This song is so beautiful not just because of the melody and the lyrics, but also because it shows Red Velvet's beautiful harmonization. Honestly all RV b sides are worthy of a performance which is why their concerts are so amazing.
@@shineexokpop6824 You're a hater. Wendy is definitely higher than top 10. You are the one spreading misinformation. Go focus on your less talented favs.
I didn’t know that wendys hight note is that long and the fact she managed to continue harmonizing with members at the end. Seungwan best girl! Red velvet jjang!!
@@requiem5151 wendy had a really bad accident during the sbs gayo 2019 that left her bed ridden for months and she had to have multiple surgeries to recover from it. please be a little bit more understanding.
@@requiem5151 She broke her jaw sis and she didn't get plastic surgery to fix it, her face always looked like this she is also skinnier in her face this comeback which is also normal??
@@Rosevieenla yes seulgi and yeri usually are the loudest especially that they has the most distinct voices in RV while joy has low voice while irene and wendy almost has similar tones..when doing harmony you can pinpoint their voices
I thought so too.....her high harmonies almost ended me....I don't remember being hit like that for a part of a song....she hit me real deep!!! Maybe I do have a soul!!!
i can't believe redvelvet actually perform their top-tier bside on a music show omgg like im still waiting for body talk, kingdom come, so good, in and out etc bruh likeee
Kpop will always have a backtrack tho.., it's a backtrack for the studio speaker and for the listener like us who watched them through virtual nor live.. sometimes 2e can Hear their voices more bcoz they sing loudly I mean their vocal u can hear more but sometimes idol dnt sing that much so ppl will see they look like lypsinging.
@@Lunafreya_Nox yeah but I think for this performance, since they're just sitting, theu opted to sing love. The backtrack we hear are mostly the harmonies. There are performances where the backtrack for the front vocals can be heard but the live voices are louder. In this one, it's mostly harmonies. Or I could be wrong. It's just based on what I hear. Hehehe
@@keienn7259 Yeah, I agree with you. The backtrack are just harmonies. But in the the later part(last chorus) of the song they mostly sang the harmonies.
@@Lunafreya_Nox SM should refrain from making their artists lip sync most of the time. This is how it was before, backtrack is present but volume is lower than their mic
I agree with that backing track being too loud. I think it affected their performance a little bit, especially Yeri's. But no performance is gonna be perfect and it's still lovely getting to hear this. I hope they come to the states in 2023. I'd love to see them live.
When everyone praises Wendy for the amazing and unbeatable vocal in this generation, I am really impressed how every member harmonize and did their part beautifully, especially irene and yeri who are in charge of completing their harmonization in their beautiful low register voices.
I love this. No forced dance for it. Appropriate melancholic expressions. Just them and their angelic voices. This song immediately shot up to my top 10 RV songs. It's been on repeat since release.
@@REd-mw4ll I agree. That's why she's #1 vocalist for me. Wendy can sing in so many different ways and voices. Have you heard her on 55? I've never heard her sound like that. Simply blew my mind. Again.
Since debut I wanted Red Velvet to perform a song without any dancing, just pure vocals, on a music show. Now after 8 years seeing them perform "In My Dreams" feels surreal. Best harmonization in KPop indeed, they sound like angels. And lastly, OT5 looking happy and stunning is what every Luvie wishes for 💖💛💙💚💜
Actually they served the best ballad in " One of these nights" tho, but it feels good to see more ballad song of them, serving not only vocals, but visually pleasing
@@remyratatata Nope, I didn't. OOTN did have a simple choreo, right? What I meant to say is that, I wanted them to ONLY sing and NOT dance on a LIVE MUSIC SHOW (something like SM station×Red Velvet 'Would U' and 'Milky Way'). Sorry if my wording was confusing.
@@seulgi.gyu.yoongi.jongseong I recommend you to check their performance for Wish Tree, it's a short performance but they did great too :D I hope you;ll like it
Although I don't hate when idols don't sing live during promotions because we understand the physical pressure they have but I can always appreciate amazing live vocal when I see one.
