He is widely recognised by his peers. Also, you have to remember that the individual members of Rush are all so talented that being a member of the unchanged power trio lineup for four decades is a huge credit all by itself.
Thaty's what they said in an interview. They've played together for thirty years but are still best mates, leaving close one to another in Toronto (or is it Montreal ?), holding barbecues n'stuff…
@@pateris Alex & Geddy live not too far from each other in Toronto. Been band mates since '68. Neil (RIP) was the "new guy" on drums in ' 74. Toured together for 40 years. More consecutive gold & platinum albums than any other group, right after the Beatles & Rolling Stones. Lyrics always had meaning, no explicit profananity or sex in any of their songs. And the kicker that proves they're just genuine, decent Canadian guys.... they're still happily married to their high school sweethearts.
Neil Peart was a magician on the drums, and an extraordinary soul with an incredible gift for lyrics and storytelling. The world is lesser without him. The great moment in this video starts at the 2:06 point, where Geddy sings the epic line "one likes to believe in the freedom of music, but glittering prizes and endless compromises shatter the illusion of integrity." Behind him, Alex and Neil smile mischievously at each other as they share the inside joke: they are (finally) singing these lines at - of all places - the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the center of the establishment music industry that had improperly rejected them for so long. Living well is the best revenge - and Neil certainly did that for as long as his body would let him. RIP.
3 guys that sounds like 6 onstage. Boy, they sure don't make them like this anymore. Talent, hard work and decades of experience. Glad we have it here online; I fear we won't see the likes of these guys anytime soon.
nah man don't despair. The internet is spawning young people that were like these guys and now they can find all this and absorb it learn from it. We are going to get some great stuff because the Lives and music of great Bands like Rush exist in perpetuity and easily available for everyone. Maybe we never get another as good But Mona Lisa is just one brilliant piece of art we wont ever see it again but we saw a lot of art that was influenced by it.
When I wasn't even legal to get into a club, my brother invited me to the Agora in downtown Cleveland for a Monday night concert series they had featuring Rush. When we walked up to the door to get in, ( as my brother had met the sons owner in college) we were greeted by Cleveland s finest who said, "sorry buddy, we're sold out" as there was a long line of people waiting for the doors to open. My brothers friend shook hands with the cop, the lady in the ticket window stamped our hands with out money or id's, and we walked right in. We went right up to the stage, took the table closest to the stage, as the place had not even opened, and was ABSOLUTELY BLOWN AWAY, not to mentioned deafened as they played their entire debut album. My ears range for 3 days afterwards, and I have been a die hard fan ever since. Incredible talent and a sound and history others can only dream of. I miss them. RIP Neil.
Check out Yoyoka Soma. She does a cover of YYZ along with many others ranging from Led Zeppelin to The Stray Cats. Oh BTW, she’s 10 years old and has cover videos from when she was 7.
At 62 NOW and a spoiled middle -class growing up in the 70's with everything rock & roll from Alice Cooper to Peter Frampton, from Led Zeppelin to Queen jus naming a few...knowing I have been Literatured & Cultured in Music as a child from Opera to Classicals... eventually spreading my wings from my father's persuasion's...I have critique rock & roll for years now...and have concluded that The Number One Rock Band The one real -deal rock'n and roll'n of them ALL is none other than this 3piece band from Toronto Canada with each individual player just an incredible rare skill & talent -RUSH..and if you don't believe me..allow me to ask of you too listen to just one of many of their songs called WORKING MAN.. AND I CHALLENGE YOU TO FIND A MORE ROCK'N & ROLLING SONG THAN THIS!!..
I love this band so much that I quit countless jobs and went to see them 105 times starting with moving pictures at the Philadelphia spectrum all the way until the last show in Inglewood. My only regret is that I wasted so much money on food and shelter instead of going to more RUSH concerts 😳
Words that have even more meaning today, "One likes to believe In the freedom of music But glittering prizes And endless compromises Shatter the illusion Of integrity." - Peart (1980)
I will die a RUSH fan. These three guy's have meant SO much to me over the past 40+ years. It was a SPECTACULAR Journey they took me on. I thank my Sister Astrid that is no longer with us. For Pulling out an album in 1981 called Moving Pictures and placing it on her turntable for me to listen. I was instantly intrigued. SO MUCH LOVE for Neil, Alex and Geddy.
1978. My next duty station after Korea was Ft. Bragg, NC. After a 35 day home leave, I packed up my car and headed to NC. Got to my living quarters and unpacked my audio gear. My albums were unpacked. I went through to make sure I got 'em all. In the stack was my little brothers album RUSH 2112. Never heard of them. What the hell, I'll play it. After about 3 minutes I'm saying who the hell are these guys? Needless to say, I was hooked. I only saw 25 concerts. However, I got to see a fresh performance of La Villa Strangiato. Wow. By far, my favorite band.
