I've had a vivoactive 4 for years now and love it. The loss of the altimeter stinks but realistically it only tracked stairs for me and that's not something that's a concern in my house full of stairs. I'm the person who needs a "casual" fitness watch and this fits that pretty well. I'm very happy with my vivoactive 4 and will likely ask for the vivoactive 5 for Christmas.
My 4 died after a brief trip into the sea last week. Beyond annoyed but the timing works for a 5 upgrade - though yeah, the loss of the barometer is baffling and only discovered by me an hour ago after it turned up. I just didn't think they'd be removing features like that within a range.
I agree with venu and vivoactive, but the forerunner(especially 955) has many differences. I fell the 955 and the fenix should be one with having a plastic option
@@DylanTK for me the fenix/epix series is a combination between the Venu and Forerunner Series. These both a subsets of the epix/fenix. Forerunner with a sports Focus (2xx Light Version) and venu/va with a smartwatch/health Focus (vivoactive as a Light Version). A combination between the VA and FR2xx as a fenix/epix-light would be great on the other hand.
WOW!! I’m seriously at awe how you’ve devoted to diligently study this watch to make this very in depth 18 min video…. You said it yourself, the smart watch industry is way to complex and broad for regular people like me to understand what we need. Thank you. I’m buying this watch!
Please make an in depth comparison between venu 3 vs vivoactive 5, it would be super helpful for people deciding between the 2 watches! I think another good Garmin to compare to both is the Instinct 2, besides the different screen type it has similar features and is priced in the middle of the vivoactive and venu.
This watch seems like amazing value and a great choice for the more casually gym-go'er/runner/moderately active person, who thinks the price of the venu 3 is kinda steep, I like it! great review, thanks!
Yes absolutely. I stumbled on this watch and I am considering it more and more, and may in the end not get an Apple watch as I was supposed to initially.
3:38 I love these sort of comparison. If we can get these over more days, gives us a great understanding of these devices!! Thanks for sharing that. I really found that table SUPER insightful.
17:35, yeah, same think im looking for a watch and is very hard to learn what doing all models to choose the best one for your pocket. Finally im stoped between: Venu 2 Plus, Forerunner 265, Vivoactive 5, Instinct 2 Solar and i still learn which is the best for me. But anyway any Garmin watches is good.
Same. Was excited about the Vivo 5 until heading about the lack of altimeter. As a cyclist and mountain biker, altimeter was really important. I'll hold on to my Vivo 4 until it croaks then look elsewhere, I guess.
I just bought the Vivoactive 5 because its one of the very few out on the market with a Wheelchair Mode. From what I've seen of other people with disabilities, Garmin's system is better than most of the competitors. I really hope that I can tweak the settings to match me, especially at this price point. For instance, my heart rate physiologically caps at 130, due to a damaged peripheral nervous system. I believe it can move with me to acknowledge that bit. It'll be interesting to see if it changes for energy expenditure accurately, seeing that most people don't have to bodily throw themselves out of bed. Your review has put some of my concerns to rest! Its nice to know that its as accurate as most other watches, or at least close enough to be effective. It took me a long while to finally decide to do this and only really to help monitor my general health. I don't expect perfection, just reminders and trackers. The music piece is actually a nice bonus as well.
Agree. Garmin just swimming in their sea of watch models. Got tired of deciding on the next upgrade with Garmin and just switched to Pace 3 myself, just keep it simple.
I went deep with all kinds of reviews. I basically figured you have to pick a price range you are comfortable with first. Lots of the 500+ are just full of stuff you might not need. Personally I found the 255 which is $300 to $350 has all I need. Just think about what you need, not only what is on it. If you don't need it, get a lower model. You should pay for what you need.
Basically it's the same, though it looks a tad less expensive, has 3 days less battery life, no floors count and you can't speak with it like you're on the phone. Oh, and it's something like 150$ dollars less than the Venu 3. Now you can pick which one you fancy.
The larger Venu has a 1.4” screen. That’s the most significant difference for the typical Vivoactive/Venu user. The lack of altimetry in the Vivoactive makes it a non-starter for me. A shame, as all the previous generations had it. But if that’s not important, the VA5 is better than the Venu 1, cheaper and has a more vivid 1.2” screen , the same size as the original Venu.
My Vivoactive 4 has been steady and reliable, but I like these upgrades and the price works. I would really like the Venu 3 for ECG and ability to take calls.
