No appreciation is adequate for Mr Premasis Mukherjee, and Mr Arunava Khasnabis, as usual, complements Mr Mukherjee's explanation. Thanks a lot, both of you.
great content, great discussion and mainly great selection of books. Aaj ker dine khub relevant ekta topic, thanks a lot. Wait korchi aro onek onek interesting erokom discussion er jonno!!
1200$ & chopper evacuation & crashing(not mentioned), some fourth-wall break by the host were the best "tell tale" evocative dialogues that got exchanged , please do continue such as these..❤❤❤
The Dictator's Handbook by Mesquita & Smith reveals how political leaders, regardless of democracy or dictatorship, maintain power through rewarding loyal supporters. In current time , it mirrors local political dynamics, where patronage and alliances have shaped leadership and governance across different regimes. Thanks a lot for choosing this in appropriate time
অনুরোধ রইলো- Gods delusion, History of everything. Selfish gene, books on Leonardo da vinci এইসব বইগুলো যদি এই আসরে আনা যায় - কৃতজ্ঞ থাকব। অসাধারণ অনুসঠান।
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman baa Bangobandhu er Based kono Crtical/Analytical Book Jadi discuss koren, The Reasons Behind The Annoyance Of Bangladeshi ppl. against Him or his Tenure, looking Forward To Hear that kind of Discussion. 👍👌🏾🙏🇮🇳
This book examines positions of power (e.g. country leadership, mayors, CEOs, deans, etc.) by assuming entirely self-interested actors who seek to gain and retain power, and argues through examples that this relatively simple model gives the first order explanation of many world events. If you really grasp the message you'll adopt a much more cynical world view, but you'll also stop torturing yourself over stupid questions like what a country "ought" to do, what is "right", or why the people in power just can't see it. At the same time, spending some time in reality will reveal ways of remedying various suboptimal situations (e.g. the inefficacy of foreign aid) with solutions that recognize the root cause and manipulate incentive structures of those in power. The book supplements its thesis with various examples. For instance, resource-rich autocracies with small winning coalitions tend to oppress the population, which is irrelevant to the revenue needed to retain power. Conversely, there exists a curious tension in countries that cannot extract riches from the ground and instead rely on a productive population to generate wealth. This leads to the development of technologies that empower people, such as better communication networks, transportation infrastructure, education, etc., but these in turn pose a threat to those in power. There is also an element of "survival of the fittest" to systems with small winning coalitions, where even if a benevolent leader rises to power who wants to raise the standard of living for the masses, they are likely to become replaced by those who promise to redirect that wealth to the key supporters (e.g. those in charge of the police, military, treasury, etc.). A coup is significantly easier if these institutions turn a blind eye. The outlooks are somewhat better for an average person living in a democracy, because the incentives of the ruler are aligned with making the average person better off to win a re-election. In short, to understand the dynamics of a system of power the first order features to consider are 1) the nominal electorate (people who theoretically have influence), or the "interchangeables", 2) the real selectorate (the people who actually have the influence), or the "influentials" and 3) the winning coalition (the number of people required to keep power), or the "essentials". You can then solve for the dynamics. My main critique of the book is that it is simply too damn long, too repetitive, and badly in need of an experienced editor. You'll hear the same statements re-iterated ad nauseam, and in many cases you'll wish the author was more concrete instead of arguing in generalities, at a level where the abstraction washes out the complexity and makes the conclusions self-evident under the simple model. Therefore, I'd recommend that the reader selectively skips through the book, or watch CGPGrey's summary video ( www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7...), or the EconTalk podcasts featuring the author (e.g. www.econtalk.org/archives/_fea...).
High tax does discourage hard work but if the government ensure certain social benefits such as medical benefits, pension schemes and free education then people are willing to pay high taxes. Nordic countries have these kind of system.
