's area. lupin probably wanted to sit in his old compartment where he would ride to school with the marauders
that wasnt the original marauders compartment it was the compartment where RON sat at RANDOM basically and harry joined him because he couldnt think of where else to sit.
it could have been the marauders compartment, there is no proof that it isn't. in fact, since lupin sat there, it is likely that it was
Also possibly to protect Harry from Sirius. Word would get around that that's Harry's compartment.
Didn't they just go there because the other compartments was full? Making it a coincident that lupin was with them when the death eaters attacked?
yes but that doesnt change the fact that lupin could have been sitting there because it was the marauder's old compartment.
I always loved how Crouch Jr. was such a mad genius that he had to attempt to play the role of Moody as perfect as he could. When he turns Draco into an animal is a good moment because it’s stated several times earlier that moody has a bad tendency to transfigure people into small animals. Also how much he just plays the role in all the other small details it’s crazy but really neat.
Crouch Jr is a method actor confirmed, lol
He also, probably, had no qualms about transfiguring Draco as he would've known that Lucius wasn't under the imperius curse in the first Wizarding war. A little revenge with "what are you going to do about it"
The only thing Barty Crouch Jr. Couldn't master was his little quark with his tongue. Which almost got him caught by Sr.
yeah crouch-eye was very smart about it
In my opinion, I feel like Quirell taught the students better than Lockhart.
A FERRET would have taught them better ...
Not going to lie, even batty crouch jr. taught them fairly well
@@-jupiter-3140 yes
@@albussr1589 PFFFT
Maybe I mean we never saw him teaching unless you play Hogwarts mystery and you in sixth year in the game
Lupin wasn’t the only professor to ride the train. Professor Slughorn went on the train in the half-blood prince
I like ur hair
Heisenberg The Fagottini thanx
I was just about to type that
I was just about to say that
And Slughorn had too many collectors items to travel any other way lol would have been a few trunks full that needed the train.
Lupin is easier to answer - anywhere near a full moon he is too weak to do magic, (or fly on a broom) ministry doesn't like his kind so he wouldn't be able to be set up to the floo network... So train was the only way to travel.
lets be honest you want to kill umbridge more than voldermort himself
random girlyness the thing is like we understood why voldemort did what he did. while it was terrible we knew where he was coming from. but with umbridge she was just evil for the sake of being evil. at least voldemort thought he was doing the right thing for the greater good. umbridge just wanted to torture the kids. I hate umbridge
random girlyness If I had two Avada Kedavra's and Voldemort and Umbridge were in from of me, I would use both on Umbridge.
random girlyness true.
random girlyness Pretty much.
I like that I hate her. For me, she's a more interesting villain than Voldie. Just the fact that her actions give reactions to viewer/readers is what makes a good villain. Belatrix is next in line for clearly enjoying what she does. Voldermort is just... there. He's the type of villain that lets his minions do most of the work. And that makes him less intimidating in my eyes.
Umbridge is VERY hands on even when she had Team Draco helping her.
The fact that Lockhart was 1 place behind SNAPE really shows a lot about the quality of the teachers at this position
Ben: Goes on a tangent about Professors sleeping at the school
Also Ben: What I’m trying to say is WHO IS THE BEST DEFENCE AGAINST THE DARK ARTS TEACHER
The fact that a death eater was in second really says something about the quality of teachers in this position
Edit: Thank you so much for 900 likes!
Second and third and the best was a werewolf XD
He was first tbh.
Bcjr. Was the best teacher Harry had
He was a double agent for Dumbledore...
Lily Bell triple
Tbh, considering it's defense against DARK Arts, a death eater is really the best to be teaching it.
Gonna say it before watching: It's Remus
Harry had the worst dada teachers possible, so a guy that is actually a good teacher needs to be number one yes.
If i had Remus as a teacher id even put him as number 1 and i cant really complain.
@@ashmonkey2572 if I had remus as a teacher I would probably enjoy going to school
Basantasena Biswas and meee
Basantasena Biswas ye, school would actually be nice
“Lupin is the only teacher we see on the train.”
Slughorn: “am I a joke to you.”
Fred and George were hitting quirrel in the back of the head with enchanted snowballs, sooo..... Fred and George were hitting Voldemort in the face! 😂
Fred and George are legends!!
True 😂😂
Old Moldy Voldy "I hate them Weasley brothers!"
Lupin is the only DADA professor seen on the train
@@kentuckywildcatgobigblue7190 old moldy voldy baldy
Yea
“Who was Harry’s best defense against the dark arts professor?” Lupin, the end.
