The fact of the Sino Japanese war from 1931 to 1945: many people believe that at that time China had only the Communist Party and the Kuomintang, so there were only two colors of China on the map. But the fact is that China was very chaotic at that time. There are many large-scale internal wars. After about a decade of super chaotic civil war, most troops, all heavy weapons, bullets and artillery shells were used to fight the civil war. For example, during the Chinese civil war in 1931, the Kuomintang deployed onemillion troops to destroy the Chinese Communist Party. At this time, it is difficult to resist a well prepared Japan.
It is not Really, The Chinese Signed an Unease Treaty Forming the United Chinese Front (Which was Temporary and not Even a Political Power), Well They show here The True Warlord Era Over the Sino Japanese War is Not that Complicated and Chaotic, One things is set on their mind, Take down The Japanese.
@@AaronIsCool450 You know too little. The United Front was established in 1937 (only the Kuomintang and the Communist Party, China's Mongolia and Tibet, and some warlords did not participate). In 1931, Japan invaded China for the first time (occupied Northeast China). At that time, China was already very chaotic. There are more than ten major warlords, including the Kuomintang, the Communist Party, Sichuan, Mongolia, Tibet, Fujian and Hubei. They all control tens of millions of people and hundreds of thousands of square kilometers of land. They vied with each other for territory and population. Therefore, the Chinese people do not care about Japan's invasion of Northeast China. The second Japanese invasion of China was in 1937. At that time, China was going through a civil war between the Kuomintang and the Communist Party, which had lasted for ten years. Both sides were exhausted. A large number of outstanding troops and generals disappeared in the civil war, a large number of people died, and the weapons and ammunition of both sides were exhausted. At this time, Japan invaded China, and China could not resist. Therefore, Japan easily occupied the Hebei Henan plain and won the Shanghai battle. Therefore, when we look at the Sino Japanese War, we should not think that China's combat capability is very weak, because before the Sino Japanese War, China had experienced about 22 years of internal war from 1915 to 1937。
@@老老实实挣大钱 since 1840 china was easily bullied by other countries. since xinhai revolution china became chaotic. that's why chinese national anthem says build our new great wall with blood and flesh, and chinese people face their greatest peril.
Yeah especially now with the PRC threatening the west, it’s definitely worth studying China’s history to know what lead to the rise of communism in China
Very detailed and informative video. However, there are still some mistakes. 1. There are two major Muslim rebellions in 1850-70s instead of one. One is Panthay Rebellion in Yunnan, and the other is Dungan Revolt in Shaanxi and Gansu in 1862-1877. The map showed the rebellion in Shaanxi, but didn't use the right name. 2. The location of Kouang-Tchéou-Wan was on the east side of the Leizhou Peninsula, which is today's Zhanjiang City. The location on the map is too east. 3. There were many changes of province borders after the founding of PRC, including Jiangsu & Anhui border, Anhui & Jiangxi border, Guangdong & Guangxi border, etc., which is not showed on the map. In 1969-1979, the eastern border of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region was also different from the current one. 4. Sino-Indian War of 1962. After 1947, India claimed the sovereinity of Aksai Chin, which is beyond the Macartney-Macdonald Line of India-China border. In this war, China got back the control of Aksai Chin, as well as the Arunachal Pradesh, but gave up Arunachal in the coming winter.
India has Still Control over Mc carthy Lines but we Belive Actually Border is Johnsan Line which is present day Aksai chin sorry i know this Areas are chinese but Due to Politics we Are Doing Expansionism Because in our Religon More Territory Means More Power☠️ Thinking Of Tsarist Russia wanted Dreams of Greater India Sorry Chinese Brothers I understand your Feelings
as a Chinese, I would say this video is from neutral stance and is really amazing. I can image how long it will take for a foreigner to make it. Great and thanks.
@NanamiNishijou it's like saying, as a German, I don't see a history of the American Civil War as made from a neutral stance because they put a Confederate song in it their not supporting ether side with placing a Era correct song in that Era
For years, believe me, for years I've been searching for a video showing the evolution of the political subdividion of China, and suddenly I found this video. Thanks a lot. New suscriber. 👍👍👍
I really thought “wouldn’t it be funny if that 1 Mao Zedong song played during his rule? Nah this is a serious video.” And then that 1 Mao Zedong song played during his rule. Lovely.
The song played in that part is kinda weird. Mao-era songs didn't sound like that at all. I don't think there is any song better than 'The East is Red'(东方红) to represent Mao-era.
Exactly, it's unfortunate but 90% of the best channels, in terms of dedication and quality, are under the shadow and are little known compared to others. It's unfortunate but that's the way the market is, we have to respect and continue working hard to reverse this situation.
What people need to remember is that for the entire time that Chiang Kai-Shek ruled the RoC, it was at best a corrupt oligarchy, and eventually just became an outright dictatorship that oppressed the native Taiwanese.
Until they changed to a democracy in the 80’s. Also there are benevolent dictatorships, and ChiangKai Shek wasn’t one, but his successor (in terms of leaders) was.
also, another fun fact was that even though chiang was not corruption, his wife soong mei ling and her siblings were extremely corrupt. they were extremely filthy rich. that was how bad the corruption was.. even the american president at time time bitched about chiang.
I agree with you. We never wanted to be ruled by the ROC (Rubbish of China). The current situation now is a lot of people who support Kuomintang are also supporting, or hoping that the CCP take over Taiwan. This means that the real Taiwanese people (people who love and respect Taiwan) are now fighting against both CCP and ROC (Kuomintang).
The fact that those words below "Emperor:" of Great Qing are not the name of emperors but the reign title. Reign title; name Xianfeng(咸豐); Yi-Zhu(奕詝) Tongzhi(同治); Zai-Chun(載淳) Guangxu(光緒); Zai-Tian(載湉) Xuantong(宣統); Pu-Yi(溥儀)
非常感谢作者制作了如此优秀的视频，视频里涉及的所有时期的中国版图都是正确的，这是对中国这个国家、对历史最好的尊重！！！辛苦了，你的努力和用心值得大家的尊重 江海滔滔，山岳高崇，中华自古为世之雄！ 祝愿我亲爱的祖国永远繁荣昌盛 May my dear motherland be prosperous forever 🙏🙏🙏
Its nice hearing the Chinese Victory Song From World War 2,I Listened to both defend the yellow river and Victory Song,Which The Song sounds Very Beautiful.
I gotta say, I only knew surface-level 20th century history about China, particularly WW2 and a little bit about the Sino-Soviet split later on. However, I ended up taking two semesters of Chinese history at university covering 1890 to 2010 pretty in-depth, and I gotta say, Chinese history is really fucking interesting.
@@emdeelabbeautypreneur Taiwan and mainland china are both countries, doesn't matter if you disagree, they both have sovereign governments which make them countries
You don't have to spend much time on those dog barking period. Those warlords were all shit. Only Communism Party of China saved the country and the race. Meanwhile KMT was the evil submissive presenter of the imperialists.
Without the Russians, British, French, and the Japanese labeled with color, it gets a little confusing... There's the second opium war, the Russian invasions in the North and Russian backed independence movements in the Northwest, and fighting against the French in Vietnam. Also, if Joseon is labeled as a protectorate of Qing, why isn't Vietnam also labeled as such? I've also never seen people consider Lanfang as an extension of Qing. Qing's control over Taiwan also was far from complete. It would take the Japanese well into the 1930s to fully control the entire island.
