Precipice can’t be lacking tier because it is actual music. And it’s good imo. EDIT: So this comment was made 3 months ago at the time of this edit and, wow. When I made this comment, I thought precipice was alright, nothing groundbreaking, but absolutely not lacking. But over the past month, I’ve found myself listening to it constantly. It fills me with indescribable joy and happiness. It has become my favorite music disc in the game, dethroning pigstep for me. TL;DR: Precipice is my new favorite disc. Aaron Cherof COOKED!!
I think it’s something super subjective. When the new discs came out, I loved creator in its two versions, but I really hated precipice. However I saw a lot of people at twitter loving precipice and hating creator. In my opinion, I’d also say precipice is lacking, I consider it boring, but again, it’s just muy opinion
@@dydierripe5611 Same here, I do think Creator is the best. I think what some dislike about the song is the pauses that "cut" the flow. But precipice is very, Very repetitive. It is juste "fine" at best. It's like you can't love these two songs at the same time, really interesting.
If you’re gonna put the lore discs in the bottom tiers because they’re not good musically then it would probably make sense to not include them in the tier list.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who strongly disagrees with not only the rankings, but the reasons for the rankings. "Reminds me of classic 2013 Minecraft"; that's just nostalgia getting in the way of him properly judging the discs.
Calling an EDM track dubstep is criminal, there’s a huge difference between the two that this guy is clearly missing. Also I’m ok with someone having a different view of something. However, hear me out, THERE IS NO JUSTIFICATION OF PUTTING THE MUSIC BOX VERSION OF CREATOR OVER THE ORIGINAL. Creator is such a thematic and fun masterpiece of a track. How dare you!!??
5, 11, and 13 are all S tier and I’ll tell you why, count to 13 and when you reach 5 play 5, when you reach 11 play 11, when you reach thirteen play 13. It creates a story almost, as if you were getting chased by a enderman
PERSONALLY YALL. If that were me. Otherside and precipice are BANGERS++ Relic is Banger+. Strad goes in Banger++ PLUS Og Tier " Wait " is Banger+ tier I ain't gonna lie, I'd also put Ward in Banger. But not Banger+ or ++ AND FAVOURITE ( NOT MUSIC DISC ) ONE EVER. IS MINECRAFT SWEDEN- BANGER A+++ ( otherside and precipice are my fav music discs and also relic)
Never let bro cook, putting mellohi in good? The bangers are both versions of creator otherside pigstep and mellohi I thought that (not including creator) was universally agreed on
2:44 it not creepy i like it. cuz of alan becker cuz he used it for blue stick figure when he cooks that why i like it and i also a good music edit: What! why would you put stal in rip eardrums bro that my 2nd favorite disk i completely disagree
I have to be honest, cat just isn’t that good in my opinion. By “not that good” I mean in comparison to other discs. All Minecraft music is really amazing. Cat is the only actually musical disc a majority of people will get. The other discs are gotten more rarely and in more specific ways, but people will find 13 and cat in most dungeons. The other OG music discs are such bangers compared to cat, it’s just nobody listened to them much. And the newer music discs, just truly amazing. Cat is nostalgic to me, but I just can’t rank it higher than a fair amount of other discs.
He ain't that bad he's a boomer I understand even if the new ones are good he may not be used to it me personally I like the new ones because I feel like there from specific eras in the minecraft lore
IMO the 3 new discs are all bangers and so is stal. I swear those recorders are so awkward they remind of when my younger brother wouldn't SHUT UP with his, sounds damn hilarious
I wonder how many people don't even listen to Chirp long enough to reach the part where it doesn't sound like it's being played on an old Phonograph. Thats's my favorite part and it definitely adds to the disc ( Edit )
I understand the Recorder complaint... another reason why I hated 4th Grade... But Stal is an amazing disc besides, I honestly hope in the future, they could another disc that gives off the same vibes... Stal is evidence enough that Jazz music works well with Minecraft.
