QUESTION WHY DDI YOU NOT COUNT THE "GET ME GET ME KNOW" part for karina and giselle but you counted it for winter and ningning. it makes no sense cuz they all have multiple voices singing on those parts . so they should count towards their line disdtribution
@@pennydreadful5163 kwangya 3:16 For Naevis so loved the world that she gave her only aes that whoever believes in her shall not synkout but have eternal life
The first half of the song really made me think Giselle was going to be first, not gonna lie. Even if she ended up last like always, she still shines and sings more than most rappers in other groups with more members. Edit: wow 4k likes. I never had a comment with so many likes before! Thank you! And btw I hope I didn't start a war lol
I think this line distribution is unfair they counted ning and winters "get me now" when the voices overlap but not giselles and karina. the "naevis we love you" part is clearly all of them so why only counte karina and giselle the neding part with all the vocalizations multiple people were singing only 2 were given time. I want them to perform this live so we can see
@@krystalyan4719 Actually she had lots of screentime during next level which was her era she also had a good amount of screen time in black mamba as well as karina since it was her era, and for this song it was most def winters era.. and it's ok for ningning to have 2 minnutes of screentime bc most of the comments r about her anyway lmao
One of the best line distributions ever. Everyone shined in their own ways. Ningning with her amazing high notes and vocals, and also Winter with her soothing vocals. Karina and Giselle with their powerful raps and deep voices. STAN AESPA!!
@I Love Blackpink guys, please just ignore comments with obvious usernames like these. they’re usually antis of the group in the username trying to set them up so fans will attack them.
NINGNING’S VOCALS! Oh my god, the way she just belts at the end! She is singing like rent was due and she hadn’t received her check yet! She ate this comeback and left no crumbs! WE STAN A MAIN VOCALIST!!
@@AoTglazer I think you should understand that other members are too. It is for this reason that she should not take possession of what belongs to others.
I just saw a few comments disrespecting Ningning to bring up other members, let me make this clear Ningning is obviously the main vocal whether you like it or not. Go ahead and praise them but please don’t disrespect her position!
Yes, they are well balanced. But i hope they get a song with less rap in the future. Its not like i dislike Giselles and Karinas rap, but i think Aespa has the best Vocals in Kpop rn.
I don't really care about the storyline but the lyrics have such a deep meaning. The song addressed problems such as internet bullying. The ae represents our internet personas, kwangya represents the virtual world (internet, social media), black mamba represents the downside of technological advancement. In the mv we can see Winter surrounded by black smokes, Ningning got harassed by emojis that represent anger, Giselle became the victim of deep fake and mockery, and Karina got trapped. What we fail to see is sometimes the bully and the bullied are the same. When Karina contacted her ae, she was terrified that her ae became evil and twisted, poisoned by the black mamba. Sometimes we say something mean in the internet out of rage, and suddenly our ideal self (ae) turned into a monster that we could never imagine.
If you listen to the song very carefully, you will notice that random_k missed a lot so we tend to think that giselle had the least lines but actually, Giselle is in the 2nd spot of the line distribution. I think kawaiikpop's line distribution is more accurate
THE SONG ITSELF SHOWS THE TALENT OF EVERY MEMBER... THE FOUR MEMBERS' VOCALS, THE RAP PART OF GISELLE OMG.. AND THE HIGH NOTES BETWEEN WINTER AND NING NING THIS IS JUST TOO MUCH OMG
@@hehehehshbdbaa I know. But when ningning sings the give me give me now high vocals literally no screentime for her... I don't get why. For winter, she always gets focus when she sings.
@@peaches411_ I mean, they're still rookies? So not really fair to say yet. Plus, this is a four member group all members get great amounts of lines and screentimes compared to most groups. So there isn't really anything to complain about
@@nicolasraffoul8932 they are just stating winter is not perfect because she had her nose done (apparently) - they are not saying it was wrong to get her nose done
Winter is the ACE of the ACES. She’s already an incredible vocalist who can hit high notes easily, great at dancing, a beautiful visuals and now she raps. She’s absolutely insane !!