( 1) Remus Lupin
( 2) Severus Snape
( 3) Dolerus Umbrige
( 4) Gilderoy Lockhart
( 5) Professor. Quirill
( 6) Mad- eye moody/ Barty Crouch Junior
Any ranking different than that is a total misunderstanding of the role of a professor
.
I think you should put umbridge on the bottom other than that tiaguinhoMu your list is accurate
Honestly, Barty crouch was a great teacher. He definitely was intense, but Harry would have never survived Voldemort without him.
True very true
The first 3 from my list are the only actual professors. The other 3 lack motive or were corrupt/working for voldemort rather than hogwarts somehow @@2p-blog-thing
top 10 worst hp characters
1. no
2. character
3. deserves
4. to
5. be
6. rated
7. as best
8. or
9. worst
10. dolores umbridge
10 should be number 1 😂
Zouwu _ Lockhart is the worst with her
Hate the characther but respect the actor
*
10. No
9. Character
8. Deserves
7. To
6. Be
5. Rated
4. As best
3. Or
2. Worst
1. Dolores Umbridge
Fixed it.
Best Dark Arts Teacher: Remus Lupin
Worst Ever Dark Arts Teacher: Dolores Umbridge
Easy mode.
The Worstest Teacher Ever
Best Defense Against the Dark Arts Teacher:Remus Lupin
Worst Defense Against The Dark Arts Teacher: Toad-Like Face Umbridge
SO NOW THE RANKING
6th=Toad Face
5ty=Lockhart
4th=Alastor Mad Eye Moody (Imposter)
Joint 2nd=Quirrell And Snape
Honourable Mentions=Harry Potter (that's it)
1st=Remus Lupin!!
She shouldn't even be on this list. It said TEACH-ers.
Donna Doonan I’d say snape was better than quirrel.
Erwin Pasamanero (For notes, I’m talking about the documented classes we know about. Nothing beyond what is shown to us in the books, nor from the other books.) I looked at the title, and immediately crossed off Lockhart and Umbridge. Crossed off Quirrel, although he might’ve shown potential if he wasn’t Voldemort’s puppet. So that leaves Lupin, Mad-Eye, and Snape. For future reference, I am talking about Barty Crouch Jr impersonating Mad-Eye, not the real one, due to the real one not actually being the teacher. I am also leaving him in, partly due to the whole ferret incident, but also due to the fact that he actually did teach things, such as showing them the unforgivable curses, and even teaching the class how to throw off the Imperious Curse. But I’m still placing him at third. Leaving Snape and Lupin. Lupin was a good teacher, and taught them how to combat some of the magical monsters in their world, and literally, *1*, curse, which was only useful against boggarts. He might’ve taught them other curses, but when your enemy tells you that you’re behind on curses with knowledge of what Lupin taught them, well that doesn’t bode well for you. So (I’m gonna start WW3 aren’t I by saying this,) I’m rating Lupin second. Now people are definitely going to hate me for this, but I’m placing Snape first. While he wasn’t a good person in general, he was a good teacher, and taught them somewhat in self defense. Yes, part of what he taught was taught to them by Harry in 5th year, but that doesn’t change the fact that he taught it nonetheless, and even that some of the class didn’t know any of it. Snape also taught them how to distinguish inferi from ghosts or other magical creatures. So yes, I’m rating Snape as the best Hogwarts teacher, not because of character, but because of what he taught
The teachers here were so amazing that the best one was a werewolf and the second best was a death eater-
and the third best was also a death eater
and don’t forget the fact that the worst one killed a dementor just by being evil
@@jesseyu69420how?
1) Lupin - He was their best DADA teacher, taught them a lot, let them practice and was very helpful
2) Snape - Second only because of his approach. I truly think he taught Harry the most, by far, about defence against dark arts. He kept giving him lesson even during their duel after Dumbledores death. He also is the most knowledgeable about the subject. The thing is, he truly is too socially awkward, demanding and bitter to make a good teacher.
3) Crouch Jr. - too bad Barty didnt chose academic career instead of, well, world dominance. He was a natural.
4) Quirrell - He at least tries to teach, even while willingly possessed by the darkest wizard of all time... I dont want to even imagine his headaches
5) Lockhart - useless self-centered idiot.
6) Umbridge - Useless, doesnt even intend to teach, just there to torture everybody...
perfect list
And don’t forget about the Carrows, who in book 7 were torturing students more than Umbridge. They truly are the 8th on a 7 character list
And don't forget... Lupin was also the only Professor who wasn't being a total prick...
Timon Heidema quirrel wasnt a prick untill the end
Severus Snape Yeah, but he was a prick.
