I mean ok but am I the only one who is shocked to see D4 on that list? Man can you imagine Diablo 4 on par with Baldur Gates 3? How is this even in the list first it's a super shitty game and second it's NOT an RPG comparable to a Fallout or even a Mass Even or Starfield but hack and slash game action RPG, has nothing to do with story oriented RPGs, so yea instant unsub shit channel trying really hard to sell their masters product to the most credulous people.
Well, I will admit Starfield is not the number one RPG of the year by far that definitely goes to baulders gate 3 it is still really really good game. It’s problem is that it has a lot of mechanics that it doesn’t explain and you gotta get used to and figure that stuff out for yourself which isn’t fun but once you get all the mechanics down and the base building and all the missions and all that stuff it is actually a very solid RPG, that is getting a lot of hate when it shouldn’t
@@jtzoom86I think most are discovering that it is a dated system we’ve seen many times before and in some regards such as loading screens and bland procedurally generation, a significant step back. It’s now down to mostly poor reviews on Steam as most people realise it couldn’t match the expectations and hype that Bethesda promised. It’s a strong 7 in my book and it’s weird saying that IGN got it right. It’s not a poor game, but it’s not great and doesn’t show anything improved or new. Seeing it at number 1 on this list certainly goes against the majority views and other awards and rankings currently of the game.
Giving Starfield the number one spot on anything other than a loading screen simulator is unacceptable especially when you have it beat a game like Baldurs Gate 3.
The dude is definitely mis-genre(ing) games as RPG, for certain... Hack-n-Slash or Click to Hit / Shoot aren't really RPGs, they are ACTION GAMES, whether fantasy or not. Now, Neverwinter Nights (1, 2, or Enhanced Edition) or Baldur's Gate are a real RPG Game. Even Final Fantasy Tactics is more RPG than these games, sadly.. lol Hell, evenThe Fallout series is more RPG than many of these games!
@nwngenisys8969 I think these days, any game that has even a bit of customization to its characters skills or weapons is considered RPG by these guys. In that case, a game like Doom Eternal is not a fps game but a RPG as well since it has weapon Mods and allows "Stat allocation" between HP, Armor etc.....
This is just a matter of opinion like I said myself I personally enjoyed the game once I learned all the mechanics and dealt with the weight issues and the flying around and all the spacecraft stuff. It’s actually a pretty damn good in death RPG now I wouldn’t give it the number one spot that would definitely go to Baldor gate three, but it would be in my top three.
@@oblikuathe trade off is lack of respect and trust. IGN have improved but they have dealt with a bad reputation for years due to perceived poor and questionable reviews from the majority of viewers.
This is the second reason i'm unsubscribing after this video, who makes a list without time stamps. You don't have to put the game name, but you at least need to mark each rank.
The fact that Wild Hearts and Starfield are on this list at all while there is no mention of Sea of Stars, Octopath Traveler 2, or even World of Horror, is pretty much all you need to know about this list.
Thank god you said this. As someone who hasn't played games for 10+ years I was wondering "what did they to my genre? How did we went from Diablo 2 and Dungeon Siege to this!?"
This is the 1st time I’ve seen anyone rank Starfield higher than Baldur’s Gate 3. I own both games. Haven’t started Starfield yet but I’m having a blast with BG3
Yeah I've p[layed all th etop3 an dwhils tm ynumbe r1 is Hogwarts fo rme I've had a blas twit hBG3 lately a swell and have ideas for several characters I want to play. Even t oth epoin twher I'm tempted t ouse 1 or 2 o fthe origin ones like Shadowheart. S ofo rm ethey'v ekind o fgo tthe top 3 back t ofront. So basicall yswap Starfiel dwit hHogwarts and you'l have my order
Wow, Starfield is definitely not better than end. Bald doors gate three it is definitely a good game now. They do a shitty job of explaining all the systems and all that but once you learn all the stuff like weight management, building ships forming alliances and all the weapon stuff it is actually a pretty good in death RPG I know people say stuff about the loading screens, but just because there’s loading screens doesn’t mean the game isn’t good, this is just a opinion piece and this is my opinion
@@jtzoom86 Yeah mos tgames have loading screens some games just have bette rway sof disguisin gthem for example in Mas Effec tAnfromeda wheneve ryo usee you rship landin gin tha tgam ethat's a loadin gscreen. Even Baldur's Gate 3 ha sloadin gscreens. Mostl yI thin kthe yoccu rwheneve ryo uventuer into a new aera on the map though.Lik eas yhte druid grove.
