When all known India haters sits together and discusses about India in a so called literary festival, we Indians must realize that something very right is happening in India right now. We are aware of the backgrounds of the participants very well. These ill informed people don't realize that India's days of colonial and cultural slavery is over
Ha ha ha ..They have invited Audrey ChoosKe (Trusschke) and they are talking about Indian democracy in Pakistan, a terror factory and islamic theocratic terrror camp (its not a country)
Your comment proves that India is in the grips of hndutva terror. India uses terrorism against Kashmiris and uses Afghanistan as a terror industrial complex. Funding all sorts of groups to cause chaos in the region.
1000 hindu girls are converted every year in pakistan and they won't talk about this! Pakistan occupied Kashmir has turned from Shia majority to Sunni majority, they won't talk about the shia genocide! Even Pakistani textbooks have Hindu hatred.
The reason why India was, is and will always be an exceptional country is due to the hindu majority and hindu ethos - but where the line is getting drawn is on nationalism, integrity and anti-Ismalist mindset - hence our enemies are crying!
This is supposed to be Literary Festival but I find it more of a bashing, lying n uneducating festival. No wonder Pakistan is at this stage on 06/03/2023. Congratulations Organizers, Panelist n participants. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@Simple Minded Oh please, do not take the Brits too seriously.... 2 billion people follow Hindu and Buddhist faiths in this world - come out of Mohammad's gand
@@haideraliibnakhlaq8823 just checking on you after 2 years. lol. A woman could’ve been quilled over the dress she was wearing. You are stating it as if thousands of mumeins are hanging on trees like Tipu did hundreds of years back. RIP Prasantha Kumara.
@@nirvanabliss73 the thing is they are discussing internet restrictions sitting in pakistan if this debate was happening in sweden or uk then i had not commented about balochistan ..hope u got me why i mentioned Balochistan ..now u can go for chile n congo internet protests
@@aaaravmalhotra4 The topic is 'Where is India headed?' and not 'Where is Pakistan headed'. Now are you saying India is as bad as Pakistan and that the speakers should have mentioned that?
@Vi K @Aaarav Malhotra The topic is 'Where is India headed?' and not 'Where is Pakistan headed'. Now are you saying India is as bad as Pakistan and that the speakers should have mentioned that?
What an ironic debate on India held in Pakistan! If they want a referendum in Kashmir, then it is high time that India has a referendum on whether Hinduism should be the state religion, like Pakistan has!
@Simple Minded ha ha.... They are talking so negative about india don't you feel thoda zyada ho gaya... Or this people have nothing to do then talking on india......
Natasha mam., we are living in Democratic country ... We have full freedom on speech and our wish that's why we are developed then Pakistan... Ha ba... Don't fool world...
What some English speaking libtards portray India in international papers, they are not valued/respected even 5% in India. Eg- Arundhati Roy, Shashi tharoor, Manishankar ayyar, Swara bhaskar. Etc. Bigotry just died😀😀😀🙏
@@lordmephisto6654Pig, if you type in the Google search as 'was India the richest country' the following would appear: India was one of the richest countries in the world, for about two and a half millennia starting around the end of 1st millennium BC and ending around the beginning of British rule in India. Around 500 BC, the Mahajanapadas minted punch-marked silver coins.
Pakistini are discusing about where is India heading. And I am watching it on 8th April 2022 .. After Imran Khan Niyazi drama...This is most hilarious.
2 years down the line Kashmir is heading towards peace without any concentration camps & Pakistan headed into Chaos, hypocrites always proved wrong by time. Hindu philosophy tells "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" - World is one family, which is the core philosophy of this country & Democratic Republic existed in India from 350 BC in Vaishali, Taxila & Cholas. RSS has the highest number of branches in Kerala but still Kerala has a leftist govt. says a lot about fascist narrative peddle for RSS.
Everyone is taking about Audrey.....but Nitasha is a classic hindu hating liberal character and happens to be a Kashmiri pandit. Wonder why did she leave Kashmir?🤔
Discussing this in Pakistan? Wow. When did Pakistan become a minority friendly and inclusive country? With less than what 1 or 2 percent minorities, no one to fight, now fighting other Muslim sects, wow, sure Pakistan is perfect host.
