Girls with wild eyebrows and cool fashion choices Music that's made up of nothing but voices A channel that shows me how my hero sings These are a few of my favorite things
Spoiled by metal chords go wakka wakka let's hear it again so let's go a' back-a diphthongs and vowels, resonance and ping these are a few of my favorite things!
I used to get so frustrated at numerous pauses in reactions until I realized there is a big difference between a reaction and a musical analysis put out by a professional singer/musician/vocal teacher. Then it made sense and I appreciate your take on this. I learned things and heard things for the first time that I didn't catch upon first, second, 10th hearing. THANK YOU!!!!
Sorry Susan but I think she pauses way too much and makes the reaction rather boring. I watch many many reactions and this person is too analytical to the point of nausea. Pause ad nauseum, rather terrible, but that's just the opinion of a retired person who listens to this stuff all day. I can't believe she still hasn't finished the song. LOL And she continues to pause, and pause, and pause, etc. etc.
@@randycolaianni4937 after 30 seconds of play, they have to pay royalties. Hence the frustration at the pauses. I suspect she has a timer to keep her on target.
@@deansmith4752 Thanks for the response and I was not aware of that because almost all the others that do reactions do not pause anywhere near as much as she does.
I love the way you break things down and of course your giggles. Their recent cover of The Prayer is sublime and in my opinion the best thing they have produced to date. I really hope that you react to it. I'd love to hear your thoughts.
There's no doubt that Elizabeth's analysis of the vocals and the musicality is expert, but Pentatonix doesn't just sing -- they perform. Each video is a small play in and of itself and this one is the most fantastic I have ever seen. Elizabeth, if you read this, you are a performer as well as a singer and I would really like to hear your comments concerning the scripting and acting that Pentatonix does because they are far and away the best I have seen.
I Just found Pentatonix.. I've never heard or realized, Accapella was so diverse, making all the different sounds vocally.. your a Hero in my Book Thank you for your Fun and Wisdom!!
Pentatonix modulations show how their skills in chromatic movement as an ensemble have grown over time! Killin! I love the occasions when they sing two against three as well! Your mention of Mitch at the outset is well said; being an authentic countertenor, Mitch’s emotions really come through with that timbre he expresses! As a composer-pianist, I’ve been a Pentaholic since 2012 and the growth I’ve observed in Kirstin over the last decade has, for me, been sooo heartwarming! Early on, Kirstie was wonderful, but she lacked confidence. Now, she belts right alongside the boys. She’s now an equal leg of The Trio!
Hi Elizabeth, I'm glad you're getting back to another PTX reaction, and this performance was amazing. I loved Kirsten's lead vocals, Kevin's vocal percussion, and the flair of the harmony. I also enjoyed how they kept the feel of the original song, and made it more upbeat and modern. Thank you, Elizabeth!!! 💙
They do indeed shift parts! Their ranges overlap hugely. Mitch and Kirstin swap soprano/alto lines all the time, and Scott sings tenor when Mitch is solidly up in his higher range (most of the time, right?). Matt has a beautiful melodic baritone, and as we all know, Scott doubles for the bass (Matt now, Avi in the early days) when the bass has a solo. Then if Kevin joins in on vocals instead of making beats, he's a tenor with a lovely soprano falsetto. I believe that Kirstin now bills herself as an alto instead of a mezzo-soprano. And Scott could power through all of them - he got dinged for overpowering his group-mates early on during the The Sing-Off. Re the skull: apparently the set dressers went nuts with what's on the table, and the group was just told to each pick something and play with it!
Elizabeth - an assignment? Bobby McFerrin who has spent his life experimenting with voice . His own voice at first, then later voice play with an audience. His range is extensive. His body of work is worthy of a PBS study of the various periods of his life coupled with a conversation with him. I only ever found one extensive interview which helped me love him more. He seems like a giant in the charisma of voice! So a little taste through the periods of his experiments. Don’t forget when he directs famous orchestras in bare feet. Getting the players to use their voice to “play” their instrument. He has played (sang) with so many famous. People. Chic chorea is my favorite
“Don’t worry be happy”. is the least like his usual experimental work. Although he is most generally known for it. He disappeared from the pop scene after that song since he never does any thing twice. Turns out he was directing famous orchestras doing classical pieces in Bobby Mcferrin style completely under the radar of the pop world I agree that blackbird is very nice. And there is his more recent work where he uses the audience to improvise. He is really famous for his improvisation. There is a you tube video of him getting the audience to do a pentatonic scale by showing the audience the intervals through jumping sideways
I have figured it out! You are the "Music Appreciation" professor we all wish we had as college freshmen. The genuine love and enthusiasm is SO infectious! Of course you weren't even a twinkle in your daddy's eye when I was in college... But the thought remains... The energy and positive vibes are much needed and appreciated. Thank You, Ma'am!