Qing always had control of Taiwan important areas. If you look at current day Taiwan. Most population is on the West Coast. Why? Because it’s mostly flat plains and ideal for administrations. The idea that Qing should soldiers stationed all over the island is stupid. That’s like saying the British didn’t directly controlled india because they didn’t have troops stationed everywhere
Joseon and Vietnam are very different when it comes to Qing's rule.The Qing started a war against Joseon in 1637,occupied its capital and captured almost all its royal members(including the heir to the throne), forcing the king of Joseon to kowtow to the Qing emperor to surrender,who accepted all the conditions imposed by Qing dynasty, including paying substantial tribute such as rice, paper, silver etc to Qing every year, obey Qing's millitary commands, send the heir to the capital of Qing as a hostage before returning to inherit the throne, stop any diplomatic relations with Ming etc. These conditions means that Qing had some kind of actual control(though not much) over the Joseon dynasty. However, the only millitary action against Vietnam in the 18th century failed at last. So Qing never had any actual control over Vietnam. The vassel relations between Qing and Vietnam is only nominal and symbolic. That's why you can see European maps in the 18th and 19th centuries show Joseon as part of Qing empire but Vietnam as an independent country. In fact, sometimes even maps made by Qing itself showed Joseon as part of its own, but never showed Vietnam.
The answer to many people's questions about modern China can be found in the history of China, which is a history of repeated invasion and resistance. We all know that peace is hard won, and the resilience of the Chinese people in their bones is beyond the understanding of Western countries
Yeah no we understand it just fine. Especially considering some of us in the western world had to fight for our homes. Americans had to fight for our freedom. Poles had to fight for theirs. Ukrainians are fighting now. Baltic country’s. Finland. I could go on. Chinese history is truly one of tragedy and heart ache. And I hope for them that one day it can end with the rightful government reclaiming the mainland to end this civil war once and for all.
no one: me: Chinese don't get mad if you say Taiwan is under ROC's control which is the fact, Chinese only get mad when you say Taiwan never belongs to China. I mean, there is technically two Chinas. also Taiwanese call their country are Republic of China even in 2022
In the 50s-60s, India actually occupied tens of thousands of square kilometers of Tibet, but the map did not show it. After 1962, the occupied part of western Tibet was taken back by the PLA.
@@zondor8123 Chinese usually call it BegoniagrandisDry subsp.sinensis(A. DC.) Irmsch leave. Many Chinese agree that the original land has the most desired border line
Some division of provinces is wrong. Gansu has some of its boundaries just next to Mongolia. And Henan and Jiangsu are now not “neighbors ” next to each other . And there are a few mistakes in the division of Shaanxi and Guangdong Province. Well, though the video has some mistakes, it’s still a good job.
Some very detailed mistakes in nowadays provinces: 1.Gansu-Mongolia border (Mazongshan,Gansu have a border around 70kms and ever a bordercheck port with Mongolia ) 2.Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei border,the enclave of Hebei Garent shown(北三县/大三香) 3.Shaanxi's north border with Inner Mongolia.(In fact the border in the video is the location of the Great Wall,but the real border is over that during hundreds years ago) 4.Hebei-Henan border(the west part in the video still keep the shape during the Qing Dynasty) 5.Anhui-Jiangsu border(Counties exchange at 1955) 6.Anhui-Hubei border(Yingshan County belongs to Hubei now) 7.Anhui-Jiangxi border(Wuyuan County is in Jiangxi since 1949) 8.Guangdong-Guangxi border(Huaiji County was given to Guangdong when Guangxi had coastline) 9.Hebei-Shandong border 10.Shandong-Henan border(the Dongming County) 11.Hubei-Chongqing-Shaanxi border 12.Qinghai-Gansu Northwest border(changed in 2001) Chinese provincial change is very severe during the 20ce. Actually lots of these boundaries was correct decades ago but not now,maybe the author forgot to edit or they were ignored.
As a Chinese from mainland, I can say that this video is pretty good and accurate, what’s need to be specific is Korea was part of Qing Dynasty untill 1895, after the war of JiaWu, Japan occupied it. Apart from that it’s a very good video from an objective perspective to show the history of China. Hong Kong, Marco, Taiwan, Outer Mongolia, Outer Northeast, Northwest Xinjiang, Kashmir, Ulya Sutai… Those are the territories we have been divided. As a Chinese, I can't forget.
Korea was never a part of qing. Learn the difference between territory and a tributary. Korea stopped paying tribute to qing in 1895 and was fully independent until 1905 when it became a protectorate of japan and became a part of japan in 1910. Mainland chinese are full of inferiority complexes against koreans
Don't be fooled by your government's propaganda, just watch the video, Ladakh was ours during the Qing Dynasty, only it was later occupied by the British!@@RajeshSoni-k7d
LanFang Republic was established by Chinese people. Actually, there's more than a dozen Country established by Chinese at that time. If China had been industrialized at that time, maybe we will see an extremely large China.
@@落羽楓華 Well if you have alot of laborers, you really don't need machines. Until the western countries back then came to China and shown what industrialization do. Only fully realized when the communist fully occupied mainland, well its not too late to the industrialization party
Average European War: Guy says the most violent shit ever: 20k Casualties Vs Average Chinese Rebellion: Kid gets an F at an exam, 500 million dead + 7 Plagues and 8 Dynasty collapse
@@khanhvujade9182 No, it is Japan which has problems with Russia, Russia is perfectly fine with islands. They will be more strictly guarded now tho. And no more fishing for japanese poachers there
IDK if you mean they were not satisfied with what the got or you are not satisfied with the history fact. If the previous, I'll say yes, Russians had plans to take over whole Manchuria, Inner Mongolia, and Sinkang. Actually as they did occupied part of Sinkang during the civil war, it is reasonable to infer that they would refuse to give them back to ROC if CPC lost the war. If you are just not satisfied with the history, I can only say, that's history, we cannot change anything.
Moi. KMT was in the mainland for many years, although they presented mostly as guerillas after 1950. As for East Turkestan, it was a complex problem with CCP, KMT, Sheng Shicai, USSR and local landlords during WW2.
Republic of China-Peking Government and Republic of China-Nanking government should use different colors. Two regimes are completely different. Peking Government was a constitutional republic, while the Nanking Government was a military dictatorship modeled after the Bolsheviks. This video is very detailed and well done.
Mao Fuhai, the biological mother of Chiang Ching-kuo, the second leader of the constitutional government of the Republic of China, is the cousin of Mao Zedong, the first leader of the People's Republic of China
@@mrme8580 Ya need to rmb There’s a place in China called Hong Kong. Even I’m not in HK, Most of VPN in China is free, which is zero-cost connecting the Google. Or downloading google service add-on into the phone also work. So actually, the Great Fire Wall doesn’t actually ban the connection at all (Imagine people in North Korea) This thing only protect the network security for the military, I think.
@@Triantafyllos_Strantzalis Qing (Dowager Cixi) declared war against an army of other 8 countries' soldiers with advanced equipment and weapons. Qing lost, although the 8 countries had got only 30,000 to 50,000 soldiers to fight against Qing's millions of people (I say 'people' because they weren't trained military).
@@鸡你太美-i7l You know nothing, Taiwan gov continuously war with CCP in Taiwan sea、Burma、Thailand、Southern Vietnam until 1990 and still no any peace agreement.