@@alexandrareyes8922 both karina and winter are all rounders , sm confirmed it tho when they first debut , winter is lead vocal , lead dancee , sub rapper , and karina is main dancer , lead rapper , and sub vocal , both are super talented
Winter with the vocals too, her voice in general fit the concept more since her voice is deeper, and she also added that growl in the pre-chorus, don't get me wrong ningning ate that shit up at the end but her voice is more light hearted while winters is gritty, I love how their voices have a different style to them but, they still complement each other! If you don't know what i mean by the growl listen to ningning 0:53 then listen to winter 2:16
@@Us-yx4dc ?????? it's ningning wtf r u saying? although they don't have fixed position NINGNING IS THE MAIN VOCALIST in terms of vocal technique ningning is the one! Winter is so good too not too far but did not top ningning's edit: PLEASE RESPECT HER POSITION!
@@Us-yx4dc Ning Ning is definitely the main vocalist especially if you’re only looking at this song in particular girl is belting those notes at the end of the song
a popular fact right here, this is for sure giselles era. although all members shined in this era, giselle shined the most and no one can prove me wrong.
me too hun🥸 I have a feeling maybe in 3 years or a century, it pains me that my kawaii gurl ain't being appreciated as much as the hype around the main "aces". NingNing is still my bias but I really want to see a Giselle Mixtape or collab with another rapper like Mark, Taeyong or Chanyeol. that would be badass if all of them collabed 👀
its a four member group shes getting 20-60 seconds for her position and thats considered a lot considering line distributions like 2NE1, Sistar, Brave Girls, Blackpink etc. they have a really fair distribution for a 4 member group and here she got 43 seconds which is a lot and thats basically almost above average for main vocal lines ex. (Yuju, Wendy, Hyolyn, Jihyo) who gets around 30-60 seconds for a song depending on its length and how vocal heavy it is
@@alovegreat955 ur really that jealous of a rookie group go worry about your group pls stop hating.. can u explain what they copied? also bp and SNSD has similar things and concept photo is anyone blaming bp for that no ryt idk some blinks are here to hate on other grps cause they jealous.. go away from here hater
Winter never misses with her growls. Ningning high note queen like giselle said. Karina beautiful timber. Giselle cool girl rap. Aespa pretty girls you'll always be famous.
[CORRECTION] - 2:54 Karina's adlib "oh oh oh" and "my naevis we love you". - 3:30 Karina's adlib "up up up up". - 3:31 Giselle's adlib "oaw" and from 3:32 - 3:37 Giselle's "Gimme gimme now x 2 + 4Zu + Jigeum nareul jaba anim nan deo savage + 4Zu" - 3:38 - 3:44 Karina's "Gimme gimme now x 2 + 4Zu + Ijen naega neoreul jaba now, I'm a savage" - 3:45 - 3:47 Karina and Ningning's "Gimme gimme now x 2" - 3:48 - 3:51 Karina and Giselle "Neoui mari boyeo ne yakjeom algorithm" - 3:47 Karina's "give it give it now" - 3:51 - 3:57 Karina and Winter's "Gimi gimi na gimi gimi na MA æ SYNK banghae malgo kkeojyeo savage" - 3:53 Giselle's "give it give it now" P/s: SM songs usually have many adlibs and harmony so it's okay if the line distribution is wrong.
omg!!! We have the same thoughts after i saw their performance in coachella and listening carefully the savage coachella mr removed i was so convinced that giselle and karina really sang the last chorus while ning ning and winter sang the adlibs which is highnote. We are so correct!
@@thedivinefolktales3555 yes he has improved but songs like pretty savage playing with fire jisoo got most lines but in his line distribution she is last and many song he needs to correct like gxxd boy everglow icsm twice and many more
Madre mía con la voz de Winter, me dió hasta escalofríos. Sus notas altas, su rap y su baile es increíble. Ciertamente es una de las idols más completas.
Cam we appreciate ningning highnote more because OMFG my girl went way too hard with those highnote adlibs and vocals omfg best vocalist of 4th gen with bora for me ngl
Aespa is really on the way of becoming Blackpink 2 with this much amount of solo fans. This whole comment section is filled of solo stans just praising their favourite girl and bashing other girls and their fans when someone mention them.
Winter's vocals are truly insane...I'm glad they took advantage of the period where they don't have to perform live to bring us this vocal-heavy and experimental song
Winter has an incredible versality. She might be the first to be on par with Wendy regarding range and vocal possibilities, so it is logical she gets the most lines, producers simply make good use of her. That being said, to me, Giselle still own this era.
