Historically, Hmong is as Chinese as it come. They are the direct descendants of the legendary Fire (Flame) Emperor and Chiyou. The Fire emperor is the leader of the first tribe who used fire, farming and medicine. Later, they lost the first major military conflict in ancient Chinese history where the first compass was invented and used in battlefield by the Yellow emperor. After the defeat, they broke up and exiled for the next five thousands year, part of this group exiled to the west, and the part that moved south are the ancestors of Hmong. The major part stayed and combined with the Yellow Emperor's tribe. To honor this, Han Chinese called themselves the descendants of Yan Huang 炎黄子孙 (Yan: Fire . Huang: Yellow).
Sorry, but that's just tribal folklore. NOT to say the Hmong didn't have any struggle against the expanding, powerful Han Chinese. They did, as did many other small ethnics whose traditional lands the Hans forcibly took over. But, yes, the Hmong WERE one of the original and ADJACENT neighbors to the Han Chinese. Hmong generational folklore about floods and mighty rivers, for example, were largely about the Yantze and Yellow rivers that flow from the Himalaya northerly into central and eastern China. Hmong have STORIES --- recent stories ---- about the mighty Maekong River; but those stories were created from the 1800s on, when a TINY percentage of Hmong started moving to Northern Laos, from Yunnan. More Hmong moved down to North Vietnam, but those were the Hmong in the most southeastern Yunnan to southwestern Guangxi provinces. Further, close to 100% of the Hmong in Northern Vietnam have been COMMUNISTS like the Chinese and North Vietnamese; close to zero Hmong from Nothern Vietnam "escaped from the Vietnam War" like Hmong in Laos. Anyway, the Hmong in northwestern Laos were those who moved there from Paj Tawg, Yunnan, Yunnan. My great, great, great, grandfather, for example --- my dad still knows all the names of those paternal guys ---- crossed from Paj Tawg to northern Laos (Muong Xai and Northern Luangpraband), literally just a stone throw in distance... Historically speaking, when the much more powerful Hans started expanding outward, from their traditional lands, which were in the eastern and northern parts toward the Sea and Beijing .... around the time or the First Emperor.... Hmong and other ethnic groups in and around the Sichuan/X'ian region --- especially the "trouble makers" who didn't want to conform/didn't want to be ruled over by the Hans ---- were pushed ever deeper south. That's how over 90% of the various related Hmong tribes ---- the 5th or 6th largest minorities in China ---- ended up, now, situated between Sichuan, Yunnan, Guizhou, and Guangxi. Roughly 5% of the Hmong in China moved to Northern Vietnam. Another 2-3% moved to Northern Laos, in the early to 1800s. It's 100% from those Hmong in northern and eastern Laos that the 500K or so Hmong in the West here came. All the Hmong in Northern Vietnam, plus 40% or so of the Hmong in Laos.... WERE/ARE Communists, so they fought against our parents and grandparents in the Vietnam War. They were victorious, so we had to take a long hike... crossing the Maekong to Thailand, from where we came to the West, in the last 45 years... One EXCEPTIONALLY IMPROBABLE but true fact: ---- it is from these 500K Hmong in the West, that the VERY FIRST ASIAN WOMAN, ever --- not a Chinese, not a Japanese, not a Korean, not a Vietnamese, not a Thai, not a Filipino, not a Lao, not an Indonesian or any other woman from the other much larger Asian ethnics.... but an 18 year-old Hmong woman ---- came to be the All Around Olympic Gold medalist, of the women's 2020 Olympics.... Her name is Sunisa Lee. If her kidney diseases are controlled and if she qualifies for the 2024 Paris Olympics, in her home state of Minnesota.... there are very good chances she would win more medals... what colors they may be can't be sure.... The TOUGHER part, for American women, would be to qualify on the America US Olympic Women's Team, due to the depth and breadth of quality gymnasts in America.... But once you qualify to be on the US Women Olympic Team, you're ALMOST guaranteed to win SOME MEDALS at the Olympics....
@ll51019 no. Only hmoob Americans have laos influence. Other older miao traditions don't. Native laos people are like khmute people. Laos and Chinese are just nationality not culture. There are multiple cultures in both laos and China.
@@kiabtoomlauj6249 You seem to know so much and I was so interested until you ended up with Suni Lee! 😂 Suni Lee did good but I don’t believe she is our Hmong people’s biggest accomplishment here in the US 😂 We have people in congress & several Hmong people sitting in court rooms as Judges, we have Hmong owned pharmacy & Hmong grocery stores all over the country
My family tree isn't too far from China. From what I know, I was born in Thailand, my parents were born in laos, my grandparents were born in Vietnam, and my great grandparents were born in China.
Yes our Hmong peoples history are starting from China in the 17 th centuries after the Maos peoples and China are living together in China but in the history said Chinese peoples started the wars back in 17 centuries with Hmong peoples first then after our Hmong king had die then Chinese peoples began to kill Hmong peoples want to get ripped of our Hmong in China that’s why our Mao peoples had fought Chinese peoples until we the Maos peoples didn’t want with Chinese anymore then our Mao peoples were fulling apart and had gone to move or live in a separate ways then some Maos peoples immigrants to Vietnam country some had in migrated to Berma country so after many years then some Maos group immigrants to Laos country then some immigrants to Thailand that’s why now our Maos had live every where’s but still speak the same languages just some words had different dialect only wall are from the same continent we all immigrants from China during in the century Chinese peoples names us that ( Maos ) peoples but since we immigrants to many different Asian countries then we Chang the name Mao to ( Hmong) because the name Maos is not appropriate it doesn’t hmatter Hmong in China, hmong in Vietnam, hmong in America, hmong in France, hmong Thailand, or any other country remember that we all are Hmong the same ruts ok thank you.
@@youtuberx199 Our Miao or Hmong people are indigenous to China We’ve been there since the beginning of time. My understanding is the ones who moved out of China are only the very few & are the ones who did not want to go along with the rules of China’s ruling dynasties/Emperors at the time. Because of the vast land in China & countless ethnic groups & different dialects, some of the Emperors wanted everyone to write & speak one language. Wear one clothing. My understanding is the Hmongs who kept rebelling against the ruling dynasties refused to give up their dialect & their traditional clothing. People were given the choice & ones who don’t comply were killed. BUT most Hmong people today don’t know or understand this.. they were told by the older generations that the Chinese are their worst enemy & hates them & kicked them out of China The Miaos that stayed in China know the truth better
The ancient homeland of ALL HMONG/MIAO is in Mainland China ie HuaXia/Central Plains between Yellow River, Yangtze River and Pearl River. In short, all Hmongs are the people of China.❤❤❤❤❤
Nope china is simply the nationality. Being miao/hmong is their ethnicity. They're not from china. they are descendants of an ethnicity which originate from that land. It's different.