Your #1 on my list of the D.A.D.A teachers ranked, Also, Lily was forced to date James, Lily loved you, and she watches over you as a ghost, R.I.P Lily Potter/Evans
Cookie Gurl, ROBLOX, Minecraft & More! Thank you...
Cookie Gurl, ROBLOX, Minecraft & More! It was actually her own decision...
Admit it, as soon you saw the thumbnail you thought
"Lupin"
Yup
I thought quirrell.
I blame the QuirrelMort fics for that.
@QBananaQ 723
what
is
wrong
with
you
Definitely Lupin ROCKED R.I.P. Lupus :(
Yes
Ben: Lupin is the only teacher that's ever been on the train
Slughorn: Am I a joke to you?
Who else reading the title immediately thought that it would be Remus Lupin.
I thought it might be Barty Crouch Jr: for an evil dark wizard, he’s definitely my favorite D.A.D.A. professor, and he’s REALLY good at it.
Me!✋🏼
i did!
@@LOVEMUFFIN_official Well other than using the imperius curse on the students, yeah, I agree.
Sure, it helps Harry specifically resist the imperius curse when it's cast on him by Voldemort, but Harry seemed to be a special case. Everybody else was just puppeteered by Barty jr. for the shi*s and giggles.
Before watching the video, I have one thing to say:
Clearly it was Harry. He taught the entire fifth year (excluding Slytherins) Defense Against the Dark Arts, and they actually LEARNED from him. And he was FIFTEEN.
I never even thought about Harry, but he might be the best. (As much as I love Remus). He was fair and helped those who needed help, which is what a teacher is suppose to do. But if we're going with the adults then it would be Remus.
Mephostopheles AWW YEAAAH
Mephostopheles Harry didn't only teach fifth-years!! Luna an Ginny were fourth years for example, and Fred and George seventh, and I believe Cho, Marietta and Katie Bell were even sixth year students!!
Dagmar Eileen You're right. This only proves my point further: Harry is a great teacher.
Mephostopheles yes, I totally agree
Dolores shouldn't even be on the list. She wasn't a teacher, she was a torturer.
she did teach some things... useless things but some things.
She taught us that human-toad hybrids are real thing.
Ana N she taught Harry not to live with the way things are.. Life lessons with umbridge people!
She was hired as a teacher, so she was a teacher. She didn't _do_ any teaching, but that's like saying a soldier who hasn't had to fight for a while is no longer a soldier.
Ana N amen
“We8ve only seen one professor on the train”
*Professor Slughorn left the chat*
But who is the best DADA teacher Neville had?
Harry Potter.
*Admit it.* WE ALL WANTED UMBRIDGE DEAD MORE THAN Voldemort.
Edit: 1k likes?!?!? Thx so much!
I think even though Voldemort committed more atrocities, there are two reasons people hate Umbridge more:
1) She is relatable. Almost everyone has had a bitch of a teacher or boss or neighbor etc. We know how it feels to be on the receiving end of that abuse. She represents every authority figure who was an asshole to us for no apparent reason. In that way you could say she is similar to Severus Snape. However unlike Snape, she had another trait that made her unbearable.
2) She played innocent. She was obviously a sociopathic monster, but she had an act that everything was gumdrops and rainbows and that she was just doing her duty. The most aggravating part was that she knew that everyone knew how much of a bitch she was, but she still pretended. It was condescending and annoying.
Snape was angry about Lily's death, Umbridge had no reasons. And Snape never physically tortured anyone.
3.14 Dragon Harry's oclumamency (spelling) training was arguably torture.
Tara Jones I saw this on a meme xD
TheUnknown Angel Omg yes
obviously professor Lupin and Snape.
chloe white and also crouch junior impersonating madeye he was practical and truthful in defense against the dark arts... In order to defend urself u must face wat threatens u... Same as life
Well, Snape actually bullied nearly all his students for no reason, so even if he teached Harry really usefull stuff - In reality Dumbledore should have fired this guy long before Harry started school :P
I think that's why he isn't No 1 or 2 ^^
Nooo, not my toad D':
I love it so much, even though it's borring and stupid and dirty and useless and probably toxic and...uhm...why exactly do I own a toad? Oh yeah, I hadn't enough money with me to buy an owl and my cat was eaten by an acromantula...T_T
chloe white Yes of course! Thank you I'm waiting for this.