Two perfect velvet voices, one higher and one lower (Seuilgi and Irene), two perfect brigth voices, one higher and one lower (Joy and Yeri), and the absolute prodigy of the industry (Wendy). This combination of talent and luck won´t repeat in a hundred years in Kpop.
ik mistakes arent necessarily a good thing but 0:39 when wendy mixes up the lyrics its nice to see theyre actually singing live and u can actually hear their voices
I can't believe SM let them sing live. I'm so estatic right now, this song is so beautiful, I wish the back track was a little less loud but I'm just so happy to hear their live vocals again after so long
I am so so happy that Red Velvet performed this wonderful song, live. In My Dreams is my most favorite b-side from the album mainly because of how good they sang it. The lyrics is also beautiful. Red Velvet's vocals and harmony are top-tier! 🥰 also, they all shined in this song. I love how every member are given the parts that shows how beautiful their voices are. I hope Red Velvet would perform this again, this is just really beautiful. 🤍
Demi apapun mereka cantik bangeettt. Aku se happy itu sama style mereka yg sekarang. Ntah stylish nya ganti atau sekarang udah sadar🤣, pokoknya good job SM. Lagunya enak bet lagi, terdabes deeh in my dreams 😍. Suara mereka tidak usah diragukan lagi man teman
It proves they're not lipsync.. Wendy you successful to silence haters with your accidental mistakes.. Dont worry, we always love you💙💙💙 💙💛💚💜❤️red velvet💙💛💚💜❤️
my bf and i are music majors and he has always disliked kpop, by the end of this album he was singing along to the “in my dreams you love me back” during the prechorus and when i told him the album was over after the song ended he wanted it to be longer. it literally felt surreal as it was happening it felt like i was seeing a fake story actually happen and as im typing it out i would probably think it was fake if i read it somewhere lmaoo
@@cornzznhe finds most of it uninteresting, he has told me that when i show him kpop he just listens to the instrumentals and not really the vocals and he likes the songs that have interesting chord structures, which this album had a lot of
We fans are so lucky that we're alive and witnessing RV's building up their discography in every cb I don't know any group whose par in terms of discography bruh 😍
@@moonlight-io8ey this is your opinion. i love both twice and red velvet and i started stanning them both at the same time. i listen to both twice and red velvet's most recent albums (from after 2017-2018) and i wouldn't be able to choose my favorite in terms of music
Vocal & Harmonization Queens : Joy sweet voice ✓ Yeri deep voice ✓ Irene husky voice ✓ Seulgi powerful vocal ✓ Wendy highnote ✓ in this song everyone has their own voice character plus the harmonization is very beautiful, its like eargasm.
Irene's singing in In My Dreams reminds me so much of her performance in her and Seulgi's Monster album. This particular tone of hers is haunting and beautiful; perfect for, for lack of better term, "creepy" and epic songs. And now, we'll get to hear more of it once 'Marionette' (part of their 1st Japanese full album, 'Bloom') drops on March 28!!! If you haven't listened to its highlight yet, it's posted on their official Japanese accounts (TWT and IG).
The more times I hear this song, the more I appreciate every member of the group. RV harmonizes like no other and this song is a perfect example. I hope they break through the typical K-pop barriers because these ladies deliver time and time again.
Irene's 'in my dreams you love me back' part is my fav. Like it gives me chills in a pleasant way! Her voice really gave out the meaning of the emotion of painful one- sided love and the hope that comes with it. If you understand what I'm saying. Btw tell me your fav part. And lastly my girls back with another outstanding performance.
![Cosmic - Red Velvet レッドベルベット 레드벨벳 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240628](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/66xQLVKZoY4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Cosmic - Red Velvet レッドベルベット 레드벨벳 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240628](/img/tr.png)
bamboleo and rainbow halo are bsides that i like, but in my dream are bside masterpieces that shouldn't be skipped
I love all.
Personally not really a fan of in my dreams
@@shineexokpop6824
You Just can't compliment them without hating. Why are you even here? Go away.
@@eyebrowstj pff you are the one to say that. I like all the other bsides but not in my dreams. Are you here to drag Seulgi again?
@@eyebrowstj Difference in opinion ≠ Hate, in fact they stated their opinion more respectfully compared to a lot of other brutal stans on here 😭
Wendy sang that high notes while sitting down. What a queen!!
Indeed. No one is on her level.
Best Vocalist of 3rd gen indeed 💙
Exaggeration
Wendy is a queen, but I would hope she would be able to hit that high note while sitting still...