@@nirvanabliss73 u can also talk about sun moon god or me but in reality u don't know anything out of these fully and is precisely because ur knowledge about these things is not complete or absolute but u talk about these things as u know everything similar mistake u r doing about India or Hinduism if u have any doubt ask me anything about India or Hinduism I will give right answer u and these fools know nothing about Indian culture or about Hinduism
@@ashishmishra3612 if you breakdown your sentence into smaller sentences it will be easier to understand it also whats the point of stereotyping people just because you dont agree with their views...all those with different viewpoints are not anti-nationals or doing propaganda. if you have any specific data points, share them. generic statements se kya hoga?
@@ashishmishra3612 aise generic statements marne se kya phayda? Convince people with data not with high level statements or with trolling or spreading hate
Sometimes it's funny to hear Pakistani program. First they need to address extremist inside their country. Don't worry Indian democracy very strong than ur imagination
it was as true as the statement that pakistan's democracy and media is free from is it's army. These are some ISI planted people for satisfaction of pakistani people.
@@lordmephisto6654 thank you from Religion of peace. You are reason most peace in the world and almost everyone in UN peace list are from your fraternity. But I don't think everyone from your community is spreading peace , some are kaffirs and should be treated badly . Like muslim soldiers and policemen of j &k who were shot or killed while working in Kashmir almost 20,000 of them by peace spreaders.
Festival in lahore. Topic is where is india headed? Ok. It's heading towards wrong direction. How are you and your discussions going to control it? Had you discussed where is Pakistan heading it would have made sense.
What an ill informed talk!! Its aim seems to be to peddle a narrative. The fact that it is being done in Pakistan seems to be to further ‘otherise’ India and make them more radicalised.
These jokers sitting in Pakistan talking about India. If you are real intellectuals and educationist you should be sitting in front of home audience and talk where they are wrong and what they should do. All these people talk about how India in past was great and exceptional. If that was true, how come western govt was so much inclined to Pakistan and not India at that time???
Isn't it boistrrous to say that if you agree with the viewpoint of this panel then you are civilized otherwise not. To me, these people sound uncivilized, uneducated and ignorant.
India was good in the eyes of the west so long India did not raise its head to protest against the injustices which were inflicted on India for long . But now as India has started doing it because of its new acquired economic status and new position in the world platform, it is bigotry in the eyes of the hypocrites. . The right way of looking at the issue would be, however, to see what you people did in the last 300 years. You would find your record was so brutal and inhuman that you left no parallel for any country to cross it ever. But now you are trying to assume the role of a judge. What hypocrisy. You are simply not qualified for it. You do not have that clean record. History is very rude. Now India will stand up in all world forums and take the humanity along with it. India will show the world what is the right way of living and that would be accepted as the right way by the world .
Watching this a year later. When trump was there, the Hindu extremist killed, and injured hundreds of Muslims in Delhi, and destroyed houses, businesses, and places of worship.
Great debate with four looser what a fake program.Audrey book published a few years ago and only sold seven books what a failure.Since this program BJP economy grows to six trillion dollars,Modiji is a power house.
no, she is not, she is a sham of a historian, she can't speak or understand Sanskrit or Persian completely but claims to have read original sources , such a joke
Gandu, they are sitting under bomb of Pakistan terrorist.... Haha... But point is they are sitting in Pakistan and talking about India.. Ha ha... They know well their earning source is name "India"
When all known India haters sits together and discusses about India in a so called literary festival, we Indians must realize that something very right is happening in India right now. We are aware of the backgrounds of the participants very well. These ill informed people don't realize that India's days of colonial and cultural slavery is over
Aurangazeb was secular and provided religious freedom. He gave free 1GB internet per day to Hindus.
- Audrey TRASHke
Now we know who is funding this trash ?
Jinnah was a Secular too, as he wanted everyone to be secular and never wanted to create a separate country --- Ayesha Jalal
The fact that Audrey is taken seriously is hilarious 😂
Only in Pakistan 😆
only by goras and their pets
...and look at the moderator. - I don't want this to be an India bashing session...but let's do it anyway!