This is why I love reaction videos, because other people catch things I missed, and I can experience the song in a new way. There were so many details that I missed
You are an absolute delight to watch because of your delight. Its captivating! I so enjoy seeing people react who understand and can communicate WHY Pentatonix is so masterful. "That was awesome" may be true every time, but there's so much more to say!
20:55 made me think of a haunted fairground merry-go-round, it was so effective. Cool vid! I first heard of these guys about 5 years ago when they were guests on a Saturday morning cooking show, here in the UK, and their personalities really impressed me, they seemed so friendly and sweet. I love their talent 👍
I have listened to this song so many times over the last couple years and you are pointing out things I never heard like the "pew pew". very cool. great reaction. I really hope you react to Over The River - you'll enjoy it I think.
Their cover of Over the River was the most clever and amazing reimagination of a song that has never been one of my favorite Christmas songs. Please review that one!
My favorite Pentatonix song is "God rest ye merry gentleman", turned me into a big fan. While Matt Sallee has a fantastic voice, Avi Kaplan was amazing and unique. I would love to hear you compare and contrast the two.
Scott's voice can come across mysterious at times (especially in his part in this song which make him seem like a wizard or vampire trying to tempt you into joining them in their fun). So the skull is fitting.
I love the way she nerds out about every little thing. It's my first time here, but it felt like I was watching it with a friend and having a very technical fangirling session xD
Please don't wait a year to react to PTX's cover of The Prayer. It just came out this year and it may very well be their best work yet. A very close second is last year's "Amazing Grace" which is just spectacular.
I can’t wrap my head around it how they memorise all these notes ! Mind boggling! And also very creative and flawlessly executed! Sparkling like thousands of little diamonds and various Crystals 😍😍😍🥰
Hi Elizabeth. I have 4 daughters and they all Have Elizabeth in their names somewhere. ☺ When are you going to do the new PTX? "The Prayer". I love all your comments and I appreciate you sharing your knowledge with us. Hugs from Florida 🌞!
@@Astaroth236 well he did say that Elizabeth is in their name somewhere, so I'm guessing some of them have it as a second or third name Still weird tho yeah
This piece has “Making Christmas” vibes. I love the fact that PTX is never too precious about their arrangements-particularly on the up tempo charts! The general public has no real idea how intricate these pieces are... the chromatic harmony and the key changes! The group is made up of real genius!
I've listened to this reaction a few times since my first time 4 months ago. I've also listened to numerous other reactions to it. yours is the BEST!!! Each time I play this I enjoy how you break it down and add to the experience. LOVE your facial expressions and descriptions! Still. 😊
This old song that I loved as a kid , now is made fresh and up beat ! Unbelievable the degree of flawlessly interacting and made colourful ! Every member shines ! ! Great comment with a lot of loveable theatrical smiles and caresses ! I feel you appreciate and understand everything ! 🙏 thanks
You're such a music nerd...like me. I love how you can hear all the layers at the same time and can point it out. I could watch you for days. I was wondering about the skull as well.
Music is my first love. I am not educated in the technicalities of it. When I was a child, I wrote songs simply by using lines, curves & bumps. I knew what it meant & that's all that mattered. In elementary school I took up the flute. 3 months in and my teacher wanted me in first chair. When I found out what that meant, it scared me so bad that I quit. Biggest regret of my life. Anyhow, (sorry) Even though I don't understand the language, I can understand what you are saying each time I watch & find what you say fascinating. You are such a joy to go on a journey with through music. You didn't miss your calling! Thank you for all you do.🙂🙏🏼
Loved your reaction and in particular your descriptions of what makes Mitch's voice just so..... wonderful. In a group of amazing vocalists, I find it hard to explain why I love his the most! Your attention to detail and picking up on all of the little background jewels is lovely to see. I really enjoy your reaction and the joy you show while watching.
I think of this as like a scene from a Disney movie where the villain has a solo. This is Kirstin as a Disney villain singing about her favorite things while her minions dance around her. Great reaction as always!
First time actually watching this video of Pentatonic, regardless of the commentary, which was so welcome. First thought in those few moments, I said to myself, "This is "Interview With The Vampire" combine with the tea party in "Alice In Wonderland." They nailed it... if that was the intention of course. 😊
I've seen this many times, but the details and moments you point out and explain add so much to my enjoyment. I know you a vocal person, but go back and watch it a few more times just to catch the items dropping from overhead. A blue satin sash and a white dress are two of them.. but there are so many more... need to pause the video many times to catch them all.
I love how giddy she gets whenever she listens to music. I have a completely new appreciation of music after watching her analysis. I hear and feel more when I listen to my favorite songs.