That's right, I'm from the Republic of China🇹🇼. On the other side of the People's Republic of China🇨🇳, there are a lot of ghost policies and persecution of the people, but it doesn't affect me😁. After all, the Republic of China🇹🇼 is a country of democracy, freedom and human rights.👍
@@figtree_video_archive This is our mission in the Republic of China, no matter how low the social credits🇨🇳👎 on the other side is, none of my business ～ 🇹🇼
@@figtree_video_archive I don't want to give it to Japan🇯🇵. I like Japan🇯🇵, but unfortunately Japan belongs to the outside world. Those 50 years were just colonization. It can be said that we still exist in the Republic of China🇹🇼, and we already belong to the infinite negative social credits. 😂
It'll be better if the video starts from 1839, because all Chinese know the "century of humiliation", also known as the "hundred years of national humiliation", is a term used in China to describe the period of intervention and subjugation of the Qing dynasty and the Republic of China by Western powers and Japan from 1839 to 1949. wiki: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Century_of_humiliation
If it starts in 1839, doesn't that highlight the savage side of Western pirate civilization? Let more people know that the West once savagely invaded the civilized country of China!
This is your “masochistic and persecutory delusions” view of history...The humiliation is the result of your own isolation, xenophobia, and ignorance. Opium addiction was actively infected by your own , not instigated by foreigners，smoke-house and smoke-pipe invented by your own far before the international trade of the British，at that time， westerners could not even enter the city area of Guangzhou
Question, what’s the difference between the relation between qing and its tributaries (korea, thailand, nepal, etc.) and the relation between qing and lanfang republic? Why do you only show lanfang as a influenced by qing instead of all its tributaries or none?
@@DadaduduxD imperial Japan annexed the Ryukyu islands which were a Japanese territory. The populations there are Japanese and I don't see the Ryukyu inhabitants complaining. Also what territories from Korea and China are we talking about because they were all handed back in the treaty of San Francisco as far as I'm concerned.
this video i guess is made by Taiwan people, in mainland acedemic Lanfang asked to join as a part of Qing but Qing refused. So lanfang wasnt a part of Qing
Fun fact, neither republique of china, people republique of china admited the "independence" of Tibet since 1911, they just couldn't take control of this region under the wars against Japan and after the civil war, that's why the first thing that Mao did after the creation of People republique of china is to take over Tibet
@@百亿补贴勋多多 I don't know where r u from, I am mainland Chinese, i would say your point "local landlords and monks continued human sacrifice and serfdom" mostly are CCP's propaganda, yes, it is just partly correct, the CCP's goal is not to make the Tibet's people have better life, but taking over the power, see what CCP done to the non-Tibet people from 1950 - 1979, more than hundreds millions people got killed, hurt.
In fact from 1945 to May 1955, Region of Lvshun (Port Arthur) and Dalian/ Kwantung Leased Territory de facto controlled by USSR. So during that 10 years, the color of that region should be changed by my opinion.
@@sahilsingh6048 You didn’t get my point. If you compare the map of this video with the map of Arunachal, you will find that Arunachal was included. Such political stuff is complicated, and I don’t want to focus on that when I am stating something that really happened. Otherwise, people will focus on defending their positions and ignore the problem I pointed out.
The area once belonged to Qing, but a British called McMahon draw a line claiming that it belongs to India. Neither the ROC or PRC accepted the McMahon Line, but we were too busy fighting the world wars and fighting ourselves to take back the region. That's the fact.
In fact, 99% of the territory lost in the video is related to Russia. The Independence referendum of Mongolia is the same as the Independence referendum of eastern Ukraine.
@@octopus_72 It’s not Weird. You see it’s exactly 6 years away from the Austro-Prussian War. Which changed the course of German History. The War would Made Austria Weaker but Prussia Stronger to the point of them being able to defeat The 2nd French Empire in the Franco-Prussian War (1870-1871), which created the German Empire. Therefore 1860 is an Appropriate Date. What you said about 1815. I took it into consideration and the would make the video too much Longer. And also from 1815 to The Year of the Schleswig Wars (Prussia, Austrian Empire vs Denmark). They were Peaceful and has not done any major wars up until that point. Therefore proving my Point 1860 is a Major Start Day.
@@ClassicalMusicMan lol, for us Chinese, German history video should start from the Holy Roman Empire in 1522. Because the birth of the German nation was based on language, Martin Luther translated the Bible in that year, the concept of the Deutschland nation state came into being.
China be like: Great Qing has joined the game. Great Qing has leaved the game. Republic of China has joined the game. Republic of China has leaved the game. Republic of China has joined the game. Republic of China has War the C.C.P U.S.S.R has send a rebels name C.C.P C.C.P has named People's Republic of China Republic of China has Peace People's Republic of China
No. U.S.S.R has send a rebels named Nationalist-Party aka KMT to Republic of China(Warlords) in 1924, the C.C.P joint with KMT by the personal level. And after ChiangKS's Amry part of KMT turned to the CCP, U.S.S.R had cut off conection with CCP. That's the main reason leading to alot of problem and weird thing in the 1945-1979 USSR-Sino relation ship.
can someone explain or give me the names of those kmt pockets that lasted till the 50s? i know about the KMT islamic insurgency but the one in Fujian i have never heard of thanks!
"Give me freedom or give me death!!" Meaning if you are robbed of your freedom you will stay subservient because you don't have what it takes to end yourself
lanfang is not part of Qing. Lanfang, a Chinese mining company, is located in the Mandor area under the protection of the Sambas Sultanate. finally Lanfang was dissolved by the Pontianak Sultanate which was supported by the Dutch and had a very large area in West Kalimantan.
At that time, the National Army of the Republic of China in Qinghai Province was still stubbornly resisting the People's Liberation Army of the People's Republic of China
科科蛋糕It is the Kekexili no-man's land (a movie about protecting Tibetan antelopes called Cocoxili), where less than 1,000 people live on hundreds of thousands of square kilometers.
The fact of the Sino Japanese war from 1931 to 1945: many people believe that at that time China had only the Communist Party and the Kuomintang, so there were only two colors of China on the map. But the fact is that China was very chaotic at that time. There are many large-scale internal wars. After about a decade of super chaotic civil war, most troops, all heavy weapons, bullets and artillery shells were used to fight the civil war. For example, during the Chinese civil war in 1931, the Kuomintang deployed onemillion troops to destroy the Chinese Communist Party. At this time, it is difficult to resist a well prepared Japan.
They not wrong but they not right either
It is not Really, The Chinese Signed an Unease Treaty Forming the United Chinese Front (Which was Temporary and not Even a Political Power), Well They show here The True Warlord Era Over the Sino Japanese War is Not that Complicated and Chaotic, One things is set on their mind, Take down The Japanese.
@@AaronIsCool450 You know too little. The United Front was established in 1937 (only the Kuomintang and the Communist Party, China's Mongolia and Tibet, and some warlords did not participate). In 1931, Japan invaded China for the first time (occupied Northeast China). At that time, China was already very chaotic. There are more than ten major warlords, including the Kuomintang, the Communist Party, Sichuan, Mongolia, Tibet, Fujian and Hubei. They all control tens of millions of people and hundreds of thousands of square kilometers of land. They vied with each other for territory and population. Therefore, the Chinese people do not care about Japan's invasion of Northeast China. The second Japanese invasion of China was in 1937. At that time, China was going through a civil war between the Kuomintang and the Communist Party, which had lasted for ten years. Both sides were exhausted. A large number of outstanding troops and generals disappeared in the civil war, a large number of people died, and the weapons and ammunition of both sides were exhausted. At this time, Japan invaded China, and China could not resist. Therefore, Japan easily occupied the Hebei Henan plain and won the Shanghai battle. Therefore, when we look at the Sino Japanese War, we should not think that China's combat capability is very weak, because before the Sino Japanese War, China had experienced about 22 years of internal war from 1915 to 1937。
@@老老实实挣大钱 since 1840 china was easily bullied by other countries. since xinhai revolution china became chaotic. that's why chinese national anthem says build our new great wall with blood and flesh, and chinese people face their greatest peril.
