ध्रुव राठी जी आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद ,इतनी बेहतरीन मूवी अभी तक हमने देखी नहीं , देश के टीवी चैनलों को बार-बार सूर्यवंशम दिखाने से बेहतर है कि वे देश की और बेहतरीन मूवी को दिखाए।
Many thanks to Dhruv Rathi for recommending this beautiful piece of art. Now I can say, Amul is not only the Taste but also the Pride of India and one of the most important bone of our Indian economy.
I saw Manthan soon after it was released in theatres. I am not sure of the year but I was in college. It was the late-Seventies, a glorious decade for the Arts. When you are young, you are impressionable and full of idealism. I was impressed, not to say floored, by Manthan. Three things stuck in my mind. The first was Smita Patil. Of that genre of actress, of someone of her raw acting genius, where the line between acting and the real are blurred, there conceivably won't be another actress to grace Indian cinema. I became a lifelong devotee of Smita's cinema after Manthan . She left the world too soon. Number two was Naseeruddin Shah. What brilliance. And, finally, there was the dignity of Girish Karnad, loosely based on the great Dr Kurien. Mostly, I have been appalled revisiting the movies I liked in my youth. It is, therefore, with trepidation that I watched Manthan just now. I was pulled to it again by its restoration which was recently appreciated in Cannes. I must say the movie has stood the test of time. Smita still comes across as a force of nature. Naseer is very good. But I must appreciate the script of the remarkable Vijay Tendulkar which provides the backbone to this picture. The script is taut and pacy, it never wavers from its position that a cooperative is one of the grassroots instruments of a democratic society, and the end is fashioned to support this all-important truth. I am glad that the bulk of Manthan's present viewers are young. We need more of such cinema, and actresses and actors of the integrity and possessed of the talent of Smita Patil and Naseeruddin Shah.
मैं गुजरात से हूं और किसान परिवार के बीच मे बड़ा हुआ हूँ। अब तक मैंने यह फ़िल्म क्यों नही देखी थी? हर फिल्म की तरह श्याम बेनेगल की बेहतरीन फ़िल्म। स्मिता पाटिल,नसीरुद्दीन और गिरीश कन्नड़ का बेहतरीन अभिनय। लाजबाव गाना जो बीच बीच मे गूंजता रहता है।
How many of you came here directly by searching for this movie without any recommendations? I saw this movie when I was a kid and then I read the book "I too had a dream" by Verghese Kurien about a year back. So decided to revisit the movie again :)
I came here directly because I am Naseeruddin Shah's fan that's why now in my free time watching all his movies.Watched Paar movie loved it then watched Nishant movie and now I am here watching Manthan!!!
ध्रुव राठी जी आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद, बहुत ही बेहतरीन मूवी को आज हम 2022 में देख पा रहे हैं जिसमें भारत की 50 वर्ष पुरानी स्थिति को देखने और जानने का मौका मिला इस मूवी से।
Watching in 2022 1st time. How can i miss this masterpiece. What an excellent drama and acting of every actors. Nasaruddin shah's acting is just amazing. No words !
अमूल के फाउंडर श्री त्रिभुवनदास पटेल जी और श्री डॉ .वर्गीस क्यूरन के करे गए काम को गुजरात हमेशा याद रखेगा.और उनके विचारो को आगे बढ़ाएगा|| उन्हें मेरा शत शत प्रणाम||
May Dr Kurien be remembered always for his unmatchable vision, perseverance and the 50 odd years he dedicated for his country's self sustainability in the dairy sector. That's almost equivalent to freedom fighters grit ..... What a visionary he was! It was almost a single handed effort Thanks to Benegal for creating a movie showcasing the co-operative movement.
Today I knew about this movie while reading news paper of BBC that 5 lakhs farmers sponsored Rs.2 each for make this movie. Internationally appreciated this movie. I downloaded will watch in my travel time.
Me iss gaav k karib hi rahti hu or mene bachpan me ye movie dekhi thi iss me meri favourite Smita Patil hai or Naseeruddin Shah Girish Kannad kulbhushan or mere favourite villain Amrish Puri ji in sabhi ki behtarin aur umada adakari dekhane ko mili he aaj itane saalo baad movie dekhi to purane din yaad aa gaye Wah kya filme hua karti thi
I am from Gujarat, rajkot district I know very well of this co-operative dairy system.....and today it is in every village ...our farmers and I also a farmer, we have two income one is from farm and second is from milk..started this type of co-operative societies is very appreciated..I support it.👍
A legendary movie. It shows how much difficulties AMUL would have faced before standing up to become a Brand. It wasn't easy. AMUL just didn't rose as a company, standard of living of millions milk producers rose along. Amul is not just the taste of India, it's Pride of India. India needs several such societies in farming also.