Couldn’t agree with you more. Garmin needs to streamline their watch models because trying to tell my customers why this watch is basically a Venu but cheaper and why is it cheaper is just so confusing for them and frankly for myself also.
I got this watch for Xmas I love it is great comfortable I've had on 4days straight8 only took off for 5mins it's got so many great features on it I would recommend this watch for sure especially if your not tech savvy it's easy to use
I've got a long history of Garmin watches, and the Vivoactive/Venu bracket is where I pitched my camp some years ago. I still have a Vivoactive HR, a Vivoactive 3, a Venu and a Venu 2+. I'll probably pick up the Venu 3 in a month or two. I kind of got the parallel marketing of the MIP VA4 and the amoled Venu 2/2+; it echoed the relationship between the Fenix and Epix, and the FR255/265, and 955/965. But it's getting a bit ridiculous. I agree that Garmin needs a watch at the $299 point. They could have taken the opportunity to merge and rebrand the Vivoactive, Venu and Forerunner lines into a single product tree with SKUs at 199, 299, 399, 499 and 599, with clear and logical distinctions between the products and an aspirational route to upgrade. Instead, this is a mess!
As a current owner of a VA4, neither is the successor I was looking for. I'd basically like a FR255 with touch. Will stay on my VA4 for as long as it holds up....
I disagree. The Forerunner clearly is aimed at runners that want to prepare for competitions while venu and VA are for more casual users that want SmartWatch features
I have a Vivoactive 4 and was looking to upgrade. It's really disappointing they removed the altimeter, it's basically makes tracking skiing/snowboarding useless and also no mic like the new Venu
@@moritztweber That's the plan now just disappointing to see features removed from the Vivoactive. I believe the 4 was $350 now the "replacement" is $450
@@moritztweberI don't need my watch to be a Bluetooth speaker when my phone can't be more than a couple of meters away. Also would have liked the VA line to stay on MIP, like Fenix vs. Epics. But the barometer is a feature that already was there
Great review, thank you. My vivoactive 3 music broke this weak after going to the indoor pool and I got myself the vivoactive 5. I hope it can withstand the water better. I also think Garmin should merge some of their watches but keep the price range. I've been using the vivoactive line for years now and they are good and also afordable.
I previously had a Fitbit, but I'm exploring other watch brands as I want a change. The final point you make about Garmin's portfolio, absolutely spot on! As potentially a new customer to Garmin, I am confused as fuck as to where to start with their product range. Thanks for the video & review 👍🏻
Have you chosen a new watch yet? I've been a Fitbit user for a decade, but with my current Versa 4 reaching its last leg and Fitbit being discontinued by google soon I'm looking at the Garmins.
Picked one up for $189 during Black Friday. I wish the bezel wasn't so big (and display not so small) but for the price its good. I needed to replace my vivoactive 3.
Really nice review. I have the vivoactive 4 for a year now, but after 2 weeks in the sea, it starts to act a little weird, with sometimes very slow charging, to fast drop in charge levels, to funny screens on restart. I assume this is because of the extended exposure to sea water. Hence I wanted to change the watch and get a casual watch (with touchscreen, Garmin Pay and open water swimming) and Vivoactive 5 seems to fit pretty well. I could figure this out because of your review, so thats a lot!! You are also totally write about crazy amount of models, doing very similar stuff and with different pricing etc. Videos like this one helps in deciding 👍
Holy cow music for 299! And I tooooootally see its place in the lineup because now they really have polished, solid, strong offerings at literally every price point, save an ultra cheap option. Awesome video as always. Always watch yours first! Super super well organized and clear on differentiating aspects and benefits and features
As discussed the other day on the Instinct 2 series: Eventually Garmin will realize they're just making things messy and potentially killing their own products with that many confusing watch series models and "unpredictable" features releases.
yep, they should stop wasting time and effort on so many different models and focus on a couple models with all the features combined. They would be king in the sport/smart watch sector, especially as Apple just can't rival the battery life.
Yeah. Where I am at, they are selling the Venu 2 for like 319€, while the Vivoactive 5 isn't even available yet and will cost 299€...Unless the price drops to like 249€, you are better of with Venu 2 while stock still lasts...
Would you please do a comparison video of the Vivoactive 5 and the Venu 3? It would be nice to know which features I wouldn't have if I went with this watch over the Venu 3.