The correct list: Banger: Creator, Precipice, Otherside, Cat, Chirp, Pigstep, Relic Good: Wait, Creator MB, Mellohi Alright: Ward, Far, Blocks, Strad Lacking: Stal (it would be a banger if the made the flute not make my ears bleed) RIP Eardrums: 13, 5, 11
Strad is banger for me. So is Pigstep!, my ranking is 1) Pigstep 2) Strad 3) Cat, then Wait and Chirp and a few others are right there. but love the video man, thank you! now I want to go collect more discs!!!
When I first started playing Minecraft, around 2014, if I remember right... I'd say Wait and Strad were my favorite discs, more upbeat than Mall, but they still had a good calming vibe to them.
13: ears bleeding Cat: Cats Blocks: blocky Chirp: Old school Far: the void Mall: Backrooms Mellohi: Mafia gaming Stal: Recess Strad: bing chilling Ward: forgettable 11: Creepy Wait: Elevator Otherside: Me showcasing my builds 5: Marching until the warden pulled u Pigstep: Technoblade never dies Relic: My ears hurt Creator/ music box: I’m in your house vibes Prerecipe: Japanese samurai fight intro
Strad is definitely the most nostalgic music disc for me. I didn't play much Minecraft before it's revival in 1.13, but when I did I must have found that disk, because it really takes me back
Stal under disc 11, really? Why is my favorite disc always being bullied like that😭
FACTS
Indeed, Stal is the best disc. Some people see it, others are wrong😃
Rip ear drums NAH
Stal is fire i feel that the bad recorder adds a personality to it
stal and creator are the 2 best and if you disagree you are objectively wrong
HOW THE FUCK IS CREATOR IN ALRIGHT AND NOT BANGER
how tf is cat on banger and creator not
@@zenit2161 exactly
Ikr guys… fuckin outrage
@@zenit2161 because creator is decent the real question is why precipice lacking it’s the best music disc
Creator is the best disc
no way creator and preciepe arent S tier
both kinda mid
If it were me, Creator would be S and Precipice A tier. Note Creator is now my favourite music disc, keep doin your thing Lena
Fr
Agreed. Sue this man for not putting creator and precipe in s tier
I agree 100%
Far in Alright tier is a war crime and you shall pay for your sins
Both Creator variants are certified bangers in my eye
I agree
How do you get them???
@@Blopy123prob from trial chambers
@@mariofire3940 yea
i completely disagree
Precipice can’t be lacking tier because it is actual music. And it’s good imo.
EDIT: So this comment was made 3 months ago at the time of this edit and, wow. When I made this comment, I thought precipice was alright, nothing groundbreaking, but absolutely not lacking. But over the past month, I’ve found myself listening to it constantly. It fills me with indescribable joy and happiness. It has become my favorite music disc in the game, dethroning pigstep for me.
TL;DR: Precipice is my new favorite disc. Aaron Cherof COOKED!!
No he is right for once
Precipice is a good music disc, I agree with you
I think it’s something super subjective. When the new discs came out, I loved creator in its two versions, but I really hated precipice.
However I saw a lot of people at twitter loving precipice and hating creator.
In my opinion, I’d also say precipice is lacking, I consider it boring, but again, it’s just muy opinion
@@dydierripe5611 Same here, I do think Creator is the best. I think what some dislike about the song is the pauses that "cut" the flow. But precipice is very, Very repetitive. It is juste "fine" at best. It's like you can't love these two songs at the same time, really interesting.
@@crunchywashere3513wdym? precipice is 1 of the best, and stal is pretty good
I like how when 13 started playing, there were some glitched parts of the video in the corner which seems to show a later part of the video.
Tell me the time
0:39 ohh I see it now buddy
I keep seeing glitches
honestly Strad is underrated it's one of my favorites
Agreed.