One of the amazing things about this band is they always look like they are playing within the comfort zone of their abilities. It’s just that their abilities far exceed those of mere mortals…
Last time I saw Rush playing live was back in 2013 at Festival d’été de Québec and I remember clearly that the musicianship was outstanding, but that the vocals were hard to witness. I love Rush but I think they should have got a new singer at least for live performances many years ago. Ok Rush is a 3-men band but Geddy’s has aged and their early work is too hard (which is perfectly understandable). Some people age and remain able to sing their earlier stuff without too much trouble (thinking of Sting and Rodger Hodgson), but others can’t and it’s ok.
The production team melodyned it (tried to fix it) after the fact and badly mangled the vocal. I’ve recorded vocals for years on various projects, so I know the sound of these bad melodyne jobs. Someone was incredibly lazy in the mix down office and completely destroyed this one. Geddy most certainly sounded much better than this at the actual show.
@@photoniccannon2117 I just told you that he does not lol. He has aged and he cannot sing his work from the early albums, it's perfectly understandable. That's all. No magic, no trickery, no wrong mix.
@@Ogilla I don’t disagree with you my friend. Just sharing the results of my own research and my experiences with these tools. I have likewise noticed that Geddy’s voice has definitely changed, but it sounds quite different on their own DVDs than it does here. This particular video was was the HOF’s production team and was very likely not managed by Rush. This is probably not something Rush or their producers would have ever done themselves. And like you, I cut him slack as well. He maintained most of his range all the way to the very end. It’s impossible to maintain his 30’s level physical stamina all the way into his 60s. He did an impressive job given his age, but nobody could deny he’s had more trouble these days than in the past. And you said it well. It’s totally understandable. Geddy still did better than many other rock singers his age, and for that we give him credit and cut him slack on the rest. (He was a phenomenal singer really. Never got the credit he deserved for it.) But with tools like Melodyne, they are VERY common in the industry and at minimum, 80-90% of the songs on the radio have used them. These tools have a characteristic sound if misused. We are quite used to hearing it so we don’t easily notice the artifacts anymore, but the very rapid pitch shifts and shadow notes (the underwater feeling) is VERY characteristic of Melodyne. Rush was unusual in that they did not use magic for his vocals or treat them. Most bands can’t say the same. Essentially, these tools try to detect two things: pitch and formant. But singers never hit a note dead on, and they never transition without a ramp up to the new note. As a result, the detection algorithms have to have parameters on how quickly they will jump to a new note. If this timing is too fast, it sounds artificial and robotic. If it’s too slow, it doesn’t do any corrections. This is why a lot of manual input is required when using these tools, and it’s how they can sound so transparent and totally invisible. But it literally has to be done by hand for good results. (I’ve had to correct some pretty bad vocals before. A professional could probably elaborate better than I could, but safe to say, it’s definitely tedious.) It sounds like what happened here was that someone didn’t do this process manually and relied on the built algorithms to try to detect the original and “correct” notes. When it thinks it detects a note and it’s off from the root/correct pitch, it will try to correct it in place, and it also shifts the formant while it’s at it (making the note sound “deeper” or “higher” as if it was sung at that actual pitch. It does this seamlessly if it’s correcting to the right pitch, but has some pretty funny-sounding results if the algorithm is wrong.) But when these notes are detected in a choppy way without manual input, the algorithm is always trying to force notes that aren’t actually incorrect into places that they aren’t supposed to be. And while it’s at it, it does so very fast, often bouncing rapidly between several notes before actually settling. And it even tries to correct the “ramp up” transitions between notes. These ramp up transitions are where the washy underwater feeling comes from. It’s trying to force a note where there is none. And it can totally mangle an otherwise decent vocal because those transitions aren’t actually natural. The end result is that very characteristic strained, glassy, washed out/underwater sounding vocal. That’s exactly what seems to have happened here. It’s very different from the sound of their official DVDs or any of their live shows (or anything Rush themselves ever released). But I have to give Rush immense credit. They stayed away from these tools and released honest live albums even into their 60s. It’s rare in the industry. I respect it and have always enjoyed Geddy’s vocals. The only album where production ever really used these tools was TM (you can hear the difference from the cellphone recordings vs. the DVD. They weren’t overdubbed. They were just treated properly.) I have a feeling that the rock and roll hall of fame producers probably did this one. this whole thing doesn’t sound like something Rush would do. I have to say it’s still phenomenal recording/video. And it’s Rush. Any rush show is always over the top. Best regards my friend, and cheers to a fellow Rush fan.
@@nahiyanalamgir7056 you sir are wrong, they didnt use autotune in the 80s, as it was invented in 1997, they did have CD and audio recordings enhanced before they hit the markets. They have stated that they don't use it.
Goosebumps watching this. They are so awesome! There will never be anyone like Rush...3 Canadian guys with a set of drums and 2 guitars...wow what they could do!!! Just THE GREATEST! RIP NEIL, you are so missed.❤
The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame invited me to watch this video called “Spirit of the Radio”. Here, it’s closer, listed as “Spirit of Radio”. Sigh. Rush is too good for you. I enjoyed watching “The Spirit of Radio” again.
Rush should have been inducted long before 2013. They were consummate professional lyricists and musicians. Somehow they kept the creative juices alive over four decades of musical change. Kudos to excellence.
I was 17 when I first heard this and 40 years later I love it even more now, our music keeps us young inside regardless of what we look like on the outside.