A country which prides upon being an islamic republic debating where India is headed😅😛 Irony committed suicide from 500th floor😂
♨️💯💯
Ha ha ha ..They have invited Audrey ChoosKe (Trusschke) and they are talking about Indian democracy in Pakistan, a terror factory and islamic theocratic terrror camp (its not a country)
Your comment proves that India is in the grips of hndutva terror. India uses terrorism against Kashmiris and uses Afghanistan as a terror industrial complex. Funding all sorts of groups to cause chaos in the region.
...and the audacity of these know-all white people! They just want to preach.
450,000 Kashmiri Hindhus were forced out of Kashmir in 1989-90, 250,000 Hindhus and Sikhs were forced out of Kashmir in 1948.
To these panel, Islamitva in Kashmir or elsewhere, in Pakistan too, is not worth mentioning?
Bolte hai na Bhagwan sab ke sath hota hain now Nitisha visa is banned in india
Audrey 1: Aurangzeb was a noble emperor
Audrey 2: I believe in Human Rights
Conclusion: Only a Legend can dare to say it 😂😂😂
It is misfortune that Lahore literary festival is starting to bigot and spreading nonsense about India.
Do they read books in Lahore ? Many Indians will have more books in their personal collection than getting sold in their book stores 😜😜
1000 hindu girls are converted every year in pakistan and they won't talk about this! Pakistan occupied Kashmir has turned from Shia majority to Sunni majority, they won't talk about the shia genocide! Even Pakistani textbooks have Hindu hatred.
😭😭😭😭😭
this people sitting in terroristan and talking about India
They are talking about terroristan while sitting in Pakistan.
@@sohaibahmed3936 Lol a big joke 😂😂
@@sohaibahmed3936 go check how many in designated terorist from which Country
@@sohaibahmed3936 😂😂.. come out of madarsa
A guy like Swapan Dasgupta should be here, but Pakistan is not ready to digest what he says
They can't afford Das Da🙏🇳🇪
The reason why India was, is and will always be an exceptional country is due to the hindu majority and hindu ethos - but where the line is getting drawn is on nationalism, integrity and anti-Ismalist mindset - hence our enemies are crying!
Rana Ayub is missing
so much talk about Kashmir without a single word on Kashmiri Pandits.
This is supposed to be Literary Festival but I find it more of a bashing, lying n uneducating festival. No wonder Pakistan is at this stage on 06/03/2023.
Congratulations Organizers, Panelist n participants. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Why is lahore litfest worried about india? Lmaoo please
Lamo they can't talk about where Pakistan is heading. That's Ludacris.
Because Pakistan is backwards since its Independence😂😂😂
Hindutva has just started
@Simple Minded 😂😂😂 g**;d me bhawishya dekhne Wala tota🦜 chupa rakha hai Kya janab.
i am hindu. Hinduism is not hindutva
@Simple Minded It will end when the world ends - Islam in comparison has a much shorter lifespan
@Simple Minded Oh please, do not take the Brits too seriously.... 2 billion people follow Hindu and Buddhist faiths in this world - come out of Mohammad's gand
@@adityabanerjee7145 uneducated. your numbers are wrong and east Asian Buddhism is nowhere related to modern Hinduism
I think if they would have devoted such time and energy for Pakistan, Pakistan would be in better position.
If Audrey is historian then I am Elon Musk.
🤣🤣🤣
Let's talk on Balochistan people here... Ha ha.... There are very much suffering in Pakistan then kashmiri.
I am not a supporter of BJP.but discussing this in Pakistan in funny.pakistan lecturing India and western countries on human rights.
Pakistan is not the one lynching people ( Muslims ) for eating beef …
@@haideraliibnakhlaq8823 Pakistani are lynching people for saying truth about pedophilia Muhammad.
@@haideraliibnakhlaq8823 yes bcs pakistanis just abducts little daughters of hindus and sikhs and converts them forcefully and marries them eventually
@@haideraliibnakhlaq8823 just checking on you after 2 years. lol.
A woman could’ve been quilled over the dress she was wearing.
You are stating it as if thousands of mumeins are hanging on trees like Tipu did hundreds of years back.