Mitch and Matt often get spotlighted for having incredible high and low ranges respectively, while Scott gets kind of relegated to "guy in the middle", but what amazes me is that, actually, he does the bass in parts where Matt sings lead, and does the high backing when Mitch sings lead, and you barely even notice it.
I guess his name is Mitch, whoever opened with the first vocals. You said this reminded you of Tim Burton. Mitch looks almost a spot-on twin of Johnny Depp's character, Barnabas (I think), in the movie Dark Shadows.
I do think this has a really strong vampire vibe! Yes, Mitch Grassi, tenor/countertenor - 6 octave range and sings well into the soprano female range. You might like their cover of Making Christmas (from Nightmare Before Christmas) as well.
First time hearing this, and OMG. I'm in my 50's, grew up watching musicals with my mother. In my 20's and 30's, picture a biker type looking guy that knew about Cab Calloway mThe Nicholas Brothers. Yes, have seen the sound of music several times, as well as 7 Brides for 7 Brothers, Oklahoma, My Fair Lady, etc. All the Bob Hope/ Bing Crosby Road to wherever. I absolutely loved this.
I love Pentatonix and watching your reactions just brings a smile to my face to think that someone else likes them as much as I do for all the same reasons.
I need her brain. It is not easy to pick apart and appreciate all the different layers of a Pentatonix song the way she does. Her ability to perceive and process is on another level
When Scott first picks up the skull and looks in it's eyes, it looks so Shakespearan! Lol Like Hamlet! Also, the end reminds me of an old-time German clock with the animated characters that come out when the clock strikes the hour, which is emphasized by the moment when Scott and Mitch reach up for that final clap over Kirstin's head, but their hands don't quite meet!
So looking forward to this. They are both fun to listen to and fun to watch. Lovely and interesting harmonies that are sure to come alive with your always entertaining and inciteful commentary. I hope to have a front row seat for your performance. Give me just a moment to grab some popcorn!
The way this song was used in the film 'Dancer in the Dark' -sung by none other thanBjörk- was just so sad that it was out of this world. Love the upbeat Pentatonix version so much!!!
My grandmother had a snowglobe with a music box built in that played this song. It is one of my strongest and fondest memories. She died when I was 13…I’m 38 now, so that’s a powerful memory.
One of my favorite songs by them and for most of my life. I used to watch Sound of Music as a kid back to back to back🎶💕 But they bring such a mystery and almost dark ominous feeling to it.
One of my favorite music videos purely because of how out of left field the vibe is lmao. Such a sweet and whimsical song, but the way they arranged it had this eerie Nightmare Before Christmas vibe to it, not to mention they all effectively look like vampires with the way they're styled. A bunch of immortal christmas-enthused theater nerds. Love it.
Hello Charismatic Voice. So many great reaction videos from you!. You always seem to identify each performers best points. I don't think I have ever heard a negative comment come from you, have you?. You are a pure beautiful soul. Happy holidays.
This is only the 2nd video I've watched of you, but when you mentioned the Alice in Wonderland Tea Party vibes, we both said "I love it" at the same time afterwards, and I immediately subscribed! xD Thank you so much for the fun analysis of one of my favorite groups and songs!
I really like the way Matt has been able to integrate himself into the group. As I understand it, Avi recommended him when he departed the group. I could be wrong though. I like how this group puts the focus on different singers. Not necessarily all in one song, but across the selections. @ 11:18 Yes I've noticed they do frequently exchange parts. One of the things my mom told me was I liked a far wider range of music than she did. One piece I used to listen to had about 60 beats per minute, but there were multiple beats. One of those was 240 beats per minute, and she told me it felt frantic to her.
Wow! What a reaction!! Yes, the song is off the hook, insanely sick. But I already knew that. 😊 HOWEVER... It was your reaction that gathered both my immediate subscription and my like. With a single reaction you earned my profound respect for your amazing ear AND your ability to describe and explain what you are hearing. At first I thought, 'she talks too much.' As I listened I threw that initial thought overboard, and went back to the beginning. I learned more in this one reaction about style, texture, technique... than the total of what I knew before. I think I have a pretty good 'natural' ear, but your education, training, and experience made me think, "I'm a flippin' NOVICE." 🤣 And the completely endearing facial expressions (and wonderful laugh/giggle) and obvious joy you have for music just melted me! You have a new fan that will eagerly listen to any reaction I see from you! Bravo!
So good! I had not seen or heard this version before either; I was not aware of it. Thank you for your amazing reaction; yours are always a delight to watch!