You can listen to there music 50 years from now and it still will sound fresh. This music you will still able to listen to it and never get tired of it
You mean right as Ged was singing the line that Neil wrote, "But glittering prizes and endless compromises shatter the illusion of integrity"? At the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame? While they were getting inducted? After years of being ignored by the Rock and Roll hall of fame and Rolling Stone? I love these guys, just the best band ever.
That’s actually kind of funny geddy does the clap thing and than seems to kinda remember “oh yeah this isn’t our usual concert with like 50,000 hardcore rush fans” ....
Rush played my high school... with John Rutsey back in 1975ish... I missed them. Luckily got to see them New Years Eve 1978 at Maple Leaf Gardens. Killer show. Still see Geddy at the ballpark... Skydome (pre-COVID) from time to time...
@2:15 My favorite part of the performance. Neil and Alex just being friends on stage, finding humor in something we'll never know, but it doesn't matter. They're having a blast, and it shows, still after all those years. So endearing!
@@482jpsquared "878787random 7 months ago (edited) Neil Peart was a magician on the drums, and an extraordinary soul with an incredible gift for lyrics and storytelling. The world is lesser without him. The great moment in this video starts at the 2:06 point, where Geddy sings the epic line "one likes to believe in the freedom of music, but glittering prizes and endless compromises shatter the illusion of integrity." Behind him, Alex and Neil smile mischievously at each other as they share the inside joke: they are (finally) singing these lines at - of all places - the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the center of the establishment music industry that had improperly rejected them for so long. Living well is the best revenge - and Neil certainly did that for as long as his body would let him. RIP.
Right on. The only reason I even watch these RRHOF videos is because they commemorate Rush giving the finger to the machine. Alex Lifeson's acceptance speech was exactly what the HOF deserved.
I've been a RUSH fan since 2112. Being a drummer in the 1970s - 80s was an awesome time to learn from a lot of talented drummers but Neil Peart was the highest challenge to be able to pull off his drum fills and timing. Congrats to these 3 brothers! I'm so glad they were finally recognized for their professional musicianship and their brand of rock n roll.
Dude... At 3:09 Geddy goes to Alex his best bud and is like " voice ain't what it used to be 😒" but Alex just looks at him and is like, " you got this dude. Keep going. 💪" I effing love this band. Best band mates anyone could ask for.
My two boys grew up listening to Rush as I played air drums with their little arms to their uncontrollable giggles. Their first concert was my last concert. Time Machine tour 10 years ago next week I believe. They met me for dinner last week and I hear Digital Man Live pumping in the air before I could even see his truck. Proud Pops. Sucks we'll never hear the fruits of their creativity again, but damn glad we got to enjoy the group as long as we did. Thank you gentlemen. RIP Neil.
"All this machinery making modern music can still be open-hearted." This class also had Heart, Public Enemy, Donna Summer, Randy Newman & more. You may not like these other genres or acts, but Rush literally sings about appreciating the creative journey. It's OK to dislike an artist without discounting their vision.
Five decades of not just staying together, but making awesome music the whole time! RIP Neil Peart. Thank you for being a part of our lives for so long.
I can still recall that moment, coming home from the record store and dropping the needle on Permanent Waves for the very first time. What an incredible way to kick off an album. An intro riff that, imo, doesn't get nearly the recognition it deserves. It's up there with every other iconic riff throughout rock history.
For a long time I thought it was Neil's performance on this song that really made it. But then, as I got older, I really appreciated Alex's performance. Later still, I saw how Geddy's playing was so key to this song. Watching them live ... it's so clear that all of them are unbelievably good musicians. I don't care much for Geddy's vocal performance here. But the music ... hoochie mamma, is it good.
You got to give the old geezer credit where it's due. Geddy's ONLY 60 years old at the time, 33 years after the song was released. Sure he's not as good as he was, but he's as least as good as you and I never were, and this was a good performance nonetheless. Instrumentality of all three was stellar, almost as good as the original studio recording we all love. KC fan Retro B said it... ..."Rush kicks ass"
"For the words of the profits were written on the studio wall Concert hall" i love it when everybody screams. Gave me the chills! lol just like the record! great performance! RUSH FOREVER! LOVE AND MISS YOU NEIL!
A reworking of a line from The Sound Of Silence by Simon & Garfunkel that said: "And the sign said, "The words of the prophets are written on the subway walls And tenement halls" And whispered in the sound of silence"
I just started dating a man who is a huge Rush fan. I never heard of them before he mentioned them (Don't shame me) but to think of what I've been missing this whole time !!! Thank you marshmelito 😘
Respect to the Foo Fighters to have inducted Rush into the RRHF Was hoping this would have occured a couple of decades ago..but hey, so glad that Neil was still with us to receive this award!
Everyone in that theatre was taught a lesson in musicianship that night.
I seriously don't think Alex Lifeson was ever given enough credit for it ability.
He could make the guitar talk
He is recognized by other guitarists as one of the greats.
Only from people who doesn't know shit about music
I totally agree
He is widely recognised by his peers. Also, you have to remember that the individual members of Rush are all so talented that being a member of the unchanged power trio lineup for four decades is a huge credit all by itself.
