ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ย. 2011
- Ground Zero responders relive their haunting experiences on the tenth anniversary of the 9/11 attacks for a "60 Minutes" segment about their road to recovery and the doctor who is preserving their oral histories. Scott Pelley reports.
"He places the bones on the table and says: 'this is my son.'" WOW. that hit me really hard.
Ik, I started crying, I never expected that! Broke my heart!
Got tears in my eyes, OMG I can't even imagine 😢
The pain on her face trying to talk about it, heartbreaking.
Nobody should lose there children but to do that I dont think you can get over that
But how did he know those bones were his son's?
gaspandsaywhat I think he found them in what was left inside his uniform
'The real heros are dead...' That gave me chills.
except that wasnt true. william rodriquez was the one of the only ones who actually saved lives that day and it wasnt even his job to do so.
Ross Cardenas F**k off with anecdotes, it’s true for more than the most part. 412 first responders died that day, look up Orio Palmer for a 100% god sent hero on that day. Don’t you dare discredit the hundreds of first responders that remained in those buildings just to prove some anecdote.
@@Poseidon650 Disrespectful. I'm not sensetive but thats just disrespectful poseidon.
Miodrag Jr My statement or Ross’s?
@@Poseidon650 I re read it but I think I misunderstood, it's fine.
The fact that they struggle to pay their medical bills is heartbreaking. We are one of the richest countries in the world and can't help fund our own people? What an international embarrassment!
I was a firefighter and was there on 9/11
The things we seen there aren't meant for human beings to experience without facing some psychological problems. Yes the real hero's are dead I certainly agree ,the rest of us have to carry on and teach the generations ahead of this tragedy and keep the memories of the victims alive.
Thank you for your service, my friend. I salute you. May God bless you.
✌🇺🇲
God bless you!
♥️♥️♥️
Thanks Sal. #neverforget
This country would be perfect if we all cared for eachother the same way we did during 911
We did NOT care for each other. White people cared for each other. Muslims and middle eastern people faced racism and harrassment. My mothers best friend had her hijab ripped off her head and was spit on.
Lillith Rivera I’m sorry to hear that, as a fellow Muslim I hope everything is better for u and her. I was only a baby when that happened so I never really grew up with harassment, everyone always joked with me bout it
@@nikkirivera5307 don't blame a nation for one or two foolish peoples actions.
@@BigAlWillis but what happened after 9/11 how do you justify the killing the US did in the middle east
@@nikkirivera5307 I'm so sorry for your mother being put through that
watching this video 19 years after the incident in 2001. It still impacts me.
Same
Sweetie your not alone 💜
We will never forget 🙏🏼 sending love, light and blessings. From UK🇬🇧
A good friend of mine was a firefighter from Ohio. He has lung cancer, PTSD, and more. No help with medical treatment, WHY? He gave up his life to keep us safe & we can't help him?
FireFighters:
m.th-cam.com/video/j9GHBwdC1Bc/w-d-xo.html
You was in the buildings and he rescued you? You are so lucky Kathy, why don't you pay his medical bills as a thank you for what he did?
Because conservatives think people should "pUlL tHeMsElVeS uP bY tHe BoOtStRaPs"
@@jcholroyd5598 can you read
It’s an absolute disgrace that that bill is only guaranteed for 5 more years….
"It isn't the 10th anniversary of something that happened, it's the tenth year of something that never ends."
*FaiLed at Math, didn't You?*
@@Justin.Martyr failed philosophy?
@@allencollins6031*
@@allencollins6031 *How OLd were YOU, when ALLen, did your FirstKID???*
No sir! To the last gentleman who spoke....you are ALL heroes!!! Every single one of you. God Bless
He admitted he ran from his moment of cowardice. That's incredibly brave to admit. But anybody who thinks deeply enough knows it. Those who ran towards their fear of death in order to save as many as they could are truly heroic. Some just didn't know the building was gonna collapse
I cant believe the US Does not pay all medical bolls for The heroes and their families. So many are ill bc of their help snd many already passes away after fighting cancer.
