ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 พ.ค. 2017
- Anchor: Amrita Rai
Description: In this edition of Sarokar, we debate the crucial internal security issue- Naxalism. The government has recently held a meeting of all naxal affected states and formulated the SAMADHAN policy to tackle the problem.
Guest: E N Rammohan , Former BSF Head; K P S Gill - Former IPS; C Pal Singh, Former, IG, CRPF; Nandini Sundar, Professor, Department of Sociology; K C Tyagi, Leader, JD (U); Gopal Krishan Aggarwal , spokesperson, BJP
i am the upsc student .this programme is very helpfull for upsc aspirant.please include important issu
kumar Sarathi .. Bhai kuch khud v prlo
E N Rammohan u spoke very well. even more than that of sociologist nandani Sundar.
Do not call politicians in such debates bcz they simply politicizes the issue rather to take stringent actions against these kinds of internal threats .
This type of debates is of national importance and must be concluded.i urge all these academicians and officers to put forth their excellent reviews rather than criticizing one another.
I have been watching these rajyasabha debates for long but most of the time it has unconcluded.
Kash debate aur channel par hoti...others channel ki debate
Sun kr mind me distraction aa jata hai........ Realy its very good debate...
Thanx rstv..
Thanx so much
Sir, please tell me which website name told by Retd. IPS Gill sir on data of naxal areas where attack went done.
Gill sir ne konsi site ka name btaya?
include all important issu.....nice....
pragmatic debate.all participants are somewhat correctl in ther arguements,situation is much more complex than it seem to be
Thanks rajya sabha tv and amrata ji for conducting such type debate special on non voiced people.thanks again.
Nandini is also a Naxal supporter 😖
Why anchor is interruption before complete
बस्तर से नक्सलवाद खत्म करने का मेरा एक सुत्रीय सुझाव - बस्तर को छत्तीसगढ़ से पृथक कर एक केन्द्र शासित अनुसुचित प्रदेश बना दीजिए।
Thanks....
Naxalwad is good
Today this types of unbiased debates not happening on rstv. Now rstv talks only govt side only..
This is the best debate
The bullet can never be an answer to such issues. All government top leaders know that they are culprits and tactically defending itself. bjp spokesperson was mostly useless in this. professor mam and crpf sir were excellent. thank u Rajya Sabha for this debate
Congrats for 2m subscribers
well done job
Responsibility of Development(majorly) is a state subject ,which is not happening in these areas .
Why not these areas should be combined and make a UNION TERRITORY.
Then development and security both can be coordinated by the center.
Thank you. madam aapko dekhna ek sukhad anubhav rha aapke patrakarita prabhavashli h
C pal singh's view is nice.
People who are stopping developmental works by violence have political motives.
I don't think any normal tribal man will have any problem with roads or school construction.
Gill sahab rocks
KC Tyagi- spot on!
very good debate..thanks *amrita mam*
Great jatt hero.
Jat balwan, jai bhagwan
Not bad
I only understood "establishment" ...
Natalites ko agar khatam krna hai to education di jaye
equality di jaye
rojgar diya jaye
aur sath hi Hume apni internal security ko strong kiya jaye
hamare sarkar ke sath sath logo ko v jagruk hone ki jarurat hai hamare aas pas kya ho raha h
kaun kah a kis kamo me involve hai
chhote chhote level pr meeting kr ke jaanne ki koshish ki jaye ki akhir waha ke logo ko kis chij ki jarurat hai
and unki problem ko quickly plan bana kr implement kiya jaye....
Amrita prakash the government has already dont that.. their bosses wants full freedom to operate a parallel government there also they want each and everyone given equal amount of wealth throughout the area.. is that possible.. how will you feel if someone comes to you and say that the cellphone or the pc from which you are commenting on this channel is not somebody else's think about it.. they are demanding nonsense.. that's why the government has no option but to supress the movement like it was started..
By force.
Equality Leni padhti hai di nhi jaati
45:48 toh bhai.....kya jo sarkar se nakhush hain woh sare hathiyar utha le??
Gill sir spot on.
Please avoid politicians in your show. Period.
good
शहीद हुए हैं
Hathiyarband Naxalism ka kewal ak hi upay hai, "gun, gun and gun" bullets ,bullets and bullets..
Gaon me Pradhan Sc,St,OBc are pradhan and as soon as they become Pradhan,make a new house,buy bike,new mobile.and loot full 5 years along with govt secretary.if you give parallel administration,conflict will emerge.
Deviding farmes land the govt made labour to all big farmer and the rural worker.Earlier neither farmer,small jamindar and rural labour tribel never go to city for earning.