I am glad I found this channel. Thank you. However, I have a suggestion. Never try to give real-life examples to illustrate an abstract idea, which you are willing to name. That will compromise your credibility, and may cast a shadow on both your selection of books, and the objectives of the discussion. And this is completely unnecessary for such a potentially rich discussion. 🙏
চমৎকার সময়োপযোগী বই বাছাই করেছেন।কৃতজ্ঞতা জানবেন🇧🇩🇧🇩
একটি গুরুত্বপূর্ণ বইয়ের চমৎকার সারসংক্ষেপ। বইটিতে বর্ণিত খলনায়কদের বর্ণনার সাথে মানানসই সাম্প্রতিক চরিত্রগুলি সনাক্ত করা বেশ সহজ।
"স্বৈরাচারীর সহজপাঠ ১ ভাগ "
অদ্ভুত ও অসাধারণ
ভারতীয় ভাষায় অনুবাদ হওয়া উচিৎ
বিদ্যালয় পাঠ্য হওয়া উচিৎ।
Mr Mukherjee is a perfect narrator to deliver the objective of this book.
একদম সত্যি কথা "perfect narrator to deliver the objective"।
কি দুর্দান্ত একটা বই! কি দারুণ আলোচনা। অসাধারণ।
No appreciation is adequate for Mr Premasis Mukherjee, and Mr Arunava Khasnabis, as usual, complements Mr Mukherjee's explanation. Thanks a lot, both of you.
বেশ সুন্দর ভাবে seriousness r চর্চা টা বজায় রাখার জন্য অশেষ ধন্যবাদ।
অনেক ধন্যবাদ ও ভালোবাসা
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।
গতকালও দেখেছিলাম আজও আবার দেখলাম। এক কথায় অসাধারণ ভাবে বোঝানো। নতুন করে পড়াশোনা করতে ইচ্ছা জাগল। অনেক ধন্যবাদ ...
A very contemporary topic especially for west bengal. Thank you for a wonderful discussion and enlightenment
চমৎকার বিশ্লেষণ। ভাল লাগল।
Khub I valo laglo., informative..,
great content, great discussion and mainly great selection of books. Aaj ker dine khub relevant ekta topic, thanks a lot. Wait korchi aro onek onek interesting erokom discussion er jonno!!
This is a million dollar episode❤❤
Thank you!
দারুণ 👍দুর্দান্ত বিশ্লেষণ 👌
Awesome laglo .. thanx ato sundar alochonar jonnoyo .. choice of books and discussions are enthralling .. keep going and all the best .
1200$ & chopper evacuation & crashing(not mentioned), some fourth-wall break by the host were the best "tell tale" evocative dialogues that got exchanged , please do continue such as these..❤❤❤
Please do a session on The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism & Slow Violence and the Environmentalism of the Poor
Thank you for your suggestion, we will consider it!
Sir অসাধারণ 👌✨
my fav youtube channel right now, watched all the episodes of Boithek
shob kirokom jeno mile mile jacche. Great discussion, now we realise that there is always a method to the "madness"
Uff ki shunlam👌👌👌
Darun choice of book
"Nexus" by Harari could be another nice choice.
Choluk ei discussion 👌sobkota sunchi ❤️
The Dictator's Handbook by Mesquita & Smith reveals how political leaders, regardless of democracy or dictatorship, maintain power through rewarding loyal supporters. In current time , it mirrors local political dynamics, where patronage and alliances have shaped leadership and governance across different regimes.
Thanks a lot for choosing this in appropriate time
Osomvob bhalo alochona. Apnader channel ta dekhe mone hai bangali ekhn o tar bangalitto dhore rekheche.
Very good awareness and relevant for the time
Very good presentation, perfect timing 😊
Thanks
Thanks a lot!
Oshadharon conversion 🙏
Very interesting and relevant ❤
Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you
অনুরোধ রইলো- Gods delusion, History of everything. Selfish gene, books on Leonardo da vinci এইসব বইগুলো যদি এই আসরে আনা যায় - কৃতজ্ঞ থাকব। অসাধারণ অনুসঠান।
অসাধারণ ❤
Relevant discussion
Exciting, enlightening and thought provoking! We want more episodes like this. This is an absolutely top tier content!
Darun darun darun 🎉❤
Khub bhalo
Khub bhalo laglo
Love from Bangladesh
Darun ❤
Please discuss the latest book of Yoval Noah Harari "Nexus"
অনেক ধন্যবাদ আমাদের জ্ঞানচক্ষু উন্মোচনের জন্যে
Huuummmmmmmmmmmmmmm.......!!