@@luxenn it’s harder to hit high notes sitting down than standing
Red Velvet has the best harmonies in K-Pop. They're just perfect.
fact
They are the queens of harmonization :')
This is not mamamoo
true, but snsd and mamamoo also come to mind when it comes to best harmonies. Love all three groups because of their great vocals.
@@mydilemma447 stay mad
1:27 Wendy's voice flows like water but it hits like a tsunami. I'm so crazy about how she sang that line smoothly!
I appreciate With you
Wendy do you love me yes or no
Also, her eyes contact actually went through my heart😂
I wait
Maybe that’s why we all love her voice, cuz both are like water lol
This song is so beautiful not just because of the melody and the lyrics, but also because it shows Red Velvet's beautiful harmonization. Honestly all RV b sides are worthy of a performance which is why their concerts are so amazing.
Wendy's high harmonies at the end almost finished me!!!! OH MAN!!! This is beautiful!!!
Red Velvet really are queens of harmonization!
For once that they didn't need to dance and this song was so perfect its one of my favourite b track song
Wendy doesn't have to prove to anyone that she's the best and finest singer in the industry
Okay that is a reach but she is insanely good!
@@shineexokpop6824 among the female idols she is probably on top 5 or even 3 of the best ones for me.
@@shineexokpop6824 idc she's fvcking good and we can appreciate her without trying to make it seem like she's not
@@ericacella1180 she is maybe in the top 10 but definitely not the best. You can praise her but let’s not promote misinformation.
@@shineexokpop6824
You're a hater. Wendy is definitely higher than top 10. You are the one spreading misinformation. Go focus on your less talented favs.
I didn’t know that wendys hight note is that long and the fact she managed to continue harmonizing with members at the end. Seungwan best girl! Red velvet jjang!!
You know wendy always go for extra. mile...
Was it necessary for Wendy to undergo plastic surgery I wonder? SM as always with their manufactured looks.
@@requiem5151 wendy had a really bad accident during the sbs gayo 2019 that left her bed ridden for months and she had to have multiple surgeries to recover from it. please be a little bit more understanding.
@@requiem5151 ? Wendy had plastic surgery because she had an accident.
@@requiem5151 She broke her jaw sis and she didn't get plastic surgery to fix it, her face always looked like this she is also skinnier in her face this comeback which is also normal??
1:27 Best part. Wendy’s voice is silky smooth and full of soul. GROWN WOMAN VOCALS.
@@skzot8255 a stray kids fan talking about racism is hilarious
@@skzot8255 stop letting us stays seem toxic, stays 💜 other fandoms too. If u were a real stay u would do the same as bangchan and love everyone.
@@ericacella1180 your girl is literally a repeat offender and you dare to talk about others 🤣
@@rika3707 I like the other 4 though. Just don't like racists
@@skzot8255
Good for you. Here's a cookie. Eat it and go away.
We still stan Wendy.
Signed,
Wendy's #1 black fan 😁😁
I always hear Yeri's voice the loudest whenever they are harmonizing.
me too, her voice make red velvet’s harmonize sounds more unique
It's mostly wendy and seulgi
@@nothingmattersoi9487 Seulgi and Yeri lead their harmonies most often. Especially on especially tight harmonies like their cover of Milky Way
@@Rosevieenla yes seulgi and yeri usually are the loudest especially that they has the most distinct voices in RV while joy has low voice while irene and wendy almost has similar tones..when doing harmony you can pinpoint their voices
It's the RV sound
this is Yeri and Wendy's song they absolutely dominate
Exactly
by the gays.. for the gays
finally seeing a comment about Yerene. Our rappers sounded absolutely amazing here!
Wendy's ad-libs are causing me to ascend. Red Velvet is such a vocal powerhouse and this song is giving me all the feels.
I thought so too.....her high harmonies almost ended me....I don't remember being hit like that for a part of a song....she hit me real deep!!! Maybe I do have a soul!!!
i can't believe redvelvet actually perform their top-tier bside on a music show omgg like im still waiting for body talk, kingdom come, so good, in and out etc bruh likeee
Body talk is probably my all time favorite RV song
We have similar taste omg
Kingdom Come stan first, human second.