@@Rosevieenla Yes I agree, her voice has also more volume in mediums and more stability, I just say Winter has an amazing range. She can sing anything.
I hope everyone knows that ningning is also a really talented girl and worth-praising too like the others. She's a treasure and I hope more ppl talk about her
![aespa 'Whiplash' [SING WITH ME] {KARAOKE}](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HFfCgA64MOo/mqdefault.jpg)
![aespa 'Whiplash' [SING WITH ME] {KARAOKE}](/img/tr.png)
![[Karaoke] aespa (에스파) 'Whiplash' You As A Member. 5 members ver](/img/n.gif)
Make a Request/Vote for Requests: randomk.me
Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/random_k
ITZY and I.O.I songs PLEASE!!!!!🙏🙏🙏🙏
Please the b sides of aespa savage
B side of Aespa please
QUESTION WHY DDI YOU NOT COUNT THE "GET ME GET ME KNOW" part for karina and giselle but you counted it for winter and ningning. it makes no sense cuz they all have multiple voices singing on those parts . so they should count towards their line disdtribution
Make for TREASURE please
Winter's and Ningning's highnotes got me levitating around my room
I'm levitating rn...help me !
im laughing so hard
You need a priest.
@@pennydreadful5163 kwangya 3:16
For Naevis so loved the world that she gave her only aes that whoever believes in her shall not synkout but have eternal life
Girl just wow
The first half of the song really made me think Giselle was going to be first, not gonna lie. Even if she ended up last like always, she still shines and sings more than most rappers in other groups with more members.
Edit: wow 4k likes. I never had a comment with so many likes before! Thank you! And btw I hope I didn't start a war lol
Actually, she is second in next level
Same here but she really caught my attention on this comeback.. Her raps is really on the Next Level..
Yass I think so too, happy for giselle
Literalmente, soy adicto a su rap😌😏
She's probably first not including all the final adlibs
I love Karina's Voice here 2:09
Also, Winter and Ningning slayed those vocals and Giselle slayed this concept
damn, Karina's voice is definitely the best(most relaxing)
Omg me too
Yeah karina is the best in aespa❤❤❤
This is why Giselle is the main rapper.
in love with her part
I Love her "savage" on 3:26
I think this line distribution is unfair they counted ning and winters "get me now" when the voices overlap but not giselles and karina.
the "naevis we love you" part is clearly all of them so why only counte karina and giselle
the neding part with all the vocalizations multiple people were singing only 2 were given time. I want them to perform this live so we can see
@@jisooinyourarea6751 random_k usually updates line distributions if there's a mistake. Once we get a live performance we'll check :)
@@schitowanouri ME TOOOO
Ningning’s high notes snatched everyones wigs.
yas gurl👩🏻🦲the bish snatched me bald.
yes now we bald 🧑🦲
@mari
I’m your 700th like
👩🦲👩🦲👩🦲
NINGNING ATEEEE, shes literally perfect omg her vocals are on a whole other level why are people not talking about her???
ikr, she's not given screentime..
@@krystalyan4719 shes yeah
@@krystalyan4719 Actually she had lots of screentime during next level which was her era she also had a good amount of screen time in black mamba as well as karina since it was her era, and for this song it was most def winters era.. and it's ok for ningning to have 2 minnutes of screentime bc most of the comments r about her anyway lmao
@mari
Im on the next level
One of the best line distributions ever. Everyone shined in their own ways. Ningning with her amazing high notes and vocals, and also Winter with her soothing vocals. Karina and Giselle with their powerful raps and deep voices. STAN AESPA!!
#stanAespa
@I Love Blackpink guys, please just ignore comments with obvious usernames like these. they’re usually antis of the group in the username trying to set them up so fans will attack them.
@I Love Blackpink th-cam.com/video/yWgmj4FiHAo/w-d-xo.html
@I Love Blackpink your cousin
@I Love Blackpink mejores vocales que tú grupete si. 😔
I love how you add that little details
Karina is typing…
Giselle is typing…
Winter is typing…
NingNing is typing…
Thanks for this great work!
also the ‘giselle has left the chat’ after her last line!