By watching this movie, I got an idea of the lifestyle of my paternal grandparents, how they lived in India. I miss them terribly. And I have grown fond of visiting their villages. And I want to come to India. If Indians don't mind. Pray may Allah help me Ameen
What a movie. This shows how our nation is built upto what it is today. Loved this work. I bet 99.99% of movies made recently would never reach 0.01% of this masterpiece. Jai Hind Jai Bharat
@@dhirajsharma3227dhruv rathi is a youtuber who made a detailed vdo on the success story of AMUL.. He link and recommend this movie for better understanding😊
This is one of the greatest Indian movies I ever saw. The acting is very good, also the music is beautiful. I am sorry I cannot understand Hindi, but fortunately there is a copy on youtube with subtitles. Greetings from the Netherlands.
Mann mein ek udasi chha jaati hai, jab bhi iss film ko dekhti hu. Smita patil, Girish Karnad sahab, Naseruddin Sahb, Amrish Puri sagab, sab ek se badkar ek kalakaron ka kaam dekhne ko mila. Aur Sham Benegal sahab ki direction. Sabhi ko ye filmein dekhni chahiye. Acting, dialogue, directions, kitna natural hote thhe tab. Good old days.
ध्रुव राठी आज फेमस है जनता के बीच में। लेकिन उन्होंने जनता के इस दुख दर्द को दूर करने के लिए कौन सा कदम उठाया। सिर्फ अपना सोचना। यहीं तक सीमित है उनका जीवन।
मैं तो देखु तेरी बाट... बिंदु का दर्द दिल को झकझोर गया। भोला का पात्र भी दिल को छू गया। जिसको जीवन में कुछ करना है उसको यह फिल्म देखनी चाहिए। कार्य के प्रति समर्पण सीखने को मिलता है।
Bharat k ak se bdhkar ak kalakar hai isme meine bachpnme dekhi thi fir dekhi aise kalakar ak se bdhkar ak salute shyam benegal ji aur sabhi ko jinka is movie k liye apna yogdan diya hai smita patil girish karnad nag sir kamal k the naman hai inko
@@ShivkumarJhadr I was reading the novel( I too had a dream) at that time. So I don't remember about benefits going back but all farmers are kind of owners of amul so benefits from film don't much to farmers of ANAND.
@@ShivkumarJhadr you know these type of films are not for profit making rather message giving movies and at least these days people are watching meaningful films along with commercial crap so i doubt it would have made any profit but for sure the benefit of the message might have gone to the public that is why there was a white revolution in our country and not just the farmers but the whole country benefitted from that, now you need to judge which is a bigger and better benefit the film making profit and it reaching the farmers or this white revolution which has benefitted the nation and it is also well known and studied in international universities curriculum too.
Superb depiction of the struggle of Dr. V. Kurein, women empowerment, castism, debt trap, village politics........and all leads towards evolution of our AMUL...the taste of India. Picture could be made of even 4,5,10 hours. 2 hours is less to tell the story of AMUL. Salute to acting of Naseeruddin Shah, Amrish Puri, Mohan Agashe (first time seen him in young look), Kulbhushan Kharbanda and Mr. Girish Karnad. Song's lyrics are beautifully written.
I hv spend two years in anand . Loved the hospitality of the people . And yes came here after prashan dhawan sir's video though i hv read so many times about the movie for the cultural perspective but watched it for the first time
What a movie and the actors. "The Smita Patil" one and only.. btw she was the only actress in Bollywood never used glycerin in emotional scenes., Real acting, Real feeling, Real Tears. Superb..
I saw this movie first time at Regal Cinema in Delhi in 1977. I was really moved by this movie. I always thought weakest link in the movie was Amrish Puri as he used Punjabi or Haryanvi dialect in a movie with Gujarat as background. Priti Sagar’s song was a great hit and she sang on TV shows many times. Black & white TVs those days with only DD channel. Watched it after so many years and it still feels fresh!!
मंथन बहुत ही बेहतरीन फिल्म है जो उस समय के सामाजिक आर्थिक एवं सामाजिक ताने-बाने को अच्छी तरह से दिखाती है जबकि उस समय तानाशाही जोर जुल्म और जातिगत विद्वेश अपने चरम पर होता था फिर भी श्याम बेनेगल साहब ने इतनी बेहतरीन दुध क्रान्ति पर फिल्म बनाई उनको कोटि-कोटि प्रणाम
What a wonderful film. I have seen it more than 100 times while growing on the NDDB campus in Anand. Was at the premier in Anand in 1977 I think it was and now saw it again after 35 years or so. Everyone in the film is outstanding. Amazing Smita Patil, perfect Girish Karnad, tenacious Naseeruddin, mean Amrish Puri and cool Kulbhushan Kharbanda.
जीवन में एक बार अवश्य देखें |भारतीय सिनेमा के इतिहास में एक महान उद्देश्य के साथ बनी एक बेहतरीन फिल्म ,इन सहकारी सहयोग ,एकता के दम पर ही भारत में आज दूध का उत्पादन विश्वस्तर पर पहले पायदान पहुँच गया हैं | आज कितनी समस्याओं को पार पा कर यह मुकाम हासिल हुआ है | My grate salute to Shayam Benegal ji's and his all team members for this great real film which deals almost all major social issues. Best movie of all which shows us the real pictures of rural indian societies. It also shows that unity is strength.must watch this great work and great actor's acting.