多谢啊， 我去过四川兴文县，那里也有我们苗族的 “走亲节“ it may be a good place for the next stop in your exploration of the Hmong journey. Also, fenghua, not many people know why xiangxi and Shen Congwen played such an important role in global Hmong narratives.
@@generalnguyenngocloan1700 Long Cheng is debatable. If North Laos is captured by the Hmong people-if we win the suing and court case against them-then yes. Long Cheng will be a big city like Los Angeles. No Commie Laos to enter unless you give up your Lao citizenship.
No matter which nation, tribe, or ethnic group, as long as your ancestors have left their footprints in the Central Kingdom, you can always touch their culture and read their stories by combing through piles of books written in Chinese characters. Never forget to teach your children and grandchildren Chinese language, which is the bloodline that connects your family to this vast land. As long as they can speak and read Chinese, they will have 5,000 years of civilization as their backing and 1.4 billion people as their compatriots.
All the chinese people have lost there root Erase and Force by the new ruler every time. We dont Believe in some thing that the chinese written in book where the king can to change History. Our secret weapon is to pass the real Information by Mouth to our Next generation. That why we know we are not chinese.
Thanks, Yanyan for the interesting story. Tracing the roots since ancient times is important, any doubt. It was said that there are about 60 million chinese people living outside china... Is that true?
@virgiliomateus They are 400 millions White people live outside Europe They killed all the natives in North America ( including Canada), Australia and New Zealand, but always lying and talk about human rights
60 million are just Han people who insist on not changing their nationality. In the last century, the United States and the Soviet Union provoked a wave of anti-Chinese sentiment throughout Asia. From the Black Sea to ASEAN, Japan and South Korea, Chinese people in various countries were persecuted. A large number of Chinese chose to change their nationality. If we count other ethnic groups that migrated from China, such as the Dai, Zhuang, Miao, Hui, Kyrgyz, Mongolian tribes, Wa, etc., and those with maternal Chinese blood, the overseas Chinese blood population exceeds 200 million. This is limited to large-scale immigration that began after the 16th century, and does not count Chinese immigrants to the world before the 15th century. According to legends and documents of various countries, more than half of the countries in Asia can be traced back to China.
China never fails to amaze me with the ethnic minorities and the many provinces. The CCP recognized and even help to preserve their cultures. Truly a good governance of humanity. Glad the diaspora Hmong love for the motherland. That says it all of the greatness of the Chinese civilization.
They're ridding minority languages in many regional areas. Broadcast in minority tongues are banned, including cantonese which has a longer historic origin than inferior mandarin.
Do more video tours of Hmong people in China. Whether we are Hmong, Chinese, Vietnamese, or other ethnic, we're all related if you do blood tests. We all came from one parent.
If Hmong Americans genuinely want to explore their ancestral origins and heritage, visiting the Guangxi region in southern China may provide valuable insights and a deeper connection to their roots.
@scottishd0g87 Has the DNA of all Hmong people in the USA been analyzed? All individuals who have used 23andMe to trace their ancestry find connections to Guangdong. Additionally, the White Hmong dialect spoken in Guangxi shares a similar accent with those in Vietnam, Laos, Thailand, and the USA.
The Miao did not originate from the Guangxi area; they only moved there recently, historically speaking. Guangxi area is where BaiYue tribes occupied in ancient times; they're the ancestors of the Tai-Kadai people. Also, Miao or Hmong have different lineages and migrations; we can not simply say that all Miao/Hmong people belong to that group, although we are related through history and culture.
Hmong people’s ancestors can be traced back to Chiyou, one of the three tribal leaders who were recorded in the grand historian. Hmong appeared about two thousand years earlier than Han, which is contradictory to the current communist regime’s narrative for Han people dominating the entire Chinese history. Sanxingdui excavations in Sichuan province proved that ancient civilizations could trace back to Sumerian times.
50cent warriors from CCCP lol History is history Chiyou and Huan Di were contemporaries The miao were ancient people in China before the Han people That's simple history no politics So chill
Hmongs used to have their kingdom in China but the Hans drove them to mountains and genocided them to the point that they lost their home and migrated to south east Asia.
That is incorrect as it should be Miao. The label Miao were given by the Chinese for those who assimilated in China and not leave persecution during the Manchu and Han dynasty. While the label Hmong was created later on for those who escaped with their families or Chinese spouse and lived in SEA for many generations. Miao in this today generation has more Chinese blood making them more Chinese citizens beside them living there. While the Hmong who lives in SEA for many generations has little to no Chinese blood.
@@andyyang50 How can the name Miao still be used if they have assimilated into Han culture? You're correct that some groups of Miao accepted the "Chinese" rule and were called cooked Miao. You realize Miao culture survived Sinicization; therefore, they still practice Miao rituals and traditions in China. I don't understand your concept of Miao in China having more "Chinese" blood because they live in China. Does the same apply to the Hmong in the US, Laos, Vietnam, and Thailand, who now have more of their host country's blood? Could you make me understand your logic?
@ll51019 Oh, smart ass are you sure about that? Or you just making assumptions? Since you decided to flap your gums, go ahead and tell me what you think you know about my grandma's lineage.
I would like to ask a request. The Hmong history is best known because it’s an oral history culture. Would it be possible for you to interview Hmong people and we would like to see them speak? Thanks and no worries if you can’t
To Ralph Murphy- You're talking through some rear orifice about China "looking down on their 56 ethnic minorities". Actually you must mean the Hans "looking down" on the other officially recognised 55 ethnic minorities. Presumably you mean discrimination. So much for your scholarship and accuracy! People from the minority groups enjoy many privileges which are denied the Hans. How can that be described as "looking down"? Old age may bring wisdom. But you seemed to have got stuck like an old record at some groove which says "China bad, China bad"! Have you been to China recently instead of reading NYT or neo-con think tank reports?
Hmong are another group of Chinese, the only difference is that the Han under the last Qing drove them into the mountains of south China and out of China. The Hmong were the last group of Chinese to fight against the Qing Dynasty before the Han finally rid themselves of the Manchus and Japanese.
@@yellowneck92 Define Chinese. Miao is a culture. Hmong is part of the Miao culture. If you trace all the Miao groups' roots, it leads back to one mother tongue sharing a history and culture. We are one people.
My great great grand father was born in from Longling area but in 1820 to then Laos that they've considered wild country side who own by nobody, and we still believe Beijing- China was a place that there a stair drop from Heaven down to Earth for the Death to use it for ascent to the Heaven. Hmong all still do this ritual when death occurring in America
Yes. The word "ceeb tsheej" derives from 京城. It got misinterpreted into heaven. But realistically it is just the capital city. In olden days, people were so poor that they can never visit the capital city where all the wealth is at. So they preserve their finest clothes and shoes and one day hope to visit ceeb tsheej in those clothes and shoe. But for many, that time never comes, so in death is the only time they believe they can go to ceeb tsheej. And those finest clothes and shoes are put on in death.