This is how many times Ben said "half-full kind of guy"
I
I
V
Quirrel : We didnt really see what he taught to 1st years
Lockhart : Set up the dueling club which help them learn Expelliarmus
Remus : Literally everything...Expecto Patronum the most important
Barty Moody : The Unforgivable curses
Umbridge : Taught how to survive torture
Snape : Non-verbal spells...Sectumsempra...Potions book
Happy face: :-)
Sad face: :-(
Voldemort face: :)
Sad Voldemort face: :(
Umbridge face: 🐸
Voldemort's face: :=)
Voldemort should've ended her
:=) Voldemort
I LOVE YOUR UMBRIGE FACE...
Or should I say umbfrog face
Dont hate me
Umbridge Face:
🐮
3:40 "I guess he did try to teach the students though. I mean, after all, he did show them an iguana; that's more than Umbridge did." ~Ben 2017
Thx yeah you're right
Kitty Rose Did someone delete their comment?
Kitty Rose lmao
He ain’t wrong
Ummm why did u comment yourself yeah I think your right?
Me: *thinking this could be redone now that we’ve learned dumbledore worked the position at some point.*
he was probably using the main harry potter books 1-7 & excluding the books concerning newt & grindawald
It’s a bit incredible how Hogwarts got away with having only ONE teacher per subject
It’s funny that the guy who had lord Voldemort on the back of his head isn’t even the worst defense against the dark arts teacher😂😂
I have been wondering… Voldemort wanted to teach DADA. So imagine one day he makes Quirrell také off his turban, turns around in his chair and starts teaching. And everyone is super confused, but Tom turns out to be a very good teacher.
@@barboraklepalova3886 omg he probably made quirrel apply for Dada and what if he sometimes helped quirrel prepare for lessons
Barbora Klepalová ummmm
Yes
I haven’t watched the video yet but I’m not surprised because we all know how terrible Umbridge is
*see title*
obviously LUPIN!!
zahra hanifa same
zahra hanifa SAME!!
zahra hanifa Lupin Squad :D
YEAH AGREE
OBVS 😂
Remus of course. The amount of tears I cried when he died in Deathly Hallows
Same my favourite
Arrrgh 😭😭😭😭😭
Me: DADA
My mom : dad
Me : ...
I really like Lupin... Plus, its not HIS fault he's a werewolf... =T
To be fair, I've come to terms with my lycanthropy quite well.
Izzy0308 Greyback is cool, but he's mean
nigga finna woke
Izzy0308
His father was basically asking for his son to be bitten
Izzy0308 same
Let’s be real umbridge isn’t as bad as Voldemort
She’s ten times worse
Truee3e
Twenty time worse
Yup.
not true shes worse
Greyback is the worst
"only instance we see of a professor on the train"
Slughorn: am i a joke to you?
Umbridge x Dementor
Can’t wait for there first kiss! 😂
I disagree with 5 Quirell was a decent teacher, he just had(or rather pretended to have) a severe stutter, while Lockhart indirectly taught 1 spell
Anthony Bouffiou well all quirell did was teach Harry that if he touched voldermort would die, which was almost useless
C3PO Robotic no he taught the class a number of things actually including the knockback jinx and how to identify the curse of the bogies. It’s also implied that he taught the class petrificus totalus. Lockhart taught nothing. So Quirrell was definitely a better teacher than Lockhart.
Idk, having the Dark Lord sharing your body is a big no-no for the position.
Being a literal Death Eater is also a big no-no, but he was in second place.
Yea i think he would have been the 4
The full moon was the night before September 1st in 1993, so maybe that has something to do with why Lupin was on the train? He's my all time favorite character, though, he's great.
SAME! Lupins awesome
Britt in Wonderland wasn't the ministry tracking apparation? could lupin have been trying to keep a low profile? while it wasn't necessary for him to keep a low profile until year 5, maybe he was just paranoid. also, that's a great theory as well. maybe he was too weak to apparate to hogsmeade.
Shane Levesque II oh yeah that's very true! It probably was that. Could be a combination of weakness and avoiding being noticed by the ministry.
I never really thought about why lupin was on the train much, I had always assumed the teachers just apparate to hogsmeade or flooed in.
That was also the year dementors were at Hogwarts they likely planted the teacher on the train in case since the patronous charm which protects against them was advanced magic. They even said it was when Lupin was teaching it to Harry.
"reason number one: chocolate"
Well, no duh.
Lupin is my favourite and I regret nothing about him being my favourite teacher and Harry Potter
Same
I love the way lupin never gave up on harry when he was trying to teach harry how to conjure a patronus most teachers will just give up on the student.
( 1) Remus Lupin
( 2) Severus Snape
( 3) Dolerus Umbrige
( 4) Gilderoy Lockhart
( 5) Professor. Quirill
( 6) Mad- eye moody/ Barty Crouch Junior
Any ranking different than that is a total misunderstanding of the role of a professor
.