हकीकत में ऐसा महसूस नही हो रहा है कि इसमें कोई कलाकार काम कर रहे हैं। बिल्कुल ऐसा लग रहा था कि किसी साधनहीन साधारण से गांव की सामान्य दिनचर्या को फिल्मकांन करके प्रस्तुत कर दिया हो। श्याम बेनेगल जी का बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद।
Beautiful film. I had only heard the name but never saw the film until now. What a true depiction of village life in India. The great actors like Nasiruddin Shah ji, Annant Nag ji, Girish Karnad ji, Smita Patil ji, Kulbhushan Kharbanda ji, Amrish Puri ji, make this film memorable. Thank you so much for this film.
My father is retired from milk cooperatives...he did the same job as Girish Karnaad did in this film back then in 80s 😊😊😊...with these efforts now india is the highest milk producer in the world...intersting to note that milk value ( 200 MT / year) is greater than the combined value of Rice (115 MT) and Wheat ( 100MT) in india 😊😊😊...with no loan waiver...no no free electricity...no overexploitation of ground water 😊😊😊😊
I watched movie today on 3 November 2020 and I realized how was the life of people in the past which we use to hear. I am from rajasthan and still remember we use to live like this everything was perfect except discrimination. I hope people will know their reality.
Bapre itni zabardast movie maine aajtk nahi dekhi.... What a acting by smita patil. And Girush karnad ji.... Superb..... Smita's way of looking 47:49 at Girish karnad ji was superb...her face smile.,her love..her inner happiness Oh my god... Amazing , awesome... Zindgi bn gayi ye movie..aur ye movie mere dimag me ghumti rhti he...wow..😍😍😘😘
Thanks dhruwa Rathi for recommending for the movie. I left India for higher studies abroad and settled in the USA. Prior to departing India, I used to use Amul butter. WA, USA.
Everyone here is thanking Dhruv Rathi, But I thank my father who recommended this movie to me since childhood. He first watched it during 80s when he visited Anand, Gujrat and it left lasting impact on him. He used to work for NDDB.
Great movie. Salute Shri. Thrbhuvandas Patel,Dr.Varghese Kurian and director Shyam Benegal sir .❤❤❤❤. We as a nation has moved ahead.But the movie reminds us that a lot is yet to be achieved. There are still many backward villages and communities in India especially in the tribal sector. We can achieve development only if we think like one people one nation. I love India.❤❤❤❤
2:2:25 in the background bird's humming reminds me the way to primary school class in the morning lonely passing through the grassland cropfield the same sound coming from the trees aside lovely village times of early 90s..
ध्रुव राठी जी आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद ,इतनी बेहतरीन मूवी अभी तक हमने देखी नहीं , देश के टीवी चैनलों को बार-बार सूर्यवंशम दिखाने से बेहतर है कि वे देश की और बेहतरीन मूवी को दिखाए।
তার কোন আলোচনায় এই ছবির উল্লেখ ছিলো? আমি ত ইদানীংয়ের একটা আলোচনায় জানলাম, আগের কোন ভিডিও তে উল্লেখ আছে জানতে পারলে উপকার হয়
Many thanks to Dhruv Rathi for recommending this beautiful piece of art.
Now I can say, Amul is not only the Taste but also the Pride of India and one of the most important bone of our Indian economy.
Same bro 🤜 ❤❤😍😍
Dhruv sent me here
I am Pakistani but I also love indian people like Dhruv rathee
Same bro
I also came here after Dhruv`s recommendation
ध्रुव राठी का बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद जिन्होंने इस फिल्म से हम सभी को अवगत कराया l धन्यवाद Dhruv Rathee ❣️🇮🇳
कही इसमें भी हिंदू को बुरा तो नहीं दिखाया गया है तभी ध्रुव राठी साले ने बोला होगा ये देखने को
Yes
Yo
તમે પણ મારી જેમ ધ્રુવ રાઠી ના વિડિયો જોયા પસી આ મુવી જોવા આવ્યા છો 🙏👌
Who is Dhruv Rathee?