The 80s would not have been the 80s without these guys
My God they were good. If they were any tighter they'd snap. Best friends until the end.
Thaty's what they said in an interview. They've played together for thirty years but are still best mates, leaving close one to another in Toronto (or is it Montreal ?), holding barbecues n'stuff…
They stayed normal people til the end yet played like something out of this world
even death doesn't change that........
@@pateris Alex & Geddy live not too far from each other in Toronto. Been band mates since '68. Neil (RIP) was the "new guy" on drums in ' 74. Toured together for 40 years. More consecutive gold & platinum albums than any other group, right after the Beatles & Rolling Stones. Lyrics always had meaning, no explicit profananity or sex in any of their songs. And the kicker that proves they're just genuine, decent Canadian guys.... they're still happily married to their high school sweethearts.
@@nobodyimportant6851 And they have a good sense of humour too !
Neil Peart was a magician on the drums, and an extraordinary soul with an incredible gift for lyrics and storytelling. The world is lesser without him. The great moment in this video starts at the 2:06 point, where Geddy sings the epic line "one likes to believe in the freedom of music, but glittering prizes and endless compromises shatter the illusion of integrity." Behind him, Alex and Neil smile mischievously at each other as they share the inside joke: they are (finally) singing these lines at - of all places - the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the center of the establishment music industry that had improperly rejected them for so long. Living well is the best revenge - and Neil certainly did that for as long as his body would let him. RIP.
OMG, I hadn't caught that previously! Thanks for pointing it out. Makes this performance all the better for that moment.
Ha! I'm glad I read this comment before that point came up.
Beautifully put. Living well is the best revenge.
Thank you. This was the most genius band of all time indeed
Perfectly put , thanks for helping more people become aware of what we all had !
Been listening to Rush for close to 40 years and I still shake my head and go "Holy Fuck"
The best song ever written about the power of music. Fucking hell do I fucking love these three wonderful men.
Indeed!
So do I, and I usually dislike prog !!!
three of the best musicians rush rules forever rest in heaven mr peart miss your wonderful lyrics and drumming
ABSOLUTELY!!! Been listening to them since early 80's.
Magic Power by their Canadian brothers Triumph ain't to shabby either.
Just glad we have video of these guys together. 😢
Drummers ...take note. Neil LOOKS at what exactly he is striking. Such focus and intensity....RIP Professor .
I agree ... Neil rules !!! ... Master !!
It was nice to see him grinning at some inside joke with Alex at about 2:15 or so. A less serious moment. Still miss him.
@@brianball6670 It's what Ged's singing at the moment, in the context of the venue. =D
@@LincolnCrisler Ahh! Good point!
Simply the greatest of all time RIP Neil
3 guys that sounds like 6 onstage. Boy, they sure don't make them like this anymore. Talent, hard work and decades of experience. Glad we have it here online; I fear we won't see the likes of these guys anytime soon.
Yep, we never will again unfortunately. I know Neil is rockin it up in Heaven.
nah man don't despair. The internet is spawning young people that were like these guys and now they can find all this and absorb it learn from it. We are going to get some great stuff because the Lives and music of great Bands like Rush exist in perpetuity and easily available for everyone. Maybe we never get another as good But Mona Lisa is just one brilliant piece of art we wont ever see it again but we saw a lot of art that was influenced by it.
This is what I LOVE about Rush. It's a 3 man team putting out this incredible sound.
and you won't find three men with more love and respect for each other either.
@@Conn30Mtenor and what music we are all stuck with
In few words: "Thanks Neil Peart, Alex Lifeson and Geddy Lee"
Have to admit these guys are truly amazing.
When I wasn't even legal to get into a club, my brother invited me to the Agora in downtown Cleveland for a Monday night concert series they had featuring Rush. When we walked up to the door to get in, ( as my brother had met the sons owner in college) we were greeted by Cleveland s finest who said, "sorry buddy, we're sold out" as there was a long line of people waiting for the doors to open. My brothers friend shook hands with the cop, the lady in the ticket window stamped our hands with out money or id's, and we walked right in. We went right up to the stage, took the table closest to the stage, as the place had not even opened, and was ABSOLUTELY BLOWN AWAY, not to mentioned deafened as they played their entire debut album. My ears range for 3 days afterwards, and I have been a die hard fan ever since. Incredible talent and a sound and history others can only dream of. I miss them.
RIP Neil.
Every time I watch this
My eyes water
I am so proud to be a Canadian and live in the time of Rush
You don’t need to be Canadian to appreciate Rush. Somewhat proud American who credits Rush for making life a little easier
@@jims2987 well said my friend.
@@jims2987same! Lolz 🤘🏼✨🤘🏼♥️♥️🔥🔥🔥🔥
Im Mexican and also I Feel Proud to be Rush Fan!!
watch justin bieber and see how proud you are lol i am kiddin
That was tight AF.
In my opinion, one of the greatest songs ever written. Lyrics, music, playing, and production all top notch.
