Someone said something about Anthony being one of the few real vocal talents today. The thing is, he's more than just that. His vocals are amazing, his lyrics have true meaning, he puts his heart and soul into what he makes, and he enjoys the music. He's not just performing for fame and money, that's just a byproduct for him. And that's why I think he's one of the few great artists of our time.
Heard the cover on SNL and immediately thought of this. I love how the guitar is allowed to show through and shine in this instead of being relegated to accompaniment.
Mistakes are proof that a musician is real... proof that they don't need to hide behind a wall of studio makeup... this is absolutely why I love Circa... they may not be what some consider "the best"as I do... but they can't be denied the award of the most honest band in the industry.
anthony green is amazing. circa is by far my favorite band. i was a fan of ants ever since Jeer at rome, and i knew he was going to be great one day. now him and the addition of all the amazing musicians and his bandmates in circa make the best band ever.
I really like this. I really like that the guys seem really into it... and Im one of those 30 yr old guys that smokes alot and listens to Floyd...but Circa is hands down one of the best bands to come out in the last decade!! Other than The Mars Volta!!
wow my wish came true!!!! i once thought about what would anthony green would sound if he sang "wish you where here" by pink floyd,i never thought he would actually do it,wow just wow!! i love this song :}!!
I'm a fan of the coverers and the coveries and I have to say, pretty good cover. I really liked it. They managed to make it a little mellower than the original, and it was still cool. Thanks for the upload.
Who the fuck cares? It's one of this generations greatest bands playing Pink Floyd and doing a decent job at it. Just because a person has different vocal ranges doesn't mean the music is different.
:o this cover is GREAT. Anthony Green is epic on this song. Circa Survive are so good. This obviously isn\t as good as the original, cos its Pink Floyd, and they can only do their songs perfect, but for a cover this is pretty spot on. This cover does it for me.
i saw his bear vs shark shirt and got SO excited. absolutely love and miss those musicians. probably cause both bands were associated with equal vision at some point. anyways awesome bands, tight cover.
@mazterson I'm 17, don't do any drugs of any sort, and listen to pink floyd almost daily. There is no such thing as a cover being better than an original, but i do agree that this one comes damn close.
so im a big Circa fan, and a big Pink Floyd fan too.. when i clicked on this i expected it to not be a good cover just kuz the original is so amazing. but SHIT!! Anthony n the boys killed it! fucking amazing!
@BretCoalition Couldn't agree more. I mean these songs are really complicated to play! The instruments all sound excellent with cool solos and guitar lines and let's not forget about the bass and drums... in other words, EVERYTHING in their music sounds great and works together well!
I'm sorry but who in their right mind would dislike this?!?!?! I feel horrible for the 28 poor souls that disliked this.... they probably like justin beiber...
boobins hahahah omg u made me laugh so hard.. u made my day... pink floyd has over 10million views just in one of his songs.n guess wich one it is?... n i know somebody is probably gonna say views dont mean anything but views mean talent. he has so many views because he has talent n thats what people like..
how i wishh, how i wishh you were here. we're just two lost souls swimming in a fishbowl year after yearr. runningg over the samee old ground. what have we found?' the same old fearss wishh you were here.
I'm not putting Mr.Green down, although I have heard him do better, in my honest, humble opinion. Don't get me wrong though. I totally idolize this man :)
Hrm. I am only just beginning to listen to this band, but I actually appreciate that Green recognizes his own voice well enough to tweak the bits that I'm ready to cringe at--because they don't fit at his register--and make them work properly for his voice. It's not different to be different, it's different to fit his voice. (That said, I was cringing at the fail-some rhythm guitar..)
I agree with you about liking the power that comes from Anthony's voice, but that's not really what this song is about. I think his toned-down style here fits very appropriately. I've heard this song a few times but this is the first time I've seen the video for it. In my opinion, it's one of the better Pink Floyd covers I've heard/seen.
Still coming back in 2024 for this
Someone said something about Anthony being one of the few real vocal talents today.