Origins as referring to ancestry your incorrect. Hmong and Miao ancestors were not Chinese. No one knows what we the Hmong or Miao were called back in the day. The term Miao were a term or label given by the Chinese. While the term or label Hmong was created later on for those who escape the dynasty persecution that currently resides in SEA or immigrated overseas during the Vietnam War. The biometrics your referring to is the Miao in this day generation that live in China. There is a vast difference between Hmong who live in SEA and the Miao who live in China. After many generations the Miao who decided to assimilate with Chinese culture has more Chinese blood. While the Hmong who who fled China with their families or Chinese spouse that live in SEA for many generations has no Chinese blood at all or a little.
@@andyyang50 What do you mean by no Chinese blood? Have you ever done a DNA testing? Please let me know who you're grouped with. You're confusing biology with culture.
@@andyyang50idk about u talking about, but Hmong American DNA are 40% or more related to Han Chinese, while the rest of the percentage is mixed up with other South East Asian from migrating. Sounds like you never did your DNA test before.
Thaum ub thiab puag thaum i hnov peb tej Niam tej txiv, pog koob yawg suab lawv cav2, hais2 txog hmb lub tebchaws paj tawg lag li peb tiam nco2 Looj Ceeb. Ua li nej rov mus txog paj tawg lag hmb tej qub tebchaws, qw lw , ua li tam sim no ho zoo li cas lawm.? Puas Xis nej nyob thiab.? tus tas lub neej txoj sia lawm los tseem taw kev rov los paj tawg lag lawm thiab, puas Pom peb tej pog koob yawg suab lawv nyob pem ko na.?
How accurate is this history though? Cause thru out human history, when wars exist between certain people, the winner usually dictate and manipulate whats allow to be scribe or narrated with-in records, you never get the actuals history. The winner will get to decided what allow to stay or what need to be erase. And this might be true for the hmong because hmong chinese and the hmong people who migrate west south when they lost the war seem to have difference in dialect and also difference exist within religious practices.
Very Funny, the last time the American Hmong said they will never never recognised the Miao people of China as Hmong at all. The American Hmong also that all China's Miaos are Han Chinese already.
Well can’t blame them. Miao and Hmong share the same ancestry. Now the Hmong and Miao can’t communicate well with each other after so many generations. The Miao has more Chinese blood.
@@andyyang50 The Miao language has three main branches that evolved from proto-Miao, which are eastern, central, and western, with subdialects within them. Hmong people outside of China speak the western dialect. Of course, after many generations and migration, language will evolve. And no, the White Hmong dialect outside of China is not the original. Linguistic research does not support this claim made by Hmong outside of China.
Hmong=Miao = 蚩尤 one of the four ancient elements of ancient Chinese people. Those were assimilated became components of Han people, those who migrated to the southwest became Hmong/Miao. ❤
In ancient times, there was no concept of ethnicity. The Han and Miao peoples were originally from the same family. The father of Huangdi and Yandi was called Shaodian
Base a couple of deep researcher it's said that Hmong have a direct relations with the people currently living in Mongolian, the Hmong originate from the Xiongnu tribe which splinter into multiple group heading in multiple directions when their land was taken. Best way to know is DNA, that doesn't lie about who is related to who!
Agreed. People often mistaken Hmong for Mongolian just because of the similarities in pronunciation. The XiongNu were not Hmong either. I remember from an old video of Hmong in China. It a profound impact on me due to the fact that he said, we should be proud to be Hmong and to do the things we do because what we did preserve our existence today. The XiongNu was a huge ethnic group and has disappeared or extinct.
@@shailee9762 that's correct the Xiongnu were a collective group of people from all over. As group lost land, those closest to each other move as groups in different direction.
Can someone verify if this is true. It was said that during the Hmong vs Chinese wars, how the Hmong were easily spotted and recognized by the Chinese was because alot of the Hmongs had blonde hair and blue eyes. If that's true then the Hmong's ancestors are not Chinese but of Western decent like Seberia.
I hear this story all the time and its not true. Only a small tiny minority of Hmong had blonde hair in the past and that still holds true today. Also the suggestion that because some Hmong had blonde hair that meant we were once white people. As a counter to that argument, genetic mutations happens sporadically all the time and just because someone has blonde hair and blue eyes, doesn’t mean they must originate from white people. Hmong blonde hair isn’t all blonde too. Its like the color of dirt. Also the argument that blonde hair is really easy to spot, is it really? And blue eyes? Think about it. You must be really close to know if someone has blue eyes. Blonde hair just blends in with the environment as there are lots of plants that are yellow, especially during the dryer seasons. Yes some Chinese do carry blonde hair traits.
@user-mm7zi4ue7d it's not albinism ,my uncle is a red hair with brown clear eyes and my cousins were red hair when they were young...but with age,their hair turned black .
Hmong are not Chinese. Miao is a term referred to other ethnic besides Chinese. Hmong is not Miao either. Hmong is Hmong, we have a culture much different from any Chinese culture. Chinese conquered those lands back in the day and burned all of our culture and history. Don’t believe the lies nowadays.
The Hmong American are from Southeast Asia and they came from Laos. According to the US government they are classified as people from Southeast Asia and came from Laos. Wenshan is classifed as a Zhuang and Miao Autonomous Prefecture. Hmong American are Miao and Yao group from Laos and Vietnam and are not Zhuang and Miao group from Wenshan, Yunnan.
Do a little more research, beyond the U.S Hmong people are for certain a subgroup of Miao people. there are plenty of sources out there that prove this. the Vietnamese, Thai, Lao even call us Meo, their pronunciation of Miao.
@@JVue997 That still doesn't change the fact that Hmong American are Miao and Yao of Laos and Vietnam. Southeast Asian Hmong are not the same as Miao people in China but are grouped as part of Miao people. The Miao's that comes from Yunnan are not the same as the Miao from Guizhou. Hmong American are cluster with Yunnan and Southeast Asia people.
@@andyyang50 No I was talking about classification and where they came from. It has nothing to do with nationality and Hmong American doesn't have a country therefore they don't have a nationality. They are just grouped under Miao people.
Hmong people is a lost tribe from Korean ruling Sandong peninsular in BC 2nd millenium when the unified HAN had expanded into all 4 directions. Still, Korean and Hmong share in physical traits, language, and traditions.