Same taste in bsides
@@notjp388 yasss i love kingdom come so much!
There's a backtrack but still their vocals stood out and you can clearly hear it 😭😭😭 omoooo my cake girls be slayin' always
The backtrack is mostly just for the harmonies too, not the main singing parts. They're really singing the song live! 😍
Kpop will always have a backtrack tho.., it's a backtrack for the studio speaker and for the listener like us who watched them through virtual nor live.. sometimes 2e can Hear their voices more bcoz they sing loudly I mean their vocal u can hear more but sometimes idol dnt sing that much so ppl will see they look like lypsinging.
@@Lunafreya_Nox yeah but I think for this performance, since they're just sitting, theu opted to sing love. The backtrack we hear are mostly the harmonies.
There are performances where the backtrack for the front vocals can be heard but the live voices are louder. In this one, it's mostly harmonies.
Or I could be wrong. It's just based on what I hear. Hehehe
@@keienn7259 Yeah, I agree with you. The backtrack are just harmonies. But in the the later part(last chorus) of the song they mostly sang the harmonies.
@@Lunafreya_Nox SM should refrain from making their artists lip sync most of the time. This is how it was before, backtrack is present but volume is lower than their mic
Didn't notice Wendy's high note was so long, I'm so impressed
That backing track is too loud but it cannot stop Wendy. My favorite part is her line at 1:27
she harmonizes so well with herself
I agree with that backing track being too loud. I think it affected their performance a little bit, especially Yeri's. But no performance is gonna be perfect and it's still lovely getting to hear this. I hope they come to the states in 2023. I'd love to see them live.
PUKUPUKUPAWPAW
Wendy overpowering the backtrack and doing that high note while sitting prove yet again why she’s 3rd Gen’s MAIN VOCAL 💙💙💙💙💙
Wendy’s high note while sitting and their vocals is stunning.
I love her so much.
When everyone praises Wendy for the amazing and unbeatable vocal in this generation, I am really impressed how every member harmonize and did their part beautifully, especially irene and yeri who are in charge of completing their harmonization in their beautiful low register voices.
True
I’m all for these two’s lower register voices😭 It just calms me down and add so much to the song
OMG I TELL U THIS IS WHAT IM THINKING
her voice is so stable tf yiyiybiyb8yn8uyfvygbihbyfted i cant
So true and in this so g the line distribution is pretty much equal which goes to show they are all very great singers!
1:26 i don't know why but I am obssessed with this part ☺
2:59 phenomenal
So am i. It reminds me of some other classical song or movie. I'm still figuring out which one
@@HeyDeka maybe snow white?
Wendy belting at the end and nailing the high note runs WHILE SITTING!! She's a vocal master, absolutely incredible
Wendy that high note run 💙 can't believe we got hit that drum 2.0 😭
What do we expect? It’s KBS 😑😑😑
The cameraman always messy
THIS 😭😭😭
and that intro queendom duet solo part on award show 😭😭😭😭
3:00 oh my god this part is so beautiful Wendy's highnote 😭😭
I love this. No forced dance for it. Appropriate melancholic expressions. Just them and their angelic voices. This song immediately shot up to my top 10 RV songs. It's been on repeat since release.
Wendy's as an Ultimate Vocalist is like none other in both 3rd and 4th gen
Absolutely! Wendy's vocals are phenomenal 👌
So strongly agree.....her high notes near the end....just about exploded me!!!
She's the most versatile vocalist too! Her techniques are unmatched!
they dont produce people at her level anymore sadly
@@REd-mw4ll I agree. That's why she's #1 vocalist for me. Wendy can sing in so many different ways and voices. Have you heard her on 55? I've never heard her sound like that. Simply blew my mind. Again.
Wendy hitting the highnote effortlessly 😭 goosebumps
Since debut I wanted Red Velvet to perform a song without any dancing, just pure vocals, on a music show. Now after 8 years seeing them perform "In My Dreams" feels surreal. Best harmonization in KPop indeed, they sound like angels.
And lastly, OT5 looking happy and stunning is what every Luvie wishes for 💖💛💙💚💜
Actually they served the best ballad in " One of these nights" tho, but it feels good to see more ballad song of them, serving not only vocals, but visually pleasing
did you miss one of these nights lmao
@@remyratatata she/he said “to perform a song without dancing”. One of these nights has dance parts tho.
