IS RDR 2 REALLY MORE REALISTIC THAN GTA 5? (GTA 5 VS RDR 2 DETAILS COMPARISON)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ม.ค. 2024
- Comparing the details in GTA 5 and RDR 2.
Want more comparisons?
GTA ONLINE VERSUS SERIES PLAYLIST:
• GTA 5 ONLINE : WHICH I...
Connect with OneSpot Gaming
Instagram: OneSpotGaming ( / onespotgaming )
Discord: / discord
Twitter: @onespotgaming ( / onespotgaming )
Facebook: / onespotgaming
Outro Music:
LFZ - Popsicle [NCS Release]
• LFZ - Popsicle | House...
[LFZ]
• / lfzmusic
• / imlfz
• / lfzmedia - เกม
Ever noticed these details?
Yes
Bhai kya me bhi kabhi aapke Jesa bada youtuber banunga kya 😢😢
Yes
Thanks yaar ❤ bas aap sab ka support bana rahe 🥰🥰🥺
Some of them most but not all lol
6:18 Obviously the rainbow parachute doesn't work straight...
💀
Bruh
Hell nah
LMAO
W comment😂
In gta6 if I punch a wooden fence I wanna see my character reeling in excruciating pain
Gta6 😂
or it won't work at all, it has the same engine as RDR2
@@VTaurus7598 Firstly, GTA5, RDR2 and GTA6 are all the same engine. Secondly, the engine has little to do with anything in games. It means that some graphics bugs/artifacts can be the engine, or some assets and textures, meaning 2 games on the same engine can look similar, aside from that the engine does whatever you program it to do. Payday 2's engine was previously only used for racing games. If a game has issues, it comes down to either developer incompetence or lack of experience, it's rarely the engine's fault.
You people are overrating this stupid game so much, you people are gonna be really dissapointed once the game comes out.
@@gaminghellfirenegative Nancy over here
I love how the rdr2 map is smaller than gta 5's but it feels much bigger because there are multiple towns and biomes and horses are also slower than cars lol
I am pretty much sure that RDR2's is larger than GTA V's map. GTA V is indeed smaller
@@anushkashukla1691 Trevor’s testicles seem far larger than Arthur’s though. Like the difference in ball size is actually colossal. Which makes up for the potential difference in map size. Trevor even has a tattoo of the entirety of the map of Canada on them, which really ups his game, and in fact even adds “map” to his “game”.
@@Brandon-br7tcit’s hard to compare because they are completely different shapes but RDR2 not only has the main parts it has out of bounds and an unfinished Mexico, which adds a lot more map to the game. I do think rdr2 has a bigger map
it’s not that much smaller tho only by a little
@@averageSE I don’t think the tattoo of Mexico on Arthur’s nutsack is even mildly comparable in size to Trevor’s tat. Trevor’s just seems to scale much higher, especially when you consider how many wrinkles his has which implies even more surface area of skin on his already very volumous testes.
2:20 buddy got really interested by that glass bottle huh
A big black guy came to pound him
☠️
Whatttt
lmao 💀
I RAN to the comments
1:59 Benchs in 1899 were just built different
Nothing can be more realistic than drunk arthur calling lenny 💀💀
Don't you mean Ynnel?
Even the saloon girls looked like lenny 😂
@@JWonneveryone looked like Lenny 😂
Haha true
Haha. I started playing recently and just went trough that mission yesterday. It was hillarious 🤣
I wouldn’t call punching a fence with your bare hands and it breaking, realistic. So RDR2 wins for the realism that your fist isn’t going to shatter wood in one punch.
You underestimate franklin's power, some people can break 2 x 4s with their fists
Depends on the person
Proof Franklin is on CLEN,TREN and ANAVAR
@@JohanStrombeckno
Franklin is a ghetto boy, he can definitely demolish a fence
2:19 what's bro doing off camera 💀
It's me pegging him😊
💀
That's not him dufus
💀💀💀
That's not him
2:19 whats going on back there💀
2:21 wtf 💀
Yaa bro I suddenly fear by hearing that voice 😂
he is just sad... i mean.. franklin is shooting a healthy beer ;(
Fetsh boy getting f 💀
For the fences you can actually break it, but with your horse, just by jump on it multiple times. In my opinion it’s make more sense than breaking it by hand
Strictly speaking, there is nothing sensible about it at all
@@VTaurus7598 for you, it makes more sense to break a fence with a punch rather than breaking it a little with the help of a horse that has a lot of strength
@@VTaurus7598have you tried breaking a fence with your bare hands before? It ain’t gonna look like gta chief. The other guy was obviously right
@VTaurus7598 Go try it, record it and upload it for our amusement then. Go punch a fence as hard as you possibly can to see if it splinters before your hand does.