2:18 That smile on Neil when Geddy sings ".....shatters the illusion of integrity", and the whole RRHOF deal, says it all.
Playing this song right there is irony in overdrive
I think they're just enjoying the music there, but the lyrics still rung true
They knew exactly what they were doing by plying this song. It was a great FU to the higher ups of the music industry.
@@ericwyatt3646Love the Born Again profile pic
Pure Awesome.
Two master technical musicians with the greatest drummer that walked this planet.
Check out Yoyoka Soma. She does a cover of YYZ along with many others ranging from Led Zeppelin to The Stray Cats. Oh BTW, she’s 10 years old and has cover videos from when she was 7.
Second greatest, John Bonham is #1.
Yep!.
@Sugar Shane whose the third?
@@lisahill3749 Keith Moon...
At 62 NOW and a spoiled middle -class growing up in the 70's with everything rock & roll from Alice Cooper to Peter Frampton, from Led Zeppelin to Queen jus naming a few...knowing I have been Literatured & Cultured in Music as a child from Opera to Classicals... eventually spreading my wings from my father's persuasion's...I have critique rock & roll for years now...and have concluded that The Number One Rock Band The one real -deal rock'n and roll'n of them ALL is none other than this 3piece band from Toronto Canada with each individual player just an incredible rare skill & talent -RUSH..and if you don't believe me..allow me to ask of you too listen to just one of many of their songs called WORKING MAN.. AND I CHALLENGE YOU TO FIND A MORE ROCK'N & ROLLING SONG THAN THIS!!..
👍🇨🇦
First concert i ever saw in 1982. rush Hollywood Sportatorium, Hollywood Florida. Thank you Geddy, Alex & Neil for everything.
R.I.P Neil Peart
The master of the art of percussion.
I love this band so much that I quit countless jobs and went to see them 105 times starting with moving pictures at the Philadelphia spectrum all the way until the last show in Inglewood. My only regret is that I wasted so much money on food and shelter instead of going to more RUSH concerts 😳
Relatable!
I saw them at The Spectrum two times- Power Windows and Grace Under Pressure. Absolutely wish I had seen them more times. Life always got in the way.
Words that have even more meaning today, "One likes to believe In the freedom of music But glittering prizes And endless compromises Shatter the illusion Of integrity." - Peart (1980)
1979
and it echoes in the sound of salesmen
@@BobSmith-mg6iz I mean, the album came out on January 1st, 1980, but I guess 1979 is TECHNICALLY correct lol
@@bmxboxter Written in 79, tour started in 79. Saw them play it in Chicago August 1979.
Yes,
they HAD to play this song at this ceremony.
Freedom of Music!
The holy Trinity of Rock. 3of the best musicians to ever pick up instruments
A trio at the top of the game and such a unique sound...So glad there in the HOF and the should have been there a lot sooner!!!
That bass tone is 🔥
I will die a RUSH fan. These three guy's have meant SO much to me over the past 40+ years. It was a SPECTACULAR Journey they took me on. I thank my Sister Astrid that is no longer with us. For Pulling out an album in 1981 called Moving Pictures and placing it on her turntable for me to listen. I was instantly intrigued. SO MUCH LOVE for Neil, Alex and Geddy.
🙏amen.
Ask my oldest;
Desiree Nicole RUSH Boehm, what they meant to me.
What's a turntable??? Imma Gen Z'er...
1978. My next duty station after Korea was Ft. Bragg, NC. After a 35 day home leave, I packed up my car and headed to NC. Got to my living quarters and unpacked my audio gear. My albums were unpacked. I went through to make sure I got 'em all. In the stack was my little brothers album RUSH 2112. Never heard of them. What the hell, I'll play it. After about 3 minutes I'm saying who the hell are these guys? Needless to say, I was hooked. I only saw 25 concerts. However, I got to see a fresh performance of La Villa Strangiato. Wow. By far, my favorite band.
i was 12 when the first time i heard this song from cassette player in my brother's bed room, 35 yrs later still listening until today
2:14 Neil looking at Alex during the "glittering prizes" part is priceless. Miss him so much!
One of the amazing things about this band is they always look like they are playing within the comfort zone of their abilities. It’s just that their abilities far exceed those of mere mortals…
The years obviously put an strain on Ged’s voice but right up til the end they were at the top of their game musically.
Can you imagine Geddy trying to sing Fly by night or even Bastille Day.
Last time I saw Rush playing live was back in 2013 at Festival d’été de Québec and I remember clearly that the musicianship was outstanding, but that the vocals were hard to witness.
I love Rush but I think they should have got a new singer at least for live performances many years ago. Ok Rush is a 3-men band but Geddy’s has aged and their early work is too hard (which is perfectly understandable).
Some people age and remain able to sing their earlier stuff without too much trouble (thinking of Sting and Rodger Hodgson), but others can’t and it’s ok.
The production team melodyned it (tried to fix it) after the fact and badly mangled the vocal. I’ve recorded vocals for years on various projects, so I know the sound of these bad melodyne jobs. Someone was incredibly lazy in the mix down office and completely destroyed this one. Geddy most certainly sounded much better than this at the actual show.