I saw Manthan soon after it was released in theatres. I am not sure of the year but I was in college. It was the late-Seventies, a glorious decade for the Arts. When you are young, you are impressionable and full of idealism. I was impressed, not to say floored, by Manthan. Three things stuck in my mind. The first was Smita Patil. Of that genre of actress, of someone of her raw acting genius, where the line between acting and the real are blurred, there conceivably won't be another actress to grace Indian cinema. I became a lifelong devotee of Smita's cinema after Manthan . She left the world too soon. Number two was Naseeruddin Shah. What brilliance. And, finally, there was the dignity of Girish Karnad, loosely based on the great Dr Kurien. Mostly, I have been appalled revisiting the movies I liked in my youth. It is, therefore, with trepidation that I watched Manthan just now. I was pulled to it again by its restoration which was recently appreciated in Cannes. I must say the movie has stood the test of time. Smita still comes across as a force of nature. Naseer is very good. But I must appreciate the script of the remarkable Vijay Tendulkar which provides the backbone to this picture. The script is taut and pacy, it never wavers from its position that a cooperative is one of the grassroots instruments of a democratic society, and the end is fashioned to support this all-important truth. I am glad that the bulk of Manthan's present viewers are young. We need more of such cinema, and actresses and actors of the integrity and possessed of the talent of Smita Patil and Naseeruddin Shah.
Very well said.. 👍👍
Thanks dhruwa Rathi for recommending for the movie
Love the music & everything ❤️
I miss my village 😭
Bhai Dhruv Rathi ne to aaj video upload ki...to ye 5 month pehle kaise keh rhe ho?
@@irexxjr.2127 Wahi na yr 🥺
@@irexxjr.2127 same question
How is this possible bro...? Confusion ho rhi
??
I am here......
After watching world affair
धन्यवाद आचार्य प्रशांत धवन जी
LOL many people came from there
मैं गुजरात से हूं और किसान परिवार के बीच मे बड़ा हुआ हूँ। अब तक मैंने यह फ़िल्म क्यों नही देखी थी? हर फिल्म की तरह श्याम बेनेगल की बेहतरीन फ़िल्म। स्मिता पाटिल,नसीरुद्दीन और गिरीश कन्नड़ का बेहतरीन अभिनय। लाजबाव गाना जो बीच बीच मे गूंजता रहता है।
क्योकी यह सिनेमा कमाई उद्देश से नही बनाई गई और ना ही ये मसाला छाप सिनेमा है
Amrish puri ne bhuli gaya
@@amitvaghela879 और मोहन आगाशे को भी भूल गए
पता है ना मोहन अघाशे कौन है
How many of you came here directly by searching for this movie without any recommendations? I saw this movie when I was a kid and then I read the book "I too had a dream" by Verghese Kurien about a year back. So decided to revisit the movie again :)
I came here directly because I am Naseeruddin Shah's fan that's why now in my free time watching all his movies.Watched Paar movie loved it then watched Nishant movie and now I am here watching Manthan!!!
ध्रुव राठी जी आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद, बहुत ही बेहतरीन मूवी को आज हम 2022 में देख पा रहे हैं जिसमें भारत की 50 वर्ष पुरानी स्थिति को देखने और जानने का मौका मिला इस मूवी से।
Me bhi
50 वर्ष पुराने समाज को समझने के साथ साथ एक नई सोच केसे विकसित की जा सकती है।
Sulerb
Watching in 2022 1st time. How can i miss this masterpiece. What an excellent drama and acting of every actors. Nasaruddin shah's acting is just amazing. No words !
I am going to watch on the basis of your comment
let's see
Right
@@gaytrigaytri9514 whats your opinion
@@shahid7443 yes it is really a master piece
Actually I fell in love with Girish Karnad
Not only drama it's riyal fackt
अमूल के फाउंडर श्री त्रिभुवनदास पटेल जी और श्री डॉ .वर्गीस क्यूरन के करे गए काम को गुजरात हमेशा याद रखेगा.और उनके विचारो को आगे बढ़ाएगा|| उन्हें मेरा शत शत प्रणाम||
Right
I'm from AP. Watched several times. Legends on screen touching the hearts and real life of Gujarat rural.
ध्रुव राठी बहुत ही बेस्ट मूवी को देखे आपकी वजह से , हमे जाति से उपर उठना होगा लेकिन एक दूसरे को जलाकर नही समझ कर आगे बढ़ना होगा
डा. वर्गीज कुरियन व श्याम बेनेगल ने इस मूवी कि कहानी लिखी है, अगर वर्तमान में आप युवा होकर इसे देखना पसंद करते हैं, तो यकिनन आप बहतरीन युवा है
kya yah story real nahi hai?
@TheAryavrata I think it must be real ....but this is not a single story, this must be a compilation of many real stories....
May Dr Kurien be remembered always for his unmatchable vision, perseverance and the 50 odd years he dedicated for his country's self sustainability in the dairy sector. That's almost equivalent to freedom fighters grit ..... What a visionary he was! It was almost a single handed effort
Thanks to Benegal for creating a movie showcasing the co-operative movement.
Really Dr. Verghese Kurien sir achieved his dream. I too had a dream
बहुत ही शानदार फिल्म है। स्मिता पाटिल को सादर नमन, शानदार अभिनय।
I am here....
After watching world affairs
Thanks Prashant Dhawan sir
Me also
Me bhi 😂😆
I also 🤟
I also 🤟
Me too
Smita Patil was not an ordinary actress, this woman alone was an entire university of acting. She looks more real than the real. Hats off!
