What is the difference between Hindi and Urdu? I haven't gotten a satisfactory explanation yet. Watched many people speak on this - recently heard a talk by Nityananda Mishra where he argued they are certainly different yet couldn't really give the details on how they are different. Both Hindi and Urdu lack the schwa of the Devanagari and other Brahmi-based alphabet because of the strong influence of Persian on North India. Even when they write Hindi in Devanagari, they pronounce it like Persian (without the trailing schwa after consonants). That's why Rama becomes Ram, Alaka becomes Alka, Karna -> Karn, Yoga -> Yog, Mamata -> Mamta, Angsha -> Ansh etc. etc. I see them as one and the same language - Hindustani language - with the difference being politically and ideologically manufactured. Punjabi too got influenced by the Persian alphabet and lost their schwa and juktakkhors (assuming they had one before). Among Indo-Aryan languages Odia is probably the only major language that has almost completely retained its schwa, ie it has had minimal Persian influence.
URdu is hindi grammar with arabic religious words and persian verbs. its a language to divide hindus and converted momins, urdu was used as a political tool and weaponized against the native hindus hindi is sanskrit based
@@AA13494 Regular spoken Hindi too has tons of Persian, Arabic, and Turkish words. Most North Indian languages do. The word Hindi itself is Persian. Where does Hindi end and Urdu begins? I have seen Pakistanis speak the exact language as the people of Delhi. Bengali spoken by Hindus too has 10-20% words of Persian/Arabic origin.
@@aritrabhattacharyya8797sasnkritized hindi dosent have any Persian words ..but today's hindi which people speak has urdu words though not as much in pakistan but still they exist ...its because of our education system
@@MysSo-r8f yes, but what about other Persian, Arabic and foreign words that we Hindu Bengalis use - ayin, adalot, ukil, morji, mushkil, kom-beshi, khawa-dawa, haowa, abohawa, jomi, jomidar, baba, etc etc. we don't even realise how many foreign words we use on a daily basis. We just highlight the few extra ones that Bangladeshis use. Same is the case with Hindi-Urdu. How many Hindi speakers say Hriday instead of Dil and Vyatha instead of dard?
Unfortunetly hindi language didnt get define what words are hindi and foregin like urdu did by removing all sanskrit rooted words and only use "hindi grammer". And bollywood made it worse. The only reason foregin words exist cause we didnt define the boundaries and purify it. This led to the myth or urdu and hindi as same language. As simple as that.
Specially focus on the last sentence to understand the boundaries of Hindi. Article 351 of the Indian constitution states: It shall be the duty of the Union to promote the spread of the Hindi language, to develop it so that it may serve as a medium of expression for all the elements of the composite culture of India and to secure its enrichment by assimilating without interfering with its genius, the forms, style and expressions used in Hindustani and in the other languages of India specified in the Eighth Schedule, and by drawing, wherever necessary or desirable, for its vocabulary, primarily on Sanskrit and secondarily on other languages.
@@abhayagarwal2589 we do have technical and daily used words in sanskrit but unfortunately they are not implemented and as I said no boundaries are drawn to distinguish what is hindi and what is not. And currently it's also happening to other Indian languages.
@@gouthamvarun5258Because unlike English, French, German, Hebrew, Japanese, etc. our Indian languages are hardly used for formal businesses and documentation. Therefore, there is no need for standard of our languages to be maintained because our languages have been reduced to street languages.
![ILLSLICK - KILLSHOT REMIX [FULL VERSION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RIK8RrqIAzE/mqdefault.jpg)
What is the difference between Hindi and Urdu? I haven't gotten a satisfactory explanation yet. Watched many people speak on this - recently heard a talk by Nityananda Mishra where he argued they are certainly different yet couldn't really give the details on how they are different. Both Hindi and Urdu lack the schwa of the Devanagari and other Brahmi-based alphabet because of the strong influence of Persian on North India. Even when they write Hindi in Devanagari, they pronounce it like Persian (without the trailing schwa after consonants). That's why Rama becomes Ram, Alaka becomes Alka, Karna -> Karn, Yoga -> Yog, Mamata -> Mamta, Angsha -> Ansh etc. etc. I see them as one and the same language - Hindustani language - with the difference being politically and ideologically manufactured.
