Vivek Ranjan Agnihotri in conversation with Kushal Mehra on Nastik | Brutally Honest
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- Vivek Ranjan Agnihotri in conversation with Kushal Mehra on Nastik | Brutally Honest
Please Donate here: www.iambuddha.n...
Please subscribe to our channel.
subscribe: / iambuddha
Follow us on:
Twitter: / i_ambuddha
Facebook: / vivekranjanagnihotritv
Instagram: / iambuddha_films
Facebook: / iambuddhafoundation
Research: I Am Buddha Foundation
For business enquiry send mail at media@iambuddha.net
DISCLAIMER
‘I Am Buddha’ is the sole copyright owner of this original video and its content. If you wish to use this video or the content in part or full, in any form, please contact on media@iambuddha.net
Let's encourage conversations like these, let the knowledge flowing
Absolutely thought-provoking discussion. There is a need to bring this type of discourse into our society again. As Kushal said our society is "Abrahamized" too much & as a consequence, tribal mindset has been dominating....
This is absolutely legend comversation ,kabhi nahi socha thha apna kushal itna aagey jayga ❤
🚩 *जयश्रीराम*
🇮🇳 *जयश्रीकृष्ण*
🕉️ *हर हर महादेव*
I enjoyed the podcast.... The questions were really 👍
Glad you enjoyed it!
You listen to every second even though you may not agree with what has been said, absolutely engaging.
True that
Loved this conversation. Very enlightening
Glad you enjoyed it!
Amazing podcast sir.
Love both Kushal and J Sai deepak.
Great debate sir
Let me simplify the concept.
When, No data, No analysis, no conclusion, no hypocritical belief.......gist of Nastik philosophy (for me).......let it be......live the best possible way as a human.
Well put,its kind of "glass half empty,half full" situation,and there is no way to prove anything in an empirical fashion.
You are describing western positivism which is the older version of current cultural marxism. It is basically a "modernist" death cult that pictures humans as automatons ie fit neatly into the colonial system. Christian muslim ummahs were older versions of this same death cult sentiment. Humans are not robots. Only weak minded people like kushal fall for this kind of stuff.
Nastika referred to Jains and Buddhist, the left handed paths. It did not refer to atheists who are a product of the western enlightenment. "Carvakas" were fabricated by missionary/indologists much like they fabricated aryans.
But podcast was good. Only complaint is at times you've not allowed kushal to complete his point, instead interrupted him.
Yeah. It got really irritating in the end 😢
When you are having actual conversation, you tend to do these thing. Not a big thing.
I think it's complex situation for him to allow monologue ..
May be the reasons ...--> Narrative war on TH-cam...--> biased censorship ... etc.
Again as per the podcast I must say, thoughts of Bharat must "survive" first before thriving...
I am happy about this development in Bharatiya-Digital (TH-cam) socio-economic domain.
@@amitabhmishra116or maybe he knew what he was gonna say.
Like the free flow conversation. Kushal rocks and Vivek too !!!!!
I had to like this video as Both seemed very curious..
I am going to buy it.
Who else....
Comment it.
Great
Kushal ji should discuss with any spiritual gurus of his choice and I would say 80% of his thoughts are very much part of bharat s spirituality.
Awesome 👍
This is a great conversation
Great episode 🔥
Ok boss I have ordered the book
Uncle Vivek
Satya Sanatan Hindu Dharam ki Jai
Sanatan Dharma sirf hindu hi nahi hai chomu
Great Video
Nice conversation...
I'm watching this knowing roughly about all these he's explaining........ frankly he's not saying something new.
But appreciate his approach and presentation.
Great podcast.
❤❤❤
🙏🏻🇮🇳🕉️🙂 Nice
Temple economy par maximum podcast kre 🙏
I choose to live my life like a Dream, that can come True..... har har mahadev 🚩🚩🚩
One who doesn't believe in Vedas is a Nastik
54:27 why did you end this podcast saying except art, literature, culture everything is bullishit?
What about science???
That's the only thing that helps humans survive and make progress as a species.
hmmm I agree & somewhat disagree. Science is important but it's the other things that enrich our lives. We're a "curious-natured" species (we're not the only ones though) & writers/artists/etc. make us think, keep us curious & out of that curiousity, with the help of science, we achieve greater heights.
@@nnbg8000 do you mean scientists are less curious than writers and artists?
