Why Real Madrid SHOULD NOT Sign Alexander Arnold
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.พ. 2025
- Why Real Madrid SHOULD NOT Sign Alexander-Arnold ⚽ | A Perfect Fit or a Risky Move?
Real Madrid's pursuit of Trent Alexander-Arnold has sparked serious debate across football circles. As the star right-back continues to dazzle with his incredible passing range and attacking threat at Liverpool, the question remains-is he truly the right fit for Real Madrid's tactical system?
In this video, we explore:
Trent Alexander-Arnold's style of play: His brilliance in attack and the question of his defensive capabilities.
The Real Madrid philosophy: Are they looking for another Galactico, or is Trent’s weaknesses something they’ll regret?
The comparison with Dani Carvajal: Real Madrid's current rock in the right-back position-can Trent do better?
We also dive into:
The balance between attacking flair and defensive reliability.
The evolution of Real Madrid's youth-driven recruitment strategy and how Trent fits in this vision.
Why bringing Trent in might be a step backward in terms of defensive stability.
Would this move be the right one for Los Blancos? Or should they stick with their current options? Let's break it down.
Don’t forget to subscribe to Futbol Historia for more deep dives into football's biggest stories and tactical analyses! 🔔
#RealMadrid #TrentAlexanderArnold #FootballTransfers #Galacticos #LaLiga #LiverpoolFC #ChampionsLeague #Tactics #FootballAnalysis #TransferTal #FabrizioRomano - กีฬา
First plz pin
👍
Pin "Sugondese"
@@FutbolHistoria88 thanks bro
Bruh
In summary Trent is a attacking player and real madrid are struggling in defence so they should buy a proper defender
yeah...agree, but who knows? Maybe he will renew the contract with Liverpool 😁
Doesn't matter Madrid will Obviously manage a good defensive RB also
Proper right back like who
Real Madrid doesn't really care about defending.. although they need defenders. I say we STILL take Trent and use him in a different position
@@alinesi237 Kimmich
Respect To my man, Cafucus Vazquez . RWF playing as a makeshift RB and still balling attacking wise.
People forget that Capello benched Beckham after signing for LA Galaxy and Real were in such a bad slump he had to bring Beckham back and he was literally the best player on the Galactico's. One of those thing you can't google or find on youtube.
Good point man! 👍👏
That is why Madrid have made Saliba their secondary target someone like Saliba can play the role that Van Dijk does for Liverpool and cover the space Trent leaves when he moves forward.
Totally get what you're saying! Saliba could be a solid pick. Can’t wait to see how this all plays out!
I still don’t understand why not go for a defensive RB. The team needs balance, and someone like Saliba can’t just cover for a player the entire game. He’s got his own job. Against any attacking team, that defense would get sliced open
If Trent joins Real Madrid, one change Carlo must do is to make the pressing cohesive. Currently, Real Madrid are a trying to press high but it hasn't been cohesive at all. Jude and Rodrygo try to press but we need to see more intent from both Mbappe and Vini. Speaking about them, in the past few games, I can see more intent from Mbappe and its easier to convert Vini to a presser because of his experiences in Brazil. But, the press hasn't still been cohesive (its a work in progress I believe) and they still leave gaps. This allows transitions and puts burden on fullbacks to cover 1v1s vs wingers and just like Lucas, Trent isn't good in these situations unlike Dani Carvajal. At the left side, it isn't a big problem as Ferland Mendy is a specialist in these 1v1s, I do know currently he isn't at his best but last season there was a stretch where he only got dribbled past once. At the right, Carvajal was a specialist as well, not to mention, he kept a terrifying winger like Musiala quiet in both UCL semifinal in Bernabeu and euros quarterfinal. Trent isn't and leaving him vulnerable in 1v1s will only expose his weaknesses. If the press is cohesive, it allows to win the ball high up the pitch and make sure the RB doesn't get tested as much. This is sth Ancelotti needed to do long time ago even when Lucas was playing, he's currently trying and I hope he can implement this cohesive style of pressing sooner.
