The debate is so interesting because one is only attacking , other one is defending which makes it not like usual arguments like telling opinions and so on
Well, it's not entirely true. The one who is "attacking" is responsible for asking questions and the other one is responsible for giving an answer of yes or no. Sometimes opinions are needed😅
This is in East Tibet, Kham province. You can tell by their dialect and the wooden monastic dorms in the background characteristic to Khampa monasteries since Kham is the only province in Tibet with significant timber growth.
I wonder if they could do it like this in chinese Tibet, I should rather think this is Nepal -- or? The Rinpoche quotes all the time, are the monks so learned in "China" today?
@@lilithdandelion6177 yes maim they can its just language differences. Now many professional have translated middle way view into english also As for me i am a Bhutanese monk like them
Rap battle has an ancient tradition.
The debate is so interesting because one is only attacking , other one is defending which makes it not like usual arguments like telling opinions and so on
Well, it's not entirely true. The one who is "attacking" is responsible for asking questions and the other one is responsible for giving an answer of yes or no. Sometimes opinions are needed😅
@@gonpogamerff6598 yea that's correct only when the attacker asks for accounts of what the defender is really speculating about....
@@gonpogamerff6598 it's "yes", "no" and "neutral"
This is in East Tibet, Kham province. You can tell by their dialect and the wooden monastic dorms in the background characteristic to Khampa monasteries since Kham is the only province in Tibet with significant timber growth.
I wonder if they could do it like this in chinese Tibet, I should rather think this is Nepal -- or? The Rinpoche quotes all the time, are the monks so learned in "China" today?
@@lilithdandelion6177 No, they're learned in Tibet
@@Jahtso Oh! How good! I once saw a documentary in which the ceremony seemed pretty far away from what I heard from our Lamas in exile.
Yes by language and yoe tshang has different language (accents)
@@lilithdandelion6177 yes maim they can its just language differences.
Now many professional have translated middle way view into english also
As for me i am a Bhutanese monk like them
Damn I've never heard Tibetan rap before
Haha bro funny reply
Not rap hahah
I want to know details
They are debating on the first chapter of Pramanavarttika(Buddhist logic) subject. The debate place is in Tibet.
The principles of Buddhism teach to know not to teach for faith.
@@ภังคีนาคา Say what.. devolv please.
Nice
What's tradition
他说的是什么啊?好想知道。哪怕一个字。
我知道这是一种辩论。但是内容在讲什么我不知道怎么解释因为我的中文好差😢
Interesting
Молодец🙏🤲
Rap battle
No debate
🙏🙏🙏🙏
♥️♥️♥️💐🙏💐♥️♥️♥️♥️
🙄🙄
What are you doing you are not a monke
In tibetab monk we play debate like this
condemning people without knowing them is not buddhist
What are you doing you are not a monke
What do you mean?
I think you don't know about buddhism..
monke? huh u mean🐒 or monk😀