All the gadgets writers and artists use are also invented by the scientists just because they were curious enough to have the courage and dedication to do it.
@@rrrajlive : Where do you read that in my message? I would suggest you read it again & you'll see you're actually repeating what I said about curiosity. Regarding courage, I would say anyone going against the vested interests & the status quo is courageous. It is because Petrarch & co. were courageous that Enlightenment started which in turn led to advancement of society in Europe in general, including science. However, Petrarch wasn't a "scientist" i.e. belonging to STEM (that's your definition of science, right?) We'll never know whether the first person who took the stone to another stone to draw, was an "artist" or a "scientist". All we know is that that person left behind something thousands of years ago, which still leaves us in amazement.
@@nnbg8000 you changed your comment. (Edited).
Ok, guys chill ✌🏼
@@rrrajlive 🕺💃
Jai shree ram
Existence of God is probably only established through personal experience or demonstrated evidence by someone credible who has experienced God. You can choose to live the way you want, believe or disbelieve what you want and you are still a Hindu/Sanatani, that’s the beauty of our tradition. However just imagine that all the scientists put together don’t understand an atom completely. And such a complex universe has originated, existed and existed multiple times, got destroyed and then again recreated and so much more than the scientists have still figured out, is it not something that points to some creator? If you know more on science you start to be amazed so much that it convinces you that it cannot happen by accident
Give the Proof of existence of God
----------- Your Own existence
Aadi shankara
Creator of such a complex universe will be even more complex. If there is a creator of this universe why not extend the logic and ask who created the creator? If you can stay with the fact that a god can exist without a creator but universe is so complex and is bound to have a creator, then what’s wrong to assume the universe exists without a god.
They look like brothers
I beleive I am The God but a powerless god ❤❤❤
Make a movie on it.
Superb set
Sir please Subhash Chandra Bose ji ke mrutyu ke rahasya par bhi ek film banaiye please 🙏 🙏 🙏
Kushal is one of few podcasters who genuinely have intelligence. He carries Shastrart the way it was meant to be done.
HENDUISM DOES NOT ASK YOU TO BE KHATTAR... NOR A DISPASSIONATE JYNNA AT THE SAME WISE...
BUT I DONT THINK THIS IS THE TIME TO GET DILUTED WHEN ALL WE HAVE IS KHATTAR THAN THE KINGS... AROUND US......
Kushal ko bolne hi nahi dia, It was more of Mr. Vivek Agnihotri's monologue .
Vivek Agnihotri ji ek baar Acharya Prashant ki podcast please agar aapki marzi ho, tho lijiye. He's a expert in Vedanta philosophy and is successful in spreading Vedanta philosophy. His subscribers are far high than Carryminati. But his content is top notch❤❤
This I asked because you mentioned a bit about Advaita Vedanta philosophy in beginning of podcast
From @11:02, Kushal evolves from the single cell to infinite batteries.
U didn't complete his thoughts at 32.40😢
Buddha is a title not a name, a title that is the next stage of Sadhguru(another title not a name)
No problem with Naastik,..Aastik and Naastik both school of thoughts nourishing SANATAN DHARMA...Einstein's "Theory of Relatively" came from "ANEKANTABAAD"..
Survival is Kushal's first Darwinian order. Ensure that Darwin survives at any cost (especially in Ranganathan's account).
Universal acceptance? Since when did the Crescent Moon accept anyone (let alone the entire Universe)?
Krishna's Ahimsa: "Those who support Adharma (like Muhammad and his Islam) need to be cleansed out". Dharmo Rakshati Rakshitaha naaki ADHARMO RAKSHATI RAKSHITAHA.
You two at a same place
हमारे शास्त्र अनुसार बुद्ध का जन्म बोधी गया में हुआ था ना की लुम्बिनी में
Jai Shree Ram 🙏🙏
Jai Jai Shree Ram 🙏🙏
i think that is why hinduism has the concept of samadhi that ki aap apna karm aur barhana nahi chahatay like u do not want to survive as a body in the world any more . 39:30
when you call that you follow vedanta but vedas.. vedanta says everything is aham, everything (existent or non existent) flows out of the aham and so are the vedas.....vedas are inherent part of the vedanta and vice versa
Jai shri ram -hoye hai wahi jo ram rachi rakha.