@@老老实实挣大钱 you are right, but as a Chinese, what I want to say is that the Sino Japanese War of 1894-1895 was over before the Sino Japanese war
China’s history is very underrated and needs to be talked about more in the west. Anyways, great video!
Technically it not as proc a country with the biggest population teaches Chinese history
Edit:just realized you said west which is true
@Bystanders (雲霧叆叇) 是的
Tbh I feel like Middle Eastern history is a little more underrated
I
Yeah especially now with the PRC threatening the west, it’s definitely worth studying China’s history to know what lead to the rise of communism in China
Very detailed and informative video. However, there are still some mistakes.
1. There are two major Muslim rebellions in 1850-70s instead of one. One is Panthay Rebellion in Yunnan, and the other is Dungan Revolt in Shaanxi and Gansu in 1862-1877. The map showed the rebellion in Shaanxi, but didn't use the right name.
2. The location of Kouang-Tchéou-Wan was on the east side of the Leizhou Peninsula, which is today's Zhanjiang City. The location on the map is too east.
3. There were many changes of province borders after the founding of PRC, including Jiangsu & Anhui border, Anhui & Jiangxi border, Guangdong & Guangxi border, etc., which is not showed on the map. In 1969-1979, the eastern border of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region was also different from the current one.
4. Sino-Indian War of 1962. After 1947, India claimed the sovereinity of Aksai Chin, which is beyond the Macartney-Macdonald Line of India-China border. In this war, China got back the control of Aksai Chin, as well as the Arunachal Pradesh, but gave up Arunachal in the coming winter.
我作为一个中国人知道你说的很对
India has Still Control over Mc carthy Lines but we Belive Actually Border is Johnsan Line which is present day Aksai chin sorry i know this Areas are chinese but Due to Politics we Are Doing Expansionism
Because in our Religon More Territory Means More Power☠️
Thinking Of Tsarist Russia wanted Dreams of Greater India
Sorry Chinese Brothers I understand your Feelings
very comprehensive, as a Chinese from mainland China, i couldn't thank you more, do you major history or are you a specialist in history?
The quality is very good. I can't imagine how long this took.
as a Chinese, I would say this video is from neutral stance and is really amazing. I can image how long it will take for a foreigner to make it. Great and thanks.
@NanamiNishijou it's like saying, as a German, I don't see a history of the American Civil War as made from a neutral stance because they put a Confederate song in it their not supporting ether side with placing a Era correct song in that Era
@@NanamiNishijouin China ROC has already disappeared so it is neutral
中立还能放红彤彤 你是否有点殖了😅
@@无名-z7j 那你说放什么歌？放科目三吗？
@@NanamiNishijou what, you want a cocomelon song to play or something? But then you'll say "that isnt neutral cuz its this country song bla bla bla"
Bro your music taste is amazing!
this is old national anthem of china
虽然这是一个外国人制造 的视频，但我深深地佩服作者。因为作者对中国历史的了解程度已经超过了很多中国的国民。而且这些历史的信息也全是正确的。感谢作者辛苦的付出，制作出了这样的好作品，在网上公开，让西方的人民也了解中国的历史。中国的和平来之不易，中国近代以来就是一段不断被入侵，且中国人民也在不断反抗侵略的历史。
中国人学的近代史假历史居多
@@東隅 你是吃屎长大的
@@東隅 台湾现在教材基本删光了中国历史
@@東隅 清朝其实是满洲的朝代，当时中国灭亡成为满洲的殖民地。
@@CiaYazhoufenjuagree
This is the most headache inducing map timelapse video I’ve ever watched, thank you for the history lessons I’ve learned
Like wow that was a lot of rabbit holes of research and Wikipedia articles I went through
For years, believe me, for years I've been searching for a video showing the evolution of the political subdividion of China, and suddenly I found this video. Thanks a lot. New suscriber. 👍👍👍
Now it’s your turn to make one
I really thought “wouldn’t it be funny if that 1 Mao Zedong song played during his rule? Nah this is a serious video.”
And then that 1 Mao Zedong song played during his rule. Lovely.
The song played in that part is kinda weird. Mao-era songs didn't sound like that at all. I don't think there is any song better than 'The East is Red'(东方红) to represent Mao-era.
@@mastermirror3888 definitely, at least the drum beat isn't sth of that era
Wait, so that song wasn't from Mao's era?
中國歷史：夏朝>商朝>周朝>春秋戰國>秦朝>漢朝>三國>晉朝>魏晉南北朝>隋朝>唐朝>五代十國>宋朝>元朝>明朝>清朝>北洋時代>中華民國(大陸時代)>中華人民共和國(中國大陸地區)與中華民國(台灣) 一個中國兩個政府長期休戰
@@ChiangKai-shek蔣介石 speak English bro
This channel is criminally underrated
Exactly, it's unfortunate but 90% of the best channels, in terms of dedication and quality, are under the shadow and are little known compared to others. It's unfortunate but that's the way the market is, we have to respect and continue working hard to reverse this situation.
Never have I seen such a detailed mapping channel, you got even the provinces! Congrats
Although this video has provinces,the provinces change are not completely recorded during the 20ce in the video.
What people need to remember is that for the entire time that Chiang Kai-Shek ruled the RoC, it was at best a corrupt oligarchy, and eventually just became an outright dictatorship that oppressed the native Taiwanese.
Just like how South Korea was not much more free than North Korea until the 70s
Until they changed to a democracy in the 80’s.
Also there are benevolent dictatorships, and ChiangKai Shek wasn’t one, but his successor (in terms of leaders) was.
also, another fun fact was that even though chiang was not corruption, his wife soong mei ling and her siblings were extremely corrupt. they were extremely filthy rich. that was how bad the corruption was.. even the american president at time time bitched about chiang.
I agree with you. We never wanted to be ruled by the ROC (Rubbish of China). The current situation now is a lot of people who support Kuomintang are also supporting, or hoping that the CCP take over Taiwan. This means that the real Taiwanese people (people who love and respect Taiwan) are now fighting against both CCP and ROC (Kuomintang).
No shit
The Qing borders look so nice
Edit: Wow, thanks for the likes
Thats because we arent seeing european sphere of influence lol
@@furlan1743 ?
@Il kekkvs You realise the Qing made their own borders right? Not Europeans.
not until when the westerner decide to divide chinese territory
@@jinvonastrea1141 Bruh they took a few ports calm down
The fact that those words below "Emperor:" of Great Qing are not the name of emperors but the reign title.
Reign title; name
Xianfeng(咸豐); Yi-Zhu(奕詝)
Tongzhi(同治); Zai-Chun(載淳)
Guangxu(光緒); Zai-Tian(載湉)
Xuantong(宣統); Pu-Yi(溥儀)
There's nothing more Chinese than traditional Chinese music playing while watching a map of China fragmenting
中國歷史：夏朝>商朝>周朝>春秋戰國>秦朝>漢朝>三國>晉朝>魏晉南北朝>隋朝>唐朝>五代十國>宋朝>元朝>明朝>清朝>北洋時代>中華民國(大陸時代)>中華人民共和國(中國大陸地區)與中華民國(台灣) 一個中國兩個政府長期休戰
我希望你的国家能分裂🤗🤗🤗
@@TheaccounthasbeencancelledYang It was in the 1600s for a short while until it was united again by monarchists.