Not to mention how their icons change to their ae avatars!
im curious how much time would it take to edit this video. Might be more than a hour :')
@@neopolitian How attentive of the editor!
@@DawnBreaker5 This amazes me, too! It’s really creative.
Winter - 72.74s (33.22%)
Ningning - 57.22s (26.13%)
Karina - 46.04s (21.03%)
Giselle - 42.97s (19.62%)
Winter's "Oh my gosh" is so sassy and I love it😍
th-cam.com/video/_L3Ex8BKxfg/w-d-xo.html
aespa 'Savage' Background & Hidden Vocals ❤️
Yash 😍
She could have done better
@@octopusmusic332 damn alright, you must be fun at parties
its very cringey 😃
NINGNING’S VOCALS! Oh my god, the way she just belts at the end! She is singing like rent was due and she hadn’t received her check yet! She ate this comeback and left no crumbs! WE STAN A MAIN VOCALIST!!
periodt💅🏻
Finally someone talked about ningning💖🌌
agreed
@@Ami-gu7he
All love and appreciation for all of aespa but we gotta make some noise for NingNing! 💓
@@alaaye5237 YESSIR
i love how the faces of the members next to the bars turn into the ae characters when they sing!! i love these lil details in randomk's vids
As a Karina stan I have to say that all of them slayed but Giselle and Winter DEVORED IT( Giselle with her rap and Winter with the vocals)
RIGHTT
YEEESSSS, CONCORDOOOO
Devored?
@@NoOne-bp4oe she ate it
ningning was good too
winter fucking went off this comeback, she damn ate it all up and left no crumbs
Agree. She have so many lines in most of their songs in this album. Not to mention that she got the main highnotes in most of their b-sides.
Winter shines in every Comback. She is the most talented idol right now
@@AoTglazer I think you should understand that other members are too.
It is for this reason that she should not take possession of what belongs to others.
@@mingyu_kaki7282 Ups i forgot to say: "for me"
@@mingyu_kaki7282 theres also reason why she has many lines it look like youre not smart enough to understand
I just saw a few comments disrespecting Ningning to bring up other members, let me make this clear Ningning is obviously the main vocal whether you like it or not. Go ahead and praise them but please don’t disrespect her position!
agreed bestie
preach!! we don't have to bring down a member to praise others 🤍
Exactly! SHE'S THE MAIN VOCALIST FOR LIFE!
People should recognize and respect her as one of the best female singers in 4th gen through her long and high learning experience.
@@slaystinn ningning and monday *are the best female vocalist* in 4rth gen.
I don't know about others but for me giselle stand out the most in this MV. She killed it with her incredible rap
For me Winter. I cant get enough of her Vocalsssssssssssssss
@@AoTglazer ok but be quiet we are talking about Queen Giselle
@@kdome9107 wtff ?? What if she want to talk about queen winter
@@emaaass ikr like
@Ema because this is a giselle comment
4 great vocalists, 4 great rappers, 4 great dancers, and 4 top notch visuals in one group, SM wasnt playing around when making aespa ❤️
Yes, they are well balanced. But i hope they get a song with less rap in the future. Its not like i dislike Giselles and Karinas rap, but i think Aespa has the best Vocals in Kpop rn.
I don't really care about the storyline but the lyrics have such a deep meaning. The song addressed problems such as internet bullying. The ae represents our internet personas, kwangya represents the virtual world (internet, social media), black mamba represents the downside of technological advancement. In the mv we can see Winter surrounded by black smokes, Ningning got harassed by emojis that represent anger, Giselle became the victim of deep fake and mockery, and Karina got trapped. What we fail to see is sometimes the bully and the bullied are the same. When Karina contacted her ae, she was terrified that her ae became evil and twisted, poisoned by the black mamba. Sometimes we say something mean in the internet out of rage, and suddenly our ideal self (ae) turned into a monster that we could never imagine.
wow, this is deep! i never thought about it like this...
this deserves more likes ngl
2:51 a tribute to someone?