Chiyou is not our Mong hmong txiv yawg. Chiyou is the ancestors of Nanman maab dong Yi Bu Yi thail Yi Suave Yi. Miao Nanman maab Dong Yi, Bu Yi, thai Yi, suave Yi Han Chinese is not our Mong hmong brothers sisters,but the natural enemy of our Mong hmong people. Faajtim huangdi khan Beijing is our Mong hmong ancestor. Today we the Hmong Mong people feeyang, we still call Mong hmong Txiv Faajtim huangdi. In the case of fighting war, we the Mong hmong people calling upon Mong Hmong Txiv Faajtim huangdi khan Beijing and Mong hmong Txiv yawg Zengshis Khan Genghis Khan to protect the Mong hmong peoples.
@@bassqueens Inner Mongolia and Mongolia and all Central land call China today is our Mong nation Mongol teb chaw Mong. Mong txiv yawg Kublai khan yuan dynasty is our Mong hmong ancient ancestors land. No such thing as Chinese China. No such thing as Miao.
Mong Hmong we are Xiongnu bear tribe. Miao Nanman maab Dong Yi Bu Yi thai Yi Suave Yi Han Chinese people is slaves to our Mong hmong ancestors. We call Miao Nanman maab Dong Yi Bu Yi Suave Yi Han suave maab qaab or in English is Nanman maab suave slaves.
Because of certain reasons? Why so coy? They left Vietnam and Laos because of the American loss of the war in Vietnam and the Hmong had supported the Americans against the Vietnamese. The Vietnamese persecuted the Hmong. Therefore the Hmong people were in danger from the Vietnamese, so the Americans arranged to get them out of Vietnam and Laos to safety in America. Are you not allowed to tell the truth about this?
@@hanzhovaj4129 Thank you. The Hmong were against the Vietnamese as a whole group - both north and south! Beware of the history as told by the ruling powers, it is always biased in their favour. That's why people need to tell their own histories. Your history is you. Don't let anyone take it, steal it, use and abuse it. By doing that they are using and abusing you and your people.
you are wrong about the Vietnamese persecuted the Hmong after the war. What has recently come to life is those crimes was done by Hmong communist who are now living in Phosovan, Xieng Khouang pretending to be left over GVP soldiers. Hmong Americans have married a lot of these communist's daughter and brough them to the USA and they continue to leech off us after wiping out our relatives. the most famous one of these is that lady/husband telling hmong story and recently as of last year Lee Leng from Sacramento story shed some light into one of few butcher/rapist of hmong women, child and executing their husband (this was documented by French journalist; at the time they though it was the Vietnamese but it was Hmong Commies SOB living in Phosovan, Nong Het) You can see the multiple videos it's "hunted like animals" a lot of these kids/women who are now in the USA can testify to it. Let's not be quick to point fingers
@@shinbi6009 The opportunities to be wrong are endless but I know these things happened. I'm 67 years old and a trained historian and the war in Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos had a great impact on me, and I've studied this period ever since. If you think the whole nation and all the peoples of Vietnam are united and in agreement and are all treated alike you're misled. The Chinese look down on the 56 minorities in their country. The Vietnamese do exactly the same in Vietnam with their 54 minorities. I never said Vietnam tried to genocide the Hmong and other ethnic minorities. Do a little study yourself. Learning is fun.
Historically, Hmong is as Chinese as it come. They are the direct descendants of the legendary Fire (Flame) Emperor and Chiyou. The Fire emperor is the leader of the first tribe who used fire, farming and medicine. Later, they lost the first major military conflict in ancient Chinese history where the first compass was invented and used in battlefield by the Yellow emperor. After the defeat, they broke up and exiled for the next five thousands year, part of this group exiled to the west, and the part that moved south are the ancestors of Hmong. The major part stayed and combined with the Yellow Emperor's tribe. To honor this, Han Chinese called themselves the descendants of Yan Huang 炎黄子孙 (Yan: Fire . Huang: Yellow).
Where you get all these info I loved to read more
Sorry, but that's just tribal folklore. NOT to say the Hmong didn't have any struggle against the expanding, powerful Han Chinese. They did, as did many other small ethnics whose traditional lands the Hans forcibly took over.
But, yes, the Hmong WERE one of the original and ADJACENT neighbors to the Han Chinese.
Hmong generational folklore about floods and mighty rivers, for example, were largely about the Yantze and Yellow rivers that flow from the Himalaya northerly into central and eastern China.
Hmong have STORIES --- recent stories ---- about the mighty Maekong River; but those stories were created from the 1800s on, when a TINY percentage of Hmong started moving to Northern Laos, from Yunnan.
More Hmong moved down to North Vietnam, but those were the Hmong in the most southeastern Yunnan to southwestern Guangxi provinces. Further, close to 100% of the Hmong in Northern Vietnam have been COMMUNISTS like the Chinese and North Vietnamese; close to zero Hmong from Nothern Vietnam "escaped from the Vietnam War" like Hmong in Laos.
Anyway, the Hmong in northwestern Laos were those who moved there from Paj Tawg, Yunnan, Yunnan.
My great, great, great, grandfather, for example --- my dad still knows all the names of those paternal guys ---- crossed from Paj Tawg to northern Laos (Muong Xai and Northern Luangpraband), literally just a stone throw in distance...
Historically speaking, when the much more powerful Hans started expanding outward, from their traditional lands, which were in the eastern and northern parts toward the Sea and Beijing .... around the time or the First Emperor.... Hmong and other ethnic groups in and around the Sichuan/X'ian region --- especially the "trouble makers" who didn't want to conform/didn't want to be ruled over by the Hans ---- were pushed ever deeper south.
That's how over 90% of the various related Hmong tribes ---- the 5th or 6th largest minorities in China ---- ended up, now, situated between Sichuan, Yunnan, Guizhou, and Guangxi.
Roughly 5% of the Hmong in China moved to Northern Vietnam. Another 2-3% moved to Northern Laos, in the early to 1800s.
It's 100% from those Hmong in northern and eastern Laos that the 500K or so Hmong in the West here came. All the Hmong in Northern Vietnam, plus 40% or so of the Hmong in Laos.... WERE/ARE Communists, so they fought against our parents and grandparents in the Vietnam War.
They were victorious, so we had to take a long hike... crossing the Maekong to Thailand, from where we came to the West, in the last 45 years...
One EXCEPTIONALLY IMPROBABLE but true fact: ----
it is from these 500K Hmong in the West, that the VERY FIRST ASIAN WOMAN, ever --- not a Chinese, not a Japanese, not a Korean, not a Vietnamese, not a Thai, not a Filipino, not a Lao, not an Indonesian or any other woman from the other much larger Asian ethnics.... but an 18 year-old Hmong woman ---- came to be the All Around Olympic Gold medalist, of the women's 2020 Olympics....
Her name is Sunisa Lee.