@@communistdeer所以你是哪国人？
@@TheaccounthasbeencancelledYang why?
非常感谢作者制作了如此优秀的视频，视频里涉及的所有时期的中国版图都是正确的，这是对中国这个国家、对历史最好的尊重！！！辛苦了，你的努力和用心值得大家的尊重
江海滔滔，山岳高崇，中华自古为世之雄！
祝愿我亲爱的祖国永远繁荣昌盛
May my dear motherland be prosperous forever
🙏🙏🙏
@@user-du5uq6hf6x 哪裡錯
@@user-du5uq6hf6x 好啦小粉紅不要玻璃
@@user-du5uq6hf6x 确实很正确啊, 库页岛都有了
藏南没有
@@刃下狼血藏南又没有实控
Brother, you are the best map of China I have ever seen from another country
10:18 the music got me rolling on a floor 💀🙏
What is funny
Just song by People's song
Got greated rhis song by Mao Zedong watching to the sun like Chinese red sun
@@U29275Hshi It's been used in a lot of meme videos. Hearing it no longer has it's original meaning, it makes people laugh now hence the OP comment
Its nice hearing the Chinese Victory Song From World War 2,I Listened to both defend the yellow river and Victory Song,Which The Song sounds Very Beautiful.
I gotta say, I only knew surface-level 20th century history about China, particularly WW2 and a little bit about the Sino-Soviet split later on. However, I ended up taking two semesters of Chinese history at university covering 1890 to 2010 pretty in-depth, and I gotta say, Chinese history is really fucking interesting.
确实，作为中国人我也对本国历史非常感兴趣
中國歷史：夏朝>商朝>周朝>春秋戰國>秦朝>漢朝>三國>晉朝>魏晉南北朝>隋朝>唐朝>五代十國>宋朝>元朝>明朝>清朝>北洋時代>中華民國(大陸時代)>中華人民共和國(中國大陸地區)與中華民國(台灣) 一個中國兩個政府長期休戰
@@ct_zimafox 中國歷史：夏朝>商朝>周朝>春秋戰國>秦朝>漢朝>三國>晉朝>魏晉南北朝>隋朝>唐朝>五代十國>宋朝>元朝>明朝>清朝>北洋時代>中華民國(大陸時代)>中華人民共和國(中國大陸地區)與中華民國(台灣) 一個中國兩個政府長期休戰
@@ChiangKai-shek蔣介石 来个英文版，方便看懂
对外国人来说可能很有趣，但是对我们中国人来说近代的这近200年历史，是一段屈辱的记忆，中华文明千年未有之大变局，几近亡国灭种，自从朝鲜战争后也是中国凤凰涅槃浴火重生的历史。台湾仍然割据分裂，中国仍未成为世界霸主，革命尚未成功，同志仍需努力
我的天，这么好的政治版图变迁视频。精确到了月份。
What about taiwan being a country
@@emdeelabbeautypreneur Taiwan and mainland china are both countries, doesn't matter if you disagree, they both have sovereign governments which make them countries
Warlord era It's the most confusing period I've ever studied
不，中國的“五代十國”時期比軍閥混戰時期更亂
@@zihaofang9194 说是五代十国和宋辽夏其实是大唐内战
You don't have to spend much time on those dog barking period. Those warlords were all shit. Only Communism Party of China saved the country and the race. Meanwhile KMT was the evil submissive presenter of the imperialists.
@@zihaofang9194 魏晋南北朝更乱
@@汤圆水饺 这个知道，学这段前老师就说过很乱
incredible video, this really deserves more views
Amazingly informative! I'm definitely saving this.
Without the Russians, British, French, and the Japanese labeled with color, it gets a little confusing... There's the second opium war, the Russian invasions in the North and Russian backed independence movements in the Northwest, and fighting against the French in Vietnam. Also, if Joseon is labeled as a protectorate of Qing, why isn't Vietnam also labeled as such? I've also never seen people consider Lanfang as an extension of Qing. Qing's control over Taiwan also was far from complete. It would take the Japanese well into the 1930s to fully control the entire island.
Apprently, the first kongsi president declared himself a minister, not just a vassal, of the qing empire, so the dutch would be cautious with him
Yeah it randomly loses land 4:39
Qing always had control of Taiwan important areas. If you look at current day Taiwan. Most population is on the West Coast. Why? Because it’s mostly flat plains and ideal for administrations. The idea that Qing should soldiers stationed all over the island is stupid. That’s like saying the British didn’t directly controlled india because they didn’t have troops stationed everywhere
Joseon and Vietnam are very different when it comes to Qing's rule.The Qing started a war against Joseon in 1637,occupied its capital and captured almost all its royal members(including the heir to the throne), forcing the king of Joseon to kowtow to the Qing emperor to surrender,who accepted all the conditions imposed by Qing dynasty, including paying substantial tribute such as rice, paper, silver etc to Qing every year, obey Qing's millitary commands, send the heir to the capital of Qing as a hostage before returning to inherit the throne, stop any diplomatic relations with Ming etc. These conditions means that Qing had some kind of actual control(though not much) over the Joseon dynasty. However, the only millitary action against Vietnam in the 18th century failed at last. So Qing never had any actual control over Vietnam. The vassel relations between Qing and Vietnam is only nominal and symbolic. That's why you can see European maps in the 18th and 19th centuries show Joseon as part of Qing empire but Vietnam as an independent country. In fact, sometimes even maps made by Qing itself showed Joseon as part of its own, but never showed Vietnam.
@@isbsxecjeci2428哦？那法國跟清廷簽啥鳥屁約？
The answer to many people's questions about modern China can be found in the history of China, which is a history of repeated invasion and resistance. We all know that peace is hard won, and the resilience of the Chinese people in their bones is beyond the understanding of Western countries
Yeah no we understand it just fine. Especially considering some of us in the western world had to fight for our homes.
Americans had to fight for our freedom.
Poles had to fight for theirs.
Ukrainians are fighting now.
Baltic country’s.
Finland.
I could go on.
Chinese history is truly one of tragedy and heart ache. And I hope for them that one day it can end with the rightful government reclaiming the mainland to end this civil war once and for all.
@@Wesley-1776 "fight for ur freedom", good, keep invading other countries for it
@元若蓝💙💛 under the ROC government
@@Wesley-1776 The People's Republic of China is the legitimate government
@元若蓝💙💛 机器人闭嘴吧
4,000 subscribers is not worth it for him, he needs more, must be more than 100,000!
Srsly he gets so many views but so few subs, sad
@@clouds-rb9xt You're right 😀
You made a great video! Looking forward to making more excellent videos
the fact that this lad played red sun in the sky when it came to the prc is hilarious
no one:
me: Chinese don't get mad if you say Taiwan is under ROC's control which is the fact, Chinese only get mad when you say Taiwan never belongs to China.
I mean, there is technically two Chinas. also Taiwanese call their country are Republic of China even in 2022
The only two Chinas I acknowledge is China itself and the countries that houses the Chinese diaspora and partial blood relatives.
Real chad moment: People's Republic of China belongs to the Republic of China (Taiwan)
但都是中华
中国的传统就是不能有两个中国，必须统一，这和吃饭用筷子一样是天理。
@@chiangwinston7460 是，但是南北朝并立互相宣称正统和一边放弃宣称 长久以往变成外族致使另一边完全丧失法统
这俩你挑一个
Fun fact : 03:27 At that time, Heungseon Daewongun, the leader of Joseon, was kidnapped by the Qing Dynasty and was imprisoned for four years
In the 50s-60s, India actually occupied tens of thousands of square kilometers of Tibet, but the map did not show it. After 1962, the occupied part of western Tibet was taken back by the PLA.