I have come to realize that this video format is one of the best to have on in the background while I do homework, so more binging of these will be occurring
While this is an excellent version, I am am a stickler for the way Julie Andrews performed this. I guess I am just old fashioned. Thank you so much for your videos. I don’t think most people realize how incredibly hard this kind of singing really is to perform well. Your love for music keeps me coming back for more. You have such a giddy happiness like a child on Christmas morning when you review a song.💗💗💗💗
I am amazed how fast they can sing! Love PTX right from the beginning. But I wish you could explain to me why the early songs which I love the MOST Versus these much more produced ones of the last few years. My feeling is that I can experience the actual voices in their early work. Am I crazy to feel this way??!!
Kirsten, Mitch and Scott all went to school together I’m Arlington, Texas and have been friends since grade school. In high school they were all in Choir. together. It was Scott who was interested in forming a group and going to California for the Sing Off competition but they needed 5 members so Avi and one other were recruited. They won the competition and the rest is history.. information provided by another Pentaholic!
I know it's 6 months after you did this video But if you thoughts. 1st and for most I absolutely adore you. I love how passionate you are. At the beginning of every reaction I've seen you're on the edge of your chair and your face is lit up Because you are anticipating to hear something wonderful. All of those items were on the table and they weren't told to reach and get any particular item they just said pick up the item. Kevin said that this is the hardest song that he Has Done because it was so hard to figure out how to Set his beatboxing in with the song. My life is complete now that I've heard Mitch sing "Schnitzel and noodles"
Itès been a delightful experience to watch you analyze and suss out the qualities and characteristics of voices and songs...I have a suggestion: have you considered The Host of Seraphim, by Dead Can Dance? Their music is a hybrid sound, where Lisa Gerrard's fantastic voice laments and soars. I saw them live 20 years ago, and this song made the entire audience cry.
Love Pentatonix and love TheCharismaticVoice. You take that love to a whole new level thru both educational awareness and musical energy. I’m always so pumped up after your videos. I believe there was a video called After Party by Pentatonix where they talked about this video. If I remember right the producer suggested a Mad Hatter theme and they loved it and when it came to their favorite things they were told to just pick up something off the table near them. Hopefully u noticed the things falling out of thin air also throughout the video. The video is now on their premium site so it’s no longer available. Maybe others that seen this can remember other things that were talked about. Love what u do Please keep ur reactions coming
We just released merchandise! Check out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
Please don’t pause each time to explain your musically analysis, just play the whole video without pausing.
I saw a comment on the original video saying that it gave off the vibe of a group of vampires welcoming you to dinner and that just fits so perfectly.
I guess most German speakers would agree that the very idea of serving Schnitzel with noodles is creepy in itself. They just expanded on the idea.
The appeal of a fridgerator filled with baby blood
What is delightful about autotune and manipulation? Oh, i guess you have to be a vampire to get it.
The Originals.
Tell me different
Lol… Spot on! It’s the pacing, I think. “Sinister”, I believe… that’s how I’d describe it. Lol
Girls with wild eyebrows and cool fashion choices
Music that's made up of nothing but voices
A channel that shows me how my hero sings
These are a few of my favorite things
Spoiled by metal
chords go wakka wakka
let's hear it again so
let's go a' back-a
diphthongs and vowels, resonance and ping
these are a few of my favorite things!
@@briancollis1809 "Let's go a' back-a?" You win! 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Awesome!!!
@@thmonz 👍
This is amazing 😂😍
I used to get so frustrated at numerous pauses in reactions until I realized there is a big difference between a reaction and a musical analysis put out by a professional singer/musician/vocal teacher. Then it made sense and I appreciate your take on this. I learned things and heard things for the first time that I didn't catch upon first, second, 10th hearing. THANK YOU!!!!
I’m glad to see this because they were a lot of people who are like the way that you used to be and it can be annoying to read their comments.
Sorry Susan but I think she pauses way too much and makes the reaction rather boring. I watch many many reactions and this person is too analytical to the point of nausea. Pause ad nauseum, rather terrible, but that's just the opinion of a retired person who listens to this stuff all day. I can't believe she still hasn't finished the song. LOL And she continues to pause, and pause, and pause, etc. etc.
@@randycolaianni4937 after 30 seconds of play, they have to pay royalties. Hence the frustration at the pauses. I suspect she has a timer to keep her on target.
@@deansmith4752 Thanks for the response and I was not aware of that because almost all the others that do reactions do not pause anywhere near as much as she does.
I love the way you break things down and of course your giggles. Their recent cover of The Prayer is sublime and in my opinion the best thing they have produced to date. I really hope that you react to it. I'd love to hear your thoughts.
I 100000000000% agree!!! Their cover of The Prayer is Grammy worthy on sooooooo many levels!!
@@KennyScharlattMusic the scammys don’t pay attention to ptx as of late 🥲
Agree! Their version of “The Prayer” is, in my opinion, their best yet, and that is an extremely high bar considering all their amazing work to date.