Ji
No wasnt, she is overrated
@@heersaleti849 really.
My ALL TIME FAVOURITE NO ONE CAN TOOK HER PLACE BEAUTY 🤗
Hlo kudiye
ऐसी फिल्में समय समय पर आती रहनी चाहिए, ये काफी प्रेरणास्पद होती हैं.!
किसान विरोधी मोदी मुर्दाबाद मुर्दाबाद
@@AvinashKumar-qg2nv lavde.....is sal se pehle kisaan Ferrari me ghumte the ???
@@Content_Chor14 bhasha insaan ke bare me kafi kuch bata deti hai
@@nitishsaxena1372 isiliye to pankaj tripathi sabke hero banke baithe hain...philosophy ka lesson side rakhiye...
@@Content_Chor14 आप अंडभक्त हैं।
Today I knew about this movie while reading news paper of BBC that 5 lakhs farmers sponsored Rs.2 each for make this movie. Internationally appreciated this movie. I downloaded will watch in my travel time.
Finally watched so nice movie... it exposed the Indian society which is built on castiesm.
here after.....PD10...smjhe to batao
Dhawan sir
Dhavan sir
Prashant dhawan
Prasant Dhawan sir army rocks 😁😁
My fv.
Amul is not only Taste of India but also the Pride of India 🙏
Hi
World Affairs
Ha bhai 🔥🇮🇳❤
Nandini is best milke in Karnataka
@@Quality-hindille 😂
अब ऐसी फिल्में नहीं बनती बहुत ही बेहतरीन फिल्म और आज की जनरेशन के लिए प्रेरणादायक जय हिंद
जीवन संघर्षमय हैं।
यथार्थ
Me iss gaav k karib hi rahti hu or mene bachpan me ye movie dekhi thi iss me meri favourite Smita Patil hai or Naseeruddin Shah Girish Kannad kulbhushan or mere favourite villain Amrish Puri ji in sabhi ki behtarin aur umada adakari dekhane ko mili he aaj itane saalo baad movie dekhi to purane din yaad aa gaye Wah kya filme hua karti thi
From 🇧🇩. This movie portrayed the diligence of villagers. Truly an epic one. Heart touched hindi cinema had ever made.
Love from India..
I am from Gujarat, rajkot district I know very well of this co-operative dairy system.....and today it is in every village ...our farmers and I also a farmer, we have two income one is from farm and second is from milk..started this type of co-operative societies is very appreciated..I support it.👍
Good to see your comment
Namaste bhai..
With love and respects from kerala..
@@SivaKumar-ze3eo namaste🙏🙏bhai
Such a great inspiration
Still have this kind of cooperative society there ?
A legendary movie. It shows how much difficulties AMUL would have faced before standing up to become a Brand. It wasn't easy. AMUL just didn't rose as a company, standard of living of millions milk producers rose along. Amul is not just the taste of India, it's Pride of India. India needs several such societies in farming also.
V have Verka in Punjab
But now amul change into profit business only
Who Dhruv Rathi? This movie depicts Dr. Kurein's work, he is father of White Revolution in India.
By watching this movie, I got an idea of the lifestyle of my paternal grandparents, how they lived in India. I miss them terribly. And I have grown fond of visiting their villages. And I want to come to India. If Indians don't mind. Pray may Allah help me Ameen
You are most welcome bro! ❤
What a movie.
This shows how our nation is built upto what it is today.
Loved this work.
I bet 99.99% of movies made recently would never reach 0.01% of this masterpiece.
Jai Hind
Jai Bharat
Of course,no doubt. Even i am 22 years old and find peace by watching these old classics.✨✨♥️
Who Dhruv Rathi? This movie depicts Dr. Kurein's work, he is father of White Revolution in India.
@@dhirajsharma3227dhruv rathi is a youtuber who made a detailed vdo on the success story of AMUL.. He link and recommend this movie for better understanding😊
This is one of the greatest Indian movies I ever saw. The acting is very good, also the music is beautiful. I am sorry I cannot understand Hindi, but fortunately there is a copy on youtube with subtitles. Greetings from the Netherlands.
🤗🤗🤗
😚😚😚
You should watch Satyajit Ray's Film to understand the quality of Indian movies
Great music by vanraj bhatia
❤️❤️
This is called a perfect movie. Consist social democracy, economic development, self reliant, Awareness.
Ga,
Cg.
V
And Bad politics
Bhai, religious angle nahi ha, iskay liay flop hi hogi.
agar baat burri lagi to sorry.
@@Shoaib_Khan85 Ache comment me ghatiya mazhab aapne ghusa hi diya..
Mann mein ek udasi chha jaati hai, jab bhi iss film ko dekhti hu. Smita patil, Girish Karnad sahab, Naseruddin Sahb, Amrish Puri sagab, sab ek se badkar ek kalakaron ka kaam dekhne ko mila. Aur Sham Benegal sahab ki direction. Sabhi ko ye filmein dekhni chahiye. Acting, dialogue, directions, kitna natural hote thhe tab. Good old days.