@@photoniccannon2117 I just told you that he does not lol. He has aged and he cannot sing his work from the early albums, it's perfectly understandable. That's all. No magic, no trickery, no wrong mix.
@@Ogilla I don’t disagree with you my friend. Just sharing the results of my own research and my experiences with these tools. I have likewise noticed that Geddy’s voice has definitely changed, but it sounds quite different on their own DVDs than it does here. This particular video was was the HOF’s production team and was very likely not managed by Rush. This is probably not something Rush or their producers would have ever done themselves.
And like you, I cut him slack as well. He maintained most of his range all the way to the very end. It’s impossible to maintain his 30’s level physical stamina all the way into his 60s. He did an impressive job given his age, but nobody could deny he’s had more trouble these days than in the past. And you said it well. It’s totally understandable. Geddy still did better than many other rock singers his age, and for that we give him credit and cut him slack on the rest. (He was a phenomenal singer really. Never got the credit he deserved for it.)
But with tools like Melodyne, they are VERY common in the industry and at minimum, 80-90% of the songs on the radio have used them. These tools have a characteristic sound if misused. We are quite used to hearing it so we don’t easily notice the artifacts anymore, but the very rapid pitch shifts and shadow notes (the underwater feeling) is VERY characteristic of Melodyne. Rush was unusual in that they did not use magic for his vocals or treat them. Most bands can’t say the same.
Essentially, these tools try to detect two things: pitch and formant. But singers never hit a note dead on, and they never transition without a ramp up to the new note. As a result, the detection algorithms have to have parameters on how quickly they will jump to a new note. If this timing is too fast, it sounds artificial and robotic. If it’s too slow, it doesn’t do any corrections. This is why a lot of manual input is required when using these tools, and it’s how they can sound so transparent and totally invisible. But it literally has to be done by hand for good results. (I’ve had to correct some pretty bad vocals before. A professional could probably elaborate better than I could, but safe to say, it’s definitely tedious.)
It sounds like what happened here was that someone didn’t do this process manually and relied on the built algorithms to try to detect the original and “correct” notes. When it thinks it detects a note and it’s off from the root/correct pitch, it will try to correct it in place, and it also shifts the formant while it’s at it (making the note sound “deeper” or “higher” as if it was sung at that actual pitch. It does this seamlessly if it’s correcting to the right pitch, but has some pretty funny-sounding results if the algorithm is wrong.) But when these notes are detected in a choppy way without manual input, the algorithm is always trying to force notes that aren’t actually incorrect into places that they aren’t supposed to be. And while it’s at it, it does so very fast, often bouncing rapidly between several notes before actually settling. And it even tries to correct the “ramp up” transitions between notes. These ramp up transitions are where the washy underwater feeling comes from. It’s trying to force a note where there is none. And it can totally mangle an otherwise decent vocal because those transitions aren’t actually natural.
The end result is that very characteristic strained, glassy, washed out/underwater sounding vocal. That’s exactly what seems to have happened here. It’s very different from the sound of their official DVDs or any of their live shows (or anything Rush themselves ever released).
But I have to give Rush immense credit. They stayed away from these tools and released honest live albums even into their 60s. It’s rare in the industry. I respect it and have always enjoyed Geddy’s vocals. The only album where production ever really used these tools was TM (you can hear the difference from the cellphone recordings vs. the DVD. They weren’t overdubbed. They were just treated properly.)
I have a feeling that the rock and roll hall of fame producers probably did this one. this whole thing doesn’t sound like something Rush would do. I have to say it’s still phenomenal recording/video. And it’s Rush. Any rush show is always over the top.
Best regards my friend, and cheers to a fellow Rush fan.
You know hearing geddy sing those high notes even tho he’s struggling and seeing Neil smile is just awesome
😭 I miss the Greatest Rock band EVER
3 people making all this music without autotune and tracks. Truly amazing.
They used some autotune in the 80s but this performance is raw.
@@nahiyanalamgir7056 you sir are wrong, they didnt use autotune in the 80s, as it was invented in 1997, they did have CD and audio recordings enhanced before they hit the markets. They have stated that they don't use it.
@@jamesjoy742 They used vocal enhancements and pitch correction I believe. I didn't mean autotune as an audio processor created in 1997; my bad.
Even in 2013 their playing live was sooooo tight, not a single misstep. Hearing Rush live was an experience that can't be replicated.
There music is all about the journey. Neil is finally home with his wife and daughter.
Love all the years you guys gave us.
Geddy pounding on that bass was AWESOME !!!! Each one was a master at their craft. Love it !!!! RIP Professor
Hands down the most talented rock group in HISTORY...RIp Neil.
That look from Neil to Alex when "glittering prizes" came along was priceless
Goosebumps watching this. They are so awesome! There will never be anyone like Rush...3 Canadian guys with a set of drums and 2 guitars...wow what they could do!!! Just THE GREATEST! RIP NEIL, you are so missed.❤
@João Piza bass guitar.....
You do know they're using some backing tracks here, right? Who's playing the piano at 4:34? Kind of disappointing.
@@Simonchez There are no backing tracks. Geddy is playing the "piano" with his right foot on the Taurus pedals (You can see it briefly at 4:40-4:41).