This is an opinion piece and they are clearly just giving their opinion. Now I’ve played Starfield for about 130 hours and I’ve also played baulders gate 3 for about half of that time and I will admit Baldor gate is a better game but that does not mean that Starfield isn’t a good game Starfield problem is that it’s got so many mechanics that just aren’t explained when you get used to all the stuff that you do in the game it is actually a very very solid RPG and people aren’t the kudos to the game that it deserves. It’s a good game, don’t hate it just because everybody else does if you’ve never played it, you should not be talking about how bad it is
@@jtzoom86Starfield may be a good game but it is very strange seeing this at the top of a list considering that Starfield is a Significant step back with loading screens and bland procedural maps. It’s certainly not what Bethesda promised and it did not meet the high expectations many had for it. It’s a strong 7. However, It now sits at mostly unfavourable reviews on Steam as many realise it is not an improvement of the Bethesda formula or anything new which is shame considering how long it’s been in development. When one of the top mods calls the game boring and announces they are no longer modding for it should indicate something has gone wrong. The game has not received any awards from the major organisations or even any other major publications. Personal opinion is fine but this ranking stands out as odd and an exception Looking at this channel saying Microsoft won the year is also certainly very strange considering Phil Spencer said at the end of the year they had lost this generation and the PS5 was dominating. Microsoft exclusives mostly failed. Sony may have had much fewer than normal, but they all hit and the old ones still exist. It’s a bizarre video that only an Xbox fanboy could believe…with difficulty. I think that context makes this ranking more understandable. I think this reviewer clearly prefers Xbox for some reason.
To overlook Sea of Stars and Octopath Traveler 2, or even Remnant 2 for Horizon, Dead Island 2, and especially Starfield is a criminal travesty. Gamingbolt had their AAA glasses on for this one.
I completely forgot about CS stars that is a fantastic game that brings up memories of CHRONO trigger from back in the day another excellent game. In fact, this is been a damn good year for RPG‘s in general small land big.
You do realize this is an opinion website, right? So if they don’t automatically agree with what you think they’re paid off by Microsoft that’s silly. I think Starfield is a very good game underneath all the stuff that all the mechanics that you gotta do in the game but that’s where the problem lies there’s a lot of mechanics in the game that are not explained very well, and you have to figure out on your own, but that’s just my opinion but saying that I think baulders gate 3 is the RPG of the year by far
1. Baulders gate 3 2.lies of p 3.sea of stars 4. Starfield Again, this is just my opinion on it. I’ve played all these games and I believe that baulders gate 3 is definitely the best RPG of the year. Now when it comes to Starfield, it’s getting a lot of hate from a lot of people and I suspect some of these people have a played it. The problem with Starfield is that it’s got a lot of mechanics and a lot of systems that aren’t explained very well, but when you get used to how all this stuff works and all the side missions, the shipbuilding And all the faction stuff it is actually a pretty damn solid RPG. the biggest issue with Starfield is that it was super built up and it didn’t quite live up to what it was supposed to be but that does not mean the game is not fun and enjoyable because it definitely is I have over 120 hours into the game
It’s painfully obvious Microsoft or Bethesda has a financial relationship with Gamingbolt 😂 the only people putting Starfield anywhere near the top of any lists
remnant2 is probably the best rpg and coop game i've played in recent years, up there with elden ring and sekiro. but starfield got no 1 is crazy. dude probably bethesda diehard fan. lol
if you see this comment don’t waste your time watching the video. Starfield is their best rpg of the year so the list is invalid and watching this is a waste of time.
Everyone has their own opinion hence why this is an opinion Piece. I wouldn’t put Starfield at number one but it’s definitely in the top five because no matter what a bunch of people say to hate on the game when you get into it and you learn it’s mechanics. It’s actually a very very good game. It’s a solid story shipbuilding and all other kinds of stuff. It’s really not that bad but I would say Baltimore gate three would be my number one pick that game is phenomenal. I put Starfield probably three or four maybe. Again, this is just a matter of opinion. Just because somebody doesn’t like it doesn’t mean it’s not good to somebody else.