अगर जातिवाद जैसी समस्या देश में ना होती तो भारत विश्व में सबसे अग्रणी होता
Right
Right
True
Or reservation Na hota to
@@beingcyrus6821 pehle reservation aaya ya jativad aaya???
जब कोई रोग आया है तो दवाई भी तो आएगी
I am an MBA student of India's first Cooperative University which is in Assam. Our Dean Rashida ma'am suggested to watch this movie and i loved it.
🙂And I am journalism student. We were asked to write review of Manthan, Ankur, Sooraj Ka Satva Ghoda and Bhumika
What uni?
Which uni?
@@WhatEver-yj5rg good
@@sunandatalukdar4971 hlo mam...
इसे कहते है काम। बेहतरीन सिनेमा । श्याम बेनेगल का शानदार प्रयास
I agree with you 👍
Quality content
Watch MAMMO too....
Mishra is villan in this film... hahaha
Yes
ध्रुव राठी आज फेमस है जनता के बीच में। लेकिन उन्होंने जनता के इस दुख दर्द को दूर करने के लिए कौन सा कदम उठाया। सिर्फ अपना सोचना। यहीं तक सीमित है उनका जीवन।
मैं तो देखु तेरी बाट...
बिंदु का दर्द दिल को झकझोर गया।
भोला का पात्र भी दिल को छू गया।
जिसको जीवन में कुछ करना है उसको यह फिल्म देखनी चाहिए। कार्य के प्रति समर्पण सीखने को मिलता है।
came to see this legendary film after watching Druv rathees video !! thanks Druv Rathee !!
Now this movie will reach 5 million soon because of Prashant Dhawan Sir.😍😍😍😍
Yes and me too .. 😂
Bhai prashant dhawan ka khud 5 million view nahi aata....
By the way i am also a big fan of PD sir...
@@krishnasao2550 are नहीं भाई dekho sir बहुत aage nikal chuke h
Iiiiiii]i]]i]i]
Great movie without any background music and without any useless songs
👍❤️🇵🇰
If you are watching this, then you have a good taste in movies ❤️
I belongs to this generation but i literally want those days, movies, songs back
A masterpiece.
Being a dairy technologist I could relate to this so much.
It just brought tears in my eyes.
Are u dairy technologists??? Where??
@@muskanansari9869 Yess
From West Bengal
SAME HERE BRO!!!😭🥺
Can I have a job?
Same bro 😭
Bharat k ak se bdhkar ak kalakar hai isme meine bachpnme dekhi thi fir dekhi aise kalakar ak se bdhkar ak salute shyam benegal ji aur sabhi ko jinka is movie k liye apna yogdan diya hai smita patil girish karnad nag sir kamal k the naman hai inko
इस फिल्म ने आखिरी 1 मिनट तक मेरे को बांध के रखा और क्लाइमेक्स देख के आंखों से आंसू आ गए।
Hats off to shyam benegal.
so "A lot to know A lot to discuss "❤👍 it's enough for recognise him 🙏
Fun fact: This movie was produced by CROWDFUNDING! Five lakh farmers from Gujarat donated 2 Rs. each for this film! True to the theme of this movie!
10 lakh farmers contributed 1 re each which was the budget of film
@@prashant6621 Did the benefits go back to them?
@@ShivkumarJhadr I was reading the novel( I too had a dream) at that time. So I don't remember about benefits going back but all farmers are kind of owners of amul so benefits from film don't much to farmers of ANAND.
@@prashant6621 where were you back then? you've witnessed this revolution?
@@ShivkumarJhadr you know these type of films are not for profit making rather message giving movies and at least these days people are watching meaningful films along with commercial crap so i doubt it would have made any profit but for sure the benefit of the message might have gone to the public that is why there was a white revolution in our country and not just the farmers but the whole country benefitted from that, now you need to judge which is a bigger and better benefit the film making profit and it reaching the farmers or this white revolution which has benefitted the nation and it is also well known and studied in international universities curriculum too.
Because of you Prashant Dhawan sir..apka do saal ka video dekh ke aya dekhne movies
I am here after Prashant Dhavan sir's video
Amul : The Pride Of India
After watching world affairs.
Legend prasant dhawan sir 👆👆
Superb depiction of the struggle of Dr. V. Kurein, women empowerment, castism, debt trap, village politics........and all leads towards evolution of our AMUL...the taste of India. Picture could be made of even 4,5,10 hours. 2 hours is less to tell the story of AMUL. Salute to acting of Naseeruddin Shah, Amrish Puri, Mohan Agashe (first time seen him in young look), Kulbhushan Kharbanda and Mr. Girish Karnad. Song's lyrics are beautifully written.
U forgot samita patil
good Movie..
