Nothing will happen. More soldiers will die until the government realizes that it has to urgently buy American or Israeli systems in the 11th hour.That is a story repeatedly happening in India. Remember after balkot strike our fighter pilot was captured by Pakistani soldiers while flying an antiquated plane against F 16s.DRDo se kuch nahi hoga
Is it true that the Spike ATGM was tested in the Thar desert (can't recall the year) & its seeker failed to distinguish between the target & its surroundings because of the extreme temperatures?
DRD0 is a white elephant 🐘 While in Army I interaced with it for 10 years . They couldn't produce a standard RIFLE even. 5.56 mm INSAS rifle was good to kill birds . Pakistan army was using Hecklor & Koch German rifles. Thanks to PM Modi to bye 70 thousands SIGSAUR rifles from USA and start manufacturing AK 203 in India
Condensing 14 years of history into 7 minutes, good one Snehesh 👍 Great going Print team, would also place a small request for a "Defence by Snehesh" section in the home page 😊
@@robinsonfrancis1498 bro don't know wtf he was talking about. He only have cursery knowledge and don't know there are tens of thousands in reserved storage, much less the inventory in the Army of various countries.
ATM Project was initiated in 1960s itself. At that time it was wire guided ATM. Many successful trials were made by 1967- 68 itself but not in transfer stage to Army
Yes, but Ukraine is using drones to destroy Russian tanks. So need to wonder if you India should invest such things because those missile are are very expensive.
@@stormbless373 No Indian. There is tremendously new innovation and technology in war and you guys are like two steps behind. Just remember on a tank their frontal and side armor is thick but the top is very thin to save on weight. The rear normally has engine and must have fents for exhausts. So they are very vulnerable to drone attacks.
@@stormbless373 Also, with drones you can track your enemy movements and call in artillery support from a fire base in area. Also, you can lay mines this is the biggest innovation. So let say the Chinese attack you and a mine blows up one their tanks. You sending in a drone and let drop a mine so that if the try to go around the exploded Chinese tank that tank will blow up too. The Ukrainians do this to the Russia all the time.
So heaven are going to drop weapons? No country sells best of specification to any other countries it is always downgrade version that the sell at high price. You can't upgrade foreign origin weapon. So i.
Our space achievement has huge contribution from west and soviet union. Not saying we were not doing anything, we always have that ambition and initiative but severely lacking in any innovation in space technology. All our remarkable achievements are using existing technology and are coming from our long term decades old commitment, in that sense i expect more from ISRO. Also we are relatively good in launch vehicles, which are perishable equipments which will end up in ocean after few minutes of its assigned operation. When it comes to military or aviation, it needs reliable lasting sophisticated mechanical and electronic equipments. We are not good in these sophisticated technology field. Good example is that we are still struggling to build an indigenous jet propulsion engine.
First it was called NAG, then HELINA, now DHRUVASTRA and MPATGM but the system is still not ready. We can continue developing our own MPATGM but we shouldn't miss out on American Javlin because these systems will be extensively used in future warfare and even in counter insurgents operations...!!
India has Spike. Some quantity. Version that is mounted on vehicle has better range is bigger than Javelin. Infantry atgm version ,Javelin is better as long as US provides same latest EFC they use for themselves. Other than that its up to preference. I think Javelins will go to mountain corps Spike will be integrated to Apaches like US/Israel does…
Similar systems, but spike has many variants with the LR variant having a rage of 25 km or so. Overall spike is a better system . The spike variant equalant to javelin is lighter. Both the missile have top attack and direct fire mode. But spike has larger foldable control surfaces which may provide it slightly better flight characteristics than javelin. But I believe it's better go for a locally developed system rather than a foreign one even of its not the best of the best. If it works and has a 90+% chance of getting target, it's better to opt for it. That might give the scientists and engineers chance to improve the system over the years in later variants. Just my opinion🙏🏼
Why does the DRDO try to do everything?? even the largest defence firm in the world don't try to do everything because it's almost impossible. They have specialization in some specific field.
@@divyanshraiswal6969 Yar! we dont need aircraft carrier. We are working on making portable ATGM but believe me its going to light weight with long range not like the one your DRDO is displaying, I can bet that Indian armed forced will not accept this crap and will soon be sent back for changes.
do you know even why is it in testing phase?? When you dont understand technology, dont talk!!! The IA wanted minimum distance of fire from top and straight to be 150 m and max at 4 kms..All other foreign systems have it at 400 m as minimum distance..Compared to that DRDO has brought it to 200 m and max at 4 km..a lof engineering is required!! And the test that has happened is without wires which can be said that this is in final stages!!! Understand requirement and technology snehesh!!
Don't parrot alpha defense narrative here.. American javelin, French akeron has min range of 150m in top attack mode. While min range of 60m in direct attack mode.