@@Simonchez dude! Getty plays keyboards and/or bass through a pedal. Alex will share some of the pedal duties too. They're the GOATS!
@João Piza sung*
The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame invited me to watch this video called “Spirit of the Radio”. Here, it’s closer, listed as “Spirit of Radio”. Sigh. Rush is too good for you. I enjoyed watching “The Spirit of Radio” again.
Rush has taught us to be perfectionists. Don't be messing song titles up, not with the Holy Triumvirate
You got that right!
Three 'Masters' of music. Proud to be Canadian! Rush at their finest!
Yep, this is one time you Canadians beat us Aussies, we had nothing quite like Rush.
Rush should have been inducted long before 2013. They were consummate professional lyricists and musicians. Somehow they kept the creative juices alive over four decades of musical change. Kudos to excellence.
I was 17 when I first heard this and 40 years later I love it even more now, our music keeps us young inside regardless of what we look like on the outside.
I remember first hearing Tom Sawyer in a delivery van I drove back then. It's was just released that day.
It's amazing how 3 people can make so much sound and make it badass!
Geddy's eyebrows never cease to put a smile on my face
My favorite Rush song
You can listen to there music 50 years from now and it still will sound fresh. This music you will still able to listen to it and never get tired of it
I love the look between Neil and Alex at 2:14, Neil's smile just lit up the room.
That was something special. I saw about 30 Rush concerts over the years and hardly remember ever seeing them do that.
I think they were amused at Geddy's voice. Other commenters said Geddy was singing with a cold. They were probably surprised he pulled it off. :)
You mean right as Ged was singing the line that Neil wrote, "But glittering prizes and endless compromises shatter the illusion of integrity"? At the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame? While they were getting inducted? After years of being ignored by the Rock and Roll hall of fame and Rolling Stone?
I love these guys, just the best band ever.
My God they were the epitome of the perfect rock group. They exceeded bling and pizzaz and captured the definition of Rock and Roll.
That’s actually kind of funny geddy does the clap thing and than seems to kinda remember “oh yeah this isn’t our usual concert with like 50,000 hardcore rush fans” ....
They had a one of a kind sound with Geddy on vocals and bass
Neil on drums and Alex on lead guitar
I will always love them ❤️
What made them legends was their dedication to their art & refusing to compromise, less then perfect was not an option.
Rush played my high school... with John Rutsey back in 1975ish... I missed them.
Luckily got to see them New Years Eve 1978 at Maple Leaf Gardens. Killer show.
Still see Geddy at the ballpark... Skydome (pre-COVID) from time to time...
I Love how Alex forms the guitar licks with his mouth!
Geddy Lee on bass is a beautiful vision to my eyes and a beautiful sound to my ears ....there's no better bassist out there !
@2:15 My favorite part of the performance. Neil and Alex just being friends on stage, finding humor in something we'll never know, but it doesn't matter. They're having a blast, and it shows, still after all those years. So endearing!
If you want to know what it is that they're smiling about, go to the top of the comments section. It's perfectly explained.
@@mtlnascarfan Can you point to that post? I can't find it.
@@482jpsquared
"878787random
7 months ago (edited)
Neil Peart was a magician on the drums, and an extraordinary soul with an incredible gift for lyrics and storytelling. The world is lesser without him. The great moment in this video starts at the 2:06 point, where Geddy sings the epic line "one likes to believe in the freedom of music, but glittering prizes and endless compromises shatter the illusion of integrity." Behind him, Alex and Neil smile mischievously at each other as they share the inside joke: they are (finally) singing these lines at - of all places - the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the center of the establishment music industry that had improperly rejected them for so long. Living well is the best revenge - and Neil certainly did that for as long as his body would let him. RIP.
Right on. The only reason I even watch these RRHOF videos is because they commemorate Rush giving the finger to the machine. Alex Lifeson's acceptance speech was exactly what the HOF deserved.
"Bearing a gift beyond price - almost free". Damn right
Rush is what it truly means to be a musician. Always evolving, never stopping, no room for ego
This is just one of the songs whenever I hear it, I just stop whatever I'm doing and just listen . A timeless classic.
That quick moment where Neil smiles... my god. I never teared up so fast. RIP Professor. Thanks for all the words and music.
no one more deserving of the hall of fame then the greatest 3 man Canadian band ever
but is the HoF deserving of THEM? 🤔
Doesnt mattter they were Canadian, the greatest 3 man band ever !!!
Those three dudes could make one hell of a an amazing amount of excellent rock and roll music for sure! RIP Neal Peart.
man these guys are so badass seriously
The rock and roll hall of fame should be honoured they bothered to acknowledge it ;)
Damn right
This performance had every bit of spirit and energy from each fan behind all those Hollywood folks. Perfect gentlemen absolutely perfect 💖💖💖🙏🇺🇸
Rush is a very otherworldly group of guys with a kismet connection that could never be stopped . If there ever could be perfection this is it. ✌👍🌹
I miss RUSH.RIP NP.ILL NEVER FORGET ABOUT YOU. THE MAN ,THE GENIUS.