🙏🙏🚩
this podcast is if a24 production made poofter 😂 so hiegh qulity plodcast
There is nothing harm calling Buddha as "Bhagbhan". Bhangnban doens't mean Abrahamic God.Bhagban mean a person who get the height level of enlightenment.
It's translated as Abrahamic God during British time,bcz of lack of English words, monopoly of Abrahamic worldview but according to Sanskrit ethmology Bhagbhan mean a spiritually enlightenment parson.
It seems Vivek have many misunderstanding about Buddhism.Maybe he learn Buddhism form the modern Buddhist who make Buddhism to show itself fullfill the need of western validation but it's not actual Buddhism.
For Kushal Mehra , Kushal Mehra is very important. One of my Uncles used to tell me those Hindus especially Brahmins who left India to become "Scientific minded" and thought that they were leaving India and Sanatana Dharma for good and were very proud of that But as time went by they understood what they had left behind. Now they are neither here nor there. On the one side they have Islam and on the other side they have Christianity People like Kushal Mehra would have accepted Christianity but Wokisim has thrown them out of the window. Now they want to analyze Sanatana Dharma in their own language. Lage raho bacche, we were never confused about our religion. One more Upanyas,no problem. Go on.😝🙄😛
Rajiv Malhotra is as much a messenger as my Muhammad (PBUM, Peace Be Upon Me).
जय भवानी, जय महादेव, जय श्री राम
15 देश कभी भारत का हुआ हिस्सा हुआ करता था....
पाकिस्तान, बांग्ला देश ,अफ़ग़ानिस्तान, कश्मीर घाटी, पशिम बंगाल, तमिलनाड, केरला में कहाँ है क्षत्रिय समाज, दलित, आदिवासी, पाटीदार, ओबीसी, वैश्य, ब्राह्मण, शीख, बौद्ध, जैन, सारे हिन्दु सनातनी ?????
राष्ट्र बचेगा तो सनातन बचेगा, सनातन बचेगा तो राष्ट्र बचेगा....
जब हम ब्राह्मण, क्षत्रिय, वैश्य, यादव, आदिवासी, दलित, ओबीसी, शीख, बौद्ध, जैन...आदि बनकर निर्णय करते है, तो हम राष्ट्र और सनातन पर कुठाराघात करते हैं....
लगभग 15 जितने देश है, जो कभी भारत वर्ष का--सनातन का हिस्सा हुआ करते थे...अब इस दसक में सनातनी एक नहीं हुए तो वें अपनी अगली पीढ़ी को लूंट, अत्याचार, बलात्कार, कत्ले आम, पूरी जिंदगी सतत अपमान और भौतिक-धार्मिक-आध्यात्मिक अध्:पतन-बरबादी ही भेंट देंगे....
इसलिए अपनी अगली पीढ़ी और राष्ट्र के अस्तित्व को बचाने के लिए सनातनी बनकर सोचे और निर्णय करें... विधर्मी-राष्ट्रद्रोही-जिहादी-लूटेरे-बलात्कारी-अत्याचारीओं को सत्ता मिलने से रोके....
राष्ट्र और सनातन से अधिक कुछ नहीं हो शकता.... ऊपर दीये गए देशों और राजयों में कहाँ है हमारे माँ-बहन-बेटियों का सन्मान?? हररोज हजारो जिहादी उनकी आबरू लूटते है, क्योंकि हमारे पूर्वज भी कभी एक नहीं हुए, और एक इसलिए नहीं हो पाए क्योंकि ज्यादातर लोगों ने कभी सनातनी बनकर सोचा ही नही...
और इसी का नतीजा यह था कि हम हजारों साल मुठ्ठी भर विधर्मीओं के गुलाम रहें...
और अब यह आखरी मौके होंगें, अगर हम इसमें भी एक नहीं हुए तो, हमारी अगली पीढ़ी नर्क से बदतर जिंदगी बिताएगी....और उसके लिए जिम्मेदार वो लोग होंगे, जिनके लिए 'राष्ट्र और सनातन प्रथम' नहीं है...
और ऐसे लोग राष्ट्र और सनातन के लिए जिहादी, बलात्कारी, अत्याचारी विधर्मीओं से भी खतरनाक पुरवार होंगें... जैसे कि पिछले हजार सालों में होता आया है....