@@remyratatata Nope, I didn't. OOTN did have a simple choreo, right? What I meant to say is that, I wanted them to ONLY sing and NOT dance on a LIVE MUSIC SHOW (something like SM station×Red Velvet 'Would U' and 'Milky Way'). Sorry if my wording was confusing.
@@seulgi.gyu.yoongi.jongseong I recommend you to check their performance for Wish Tree, it's a short performance but they did great too :D I hope you;ll like it
Although I don't hate when idols don't sing live during promotions because we understand the physical pressure they have but I can always appreciate amazing live vocal when I see one.
Yes so true i mean they’re pursuing their dreams to be a singer not a dancer
Wow Wendy is so talented. This is the most satisfying live singing for me, red velvet always slaying
1:27 and 3:00 best parts of the song. Wendy just killing it as always!
wendy's vocal and technique >>>>>>>>>>>
@1:27 Wendy's voice here was so clear and beautiful and her high notes please!
Wendy's vocal is so incredible
YOU GO WENDY!! EAT THIS SONG UP!! YALL HEAR THOSE VOCALS?!
Joy Seulgi and Wendy's vocals are no joke.. beautiful and angelic voices
Two perfect velvet voices, one higher and one lower (Seuilgi and Irene), two perfect brigth voices, one higher and one lower (Joy and Yeri), and the absolute prodigy of the industry (Wendy). This combination of talent and luck won´t repeat in a hundred years in Kpop.
Wendy Is Really Queen of Vocal
wendy singing that note live oh god it’s a sin not to focus the camera on her in those seconds
WENDY VOCAL HITS DIFFERENT, ITS AMAZING !!!!!
Wendy’s high note is so beautiful 🥺
Ok but the way Wendy delivered the parts from 1:27 & 3:00 are just amazing. How could she make her parts so addicting?
ik mistakes arent necessarily a good thing but 0:39 when wendy mixes up the lyrics its nice to see theyre actually singing live and u can actually hear their voices
wendy hitting those notes while sitting down 🥲 she's unreal 💙
It's not a surprise that when they perform live they sound 100% exactly like the CD 💓💙💛💚💜
Red Velvet is the top notch #1 Vocal Queens 🐰🐿🐻🐥🐢
Wendy always no 1 God blessings with
Yayayaya 💖💛💙💚💜
Exactly! The backtrack is kinda annoying though because it echoes in their raw voice. I'm glad they overpowered it in some parts
Can't you hear the back track? Not completely live
1:27 wow this is so beautiful. 💙
3:00 Wendy's vocals omgg 😍
I can't believe SM let them sing live. I'm so estatic right now, this song is so beautiful, I wish the back track was a little less loud but I'm just so happy to hear their live vocals again after so long
Those were their loud vocals tho
I am so so happy that Red Velvet performed this wonderful song, live. In My Dreams is my most favorite b-side from the album mainly because of how good they sang it. The lyrics is also beautiful. Red Velvet's vocals and harmony are top-tier! 🥰 also, they all shined in this song. I love how every member are given the parts that shows how beautiful their voices are. I hope Red Velvet would perform this again, this is just really beautiful. 🤍
Demi apapun mereka cantik bangeettt. Aku se happy itu sama style mereka yg sekarang. Ntah stylish nya ganti atau sekarang udah sadar🤣, pokoknya good job SM. Lagunya enak bet lagi, terdabes deeh in my dreams 😍. Suara mereka tidak usah diragukan lagi man teman
Stylist mereka baru ganti waktu zaman queendom...
Mgk skrg msh sama...
Kalau ga salah emang sm mau treat rv better atau gimana lupa! Sepertinya sm baru sadar rv itu mutiara mereka !🤍
@@jasmine_soo8839 pantesan ya, auranya kek lebih bersinar (menurutku)
@@Abcdefghisauu Ceo nya ganti, dan g cuma RV yg di perlakukan lebih baik tp semua artis SM, seneng sih liatnya
iyaa bener banget.. ini semuanya menonjol banget visualnya, ngga cuma fokus di beberapa member doang
Red Velvet’s harmonization and their vocal presence are people sleeping.