The people deserve all the help they need for free!
RIP all brave men and women who gave their lives...
VeeK exactly
It sounds great and all but in today’s times it would pretty much be impossible. Either patients scamming the system or doctors scamming the government.
They federally passed a bill this year to fund the medical bills for the next $6.2 billion.
It took them 18 years to do that what a pity
The thing is, that money would come from all.other Americans being taxed . As much as these people are heroes, I'm not sure it's fair to have unaffiliated people from all over the country have to pay for it
I want to add: there are many other heroes that remained inside the building/ climbed back upstairs to help others.
m.th-cam.com/video/j9GHBwdC1Bc/w-d-xo.html
Amen
I know this is late, and you may never see this, but a boy I know of knowingly ran up the steps that day. He was a firefighter and his colleagues said they tried to stop him because they all knew the steps werent stable anymore. He got all of the people down the steps on one floor and out of the towers safely. He collapsed with the stairs that day and didnt make it out. He was a good man
Whatching today 9/11/19 so sad still after these many years...😥
Yes....
Breaks my heart every time I watch this. 9-15- 2019.
like when Kennedy was killed. the people who lived it will never forget it.
Almost a year after your comment but still so true. May this event never be forgotten.
Tomorrow is 9/11/20 and I'm watching this for the 1st time although every year since I always watch documentaries about the day and try and learn as much information about the brave men and women who sacrificed their lives. We will never forget!
Here in 2019, I will never forget.
I was in the 10th grade and seen it on TV I was horrified RIP TO ALL THE VICTIMS 🙏
I was in the 7th and can remember it like it was yesterday. Gone but never forgotten!
AMEN to that
“My issue is that the responders became their disease, they became a liablity” wtf did I just hear?! I was in sixth grade when this happened. I enlisted in the military when I came of age like many others. The fact that the people who met THAT BATTLE, THAT DAY aren’t being taken care of by the government is completely ridiculous. You’re all heroes. Idc who has to say what. Red, white and blue, we’re behind you.
You misheard him. He was talking about other people seeing survivors only through their disease and liability and how they shouldn’t be looked at through that lense, and instead as individual human beings.
agreed. relying on government to do the right thing is like expecting the sun to never shine again.
www.stloiyf.com/blog
@@jacobe4836 No he didn't mishear.
it actually was misunderstood by you guys. what Dr Luft was describing what most other physicians would typically redice them to. he was also describing his stance of seeing them as actual human beings in need of help and wanting to get to know them as human beings. therefore, he started the clinic as well as his project of recording the things they had to say about the tragedy and working at Ground Zero.
Reading/listening comprehension in this country has plummeted. Just take some of these comments for instance. Jesus h Christ.
"This is my son...." Oh my heart! 💔 My prayers and love. Those prayers and love goes out to everyone else who were there also.
Time stamp pls
All these black and white photos make it look like this happened in the 1960’s or something. 17 years ago...time has flown. RIP
Shred Guitar76 a black and white photo is still a record of the moment. Just as a color photo does. Get over it. Thanks and prayers for these brave people.
ruthieo54 wow, you totally took my post the wrong way. Get over what? I was just saying it’s hard to believe it’s been 17 years. Get over yourself and have a nice day
Remember everything was black and white at ground zero that day... smoke & ash. Manhattan was covered with a cloud....
No , you are ALL heroes. The ones who went into the buildings and didn’t make it out and all of you as well, the ones who responded that day and came back day after day after day despite the horror. I honor each and every one of you
Forgive me for just watching this. I had heard about the people that went to ground zero and having health issues all these years later. It is not right they are in debt or can hardly survive b/c of medical bills. Come on people these guys went into a 'war zone' to help others on the worst day of our lives! They could of went home to be with their families but they didn't. They risked their lives to help others & are still risking their lives b/c of the toxic air they inhaled! There's truly something wrong when our first responders retired or not can't get the healthcare they require after saving or recovering people. I for one would be eternally grateful to them for recovering my loved one!
Thank you for sharing your stories & my condolences to everyone that lost a loved one that horrible day!!