There's no doubt that Elizabeth's analysis of the vocals and the musicality is expert, but Pentatonix doesn't just sing -- they perform. Each video is a small play in and of itself and this one is the most fantastic I have ever seen. Elizabeth, if you read this, you are a performer as well as a singer and I would really like to hear your comments concerning the scripting and acting that Pentatonix does because they are far and away the best I have seen.
I Just found Pentatonix.. I've never heard or realized, Accapella was so diverse, making all the different sounds vocally..
your a Hero in my Book Thank you for your Fun and Wisdom!!
Pentatonix modulations show how their skills in chromatic movement as an ensemble have grown over time! Killin! I love the occasions when they sing two against three as well! Your mention of Mitch at the outset is well said; being an authentic countertenor, Mitch’s emotions really come through with that timbre he expresses! As a composer-pianist, I’ve been a Pentaholic since 2012 and the growth I’ve observed in Kirstin over the last decade has, for me, been sooo heartwarming! Early on, Kirstie was wonderful, but she lacked confidence. Now, she belts right alongside the boys. She’s now an equal leg of The Trio!
Hi Elizabeth, I'm glad you're getting back to another PTX reaction, and this performance was amazing. I loved Kirsten's lead vocals, Kevin's vocal percussion, and the flair of the harmony. I also enjoyed how they kept the feel of the original song, and made it more upbeat and modern. Thank you, Elizabeth!!! 💙
They do indeed shift parts! Their ranges overlap hugely. Mitch and Kirstin swap soprano/alto lines all the time, and Scott sings tenor when Mitch is solidly up in his higher range (most of the time, right?). Matt has a beautiful melodic baritone, and as we all know, Scott doubles for the bass (Matt now, Avi in the early days) when the bass has a solo. Then if Kevin joins in on vocals instead of making beats, he's a tenor with a lovely soprano falsetto. I believe that Kirstin now bills herself as an alto instead of a mezzo-soprano. And Scott could power through all of them - he got dinged for overpowering his group-mates early on during the The Sing-Off. Re the skull: apparently the set dressers went nuts with what's on the table, and the group was just told to each pick something and play with it!
LOVE when Kevin joins in with vocals…he has an amazing voice just like every other member
Pentatonix has so much texture in all their songs. Soooo good
Elizabeth - an assignment? Bobby McFerrin who has spent his life experimenting with voice . His own voice at first, then later voice play with an audience. His range is extensive. His body of work is worthy of a PBS study of the various periods of his life coupled with a conversation with him. I only ever found one extensive interview which helped me love him more. He seems like a giant in the charisma of voice! So a little taste through the periods of his experiments. Don’t forget when he directs famous orchestras in bare feet. Getting the players to use their voice to “play” their instrument. He has played (sang) with so many famous. People. Chic chorea is my favorite
i like bpbby's version of "blackbird".
Don’t Worry Be Happy would be an awesome reaction.
“Don’t worry be happy”. is the least like his usual experimental work. Although he is most generally known for it. He disappeared from the pop scene after that song since he never does any thing twice. Turns out he was directing famous orchestras doing classical pieces in Bobby Mcferrin style completely under the radar of the pop world
I agree that blackbird is very nice. And there is his more recent work where he uses the audience to improvise. He is really famous for his improvisation.
There is a you tube video of him getting the audience to do a pentatonic scale by showing the audience the intervals through jumping sideways
Fantastic analysis! Alice in Wonderland meets Steam Punk for Christmas! I think this was the first time all 5 wore makeup. A capella for the win!
I have figured it out! You are the "Music Appreciation" professor we all wish we had as college freshmen. The genuine love and enthusiasm is SO infectious! Of course you weren't even a twinkle in your daddy's eye when I was in college... But the thought remains... The energy and positive vibes are much needed and appreciated. Thank You, Ma'am!
DANZIG!
Honestly any Danzig song would be a great video, he’s a heavy metal Jim Morrison/Elvis!
How The Gods Kill!
Yes do DANZIG!
This is why I love reaction videos, because other people catch things I missed, and I can experience the song in a new way. There were so many details that I missed
I personally would love a reaction to Pentatonix's cover of "Over the River" it's epic.
There is no denying their voices are perfectly made for each other.
Shockingly beautiful voices. My wife is a professional singer, so I've heard good singing, but I'm sitting here in awe.
You are an absolute delight to watch because of your delight. Its captivating! I so enjoy seeing people react who understand and can communicate WHY Pentatonix is so masterful. "That was awesome" may be true every time, but there's so much more to say!
20:55 made me think of a haunted fairground merry-go-round, it was so effective. Cool vid!