Punjabi too got influenced by the Persian alphabet and lost their schwa and juktakkhors (assuming they had one before). Among Indo-Aryan languages Odia is probably the only major language that has almost completely retained its schwa, ie it has had minimal Persian influence.
URdu is hindi grammar with arabic religious words and persian verbs. its a language to divide hindus and converted momins, urdu was used as a political tool and weaponized against the native hindus
hindi is sanskrit based
@@AA13494 Regular spoken Hindi too has tons of Persian, Arabic, and Turkish words. Most North Indian languages do. The word Hindi itself is Persian. Where does Hindi end and Urdu begins? I have seen Pakistanis speak the exact language as the people of Delhi. Bengali spoken by Hindus too has 10-20% words of Persian/Arabic origin.
Khala, fufu, fazr etc forced arabisation of Bengali is pretty much there.
@@aritrabhattacharyya8797sasnkritized hindi dosent have any Persian words ..but today's hindi which people speak has urdu words though not as much in pakistan but still they exist ...its because of our education system
@@MysSo-r8f yes, but what about other Persian, Arabic and foreign words that we Hindu Bengalis use - ayin, adalot, ukil, morji, mushkil, kom-beshi, khawa-dawa, haowa, abohawa, jomi, jomidar, baba, etc etc. we don't even realise how many foreign words we use on a daily basis. We just highlight the few extra ones that Bangladeshis use. Same is the case with Hindi-Urdu. How many Hindi speakers say Hriday instead of Dil and Vyatha instead of dard?
Abhinandan
I'm from nalhati can you make a video on exposeing Mamata Banerjee
No
🔥
🙏🏿
❤
🙏🏿
Unfortunetly hindi language didnt get define what words are hindi and foregin like urdu did by removing all sanskrit rooted words and only use "hindi grammer". And bollywood made it worse. The only reason foregin words exist cause we didnt define the boundaries and purify it. This led to the myth or urdu and hindi as same language. As simple as that.
Specially focus on the last sentence to understand the boundaries of Hindi.
Article 351 of the Indian constitution states:
It shall be the duty of the Union to promote the spread of the Hindi language, to develop it so that it may serve as a medium of expression for all the elements of the composite culture of India and to secure its enrichment by assimilating without interfering with its genius, the forms, style and expressions used in Hindustani and in the other languages of India specified in the Eighth Schedule, and by drawing, wherever necessary or desirable, for its vocabulary, primarily on Sanskrit and secondarily on other languages.
@@abhayagarwal2589 we do have technical and daily used words in sanskrit but unfortunately they are not implemented and as I said no boundaries are drawn to distinguish what is hindi and what is not. And currently it's also happening to other Indian languages.
@@gouthamvarun5258Because unlike English, French, German, Hebrew, Japanese, etc. our Indian languages are hardly used for formal businesses and documentation. Therefore, there is no need for standard of our languages to be maintained because our languages have been reduced to street languages.
@@abhayagarwal2589 yes. We must also defund the funding for Indian languages and only promote english. Only then we can become "vishvakuuli"
@@gouthamvarun5258Yes. Absolutely!!
Hinduism is nothing but Brahmanisim 🤔🤔🤔
Batman is nothing but Batmobile
average neobuddhist.
and even if it is, we are ok with it. u can call it whatever. brahmanism, hinduism. semantics dnt matter.
You are nothing more than neighbour’s sperm
One Part is Brahmanism. Those who follow vedanta are worshiper of brahman, the ultimate truth. "satyam gyanam anandam brahman" .