However, If Ancelotti can make the tactical change I mentioned above, I do think that Trent to Real Madrid makes 100% sense especially in possession. One condition is Ferland Mendy needs to return to his best, because at his best, he's one of the most press resistant fullbacks itw and so is Trent. So, it allows a route for buildup. Having Trent also reduces the burden of ball progression from both Ceballos and Valverde as he's a juggernaut when it comes to progressive passing and diagonal switches. The other thing Ancelotti needs to do is to use his power of friendship and help him improve defensively. A team cannot press high all the time and there will be times he'll be tested.
Thank you for sharing your insights! It’s always great to hear detailed analysis from passionate fans like you. Your thoughts on the pressing game and player roles are really valuable!
Everyone is saying real madrid problem is defence so trent is not fit
But the real problem is vasquez position he is not the guy who makes long passes he is fast and make runs near penalty box during attack so his RB position is always vulnerable
But trent does that from midfield he makes passes from there
So he can get back to his position quickly and fill the spaces
Such a detailed analysis never seen on yt bro keep it up really liked how you explained all things here it really got my attention ... loved the video!!
Much appreciated! Thx for your feedback! 🙏🫡❤️
Trent is a tree who's giving lots more options for the team and can still be molded for a more defensive fullback because he has potential and flexibility
Trent has a bigger upside than the downside, he is going to do the Marcelo role
I think Achraf hakimi would be a better successor for Dani Carvajal in Real Madrid CF.
As long as Madrid outscore ther opps dnt matter if Trent is a defensive player 😂
For all the people giving options like Hakimi and Porro and saying no to TAA (although he's not a guaranteed signing yet either) let me tell you this first:
1. Hakimi and Porro both are not as good as TAA offensively. TAA is generational attacking RB.
2. Porro and Hakimi both have many years to go in their contracts with Hakimi just re signing as well and their cost would be HUGE considering we have to deal with Levy for Porro and RMA's relationship with PSG is not good at all. Sources inside RMA says Hakimi is impossible.
3. Historically RMA has always always prioritized attacking fullbacks as that is our ethos.
4. With changes in tactics and advancements in them, a defensive structure always negates most of the cons of attacking fullbacks and what TAA lacks in defence he makes it up with offence.
5. The actual best RB option for us would've been Reece James as he's most similar to Carvajal (very balanced offence and defence with physicality too) but it's a shame he's made out of glass and his career is borderline over now.
6. Besides this the only other option actually would be ball playing CB who can slot in as RB if ya all really like no negatives in defence but that's not going to happen either.
You make some solid points about TAA's offensive capabilities and the challenges with signing players like Hakimi and Porro. It's definitely a complex situation for Real Madrid, and your analysis highlights the intricacies involved in these transfer decisions.
@@FutbolHistoria88 hakimi cant defend
We need stability in defence and Trent is not tuat guy
Please, NO. We need DEFENDER , a feared defender
Listen Trent solves our freekick problem, combined with Valverde's direct bullets, he scores goal.. his crosses are way more pinpoint. Marcelo couldn't really defend as well as Carvajal on the opposite end. I think we just need to make sure our left back is a strong defender, I feel Trent is better than Vasquez going forward anyway. Or well, knowing Ancelotti he could move him forward into midfield successfully
Hmm, good point 👍
We have NO ONE in attack to cross to all of them prefer playing at their feet. This is why I believe we should’ve signed a proper ST opposed to Mbappe
@@J0shuaG0916 No No No.. Mbappé is the best player in the world and a fan of the club from childhood, you can't be a Real Madrid supporter and regret his signing. Name a ST better than him even with the #9 not being his preferred position.. he's literally just 2 goals behind a natural 9 (Lewandowski) who is one of the best strikers ever. I maintain that what we need is to fix our backline and considering that Mbappé came for free, I say Trent can come for free too in the summer, while we try to spend money on a defender who can possibly be a backup signing
@ Watch his games in PSG or the world cup, nobody currently is better at scoring volleys than Mbappé. He used to score one touch volleys from Di Maria, Messi, Hakimi or Neymar's crosses
@dynamite Science cannot explain the mind of a Madrid fan 🤣
I think Real can give Raul into that possession.
Regardless, defense should be improved next season. I truly hope they try and bring back miguel gutierrez. Just makes sense hes been fantastic and will be only 24. Have him and Fran Garcia as two LB, TAA and Carvajal RB then you have Asencio, Rudiger, Alaba and Militao filling in CB positions. Thats an improved defense by any standards next season!