I first heard of these guys about 5 years ago when they were guests on a Saturday morning cooking show, here in the UK, and their personalities really impressed me, they seemed so friendly and sweet. I love their talent 👍
Definitely need to listen to them do The Prayer.... fantastic rendition, with Mitch really rising high.
I have listened to this song so many times over the last couple years and you are pointing out things I never heard like the "pew pew". very cool. great reaction. I really hope you react to Over The River - you'll enjoy it I think.
Their cover of Over the River was the most clever and amazing reimagination of a song that has never been one of my favorite Christmas songs. Please review that one!
Mitch makes it look effortless. Kirstin has so much oomph to her voice. They are insanely cohesive as a group. Love their stuff.
My favorite Pentatonix song is "God rest ye merry gentleman", turned me into a big fan. While Matt Sallee has a fantastic voice, Avi Kaplan was amazing and unique. I would love to hear you compare and contrast the two.
I'd be interested in hearing them do one of their older songs with Matt. The only time I saw them live, Avi was still in the group.
Scott's voice can come across mysterious at times (especially in his part in this song which make him seem like a wizard or vampire trying to tempt you into joining them in their fun). So the skull is fitting.
I love the way she nerds out about every little thing. It's my first time here, but it felt like I was watching it with a friend and having a very technical fangirling session xD
Please don't wait a year to react to PTX's cover of The Prayer. It just came out this year and it may very well be their best work yet. A very close second is last year's "Amazing Grace" which is just spectacular.
I love you explanations of what is going on.
I can’t wrap my head around it how they memorise all these notes ! Mind boggling! And also very creative and flawlessly executed! Sparkling like thousands of little diamonds and various Crystals 😍😍😍🥰
Hi Elizabeth. I have 4 daughters and they all Have Elizabeth in their names somewhere. ☺ When are you going to do the new PTX? "The Prayer". I love all your comments and I appreciate you sharing your knowledge with us. Hugs from Florida 🌞!
but.. Why?!! Why would you use the same name on FOUR girls?
@@Astaroth236 well he did say that Elizabeth is in their name somewhere, so I'm guessing some of them have it as a second or third name
Still weird tho yeah
This piece has “Making Christmas” vibes. I love the fact that PTX is never too precious about their arrangements-particularly on the up tempo charts! The general public has no real idea how intricate these pieces are... the chromatic harmony and the key changes! The group is made up of real genius!
I've listened to this reaction a few times since my first time 4 months ago. I've also listened to numerous other reactions to it. yours is the BEST!!! Each time I play this I enjoy how you break it down and add to the experience. LOVE your facial expressions and descriptions! Still. 😊
So many times I've watched this video and only just noticed the subtle eye make-up on the guys that really gives them an almost sinister appearance.
This old song that I loved as a kid , now is made fresh and up beat ! Unbelievable the degree of flawlessly interacting and made colourful ! Every member shines ! ! Great comment with a lot of loveable theatrical smiles and caresses ! I feel you appreciate and understand everything ! 🙏 thanks
I love how you help me hear and appreciate so many sounds. Scott's make-up is stunning, btw!
You're such a music nerd...like me. I love how you can hear all the layers at the same time and can point it out. I could watch you for days. I was wondering about the skull as well.
Just seeing your anticipation was a great start! Thank you for geeking out for our education, entertainment, and absolute pleasure.
Music is my first love. I am not educated in the technicalities of it. When I was a child, I wrote songs simply by using lines, curves & bumps. I knew what it meant & that's all that mattered. In elementary school I took up the flute. 3 months in and my teacher wanted me in first chair. When I found out what that meant, it scared me so bad that I quit. Biggest regret of my life. Anyhow, (sorry) Even though I don't understand the language, I can understand what you are saying each time I watch & find what you say fascinating. You are such a joy to go on a journey with through music. You didn't miss your calling! Thank you for all you do.🙂🙏🏼
Loved your reaction and in particular your descriptions of what makes Mitch's voice just so..... wonderful. In a group of amazing vocalists, I find it hard to explain why I love his the most! Your attention to detail and picking up on all of the little background jewels is lovely to see. I really enjoy your reaction and the joy you show while watching.
I think of this as like a scene from a Disney movie where the villain has a solo. This is Kirstin as a Disney villain singing about her favorite things while her minions dance around her. Great reaction as always!
This has some serious Tim Burton vibes. It almost feels like it could've been in "The Nightmare Before Christmas"
My favorite way to start out my morning- a new TCV video 💜💜💜💜
First time actually watching this video of Pentatonic, regardless of the commentary, which was so welcome.
First thought in those few moments, I said to myself, "This is "Interview With The Vampire" combine with the tea party in "Alice In Wonderland."
They nailed it... if that was the intention of course. 😊
This song wasn't originally thought of as a Christmas song, but has become one in recent years. This version is in a definitive December key.