April Chamberlain ....just look how the US treats war veterans!!!
And now, almost 18 years later, they still suffer and so many have forgotten. 😢
@AmyBEgirl Not all have forgotten. I remember the day exactly. However I am guilty of not remembering the 2nd set of heroes all of our first responders who are still living.
Let us never forget! God bless you all and your families. 💕
I'm so sorry for them. Pray for them. I don't know how ANYONE could survive that and keep their sanity having seen all that.
We. Have to remember. We have another Republican warmonger and thinks nothing of sending more down to avoid taking care of vets and first responders
But these people are on the takers list. But the rich don't owe them a fking3 thing
I wonder that everyday. 😳
I remember when this happened thinking that there is no way anyone should be breathing the air in lower Manhattan. All those fluorescent lights, computers, insulation, etc turned into dust along with 100s of floors of concrete. If you just drop 1 fluorescent bulb in your house you're supposed to wear a mask, open the windows, vacuum, use adhesive tale to try to remove all the microscopic residue. Multiply that by thousands. I would still be wary of any environment that might have residual dust or digging under the surface soil in that area. The EPA knew this better than me and should be culpable for leading people to their eventual deaths. How can we ever trust these institutions?
Dat Meme the asbestos..
....and the bodies. survivors all covered in what you decribed and the bodies of human remains. it was horrifying. unimaginable. I lived in the west village and i had that dust on my windows, on our streets, on us walking the streets. however the wind blew it brought 9/11 to our front door
PTSD is something you learn to live with. I don’t know how long it takes to learn, because I’m only 8 years into my diagnosis. A smell, a person, a memory or a dream can make you panic and dissociate. Sometimes you don’t even know why, but your scared, you can’t breathe and all you can do is either freeze or get to a safe place so that you can collapse. It helps tremendously to talk about your trauma. The only problem is that few people care to hear it over and over and over and over. If you know someone like this, listen and just tell them you’re going to be there for them. 😕
I hope you are OK!
Pls search help in therapeutic trauma work. There is a lot nowadays. Working with the body it can help you release storaged stress.. that stress response from 9/11
It's now 18 years on. We watched that day from UK in absolute horror. I was a carer in an elderly people's home and the residents thought they were watching a film.. I was so scared, I thought another war had started and we might be next. I cried, like many others here and have never forgotten what happened. The bravery and sacrifice of those first responders was beyond any call of duty. God bless them all.
As an American, one of the enduring memories I have is a group of British military members playing our national anthem in front of Buckingham Palace a few days after that horrific day. It was a brief bright spot in an otherwise horrible time.
Good lord. You have to wonder how many of these people interviewed are still alive
God Bless them all. They relive this horror everday. May they have peace.
I’ve never seen the actual picture of people jumping out the buildings... i was 2 years old but i still come back every year in tears listening to the stories
There are some videos you can see when there is paper furniture flying in the air and than bodies jumping out specially out of the second tower. I was in middle school when. This happened. I had nightmares for days. Till this day. Breaks my heart and really breaks me emotionally. That day my teacher screamed in pain cuz her son was on the flight that hit the first tower.
Every year that the date 911 arrives I remember what I was wearing, where I was standing exactly, the scent in the air, and the horrible kick in the stomach, my knees felt weak, when I saw the news on TV knowing people I knew worked in those towers and the floor they were in only they and God know exactly what moment he called them to return home, I remember and pray for them, that they guide and make themselves present for their children. Some of the hardest days of my life.
@zakyah jones I was 35 years old when the Towers got hit, I remember everything about that day. I remembered finally figuring out that day that those were people jumping from the towers. I just found a well done TH-cam video if you search - the falling man- you will find it- it has 8 parts. God bless all, those who’s lives were take, the first responders and the people and families may they find peace!🙏🏼💕
I was 2 as well, and I do the same thing. I come back each year in September to listen to their stories. I keep them in my mind for not only the month of September, but everyday.