You deserve to be pinned and more likes and i never thought this will be the meaning
Aespa songs r really good
I don't really see what you see but I honestly like your comment so can you like say more😩
Giselle had the least lines, but she stood out with her rapping 🔥🔥
@@strawberryruiyang1792 They said Giselle had the least lines compared to other members, not that Giselle had a small amount of lines
Somehow Giselle will always ended up in last place 😔
@@kimkardashi-un2.051 well at least she always gets like 20 - 40 sec in each song
@I'm Jisoo I'm OK I can read
If you listen to the song very carefully, you will notice that random_k missed a lot so we tend to think that giselle had the least lines but actually, Giselle is in the 2nd spot of the line distribution.
I think kawaiikpop's line distribution is more accurate
GISELLE FINALLY GETTING A LOT OF RAP LINES THIS COMEBACK!!!! WE LOVE THIS!!
she got loads in next level
@@chaeyoungabadbitch9743 she got two whole verses here plus those sassy "savage" adlibs. in next level they were scattered and always after karina's.
I’m sorry but ningnings high notes where amazing and out of this world😭💜🤞🏻
@mari just because it wasn't her era doesn't mean she's underrated
Yep jin my bias is cute on your picture
No,It's mess periodt.
@@ugh4709 winter’s high notes hurt my ears and they’re actually messy
where please tell. me the minutes?
THE SONG ITSELF SHOWS THE TALENT OF EVERY MEMBER... THE FOUR MEMBERS' VOCALS, THE RAP PART OF GISELLE OMG.. AND THE HIGH NOTES BETWEEN WINTER AND NING NING THIS IS JUST TOO MUCH OMG
Ningning's vocals and high notes are insane, THE 4th gen main vocalist
But Winter's too tho-
@@hehehehshbdbaa?? I'm talking about NingNing and Winter is not main vocal only NingNing is
@@hehehehshbdbaa I know. But when ningning sings the give me give me now high vocals literally no screentime for her... I don't get why. For winter, she always gets focus when she sings.
I love how ning ning and Lia From itzy have same technic and same range vocal
Oh yeaaaah #bias
wow winter makes me speechless she's so talented.
Winter have a lots of lines,so proud of her and ningning vocals are so powerfull please-
She always has alot of lines and screentime tho
@@peaches411_ I mean, they're still rookies? So not really fair to say yet. Plus, this is a four member group all members get great amounts of lines and screentimes compared to most groups. So there isn't really anything to complain about
@@peaches411_ which she deserves ~
@@peaches411_ as she should
WINTER STANS, WON IN THIS COMEBACK. BUT FOR ME, THIS IS FAIR
th-cam.com/video/_L3Ex8BKxfg/w-d-xo.html
aespa 'Savage' Background & Hidden Vocals ❤️
I'm a winter Stan and I love it so much!!
And also for Giselle, she had THE MOST LINES IN THE ALBUM!!
@@alovegreat955 fyi, aespa didnt copy blackpink either kda
@@alovegreat955 troll
한미라
You
Winter is all-rounded. She can sing, dance and even rap. Her visual is also no jokes. She is the definition of perfection.
Yes Winter is perfection itself, multi-function, is a great dancer, great vocalist, great rapper and visual.
Perfection doesn’t exist.
Otherwise she wouldn’t have had her nose done
@@moamoaoz Oop..
@@moamoaoz so what if she has her nose done?😭
@@nicolasraffoul8932 they are just stating winter is not perfect because she had her nose done (apparently) - they are not saying it was wrong to get her nose done
Winter is the ACE of the ACES. She’s already an incredible vocalist who can hit high notes easily, great at dancing, a beautiful visuals and now she raps. She’s absolutely insane !!
All aespa is ace
right
@@yourfuture5307 maybe because it is not herofficial position? but her rap is good
Karina is right when she said Winter is the all-rounder
@@alexandrareyes8922 both karina and winter are all rounders , sm confirmed it tho when they first debut , winter is lead vocal , lead dancee , sub rapper , and karina is main dancer , lead rapper , and sub vocal , both are super talented
Everyone shined. Ningning with vocals, karina & winter with center & screentime, giselle with rap parts
Winter with the vocals too, her voice in general fit the concept more since her voice is deeper, and she also added that growl in the pre-chorus, don't get me wrong ningning ate that shit up at the end but her voice is more light hearted while winters is gritty, I love how their voices have a different style to them but, they still complement each other! If you don't know what i mean by the growl listen to ningning 0:53 then listen to winter 2:16
hi insomnia
Winter's vocal is everything!