I've seen this many times, but the details and moments you point out and explain add so much to my enjoyment. I know you a vocal person, but go back and watch it a few more times just to catch the items dropping from overhead. A blue satin sash and a white dress are two of them.. but there are so many more... need to pause the video many times to catch them all.
I love how giddy she gets whenever she listens to music. I have a completely new appreciation of music after watching her analysis. I hear and feel more when I listen to my favorite songs.
Yeah! Pentatonix! Can’t wait.
Mitch and Matt often get spotlighted for having incredible high and low ranges respectively, while Scott gets kind of relegated to "guy in the middle", but what amazes me is that, actually, he does the bass in parts where Matt sings lead, and does the high backing when Mitch sings lead, and you barely even notice it.
Magic for our ears and your beautiful smile ! What's not to love?
I guess his name is Mitch, whoever opened with the first vocals. You said this reminded you of Tim Burton. Mitch looks almost a spot-on twin of Johnny Depp's character, Barnabas (I think), in the movie Dark Shadows.
I do think this has a really strong vampire vibe! Yes, Mitch Grassi, tenor/countertenor - 6 octave range and sings well into the soprano female range. You might like their cover of Making Christmas (from Nightmare Before Christmas) as well.
First time hearing this, and OMG. I'm in my 50's, grew up watching musicals with my mother. In my 20's and 30's, picture a biker type looking guy that knew about Cab Calloway mThe Nicholas Brothers. Yes, have seen the sound of music several times, as well as 7 Brides for 7 Brothers, Oklahoma, My Fair Lady, etc. All the Bob Hope/ Bing Crosby Road to wherever. I absolutely loved this.
Just here for the giggles, and I KNOW Pentatonix will give you plenty.
No matter the greatness of the artists and songs which you're reacting to. Nothing beats your own enthusiasm. Loving it every. damn. time.
I love Pentatonix and watching your reactions just brings a smile to my face to think that someone else likes them as much as I do for all the same reasons.
I need her brain. It is not easy to pick apart and appreciate all the different layers of a Pentatonix song the way she does. Her ability to perceive and process is on another level
When Scott first picks up the skull and looks in it's eyes, it looks so Shakespearan! Lol Like Hamlet! Also, the end reminds me of an old-time German clock with the animated characters that come out when the clock strikes the hour, which is emphasized by the moment when Scott and Mitch reach up for that final clap over Kirstin's head, but their hands don't quite meet!
Kevin’s also a Cellist so it’s natural for him to use his fingering hand to make those gestures with his fingers as he does his thing… I love it! Lol
So looking forward to this. They are both fun to listen to and fun to watch. Lovely and interesting harmonies that are sure to come alive with your always entertaining and inciteful commentary. I hope to have a front row seat for your performance. Give me just a moment to grab some popcorn!
The way this song was used in the film 'Dancer in the Dark' -sung by none other thanBjörk- was just so sad that it was out of this world. Love the upbeat Pentatonix version so much!!!
Pentatonix and Home Free, best Acapella in the last 30 years.
It has a real “Making Christmas” vibe. Pentatonix is never too precious about their arrangements...
i love how you have headphones on, but you still lean in toward the screen to "hear better" when you really get in to a part
Their video productions are always as fantastic as their music.
Should be lots of giggles for this one. Can’t wait . . .
I never noticed any of this extra stuff you are pointing out. It makes the video and song even more enjoyable and I learn a lot.
My grandmother had a snowglobe with a music box built in that played this song. It is one of my strongest and fondest memories. She died when I was 13…I’m 38 now, so that’s a powerful memory.
I love Pentatonix and really enjoy listening to their take on this, but I also love watching you enjoy it so much.
You describe Mitch's voice exactly how I feel it 🎶💖
its so enjoyable watching your reactions, you clearly get so much joy from listening to this and its fun to see.
One of my favorite songs by them and for most of my life. I used to watch Sound of Music as a kid back to back to back🎶💕
But they bring such a mystery and almost dark ominous feeling to it.
Their Camera work is INSANE!
Love it spiced up.
This channel is one of my favorite things ⭐
One of my favorite music videos purely because of how out of left field the vibe is lmao.
Such a sweet and whimsical song, but the way they arranged it had this eerie Nightmare Before Christmas vibe to it, not to mention they all effectively look like vampires with the way they're styled.
A bunch of immortal christmas-enthused theater nerds. Love it.
Hello Charismatic Voice. So many great reaction videos from you!. You always seem to identify each performers best points. I don't think I have ever heard a negative comment come from you, have you?. You are a pure beautiful soul. Happy holidays.
This is only the 2nd video I've watched of you, but when you mentioned the Alice in Wonderland Tea Party vibes, we both said "I love it" at the same time afterwards, and I immediately subscribed! xD Thank you so much for the fun analysis of one of my favorite groups and songs!