And now Farmer,small jamindar labour all are searching for job in the city.
India bhoot khoobsurat desh he please stop civil war and rebelion ilove bharat maa jai jind comes from somaliland
5:48 क्या है यार ये...??😑
I think ye idological problem hai..gareebe bahut jagah hai..tribes bhi
akhir en logo ke pas etne hathiya kaha se aata h kaise aata hai kyu nahi society public government administrator ko dhayan nahi jata hai aur sab kuch jante huwe v aankhe kyu ban kiye rahte hai action kyu nahi lete
jb darjano sainiko ko maut k ghat uttar diya jata h tb sarkar ki aankhe khulti hai aisa kyu
Tum log Security Forces ko galat mat batao saalo
Indian Army Great 🇮🇳🇮🇳
sarkar murga-murgi lara rahi hai naxali nahi mulnivasi hain unki land vapas kare right de
नंदिनी मेम ने यथार्थ प्रस्तुत किया
Panjab or hariyana ke log Bihar jate hai work ke liye isse bada majak kuchh nhi ho sakta K.C tyagi Ji ,,
Bihar ke log Punjab and Haryana jate hain, jo ab wapas Bihar ja rahe hain waha pe vikas ke karan. Jisse Punjab me kaam kaise hoga. Fir se suno or samjho.
gopal pe fat tax lgana chahiye
NAXALWADI JINDABAAD.. LAL SALAM JINDABAAD..
REAL HERO..of All ADIWASI and Poors Peoples.....
NAXALWADI JINDABAAD..
LAL SALAM JINDABAAD...
At 30.10 that is mirzapur
Coming for you shit..... Count for your life 😠😠😠
Good Standard eduvation and free education to tribes is the only solution.After getiing quality education 20 yaars all problem will be finished.
Article 5 will have only 4-5 rural members only they will loot .villagers will b only dumb spectators
Jab aese teacher honge to students to anti national honge hi.
sambit patra should be call as spokesperson of BJP.
According to E r ram mohan ..naxalites want parellel govt.
.
Please correct your view..they were not killed..they were martyred
pata nhi india me kuch log hindi jante huwe bhi English me kyu bolte hai.
study lover 🤣🤣🤣👍👍👍
BecaUse iN inDiA iT is a percepTioN that thoSe whO spEak English aRe weLl educaTed...
Hllo
Xians ar opening English schools.Got schools educations system is so bad due to better mangement.If we educate well like public school,these trible people can get better life managemnt.
Are sadharana Katha semanaknu basa gruha, aducation, khadya diajau sudhuri jibe demane b m as nisa, tume ta sabu lutineba au naxal create nahebe ta au kana tumara chakara Hebe,tankara kn b echha ochhi pathapadhi bhala Manisa Hebe.
all the panelists are talking according to their ideology ...they are not providing concrete solutions...these panelists hv less knowledge about this topic ...rstv should hv called some other specialists.....
rajul upadhyay brother i think we people only have one 1ideology nukss nikalne ki auro ki .. Ye sari baatein sirf paper ya debates tak seemit hai ache ideas bhi honge to bs simit he, implementation ground level pe zero,
i support modi .. but the ironclad response without talks will elongate this problem..
Prashant Rawat AndhBhakt spotted..
***** lmao read my comments in various videos on rstv .. I aint remotely close to andh bhakt ..
Then in that case Im sorry..
कितनी बेशर्मी है कि गिल साहब की बात पर हँसी और सबूत मांग रही है।।
change this spokesperson of BJP ...he is not able to put forth any ligitimate point....he is sinking
Very balanced views of socio mam...this naxalism is created by govt by use of exploitative policies and partly by unethical forces who often resort to gross human rights voilation also the biggest tragedy of inidia wh is its electronic media except few chanels is a stake holder in self preptuating naxilism
Ehsan Dar u r right
one side intellectual persons and another size ...............bjp's donda
This moderator is inefficient
Very bad anchor, jyada Kabil samjhti h
jai naxal jawan gareeb janta ke awaz ha naxal jo suraksha ka nam per gareeb janata ko marna ha nsxalism bharat ma jawan ho raha ha jai naxal jawan
Very bad anchor
Anchor is not good...
This Nandini Sundar herself is Naxalite....These people are the real threats
to be a voice of poor is Naxalite??? asli culprit to wo h Jo unke sath atrocities krte h
Anchor bilkul bekar hai
Anchor bakwass h koi bhi baat Puri honi nhi de rhi h
के सी त्यागी , को बुलाना बेकार है। एक काम का पॉइंट नही है उनके पास।
sambit patra should be call as spokesperson of BJP.
He is fascist