Great review. Much appreciated. Just for your SA. I teach GPS stuff for a living. You will get less accurate readings when you are running down town close to high rise building. The GPS signal does what is called a multi path where the signal bounces off the buildings and gives you a less precise location. Conversely, in an open field where you have great access to the sky, you should get much more accurate locations. Thanks for the review.
Cheers. My primary motivation in looking at these watches was that the PM2 in our gym's antique concept 2 died, so i have no stroke rate info etc. I got a loaner PM4 computer but that died too. All I really want it to do is to give me stroke rate info, work out time and heart rate info (though I bought a cheap external HRM which should be connectable), and I can glean from the watch at a glance. Seems that this one is the closest without going for the superexpensive ones that have many things that I won't use.
I had a cardiac event a few months ago (died 3 times) and picked up a cheap watch to monitor my heart rate but when I say cheap I mean $19 so I think it's time to step up my game and have been waffling between this watch and the Samsung 6 and the Garmin Venue 3. I'm 65 so taking that into account and my "event" my extreme days are gone and consist mainly of Pickleball, hikes, walks and bike rides so this might work just fine,,,, thoughts?
I understand Garmin wants a wacth at this price point and this feature set. But isn't this the Venu Sq's spot? In my mind that was the baby Venu. Garmin needs to consolidate all these different models. I work at a retail store and it's confusing for people wanting to buy their first watch and complicated for the person selling it. People will stand literally for an hour trying to figure out what they want or not even buy a Garmin at all. I think Coros is doing a much better job at this.
Great review. Do you know if this watch has a replaceable battery because it it’s starting to seem like all of these smart watches are somewhat disposable which is frustrating.
screen covered with light scratches after 3 days of use although the hardest objects it came in contact were bed sheets and clothes. it feels like it's covered with cheap plastic or just regular glass. otherwise great functionality and data
Wow, im suprised how much off the sleep tracking is compared to the other devices at 3.37 - Its something thats really important to me and since my fenix7x got the same sensor it would mean its also completely off - fall asleep and wake-up times, yikes! Is this a hardware or software related issue to Garmin watches?
I so wish it had a barometer / altimeter. The only thing that almost made me upgrade to the Venu 3. But the price of the Vivoactive 5 is much more reasonable considering all the features it has.
Not the watch I hoped for. Stay on MIP. Newer sensors. Hiking and open water swimming. Maybe daily training recommendations. That's what I wanted as a current VA4 owner. The VA5 should have been the "Venu 3 lite" or "LR" (like Light & Round", matching SQ for square)
Finally a VivoActive 5! I’ve had a VivoActive 3 and currently have a VivoActive 4, which is getting near the end of its life. Personally I would pay £450 for the Venu 3 and thought my next watch will probably be another VivoActive 4 or Apple Watch SE. The VivoActive 5 is priced well at £280 and could be my next watch. Only downside I can think of is, no altimeter sensor. Garmin have not long bought out challenges or expeditions, this watch would be no good for getting the climbing badges in Garmin Connect.
I decided yes, I'll get a Garmin, thought it would be easier once that was decided, but there is too much to think about. Tho I love the purple, so might just opt for that
I’d love to know what your best watch recommendation would be for best bang for your buck? As someone who isn’t a runner but interested in other sports (climbing, skateboarding, snowboarding, hiking) which watch would be best suited that’s not at the highest price point?
Hello, can you please tell me if the watch shows resting calories? Also, does it calculate how many calories have been burned by monitoring heart rate or by counting footsteps? Thank you!
Altimeter removal is a deal-breaker for me. Another exclusive feature I loved about the Vivoactive line was the Transflective memory-in-pixel display. It allowed for an always on display that was perfectly visible even without a backlight in normal lit rooms and daylight. It gave the feel of a traditional watch where you could glance at it and read information without it needing change states. Also the increased battery life is a huge plus. I don't need a high definition display on my watch if it means losing those features. It's a fitness tracker first and foremost for me, and Garmin's initial appeal for me was the absence of gimmicky smart watch features I can do more easily with my smartphone in my pocket. I'm disappointed and will be looking at other lines from Garmin.