Watch dhruv rathee
अन् बान शान महाराष्ट्र
शेरणी की झलक सबसे अलग की स्मिता पाटील साहेब.. श्री नसरुद्दीन शाह साहेब...
समाज की जागृति के लिए इस तरह की फिल्में बनना चाहिए
Bilkul shi kha apne ji...
I hv spend two years in anand . Loved the hospitality of the people . And yes came here after prashan dhawan sir's video though i hv read so many times about the movie for the cultural perspective but watched it for the first time
Hope many one came after World Affair “Prashant Sir”.
Amul :- The taste of India.
Yes
Yes
Amul:- the pride of India
Ye hai humara pyaara Bharat🧡
The pride of India
Fine piece of art. Awesome actors. Respect from Pakistan
I am here after prashant dhawan
Ye hai hmara pyara bharat
Amul the taste of india
Amul the pride of india
What a movie and the actors. "The Smita Patil" one and only.. btw she was the only actress in Bollywood never used glycerin in emotional scenes., Real acting, Real feeling, Real Tears. Superb..
smita patil and sanjeev kumar have no match on this planet
Great movie every proud Indian should watch it once in a lifetime and share it with atleast to one person.
I saw this movie first time at Regal Cinema in Delhi in 1977. I was really moved by this movie. I always thought weakest link in the movie was Amrish Puri as he used Punjabi or Haryanvi dialect in a movie with Gujarat as background. Priti Sagar’s song was a great hit and she sang on TV shows many times. Black & white TVs those days with only DD channel. Watched it after so many years and it still feels fresh!!
मंथन बहुत ही बेहतरीन फिल्म है जो उस समय के सामाजिक आर्थिक एवं सामाजिक ताने-बाने को अच्छी तरह से दिखाती है जबकि उस समय तानाशाही जोर जुल्म और जातिगत विद्वेश अपने चरम पर होता था फिर भी श्याम बेनेगल साहब ने इतनी बेहतरीन दुध क्रान्ति पर फिल्म बनाई उनको कोटि-कोटि प्रणाम
Are you ok , what is us samsy go to Google and see today's samsy . what is happening with poor in india
Right
What a wonderful film. I have seen it more than 100 times while growing on the NDDB campus in Anand. Was at the premier in Anand in 1977 I think it was and now saw it again after 35 years or so. Everyone in the film is outstanding. Amazing Smita Patil, perfect Girish Karnad, tenacious Naseeruddin, mean Amrish Puri and cool Kulbhushan Kharbanda.
जीवन में एक बार अवश्य देखें |भारतीय सिनेमा के इतिहास में एक महान उद्देश्य के साथ बनी एक बेहतरीन फिल्म ,इन सहकारी सहयोग ,एकता के दम पर ही भारत में आज दूध का उत्पादन विश्वस्तर पर पहले पायदान पहुँच गया हैं | आज कितनी समस्याओं को पार पा कर यह मुकाम हासिल हुआ है | My grate salute to Shayam Benegal ji's and his all team members for this great real film which deals almost all major social issues. Best movie of all which shows us the real pictures of rural indian societies. It also shows that unity is strength.must watch this great work and great actor's acting.
हकीकत में ऐसा महसूस नही हो रहा है कि इसमें कोई कलाकार काम कर रहे हैं। बिल्कुल ऐसा लग रहा था कि किसी साधनहीन साधारण से गांव की सामान्य दिनचर्या को फिल्मकांन करके प्रस्तुत कर दिया हो।
श्याम बेनेगल जी का बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद।
Thank you Dhruv, for recommending this master piece, and sharing the video. I love this one.
Love from Maldives ❤️🇲🇻
It's amazing how all the Islamists from around the world are fans of Dhruv Rathee. The same Rathee who goes to the BBC to degrade his own nation.
I watched this movie in doordarshan now I relive that era ,very inspiring movie ,Thanks druv rathee for inspire me in right direction.
शानदार अद्भुत ईसे कहते हैं फिल्म, लाखों में एक उम्दा, बेहतरीन फिल्म।
ग्रामव्यवस्था का इतना सुंदर चित्रण आपको कही नही मिलेगा. Hat's off Shyam Benegal ji. N off course..Dhruv Rathiji. ❤❤❤❤
What an actress smita patil ji..real n superb..salute to her.
Beautiful film. I had only heard the name but never saw the film until now. What a true depiction of village life in India. The great actors like Nasiruddin Shah ji, Annant Nag ji, Girish Karnad ji, Smita Patil ji, Kulbhushan Kharbanda ji, Amrish Puri ji, make this film memorable. Thank you so much for this film.