I really like the way Matt has been able to integrate himself into the group. As I understand it, Avi recommended him when he departed the group. I could be wrong though.
I like how this group puts the focus on different singers. Not necessarily all in one song, but across the selections.
@ 11:18 Yes I've noticed they do frequently exchange parts.
One of the things my mom told me was I liked a far wider range of music than she did. One piece I used to listen to had about 60 beats per minute, but there were multiple beats. One of those was 240 beats per minute, and she told me it felt frantic to her.
You caused me to appreciate them even more. Thanks
Pentatonix ! They are brilliant!
this song by pentatonix rendition made me smile
Home Free's version of "Do you hear what I hear" is pure ear candy if you want to hear some cool acapella sounds.
Wow! What a reaction!! Yes, the song is off the hook, insanely sick. But I already knew that. 😊 HOWEVER... It was your reaction that gathered both my immediate subscription and my like. With a single reaction you earned my profound respect for your amazing ear AND your ability to describe and explain what you are hearing. At first I thought, 'she talks too much.' As I listened I threw that initial thought overboard, and went back to the beginning. I learned more in this one reaction about style, texture, technique... than the total of what I knew before. I think I have a pretty good 'natural' ear, but your education, training, and experience made me think, "I'm a flippin' NOVICE." 🤣 And the completely endearing facial expressions (and wonderful laugh/giggle) and obvious joy you have for music just melted me! You have a new fan that will eagerly listen to any reaction I see from you! Bravo!
I think you should react to their new one “ the Prayer”. From their new Christmas Album.
It is unbelievably beautiful. Merry Christmas
They remind me of a cathedral's pipe organ with each one willing to create strong moments even if they are short and not out front.
So good! I had not seen or heard this version before either; I was not aware of it. Thank you for your amazing reaction; yours are always a delight to watch!
You are so fun to watch... keep 'em coming!
I cannot wait to hear your break down of PTX's The Prayer!!
First time hearing this song and they did great. Love the analysis
I have come to realize that this video format is one of the best to have on in the background while I do homework, so more binging of these will be occurring
While this is an excellent version, I am am a stickler for the way Julie Andrews performed this. I guess I am just old fashioned. Thank you so much for your videos. I don’t think most people realize how incredibly hard this kind of singing really is to perform well. Your love for music keeps me coming back for more. You have such a giddy happiness like a child on Christmas morning when you review a song.💗💗💗💗
I am amazed how fast they can sing!
Love PTX right from the beginning.
But I wish you could explain to me why the early songs which I love the MOST
Versus these much more produced ones of the last few years. My feeling is that I can experience the actual voices in their early work. Am I crazy to feel this way??!!
Kirsten, Mitch and Scott all went to school together I’m Arlington, Texas and have been friends since grade school. In high school they were all in Choir. together. It was Scott who was interested in forming a group and going to California for the Sing Off competition but they needed 5 members so Avi and one other were recruited. They won the competition and the rest is history.. information provided by another Pentaholic!
I know it's 6 months after you did this video But if you thoughts. 1st and for most I absolutely adore you. I love how passionate you are. At the beginning of every reaction I've seen you're on the edge of your chair and your face is lit up Because you are anticipating to hear something wonderful. All of those items were on the table and they weren't told to reach and get any particular item they just said pick up the item. Kevin said that this is the hardest song that he Has Done because it was so hard to figure out how to Set his beatboxing in with the song. My life is complete now that I've heard Mitch sing "Schnitzel and noodles"
I loved your reaction the absolute most!
Tiz the season
Scott with his outfit and the skull gives me a Hamlet vibe. (“Alas, poor Yorick.”) Loved your reaction and analysis!
Itès been a delightful experience to watch you analyze and suss out the qualities and characteristics of voices and songs...I have a suggestion: have you considered The Host of Seraphim, by Dead Can Dance? Their music is a hybrid sound, where Lisa Gerrard's fantastic voice laments and soars. I saw them live 20 years ago, and this song made the entire audience cry.
Love Pentatonix and love TheCharismaticVoice. You take that love to a whole new level thru both educational awareness and musical energy. I’m always so pumped up after your videos.
I believe there was a video called After Party by Pentatonix where they talked about this video.
If I remember right the producer suggested a Mad Hatter theme and they loved it and when it came to their favorite things they were told to just pick up something off the table near them. Hopefully u noticed the things falling out of thin air also throughout the video.
The video is now on their premium site so it’s no longer available.
Maybe others that seen this can remember other things that were talked about.
Love what u do
Please keep ur reactions coming
I'd love to see you do reactions to vintage Crosby, Stills & Nash. Like maybe "Suite Judy Blue Eyes" or "Helplessly Hoping" for example.