Same with mellohi and ward
@@mariofire3940 Mellholi sounds like the Baldi's Basics music
@@ExodiumPlays eh not really
@@mariofire3940 the chase music? To me it does but that's just imo
Why did bro put stal at the bottom its the goat😭😭😭
It's very nice I love it
It's the best one (I'm so sorry in advance)
Because its thier options
If you’re gonna put the lore discs in the bottom tiers because they’re not good musically then it would probably make sense to not include them in the tier list.
nah bro precipice is a BANGER. period
Creator in Alright is a war crime
its terrible
@@synnrs the song?
@@linrayzou5952 yes
@@synnrs u sure u listend to Creator and not Creator music box?
@@linrayzou5952 yes, its not good
I'm glad I'm not the only one who strongly disagrees with not only the rankings, but the reasons for the rankings. "Reminds me of classic 2013 Minecraft"; that's just nostalgia getting in the way of him properly judging the discs.
this tier list is a crime how
Who let bro cook?💀
is no one gonna talk about the end part of chirp being the best possible tune ever created?
I've been waiting for this one
bro tried to cook and turned off the stove
Calling an EDM track dubstep is criminal, there’s a huge difference between the two that this guy is clearly missing. Also I’m ok with someone having a different view of something. However, hear me out, THERE IS NO JUSTIFICATION OF PUTTING THE MUSIC BOX VERSION OF CREATOR OVER THE ORIGINAL. Creator is such a thematic and fun masterpiece of a track. How dare you!!??
Putting "Creator" in the middle should be a crime
why do I think I've seen Ur account on SoundCloud
I didn’t like precipice until it got in the snapshots, when listening to it in the context of fighting in a trial chamber it becomes a total banger.
I just can't not associate pigstep, chirp and mellohi with Animation vs. Minecraft
AvM was the first time I even heard Mellohi lol
@@cousinoftheflame01 same, i thought it wasn't a minecraft music disc
@@Some_guy_iguess Yeah exactly
Never let bro rank again
This gave me goosebumps of bostalgia, especially Ward, my personal favorite when i used to play xbox 360 edition
🎶 Times of the different music disc’s:
1- Blocks 0:16
2- 13 0:40
3- Creator 1:11
4- Cat 1:41
5- Relic 2:06
6- Chirp 2:32
7- 5 3:10
8- Far 3:42
9- Creator (Music Box) 4:10
10- 11 4:38
11- Mall 5:03
12- Mellohi 5:28
13- Otherside 5:53
14- Stal 6:20
15- Strad 6:51
16- Pigstep (My Fav) 7:16
17- Wait 7:48
18- Ward 8:18
19- Precipice 8:45
I think this list is eh. Bro did not really cook.
I...
How do 11 and Precipice end up in the same tier? Are your speakers low quality and butchering the sound for you?
Man cooked so hard he burned the food
5, 11, and 13 are all S tier and I’ll tell you why, count to 13 and when you reach 5 play 5, when you reach 11 play 11, when you reach thirteen play 13. It creates a story almost, as if you were getting chased by a enderman
WHO LET BRO COOK THE KITCHEN IS ON FIRE
Pigstep just hits different for me my favorite ngl
Even tho this is not a music disc Mice On Venus is best
PS:thx for putting otherside on banger
PERSONALLY YALL. If that were me. Otherside and precipice are BANGERS++ Relic is Banger+. Strad goes in Banger++ PLUS Og Tier " Wait " is Banger+ tier I ain't gonna lie, I'd also put Ward in Banger. But not Banger+ or ++ AND FAVOURITE ( NOT MUSIC DISC ) ONE EVER. IS MINECRAFT SWEDEN- BANGER A+++ ( otherside and precipice are my fav music discs and also relic)
"The Fat Controller laughed. 'You are wrong.'"
creator at alright??? did u listen to 5 seconds of it?