Funny,so funny
当时差点打到新德里，笑死了
笑死了印度人被解放军追得比羚羊跑得都快
No you are wrong
@@鸡你太美-i7l don't involve politics be respectful to others
I like how you used songs that fit each era. Flower of freedom is a great one, Hope to see freedom for China in my lifetime! ❤
一个月的小号就出来造谣
The amount of land China lost is crazy
should see the British and french
Lmfao Qing is not even Chinese. They are manchu
It's okay china original lands which has a weird shaped borders like a hand "reaching" are still huge anyways.
@@zondor8123 Chinese usually call it BegoniagrandisDry subsp.sinensis(A. DC.) Irmsch leave. Many Chinese agree that the original land has the most desired border line
Some division of provinces is wrong. Gansu has some of its boundaries just next to Mongolia. And Henan and Jiangsu are now not “neighbors ” next to each other . And there are a few mistakes in the division of Shaanxi and Guangdong Province.
Well, though the video has some mistakes, it’s still a good job.
Some very detailed mistakes in nowadays provinces:
1.Gansu-Mongolia border (Mazongshan,Gansu have a border around 70kms and ever a bordercheck port with Mongolia )
2.Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei border,the enclave of Hebei Garent shown(北三县/大三香)
3.Shaanxi's north border with Inner Mongolia.(In fact the border in the video is the location of the Great Wall,but the real border is over that during hundreds years ago) 4.Hebei-Henan border(the west part in the video still keep the shape during the Qing Dynasty)
5.Anhui-Jiangsu border(Counties exchange at 1955)
6.Anhui-Hubei border(Yingshan County belongs to Hubei now)
7.Anhui-Jiangxi border(Wuyuan County is in Jiangxi since 1949)
8.Guangdong-Guangxi border(Huaiji County was given to Guangdong when Guangxi had coastline)
9.Hebei-Shandong border
10.Shandong-Henan border(the Dongming County)
11.Hubei-Chongqing-Shaanxi border
12.Qinghai-Gansu Northwest border(changed in 2001)
Chinese provincial change is very severe during the 20ce. Actually lots of these boundaries was correct decades ago but not now,maybe the author forgot to edit or they were ignored.
Strictly speaking, modern Chinese history begins in 1840.
When the British start the opium war
You are right. But isn't it too strict for the video?🤣🤣
As a Chinese from mainland, I can say that this video is pretty good and accurate, what’s need to be specific is Korea was part of Qing Dynasty untill 1895, after the war of JiaWu, Japan occupied it. Apart from that it’s a very good video from an objective perspective to show the history of China. Hong Kong, Marco, Taiwan, Outer Mongolia, Outer Northeast, Northwest Xinjiang, Kashmir, Ulya Sutai… Those are the territories we have been divided. As a Chinese, I can't forget.
Chinese but your account name are slavic name like serb or croats
Korea was never a part of qing. Learn the difference between territory and a tributary. Korea stopped paying tribute to qing in 1895 and was fully independent until 1905 when it became a protectorate of japan and became a part of japan in 1910. Mainland chinese are full of inferiority complexes against koreans
When was kashmir Arunachal Pradesh was pary of China 😂
Don't be fooled by your government's propaganda, just watch the video, Ladakh was ours during the Qing Dynasty, only it was later occupied by the British!@@RajeshSoni-k7d
在老外做的视频里，算是非常全的一个了，很多类似的视频里大清地图都是默认没有俄罗斯侵略的外东北的
Unlike Beiyang government, Prime minister did not exist in the KMT. It should be corrected to 'chairman of the executive yuan(行政院院長).
technically CCP doesnt have a prime minister either. it's called "premier"
@@musAKulture It's a matter of how you want to translate it into English. 总理 can also be translated Prime Minister
It’s more friendly for western understanding
I will never forget the history of modern China.
You're a race traitor. White washed Asian.
wait they had a random territory in borneo? that is fascinating
It was a direct democracy too, a vassal to one of the most authoritarian civilizations
LanFang Republic was established by Chinese people. Actually, there's more than a dozen Country established by Chinese at that time. If China had been industrialized at that time, maybe we will see an extremely large China.
@@落羽楓華 Well if you have alot of laborers, you really don't need machines. Until the western countries back then came to China and shown what industrialization do.
Only fully realized when the communist fully occupied mainland, well its not too late to the industrialization party
Guy fails an exam, believes himself to be the brother of Jesus, 100 million die.
Average European War: Guy says the most violent shit ever: 20k Casualties Vs Average Chinese Rebellion: Kid gets an F at an exam, 500 million dead + 7 Plagues and 8 Dynasty collapse
Not just "an exam", but "the exam"
@@Xmv_987 当时的中国一共4亿人，怎么可能死5亿？？？
Am I the only one who finds it increadably unsatisfying for Russia to annex Outer Manchuria and Dzungaria?
always russia
Even If they are still the biggest nation by landmass, they’re still on territorially dispute with Japan all the way back to the Siberian coasts
@@khanhvujade9182 No, it is Japan which has problems with Russia, Russia is perfectly fine with islands. They will be more strictly guarded now tho. And no more fishing for japanese poachers there
@@Admin-gm3lc I accept being corrected, I guess
IDK if you mean they were not satisfied with what the got or you are not satisfied with the history fact. If the previous, I'll say yes, Russians had plans to take over whole Manchuria, Inner Mongolia, and Sinkang. Actually as they did occupied part of Sinkang during the civil war, it is reasonable to infer that they would refuse to give them back to ROC if CPC lost the war. If you are just not satisfied with the history, I can only say, that's history, we cannot change anything.
Woah, there was Kuomintang presence in the mainland as late as '57, and next door to East Turkestan/Xinjiang too!?
Yes mainly muslim hui and loyal tibetan guerillas that were covertly paid by Chiang
Moi. KMT was in the mainland for many years, although they presented mostly as guerillas after 1950. As for East Turkestan, it was a complex problem with CCP, KMT, Sheng Shicai, USSR and local landlords during WW2.
Republic of China-Peking Government and Republic of China-Nanking government should use different colors. Two regimes are completely different. Peking Government was a constitutional republic, while the Nanking Government was a military dictatorship modeled after the Bolsheviks. This video is very detailed and well done.
你是对的，中华民国北京政府和南京政府是两个政权，只是后者宣称承袭前者的法理
@@gardragonlee3158 很高兴能在这里看到中文的认同
確實是這樣，但北洋的憲政也只是徒有虛名就是了，他們甚至沒有憲法而是「約法」
It‘s a ridiculous fact that the wife of the first of leader of ROC(Sun Yet-Sen), Song became the leader of PRC in 1969.
Mao Fuhai, the biological mother of Chiang Ching-kuo, the second leader of the constitutional government of the Republic of China, is the cousin of Mao Zedong, the first leader of the People's Republic of China
@@LLENN0420 No，I‘m just talking about the rulers shown in the video there.