I saw the people jumping on TV, while it happened. It was horror
Thank you to EVERY single one of the people that did all they could! First responders, doctors, nurses, civilians, those that saved the plane from crashing into pentagon. Every single person. You’re all our heros! Our country NEEDS to do more for these people, these heros!
That Day Is Tomorrow. Can't Believe It's Been 17 Years Since That Tuesday In 2001
I wasn’t there. I was at home. My son was at school, my husband at work and I was going to work at 1:00pm. I was laying on our bed watching Fox News. I saw the first reports then as it was covered live I saw the 2nd plane coming. I saw it hit the building, saw people screaming, running, crying. I barely left the TV for weeks. Just to go to work, take care of my family and that’s about it. That was almost 18 yrs ago. I’ve seen all of the documentaries. Every year around 9/11 I watch all of the documentaries again. I know the names of some of the people who were there or on the planes. I know their families names. During that horrific time we said we’d never forget. I hate to say this, but people did forget. After the cleanup, after it had all died down people forgot. I never forgot. Neither did my husband, my sister...how could you forget that?
God bless you all. You ARE heroes. Don’t ever forget that. Yes, the ones that lost their lives that day were heroes, too, but that doesn’t take anything away from you. God bless you, all that perished that fateful day, and their families. Today is May 24, 2019...and still I remember. 💔
Doe's this make you a islamophobe?
Betty- yeah 2001 was a big year for me . N.B. also new yorks 100th mayor was my grandfathers cousin. My sister tok photos off the towers and we watched them on slide at tikokino in new zealand.''
Same here.... 20 years later now and it still gets me
@@alankuntz6494 what 💀
@@katgreene3156 I don't know what I don't know what you're referring to put it put it into context here. I'm not sure what you're replying to, I can't see it.
It pained me when they discussed their medical issues. Considering what they went through, there should be more support for these people and their loved ones. I can't believe that they've had to not only shoulder their traumas all these years later, but also shoulder their medical bills as well. There needs to be a lifelong lifeline for these people set up so they have their medical concerns addressed without fear of bankruptcy from medical bills.
Is a day I will NEVER FORGET. Even 20 years later the image of that plane hitting is stuck in my head. So so sad. INCREDIBLE bravery of the first responders, 400+ perished. Shame. RIP TO ALL
Just crazy how all that smoke and toxic dust can do all those 1st responders are true heros much respect to them 🇺🇸
Well done guys for not just giving on 9/11 but everyday the ill effects take the rest of your life. For me the authories should be paying for their medical treatments
John's work and dedication to these men and women to be taken care of and those lost.. He's a Saint.
FireFighters:
m.th-cam.com/video/j9GHBwdC1Bc/w-d-xo.html
For the first 35 years of my life I didn’t really think about first responders much. Through some challenges I faced in my own life, I ended up starting a Telehealth therapy practice with a couple of partners. That led me to start working with more and more first responders dealing with job-related issues. I’ve even been privileged enough to get help to a handful of people that were there on that fateful day and for the traumatic days/weeks that followed. It’s been the most rewarding experience of my life. This population is so grossly misunderstood and criminally underserved. It’s quite humbling to have your worldview changed at this point in my life, but I’m grateful to these unbelievable people. I plan on spending the rest of my life trying to do what I can to give back to such strong, inspirational people. I hope we, as a society, do better by these people-they deserve it.
None of these people who should have to pay one red cent for their healthcare.
I worked in EMS both with the fire dept and ambulance service for 20 years as a volunteer. I can fully understand and appreciate those who wanted to go help because I myself wanted to go. I did not know how much I could help but I wanted to do something. When you are in a field such as EMS you become a family. Regardless if you are paid or volunteer we are all brothers and sisters. Thank you to all the EMS that helped in this situation. RIP all the innocent lives that were lost.
God bless them all and the Doctor who is helping them.
Man, this was very hard to watch. Here, even 20 years later, I still get so emotional when I watch anything about the brave men and women, those alive and those that have passed, who sacrificed so very much!