Winter's voice sounds heavenly. She could be a Main Vocalist if she's in another group.
@@Us-yx4dc ?????? it's ningning wtf r u saying? although they don't have fixed position NINGNING IS THE MAIN VOCALIST in terms of vocal technique ningning is the one! Winter is so good too not too far but did not top ningning's
edit: PLEASE RESPECT HER POSITION!
@@Us-yx4dc kind of but ningning way better in term of vocal technique so...
@@Us-yx4dc Ning Ning is definitely the main vocalist especially if you’re only looking at this song in particular girl is belting those notes at the end of the song
@@Us-yx4dc shes the lead vocalist not main but still super close behind ningning they're both such strong vocalists
@@deven7382 no winter is just lead vocalist not main it isnt rlly up for debate or on a scale
Winter literally slayed like I can't get over her rapping part are kidding me queen 😭😭😭😭
Ningning and Winter's vocals in this song is so angelic and comforting. Both girls have got a very beautiful voice. ✨💫
a popular fact right here, this is for sure giselles era. although all members shined in this era, giselle shined the most and no one can prove me wrong.
This song proved that Giselle is a terrible rapper even winter is better
@@kingjeff8186 Back off
@@kingjeff8186 bruh🙄stop leeching on every giselle comment, just praise your fave and GTFO. I see u on every giselle comment talking trash bout her.
@@kingjeff8186 You don't know a thing about rapping lmao
unpopular opinion: giselle finally got the lines she deserved but winter owns this era
Living for the moment when Giselle will get most lines in a song, but this song is fireeeeee
me too hun🥸 I have a feeling maybe in 3 years or a century, it pains me that my kawaii gurl ain't being appreciated as much as the hype around the main "aces". NingNing is still my bias but I really want to see a Giselle Mixtape or collab with another rapper like Mark, Taeyong or Chanyeol. that would be badass if all of them collabed 👀
Giselle isn't a main or lead vocal so, I think it will be a while before that happens, if it ever happens lmao
@@jennie.bean_125 Nethier is Karina
@@jennie.bean_125 she got most lines in Lucid Dream :)
its a four member group shes getting 20-60 seconds for her position and thats considered a lot considering line distributions like 2NE1, Sistar, Brave Girls, Blackpink etc. they have a really fair distribution for a 4 member group and here she got 43 seconds which is a lot and thats basically almost above average for main vocal lines ex. (Yuju, Wendy, Hyolyn, Jihyo) who gets around 30-60 seconds for a song depending on its length and how vocal heavy it is
Black mamba - ningning's high note
Next level - winter's high note
Savage - both
That's why i love SM
Now we also haver Girls with the perfects high notes lmao
Black mamba: Ning Ning era
Forever: Winter era
Next level: Karina era
Savage: GISELLE ERA!!!!!
Yesss
YESSSS
Yess
I've always thought Black mamba's was Karina's and Next level is Ningning but that's just my opinion.
@@joshuavergara3968 ningning shined in next level because if her red hari that should've been her era
The fact that all 4 of them got 40 seconds above is beyond now
winters voice is so satisfying to hear 😭
La vos de Winter es simplemente hermosa, al igual que las chicas.
voz*
Concuerdo😌
yess
same, me está llamando mucho la atención ella x sus partes y sus looks diod
SI 😭
Winter’s growl never missed
NINGNING AND WINTER THEY CAN SLAY BOTH HIGH NOTES AND LOW NOTES AHHHHHHH IM DYING
get yourself a girl that both can do high note and rap like Winter. she be slaying this era.
Wow, this distribution is fair. Vocal members outshined rap members for 10 seconds more.
Winter’s “oh my gosh, don’t you know i’m a savage?” just sounds so satisfying
Best thing i’ve heard this year.
Popular Opinion: AESPA song is getting better and getting everytime has COMEBACK.
th-cam.com/video/_L3Ex8BKxfg/w-d-xo.html
aespa 'Savage' Background & Hidden Vocals ❤️
@@alovegreat955 ur really that jealous of a rookie group go worry about your group pls stop hating.. can u explain what they copied? also bp and SNSD has similar things and concept photo is anyone blaming bp for that no ryt idk some blinks are here to hate on other grps cause they jealous.. go away from here hater
For me it's 1. Black mamba 2. Savage 3. Next level
Black Mamba is definitly the best for me. I love the Vocals more than the rap thats why.
i’m addicted to winter's “oh my gosh, don't you know i'm a savage?” 😭💗
NingNing is so beautiful and her vocals are so beautiful.. her dance is so clean and smooth, her visuals are no joke..