@@TiaguinhoMu Umbridge didn’t teach them anything
yes, she is definetely the worse out of the 3 actual professors.
(Gilderoy lockhart is a fraud, Quieill and Barty Crouch Jr were death eaters infiltrated, which is even worse)@@saulgoodman4219
@@TiaguinhoMu quirrell and barty still teached something. We're talking about the best TEACHERS. Not in-persons or personality
@@TiaguinhoMuCrouch Jr. might be bad but he taught them way better than Umbridge, Lockhart and Quirrell
Even before I clicked on the video, I said 'Lupin!' as soon as I read the title
Waddles The Pig same
me too, he is such a nice guy.
Waddles The Pig nope! Harry wins!
I think Harry actually based his stuff on what Lupin taught him. Yes he taught more, but Lupin gave him what he needed really. Not saying Harry ISN'T a good teacher, he is, just that he learned from Lupin in the first place. :)
Funny, before I watched I said, "ooooooo it better not be Umbridge."
I think I loved Snape as the defence against the dark arts professor!!
Why
I feel like the case against Quirill given isn't very compelling. If we're going to excuse Barty Crouch Jr. for being a double agent then Quirill should be the same. Nothing from the books indicate he was incompetent or not teaching properly so I'd say he's better than Lockhart.
Agreed. Actually, in OotP Umbridge mentiones that only Quirrell's classes were age-appropriate and Ministry-approved. I know I shouldn't quote Umbridge on anything but at least Quirrell tried to teach them something and I think he was actually a decent teacher though all nervous and stuttering. It's Lockhart who didn't teach them anything except for one spell and of course Umbridge who's more evil than Voldemort himself.
I'm pretty sure Quirrell's classes are described as "a bit of a joke". I'd probably still put him ahead of Lockhart though.
Remus Lupin was and will always be the best defense against the dark arts teacher. R.I.P
Saba Dvali why did you have to remind me he dies like no just dont
@@oi3702 and actually did you know that remus was in ww1? You can see it in wonderwoman.
Saba Dvali WHAT?? HOW! isnt that like much before he is even born like, ww1 was in 1914 so...
@@oi3702 wizards can live up to 200 years. J.K Rowling said it too
No, no and no!! I cried at that scene
Me: I can't wait to see what they rank in the SuperCarlinBros opinion!
Also Me: *Sharpens knives in case Lupin isn't in first and Umbridge isn't in last
yeh i feel ya. I HATE Umbridge,and I'm a Huffle Puff so according to stereotypes im suposed to like EVERYone.
Jordan Draws well, hufflepuths aren't dumb or lacking a moral compass, on the contrary, so of course you'd hate a monster
Mira Kun lol thanks. I'm sick of the stereotypes that huddle puffs are dumb and likes everyone no matter how evil they are
Jordan Draws people who say that are the dumb ones. I hate how huffleputh (and slytherin) have bad reputations. I'd probably be a huffleputh if I wasn't ravenclaw and honestly, gryffindor is the house I like the least (which apparently is normal for ravenclaws xD)
xD
Voldemort: AVADA KIDA-
Hermione: Slow down. Your going to pop someone's eyes out. Besides, your saying it WRONG.
Voldemort: How dare you criticize! AVADA KIDA-
Hermione: WHAT DID I SAY? Oh well I'll show you how it's done. Avada kidavra.
Voldemort: *dies
Hermione: my know-it-all instincts has never failed me 😏
Funny joke but just so you know it's avada kedavra
i wish that was the ending-
I original thought Kidavra was just part of the joke, but they were just misspelling
🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@ShadowDaNet I mean.. It is at the beggining, when it's Voldemort (Him saying "Kidevra" is the prounonciation mistake. Hermione should say it right, tho, I agree.
So an edit of the joke would be appreciated?? 🤷♂️ Someday 😂
There are actually 7 teachers.ill rank them
1.lupin
2.mad eye moody aka barty crouch Jr
3.harry (he did teach 30+ students)
4.snape
5.quirrel
6.lockhart
7.umbridge aka the devil
There is 7 but Harry is not one Amicus Carrow in the last movie
I wouldnt go that far insulting the devil
I agree but let’s not insult the devil
bro don't do the devil dirty like that
Ammmiiicccccuussss Caaaaarrrrrroooooo
" Snape teaches Harry the spell that overthrows Voldemort" How poetic
I have always had a soft spot for Severus Snape. I wish Rowling gave him someone who loved him as much as he deserved.
Underneath a hardened exterior beat a lover's heart.