@@nishantshrivastava9674 When you come with an agenda and when you do not understand challenges in defence product development, dont speak..I understand this because my brother works in one of the DRDO labs..There are lot of issues with DRDO but in the recent years they have changed their way of working..There are legacy issues which are being solved...With Ranbaxy even though being private, they had such legacy issues....With Zorawar, they have demonstrated that they can change..You have been made to hate and criticize what is yours ...Also check with the Armed forces, how frequently their requirement changes..I am into cybersecurity sales and its a task to sell defence organisations a software..If they are looking for a car, they expect it should be able to fly, sail everything etc!!!
My question is what the hell is the army doing 🤬🤬🤬. Why can't it give specification beforehand of the requirements. Why is it that it has issues after the product is made? Really pathetic 😡😡😡
Nothing will happen. More soldiers will die until the government realizes that it has to urgently buy American or Israeli systems in the 11th hour.That is a story repeatedly happening in India. Remember after balkot strike our fighter pilot was captured by Pakistani soldiers while flying an antiquated plane against F 16s.DRDo se kuch nahi hoga
Is it true that the Spike ATGM was tested in the Thar desert (can't recall the year) & its seeker failed to distinguish between the target & its surroundings because of the extreme temperatures?
DRD0 is a white elephant 🐘
While in Army I interaced with it for 10 years . They couldn't produce a standard RIFLE even. 5.56 mm INSAS rifle was good to kill birds .
Pakistan army was using Hecklor & Koch German rifles. Thanks to PM Modi to bye 70 thousands SIGSAUR rifles from USA and start manufacturing AK 203 in India
It was neutral or political angles are included !!
That's why no one trusts DRDO's timelines 😂😂
Condensing 14 years of history into 7 minutes, good one Snehesh 👍
Great going Print team, would also place a small request for a "Defence by Snehesh" section in the home page 😊
14 years of Javelin production was exhausted in a year in Ukraine.
Exhausted? What do you mean by that?
@@robinsonfrancis1498 bro don't know wtf he was talking about. He only have cursery knowledge and don't know there are tens of thousands in reserved storage, much less the inventory in the Army of various countries.
@@robinsonfrancis1498 Used up, finished, no more javelin videos from Ukraine.
@@captainnemo8072javelin still destroying Russian tank,US aid package to Ukraine still have javelin missile.
Or it's from the newly approved German stockpile.
This shows our collective lethargy against adversaries who are progressing by the day in developing new advanced weapon system technologies
ATM Project was initiated in 1960s itself. At that time it was wire guided ATM. Many successful trials were made by 1967- 68 itself but not in transfer stage to Army
DRDO has become multi-generation dream place ?
Where's the print school link in discription??!
Hi,
Thank you for flagging it to us. We apologise for the inconvenience caused. Here’s the link for application: school.theprint.in
They are still in testing phase.😏
Yes, but Ukraine is using drones to destroy Russian tanks. So need to wonder if you India should invest such things because those missile are are very expensive.
@@HellBot-gi5si drines doesn't substitute ATGM
@@HellBot-gi5si only reason they are doing that is bcz they are lacking Supply of US Javelin ...
@@stormbless373 No Indian. There is tremendously new innovation and technology in war and you guys are like two steps behind. Just remember on a tank their frontal and side armor is thick but the top is very thin to save on weight. The rear normally has engine and must have fents for exhausts. So they are very vulnerable to drone attacks.
@@stormbless373 Also, with drones you can track your enemy movements and call in artillery support from a fire base in area. Also, you can lay mines this is the biggest innovation. So let say the Chinese attack you and a mine blows up one their tanks. You sending in a drone and let drop a mine so that if the try to go around the exploded Chinese tank that tank will blow up too. The Ukrainians do this to the Russia all the time.
atmanirbharta at cost of security...disaster in making!
So heaven are going to drop weapons? No country sells best of specification to any other countries it is always downgrade version that the sell at high price. You can't upgrade foreign origin weapon. So i.
It's always better to develop your own weapons and defence systems than importing outdated weapons at high cost
India better just stick to making drones. They are way better options when dealing with tanks.
Why, we can sent satellite to moon,.mars, but still lacking in arms for our forces?😮😮 3:10
Yes, these DRDO scientists need to replace with some ISRO guys..
Our space achievement has huge contribution from west and soviet union. Not saying we were not doing anything, we always have that ambition and initiative but severely lacking in any innovation in space technology. All our remarkable achievements are using existing technology and are coming from our long term decades old commitment, in that sense i expect more from ISRO. Also we are relatively good in launch vehicles, which are perishable equipments which will end up in ocean after few minutes of its assigned operation. When it comes to military or aviation, it needs reliable lasting sophisticated mechanical and electronic equipments. We are not good in these sophisticated technology field. Good example is that we are still struggling to build an indigenous jet propulsion engine.