A perfect idol for me
Ningning's high note here at 3:30 reminds me of her high note in black mamba
same
Winter never misses with her growls. Ningning high note queen like giselle said. Karina beautiful timber. Giselle cool girl rap. Aespa pretty girls you'll always be famous.
[CORRECTION]
- 2:54 Karina's adlib "oh oh oh" and "my naevis we love you".
- 3:30 Karina's adlib "up up up up".
- 3:31 Giselle's adlib "oaw" and from 3:32 - 3:37 Giselle's "Gimme gimme now x 2 + 4Zu + Jigeum nareul jaba anim nan deo savage + 4Zu"
- 3:38 - 3:44 Karina's "Gimme gimme now x 2 + 4Zu + Ijen naega neoreul jaba now, I'm a savage"
- 3:45 - 3:47 Karina and Ningning's "Gimme gimme now x 2"
- 3:48 - 3:51 Karina and Giselle "Neoui mari boyeo ne yakjeom algorithm"
- 3:47 Karina's "give it give it now"
- 3:51 - 3:57 Karina and Winter's "Gimi gimi na gimi gimi na MA æ SYNK banghae malgo kkeojyeo savage"
- 3:53 Giselle's "give it give it now"
P/s: SM songs usually have many adlibs and harmony so it's okay if the line distribution is wrong.
omg!!! We have the same thoughts after i saw their performance in coachella and listening carefully the savage coachella mr removed i was so convinced that giselle and karina really sang the last chorus while ning ning and winter sang the adlibs which is highnote. We are so correct!
Everyone shined but Ningning’s vocals and Giselle’s rap 😍😍
periodt 💅🏻
2:22 this is sooo satisfying to me
The distribution is so perfect, so balanced, that no member is left out, the vocals dazzling, just perfect. The best era.
Winter's "Oh my gosh" is LONY (line of the year)❤️😅
And So dangerous, so so dangerous tooo!!!!
And Get so shy by Momo too!!!
Alls o iconiccccccccc
@@luking4music363 ikr I love all if these lines
Ningning and Winter's highnote gived me chills . Plus karina's adlibs is so heavenly and Giselle slayed it.
Ningning is always there to prove that She's the main vocalist
WHAT DOES SM FEED THESE CHILDREN THESE HIGHNOTES ARE MAJESTIC
FR THOOOO
Sm water 🤣😭🤧🤌
They gulp cds and sm water that tastes like water.
Winter shined in this album
I think i fell in love with this song
Winter‘s voice suits this song‘s vibe and overall image so much. So it’s no wonder she got the most lines
her voice tone is literally the type who can suites in almost every genre of music
1:59 "Now you're just a yogurt" 😆
NOW I CAN'T UNHEAR IT-
NAAURRRRRR 😭😭😭
Addicted with Gigi's "hmmmm, everybody look at me."
Damn best comeback of aespa ever yet, Savage showcased all of their strong points, from dance, rap, vocal to visual
3:51 Giselle's lines. She's 3rd in this line distribution.
i think random_k hates giselle thats why he or she always cuts of giselle's lines. in next level she was 3rd.
@@thedivinefolktales3555 i hate random_k his line distribution are inaccurate
@@dhyandave2700 it is accurate but sometimes ig it needs to check the live. but now it has improved alot
@@thedivinefolktales3555 yes he has improved but songs like pretty savage playing with fire jisoo got most lines but in his line distribution she is last and many song he needs to correct like gxxd boy everglow icsm twice and many more
you means the "I'm a savage"?
Madre mía con la voz de Winter, me dió hasta escalofríos. Sus notas altas, su rap y su baile es increíble. Ciertamente es una de las idols más completas.
2:51 this part is so addicting! 😍
I'm a winter Stan and I love it so much!!
And also for Giselle, she had THE MOST LINES IN THE ALBUM!!
Second most lines
@@blink-reveluv-my6875 who the first?