Starfeld does not even deserve to be mentioned here. And you have it beating out the actual GOTY, Baldurs Gate 3? Ridiculous invalid list brings shame upon your ancestors 😔 how dare you
Don't want to be rude, but Starfield Does Not deserve number one, not even close. More like 5 or 6 in my opinion. Don't get me wrong, I like the game. But Bethesda doesn't care anymore and there is A LOT of changes needed.. with a lot I really mean a lot. 🤷🏼♂️
It’s interesting to me the number of titles on here that are games with RPG mechanics while they ignore one of the great pure RPGs of the year: Octopath 2 doesn’t even get an honorable mention, but Dead Island and the Horizon DLC are on here? (No shade on Dead Island 2 or Horizon’s DLC, I thought both were great.) That’s aside from putting Starfield as the #1 spot. I must live in an alternate dimension.
saying starfield was most memorable gaming experience of 2023 is insulting to games like BG3 and Lies of P . Good job gamingbolt xbox blind fan channel.. Not biased at all right??
I don’t think this site is is biased at all. It’s all a matter of opinion now it’s definitely not as good as baulders gate 3 by a longshot, but it is still a damn good game when you actually figure out all the mechanics and how everything works this shipbuilding, jumping from star systems all that kind of stuff base building it is actually a damn good game you just gotta give it a chance. They could’ve done a better job of explaining all the mechanics in the game and they did not do that but luckily they’re coming out with a huge patch that’s supposed to solve this and again, this is just a matter of opinion
I totally forgot about dead island. I really miss the borderlands×left4dead sort of gameplay. I remember getting super lucky in finding a ludicrously overpowered katana and never putting it down after realizing how incredibly fun it was to slaughter massive hordes single handedly.
I do love Starfield but I I’ll say idk if I’d go to these guys for rpg info. Their definition of rpg is loose based on this list and they don’t even include games like octopath 2 or my personal number two game of the year behind Zelda, sea of Stars
They tend to ignore most JRPGs. They probably included FFXVI because of how action-focused it is, had it been a bit more "traditional", they would have most likely ignored it as well.
I'm watching it and I feel like I'm back 10 years ago. Nothing has changed since I played LA Noire. The best game I've played so far. Games in 2024 are supposed to be a mix of Apple Vision, Pokemon GO, and GTA I was supposed to go to an actual bar nearby correctly guess a ridge and pick the right cocktail, then a "Ghost" detective was supposed to show up in my apple vision telling me about the case he was on in 1947 while he was taken down by Mickey Cohen and he wants me to go to Pasadena to follow the criminal trail he stumbled upon. *The game industry really stalled 😟since 2010's*
I’m not too crazy about how rpgs have evolved over the years. It’s unfortunately more about action and spamming your buttons, grinding out damage sponge bosses than it is about role playing
I agree 100% Starfield is the best rpg, Starfield has a lot of haters, but currently this the only game where you can travel to many different worlds and discover new things. And for the people that have a negative mindset and are comparing it to 2077 and other games are clueless. Cyberpunk phantom liberty is only based in one world, or should I say one city, so of course it’ll look better. The developers have put a lot of effort into one city, not many worlds. You can’t even get off the planet lol. And no man’s sky? It’s outdated and looks like a cartoon space game. As for other rpgs, again you can only play in a one world environment. So by that being said Starfield wins in my book.
Bros made a "top 12 rpgs of 2023" without Octopath Traveler 2 and Star Ocean 2nd Story. Literally unfollowed and disregarded any respect I ever had for this site.
Hack n Slash modules / games don't qualify for RPGs, they are too linear to be RPGs... This is even more true for click to hit style of games, they aren't truly RPGs, they are click to hit / shoot games... Combat is NOT the main feature of an RPG, not even, it's a secondary feature at best.
Bro Wild Hearts was ok'ish game but with all of its trouble, low content and cut support way too early does not deserve to be on this list. There is like countless of amazing indie RPG games that deserve more to be on this list instead but oh well GamingBolt is gonna be GamingBolt and they rather put triple A published game on the list of "best of X" than actually something that deserve to be on said list lol Case in point Wild Hearts and Starfield
I was already on the fence with this channel after years of meh. But ranking any game above balders gate three, especially starfield is just asinine. I gotta bounce. I can't trust you guys.
I think everyone on here doesn’t understand that this is an opinion piece for somebody and all they’re doing is shitting on Starfield now Starfield wasn’t a super awesome game like baulders gate 3 but it is definitely a death RPPG. THAT THE GAME DOES A TERRIBLE JOB OF EXPLAINING ALL THE SYSTEMS IN THE GAME BUT WHEN YOU FINALLY UNDERSTAND ALL THE MECHANICS IN THE GAME YOU GET INTO THE STORY, THE SHIPBUILDING, THE BASE BUILDING, AND ALL THAT KIND OF STUFF STAR IS ACTUALLY A PRETTY SOLID RPG
Something is wrong with this video and channel Starfield Should not by any means be number 1 or not even this list. Seems this channel is biased and corrupt.