@@watersnortmoment3734 😂😂😂
The thing about grenades is because in the 1800s they were weaker and of course in modern times they are more powerful. Still, RDR2 is still very realistic but you have to take into account that the era is different, that's why many things there are different compared to IV and V.
Good video!
true, but it's still dynamite against a wooden bench, it should cause more or less the damage of a grenade at very close range. I never expected that the bench wouldn't be destroyed.
No. This dynamite pipe is supposed more powerful than a standard hand grenade
@@Billioncompany786 it's clearly wooden. It's not like they made benches of steel back then
with IV and V the main reason why theyre different is because GTA V had to run on a 2006 console with 256MB of ram. Rockstar downgraded and cut out some tiny details for performance reasons. Thats why the PS3/360 versions of GTA V only had about 2 years of update support
The games only take place 5 years apart. Its like 2019 vs 2024
@@ollibon bro i dont think the devs are very concerned wether or not you can break a bench with a stick of dynamite
4:54 Arthur in blackwater 💀
2:20 that's sound, Lol 🤣
😂😂😂
Fucking sound 🎉
The night sky part is actually quite realistic for GTAV because of light pollution
I love the lighting(both day and night) in GTAV more than RDR2
@@bharathm9892interesting take
Just wait till 6 comes out it won’t even be comparable. Kind of like RDR and Gta right now
@@DankestSupplyYou can already see it in the trailer, Gta 6 has the same engine as RDR2, only the engine has been updated
@@VTaurus7598 That’s what i mean, i can only imagine the immersion
Only logical reason I have for the rdr2 benches not getting destroyed by tnt is bcuz literally every single type of chair/bench in rdr2 is able to be used and sat on so they had to make it so they don’t get destroyed,In gta u can’t sit down so they have no reason to make them indestructible
Realistically i think the bench in rdr2 is glued to the floor
the metal frame of the bench should bend or break, unless the dynamite is weak
No it has something to do with time and resource management. It is entirely possible to make a interactable object destroyable.
In GTA you spend alot of time drviving around (and crashing) vehicles, park benches are everywhere in Los Santos. having indestructable benches everywhere in the city would bother the players.
In Red dead Redemption you don't spend as much time in cities in towns as in GTA, and benches are placed more sparsely. On top of that, there isn't really a way you "could" destroy a bench on a regular basis in Red dead, besides throwing dynamite directly onto it. Sure you could crash your horse or wagon against one, but making the crash satisfying would be quite the time consuming thing to do, for something that would happen very rarely.
Well not every one of them.
That’s a terrible reason lol
@@diegofufun1316yeah, no, it's because they're interactive items.
Gta 5 is 2013 and rdr2 is 2018. That’s it.
Could be. But GTA 4 has more advanced physics than 5 in soma aspects
GTA 5 have some things that no games haven’t, so , Rockstar games is the best )
GTA 5 also gets a new update that could fix it every week but red dead got it right on release
They're both from Rockstar so they're both realistic
FUN FACT THE NIGHT SKY IN RDR2 IS ACCURATE WITH THE IRL NIGHT SKY I MEAN THE SRATS AND CONSTILATIONS ARE ACCURATE TO PURFECTION
Awesome! But it’s perfection 👍
@@chopsyoutube mb
Well both are masterpiece in their own time ❤
They came out at the same time I think
2013 an 2018@@Fugitive685
@@Fugitive685rdr2 came out in 2018 and GTA 5 came out in 2013
@@Sillypuppy789 NICE
Are you dumb? @@Fugitive685
GTA 5 is five years older yet still can compete with a 2018 game that so many 2020/2023 games can't compete with
GTA 4 is five years older yet still can compete with a 2013 game that so many 2020s games can't compete with
@@Theoryofanything.gta san andreas is 20 years old and can still compete with a 2008 game that so many 2020s games cant compete with
@@Greg12839 GTA 3 is 23 years old and can still compete with a 2004 game that so many 2020s games can't compete with
@@TheAngryBear2323chess exists since the dawn of time and still competes with a game from 2018
@@TheAngryBear2323 GTA 3 doesn't compare with any 2004 game so we should end this at san Andreas
I remember is 2013 when gta5 came out, walking in water and your pants would saty wet, like MIND BLOWN lol. rdr2 is just gonna be hard to beat. Its what makes it great for sure.