The Vivoactive 5 is the slimmest Garmin watch, except for the fitness bands, so I bought one as addition to my FR965. As a ballroom dancer, I need something to wear under a tailcoat. I formerly had the Polar Ignite series (9,5mm), but after switching to Garmin I needed something similar and with 11,1mm, the VA5 is as close as one could get. As much as I love the Garmin ecosystem, not everyone needs extreme endurance in bulky watches. I would luckily trade half of the battery time for a watch
I have a Vivoactive 3 and was thinking I might upgrade to the 5 but good food for thought here. I am a walker, exerciser, swimmer and cycler but not particularly high level. I really liked knowing elevation increase but sort of recognized that on my watch, it was not highly accurate. On my bike, I often pair watch with an older Edge 800. As you can see, I have long term relationships with my electronics. Any how, I will take some time to decide between the Venu and Vivoactive. I also really like my watch face to be analog and to show a second hand and I will see if that's an option unless someone can just say here. Thanks for the review.
I got one of these for me wife recently and she’s mystified by the features and the learning curve. Speaking for myself, I just want to know whether and/or when her heart stops!
Basically a Venu 2 with Venu 3 software unlocked (HRV, nap detection, mornig reports, etc) but with an aluminum bezel and one size only. They should just have updated the Venu 2 software. Disappointed with Garmin's exasperated fragmentation of their offer.
Between this one and the last gen Venu 2S, which one would be a better choice ? I don't really mind not having altimeter. Sleep and activity / HR tracking is my main goal.
Is there any way to turn off the timeout setting? I have mine set to ALWAYS ON but it times out. I went into the timeout setting but it does not have a way to turn it off like older Garmin's.
Clearly the Venu 3, but it's hard to see all differences in a good overview. It has a more modern sensor, higher quality materials and smaller bezels, which might be the most obvious changes. Yet, I'm not certain if that justifies paying more than 400 Euro.
Vivoactive 5 is better technologically but it has some features removed that he lists at 8:38. Forerunner 255 is not a good option if you want something significantly better than that VA4
Any tips for GPS not working any more on the vivoactive 4s? I’ve already tried updating, resetting and restarting both phone and watch. Also tried keeping the watching searching for gps.
I own a vivoactive 4 and while investigating the venus 3 this new vivoactive series came out. I dont get the different lines as they look too similar 🤷🏻♂️
Yesterday I received Suunto Vertical bought for 320 E. Great build quality watch. Today Amazon made me thinking as I reserved this Garmin for 225 E. Would you guys downgrade to Garmin model and save 95E? I know they are two completely different watches. I love sapphire glass and stainless steal of the Suunto. On the other hand I would love to have Garmin soft. Their functions and HR sensors are just much better.
I was 2-year long user of VA4 and was perfectly satisfied with it, but time came to upgrade, so i am now on Fenix 7 SS, which brings me to the question; any insider info on adding Sleep Coach and Nap feature to fenix 7 range?
@@stennan I was in the market for a new watch recently (time has come to replace my ancient Fenix 5) and was seriously considering the 965 instead of Fenix series. I guess the new HR sensor was one of more important factors for going with a Fenix 7 Pro - I don’t change my gear too often so I want the new stuff when I buy it. But actually at the moment the difference in HR sensors isn’t great, the 5th gen in testing is maybe slightly more accurate than the 4th gen but the 4th is already very good. And the ECG is not working at all as of now. For this they have to have it certified as a medical device and there is no official timeline for this. There is even a slim chance it won’t happen at all.
I agree thay all those different watches are very confusing for customers. But also for Garmin. As they roll out updates to the watches, i noticed that they specs on the website are not updated timely or at all. For example, I have a Instinct 2s Solar which has Garmin pay on it, but last time i checked the website specs said it did not. A shame if that would be a deal breaker for someone.
Will this watch pair with an indoor trainer? Im having trouble connecting mine to my trainer and am wondering if i would have the same issue with a venu 3 or higher watch
I've had a vivoactive 4 for years now and love it. The loss of the altimeter stinks but realistically it only tracked stairs for me and that's not something that's a concern in my house full of stairs. I'm the person who needs a "casual" fitness watch and this fits that pretty well. I'm very happy with my vivoactive 4 and will likely ask for the vivoactive 5 for Christmas.
My 4 died after a brief trip into the sea last week. Beyond annoyed but the timing works for a 5 upgrade - though yeah, the loss of the barometer is baffling and only discovered by me an hour ago after it turned up. I just didn't think they'd be removing features like that within a range.