My father is retired from milk cooperatives...he did the same job as Girish Karnaad did in this film back then in 80s 😊😊😊...with these efforts now india is the highest milk producer in the world...intersting to note that milk value ( 200 MT / year) is greater than the combined value of Rice (115 MT) and Wheat ( 100MT) in india 😊😊😊...with no loan waiver...no no free electricity...no overexploitation of ground water 😊😊😊😊
My dad was in NDDB and worked with Dr. Kurdish on this project
And it is very expensive, business, u see.. 😉
Naveen sir ke bolne pr main bhi dekhne aayi hm 🤗🙏
Sir Naveen sir koune actor he kya
I watched movie today on 3 November 2020 and I realized how was the life of people in the past which we use to hear. I am from rajasthan and still remember we use to live like this everything was perfect except discrimination. I hope people will know their reality.
Bapre itni zabardast movie maine aajtk nahi dekhi.... What a acting by smita patil. And Girush karnad ji.... Superb..... Smita's way of looking 47:49 at Girish karnad ji was superb...her face smile.,her love..her inner happiness Oh my god... Amazing , awesome... Zindgi bn gayi ye movie..aur ye movie mere dimag me ghumti rhti he...wow..😍😍😘😘
I came here after Druv Rathee's analysis thanks 👍
Wow Naseer uddin acting is mind blowing.
Thanks dhruwa Rathi for recommending for the movie. I left India for higher studies abroad and settled in the USA. Prior to departing India, I used to use Amul butter. WA, USA.
Fantastic movie... a lesson for everyone who is suffering from poverty
The song is too melodious. Love it.
*AMUL* The taste of India and also *"Pride of India"* 👍👌
Shyam Benegal sir team Shabana,Smita, Nasiruddin, kulbhushan, Amrish Puri, Anant Naag, , Mohan Agashe, Girish Kannard. Best work as usual
🥰 Thank you so much Dhruve Rathee sir 🙏
For telling us a inspiring story and recommend a great movie. 😍
Your chocolate boy Dhruv Rathee is an anti national bastard who lives off on money of Congress and anti India foundations like of George Soros.
What a film !!
Excellent actors and great performances
Amul lover ... From Bangladesh... Best movie... Thanks a ton for actors cast and crews....
Everyone here is thanking Dhruv Rathi, But I thank my father who recommended this movie to me since childhood. He first watched it during 80s when he visited Anand, Gujrat and it left lasting impact on him. He used to work for NDDB.
हम मेहनत कश जग वालों से जब अपना हिस्सा मांगेंगे
इक खेत नहीं, इक देश नहीं, हम सारी दुनिया मांगेंगे - - - फैज़
Samyavad to fail ho chuka hai sari duniya me ?
@@brijbhushantyagi4456 Ji,
तभी आज के इस भयावह समय में बाजार वाद ₹37कीमत के N 95 मास्क के ₹300 वसूल रहा था।
बम और ग्रेनेड लेकर ही हिस्सा मांगेंगे या आत्मघाती हमला करके मियाँ
What an incredible movie👌. Awesome acting by Girish Karnad, Smita Patil, Naseeruddin Shah, Kulbhushan Kharbanda
one of the best movie of 70s also won Filmfare award in many category
Great movie. Salute Shri. Thrbhuvandas Patel,Dr.Varghese Kurian and director Shyam Benegal sir .❤❤❤❤. We as a nation has moved ahead.But the movie reminds us that a lot is yet to be achieved. There are still many backward villages and communities in India especially in the tribal sector. We can achieve development only if we think like one people one nation. I love India.❤❤❤❤
Samita patil is gem😍😍, her acting is real, natural actor and amrish puri,(oh my god), both have acted so well 👌🏻👌🏻
Today we have lost the exceptional actor- Girish Karnad ji. May the legend rest in peace.
A great actor and an urban naxalite too.....
Great urban naxal.
Mishra = Modi
,
Great actor in India
Here after dhurv rahtee
Jai jawan jai kishan 🇮🇳🇮🇳
अफसोस तो इस बात का हैं कि आजादी के इतने साल बाद भी स्थितियां कोई बहुत ज्यादा नहीं बदली है
amul is the best example that show how to make big dreams comes true.thanks Verghese sir.hand of you.
yogesh ramgude
Thanks morarji Desai and Tribhuvan bhai Patel .
nice movie😚😚😚😚😚😚
bjp aaje sarpanch jevu kam kari rahi chhe cooperative ma
With out vargese kuriyan.. from kerala, .. this amul would not have come up. Vagese kurian.. I salute you
This movie has so many versatile actors ❤️👍🏼
Best plot, best actors,best music,best film .Oscar award is nothing for this movie.
परदेश में अमूल के product देखकर भारतीय होने का बहुत गर्व होता है।
जय हिन्द 🇮🇳
Great memories smita patil was amazing actress I missing her a lot
2:2:25 in the background bird's humming reminds me the way to primary school class in the morning lonely passing through the grassland cropfield the same sound coming from the trees aside lovely village times of early 90s..
Such movies should be made every now and then.. Very nice movie. India's reality is shown in this one movie. Thanks to AMUL
अब भाई सब लोग आ ही गए हैं नवीन सर के कहने से तो एक बार जयकारा हो जाए नवीन सर जिंदाबाद RWA जिंदाबाद 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