If her kidney diseases are controlled and if she qualifies for the 2024 Paris Olympics, in her home state of Minnesota.... there are very good chances she would win more medals... what colors they may be can't be sure.... The TOUGHER part, for American women, would be to qualify on the America US Olympic Women's Team, due to the depth and breadth of quality gymnasts in America.... But once you qualify to be on the US Women Olympic Team, you're ALMOST guaranteed to win SOME MEDALS at the Olympics....
They laos
@ll51019 no. Only hmoob Americans have laos influence. Other older miao traditions don't. Native laos people are like khmute people. Laos and Chinese are just nationality not culture. There are multiple cultures in both laos and China.
@@kiabtoomlauj6249
You seem to know so much
and I was so interested
until you ended up with Suni Lee! 😂
Suni Lee did good
but I don’t believe she is our Hmong people’s biggest accomplishment here in the US 😂
We have people in congress & several Hmong people sitting in court rooms as Judges,
we have Hmong owned pharmacy
& Hmong grocery stores
all over the country
Thank you, Yanyan, for sharing the beauty and history of Hmong village.
Thanks for tracing back the hmong silk road. It's worth my subscription. 🎉🎉🎉🎉
My family tree isn't too far from China. From what I know, I was born in Thailand, my parents were born in laos, my grandparents were born in Vietnam, and my great grandparents were born in China.
So what is your nationality?
Cap
Yes our Hmong peoples history are starting from China in the 17 th centuries after the Maos peoples and China are living together in China but in the history said Chinese peoples started the wars back in 17 centuries with Hmong peoples first then after our Hmong king had die then Chinese peoples began to kill Hmong peoples want to get ripped of our Hmong in China that’s why our Mao peoples had fought Chinese peoples until we the Maos peoples didn’t want with Chinese anymore then our Mao peoples were fulling apart and had gone to move or live in a separate ways then some Maos peoples immigrants to Vietnam country some had in migrated to Berma country so after many years then some Maos group immigrants to Laos country then some immigrants to Thailand that’s why now our Maos had live every where’s but still speak the same languages just some words had different dialect only wall are from the same continent we all immigrants from China during in the century Chinese peoples names us that ( Maos ) peoples but since we immigrants to many different Asian countries then we Chang the name Mao to ( Hmong) because the name Maos is not appropriate it doesn’t hmatter Hmong in China, hmong in Vietnam, hmong in America, hmong in France, hmong Thailand, or any other country remember that we all are Hmong the same ruts ok thank you.
@paulavang2987 Why most Miao people chose to stay in China? There are 11 millions of them in China nowadays.
@@youtuberx199
Our Miao or Hmong people
are indigenous to China
We’ve been there since the beginning of time.
My understanding is the ones who moved out of China are only the very few & are the ones who did not want to go along with the rules of China’s ruling dynasties/Emperors at the time.
Because of the vast land in China &
countless ethnic groups & different dialects,
some of the Emperors wanted everyone to write & speak one language. Wear one clothing.
My understanding is
the Hmongs who kept rebelling against the ruling dynasties refused to give up their dialect & their traditional clothing.
People were given the choice
& ones who don’t comply were killed.
BUT most Hmong people today don’t know or understand this..
they were told by the older generations that the Chinese are their worst enemy & hates them
& kicked them out of China
The Miaos that stayed in China
know the truth better
Glad to be part of this group in 2017..
The ancient homeland of ALL HMONG/MIAO is in Mainland China ie HuaXia/Central Plains between Yellow River, Yangtze River and Pearl River. In short, all Hmongs are the people of China.❤❤❤❤❤
Nope china is simply the nationality. Being miao/hmong is their ethnicity. They're not from china. they are descendants of an ethnicity which originate from that land. It's different.
多谢啊， 我去过四川兴文县，那里也有我们苗族的 “走亲节“ it may be a good place for the next stop in your exploration of the Hmong journey. Also, fenghua, not many people know why xiangxi and Shen Congwen played such an important role in global Hmong narratives.
我来自云南文山的hmong
I am happy to be a Hmong person.
Make the Blooming City as our capital. I put a vote for a Hmong capital.
No, Long Cheng, Lao! 🫡
@@generalnguyenngocloan1700 Long Cheng is debatable. If North Laos is captured by the Hmong people-if we win the suing and court case against them-then yes. Long Cheng will be a big city like Los Angeles. No Commie Laos to enter unless you give up your Lao citizenship.
@@KevinVang1000 Hmong🌀👀👍🏻
Learned something new today.❤
Thanks for sharing Yanyan.
One should never ever forget his or her root. Forgetting the root is losing existence.
No matter which nation, tribe, or ethnic group, as long as your ancestors have left their footprints in the Central Kingdom, you can always touch their culture and read their stories by combing through piles of books written in Chinese characters. Never forget to teach your children and grandchildren Chinese language, which is the bloodline that connects your family to this vast land. As long as they can speak and read Chinese, they will have 5,000 years of civilization as their backing and 1.4 billion people as their compatriots.
Central Kingdom Master Race.
@@jimmylee1408 Stop your inciting nonsense words.
All the chinese people have lost there root Erase and Force by the new ruler every time. We dont Believe in some thing that the chinese written in book where the king can to change History. Our secret weapon is to pass the real Information by Mouth to our Next generation. That why we know we are not chinese.
Thanks, Yanyan for the interesting story. Tracing the roots since ancient times is important, any doubt.
It was said that there are about 60 million chinese people living outside china... Is that true?
@virgiliomateus
They are 400 millions White people live outside Europe
They killed all the natives in North America ( including Canada), Australia and New Zealand, but always lying and talk about human rights
A lot more, but yep, the majority of Hmong live in China.
60 million are just Han people who insist on not changing their nationality. In the last century, the United States and the Soviet Union provoked a wave of anti-Chinese sentiment throughout Asia. From the Black Sea to ASEAN, Japan and South Korea, Chinese people in various countries were persecuted. A large number of Chinese chose to change their nationality. If we count other ethnic groups that migrated from China, such as the Dai, Zhuang, Miao, Hui, Kyrgyz, Mongolian tribes, Wa, etc., and those with maternal Chinese blood, the overseas Chinese blood population exceeds 200 million. This is limited to large-scale immigration that began after the 16th century, and does not count Chinese immigrants to the world before the 15th century. According to legends and documents of various countries, more than half of the countries in Asia can be traced back to China.
China never fails to amaze me with the ethnic minorities and the many provinces. The CCP recognized and even help to preserve their cultures. Truly a good governance of humanity. Glad the diaspora Hmong love for the motherland. That says it all of the greatness of the Chinese civilization.
FYI “CCP” is used mostly by anti-China hawks and their lackeys. The party refers to itself as “CPC” so we call it so accordingly.