Garmin needs to just merge Venu, Vivoactive, and Forerunner at this point. Wayyyyy too many similarities.
Agree
I agree with venu and vivoactive, but the forerunner(especially 955) has many differences. I fell the 955 and the fenix should be one with having a plastic option
I agree in terms of say FR265/Venu 3/VA5. Those three should all just be combined.
@@DylanTK for me the fenix/epix series is a combination between the Venu and Forerunner Series. These both a subsets of the epix/fenix. Forerunner with a sports Focus (2xx Light Version) and venu/va with a smartwatch/health Focus (vivoactive as a Light Version). A combination between the VA and FR2xx as a fenix/epix-light would be great on the other hand.
So, basically, it’s a round Venu SQ, that renews the Vivoactive trademark.
WOW!! I’m seriously at awe how you’ve devoted to diligently study this watch to make this very in depth 18 min video…. You said it yourself, the smart watch industry is way to complex and broad for regular people like me to understand what we need. Thank you. I’m buying this watch!
Please make an in depth comparison between venu 3 vs vivoactive 5, it would be super helpful for people deciding between the 2 watches! I think another good Garmin to compare to both is the Instinct 2, besides the different screen type it has similar features and is priced in the middle of the vivoactive and venu.
The sleep coach and nap features are quite cool. I hope that these new widgets will be updated on the the first edition Epix Gen2 or Fenix 7 models.
This watch seems like amazing value and a great choice for the more casually gym-go'er/runner/moderately active person, who thinks the price of the venu 3 is kinda steep, I like it! great review, thanks!
Yes absolutely. I stumbled on this watch and I am considering it more and more, and may in the end not get an Apple watch as I was supposed to initially.
As a first time smart watch buyer, I wholeheartedly agree about complicated lineup of products
3:38
I love these sort of comparison.
If we can get these over more days, gives us a great understanding of these devices!! Thanks for sharing that. I really found that table SUPER insightful.
17:35, yeah, same think im looking for a watch and is very hard to learn what doing all models to choose the best one for your pocket. Finally im stoped between: Venu 2 Plus, Forerunner 265, Vivoactive 5, Instinct 2 Solar and i still learn which is the best for me. But anyway any Garmin watches is good.
So disappointed they removed Stairs. I feel like I need to stick with the Vivoactive 4 for this reason. Thanks for all of the great information!
Same. Was excited about the Vivo 5 until heading about the lack of altimeter. As a cyclist and mountain biker, altimeter was really important. I'll hold on to my Vivo 4 until it croaks then look elsewhere, I guess.
because of this downgrade I got 955 after vivoactive 4
I just bought the Vivoactive 5 because its one of the very few out on the market with a Wheelchair Mode. From what I've seen of other people with disabilities, Garmin's system is better than most of the competitors. I really hope that I can tweak the settings to match me, especially at this price point. For instance, my heart rate physiologically caps at 130, due to a damaged peripheral nervous system. I believe it can move with me to acknowledge that bit. It'll be interesting to see if it changes for energy expenditure accurately, seeing that most people don't have to bodily throw themselves out of bed.
Your review has put some of my concerns to rest! Its nice to know that its as accurate as most other watches, or at least close enough to be effective. It took me a long while to finally decide to do this and only really to help monitor my general health. I don't expect perfection, just reminders and trackers. The music piece is actually a nice bonus as well.
Agree. Garmin just swimming in their sea of watch models. Got tired of deciding on the next upgrade with Garmin and just switched to Pace 3 myself, just keep it simple.
Now we need comparison to Venu 3 please
As I’m totally confused how garmin releases watches and which one to get right now
and fenix 5 plus
I went deep with all kinds of reviews. I basically figured you have to pick a price range you are comfortable with first. Lots of the 500+ are just full of stuff you might not need. Personally I found the 255 which is $300 to $350 has all I need. Just think about what you need, not only what is on it. If you don't need it, get a lower model. You should pay for what you need.
Basically it's the same, though it looks a tad less expensive, has 3 days less battery life, no floors count and you can't speak with it like you're on the phone. Oh, and it's something like 150$ dollars less than the Venu 3. Now you can pick which one you fancy.
The larger Venu has a 1.4” screen. That’s the most significant difference for the typical Vivoactive/Venu user. The lack of altimetry in the Vivoactive makes it a non-starter for me. A shame, as all the previous generations had it. But if that’s not important, the VA5 is better than the Venu 1, cheaper and has a more vivid 1.2” screen , the same size as the original Venu.