Ah gaming bolt... Another day another s*** list. At least they are consistent with crap. Look i like starfield I'm having fun... I'm not a BG3 fan but in no way is starfield in any way better than BG3 in any way. Except load screens. Even CPPL was way better than starfield. But when it comes to crappy unthoughtout lists no one does it better than gamingbolt.
I’d pick Dead Island 2 any day. Dying Light 2 feels clunky, dull and slow, and the characters provoke almost no reaction in me most of the time. Dead Island actually wants you to have fun.
Starfield #1 is insulting to the first 11 on this list. Plain and simple. Well that’s my 2 cents. Peace ✌️
I mean ok but am I the only one who is shocked to see D4 on that list? Man can you imagine Diablo 4 on par with Baldur Gates 3? How is this even in the list first it's a super shitty game and second it's NOT an RPG comparable to a Fallout or even a Mass Even or Starfield but hack and slash game action RPG, has nothing to do with story oriented RPGs, so yea instant unsub shit channel trying really hard to sell their masters product to the most credulous people.
Well, I will admit Starfield is not the number one RPG of the year by far that definitely goes to baulders gate 3 it is still really really good game. It’s problem is that it has a lot of mechanics that it doesn’t explain and you gotta get used to and figure that stuff out for yourself which isn’t fun but once you get all the mechanics down and the base building and all the missions and all that stuff it is actually a very solid RPG, that is getting a lot of hate when it shouldn’t
I don’t even consider FF16 much of an RPG since they gutted out most of the popular systems from previous entries.
@@jtzoom86I think most are discovering that it is a dated system we’ve seen many times before and in some regards such as loading screens and bland procedurally generation, a significant step back.
It’s now down to mostly poor reviews on Steam as most people realise it couldn’t match the expectations and hype that Bethesda promised. It’s a strong 7 in my book and it’s weird saying that IGN got it right. It’s not a poor game, but it’s not great and doesn’t show anything improved or new.
Seeing it at number 1 on this list certainly goes against the majority views and other awards and rankings currently of the game.
Give me 7 PIECE of Money now GIF ME IT NOW MAN!!! EDIT: COME ON MAN!!
Giving Starfield the number one spot on anything other than a loading screen simulator is unacceptable especially when you have it beat a game like Baldurs Gate 3.
The dude is definitely mis-genre(ing) games as RPG, for certain...
Hack-n-Slash or Click to Hit / Shoot aren't really RPGs, they are ACTION GAMES, whether fantasy or not.
Now, Neverwinter Nights (1, 2, or Enhanced Edition) or Baldur's Gate are a real RPG Game.
Even Final Fantasy Tactics is more RPG than these games, sadly.. lol
Hell, evenThe Fallout series is more RPG than many of these games!
@nwngenisys8969 I think these days, any game that has even a bit of customization to its characters skills or weapons is considered RPG by these guys. In that case, a game like Doom Eternal is not a fps game but a RPG as well since it has weapon Mods and allows "Stat allocation" between HP, Armor etc.....
This is just a matter of opinion like I said myself I personally enjoyed the game once I learned all the mechanics and dealt with the weight issues and the flying around and all the spacecraft stuff. It’s actually a pretty damn good in death RPG now I wouldn’t give it the number one spot that would definitely go to Baldor gate three, but it would be in my top three.
Wether it's their actual opinion or not, it gets people commenting and moving the algorithm on yt.
@@oblikuathe trade off is lack of respect and trust. IGN have improved but they have dealt with a bad reputation for years due to perceived poor and questionable reviews from the majority of viewers.
TIME STAMPS:
#12 Diablo 4 0:23
#11 Lords Of The Fallen 0:56
#10 Dead Island 2 1:40
#9 Everspace 2 2:28
#8 Wild Hearts 3:02
#7 Horizon Forbidden West: Burning Shores 3:40
#6 Lies Of P 4:17
#5 Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty 4:55
#4 Final Fantasy 16 5:33
#3 Hogwarts Legacy 6:17
#2 Baldur's Gate 3 6:51
#1 Starfield 7:27
🐐
Thanks. At least somebody has energy and potential.
This is the second reason i'm unsubscribing after this video, who makes a list without time stamps.
You don't have to put the game name, but you at least need to mark each rank.