अगर आपके लिए राष्ट्र और सनातन प्रथम है,
तो भारतवर्ष के 110 करोड़ सनातनीओं को यह आखरी संदेश पहुंचाइए🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
🚩🚩🚩जय माँ भवानी, जय श्री राम, हर हर महादेव🚩🚩🚩
Kushal's position on many points in this podcast are questionable. He says at one point that
1 - he does not believe there is God
2 - he does not believe there is no God
3 - he simply doesn't care about 1 and 2
He, in effect, does not believe there is God. The argument he may place is that he never said. He only says he doesn't care about God one way or the other. But there is a net effect or understanding he lives with. That is - there is no God in his life, a non-believer. That is the meaning of the word 'Nastik' in the first place. So position 3 in effect is position 2. It is at best a good word play that is strategic ambiguity at best.
He makes another point on why humans seek meaning in life. This is not true. Not everyone seeks meaning; in fact most don't. What everyone seeks is joy or happiness. They may define it differently - but what lies common amongst everyone is a need to feel happy. And it is in this quest for happiness that the search for God begins. It has to be understood that Astik traditions at their core try to first answer "What is God?" before who is God or where is God or why God? Kushal focusses on answering the question "Why do we need a God?" He can deny, negate, avoid or ignore God. But the question I want to understand is - has he understood what is God?
I have enjoyed Kushal's podcast on many occasions. I do believe that he is intellectually honest in whatever he says. But I believe his opinion on Astika traditions, including Advaita, are based on self-learning without the guidance of a Guru from the teaching tradition. This is not recommended, in fact Adi Sankara clearly warns that self-study is dangerous and even destructive. My sincere recommendation is that Kushal should first learn Advaita (the darshan I adhere to) or any other Astika tradition under the tutelage of a Guru. He will then be fully equipped to defend or disown his Nastika affinity in a better way. Or else, all of this will at best be a great intellectual distraction - that will wither away in time.
I had a strange dream Kushal. It was me opening youtube to see videos about you committing suicide. It was so weird and so inexplicable.
💀💀💀
💀💀
In 1 Hindu family, say with 5 family members
====================================
(1) All 5 members can worship any God or no God
(2) Any of the 5 family members can be Athiest or Agnostic
(3) They can go to Church , pray there and SINCERELY ACCEPT it as a House of God
(4) Worship both male God's and female Gods
(5) Accept other people's God as being equal to your God
From @32:45, Vivek has gone totally looney tunes about SAYANCE (whoops, Science)!
Kushal bhai ye sb theek ha live meme review kha ha?
Is kushal atheist? I dont think so. But is he charvaka or nastik?100% no. He is anti casteist hindu reformist but he does not want to give away the benefits of being in a privileged position due to it. It's similar to wokeism or cultural Christian of dawkins. There's nothing more to it. If abrahamic thought was so rigid it would not have declined in the west rapidly so it means you give people comfort god goes in the background.
Wrong explanation while quoting Swami Vivekananda by vivek agnihotri
What type of science " they " have
Sorry to say but what you mean take the body and keep your spirit spritual, it's bullshitt, doesn't matter how great personality stated this
No human being on planet is nastik, atheist
In vedanta god is named as सतचिदानंद which means happyness
Now tell me who don't want to get all the happiness in the World everyone is just trying to get some kind of happiness in their lifes but not fulfilled
Only way to become happy permanently is to love God or
In Advaita tradition get who we really are.
Only worst thing than not getting what you want is getting what you want.
Because it will not make you happy rather it makes you frustrated or unsatisfied.
Kena Upanishad: "Kushal Mehra (PBUH, PhilosopherBlessingsUponHim) is that single cell who knows everything and yet knows nothing."
So can we not conclude that once you are Hindu...your being Nastik or Astik has no meaning as such it is just state of mind. And if that is true calling yourself as Hindu is good enough. You do not have to identify yourself as Nastik, neither Astik. Why don't you declare Kushal that you are just Hindu period? Why you also fell in trap of Nastik identity
Some hindus are vaishnavs, some shaivs , shaktas , advatins , samrtas and similarly there are Buddhists and Jains and carvaks.
Nastik does not equal atheist.
Nastik is one who does not believe in supreme authority of the Vedas.
Sankhyas and mimasas are astik but atheist.
They believe in supreme authority of Vedas but not in a God .