Lily chose poorly....but I hope in death she was able to see how much Snape truly loved her.😢❤
Pinepensubs333 So I may have read your comment wrong and… read it as “pathetic” 🤦🏼♀️
@HQ Night I understand where you're coming from.
I think Lily loved Snape in her own way.
He lashed out at her due to her horrid sister, Petunia. He also dealt with a lot of bullying from those who welcomed Lily but didnt deserve her kindness in his eyes.
You are right though...Snape was a Slytherin through and through as he was obviously taught early about The Pureblood Doctrine and thus corrupted by it. Remember- Sirius Black was raised to believe the same and only changed due to his joining Hogwarts and Gryffindor House, seeing how different but worthy his friends were (except Pettigrew, the rat) and changed his way of thinking.
Thanks for replying!🙋🏿♀️❤
@@shantellakaladypersephone8671
It comes down to different upbringing.
But Sirius was estranged from all family members. He hated his family from early on as they all were cold and did not treat him with love, but demands, criticism and expectations.
Snape, however was close to his mother, who was a pureblood witch, while hated his abusive father who happened to be a muggle. Its this situation that shaped Snapes views.
@@Raymoiful True....you're right. Thanks for responding! You've given me much to consider. I still love the series....
Why did I click this? I know it's Lupin. He's my favourite character in general but he's also the best teacher.
Samantha Darling I mean, he made his students ENJOY class. That's a good teacher there
Lupins my second faverorite teacher
Professor Lupin is DA BEST!!
Yeah but his namE IS REMUS
Samantha Darling in
Idk why I clicked on it..... I knew it would be Lupin
Thank you so much for uploading this video. It is helping me get through the pandemic!
Voldemort: how did you break free of my curse
Harry: your guy was great
Yas
yas
If you ask me, Snape was incompetent as a teacher. I mean, think about it, his book he wrote as a baby boy is even today still better than what is used - used even by himself in class!!
He's literally using it in his very own class Books that he knows are highly inferior to the school books! He cares so freaking little about basically everything, that he never bothered to tell anyone, even during talking about the very subject!
That's like a doctor knowing how to cure cancer, and he talks twice a week with another doctor about cancer, but he never botheres to mention that he knows how to cure it! Not just at all but not even during talking about the subject!
Maybe he's just so much better in Potions than anyone else because he strongly monopolizes everything? Who knows, maybe he's even like Lockhart using magic to make others dumper!
@@slevinchannel7589 woah! Thats a bit of a parragraph!!!
Umbridge isn't "as bad as voldemort" she's way worse, like, she's too obsessed with cats, like seriously. And at least Voldemort smiles at some point, I don't even think Umbridge knows how
She only smiles when she is torturing people.
In defense of Voldemort (yea, I'm going there), Harry had to put up with Umbridge for a whole school year while we only saw good 'ol Voldy at the end of every year....except for Harry's third year. So we saw a whole lot more of Umbridge's evilness than the dark lord's.
Becca The Fangirl. And we can't forget the ' hem hem'
Just Becca Umbridge smiled, they were just very fake smiles.
Yeah, Voldy was kind of fair with Harry, giving him a chance to learn stuff before trying to kill him. Although, it is the worst thing when your enemy is as dumb as cabbage, or so the saying goes, so there is that.
(PS: Not really my thought, heard it somewhere, possibly this channel.)
I love how Lupin seemingly just carries chocolate around with him at all times.
7:57 Slughorn does also travel on the train though?
Me: *Sees title*
Short answer, Remus Lupin!
( 1) Remus Lupin
( 2) Severus Snape
( 3) Dolerus Umbrige
( 4) Gilderoy Lockhart
( 5) Professor. Quirill
( 6) Mad- eye moody/ Barty Crouch Junior
Any ranking different than that is a total misunderstanding of the role of a professor
.
@@TiaguinhoMu I mean actually barty crotch did teach them quite a lot of stuff he helped Neville gain confidence which is kinda screwed up considering he tortured his family but still he teaches the kids about the unforgivable curses and more than likely a good amount of dark spells or defense against the dark arts spells he actually teaches them some pretty useful stuff Umbridge literally taught them nothing useful as they never even practiced magic in her class at least that she taught
@@TiaguinhoMu umbridge is the type of teacher that makes students hate a subject, learn only for exams and then forget everything again.
Yes, she is definetely the worst out of the 3 actual professors (the very next one on the list is a fraud but at least intend to do the job and the other 2 are voldemort's men with corrupted intentions) @@williampaulsinghharika2627
@@TiaguinhoMu Have you gone mad? The job of a professor is to teach. Umbridge didn't do that. Barty Crouch Jr. actually taught them a great deal of valuable knowledge. Anything Lockhart taught was by accident. You can argue about two and three, but the tiers are obvious. Lupin is a head above the rest, and the other three are clearly at the bottom.