They're ridding minority languages in many regional areas. Broadcast in minority tongues are banned, including cantonese which has a longer historic origin than inferior mandarin.
@@jimmylee1408 source: trust me bro. Covid is over and China is open. Anyone can just go to China to find out what you said is a lie.
Not to mention the one child policy doesn't apply to ethnic minority groups like Miao and others.
All I got to say is, “Thank you so much for sharing!” 😊
Do more video tours of Hmong people in China. Whether we are Hmong, Chinese, Vietnamese, or other ethnic, we're all related if you do blood tests. We all came from one parent.
Yanyan - thank you for all your videos. They have been very informational and insightful.
Wow this was so emotional and enlightening. Thank you for highlighting this important history for us all.
If Hmong Americans genuinely want to explore their ancestral origins and heritage, visiting the Guangxi region in southern China may provide valuable insights and a deeper connection to their roots.
@scottishd0g87 Has the DNA of all Hmong people in the USA been analyzed? All individuals who have used 23andMe to trace their ancestry find connections to Guangdong. Additionally, the White Hmong dialect spoken in Guangxi shares a similar accent with those in Vietnam, Laos, Thailand, and the USA.
23andme, only cater to the white folks. They don't pinpoint where you are actually from. Lol
The Miao did not originate from the Guangxi area; they only moved there recently, historically speaking. Guangxi area is where BaiYue tribes occupied in ancient times; they're the ancestors of the Tai-Kadai people. Also, Miao or Hmong have different lineages and migrations; we can not simply say that all Miao/Hmong people belong to that group, although we are related through history and culture.
@@Lee-du1js Guangxi was their last stop before migrating to Vietnam, Laos, and Thailand.
@@iTek14 It's only some of the Miao/Hmong group's last stop. Some entered Vietnam, Laos, and Thailand via Yunnan.
Thank you for this lovely video.
This is amazing, you did a great job. Thank you.
Great video!
Long live Hmong 👍✌️🙏
great video, thanks for sharing
Thank you for presenting amazing people and places of China!
Hmong people’s ancestors can be traced back to Chiyou, one of the three tribal leaders who were recorded in the grand historian. Hmong appeared about two thousand years earlier than Han, which is contradictory to the current communist regime’s narrative for Han people dominating the entire Chinese history. Sanxingdui excavations in Sichuan province proved that ancient civilizations could trace back to Sumerian times.
take it easy...bro, lol, the Hans knew how to read and write, and their history is well recorded in books and writing, not just claim such as yours..
Lol CIA dog is barking so hard😏🤭🤣
buildbacksidebetter……
50cent warriors from CCCP lol
History is history
Chiyou and Huan Di were contemporaries
The miao were ancient people in China before the Han people
That's simple history no politics
So chill
It's true, Chiyou's battle with Faajtim is even recorded in the ancient Korean history book Hwandan Gogi.
Wow very interesting i like ur stories.
Very good yanyan
Hmongs used to have their kingdom in China but the Hans drove them to mountains and genocided them to the point that they lost their home and migrated to south east Asia.
The Miao people have never established their own country in China
Hmongs are doing just fine in China.
Miao instead of hmong. Hmong is from SE asia
@@jol6310 How could the Miao people come from Southeast Asia? The Miao people came from the tribe of Yandi, the younger brother of Huangdi of China.
That is incorrect as it should be Miao. The label Miao were given by the Chinese for those who assimilated in China and not leave persecution during the Manchu and Han dynasty. While the label Hmong was created later on for those who escaped with their families or Chinese spouse and lived in SEA for many generations. Miao in this today generation has more Chinese blood making them more Chinese citizens beside them living there. While the Hmong who lives in SEA for many generations has little to no Chinese blood.
miao people are one of the poorest minority in China. how are they doing well?
@@andyyang50 How can the name Miao still be used if they have assimilated into Han culture? You're correct that some groups of Miao accepted the "Chinese" rule and were called cooked Miao. You realize Miao culture survived Sinicization; therefore, they still practice Miao rituals and traditions in China. I don't understand your concept of Miao in China having more "Chinese" blood because they live in China. Does the same apply to the Hmong in the US, Laos, Vietnam, and Thailand, who now have more of their host country's blood? Could you make me understand your logic?
Thank you for this history lesson. (ಥ﹏ಥ) I am so happy. I hope one day I would able to trace back too and bring my children.
I gotta show my grandmother this!!!
She from laos bruh 🤦🏿♂️🤦🏿♂️🤦🏿♂️
@ll51019 Oh, smart ass are you sure about that? Or you just making assumptions? Since you decided to flap your gums, go ahead and tell me what you think you know about my grandma's lineage.
How can we obtain a copy of the funeral scriptures?
I would like to ask a request. The Hmong history is best known because it’s an oral history culture. Would it be possible for you to interview Hmong people and we would like to see them speak? Thanks and no worries if you can’t
Thanks for sharing❤
To Ralph Murphy-
You're talking through some rear orifice about China "looking down on their 56 ethnic minorities". Actually you must mean the Hans "looking down" on the other officially recognised 55 ethnic minorities. Presumably you mean discrimination. So much for your scholarship and accuracy! People from the minority groups enjoy many privileges which are denied the Hans. How can that be described as "looking down"? Old age may bring wisdom. But you seemed to have got stuck like an old record at some groove which says "China bad, China bad"! Have you been to China recently instead of reading NYT or neo-con think tank reports?
Lots of CIA shills embedded here. 1.6bil dysinfo US budget.
Thank you for sharing..
Hmong are another group of Chinese, the only difference is that the Han under the last Qing drove them into the mountains of south China and out of China. The Hmong were the last group of Chinese to fight against the Qing Dynasty before the Han finally rid themselves of the Manchus and Japanese.
Wtf is another group of Chinese. Nope. Hans label us as Miao and we aren’t part of that group. Peb yog Hmoob
@@yellowneck92 it doesn’t matter what they call you even if it’s not a nice label. A DNA check shows Han DNA. WTF? 🧐
We all came out of Africa, are you African too?
@@yellowneck92 Define Chinese. Miao is a culture. Hmong is part of the Miao culture. If you trace all the Miao groups' roots, it leads back to one mother tongue sharing a history and culture. We are one people.
@Lee-du1js Simple: Anyone who lives in China is Chinese. Some people believe that Americans are white people 😂😂😂.
Since Hmong people don’t really have a country, they are the most interesting and complex to learn about with their history. 😊
My great great grand father was born in from Longling area but in 1820 to then Laos that they've considered wild country side who own by nobody, and we still believe Beijing- China was a place that there a stair drop from Heaven down to Earth for the Death to use it for ascent to the Heaven. Hmong all still do this ritual when death occurring in America
Yes. The word "ceeb tsheej" derives from 京城.