My Vivoactive 4 has been steady and reliable, but I like these upgrades and the price works. I would really like the Venu 3 for ECG and ability to take calls.
Couldn’t agree with you more. Garmin needs to streamline their watch models because trying to tell my customers why this watch is basically a Venu but cheaper and why is it cheaper is just so confusing for them and frankly for myself also.
I got this watch for Xmas I love it is great comfortable I've had on 4days straight8 only took off for 5mins it's got so many great features on it I would recommend this watch for sure especially if your not tech savvy it's easy to use
Do you still recommend the watch?
What about the battery?
Thanks for the all-round review as always.
I've got a long history of Garmin watches, and the Vivoactive/Venu bracket is where I pitched my camp some years ago. I still have a Vivoactive HR, a Vivoactive 3, a Venu and a Venu 2+. I'll probably pick up the Venu 3 in a month or two. I kind of got the parallel marketing of the MIP VA4 and the amoled Venu 2/2+; it echoed the relationship between the Fenix and Epix, and the FR255/265, and 955/965. But it's getting a bit ridiculous. I agree that Garmin needs a watch at the $299 point. They could have taken the opportunity to merge and rebrand the Vivoactive, Venu and Forerunner lines into a single product tree with SKUs at 199, 299, 399, 499 and 599, with clear and logical distinctions between the products and an aspirational route to upgrade. Instead, this is a mess!
As a current owner of a VA4, neither is the successor I was looking for. I'd basically like a FR255 with touch. Will stay on my VA4 for as long as it holds up....
Agree, I'm getting tired of Garmin´s model and premium price diversity.
I disagree. The Forerunner clearly is aimed at runners that want to prepare for competitions while venu and VA are for more casual users that want SmartWatch features
I have a Vivoactive 4 and was looking to upgrade. It's really disappointing they removed the altimeter, it's basically makes tracking skiing/snowboarding useless and also no mic like the new Venu
why not buy a venu3 if you want all of its features?
@@moritztweber That's the plan now just disappointing to see features removed from the Vivoactive. I believe the 4 was $350 now the "replacement" is $450
@@tchomicz1992 the Barometer, i understand. I'm disappointed for that too, but the mic etc on the other hand...
@@tchomicz1992 the Vivoactive 4 was indeed a very good allrounder.
@@moritztweberI don't need my watch to be a Bluetooth speaker when my phone can't be more than a couple of meters away. Also would have liked the VA line to stay on MIP, like Fenix vs. Epics. But the barometer is a feature that already was there
Great review, thank you. My vivoactive 3 music broke this weak after going to the indoor pool and I got myself the vivoactive 5. I hope it can withstand the water better.
I also think Garmin should merge some of their watches but keep the price range. I've been using the vivoactive line for years now and they are good and also afordable.
I previously had a Fitbit, but I'm exploring other watch brands as I want a change. The final point you make about Garmin's portfolio, absolutely spot on! As potentially a new customer to Garmin, I am confused as fuck as to where to start with their product range.
Thanks for the video & review 👍🏻
Have you chosen a new watch yet? I've been a Fitbit user for a decade, but with my current Versa 4 reaching its last leg and Fitbit being discontinued by google soon I'm looking at the Garmins.
Picked one up for $189 during Black Friday. I wish the bezel wasn't so big (and display not so small) but for the price its good. I needed to replace my vivoactive 3.
Lol - "the flashlight is on and chaos ensues."
Really nice review. I have the vivoactive 4 for a year now, but after 2 weeks in the sea, it starts to act a little weird, with sometimes very slow charging, to fast drop in charge levels, to funny screens on restart. I assume this is because of the extended exposure to sea water.
Hence I wanted to change the watch and get a casual watch (with touchscreen, Garmin Pay and open water swimming) and Vivoactive 5 seems to fit pretty well. I could figure this out because of your review, so thats a lot!!
You are also totally write about crazy amount of models, doing very similar stuff and with different pricing etc. Videos like this one helps in deciding 👍
Shouldn't take it into salt water...
I had my vivoactive 4s for 5 years it quit working and garmin sent me a garmin vivoctive 5 free of charge.worth reaching out
Holy cow music for 299! And I tooooootally see its place in the lineup because now they really have polished, solid, strong offerings at literally every price point, save an ultra cheap option. Awesome video as always. Always watch yours first! Super super well organized and clear on differentiating aspects and benefits and features
The pace 3 do it for 229...