RIP Prasantha Kumara.
I think she studied at the Pakistani Board of Secondary Education, and for validation, she consults with her Pakistani mentor Ayesha Jalal.
Audrey Truschke - "There is a lot to lose in India that perhaps was lost here [in Pakistan] a long time ago"
Internet restrictions in Balochistan not mentioned by nitasha kaul ..lol
Yes, she also didnt talk about Chile, Papua New Guinea and Congo....lol
@@nirvanabliss73 the thing is they are discussing internet restrictions sitting in pakistan if this debate was happening in sweden or uk then i had not commented about balochistan ..hope u got me why i mentioned Balochistan ..now u can go for chile n congo internet protests
@@aaaravmalhotra4 The topic is 'Where is India headed?' and not 'Where is Pakistan headed'. Now are you saying India is as bad as Pakistan and that the speakers should have mentioned that?
@Vi K @Aaarav Malhotra The topic is 'Where is India headed?' and not 'Where is Pakistan headed'. Now are you saying India is as bad as Pakistan and that the speakers should have mentioned that?
Why is this discussed In Pakistan?
India is heading towards progress..... Pakistan begging for loans from IMF
What an ironic debate on India held in Pakistan! If they want a referendum in Kashmir, then it is high time that India has a referendum on whether Hinduism should be the state religion, like Pakistan has!
Some comments here actually have more likes than this video, speaks volumes.
Has Natasha Kaul ever spoken about the condition of Hindus and other minorities in Pakistan or Bangladesh?
India is unique country... & India doesn't need anybody views on it.... Because of India all u are surviving on earth
@Simple Minded ha ha.... They are talking so negative about india don't you feel thoda zyada ho gaya... Or this people have nothing to do then talking on india......
@Simple Minded to meine kya zyda nahi bol sakti kya...? Mujhe kya terrorist ki permission leni padegi...?
I wonder why she has to say proove her credentials by saying "As historian I" before saying anything.
Audrey don't worry, your ancestors homeland i.e. Europe will be under shariya law in less than 100 years.
Better than being under hndutva law
@@lordmephisto6654 There exist no Hindutva law. Dumbo
They are talking India and non of them is Indian, they don't know the format of debate! this is called a verdict not a debate!
Natasha mam., we are living in Democratic country ... We have full freedom on speech and our wish that's why we are developed then Pakistan... Ha ba... Don't fool world...
A wonderful nexus of the most righteous people at the most wonderful of places…if you get my sarcasm! 🤧
What some English speaking libtards portray India in international papers, they are not valued/respected even 5% in India.
Eg- Arundhati Roy, Shashi tharoor, Manishankar ayyar, Swara bhaskar. Etc. Bigotry just died😀😀😀🙏
We know why Pakistan is begging from all to fund this India Haters.
Vali Nasr, a total fool. Apparently he does not know that India had 24% of world GDP for most of history! What a fool!
HAHAHAAHAHHA Did Modiji give you that number?
@@lordmephisto6654Pig, if you type in the Google search as 'was India the richest country' the following would appear:
India was one of the richest countries in the world, for about two and a half millennia starting around the end of 1st millennium BC and ending around the beginning of British rule in India. Around 500 BC, the Mahajanapadas minted punch-marked silver coins.
How shameless the panel could be talking abour minorities in pakistan where minorities are eradicated compared to India where minorities are thriving
These feminist sit in Lahore and could not utter a single word on forced conversion of Hindu Girls in Pakistan. Shame on them.
Because feminist argument only applies to nice innocent hindu mens
Audrey claims she is historian but participates in political discussion. She is neither a qualified historian nor a qualified political commentator
Pakistini are discusing about where is India heading. And I am watching it on 8th April 2022 ..
After Imran Khan Niyazi drama...This is most hilarious.
Asked in a country which has no idea about the future, present or past.
2 years down the line Kashmir is heading towards peace without any concentration camps & Pakistan headed into Chaos, hypocrites always proved wrong by time.