I've been a RUSH fan since 2112. Being a drummer in the 1970s - 80s was an awesome time to learn from a lot of talented drummers but Neil Peart was the highest challenge to be able to pull off his drum fills and timing. Congrats to these 3 brothers! I'm so glad they were finally recognized for their professional musicianship and their brand of rock n roll.
Hard to believe that Neil’s gone.
Hard to believe we lost two Grandmasters. Eddie Van Halen in the same year. 2020 sucked.
Damn, that was good. So precise, soulful, and flat-out entertaining. Rock n roll performed at the highest level here, folks...
Dude... At 3:09 Geddy goes to Alex his best bud and is like " voice ain't what it used to be 😒" but Alex just looks at him and is like, " you got this dude. Keep going. 💪" I effing love this band. Best band mates anyone could ask for.
The genius of them playing this song at this moment...👏🏼
My two boys grew up listening to Rush as I played air drums with their little arms to their uncontrollable giggles. Their first concert was my last concert. Time Machine tour 10 years ago next week I believe.
They met me for dinner last week and I hear Digital Man Live pumping in the air before I could even see his truck. Proud Pops.
Sucks we'll never hear the fruits of their creativity again, but damn glad we got to enjoy the group as long as we did. Thank you gentlemen. RIP Neil.
Best band I had the privilege to see live, 13x, without a doubt the best percussionist ever.
Even though I'm a southerner there's a lot I admire and enjoy from Canada this power trio being among all that glad they're our neighbors and allies
Geddy is as energetic as ever. He and Alex in combo is fun times 100
So many pieces to a Rush tune. Such a powerful performance for a trio live on TV. Reminded how frickin good these guys were.
They had the thrill of being the only genuine thing in the room.
Them and their wives. The RUSH ladies are pure class
"All this machinery making modern music can still be open-hearted."
This class also had Heart, Public Enemy, Donna Summer, Randy Newman & more. You may not like these other genres or acts, but Rush literally sings about appreciating the creative journey. It's OK to dislike an artist without discounting their vision.
Every bit as good as they where in the beginning, if not better!! True talent
These 3 amazingly talented souls have filled the world with wonderful music.
Lotta love on that stage and it shows in the heart of the performance
Greatest rock trio of all time so advanced they will never be duplicated ever
What I love about Rush is they did what they wanted and gave the finger to the establishment. You can't argue with success.
Five decades of not just staying together, but making awesome music the whole time! RIP Neil Peart.
Thank you for being a part of our lives for so long.
I can still recall that moment, coming home from the record store and dropping the needle on Permanent Waves for the very first time. What an incredible way to kick off an album. An intro riff that, imo, doesn't get nearly the recognition it deserves. It's up there with every other iconic riff throughout rock history.
GENIUS...
PERFECTION...
These gentlemen showed everyone...
HOW
ITS
DONE.
RIP Neil
I love the intro for this song
What a freaking great band. Just a great, great band.
For a long time I thought it was Neil's performance on this song that really made it. But then, as I got older, I really appreciated Alex's performance. Later still, I saw how Geddy's playing was so key to this song. Watching them live ... it's so clear that all of them are unbelievably good musicians. I don't care much for Geddy's vocal performance here. But the music ... hoochie mamma, is it good.
You got to give the old geezer credit where it's due. Geddy's ONLY 60 years old at the time, 33 years after the song was released. Sure he's not as good as he was, but he's as least as good as you and I never were, and this was a good performance nonetheless.
Instrumentality of all three was stellar, almost as good as the original studio recording we all love. KC fan Retro B said it...
..."Rush kicks ass"
"For the words of the profits were written on the studio wall
Concert hall" i love it when everybody screams. Gave me the chills! lol just like the record! great performance! RUSH FOREVER! LOVE AND MISS YOU NEIL!
A reworking of a line from The Sound Of Silence by Simon & Garfunkel that said:
"And the sign said, "The words of the prophets are written on the subway walls And tenement halls"
And whispered in the sound of silence"
I'm glad Neil got to live to see this honor, God bless you Neil rest in peace
These guys always worked so hard. I'm an old man now, but RUSH played at my high school before they got famous. It was AWESOME.
The best band ever...I've loved Rush since day one...3 magic musicians ....r.i.p. Neal
Honestly I'm just blessed to be alive at the same time Rush was on tour. I even took my daughter to there last show. 😎 RIP NEIL
Mind blowing concerts! Friends for life guys! Hope to see all soon. Miss you. ❤️🇨🇦 BTW Doug says Hi!
The beauty and sheer power of this song brings tears. RIP, Neil Peart.
I just started dating a man who is a huge Rush fan. I never heard of them before he mentioned them (Don't shame me) but to think of what I've been missing this whole time !!! Thank you marshmelito 😘
Respect to the Foo Fighters to have inducted Rush into the RRHF
Was hoping this would have occured a couple of decades ago..but hey, so glad that Neil was still with us to receive this award!
My goodness !!! This is Canadian pride !!! My goodness raw passion talent !!! Thank you Rush !!!💕
INSANE!!! PERFORMANCE!!!!!