The thing is, he's more than just that. His vocals are amazing, his lyrics have true meaning, he puts his heart and soul into what he makes, and he enjoys the music. He's not just performing for fame and money, that's just a byproduct for him.
And that's why I think he's one of the few great artists of our time.
2021 and I still love this with all of my heart
Pink Floyd would admire this cover
I've been homeless but I never felt so far from home... this song helps bringing it here
Heard the cover on SNL and immediately thought of this. I love how the guitar is allowed to show through and shine in this instead of being relegated to accompaniment.
Mistakes are proof that a musician is real... proof that they don't need to hide behind a wall of studio makeup... this is absolutely why I love Circa... they may not be what some consider "the best"as I do... but they can't be denied the award of the most honest band in the industry.
2 of my favorite bands that go so beautifully together
anthony green is amazing. circa is by far my favorite band. i was a fan of ants ever since Jeer at rome, and i knew he was going to be great one day. now him and the addition of all the amazing musicians and his bandmates in circa make the best band ever.
so beautifully done. keeps me coming back to listen year after year
This is truely amazing, my favorite classic band, and my man Mr. Green combined into one soothing flow of medicality.
what a perfect band circa survive is. everything they do musically is breath taking
I really like this. I really like that the guys seem really into it... and Im one of those 30 yr old guys that smokes alot and listens to Floyd...but Circa is hands down one of the best bands to come out in the last decade!! Other than The Mars Volta!!
Anthony Green is the man.
This is the most amazing cover yet.
Now this is what real talent is.
Circa Survive is truly amazing :)
wish you were here is one of my all time favourites, so far this only second cover that ive thought worthy of listening to. well done
It'll never get old.
Man i could just chill to this song over and over
wow my wish came true!!!!
i once thought about what would anthony green would sound if he sang "wish you where here"
by pink floyd,i never thought he would actually do it,wow just wow!!
i love this song :}!!
one of my favorite bands covering a song by another one of my favorite bands. Awesome.
I LOVE LOVE LOVE CIRCA SURVIVE!!!
I wasn't expecting this to be so good. I'm impressed.
Is because of videos like this that I still believe that TH-cam is worth it.
THIS IS AMAZING. 10/10 would listen again!!
I'm a fan of the coverers and the coveries and I have to say, pretty good cover. I really liked it. They managed to make it a little mellower than the original, and it was still cool. Thanks for the upload.
This is my all time favorite song... and i must say, Circa Survive, excellent work. You did this song very well.
This song was already very well
this guy is awesome! and i LOVE his voice !
this is fantastic in everyway
Such a great cover...just simply amazing.
I'm glad I found this. Circa Survive ❤️
Pink Floyd never get old!
Circa Survive covering Pink Floyd... My life is complete.
coming from a big floyd fan, this is a pretty amazing cover.
Who the fuck cares? It's one of this generations greatest bands playing Pink Floyd and doing a decent job at it. Just because a person has different vocal ranges doesn't mean the music is different.
this song is absolutely amazing! there cover is awesome!
fantasmical, Anthony Green never fails me
I didn't know that Tony hawk used to play lead Guitar with circa jajaja
Roberto Barron lol thats my friend brendan!
@@reflect9032 if he saw this would he say oh look that's my friend Alvaro clarifying I'm not Tony hawk??? If not friend may be a strong word.
I love the way he laughs as the song starts.
its great. a great band doing a great song.
"Cuz we really like it" Ant Green kinda looks like Chris Joslin
I love Anthony's voice so much !!!! 3
shed a tear everytime
simply amazing
god, Circa Survive is amazing.
ugh, anyway, this is really nice.
I love CS so much :( they're my favorite band of All Time.
:o this cover is GREAT. Anthony Green is epic on this song. Circa Survive are so good. This obviously isn\t as good as the original, cos its Pink Floyd, and they can only do their songs perfect, but for a cover this is pretty spot on. This cover does it for me.
i love this .
Hot damn I love these guys
love circa survive
Ohhhhh goodness. Love.