Hindu philosophy tells "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" - World is one family, which is the core philosophy of this country & Democratic Republic existed in India from 350 BC in Vaishali, Taxila & Cholas. RSS has the highest number of branches in Kerala but still Kerala has a leftist govt. says a lot about fascist narrative peddle for RSS.
I see why the Kaul girl was deported.
39:40 Nation state must ability to withstand freedom for the public good.
This is getting discussed in bakistan. 🤦🏾
Everyone is taking about Audrey.....but Nitasha is a classic hindu hating liberal character and happens to be a Kashmiri pandit. Wonder why did she leave Kashmir?🤔
Why don't Pakistan discuss on its economy instead of India?
This is like watching Nazis in Germany arguing about bigotry in Nepal
Discussing this in Pakistan? Wow. When did Pakistan become a minority friendly and inclusive country? With less than what 1 or 2 percent minorities, no one to fight, now fighting other Muslim sects, wow, sure Pakistan is perfect host.
These people's predictions tells India is becoming powerful and has civilization proud with the coming days 😂😂
Modi Hai to Mumkin Hay
First they should discuss where England is headed
Out these people no one knows about India all are doing propaganda
achcha..........they are actually talking about Ecuador and not India
@@nirvanabliss73 u can also talk about sun moon god or me but in reality u don't know anything out of these fully and is precisely because ur knowledge about these things is not complete or absolute but u talk about these things as u know everything similar mistake u r doing about India or Hinduism if u have any doubt ask me anything about India or Hinduism I will give right answer u and these fools know nothing about Indian culture or about Hinduism
@@ashishmishra3612 if you breakdown your sentence into smaller sentences it will be easier to understand it
also whats the point of stereotyping people just because you dont agree with their views...all those with different viewpoints are not anti-nationals or doing propaganda.
if you have any specific data points, share them. generic statements se kya hoga?
@@nirvanabliss73 u don't have mind I don't talk to fool people be happy in ur foolish world
@@ashishmishra3612 aise generic statements marne se kya phayda? Convince people with data not with high level statements or with trolling or spreading hate
After this discussion even .."Hope" left Pakistan
Sometimes it's funny to hear Pakistani program. First they need to address extremist inside their country.
Don't worry Indian democracy very strong than ur imagination
They are discussing about Kashmir in Lahore !!!!! Why should anyone care about the opinion of
Pakistanis?
A very informative and excellent panel. Looking forward to more such scholarly gatherings in Pakistan.
lol...to talk abt India? hahaha
Really?
Since they are in pakistan they should discuss on where pak headed and where it landed
What about genocide of 3 million Bengalis in 1971?
After watching this did I learn anything .. yes .. 1 ghant hag diya charon ne
I wish if Shudhansu Trivedi was there in this debate. He would have torn the american and pakistani apart....
The amount of downvotes and hndutrrorr comments by hndutva says how true the discussion in the video was
it was as true as the statement that pakistan's democracy and media is free from is it's army. These are some ISI planted people for satisfaction of pakistani people.
@@hsuyaarchives2526 LOL as expected from a flthyhndu trrorist. Blind to the terror spread by rndian army in Kashmir.
@@lordmephisto6654 thank you from Religion of peace. You are reason most peace in the world and almost everyone in UN peace list are from your fraternity. But I don't think everyone from your community is spreading peace , some are kaffirs and should be treated badly . Like muslim soldiers and policemen of j &k who were shot or killed while working in Kashmir almost 20,000 of them by peace spreaders.
Iskamic terror is dangerous for world
What kind of jokers take Audrey and cabal seriously lol.. propaganda machines. 😂
Why not talking about pakistan?
Vali Nasar, a faculty at John Hopkins. How come John Hopkins can have faculty like him with such disastrous credentials and lack of knowledge.
Sorry, the Moderator Madam Victoria Schofield is not adequately informed. Same goes for the rest of the Panel. Poor show.
Lahore Litereary Festival in pakistan discussing on Bigotry , that too in India 🤣🤣🤣. Too Dark💀💀
There is nothing wrong in India, India was and is and will remain a Hindu Culture constituting a ज्योग्राफिकल एरिया।
All india haters at one platform... Label tells the contents... 😄😄
Festival in lahore. Topic is where is india headed? Ok. It's heading towards wrong direction. How are you and your discussions going to control it? Had you discussed where is Pakistan heading it would have made sense.