@@zhuchende2995 That's right, my words just wanted to add knowledge that the video didn't have
況且你會中文吧，你的名字形勢、標點符號 看出來了
PRC 是 ROC 的合法继承者
@@孙成业-d4u 合法？當初 清朝 把 退位招書、國際條約 全都繳交給 中華民國 後結束，並且後續沒有任何朝廷延續，這才是 合法繼承
你 中華人民共和國 華獨從 中華民國 分裂出去，然後把 中華民國 打到僅剩下 臺灣島，結果沒有完全滅除 中華民國政府，你們所說的 偽中華民國政府 有沒有邏輯，畢竟當初 中華民國政府 就是 蔣中正 領導，哪來的虛偽？
你們要繼承 可以 ～ 但先過來打啊，別每次說 沒有臺海中線，卻每次不敢飛過來，說什麼不許把 臺灣 分裂出去，自己從未統治過 臺灣，連 軍隊、官員 都沒有踏入 中華民國臺灣省一步，你們至少先讓共軍飛越 金門馬祖 上空吧，至少這樣你們可以為你們的黨有點邏輯可論
Great music choice
As a Chinese, I think the video is basically fine in terms of neutrality and rigour. Thank you for making it.
How you are from china and can use TH-cam?
@@mrme8580Depends if they are living in China.
@@mrme8580 buy legal vpn
@@AllenTimecat VPN are illegal for CCP
@@mrme8580 Ya need to rmb
There’s a place in China called Hong Kong.
Even I’m not in HK,
Most of VPN in China is free, which is zero-cost connecting the Google.
Or downloading google service add-on into the phone also work.
So actually, the Great Fire Wall doesn’t actually ban the connection at all (Imagine people in North Korea)
This thing only protect the network security for the military, I think.
If u watched this video，then you can understand the Taiwan Problem and why Taiwan is believed one part of China
作者制作的很棒，身为一个中国人，就是心中有一股子莫名的酸楚
别来沾边
Lesson of the day: Declaring war is not a victory but a defeat
Didn't get it.
@@Triantafyllos_Strantzalis kaaa
kaaa
所以现在不要随意翔一个国家宣战，如果失败了，那就完蛋了
@@Triantafyllos_Strantzalis Qing (Dowager Cixi) declared war against an army of other 8 countries' soldiers with advanced equipment and weapons. Qing lost, although the 8 countries had got only 30,000 to 50,000 soldiers to fight against Qing's millions of people (I say 'people' because they weren't trained military).
Good job
3:28 There were no agreements or documents, but even before 1882, Joseon was under the influence of the Qing Dynasty.
This is a very well made map.
6:16 *insert Oh no. our table, its broken meme*
missed opportunity to time the beat drop at exactly 5:00 to a rebellion
I think the most interesting part is when the lyrics日出龙沉换国旗 times the Sino-Japanese war
Nice work im sure it took a long time to research all of this
One mistake
In 1962: China took region of Aksai Chin from India in a brief war, but didn't showed it.
Other than that, great video
Are u an indian? If u are then listen,he cant just make constant stuff on india,he needs to do on other countries also
And akai chin is occupied territory and china isn't the owner of it, he showed it as apart of india
不。那是我们的，你们还侵占我们的藏南，你们印度太贪心了，什么都想要，不可能和
@@TheTanveerGaming idiot, just google what does the name "Aksai Chin" means, the name has told you it's owner is China
@@TheTanveerGaming yes but they briefly invaded it and should be shown for accuracy
The border of Jiangxi and Anhui is wrong after 1934, when Chiang Kai-shek assigned Wuyuan in Anhui Province to Jiangxi.
Great background music, thanks!
Great video it help my social credit high! You deserve it!
he play tianament square tribute at 1989 part. you actually got minus social credit
How?
The last stage in chinnese civil war is taiwan between PRC and ROC the longest civil war in history
Are you sure? The civil war after 1945 lasted only four years
@@鸡你太美-i7l You know nothing, Taiwan gov continuously war with CCP in Taiwan sea、Burma、Thailand、Southern Vietnam until 1990 and still no any peace agreement.
@@鸡你太美-i7l In fact,they didn't sign any peace treaty after 1949,so the war is still lasting in theory
@@鸡你太美-i7l continues until now
@@鸡你太美-i7l 大陆和台湾土地上的两个政府，法律上处于战争状态
I love that until September 1958, most of the ROC was located in mainland China.
@Cigma Lee they try to take back mongolia province from russia but failed
Russia helped mongolia independence and annex tanutuva
i didnt love that it was awful ..weak gay taiwan is now them
@@حيثلاانت Russia did not annex Tannu Tuva until the 1940s.
中华民国 是四分五裂的中国，如果中华民国 那今天的中国版图 至少少掉99/100
Are you stupid or what?
Imagine being republic of china while realistically being mongolia
10:19 best moment in the entire video
+69 social credits.
Keep doing what you are doing.
@@accountthatillusetocomment3041 where's the funny?
That's right, I'm from the Republic of China🇹🇼. On the other side of the People's Republic of China🇨🇳, there are a lot of ghost policies and persecution of the people, but it doesn't affect me😁. After all, the Republic of China🇹🇼 is a country of democracy, freedom and human rights.👍
@@figtree_video_archive This is our mission in the Republic of China, no matter how low the social credits🇨🇳👎 on the other side is, none of my business ～ 🇹🇼
@@figtree_video_archive I don't want to give it to Japan🇯🇵. I like Japan🇯🇵, but unfortunately Japan belongs to the outside world. Those 50 years were just colonization.
It can be said that we still exist in the Republic of China🇹🇼, and we already belong to the infinite negative social credits. 😂
It'll be better if the video starts from 1839, because all Chinese know the "century of humiliation", also known as the "hundred years of national humiliation", is a term used in China to describe the period of intervention and subjugation of the Qing dynasty and the Republic of China by Western powers and Japan from 1839 to 1949. wiki: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Century_of_humiliation
If it starts in 1839, doesn't that highlight the savage side of Western pirate civilization? Let more people know that the West once savagely invaded the civilized country of China!
Actually I think it Start from opium War
This is your “masochistic and persecutory delusions” view of history...The humiliation is the result of your own isolation, xenophobia, and ignorance. Opium addiction was actively infected by your own , not instigated by foreigners，smoke-house and smoke-pipe invented by your own far before the international trade of the British，at that time， westerners could not even enter the city area of Guangzhou
Fun fact: this is about the time my school was created
5:18 I like how the music is timed so well as the Qing enters the 20th Century!
Cant wait to see
Same
Question, what’s the difference between the relation between qing and its tributaries (korea, thailand, nepal, etc.) and the relation between qing and lanfang republic? Why do you only show lanfang as a influenced by qing instead of all its tributaries or none?
@@DadaduduxD or China illegally occupied by CCP
@@DadaduduxD wdym illegally occupied lmao
@@DadaduduxD imperial Japan annexed the Ryukyu islands which were a Japanese territory. The populations there are Japanese and I don't see the Ryukyu inhabitants complaining. Also what territories from Korea and China are we talking about because they were all handed back in the treaty of San Francisco as far as I'm concerned.
this video i guess is made by Taiwan people, in mainland acedemic Lanfang asked to join as a part of Qing but Qing refused. So lanfang wasnt a part of Qing
@@dawid7224 they used to resist more, but all the resistant people have died already.
Fun fact, neither republique of china, people republique of china admited the "independence" of Tibet since 1911, they just couldn't take control of this region under the wars against Japan and after the civil war, that's why the first thing that Mao did after the creation of People republique of china is to take over Tibet
The CCP gave Tibet a chance to reform itself, but local landlords and monks continued human sacrifice and serfdom
Before PLA entered Tibet, local serfs in Tibet lived in hell
@@百亿补贴勋多多 I don't know where r u from, I am mainland Chinese, i would say your point "local landlords and monks continued human sacrifice and serfdom" mostly are CCP's propaganda, yes, it is just partly correct, the CCP's goal is not to make the Tibet's people have better life, but taking over the power, see what CCP done to the non-Tibet people from 1950 - 1979, more than hundreds millions people got killed, hurt.