Well, in Tomb Raider Chronicles Lara's wet hair still dripped a little when the wind blew, that was realism and the game is from the year 2000.
People comments about body physics in rdr2, and san andreas, n gta v People not, horses testicle shrink during cold in rdr2, ur clothes not only get wet but gets muddy too in rdr2. (Dogs will go to visit dead owner's grave too in rdr2) Only this bracket logic kills every gta or any game logic too, in rdr2 characters hair grow, half constructed area or destructed building gets completes too not by itself but u can see the actual npc working on it, rdr2 character loots body by complete pocketing, n if run fast, looted items lost often too, A character can only carry items, an average People could carry too, if u kill someone, npc get to avoid you, or they'll share the story about your murder too, n if they haven't see u kill someone, but when u wander n lucky you'll get the news from the npc talks about the dead body was found onthat particular area, if u donate very less money to camp, they'll react too, if u stay at home, the family will tell you to go for providing foods or works too, the family cooks the meal in particular timing by cutting the meat, washed, too, People won't forget u doing harm, or won't forget u doing good deeds, People will complain of characters not clean n foul smell too, if u punch a person, your dorsal palm actually red too, there are 1000,s great details in rdr2, n in gta v only 16, 17, whereas in gta 4 n gta sa there are much more realistic details than gta v, gta 4 n gta sa are the gta that has most realistic features, most of gta v features doesn't make sense
Does bro not realise new boats arent like wood boats?
I knew I'd find this comment eventually. Glad I did, too.
So does the ammunition
@@memesky1014 Yeah now we have better ammo. whats your point?
Both sink
@@BlindingSun_ The new one shouldn't sink as its much bigger and tougher on the floor and if water does somehow leak in itll just exit out the open back
Plus: water shouldn't leak onto the boat floor since the floor is higher than the water
In GTA 5 it is also possible to die by falling into water
it's the same in rdr2
@@DaceBruh YES !!!
You can fall from any height into a pool in GTA 5 and be fine. What are you talking about?
No its not, i fell in the ocean and pools so many damn times in this game since its release and i never died
@@mewsterx3679 but this has happened to me. How strange!
Gta V and rdr2 have very different game mechanics because of the console hardware limitations for which they were developed at different times
2:19 bruh?💀
The effort put into RDR 2 is simply mind blowing.... It is as close to real as can be....
I really cant wait to see how GTA 6 workings.. and of course after the mods
Rdr looks like real footage of spaghetti western film in opposition to GTA
2:20 what's that sound 💀
😂💀😂
RDR is way more realistic than GTA 5
3:33 flag's physics is insane
0:45 These punches are as powerful as a gun
RDR2 also leans a bit more realistic with its storytelling and gameplay, it still has a lot of the charming Rockstar over-the-topness, but it's easier to suspend disbelief than it is in GTA, where you kind of accept that it's ridiculous and learn to love it. Neither is better mind you, two different but equally fun approaches!
If GTA V didnt have its ridiculousness I think it would be a lot less beloved as a game. There’s nothing quite like sending a car flying 50 feet in the air from driving up a ramp.
Idk bro I have to shoot a wolf 5 times in the face to kill it in red dead but one time to kill a cougar in gta 5
@@orestis103 A head shot will do the trick for a wolf
RDR 2 IS BETTER BRO
5:31 typo
2:28 if you go into photo mode as soon as you shoot a bottle, you can see the bottles actually have liquid in them and it spills out
i don’t think you should compare considering one is 5 years older
2:18 that sounded so wrong 😂
Franklin is so powerful that he can rip fences apart with bare hands and manage not to get injured 😂
4:40 I like that you mentioned “less (light) pollution” instead of just saying it has more details
Rdr 2 most realistic game ever.
*so far
Minus the water situation.
let's just agree that rdr II is one of the most realistic games ever and gta VI better be even more realistiv
it will be because rdr2 uses rage 8 mechanic and gta 6 will use rage 9 so
It’d not realistic
Even GTA 4 is more realistic than GTA 5
Exactly!