The vivoactive 4 has that Feature for 199
@@Kiev-in-3-daysyeah nut it’s a coros lol
@@30mattdavies It sure is a Coros.
Thanks for review, keeping my vivoactive 4.
Is the nap detection automatic or do I need to set it? It seems to be not working automatically for me when I took a nap 😢
As discussed the other day on the Instinct 2 series:
Eventually Garmin will realize they're just making things messy and potentially killing their own products with that many confusing watch series models and "unpredictable" features releases.
yep, they should stop wasting time and effort on so many different models and focus on a couple models with all the features combined. They would be king in the sport/smart watch sector, especially as Apple just can't rival the battery life.
They should have kept MIP for Vivoactive 5 and add solar. If you want a stripped down version of Venu 3 you can buy Venu 2.
Yeah. Where I am at, they are selling the Venu 2 for like 319€, while the Vivoactive 5 isn't even available yet and will cost 299€...Unless the price drops to like 249€, you are better of with Venu 2 while stock still lasts...
Would you please do a comparison video of the Vivoactive 5 and the Venu 3? It would be nice to know which features I wouldn't have if I went with this watch over the Venu 3.
Completely agree on the final assessment.. Garmin has a confusing range of watchs and feature sets.
Why doesn't the Fenix 7x SS have the Sleep Coach?
One of the best videos I've seen on this watch. Thank you!
Just got my first fitness tracker, this watch is pretty awesome. Great review
Just spent £200 more on what is practically the same watch but says Venu 3 on the box. Thanks Garmin!
Great review. Much appreciated. Just for your SA. I teach GPS stuff for a living. You will get less accurate readings when you are running down town close to high rise building. The GPS signal does what is called a multi path where the signal bounces off the buildings and gives you a less precise location. Conversely, in an open field where you have great access to the sky, you should get much more accurate locations. Thanks for the review.
Cheers. My primary motivation in looking at these watches was that the PM2 in our gym's antique concept 2 died, so i have no stroke rate info etc. I got a loaner PM4 computer but that died too. All I really want it to do is to give me stroke rate info, work out time and heart rate info (though I bought a cheap external HRM which should be connectable), and I can glean from the watch at a glance. Seems that this one is the closest without going for the superexpensive ones that have many things that I won't use.
I had a cardiac event a few months ago (died 3 times) and picked up a cheap watch to monitor my heart rate but when I say cheap I mean $19 so I think it's time to step up my game and have been waffling between this watch and the Samsung 6 and the Garmin Venue 3. I'm 65 so taking that into account and my "event" my extreme days are gone and consist mainly of Pickleball, hikes, walks and bike rides so this might work just fine,,,, thoughts?
You and I need an effective "fall detection" smartwatch that calls a loved one and emergency services upon an event like you and I have had.
I understand Garmin wants a wacth at this price point and this feature set. But isn't this the Venu Sq's spot? In my mind that was the baby Venu. Garmin needs to consolidate all these different models. I work at a retail store and it's confusing for people wanting to buy their first watch and complicated for the person selling it. People will stand literally for an hour trying to figure out what they want or not even buy a Garmin at all. I think Coros is doing a much better job at this.
Great review. Do you know if this watch has a replaceable battery because it it’s starting to seem like all of these smart watches are somewhat disposable which is frustrating.
screen covered with light scratches after 3 days of use although the hardest objects it came in contact were bed sheets and clothes. it feels like it's covered with cheap plastic or just regular glass. otherwise great functionality and data
Wow, im suprised how much off the sleep tracking is compared to the other devices at 3.37 - Its something thats really important to me and since my fenix7x got the same sensor it would mean its also completely off - fall asleep and wake-up times, yikes!
Is this a hardware or software related issue to Garmin watches?
One would think software
Very informative, what do you and your wife take for energy? Those exercise examples are next level, I would love to have that much energy
I so wish it had a barometer / altimeter. The only thing that almost made me upgrade to the Venu 3. But the price of the Vivoactive 5 is much more reasonable considering all the features it has.
buy Vivoactive 4
When you swim lengths with this watch, does it show you how many you have done on the screen in real time?