I love how Yeri's voice is so distinct here
Red Velvet are queen of harmonies and Wendy's live vocals will just blow your mind.
WENDY VOCAL QUEEN
WENDY'S VOCAL IS REALLY AMAZING
Waaahh wendy's vocal is insane💙💙💙
Suka banget part Wendy waktu nyanyi menit 1:27 bagus banget 😭
Harmonisasi mereka juara lah❤️👍
“in my dreams you love me back” this part is such a masterpiece
It proves they're not lipsync.. Wendy you successful to silence haters with your accidental mistakes.. Dont worry, we always love you💙💙💙
💙💛💚💜❤️red velvet💙💛💚💜❤️
Even her mistake sounded phenomenal! LOL!
@@eyebrowstj wait... SHE MADE A MISTAKES?!?!? where what part??
I'm also curious, at what part did she made a mistake?
@@yugamiphilinglykasaiko7321 she sing the wrong lyrics in the first verse
@@dear_soph06 she sang the wrong lyrics 0:37
WENDY’S VISUAL N VOCAL 😍✨
RV=Real Vocal Real Visual 👏
Visual? 😂
@@skzot8255 yes , visual
@@natalie-lj2on lmao
@@natalie-lj2on agree
@@skzot8255 She's beautiful
RED VELVET VOCAL QUEENS
yes
Yess
WENDY SHON I HAVE NO WORDS YOU TOOK MY BREATH AWAY
I’m glad they decided to sing live in a sitting stage like this… SM could thing rationally at least once
my bf and i are music majors and he has always disliked kpop, by the end of this album he was singing along to the “in my dreams you love me back” during the prechorus and when i told him the album was over after the song ended he wanted it to be longer. it literally felt surreal as it was happening it felt like i was seeing a fake story actually happen and as im typing it out i would probably think it was fake if i read it somewhere lmaoo
may i know why he disliked/dislikes kpop?
@@cornzznhe finds most of it uninteresting, he has told me that when i show him kpop he just listens to the instrumentals and not really the vocals and he likes the songs that have interesting chord structures, which this album had a lot of
@@dreamcaught3876 he'll probably like Lee Jin Ah, Sam Kim, AKMU, or NCT(if he's interested in boy group lol)
Perhaps RV will be his gateway drug...
@@drea2578 AKMU, yes! Also, OP can also try to let him listen to WINNER, they have a diverse genre of music~
Wendy's vocal are really crazy 😱💙🥰
when they sing the chorus all together and wendy harmonized with some vocals at the end.... it is a masterpiece
They are amazing!!! Wendy's voice is out of this world!
1:27 this part is beautiful 💙
Who can belt high notes like that while sitting??
Yas Queens
Lots of love from the Philippines
Their visuals are so surreal
ik that was rhetorical but kinda ignorant given that you're from ph
@@mashih03 haha sentence construction is very wrong haha
@@mashih03 english is not our first language. most of us know how to speak it but only when needed.
@@mashih03 how is it ignorant
@@mashih03 now that's kinda racist, sit down boi/gurl
We fans are so lucky that we're alive and witnessing RV's building up their discography in every cb I don't know any group whose par in terms of discography bruh 😍
Probably Twice. They both consistently release amazing title track
@@bomapdich no hell no
Thuc Nguyen twice’s overall discography is not on the same level as red velvets, this is a fact.
@@moonlight-io8ey this is your opinion. i love both twice and red velvet and i started stanning them both at the same time. i listen to both twice and red velvet's most recent albums (from after 2017-2018) and i wouldn't be able to choose my favorite in terms of music
@@moonlight-io8ey it’s not a fact since it’s what you think.
Wendy you did so well, dont be sorry. You are the best singer 💙
They all look like angels but I have to say Yeri looked absolutely stunning in that colorful flower dress.
Yeri’s voice always stands out to me in harmonies , I can hear her tone and power 💜💜💜💜💜
best part wendy's part at 1:27 😍😍😍
Standing ovation for Red Velvet and all the team. Their sincerity toward this album is so heartwarming.