Me and my significant other did acid together around the time of me showing them this song.. 2020 and the other years were fun..
i saw his bear vs shark shirt and got SO excited. absolutely love and miss those musicians. probably cause both bands were associated with equal vision at some point. anyways awesome bands, tight cover.
2024 and still so good.
@mazterson I'm 17, don't do any drugs of any sort, and listen to pink floyd almost daily. There is no such thing as a cover being better than an original, but i do agree that this one comes damn close.
amazing musicians.
I love the original Pink floyd version, but anthony and his guys did a fantastic job! Just good music man. Fucking awesome
This needs a new comment. Love it.
such a brilliant cover
thanks :)
Agreed covers are basically your interpenetration of the song being released :P
haha every skaters dream who likes anthony to hear this freaking song AMAZING!
perfect
with you were here C.B.
Man I'm usually so good with grammar too. Thanks for catching that. One love bredda.
This is an excellent cover.
amazing.
Well done - really good!
pink floyd yeah! cool glasses anthony
This song inspired miracle sun.
so im a big Circa fan, and a big Pink Floyd fan too.. when i clicked on this i expected it to not be a good cover just kuz the original is so amazing.
but SHIT!! Anthony n the boys killed it!
fucking amazing!
i really like it!!!!
they didnt break up.. theyre working on a new cd right now. no lie my friends. you can ask them or go on that twitter place.
@BretCoalition Couldn't agree more. I mean these songs are really complicated to play! The instruments all sound excellent with cool solos and guitar lines and let's not forget about the bass and drums... in other words, EVERYTHING in their music sounds great and works together well!
i cant decide what i like better: anthony green's high range or mid range voice. bottom line: both are epic sounding
best comment i have seen on youtube in months
good stuff. they did a great job with it :)
amazing cover! dont be hatin on anthony green!!
I'm sorry but who in their right mind would dislike this?!?!?! I feel horrible for the 28 poor souls that disliked this.... they probably like justin beiber...
the guitars sound awsome...
love those glasses
I love the Bear Vs Shark shirt. Those guys grew up right next to me.
dood bearvsshark shirt for the win!!! i saw them in a tiny basement about 8 years ago
cuz we really like it.
boobins hahahah omg u made me laugh so hard.. u made my day... pink floyd has over 10million views just in one of his songs.n guess wich one it is?... n i know somebody is probably gonna say views dont mean anything but views mean talent. he has so many views because he has talent n thats what people like..
colin's face when he messed up … haha awwh :/
@jgilmer Haha that's awesome man. Those are my two favorite bands right now.
great cover..
"cause we really like it" hahahahah
damn
i love acoustic songs
badass song :P
how i wishh,
how i wishh you were here.
we're just two lost souls swimming in a fishbowl
year after yearr. runningg over the samee old ground.
what have we found?'
the same old fearss
wishh you were here.
anthony green i love you more now
yup.
I'm not putting Mr.Green down, although I have heard him do better, in my honest, humble opinion. Don't get me wrong though. I totally idolize this man :)
I love this song. Even better with circa survive :)
B e a u t i f u l ! :)
Hrm. I am only just beginning to listen to this band, but I actually appreciate that Green recognizes his own voice well enough to tweak the bits that I'm ready to cringe at--because they don't fit at his register--and make them work properly for his voice.
It's not different to be different, it's different to fit his voice.
(That said, I was cringing at the fail-some rhythm guitar..)
I agree with you about liking the power that comes from Anthony's voice, but that's not really what this song is about. I think his toned-down style here fits very appropriately.
I've heard this song a few times but this is the first time I've seen the video for it. In my opinion, it's one of the better Pink Floyd covers I've heard/seen.
I belive Saosin was so much then circa when Anthony was in saosin.
saosin for ever.
saosin saosin saosin saosin.
we are circa survive and we smoke a lot of weed and i cant hide it
were circa survive, and uhhh, the cover song we picked was wish you were here ffrom pink floyd, uhh cuz we.. really like it
it might be because im rolling a little bit but i cried for a second