The scariest creature in the world
An Umbridge
DUN DUN DUN
An umbridge in her natural habitat
Oh we have one at school
Nah Thats the best pokemon 😉
sittalklaughrelax equals that’s what I was thinking in my head lol
2:47 is so hilarious if u didn’t hear what he said before
I’m pretty sure everyone knows the answer to this question the second we saw this video, (lupin)
Muggles have nightmares, we have Umbridge Edit: thanks for 400 likes
Legend has it, a Dementor tried to suck out her soul. Umbridge walked away with every soul that Dementor ever took.
Cupcake Batman I heard that they thought she was Voldemort. But she was just having a good day
They are the same thing.
She's our version of a living nightmare
Muggles had Margaret Thatcher who Umbridge is undoubtedly based on
He says that lupin is the only professor on the train but in the books professor slughorn was in the train as well
Literally as he said that I was like 'nope' 😂😂
I have seen the “hardly any of you remembered that my favorite color is lilac” scene so many times on this channel that I will never forget it
Correction, if I'm not mistaken professor slughorn was also on the train.
Remus John Lupin OBVIOUSLY!!
He was the best out of all of them!
I think Crouch edges him out as a teacher. Preparing Harry to fight the Unforgivables was a HUGE step forward for him. Crouch made a massive difference in Harry's ability to triumph in the 7th book. So did Lupin, but the patronus only had niche applications while nearly every Death Eater Harry ever encountered was capable of the Unforgivables.
Aaisha Potter Geek so true I completely agree
Totally agree mate
crouch or moody?
My order is :
1. Lupin,
2. Snape,
3. Barty Crouch Jr (disguised as Mad-Eye Moody),
4. Quirell,
5. Lockhart,
6. Umbridge
agreed 100%
It says a lot about Lockhart and umbridge that they're below moldy voldy
Yep
But what did Quirell even teach Harry that Harry uses later? At least Umbridge taught him how to use defensive magic in an oppressive dictatorship situation, however unintentional that was.
Freshairkaboom Gaming. But she was an idiotic idiot champion of idiots
This is slightly unrelated, but if you notice that Snape always writes potion instructions on the board himself instead of using the book, and Hermione always succeeds following his instructions. However, once Slughorn takes over, he has the students follow the book, which leads to Hermione struggling, while Harry succeeds using Snape’s instructions in his book. Just a cool little detail that Snape may have been a bully teacher, but he was a good potions teacher.
7:52 he answers his own question 3 years later
why was Lupin on the train:
- because Dumbledoor knew the dementors would be checking the carriages
- or in case Serious Black attacked (before he knew he was innocent)
And in book 5 when Sirius is talking to them about Umbridge it says, ‘She drafted a bit of anti-werewolf legislation two years ago that makes it almost impossible for him to get a job.’ (Two years ago being around POA time) so, since he can’t Apparate to Hogwarts and has very little money (because he can’t keep/ get a job for very long) he takes the train instead?
I think it's also mentioned the previous night was a full moon
*serious*
@@dragonz6491 at least we know we was in a really bad state and slept through most of the ride.
Did you spelt that,
*Sirius-ly*?
Well Lupin is not the only teacher that ride the train to Hogwarts. In the Half Blood Prince professor Slughorn is also on the train.
Karin Markendahl True! I forgot about that...
But his the first
Karin Markendahl But he doesn't sit in a students carriage. He has a special place.
I honestly am very upset that Barty Crouch Jr as Moody couldn't stay as the teacher (under some... Unbreakable Vow or whatever), because he was so GOOD as a teacher. He treated the students with respect for their experiences instead of trying to constantly coddle them like the other adults, and he also took a more proactive stance against idiotic bullying and disrespectful students (even if we would consider a teacher turning a student temporarily into a ferret as abuse, the wizarding world is much different and we must remember that the Forbidden Forest is considered appropriate for detention). I would have loved to see exactly how much Barty-Moody would have taught the kids over the years, since he was the only one to really expose them to the magic that Death Eaters and Voldemort would actually use. I was so upset when he was revealed to be the villain.
we all knew Lupin would be number one and "Mad Eye" number two XD
it is interesting where you put lockheart though, honestly i usually put him under Quirrell, then again theyre kinda at the same level for me, and if i remember correctly, the book doesnt talk much about year 1 DADA, so Quirrell might have been doing a decent job
You know why Voldemort is better than Umbridge?
Because he's actually a likeable villain.
That likeable villain who will torture you so much that you wouldn't recognise yourself and straight up murder you!