😂😂😂wrost realistic..
@@blitlzgamer2924 Wrost?
@@MinecraftvsBurnout lol
XD, no
Goto the bunker in palato bay and the statue with the guy holding a barrel has water in it and pours out if you shoot it
i forgot you exist i havent watched you in like 2 years
2:21 sonidos ambientales:❌
sonidos perturbadores✅
Naughty sounds 😂
Imagine how gta 6 is gonna be 💀
Jiggly ass physics
Can’t wait for the is RDR 2 realistic than GtA6 videos
That bench is stronger then the prison micha was in
Wow 💚💚💚💙💙💙🔥🔥🔥
Yes 💚💚💚🔥🔥🔥
Modern boats have more layers and stronger materials than just a wooden boat. So of course it won't fill with water when shot.
I think some stuff like fences and benches only being destroyed or interactive on GTAV is because they know it will get run over by a car at some point lmao
Well gta 5 is 11 years old. Of course rdr2 is more realistic
Both games are playable. No need to argue about them
Playable what ? They are better than most 2023 games
Not arguing about anything.
Just providing examples of the differences.
I found this video very well done.
Nice video brother keep going❤❤❤
Punching a wooden fence would break your knuckles before it breaks the wood lmao
2:20 wtf
Crazy how a 2013 game still keeps up then most games that came out recently.
What's so impressive with that? Gta 4 can do the same, even better... Half Life 2 from 2004.
I hate GTA 4 dark tone
GTA V feels more graphically appealing and more pleasing to my eyes@@trashcleaner
2:20 what did i just hear😂
REALLY AMAZING VIDEO
💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
2:21 wtf happened to that NPC
Think if they add these RDR details with add up in gta 6 what the game would be 🤔
Think how realistic does GTA 6 will be 😮
Next question: "is the sun really out in the sky?"
Bro is comparing 2013 game with 2018 game 😂
Which receives 100x more updates than 2018 game
@@frenzyduk GTA does not receive updates nor does rd2😂that's GTA online and they add content not realism
💙💙💙💙💙💙🔥🔥🔥
I can break a fence by hand and foot btw and I'm not 220 lb muscle man.
Those boards are effectively 1x6 which break really easily to one kick.
1:05 wth u expect him punching through a wooden fence? lol
2:20 huhhhhhh???? WHAT THE FUCK??
Bro came and regretted
@@victor.novorskiyeah I was wondering what was that 😂
💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Smoke, clouds, etc they’re all volumetric on RDR2
my favorite past time in gta v is bumping into an npc repeatedly until they die because the ragdoll is too damn funny.
RDR2 is a practice ground for developing GTA6
Waiting for GTA v vs rdr2 vs GTA VI
This is true that if we will jump in that height we will die
You were using invincible mod in GTA V, you'd def die by falling in water too like RDR2
2:19 tf are those noises
AMBATUKAAAAAAMMMMM AHHHHHH
"Ah um ah ah ah ah"
💙💙💙💙💚💚💚🔥🔥🔥
falling from sky with that pose, possibly broke your ribs, so yeah, death is more realistic
2:20 what the hell was that sound
😂😂😂
The thing with the boat in gta 5 was because these holes were kinda above the water so its not really a good example
💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
0:38 было бы круто если бы еще доски на лодке ломались
Not too surprised for a game thats 5 years older
Details ❌ Deyails ✅
Or course I knew it Rdr2 will win
One was released 2013, the other was released 2018. So RDR2 should be more realistic
Nah bro has to be a shaolin monk in order to punch through a wood fence like its made of paper
RDR2 CAME OUT AFTER GTA V WHAT DID U EXPECT
No doubt if you completed both rdr2 and GTA v so you are informed that rdr2 is way more realistic and better than GTA v just rockstar games is milking GTA v
But it will still be the best GTA 5
RDR 😮🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Nice topic ishan bhai
Thank you :D
You will never know why got so many likes 💀
1?
Bro calling 3 likes a lot
That bench that survived 3 dynamite sticks is sigma bench
Bro, whatever you using for gameplay recording its really high quality
There are videos like this from various TH-camrs, they're all pretty much the same and nothing special.
Comparing a game from almost 10 years ago is awesome in 😂
Which was the better crew to rob banks would it be the Van Der Linde gang without Micah in it or is it Michael Townley, Trevor Phillips, Franklin, Lester and also Patrick McReary