The thing is that you are trusting that Alaba and Militao will return to a good level from long-term injuries along with a great impact. They could perfectly return being much worse than they were. In addition, the 4-0 against Barcelona was with Militao and Mendy in the line-up.
@ early season Barca and that 4-0 came after a thundering of offsides plays by Mbappe before he’s found his form. Mendy sucks. Asencio better. Alaba verdict is still out but you’re right about carvajal and militao. Who knows what happens when they come back. Regardless Xavi will be coach at that time. See what happens.
He is a good player but I don’t think he is up to the standards of Madrid.
the defensiveness isnt the best argument, cuz they're already playing the very very offensive vazquez, trent is still a more defensive minded player. If needed there will also be the midfield or the winger to help cover in defense if trent goes infront
RM plays a diamond midfield thats why they are signing attacking fullbacks
Vasquez is just an average RW playing RB.
Tchouameni is a CDM playing CB
Thery got a Rookie plating LB
Their 3 attackers are all LW and short, cant score headers.
Real Madrid is a pretty bad team and is winning on pure talent and Aura.
EC playing lb
Real Madrid needs Trent, he’s my preferred right back.
taa and hakimi are both defensive liabilities
Alexander Arnold is gonna be a legend in some time from now but David Beckham was different
Theo Hernandez is an option we should be looking deeper into
Pedro Porro is a much better opti5
To expensive atleast 70mil price
I was getting what you were saying until Lucas Vazquez and Trent commented it’s a big difference Trent can defend better than Lucas because Lucas is a rm-rw force to play rb and plus Dani will be a good backup to show Trent the ropes so he is ready to pass the torch to trent
Have you even watched his game against man united he was as horrible as vazquez in the defense. Madrid should focus on a young player who can be adapted as per squad's requirement
@ trust me we have all seen Lucas Vazquez against a high pace winger and Trent is far better than that and you’re comparing one game to seven matches leao was cooking Lucas and smiling about it
Totally get what you mean! Trent’s got skills, and with Dani to guide him, he might just be the RB we didn’t know we needed!
@ oh no we need Trent 1000 percent Rapahina and leao still haunted me to this day Rapahina and leao literally did a tag team to who will cook Lucas Rapahina cooked him leao killed him
@ It's not the 1st time arnold has faced heavy criticism for his poor defending. Against big teams his flaw has always been costly. With many attacking minded players, the team is already disbalanced and ceballos is doing 20% of what kroos used to do. We need someone who can defend as well
2:48 isn't that mostly because PSG refused to sell him? Madrid was willing to pay 200 millions for him the first time they tried to sign him
Marcelo or Roberto Carlos. The 2 best lb's in Real's history were NEVER known as good defenders and they turned out well.
But the do have that Brazilian flair TAA does not have 😂
Real Madrid knows this player weaknesses he is not strong on defense someone is going to cover his back they need someone to start the attack from the back for years they have a problem from the side to start an attack from the back.
I love kounde better than Arnold
kounde video is coming soon... 👍
@FutbolHistoria88 plz make a video of the comparison between pep guardiolas Barcelona and hansi flick
@ noted! Thx for the idea.
Trent could literally be the next Beckham
Kylian Mbappe cost Real Madrid €150m in signing bonus
Which software do you use to edit
adobe premiere
He can score goals like how Roberto Carlos used to score from LB
“Why real madrid should not sign trent”
-Every Barcelona fan
The galactios never worked
What ur talking abt bro bbc era did 3 peat of ucl
WE NEED HIM WE LOST OUR RB
Trent is better than Lucas Vazquez, but not Carvajal
What about hakimi
Doesn't seem to want to leave psg
He just renew his contract with PSG…
That would mean Real made a mistake letting him go, they would never admit that
I think he a good rb the synergy with mbappe would be deadly
Trent is destined for Madrid he's the best passer of the ball currently and Madrid's needs a passer of the ball
We ll see 👍
Madrid defence is the weak link but he’ll be for free
well alphonso davies is an eliite defender
Dani can get another injury
As a treat, for the fans
How bout someone like dumfries?
Trent can play in the Kroos role
@@muhammadkhaleel8352 that would be veeeery interesting to see 👍
say it with me, tchou-a-me-ni!
Did fam no justice