Many games in this list are overrated
The fact that Wild Hearts and Starfield are on this list at all while there is no mention of Sea of Stars, Octopath Traveler 2, or even World of Horror, is pretty much all you need to know about this list.
My man does not know what an RPG is...
Thank god you said this.
As someone who hasn't played games for 10+ years I was wondering "what did they to my genre? How did we went from Diablo 2 and Dungeon Siege to this!?"
Nah fr though this man has never played a real rpg game n his life
Is there narrative roleplaying in Diablo? If not it's not an RPG. @@yureco12
This is the 1st time I’ve seen anyone rank Starfield higher than Baldur’s Gate 3. I own both games. Haven’t started Starfield yet but I’m having a blast with BG3
well when you finish bg3 and start srarfield you will realize ... why you should have started a second playthrough instead
Yeah I've p[layed all th etop3 an dwhils tm ynumbe r1 is Hogwarts fo rme I've had a blas twit hBG3 lately a swell and have ideas for several characters I want to play. Even t oth epoin twher I'm tempted t ouse 1 or 2 o fthe origin ones like Shadowheart. S ofo rm ethey'v ekind o fgo tthe top 3 back t ofront. So basicall yswap Starfiel dwit hHogwarts and you'l have my order
Wow, Starfield is definitely not better than end. Bald doors gate three it is definitely a good game now. They do a shitty job of explaining all the systems and all that but once you learn all the stuff like weight management, building ships forming alliances and all the weapon stuff it is actually a pretty good in death RPG I know people say stuff about the loading screens, but just because there’s loading screens doesn’t mean the game isn’t good, this is just a opinion piece and this is my opinion
@@jtzoom86 Yeah mos tgames have loading screens some games just have bette rway sof disguisin gthem for example in Mas Effec tAnfromeda wheneve ryo usee you rship landin gin tha tgam ethat's a loadin gscreen. Even Baldur's Gate 3 ha sloadin gscreens. Mostl yI thin kthe yoccu rwheneve ryo uventuer into a new aera on the map though.Lik eas yhte druid grove.
It’s the first time I’ve seen it beat many of the other games in the list too. It’s their list, but it’s a rare one and an outlier.
Starfield as #1??? You have to be joking.
And… I’d like to think Bethesda for sponsoring this video🤪
Microsoft paid me nothing and I enjoyed Starfield.
@@zachwolfrom4522 OK don’t be so sensitive. It’s just a joke.🤪👍
Gamingbolt really trying to add starfield in every list in their 2023 content
Gotta make sure that they get their future review keys ahead of time I guess.
This is an opinion piece and they are clearly just giving their opinion. Now I’ve played Starfield for about 130 hours and I’ve also played baulders gate 3 for about half of that time and I will admit Baldor gate is a better game but that does not mean that Starfield isn’t a good game Starfield problem is that it’s got so many mechanics that just aren’t explained when you get used to all the stuff that you do in the game it is actually a very very solid RPG and people aren’t the kudos to the game that it deserves. It’s a good game, don’t hate it just because everybody else does if you’ve never played it, you should not be talking about how bad it is
@@jtzoom86Starfield may be a good game but it is very strange seeing this at the top of a list considering that Starfield is a Significant step back with loading screens and bland procedural maps. It’s certainly not what Bethesda promised and it did not meet the high expectations many had for it. It’s a strong 7.
However, It now sits at mostly unfavourable reviews on Steam as many realise it is not an improvement of the Bethesda formula or anything new which is shame considering how long it’s been in development.
When one of the top mods calls the game boring and announces they are no longer modding for it should indicate something has gone wrong. The game has not received any awards from the major organisations or even any other major publications. Personal opinion is fine but this ranking stands out as odd and an exception
Looking at this channel saying Microsoft won the year is also certainly very strange considering Phil Spencer said at the end of the year they had lost this generation and the PS5 was dominating. Microsoft exclusives mostly failed. Sony may have had much fewer than normal, but they all hit and the old ones still exist. It’s a bizarre video that only an Xbox fanboy could believe…with difficulty.
I think that context makes this ranking more understandable. I think this reviewer clearly prefers Xbox for some reason.
To overlook Sea of Stars and Octopath Traveler 2, or even Remnant 2 for Horizon, Dead Island 2, and especially Starfield is a criminal travesty. Gamingbolt had their AAA glasses on for this one.
I completely forgot about CS stars that is a fantastic game that brings up memories of CHRONO trigger from back in the day another excellent game. In fact, this is been a damn good year for RPG‘s in general small land big.