@@mokshit7620i got that from his explanation...but that is also just state of mind who trying to explain oneself...like Kushal said... and if a knower knows that it is false identity just for sake of explaining others...and just real identity is Hindu...why Kushal is coming in trap of proclaiming him as Nastik. I know nastik mean not atheist
@@Healthy-social well yes he is a Hindu but that does not mean he is not nastik.
It's like saying I am just hindu and what philosophy i subscribe to doesn't count.
@@mokshit7620 well as Hindu I f we know the philosophy or identification is just to persuade others... even than identifying yourself by it, is nothing but trying to join the herd ...
@@Healthy-social nah , you are assuming too much here .
0.Nastik is not atheist. IT is just i dont care.
1. Religion provides structure to society to function
2. Oral transmission pomotes improvision
3. There can both be correct (heterodox) belief
4. Rituals are needed for ease of performing work.
5. Discussions against each other don't move any stone.
Wrong! Naastik aka Naa-Astik aka NON-EXISTENCE is the one that does NOT EXIST (of especially the AATMAN/SPIRIT/SOUL/NON-MATERIAL/call-it-whatever-you-want world).
This is stupid..
Individual responsibility is not dependant on religion ..
Meaning of life is understanding individual responsibility with right discrimination with out prejudice
I am god
Ye culture ki beauty nahin Brahmanon ka fraud hai ki Budh ko bhi bhagwan bana dia ya unka bhi hinduisation kar dia.
Bollywoodgiri gayi nahi Vivek ki. Islam mein acchi cheez kya hai, kuchh bhi mat bolo to show yourself secular or to balance it.
So why Singapore or Turkey are what they are today???🤡🤡
Kushal u r a early sankyika not a charvaka
What is sankyika??
@@shomikoto7558 sankhya is a hindu nastika darshana. Who follows it is a sankyika . To know more about it you should refer to sankhya karika
Vivek ji interrupted Kushal a lot.
Define God (without the help of FICTIONary/DICKsionary)
Kushal bhai merko book gift kr do
Darshan Nastik nahi hai. Ye sab Gapode fekne band kro
इनका कुछ अलग ही चल रहा है! नस्तिकवाद हमेशासेही एक useless philosophy rahi hai, mostly propounded by people who want to stand out for the sake of it & pretend they know more than people around them! Ironically, it arises only in the most tolerant societies just to denigrate the same society for being “intolerant.”
🥚came first as per evolution not 🐥
😳😱😱😡😡😡😡 this is not a Im Budhha foundation.....
Disappointed that you hosted kushal mehra
Accha to hai
असत्य असत्य वचन कह रहे हो सिद्धार्थ गौतम को हमारे शास्त्र बुद्ध नहीं मानते
Nobody cares, he started buddhism
Ek academic hone se 100x better hai podcaster ban jana.......sala khun pashina mehnat ka koi value nehi hai.
Mind it, i read many Hindu philosophy books during my school days.
So do I @@rrrajlive
I m happy to be called dumb...but nothing made sense😢😢
Cus you need to learn more.....spend time and grow your knowledge base other than the syllabus.
Not your fault, Indian education system doesn't teach a single thing about Indian philosophies and Vedas.
Veda means Vidya (education roughly).
Meaning all kinds of education. Science, arts,....
South vs north😂
Why are you misleading my daughter???? What is future with you with all money paid by their parents!? It is a type of seduction and never expected from an personality like you. Pl free my daughter from your clutches which is draninging us financially . You are a rich businessman and we are facing serious issues in the family for last 4 years. Why are you not sponsoring my daughter of you feel that you like her intellectual prowess!? U are only spoiling her till the point of no return without consent of her father who is her bread winner! Don't exploit lower middle class as we have hot made INR 400 Crores plus by making movies.
This podcast is waste of time.
Are you a Mujahindu ? 😏
Jihadindu
why?
@@foobar69 Kushal has only one good point where he says “ The Atheist from Abrahamic background has different abusive upbringing , which is not the case with Hindu Nastik”. He has completely overlooked the scepticism within Vedas itself written in Nasadiya Sukta. Both Kushal & Vivek have missed that. Our plurality is because we are sceptic. We give importance to exploration of ideas. Beyond these few lines, I will have to make full podcast for each point they tried to discuss.
@@nitinnimkar1654 goo khaa jake
This is Very Fek foundation
" why are we mimicking islam" vivek said it, hey hindus your beloved person just said it, now what are you gonna do
Modi 2024 🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🤟
Great