Ain't no way he put Stal in the lowest tier and creator in alright, those are two of my favorite discs along with pigstep
How did you put cat in banger but put mall in alright
Stal and Pigstep are my favorites, also my friends and i call mellohi "Soviet Bread-making music"
C418 are from Soviet Union(fathers) 😎😎👍🏻
I don't understand why many people hate Stall because Stall is a good music disc in my opinion, plus Jazz music is really cool.
Creator is just objectively an S tier song
Ward sounds like something from subnautica
Why do I get the feeling that you rate things more on nostalgia, instead of how good the actual music is?
fun fact: the sound in the 5 music disc isn't actually the warden, but rather the endersent from minecraft dungeons
Never let bro cook, putting mellohi in good? The bangers are both versions of creator otherside pigstep and mellohi I thought that (not including creator) was universally agreed on
Why’d you do precipice like that
Common logic: Creator>Creator music box. This man has sinned
How is creator in the middl, i understand opinion but man its got to be at least is good
Its my favorite ngl
I keep re-listening to disk 5, because I somewhat like it…
What was that test you wanted the disk 13 enjoyers to take again?
why tf did you put creator low for having a modern vibe and then put otherside, which is objectively worse, high for the same reason
The last music disc reminds me of map osts from flood escape 2
I knew bro was brain dmged when he put creator in alright. Okay buddy...
Sorry you put Creator in a tier under Banger I’m clicking off 1:35
ikr
Mall sounds like something from hello neighbor
Nahhhh he called 13 not lore
creator is a mp and pigstep is an mp too
Stal in lowest tier is acceptable.
It sounds good and all.
But ive heard it too much
2:44 it not creepy i like it. cuz of alan becker cuz he used it for blue stick figure when he cooks that why i like it and i also a good music
edit: What! why would you put stal in rip eardrums bro that my 2nd favorite disk i completely disagree
Putting precipice in the same tier as 11 is crazy
So everyone likes creator?….Yay!!🎉
chirp sounds like your in the backrooms
Precipice in lacking? You must repent for your sins.
I will never forgive you for placing Stal in RIP Eardrums. (jk of course but imo it's really one of the best discs)
Bro's taste is nonexistent
I have to be honest, cat just isn’t that good in my opinion. By “not that good” I mean in comparison to other discs. All Minecraft music is really amazing. Cat is the only actually musical disc a majority of people will get. The other discs are gotten more rarely and in more specific ways, but people will find 13 and cat in most dungeons. The other OG music discs are such bangers compared to cat, it’s just nobody listened to them much. And the newer music discs, just truly amazing. Cat is nostalgic to me, but I just can’t rank it higher than a fair amount of other discs.
almost perfect tier list. good work.
NAH he underestimated percipiece and stal
6:48 ayyyyy
Naahhhhhh he called him c-4-1-8💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
7:35 I went back to check and he really did say it like that 💀💀💀💀
Why is precipice in the same tier as 11 and 5
cause its trash
@@synnrs *creator is trash
People who dislike Stal just hate whimsy, there's no other way to put it.
HOW, how Creator original disk is "alright" and musical box is good???
Both disks to banger.
Wait is no nostalgic for me it’s unreal
w guy I love chirp relic is good ngl
Guys Stal Isn’t That Bad It’s Decent.
bro this tier list is a absolute war crime
Nah bro otherside is the best
@@BanBloxxnah ward is the best
THIS IS WORSE THAN A WAR CRIME
nah putting stal in lowest tier, precipice lacking and putting creator in the middle are sins
Edit: how did this blow up like TNT lol
war crimes if you will
SO True
Yes
It didn't blow up though
5.287 likes a day
Never let bro cook again👽
Edit: glorp? Zoonky Zoomby?
zorp zorp worp 👽
Gworpie florp warp 👽
fr fr
Flomp slomp👽
Zeemy zory beww👽
NEVER LET THIS MAN RANK MUSIC DISKS AGAIN
Yes
yes, we need more likes on this comment,
Yes
He ain't that bad he's a boomer I understand even if the new ones are good he may not be used to it me personally I like the new ones because I feel like there from specific eras in the minecraft lore
For real
IMO the 3 new discs are all bangers and so is stal. I swear those recorders are so awkward they remind of when my younger brother wouldn't SHUT UP with his, sounds damn hilarious
agreed
I wonder how many people don't even listen to Chirp long enough to reach the part where it doesn't sound like it's being played on an old Phonograph.