Don't worry. Adudery... Modi is enough for you to destroy your career..
People who’re not even seen as intellectuals are given a stage in Pakistan & being portrayed as scholars🤦🏻♂️😂 That’s pure Pakistani level😂
India is heading to become 3 trillion dollar economy 😂
What an ill informed talk!!
Its aim seems to be to peddle a narrative. The fact that it is being done in Pakistan seems to be to further ‘otherise’ India and make them more radicalised.
I'm sorry to say but Natasha is not able to defend India in a proper manner...
Rhizomatic understanding of affinities…yeah screw the plain speak, if you want to sound like an intellectual. 37:59
These jokers sitting in Pakistan talking about India. If you are real intellectuals and educationist you should be sitting in front of home audience and talk where they are wrong and what they should do. All these people talk about how India in past was great and exceptional. If that was true, how come western govt was so much inclined to Pakistan and not India at that time???
See, how human rights question is answer by panelist. he knows how USA used to it.
Glad kaul was deported
Bunch of losers crying together. Today in 2024, their crying has carried on. It will continue for decades to come.
Isn't it boistrrous to say that if you agree with the viewpoint of this panel then you are civilized otherwise not. To me, these people sound uncivilized, uneducated and ignorant.
Where is pakistan now😂😂
32:33 Bingo ⚡
Tight Slap to funding org 🤣
Thank you for the insightful discussion. -love from India
India was good in the eyes of the west so long India did not raise its head to protest against the injustices which were inflicted on India for long . But now as India has started doing it because of its new acquired economic status and new position in the world platform, it is bigotry in the eyes of the hypocrites. . The right way of looking at the issue would be, however, to see what you people did in the last 300 years. You would find your record was so brutal and inhuman that you left no parallel for any country to cross it ever. But now you are trying to assume the role of a judge. What hypocrisy. You are simply not qualified for it. You do not have that clean record. History is very rude. Now India will stand up in all world forums and take the humanity along with it. India will show the world what is the right way of living and that would be accepted as the right way by the world .
Kaul 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Narivad kha se aa gya😂😂😂😂😂
Aur tm baithi kha ho😂😂😂😂
Watching this a year later.
When trump was there, the Hindu extremist killed, and injured hundreds of Muslims in Delhi, and destroyed houses, businesses, and places of worship.
😂😂😂😂
@@thethreespikes9737 thank you for showing more Hindu extremism, well done.
@@youknow6968 pathetic 😂😂
@@thethreespikes9737 aren't you just, pathetic.
🤣🤣🤣
@youknow6968 say the person who kills innocent people every single day for heaven and women
Dogs
Good Joke by mediocre Andrew Trushke.
More like audrey tate
Great debate
Great debate with four looser what a fake program.Audrey book published a few years ago and only sold seven books what a failure.Since this program BJP economy grows to six trillion dollars,Modiji is a power house.
And India has gone to the south pole of the moon,while great Pakistan is begging everywhere.
human rights? 😂
what about animal rights you eat as your meal ?
Matured debate
Funny conversation.Ha Ha Ha
ye toh heavy komedy ho rahi h
Lol
Pakistan ka paisa kha ke baite hai dalala
Oh, you are their accountant?
India is in big trouble.
Oh so india is in great trouble this is she speaking in pakistan wow
balochistan ke baare me baa karke dikha na, nautanki kar rahe ho pakistan me baith ke
Audrey Trushke is well versed with India. I love listening to her.
no, she is not, she is a sham of a historian, she can't speak or understand Sanskrit or Persian completely but claims to have read original sources , such a joke
So many butt hurt hindutvans in the comment section lol. An excellent and intelligent panel. Well done Lahore Lit Fest.
Gandu, they are sitting under bomb of Pakistan terrorist.... Haha... But point is they are sitting in Pakistan and talking about India.. Ha ha... They know well their earning source is name "India"
Hahahaha. Fuck Islam. We proudly say
@15:50 Countries need wealth to democratize. LOL . By that yardstick Whole of Arab peninsular should have been a democracy.