Salute to both of you :)
Sundor alochona... dhonnobad
Congratulations 🎉
osadharon...... apnader boi select gulo dekhechi darun ...kemon jano protibar i bastob circumstance er sathe mile jay..apnader osonkho dhonnoybad amader ai bhabe sikhitto kore tolar jonno..arr chaibo apnara sob somoy amader aiibhabe sikhito korun...amar join korar khomota nai noile obossoi kortam asa kori bhobisote join korte parbo.aro akbar Ontor theke onek onek dhoonobad ar ovinondon...
Darun laglo 👍🏻
Like, indirectly taking about Hasina
Joined as a member
Thank you so much!!!
Thank you!
thanks,
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you
The Uninhabitable Earth by Devid Wallace-Wells might be a good book to discuss.
Got it👌👍🏽🙏🏼🇮🇳
Nice
প্রেমশিস দা বি লাইক - “হাজার ডলার কিন্তু!” 😂
Please cover the biography of Isaac Newton by Walter Isaacson
dollar kintu. haha. eta shera chilo
Rahul Sanskrityayan er Volga To Ganga/Ganges oper Discussion er Request janachii👌👍🏽🙏🏼🇮🇳
Thank you for your suggestion!!
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman baa Bangobandhu er Based kono Crtical/Analytical Book Jadi discuss koren, The Reasons Behind The Annoyance Of Bangladeshi ppl. against Him or his Tenure, looking Forward To Hear that kind of Discussion. 👍👌🏾🙏🇮🇳
Thank you for your suggestion!
❤❤❤
The most difficult job of today's episode for Premashis Sir was giving "hypothetical" example. And for Arunava Sir it was hiding his understandings. 🤣
This book examines positions of power (e.g. country leadership, mayors, CEOs, deans, etc.) by assuming entirely self-interested actors who seek to gain and retain power, and argues through examples that this relatively simple model gives the first order explanation of many world events. If you really grasp the message you'll adopt a much more cynical world view, but you'll also stop torturing yourself over stupid questions like what a country "ought" to do, what is "right", or why the people in power just can't see it. At the same time, spending some time in reality will reveal ways of remedying various suboptimal situations (e.g. the inefficacy of foreign aid) with solutions that recognize the root cause and manipulate incentive structures of those in power.
The book supplements its thesis with various examples. For instance, resource-rich autocracies with small winning coalitions tend to oppress the population, which is irrelevant to the revenue needed to retain power. Conversely, there exists a curious tension in countries that cannot extract riches from the ground and instead rely on a productive population to generate wealth. This leads to the development of technologies that empower people, such as better communication networks, transportation infrastructure, education, etc., but these in turn pose a threat to those in power. There is also an element of "survival of the fittest" to systems with small winning coalitions, where even if a benevolent leader rises to power who wants to raise the standard of living for the masses, they are likely to become replaced by those who promise to redirect that wealth to the key supporters (e.g. those in charge of the police, military, treasury, etc.). A coup is significantly easier if these institutions turn a blind eye. The outlooks are somewhat better for an average person living in a democracy, because the incentives of the ruler are aligned with making the average person better off to win a re-election.
In short, to understand the dynamics of a system of power the first order features to consider are 1) the nominal electorate (people who theoretically have influence), or the "interchangeables", 2) the real selectorate (the people who actually have the influence), or the "influentials" and 3) the winning coalition (the number of people required to keep power), or the "essentials". You can then solve for the dynamics.
My main critique of the book is that it is simply too damn long, too repetitive, and badly in need of an experienced editor. You'll hear the same statements re-iterated ad nauseam, and in many cases you'll wish the author was more concrete instead of arguing in generalities, at a level where the abstraction washes out the complexity and makes the conclusions self-evident under the simple model. Therefore, I'd recommend that the reader selectively skips through the book, or watch CGPGrey's summary video ( www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7...), or the EconTalk podcasts featuring the author (e.g. www.econtalk.org/archives/_fea...).