Yeri's voice dominating the chorus and i love it. This girl really needs spotlight to showcase her voice.
i think its seulgi
@@ekkllkki5647 it’s both very evident in chorus
Seulgi and Yeri maybe,
truee
Red Velvet's vocals are dreamy and full of emotions. They shine like diamonds this comeback. In My Dreams is a perfect fit for fairytale's soundtrack
seulgi's voice in the chorus is so powerful!! dance + vocals + visuals she got it all truly an ace 👏💗
still now, i don't get on why some ppl still come for their vocals. this harmonization here is just one of their heavenly vocal performances.
because they still can't accept the fact and don't want to admit that RV eat cds 😌
omg, wendy's vocal is amazing
LW era Wendy came by to add some divine vocals at the end
WENDY, YOU DID SO WELL, AAAAAH
PRINCESS WENDY👑
Ending Wendy and Yeri are beautiful 💙💜🤩
Yeri looks exceptionally beautiful and confident here! Red velvet did so well!!
Their voice blend so well..
Wendy highnote on top...
Vocal & Harmonization Queens :
Joy sweet voice ✓
Yeri deep voice ✓
Irene husky voice ✓
Seulgi powerful vocal ✓
Wendy highnote ✓
in this song everyone has their own voice character plus the harmonization is very beautiful, its like eargasm.
Wendy the best vocal of KPOP
Each Red Velvet member has their own vocal cover that compliments each other therefore the harmony is 💖💜💙🧡💚
I START TO CRY! AFTER HEARING 5 OF THEM SING SO BEAUTIFULLY AT FINAL CHORUS.
It has been so long since we heard POWERFUL LIVE VOCALS like this! 🤧💞
sameeee😭
Help, I cant control my shivers
ME TOO I AM TEARY EYED 🥺😭
It's like someone let the air in 😭
@@Lafilledlapluie literally 😭 it's overwhelming especially the drop of the first chorus it sound so good I wanted to melt
Irene's singing in In My Dreams reminds me so much of her performance in her and Seulgi's Monster album. This particular tone of hers is haunting and beautiful; perfect for, for lack of better term, "creepy" and epic songs. And now, we'll get to hear more of it once 'Marionette' (part of their 1st Japanese full album, 'Bloom') drops on March 28!!! If you haven't listened to its highlight yet, it's posted on their official Japanese accounts (TWT and IG).
I know right!? I especially adored her part in the 2nd pre-chorus, I keep coming back to it.
Omg exactly
What to do unfortunately people doesn't have the taste of Irene as we have for her! I love irene so much
Ikr! I like her voice s lot
@@smolseal i love her head when she does poney tail hairstyle
I want to listen to this forever. I really love Wendy's high note!😍💙
The more times I hear this song, the more I appreciate every member of the group. RV harmonizes like no other and this song is a perfect example. I hope they break through the typical K-pop barriers because these ladies deliver time and time again.
Irene's 'in my dreams you love me back' part is my fav. Like it gives me chills in a pleasant way! Her voice really gave out the meaning of the emotion of painful one- sided love and the hope that comes with it. If you understand what I'm saying. Btw tell me your fav part. And lastly my girls back with another outstanding performance.
Me too 🤩🤩 Irene's phrase is always repeated in my mind ..
Yeri's dress is so beautiful she's like a spring fairy 🌸😍💜
This is why RED VELVET is one of the Best VOCALS in 3rd GenGroup😍 Their VOCALS is no joke they are The Best In Singing Live❤💙💛💚💜
Wendy is our Original Vocalist! ♡
YERI AND WENDY ENDING FAIRIES!!!! SO PRETTYYYY
2:59 SO PRETTY THOSE HIGH NOTES R SO SATISFYING OMFG SHES PERFECT AHHH
The most talented idols all in one group I can’t believe luvies got this lucky. We will always love you red velvet
WENDY THE FINEST VOCALIST💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
wendy does 3:00 so effortlessly it's amazing
I was so sad because I thought I wouldn't be able to hear them live again because of SM. Now I'm so happy omg 😭😭
they always sing live what r u on abt
@@ellanote2260 another fan who doesn't know the difference of prerecorded and live vocals. Nevertheless, rv slayed this live.
@@ellanote2260 Are you not updated? SM is not letting their artists sing live.
@@yanicles7084 ikr lol
@@stacyjenns3906 U mean Aespa yes, other than that the rest sing live, ur the one whos not updated LOL