I pray for their mental health
I wish I could give them all a big hug
God Bless ALL alive and deceased. Thank you to All First Responders and all others. Please give them and the ones left behind strength to carry on. Amen
I just can't believe it's been nearly *two* decades since 9/11
After Seventeen Years Never Forget the remarkable humans who stepped-up on 09/11/2001. Amen
Would love to watch this documentary. R.I.P to all those who lost their lives on 9/11/01
th-cam.com/video/8ZU_XFpNgho/w-d-xo.html
I worked for the World Trade Center Health Program for 9/11. The stories are so raw. I enjoyed helping them and trying to help as much as I could. I will never be the same. 🇺🇸🇺🇸🙏🙏❤❤
Thankyou linda ❤️🙏🏻
I wish I could heal all these people both physically and mentally.
Watching this during the Covid Pandemic. I will NEVER FORGET! I remember where I was at the time, holding my newborn and watching the terror unfold on TV. I saw the 2nd tower hit and I screamed. I frantically called my husband's cell with no answer. He was a OTR truck driver & I just needed to know he was OK. Thankfully he was and came home several hours later. My heart with always ache for those whose loved ones didn't come home. #NeverForget #NineElevenHeroes #GodBlessUSA
Got me crying I’m so sad they went through that and those innocent people gosh my heart goes out to nyc for ever and ever
This needs to be seen and I find it odd these people carry such a burden. I feel they should be honored and cherished
I remember rushing to our nearby blood center and waited in line for hours, to give blood, only to find out no one had survived 😟
Very sad
Everyone there should get free health care for life! ❤ thank you to every one of the first responders here that day! 🙏 prayers to them and their family's !
Bless all of you, life is short but heroes are a rare commodity and you all are truly heroes
Never, ever, forget.
Never forget how horrible that day was.
Never forget who caused it.
And most importantly never forget the heroes who died that day.
I've been to ground zero memorial. Paid my respects. For any of you that have never been, or that ever question the spirit of NYC and its people from afar, go and visit. It will humble you.
you are heroes man...as much as the ones who never made it out..
I understand your reasoning for saying that, but you and I both know that those people are also heros. Just because you didn’t die does not mean you are not a hero. You are too humble.
These people (and countless others) are hero’s and deserve the best medical care for the rest of their lives.
i was there for the same thing in the north tower. I hope that we will never forget this day but not get so attached to the day and my cousin worked in the south tower and died so when it comes to that time i have a roller coaster of emotions rushing through my body.
All these heroes have my deepest respect for what they did that day, and for putting others' lives first than theirs. Those are real heroes with no capes.
I was there 😓
Thank you for all those people who helped out. God bless you all
What an amazing project by Dr. Luft! I wish I discovered this sooner. My heart goes out to all of the victims and the responders
I don’t remember seeing this when it first aired. That is one of the saddest things I’ve seen in a long time. I found myself sobbing a couple of times while watching that. We all carry some sort of baggage with as we move through life... these people have a very heavy load.
These responders were the living spirit of all that is courageous, determined, faithful, compassionate, responsible, yes Godly. God bless them all , today and always.
So many heroes that day. Always help each other, not just when tragedies happen. Bless all these people. 💙❤️
15:50 YES YOU ARE HEROES !!
God bless these people, they lived and breathed the tragedy of 9/11, whether they wanted to or not. That’s a hard thing to live with.
Watching today. As I have watched before. God Bless all of you who lived through this. Including, my hero, my friend, Officer F. Stone, who was a NYPD officer, helped find survivors, diagnosed with cancer and survived. God Bless all of the responders who share their stories. WE must never forget.
Such brave service people, just thankyou so very much!!!
So sad what they had to go thru then and still go thru now. God bless them. They ARE heros. The heros who survived.
My heart truly goes out to these very brave men and wemen. And, to all the victims of Ground Zero, and their Friends and Families.
It’s funny how some people don’t believe it really happened
I know it happened but I think our gov did it personally
That is because some ppl believe in conspiracy theories. Pay them no mind.