It got misinterpreted into heaven. But realistically it is just the capital city. In olden days, people were so poor that they can never visit the capital city where all the wealth is at. So they preserve their finest clothes and shoes and one day hope to visit ceeb tsheej in those clothes and shoe. But for many, that time never comes, so in death is the only time they believe they can go to ceeb tsheej. And those finest clothes and shoes are put on in death.
Hmongs originated from China. They are Chinese, the Biometrics are evident.
We ain't no fucking Chinese
Origins as referring to ancestry your incorrect. Hmong and Miao ancestors were not Chinese. No one knows what we the Hmong or Miao were called back in the day. The term Miao were a term or label given by the Chinese. While the term or label Hmong was created later on for those who escape the dynasty persecution that currently resides in SEA or immigrated overseas during the Vietnam War. The biometrics your referring to is the Miao in this day generation that live in China. There is a vast difference between Hmong who live in SEA and the Miao who live in China. After many generations the Miao who decided to assimilate with Chinese culture has more Chinese blood. While the Hmong who who fled China with their families or Chinese spouse that live in SEA for many generations has no Chinese blood at all or a little.
@@andyyang50 What do you mean by no Chinese blood? Have you ever done a DNA testing? Please let me know who you're grouped with. You're confusing biology with culture.
@@andyyang50idk about u talking about, but Hmong American DNA are 40% or more related to Han Chinese, while the rest of the percentage is mixed up with other South East Asian from migrating. Sounds like you never did your DNA test before.
Not all miao are Hmong..Hmong is just a subgroup of Miao.
Correct. Miao is a culture. Hence, not all Miao are Hmong, but all Hmong are Miao. All Miao people have their own self-designation.
I need to visit this place
Thaum ub thiab puag thaum i hnov peb tej Niam tej txiv, pog koob yawg suab lawv cav2, hais2 txog hmb lub tebchaws paj tawg lag li peb tiam nco2 Looj Ceeb. Ua li nej rov mus txog paj tawg lag hmb tej qub tebchaws, qw lw , ua li tam sim no ho zoo li cas lawm.? Puas Xis nej nyob thiab.? tus tas lub neej txoj sia lawm los tseem taw kev rov los paj tawg lag lawm thiab, puas Pom peb tej pog koob yawg suab lawv nyob pem ko na.?
👏👏👏
Thank you.
How accurate is this history though? Cause thru out human history, when wars exist between certain people, the winner usually dictate and manipulate whats allow to be scribe or narrated with-in records, you never get the actuals history. The winner will get to decided what allow to stay or what need to be erase. And this might be true for the hmong because hmong chinese and the hmong people who migrate west south when they lost the war seem to have difference in dialect and also difference exist within religious practices.
Very Funny, the last time the American Hmong said they will never never recognised the Miao people of China as Hmong at all. The American Hmong also that all China's Miaos are Han Chinese already.
Well can’t blame them. Miao and Hmong share the same ancestry. Now the Hmong and Miao can’t communicate well with each other after so many generations. The Miao has more Chinese blood.
@@andyyang50 The Miao language has three main branches that evolved from proto-Miao, which are eastern, central, and western, with subdialects within them. Hmong people outside of China speak the western dialect. Of course, after many generations and migration, language will evolve. And no, the White Hmong dialect outside of China is not the original. Linguistic research does not support this claim made by Hmong outside of China.
By that logic, Hmong Americans are Americans already. Stop trying to define who people are because the same can be done to you.
are u a hakka from jiangxi
客家人是汉族人
Hmong=Miao = 蚩尤 one of the four ancient elements of ancient Chinese people. Those were assimilated became components of Han people, those who migrated to the southwest became Hmong/Miao. ❤
In ancient times, there was no concept of ethnicity. The Han and Miao peoples were originally from the same family.
The father of Huangdi and Yandi was called Shaodian
Retirement plan is going back home.
❤❤❤
Base a couple of deep researcher it's said that Hmong have a direct relations with the people currently living in Mongolian, the Hmong originate from the Xiongnu tribe which splinter into multiple group heading in multiple directions when their land was taken. Best way to know is DNA, that doesn't lie about who is related to who!
Hmong has 0 connection to Mongolians or Xiongnu.
Agreed. People often mistaken Hmong for Mongolian just because of the similarities in pronunciation. The XiongNu were not Hmong either. I remember from an old video of Hmong in China. It a profound impact on me due to the fact that he said, we should be proud to be Hmong and to do the things we do because what we did preserve our existence today. The XiongNu was a huge ethnic group and has disappeared or extinct.
@@shailee9762 that's correct the Xiongnu were a collective group of people from all over. As group lost land, those closest to each other move as groups in different direction.
@@nightowl7261 have every connection to those group
@GeneralMoss
Nope. Hmong had 0 connection to those groups, culturally, linguistically, genetically, or traditionally. Go do a dna test.
So Hmong US category is East or South East Asia 🤣
Can someone verify if this is true. It was said that during the Hmong vs Chinese wars, how the Hmong were easily spotted and recognized by the Chinese was because alot of the Hmongs had blonde hair and blue eyes. If that's true then the Hmong's ancestors are not Chinese but of Western decent like Seberia.
I hear this story all the time and its not true. Only a small tiny minority of Hmong had blonde hair in the past and that still holds true today. Also the suggestion that because some Hmong had blonde hair that meant we were once white people. As a counter to that argument, genetic mutations happens sporadically all the time and just because someone has blonde hair and blue eyes, doesn’t mean they must originate from white people. Hmong blonde hair isn’t all blonde too. Its like the color of dirt. Also the argument that blonde hair is really easy to spot, is it really? And blue eyes? Think about it. You must be really close to know if someone has blue eyes. Blonde hair just blends in with the environment as there are lots of plants that are yellow, especially during the dryer seasons. Yes some Chinese do carry blonde hair traits.
That story is false.
@user-mm7zi4ue7d it's not albinism ,my uncle is a red hair with brown clear eyes and my cousins were red hair when they were young...but with age,their hair turned black .
More of North Asian people.
You mean Hmong vs Han
We will never become extinct! Hmoob means God's Angels. God is always behind us. 😊 We multiply every year. 😆
How many Vietnamese are force to convert Christian or else to send home? Many adopted children Vietnamese also converted in USA
Hmong are not Chinese. Miao is a term referred to other ethnic besides Chinese. Hmong is not Miao either. Hmong is Hmong, we have a culture much different from any Chinese culture. Chinese conquered those lands back in the day and burned all of our culture and history. Don’t believe the lies nowadays.
Noo!!