Thats's my favorite part and it definitely adds to the disc ( Edit )
True bc the start of the switch is the best ngl it is the good part of the disc
I know right it made the song so much better and the middle section is something else
Oh man, I’m permanently traumatized from the bus ride home with everyone blasting their recorders. My ears have not yet recovered
Stal is perfect idk what your on about
I agree
Remember you know you know.
I understand the Recorder complaint... another reason why I hated 4th Grade...
But Stal is an amazing disc besides, I honestly hope in the future, they could another disc that gives off the same vibes... Stal is evidence enough that Jazz music works well with Minecraft.
TRUE
I would put creator on the BANGER tier list it's way too good
13 isnt bad lol. The first few high pitched noises are annoying, but I like the creepy echo at the back half of it.
You’re the first person I’ve seen that doesn’t hate 13, I think 13 is a good music disc too.
@@gusc061People hate it because it’s creepy.
If ranking the music disc on how creepy the disc is, it is terrifying, but it isn't very musical
Never let this guy touch a music disc again😭
5:52 best song in minecraft ever
Never cook again
Dude strad is my favourite, I always listen to it in my hardcore world, deserves some more love
This... is objectivly wrong
How? Its thier opinion
The correct list:
Banger: Creator, Precipice, Otherside, Cat, Chirp, Pigstep, Relic
Good: Wait, Creator MB, Mellohi
Alright: Ward, Far, Blocks, Strad
Lacking: Stal (it would be a banger if the made the flute not make my ears bleed)
RIP Eardrums: 13, 5, 11
Eww
correct w man
I agree with you until the stal part
You forgot about mall
amen brother although stal should be alright at least
Pigstep gives me thrills and that feeling of danger that the Nether is supposed to be. For a disc from hell it's pretty good🔥
It's fire BECAUSE IT'S THE NETHER DISC
Strad is banger for me. So is Pigstep!, my ranking is 1) Pigstep 2) Strad 3) Cat, then Wait and Chirp and a few others are right there. but love the video man, thank you! now I want to go collect more discs!!!
My Opinion On Top 5 Discs are,
Otherside 1
Pigstep 2
Relic 3
Strad 4
Ward 5
As someone who loves music discs in Minecraft, if I were to rank music discs on a tier list, I would put every disc in banger tier. Even 13, 11 and 5.
Well you’re boring
I would have a separate category for the horror ambiance discs
When I first started playing Minecraft, around 2014, if I remember right... I'd say Wait and Strad were my favorite discs, more upbeat than Mall, but they still had a good calming vibe to them.
chirp is my fav lol
13: ears bleeding
Cat: Cats
Blocks: blocky
Chirp: Old school
Far: the void
Mall: Backrooms
Mellohi: Mafia gaming
Stal: Recess
Strad: bing chilling
Ward: forgettable
11: Creepy
Wait: Elevator
Otherside: Me showcasing my builds
5: Marching until the warden pulled u
Pigstep: Technoblade never dies
Relic: My ears hurt
Creator/ music box: I’m in your house vibes
Prerecipe: Japanese samurai fight intro
Strad is definitely the most nostalgic music disc for me. I didn't play much Minecraft before it's revival in 1.13, but when I did I must have found that disk, because it really takes me back
Tried to cook but instead burned the house down
I think wait is one of the most underrated discs, it’s my personal favorite
stal hater 👎
The creator music box version is so good. One of the best
Agreed 👍