@@iceprince7237 I think it's winter followed by Giselle then NingNing - K
Cam we appreciate ningning highnote more because OMFG my girl went way too hard with those highnote adlibs and vocals omfg best vocalist of 4th gen with bora for me ngl
@mari
Finally, you posted
I’m so loyal to this channel to the point I don't watch other channels(except Japanese come back songs)
th-cam.com/video/_L3Ex8BKxfg/w-d-xo.html
aespa 'Savage' Background & Hidden Vocals ❤️
They created a channel for Japanese releases too! But they aren’t really posting
0:05 "Oh my gosh! Don't you no know I'm sandwich"
Can we talk about how NingNing is one of the best vocalist of this generation? Her voice is out of this world, it's amazing.
0:35 the prechorus always got me
NingNing es la razón por la que me interese en Aespa, esa chica es impresionante.
Winter and Ningning's highnotes give me goosebump
winter's vocals GIVE ME LIFE GET IT QUEEN
Winter rapping 😍
Giselle has lines 😍
Aespa is really on the way of becoming Blackpink 2 with this much amount of solo fans.
This whole comment section is filled of solo stans just praising their favourite girl and bashing other girls and their fans when someone mention them.
Agree, mys are shit
I agree..
@@xSilentChannelx You're exactly what their talking about. Your comment against Karina is disgusting!
Lyrics make no sense whatsoever but the melody’s a bop and Winter’s vocals are on point!
the beauty of SM HAHAHAHAH
tyhe lyrics makes a lot of sense actually if you know the smcu storyline
It does make sense if you know scmu...
what is smcu
You need to know the storyline
Don't mind me, I'm saving this to bless my ears 3:44
How did I just discover this channel? This is the most HD, clear and well put together Kpop translation and line distribution video I have ever seen.
NingNing as always crushing hearts with her wonderful vocals. 🥰🤩
Your note in this song makes me crazy, what a perfect high note. ✨✨✨
“mmmh everybody looks at me 익숙하잖니 (iksukajanni)” WILL FOREVER BE ICONIC 🙏🙏
Am I the only one who heard Karina saying "gimme gimme now" and after "I'm a Savage"?
03:47 listen carefully
yes that's so swag!
@@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα ikr!! I loved it
Black Mamba NINGRINA era
Forever WINSELLE era
Next Level NINGRINA era
Savage WINSELLE ERA
Winter's vocals are truly insane...I'm glad they took advantage of the period where they don't have to perform live to bring us this vocal-heavy and experimental song
2:33
i know im not the only one who’s obsessed with ningning’s voice
As we expected this is Giselle's era with her strong rap. But winter is too outstanding, I can't!
OMG WINTER'S "Oh my gosh!" IS SOOOOO GOOOOD!!!!!!
SM has the best vocalist and no one can change my mind.
Yes same !!!!!!!
When Ningning and Winter nailing their high notes, I got spat on by Karina and Giselle's rap
Perfect way to die
I will never shut up how all of them can sing SING, Ningning and Winter left me in awe. We're blessed for having aespa an all rounder group.
ning ning’s high notes on the last few seconds of the song got me in cardiac arrest
ok, honestly this song is hard to listen at first but thanks to the teaser i "adapt" to the chorus and after a few listens, this song is now my jam
That winter's intro is so SAVAGE and it's killing me!!
This song made me stan the group. The whole music video they're all so beautiful.
Winter has an incredible versality. She might be the first to be on par with Wendy regarding range and vocal possibilities, so it is logical she gets the most lines, producers simply make good use of her. That being said, to me, Giselle still own this era.
Winter isn’t the main vocalist tho but agree she’s talented
@@lunarialoonatic I know she is not, but she is already the visual so I guess they had to make a choice here...
@@FlecheDeFer there was no choice Ningning is a better technical vocalist. Hence her being the main vocal
@@Rosevieenla Yes I agree, her voice has also more volume in mediums and more stability, I just say Winter has an amazing range. She can sing anything.
@@FlecheDeFer that "they had to make a choice here" is so rude IMO
Winter is pretty good at vocal and rap, and also on visual
I hope everyone knows that ningning is also a really talented girl and worth-praising too like the others. She's a treasure and I hope more ppl talk about her