The Hmong American are from Southeast Asia and they came from Laos. According to the US government they are classified as people from Southeast Asia and came from Laos. Wenshan is classifed as a Zhuang and Miao Autonomous Prefecture. Hmong American are Miao and Yao group from Laos and Vietnam and are not Zhuang and Miao group from Wenshan, Yunnan.
Do a little more research, beyond the U.S Hmong people are for certain a subgroup of Miao people. there are plenty of sources out there that prove this. the Vietnamese, Thai, Lao even call us Meo, their pronunciation of Miao.
@@JVue997 That still doesn't change the fact that Hmong American are Miao and Yao of Laos and Vietnam. Southeast Asian Hmong are not the same as Miao people in China but are grouped as part of Miao people. The Miao's that comes from Yunnan are not the same as the Miao from Guizhou. Hmong American are cluster with Yunnan and Southeast Asia people.
Your talking about nationality. The Hmong came from SEA. While their ancestry came from China.
@@andyyang50 No I was talking about classification and where they came from. It has nothing to do with nationality and Hmong American doesn't have a country therefore they don't have a nationality. They are just grouped under Miao people.
HMONG HAVE NOT FIGHT WITH ANYONE THOSE WHO FIGHT THEY ARE MEO ONLY
Hongkong freedom country salute 🌎🌎🌎🌎🌎🌎 History
已報国安
@@tonywyli commie, you can't use youtube. CCP is watching you
This lady hosted in this video doesn’t look Mong hmong, she looks like maab Thailand maab laos Dong Yi maab yi.
hmong is from persia... that's where we came from
Hmong people is a lost tribe from Korean ruling Sandong peninsular in BC 2nd millenium when the unified HAN had expanded into all 4 directions.
Still, Korean and Hmong share in physical traits, language, and traditions.
Agree, sometimes when I hear Korean speaking I can easily identify some of their similarities in their native tongue.
Hmong people have nothing to do Koreans. Period.
@@Linkwii64 No. It called borrowing from Chinese. Hmong also retained a lot of old Chinese words.
Chiyou is not our Mong hmong txiv yawg. Chiyou is the ancestors of Nanman maab dong Yi Bu Yi thail Yi Suave Yi. Miao Nanman maab Dong Yi, Bu Yi, thai Yi, suave Yi Han Chinese is not our Mong hmong brothers sisters,but the natural enemy of our Mong hmong people. Faajtim huangdi khan Beijing is our Mong hmong ancestor. Today we the Hmong Mong people feeyang, we still call Mong hmong Txiv Faajtim huangdi. In the case of fighting war, we the Mong hmong people calling upon Mong Hmong Txiv Faajtim huangdi khan Beijing and Mong hmong Txiv yawg Zengshis Khan Genghis Khan to protect the Mong hmong peoples.
We're not Mongolians and miao.
@@bassqueens Mongolia is Mong region. Mongolia people is Mong people. Miao is slave to Mong people.
@@bassqueens Miao is Nagaland snake origin. Miao is animal 🦒 🦓 Miao is cow 🐄 and Buffalo 🐃. Miao is dog 🐩 🐕
I only heard we're from tuam tshoj from northern china.
@@bassqueens Inner Mongolia and Mongolia and all Central land call China today is our Mong nation Mongol teb chaw Mong. Mong txiv yawg Kublai khan yuan dynasty is our Mong hmong ancient ancestors land. No such thing as Chinese China. No such thing as Miao.
Chiyou is not txiv yawg. The name Chiyou in Dong Yi is red clouds naga snake reptile 🐍 yakshi aghori man eater.
Miao Nanman Maab Dong Yi Bu Yi Thai Yi Han suave is not our Mong hmong people, but Naga nagani fuxi nuwa snake reptile 🐍 origin.
Miao is Nanman Maab Dong Yi Bu Yi Suave Yi. Miao is not our Mong hmong people.
The real Mong hmong txiv yawg is txiv yawg Zengshis Khan in English is Genghis Khan.
😂😂😂 蒙古人答应吗？
@@niuLiu-n7l Miao Nanman Dao Mai Dong Yi
Mong Hmong we are Xiongnu bear tribe. Miao Nanman maab Dong Yi Bu Yi thai Yi Suave Yi Han Chinese people is slaves to our Mong hmong ancestors. We call Miao Nanman maab Dong Yi Bu Yi Suave Yi Han suave maab qaab or in English is Nanman maab suave slaves.
Because of certain reasons? Why so coy? They left Vietnam and Laos because of the American loss of the war in Vietnam and the Hmong had supported the Americans against the Vietnamese. The Vietnamese persecuted the Hmong. Therefore the Hmong people were in danger from the Vietnamese, so the Americans arranged to get them out of Vietnam and Laos to safety in America. Are you not allowed to tell the truth about this?
I agree with everything you said 💯.
@@hanzhovaj4129 Thank you. The Hmong were against the Vietnamese as a whole group - both north and south! Beware of the history as told by the ruling powers, it is always biased in their favour. That's why people need to tell their own histories. Your history is you. Don't let anyone take it, steal it, use and abuse it. By doing that they are using and abusing you and your people.
Was it the Vietnamese or Laotians? I never hear stories of the Viets gen o siding us. Are you telling the truth or are you not educated?
you are wrong about the Vietnamese persecuted the Hmong after the war. What has recently come to life is those crimes was done by Hmong communist who are now living in Phosovan, Xieng Khouang pretending to be left over GVP soldiers. Hmong Americans have married a lot of these communist's daughter and brough them to the USA and they continue to leech off us after wiping out our relatives.
the most famous one of these is that lady/husband telling hmong story and recently as of last year Lee Leng from Sacramento story shed some light into one of few butcher/rapist of hmong women, child and executing their husband (this was documented by French journalist; at the time they though it was the Vietnamese but it was Hmong Commies SOB living in Phosovan, Nong Het)
You can see the multiple videos it's "hunted like animals" a lot of these kids/women who are now in the USA can testify to it.
Let's not be quick to point fingers
@@shinbi6009 The opportunities to be wrong are endless but I know these things happened. I'm 67 years old and a trained historian and the war in Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos had a great impact on me, and I've studied this period ever since. If you think the whole nation and all the peoples of Vietnam are united and in agreement and are all treated alike you're misled. The Chinese look down on the 56 minorities in their country. The Vietnamese do exactly the same in Vietnam with their 54 minorities. I never said Vietnam tried to genocide the Hmong and other ethnic minorities. Do a little study yourself. Learning is fun.
Paj tawg lag is not china its yunnan province. Also are you hmong or chinese?
台灣行人地獄：地狹人稠 政府做秀 品德教育 差勁糟糕；廣東梅州市 梅江區市政府 沒紅綠燈 車輛禮讓 沒有警察 梅州梅江 人口40多萬...th-cam.com/users/shortsuuMAv7jsTI4