@jtzoom86 agreed. Even went back and got Chrono Trigger again on 3ds to experience again. Both Sea of Stars and Chrono are gems.
Starfield is number one?! Unsubscribed, you clowns have no idea about RPGs.
Microsoft definitely payed you to put starfield on every positive list lmao, sucking it off 24 hours a day
Not only that but as number 1 hahaha
You do realize this is an opinion website, right? So if they don’t automatically agree with what you think they’re paid off by Microsoft that’s silly. I think Starfield is a very good game underneath all the stuff that all the mechanics that you gotta do in the game but that’s where the problem lies there’s a lot of mechanics in the game that are not explained very well, and you have to figure out on your own, but that’s just my opinion but saying that I think baulders gate 3 is the RPG of the year by far
Lies of p baby. Such an underrated game
1. Baulders gate 3
2.lies of p
3.sea of stars
4. Starfield
Again, this is just my opinion on it. I’ve played all these games and I believe that baulders gate 3 is definitely the best RPG of the year. Now when it comes to Starfield, it’s getting a lot of hate from a lot of people and I suspect some of these people have a played it. The problem with Starfield is that it’s got a lot of mechanics and a lot of systems that aren’t explained very well, but when you get used to how all this stuff works and all the side missions, the shipbuilding And all the faction stuff it is actually a pretty damn solid RPG. the biggest issue with Starfield is that it was super built up and it didn’t quite live up to what it was supposed to be but that does not mean the game is not fun and enjoyable because it definitely is I have over 120 hours into the game
It’s painfully obvious Microsoft or Bethesda has a financial relationship with Gamingbolt 😂 the only people putting Starfield anywhere near the top of any lists
remnant2 is probably the best rpg and coop game i've played in recent years, up there with elden ring and sekiro. but starfield got no 1 is crazy. dude probably bethesda diehard fan. lol
When he started with Diablo i knew this list would be bad
I meant to unsubscribe earlier, and most have forgotten. This list was a perfect reminder to do just that.
Starfield is no way even close to the best RPG this year. Lies of P is even more enjoyable
if you see this comment don’t waste your time watching the video. Starfield is their best rpg of the year so the list is invalid and watching this is a waste of time.
Starfield was mediocre
Agreed. They sure are pushing this game.
You joking right
Smoking some cheap shit
Everyone has their own opinion hence why this is an opinion Piece. I wouldn’t put Starfield at number one but it’s definitely in the top five because no matter what a bunch of people say to hate on the game when you get into it and you learn it’s mechanics. It’s actually a very very good game. It’s a solid story shipbuilding and all other kinds of stuff. It’s really not that bad but I would say Baltimore gate three would be my number one pick that game is phenomenal. I put Starfield probably three or four maybe. Again, this is just a matter of opinion. Just because somebody doesn’t like it doesn’t mean it’s not good to somebody else.
How is Starfield #1?? Compared to Baldurs Gate 3???!
as soon as i saw starfield at number 1, made me question everything else
Starfeld does not even deserve to be mentioned here. And you have it beating out the actual GOTY, Baldurs Gate 3?
Ridiculous invalid list brings shame upon your ancestors 😔 how dare you
Imagine listing Dead Island 2 as one of the best RPGs... at this point, I just keep watching their videos when I need an easy target to hate on 😂
Funny thing is its not even an rpg 😂
Don't want to be rude, but Starfield Does Not deserve number one, not even close. More like 5 or 6 in my opinion. Don't get me wrong, I like the game. But Bethesda doesn't care anymore and there is A LOT of changes needed.. with a lot I really mean a lot. 🤷🏼♂️
starfield you guys just lost me.
Lords of the Fallen 2023 was announced in 2013? Aren't you mixing it up with the 2014 game?
He has to be
Gamingbolt gave starfield 10/10. Unsubscribe to this xbox fanboys🤷🏻♂️
Starfield just beated BG3... Yup, i'm out. 😅
BG3 has set the standards for future RPG's higher than ever imo.
Deserves to be number one.
Diablo making the list gave me a great laugh
Diablo isnt even the 5th worst thing about this list
Starfield is really boring, how did it make this list, lol
I guess anything gets to be called an "RPG" these days. These were almost all action or adventure games.
Sea of Stars, Octopath Traveler 2, Star Ocean 2, Super Mario RPG. What are you doing?