Khichdi
Khichdi
Khichdi
Is all that I heard
Arm-chair experts in the comments are at it again.
Yeah anything with DRDO is crap you dumbo
First it was called NAG, then HELINA, now DHRUVASTRA and MPATGM but the system is still not ready. We can continue developing our own MPATGM but we shouldn't miss out on American Javlin because these systems will be extensively used in future warfare and even in counter insurgents operations...!!
It is a Mule Portable Anti Tank Missile from DRDO.
Specifically designed for mule like you.
What ? 15 years developing?😂
I think some diwali fireworks can travel longer distance than this indian product😂
They are testing minimum distance hit. Even javelin has minimum distance hit of 200-250 metre.
Can anyone explain the difference between spike and javelin which one is superior
India has Spike. Some quantity. Version that is mounted on vehicle has better range is bigger than Javelin. Infantry atgm version ,Javelin is better as long as US provides same latest EFC they use for themselves. Other than that its up to preference. I think Javelins will go to mountain corps Spike will be integrated to Apaches like US/Israel does…
Similar systems, but spike has many variants with the LR variant having a rage of 25 km or so. Overall spike is a better system . The spike variant equalant to javelin is lighter. Both the missile have top attack and direct fire mode. But spike has larger foldable control surfaces which may provide it slightly better flight characteristics than javelin. But I believe it's better go for a locally developed system rather than a foreign one even of its not the best of the best. If it works and has a 90+% chance of getting target, it's better to opt for it. That might give the scientists and engineers chance to improve the system over the years in later variants. Just my opinion🙏🏼
Why does the DRDO try to do everything?? even the largest defence firm in the world don't try to do everything because it's almost impossible. They have specialization in some specific field.
Get Javelin , it works! Jai Hind!
Congratulations 🇮🇳 Jai Hind ❤
DRDO - Delayed Regressive Dumber Organization.
Can someone tell me which technology has the US actually transferred to other countries? I am guessing never. If yes, when will we learn our lesson?
DRDO need to reform
Us always delay its joint venture then suddenly withdraw... Its their tactics to delay our desi technology
Javelin are too expensive we should make our own javelin like this.... Good job by DRDO.
It's power of made in india ❤
USA Should not purse to deal until India supplies ammunition to Ukraine
😅 it will be overshadowed by Javelin... Its for sure, import lobby
Please dont teach your students to serve the italian family like how its happening.
Army want imported product give them that and stop wipping DRDO
Why is he eating paan
Not good quality at all
DRDO😂😂😂
The Military should make do with what DRDO has. They cannot insist on Nike Addidas shoes to learn football like an adamant spoiled kid.
Guys, pls don't ever consider joining Shekher "fraud" Guptas school of journalism!
What a joke, Look at the video, its not Man-portable ATGM but a fixed ATGM, low 3rd class qualilty weapon by DRDO.
That is man portable that man conducting trial is not a army personel.
Bhai tum konsa weapons banate hoon,jab aircraft carrier banao fir ana😂😂😂
So you should be happy since this gives you advantage. Why are you giving feedback?
@@divyanshraiswal6969 Yar! we dont need aircraft carrier. We are working on making portable ATGM but believe me its going to light weight with long range not like the one your DRDO is displaying, I can bet that Indian armed forced will not accept this crap and will soon be sent back for changes.
At least they are trying what your contribution Mr mulla 🤦
We should make are our own hardware with our technology....
do you know even why is it in testing phase?? When you dont understand technology, dont talk!!! The IA wanted minimum distance of fire from top and straight to be 150 m and max at 4 kms..All other foreign systems have it at 400 m as minimum distance..Compared to that DRDO has brought it to 200 m and max at 4 km..a lof engineering is required!! And the test that has happened is without wires which can be said that this is in final stages!!! Understand requirement and technology snehesh!!
Why is it always in tripods if i is manportable? Can it be shoulder fired?
Don't parrot alpha defense narrative here..
American javelin, French akeron has min range of 150m in top attack mode.
While min range of 60m in direct attack mode.
@@nishantshrivastava9674 When you come with an agenda and when you do not understand challenges in defence product development, dont speak..I understand this because my brother works in one of the DRDO labs..There are lot of issues with DRDO but in the recent years they have changed their way of working..There are legacy issues which are being solved...With Ranbaxy even though being private, they had such legacy issues....With Zorawar, they have demonstrated that they can change..You have been made to hate and criticize what is yours ...Also check with the Armed forces, how frequently their requirement changes..I am into cybersecurity sales and its a task to sell defence organisations a software..If they are looking for a car, they expect it should be able to fly, sail everything etc!!!
My question is what the hell is the army doing 🤬🤬🤬. Why can't it give specification beforehand of the requirements. Why is it that it has issues after the product is made? Really pathetic 😡😡😡