@@graciekate6047 Well it happened alright. But not the way it was presented by the media. th-cam.com/video/K1KHiZ3gGZ4/w-d-xo.html (and by the way, this has nothing to do with conspiracy theories)
InstallatieModel it has a lot to do with theories
Whether hijakers did it or our government did
People died and thats all that matters
So cut the crap
Idc what articles you read
God bless them
Thank you for recording these stories. There are others of us who were changed by that day much differently than others. I was in labor with my first baby and at 11:37 that night I held my son Micah in my arms and cried in confusion that I had been given this amazing beautiful miracle while other mothers would never see their miracles again. I was confused and yet so in love. He turns 19 this year. How has almost 2 decades pass?
Wow what a point of view
It’s 9/2019, I remember that day and where I was. In all these years I’ve never heard it put in this way: the heroes are the ones who didn’t make it... I will never forget.
I heard many stories of people who still are suffering after 9/11. It never really hit me hard till I got cancer in my lungs, and now know how it feels for many of these wonderful Americans. Early today I mentioned in my FB comment, how we need to pray for, and thank, the people, and their families who are still being effected from 9/11, both physically, and emotionally. Not many others mentioned them. After watching this, I am posting this, in explanation for my comments today. I pray others see how important it is to acknowledge these wonderful Americans. You are always in our hearts!
Listening to the stories of those first responders is something that I can’t even imagine. So sad.
You’re a hero, too, sir. It takes special people to risk their own lives to save people you don’t even know.💝
This still breaks my heart. I live in OKC & I remember the day before which is my b-day, it rained real hard later that evening. So hard that after it had an light orange-ish covered skies. I was in spanish class in middle school when it happened & we stopped to watch it. From class period to the next that's all we did.
Israel lo hizo hace 20 años!
Remember the USS Liberty!
I truly hope these people are still alive. So brave.
9/11 is often viewed as a day where America was _"weakened at its core."_
Well... read about those we lost and listen to these stories. *_We were not weakened as a country, we were galvanized as one people._*
You all are heroes.
i would like to hear those full interviews of those responders
I hope that all these wonderful, brave, hard working people are at peace finally.
Injuries. PTSD etc etc etc.
You're ALL heroes. God Bless you all ❣️🇮🇪🇺🇸
Absolutely so powerful! America Strong!
My heart ❤️ goes out to all that have been effected
3 more days before the 20th Anniversary. But it's 2 days from where I am. I will never forget. Rip to those who lost their lives.
God Bless them all
I feel for these people so much! was born and raised in Lower Manhattan and I skated by the pier after 9/11. And my breathing has never been the same.
I felt so helpless that day. After the second tower fell we closed shop to go and donate blood. I went to three hospitals (by foot since the subways weren't running any longer) but at that point they had all run out of forms and could not take anymore volunteers. In the evening we went to the Westside Highway to cheer on and applaud the first responders driving down in busses at the end of their shift. Some of them waved at us and blew kisses, others slumped down in their seats and started crying at the sight of us. the next day we donated socks and T-shirts and i called business partners like Phillip Morris to ask for donations like cigarettes etc. We went to the Westside Highway for the next month every evening cheering on the first responders, it was all we could do. Volunteering was next to impossible cause so many people wanted to help, there was just no spot to get (like handing out coffee or cleaning the first responders quarters), you had to know someone to get something. I went to the site for the next 5 years on 9/11 and every year less people came. Hard to believe it's been 21 years, it feels like yesterday. Bless these men and women!
It should be free health care for those who survived and first responders who was in all that smoke
God Bless all who where there. You are all heroes. This is a day and event that will live on forever. Thank you is NOT enough. No words can decibe our appreciation for what you all have done.
God Bless each and every one of you.
Your all amazing ppl
Im a new yorker till ihe end
This story will never be completely finished.
God bless my fellow Americans, RIP ...
Still makes me cry to this day.
Visiting the 9/11 memorial odds without a doubt the most emotional and moving experience I’ve ever experienced.
Your all absolutely amazing!!! These people are heroes, they should have free health care for the rest of there lifes!!! Like if you agree.
I am 44 years old now, but this I still remember if it was yesterday.
Oh my heart, and soul still remember my birth home😭
The story of the the port authority cops is very moving