LMAO at putting Starfield at #1, this channel more and more has become a joke.
agreed. This channel used to be pretty decent but now its just mid. Also why cant they spend 5min to put time stamps? ugh
It’s interesting to me the number of titles on here that are games with RPG mechanics while they ignore one of the great pure RPGs of the year: Octopath 2 doesn’t even get an honorable mention, but Dead Island and the Horizon DLC are on here? (No shade on Dead Island 2 or Horizon’s DLC, I thought both were great.)
That’s aside from putting Starfield as the #1 spot. I must live in an alternate dimension.
Does Octopath Traveler 2 even have narrative roleplaying? Because I know the first game doesn't.
saying starfield was most memorable gaming experience of 2023 is insulting to games like BG3 and Lies of P . Good job gamingbolt xbox blind fan channel.. Not biased at all right??
I don’t think this site is is biased at all. It’s all a matter of opinion now it’s definitely not as good as baulders gate 3 by a longshot, but it is still a damn good game when you actually figure out all the mechanics and how everything works this shipbuilding, jumping from star systems all that kind of stuff base building it is actually a damn good game you just gotta give it a chance. They could’ve done a better job of explaining all the mechanics in the game and they did not do that but luckily they’re coming out with a huge patch that’s supposed to solve this and again, this is just a matter of opinion
I totally forgot about dead island. I really miss the borderlands×left4dead sort of gameplay. I remember getting super lucky in finding a ludicrously overpowered katana and never putting it down after realizing how incredibly fun it was to slaughter massive hordes single handedly.
OH GEEZ I WONDER HOW MANY OF THOSE GAMES HAVE BARELY ANY RPG ELEMENTS/MECHANICS IN THEM!!!
Lmao loading screen & Fast Travel Simulator wins 1st place?
Wow Starfield….i was expecting tears of the kingdom….but I suppose that’s not an rpg👏
Tears of the kingdom is not an RPG >>
So what is it if you dont mind me asking lol ? Just curious
@@PsLove-el5bw what is it?
Starfield as number one? Really?
I do love Starfield but I I’ll say idk if I’d go to these guys for rpg info. Their definition of rpg is loose based on this list and they don’t even include games like octopath 2 or my personal number two game of the year behind Zelda, sea of Stars
They tend to ignore most JRPGs. They probably included FFXVI because of how action-focused it is, had it been a bit more "traditional", they would have most likely ignored it as well.
I'm watching it and I feel like I'm back 10 years ago. Nothing has changed since I played LA Noire. The best game I've played so far.
Games in 2024 are supposed to be a mix of Apple Vision, Pokemon GO, and GTA
I was supposed to go to an actual bar nearby correctly guess a ridge and pick the right cocktail, then a "Ghost" detective was supposed to show up in my apple vision telling me about the case he was on in 1947 while he was taken down by Mickey Cohen and he wants me to go to Pasadena to follow the criminal trail he stumbled upon.
*The game industry really stalled 😟since 2010's*
I really need to play ‘Everspace 2’. Thanks for the reminder!
How much did Bethesda pay you for making Starfield #1? I can never take you seriously again, unsubbing
Didn’t watch yet but if Starfield is up here this list is invalid. (edit) FUCKING INVALID
I owe you 8 minutes of my life, thank you sir
Ive been playing the older games ,especially on the 360 and xbox one
I’m not too crazy about how rpgs have evolved over the years. It’s unfortunately more about action and spamming your buttons, grinding out damage sponge bosses than it is about role playing
I was thought why there are so many dislikes, #1 Starfield someone need to be fired
Im suprised nobody ever mentions miasma chronicles it looks great on next gen
I agree 100% Starfield is the best rpg, Starfield has a lot of haters, but currently this the only game where you can travel to many different worlds and discover new things. And for the people that have a negative mindset and are comparing it to 2077 and other games are clueless. Cyberpunk phantom liberty is only based in one world, or should I say one city, so of course it’ll look better. The developers have put a lot of effort into one city, not many worlds. You can’t even get off the planet lol. And no man’s sky? It’s outdated and looks like a cartoon space game. As for other rpgs, again you can only play in a one world environment. So by that being said Starfield wins in my book.
Some marketing freelancers are paid money to promote a product.
Honestly i should still be playing starfield if the talent hadn't left bethesda
Starfield is an extremely good game
how is starfield even mentioned on here? its like giving gollum a shout out
DI 2 is really good
Lies of P is my personal GOTY
Yes everybody needs to experience Starfield to see how bad it really is.