In fact from 1945 to May 1955, Region of Lvshun (Port Arthur) and Dalian/ Kwantung Leased Territory de facto controlled by USSR. So during that 10 years, the color of that region should be changed by my opinion.
Even the simplified Chinese and traditional Chinese are distinguished.
15:30 at that time please be careful with the music because it was used in the Tiananmen Square massacre in 1980😢
10:20 you got 100 Social Credit sir
It’s only for Karens to lose points. Nobody else even notice its existence. Genius! 😂😂😂
8:08 LOL what kind of Chinese music is this, this sounds awesome.
都是台灣歌曲 只有一首中國歌
@@展翅高飛-n4n 好的1450愛河浮屍礦
@@jorryzhu4615 快去收屍
It’s the Taiwan victory song
@@xiangrongwang2698omg your right.
-Where are you going?
-Tian’anmen Square.
-Why?
-It’s my duty.
@ymlee5407I surmised viciously that some of them had come to block political reform
10:23 thanks to memes, I can not longer take that song seriously anymore 😂
Great Work! Thanks
Great video! It’s so detailed, but is the conflict between China and India probably missing? I mean South Tibet or we can call it Arunachal Pradesh.🤔
Arunachal is indian
@@sahilsingh6048 You didn’t get my point. If you compare the map of this video with the map of Arunachal, you will find that Arunachal was included. Such political stuff is complicated, and I don’t want to focus on that when I am stating something that really happened. Otherwise, people will focus on defending their positions and ignore the problem I pointed out.
@@alexzhang6411 yea he showed some that were not included before 1962
The area once belonged to Qing, but a British called McMahon draw a line claiming that it belongs to India. Neither the ROC or PRC accepted the McMahon Line, but we were too busy fighting the world wars and fighting ourselves to take back the region. That's the fact.
@@ridercalledryderu can cry dude 😂 arunachal is our even tibet is not urs neither culturally or politically tibet should be free
In fact, 99% of the territory lost in the video is related to Russia. The Independence referendum of Mongolia is the same as the Independence referendum of eastern Ukraine.
yes,i hate those sick russian,they rob over 3 million km^2 land
都怪这些满清鞑子
Mmmmm racism
ok
@@suboucnm无脑小粉红
This is quite nice and a bit detailed, but where's hong kong and macao?
That's too small😂😂😂😂😂
@@mcj4901 Yes,HK is only 1100 km2 and Macau has only 35km2 by land even smaller than PVG Airport
Hugs from Brazil to China
前段的配樂很不錯👍
但看著國土越來越小，心很悶
台湾人不是巴不得中国分裂吗😂头一次看到这中。
@@chao_o 愛國不分省份，台灣也有很多愛國者只是噤聲而已，就像大陸也有不少分裂主義一樣。
一樣米養百樣人，啥鳥都有。
@@chinz4556 晚清的时候看的国家分裂的感觉真的很不舒服。
正常情況吧！沙俄五百年的擴張成果也在1991年丟了中亞，高加索，白俄羅斯，烏克蘭，摩爾多瓦。
Maybe also do a Modern History of Germany from 1860 Every Month
1860 is a weird date, something more reasonable would be either 1815, 1848, 1867, or 1871
@@octopus_72 It’s not Weird. You see it’s exactly 6 years away from the Austro-Prussian War. Which changed the course of German History. The War would Made Austria Weaker but Prussia Stronger to the point of them being able to defeat The 2nd French Empire in the Franco-Prussian War (1870-1871), which created the German Empire. Therefore 1860 is an Appropriate Date. What you said about 1815. I took it into consideration and the would make the video too much Longer. And also from 1815 to The Year of the Schleswig Wars (Prussia, Austrian Empire vs Denmark). They were Peaceful and has not done any major wars up until that point. Therefore proving my Point 1860 is a Major Start Day.
@@ClassicalMusicMan 1848 is more appropriate, also *The war would make, not made
@@octopus_72 well I thank you for the Grammar Fix. But I stand by my answer
@@ClassicalMusicMan lol, for us Chinese, German history video should start from the Holy Roman Empire in 1522. Because the birth of the German nation was based on language, Martin Luther translated the Bible in that year, the concept of the Deutschland nation state came into being.
终于有人知道实际上文革时期的代理主席是宋庆龄和董必武了
这个视频很令人费解的点在于，你标注了捻乱和云南回乱，但是却没标比这两个范围大多了的陕甘回乱，白彦虎阿古柏合流也没体现出来，属于是看了开头就看不下去了
An error: in 1912-1949 it should be QingHai, not Ninghai. it's a province.
作者蠻用心的，把中國和台灣的關係充分的展現出來。
应该是中国大陆和中国台湾的关系吧？
@@huazhang4811 不是中國 是中華
@@劉秉宸-d7v 就一个破岛也敢叫中华？谁给你的勇气？梁静茹吗
@@huazhang4811 7414
@Cigma Lee 敢來 我殺一個是一個
China be like:
Great Qing has joined the game.
Great Qing has leaved the game.
Republic of China has joined the game.
Republic of China has leaved the game.
Republic of China has joined the game.
Republic of China has War the C.C.P
U.S.S.R has send a rebels name C.C.P
C.C.P has named People's Republic of China
Republic of China has Peace People's Republic of China
No.
U.S.S.R has send a rebels named Nationalist-Party aka KMT to Republic of China(Warlords) in 1924,
the C.C.P joint with KMT by the personal level.
And after ChiangKS's Amry part of KMT turned to the CCP, U.S.S.R had cut off conection with CCP. That's the main reason leading to alot of problem and weird thing in the 1945-1979 USSR-Sino relation ship.
can someone explain or give me the names of those kmt pockets that lasted till the 50s? i know about the KMT islamic insurgency but the one in Fujian i have never heard of thanks!
They were generally "bandits" who set bases in the mountains.
@@junyuanma4243 where they in KMT uniforms? or were they plainclothsmen? also are there pictures of these bandits?
福建地区好像有反共救国军
@@therthondaniel372There should be no Kuomintang organization, only authorization from the Kuomintang
There is a mistake that Dalian was not fully returned to PRC until 1955
amazing video
Huge respect to you for sneaking in "Flower of Freedom" at the end. Give me freedom or give me death!
"Give me freedom or give me death!!"
Meaning if you are robbed of your freedom you will stay subservient because you don't have what it takes to end yourself
This song Flower of Freedom 自由花 was singing in Cantonese. The lyrics was so touching and meaningful, too.
@@rainbowcat83我第一次听到粤语版的水手😂
lanfang is not part of Qing. Lanfang, a Chinese mining company, is located in the Mandor area under the protection of the Sambas Sultanate. finally Lanfang was dissolved by the Pontianak Sultanate which was supported by the Dutch and had a very large area in West Kalimantan.
It is Hakka country ❤ and I’m Hakka.
10:19 GUYS HERE IS THE BEST PART
*insert WW3 trailer here*
I can't believe that Hoi4 would lie to me about the Chinese warlord period. For shame
If you can, please make the History of Brazil from 1822 to 2024.
Why was part of Qinghai blue until around 1957?
At that time, the National Army of the Republic of China in Qinghai Province was still stubbornly resisting the People's Liberation Army of the People's Republic of China
科科蛋糕It is the Kekexili no-man's land (a movie about protecting Tibetan antelopes called Cocoxili), where less than 1,000 people live on hundreds of thousands of square kilometers.