Unlike Umbridge doesn't have guts to actually harm someone physically.
Which is weird, because Voldemort is literally wizard Hitler 2.0.
Philipizmo the thing with Umbridge is that she is banal evil- most of us have met someone like her- who gets off on control, and who is nasty and bigoted. Don’t forget- she was more than happy to head the Muggle Registration office- without being imperiused.
Voldemort, being basically a wizard Hitler is that evil that is far off- we’ve heard of it, but we don’t know it personally- not like we do with Umbridge.
@@katherinemorelle7115 Yes. She is has pure evilness in her soul. Even in the film portrayal was so good that I even hated her even more.
HE HE HE HE HE HE
Lupin isn't the only one on the train (at least in the book) Slughorn held a feast on the train with Ginny, Harry, Blaise, etc.
Thank-you, I was looking for this comment :D
I always wondered about the curse that no DAtDA teacher lasts more than one year because of Quirrel... I've just started listening to book 1 again and Hagrid speaks of Quirrel, outside the Leaky Cauldron, as if he has already been a teacher - "scared of his students" "scared of his own subject" - also implying that it's DAtDA that he already teaches.... any thoughts?
He was the Muggle Studies professor up until Harry’s first year
Snapes was incredible at potions and the defence against dark art as well. He was a worthy headmaster ❤️❤️❣️
6: Umbridge
5: Lockhart
4: Quirlle
3: Snape
2: Moody
1: Lupin!
Sierra Sonntag I completely agree.
I agree with this
Sierra Sonntag agreed so much
I agree as well. This is almost identical to the rankings in the list, except places 4 & 5 are swapped, and it makes more sense. Let's face it, Quirrell may have been a bad professor, but at least he knew what he was talking about, something that can't be said about Lockheart.
*Umbridge is placed last because, as said in the video, she actually went out of her way to make sure the students DON'T learn what she's supposed to teach them... Plus she tortured Harry almost as badly as the Dursleys did.
Erik o MAGnífico It wasn't even really Moody though.
Voldemort: "How did you escape my curse?"
Harry: "Your dude," *chuckles*
I DIED XD
😂😂😂
+
Lupin wasn't the only teacher on the train....I mean come on guys how many times have you reread the books??????
Slllluuuugggghhhooorrrrnnn
Snape is the best defense against the dark arts wizard of this list, idk about teacher.
Snape knew more curses when he arrived at school than half of the kids in seventh years. He understood them and made counter curses for them.He created his own dark magic and also made counter spells for those. And his knowledge as an adult, was so great that even Albus Dumbledore came to him for help on the subject multiple times. He also created a resistance potion to a curse invented and cast by Voldemort himself, keeping it at bay for an extraordinarily long time, given that it was such an extremely powerful curse. He brewed Mandrake Restorative Draught, which cured all victims of the Badilisk petrification which was described by dumbledore as “Dark Magic of the most advanced kind”. So powerful occlumency was so strong he kept Voldemort believing his loyalty for 17 years, Voldemort was considered the most powerful legilimence. His knowledge in healing was so great that Dumbledore once quoted to Harry that Snape was more experienced in healing against Dark magic than poppy pomfrey was. He also saved Katie bell form a cursed neck less.
For his teaching I would say: “His encyclopaedic understanding of the dark arts made so that Snape taught the class at N.E.W.T level to such an effect that even Harry Potter could not help but be enchanted by his knowledge.”
That’s something….
Ps. I just have to say the logic of “these spells were the most useful so the teachers who taught them are the best teachers is flawed to say the least. Just because it were the most useful for 1 person doesn’t mean it was useful for any of the other students.
nope, Lupin is the best
Slughorn also came to Hogwarts in the Hogwarts Express, not just Lupin.
yyyyyyyeeeeeeeesssssssssssss
For me it is
1. Lupin (Easy)
2.Snape (Always)
3. Barth Crouch Jr. (They ARE Illegal!)
4. Quirell (I mean Iguanas and dark arts! do they mix?)
5. Lockhart (at least the OTHER teachers except Umbridge teach them)
6. Umbridge (do I have to explain?)
Snape and Crouch should be switched Snape is a good person but not a good teacher and Crouch at least teaches them a lot
”Snape (always)” I see What you did there
I agree
Constant Vigilance!
Always 😭
Y'know, I've always thought Harry should've become Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher after Voldemort's death. Not immediately, of course, but like a few years after. We already see that he's really good at teaching Defense in his fifth year, and Hogwarts always felt like his home. Plus, I think it would have been really fun to see him do the boggart lesson in the same manner as Lupin and Dumbledore.