Lies of P was WAY better than Starfeild and FF16. And I played them all.
Starfield?
Remnant 2 way better then starfield and its not even on the list
Bros made a "top 12 rpgs of 2023" without Octopath Traveler 2 and Star Ocean 2nd Story. Literally unfollowed and disregarded any respect I ever had for this site.
Timestamp, where?
Hack n Slash modules / games don't qualify for RPGs, they are too linear to be RPGs...
This is even more true for click to hit style of games, they aren't truly RPGs, they are click to hit / shoot games...
Combat is NOT the main feature of an RPG, not even, it's a secondary feature at best.
Watching "Top 12 rpg's" showcase of in 2024 without timestamps,kept scrolling through the vid then i see starfield,this is hillarious hahahahah 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
How much did you guys get for your #1 pick, Starfield. Was it worth the loss of credibility?
Bro Wild Hearts was ok'ish game but with all of its trouble, low content and cut support way too early does not deserve to be on this list.
There is like countless of amazing indie RPG games that deserve more to be on this list instead but oh well GamingBolt is gonna be GamingBolt and they rather put triple A published game on the list of "best of X" than actually something that deserve to be on said list lol
Case in point Wild Hearts and Starfield
this list paid for by bethesda
22 sec in video i see d4 in a title "best rpg" dis and out
starting off with diablo 4 is like asking everyone to instantly dislike this video.. f off
What about World of Warcraft: Dragonflight ??
Not everybody chases popular opinions, salty BG3 fanboys. People are allowed to enjoy different video games, even if they are bad.
I'm shocked number one 😂
Let's be honest: BG3 is wiping the floor with Starfield on all fields.
This list is a joke.
I was already on the fence with this channel after years of meh.
But ranking any game above balders gate three, especially starfield is just asinine.
I gotta bounce. I can't trust you guys.
Starfield was boring as hell and Baldur gate 3 was just an okay game I still don't know how it became goty
Obviously not a fan of jrpgs. No Octopath Traveller II, Star Ocean the Second Story, Trails into Reverie etc.
No sea of stars and octopath traveller 2?😮.. nobody seems to care about wukong too😢
I think everyone on here doesn’t understand that this is an opinion piece for somebody and all they’re doing is shitting on Starfield now Starfield wasn’t a super awesome game like baulders gate 3 but it is definitely a death RPPG. THAT THE GAME DOES A TERRIBLE JOB OF EXPLAINING ALL THE SYSTEMS IN THE GAME BUT WHEN YOU FINALLY UNDERSTAND ALL THE MECHANICS IN THE GAME YOU GET INTO THE STORY, THE SHIPBUILDING, THE BASE BUILDING, AND ALL THAT KIND OF STUFF STAR IS ACTUALLY A PRETTY SOLID RPG
starfield number 1? man wtf is this channel
Is dead island two story good?
But I have watched a video of Hogwarts Legacy and they said that it's a great game but with a bad RPG .
So Xbox and Microsoft are paying you guys a lot of money?
Baldur's Gate III clears
rpgs are offline you share mmorpg like d4
Your content becoming controversial lately. Your best ps vita games list are bullshit
Really? Starfield? Seriously? Poor neglected armored core vi.
Some poor quality games on this list
lol a gaming channel which dont knows different between a rpg game and an action adventure game with rpg elements. Half of these game arent rpgs
Something is wrong with this video and channel Starfield Should not by any means be number 1 or not even this list.
Seems this channel is biased and corrupt.
How much did you get paid to put starfield In number 1?
Ah gaming bolt... Another day another s*** list. At least they are consistent with crap. Look i like starfield I'm having fun... I'm not a BG3 fan but in no way is starfield in any way better than BG3 in any way. Except load screens. Even CPPL was way better than starfield. But when it comes to crappy unthoughtout lists no one does it better than gamingbolt.
You guys are putting starfield in the number 1 spot? That's it I'm unsubscribing
Starfield and Daiblo IV? LOL
Colony ship is better than all of those
unsubbed disliked reported lol
Dead island 2 or dying light 2??
I’d pick Dead Island 2 any day. Dying Light 2 feels clunky, dull and slow, and the characters provoke almost no reaction in me most of the time. Dead Island actually wants you to have fun.
Stop mentioning Final Fantasy, pleeeeeeease..... It sickens me.
lmao "let's pick the most main stream titles"... give me a break. Suggestions were dog
no wonder this video got so many down votes. This list is really bad not to mention some better rpgs were excluded from the list.