A princely imposter - এই বইটি নিয়ে একটা এপিসোডের দাবী রইলো
Akta fan meet kro plzzzz❤️
কী জানি এত রিলেট কেন করে ফেলছি প্রতিটা কথা 😂
Thailand’s raja’r story.. even late Queen ElizabethII was not aware of her ill health..
Timing & Relevance: show me a stunt
Premashish da: hold my beer
ইশারা হি কাফি হ্যায় ♥️
The 48 laws of power boi ti niye alochana hole bhalo hoy.
বর্তমান বাংলার প্রেক্ষাপটে এই বিশ্লেষণ হলে আরো ভালো লাগতো।
এই বইটা শেখ হাসিনা পড়লে, আরো কিছুদিন ক্ষমতায় থাকতে পারতো।
👌👍🏽🙏🏼🇮🇳
High tax does discourage hard work but if the government ensure certain social benefits such as medical benefits, pension schemes and free education then people are willing to pay high taxes. Nordic countries have these kind of system.
Modi ,momota, jyoti bosu, gandhi family sob kotai chamaaaar....promanito ❤❤❤❤....ar real hero holen jawaharlal nehru, lal bahadur shastri ,pv narsinha rao ar Manmohan singh er moto keo keo❤❤❤❤
Aapnader channel khub taratari bandha hoye jabe... 😂😂😂😂
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।
আপনি যেটা বই পড়ে জানতে পেরেছেন আমি সেটা NEWS দেখে জেনেছি।😅
কিভাবে মেম্বার হব? বাংলাদেশ থেকে
'৩৪'টা কী ফ্রয়েডিয়ান স্লিপ ছিলো, দাদা?
Man’s search for meaning - boita niye ektu alochona hole bhalo hoy. Setao ek somoyupojogi alochona.
এগুলো যারা যানে তাদের শাসক কখনোই মানতে চাইনা।
এটা শুনতে শুনতে বারবার আমার এই রাজ্যের পরিপ্রেক্ষিত টা মনে হচ্ছে কেন?? মনে হয় মনে পাপ আমার😉
Karon ei muhurte desher bhoyaboho shashokshoktir jara somorthok tader etai mone hoi.
আজকের সমস্যা। শ্রী প্রভাতরঞ্জন সরকারের লেখা ব ইটি পড়তে অনুরোধ র ইলো। আর একটি ব ই বুদ্ধির মুক্তি- নব্যমানবতাবাদ। অবশ্য ই পড়বেন। ধন্যবাধ।
মেম্বারশিপ কিভাবে পাব?
জয়েন বাটন টায় ক্লিক করতে হবে, সাবস্ক্রাইব বাটন টার পাশে! অনেক ধন্যবাদ!
আগা মাথা শুনেছি, কিন্তু কিছু বুঝতে পারলাম না😂
I am glad I found this channel. Thank you. However, I have a suggestion. Never try to give real-life examples to illustrate an abstract idea, which you are willing to name. That will compromise your credibility, and may cast a shadow on both your selection of books, and the objectives of the discussion. And this is completely unnecessary for such a potentially rich discussion. 🙏
এই বইটা কি দিদি 12 বছর আগে পড়েছিলেন?
IPAC - প্রাক্তন মালিক প্রশান্ত কিশোর পড়েছিল।
এ বাবা হুবুহু মিলে যাচ্ছে তো!
মেম্বার হলে সুফল কি ?
Hasinar kotha bola hoocche bole mone holo amar.. hahaha
A আর L 😂
SOMOI UPOJOGI ALOCHONA.SOBGULO SUNECI BANGLADESH THEKE
Dictator spotted !!😂
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।
মেম্বারশিপ কিভাবে পাব?
জয়েন বাটন টায় ক্লিক করতে হবে, সাবস্ক্রাইব বাটন টার পাশে! অনেক ধন্যবাদ!
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।
হোস্ট আপনাকে বলছি আপনি হুম হুম করবেন না। আপনি কথা বলুন আলোচনা অংশগ্রহণ করুন। গেস্ট এর কথার মধ্যে হুম হুম করবেন না। আমরা বিরক্ত হই।