I just hope the sleep stuff gets updated on the other watches like the 255/955
How does it compare in terms of accuracy in sleeptracking and stressmeasuring with the fitbit sense 2?
Not the watch I hoped for. Stay on MIP. Newer sensors. Hiking and open water swimming. Maybe daily training recommendations. That's what I wanted as a current VA4 owner.
The VA5 should have been the "Venu 3 lite" or "LR" (like Light & Round", matching SQ for square)
Finally a VivoActive 5!
I’ve had a VivoActive 3 and currently have a VivoActive 4, which is getting near the end of its life. Personally I would pay £450 for the Venu 3 and thought my next watch will probably be another VivoActive 4 or Apple Watch SE. The VivoActive 5 is priced well at £280 and could be my next watch.
Only downside I can think of is, no altimeter sensor. Garmin have not long bought out challenges or expeditions, this watch would be no good for getting the climbing badges in Garmin Connect.
Great video and great conclusion 👍 👌 👏
Do any of the Garmin watches have the "hard fall" notification feature?
I decided yes, I'll get a Garmin, thought it would be easier once that was decided, but there is too much to think about. Tho I love the purple, so might just opt for that
I’d love to know what your best watch recommendation would be for best bang for your buck? As someone who isn’t a runner but interested in other sports (climbing, skateboarding, snowboarding, hiking) which watch would be best suited that’s not at the highest price point?
Hello, can you please tell me if the watch shows resting calories? Also, does it calculate how many calories have been burned by monitoring heart rate or by counting footsteps? Thank you!
Does ist supports a automatic training detection?
And if so, is it working precisely?
It seems this watch doesn't have the triathlon option, is that right?
Altimeter removal is a deal-breaker for me. Another exclusive feature I loved about the Vivoactive line was the Transflective memory-in-pixel display. It allowed for an always on display that was perfectly visible even without a backlight in normal lit rooms and daylight. It gave the feel of a traditional watch where you could glance at it and read information without it needing change states. Also the increased battery life is a huge plus. I don't need a high definition display on my watch if it means losing those features. It's a fitness tracker first and foremost for me, and Garmin's initial appeal for me was the absence of gimmicky smart watch features I can do more easily with my smartphone in my pocket. I'm disappointed and will be looking at other lines from Garmin.
What did you end up with??
The Vivoactive 5 is the slimmest Garmin watch, except for the fitness bands, so I bought one as addition to my FR965. As a ballroom dancer, I need something to wear under a tailcoat. I formerly had the Polar Ignite series (9,5mm), but after switching to Garmin I needed something similar and with 11,1mm, the VA5 is as close as one could get.
As much as I love the Garmin ecosystem, not everyone needs extreme endurance in bulky watches. I would luckily trade half of the battery time for a watch
Great review, thanks! Disappointed they last the altimeter for stair tracking.
I have a Vivoactive 3 and was thinking I might upgrade to the 5 but good food for thought here. I am a walker, exerciser, swimmer and cycler but not particularly high level. I really liked knowing elevation increase but sort of recognized that on my watch, it was not highly accurate. On my bike, I often pair watch with an older Edge 800. As you can see, I have long term relationships with my electronics. Any how, I will take some time to decide between the Venu and Vivoactive. I also really like my watch face to be analog and to show a second hand and I will see if that's an option unless someone can just say here. Thanks for the review.
Hi, does vivoactive 5 have built in maps (such as Fénix series with the new forerunners) that can be used for navigation (eg. during cycling)?
Another day, another new Garmin watch 🤣
I got one of these for me wife recently and she’s mystified by the features and the learning curve. Speaking for myself, I just want to know whether and/or when her heart stops!
Basically a Venu 2 with Venu 3 software unlocked (HRV, nap detection, mornig reports, etc) but with an aluminum bezel and one size only. They should just have updated the Venu 2 software. Disappointed with Garmin's exasperated fragmentation of their offer.
Great Summary ❤ i guess they have more than 100 models together and be smart and select a proper one 😂
Between this one and the last gen Venu 2S, which one would be a better choice ? I don't really mind not having altimeter. Sleep and activity / HR tracking is my main goal.
Dose the loss of the altimeter effect gps tracking when hiking trails
Does the watch „count“ the altemeter via GPS if you go for a ride or a hike or is there abolutely no Tracking about the altitude?
Thank you for the in depth review. One question. Can I turn off seeing all the sports possibilities so I don't have to see them on the watch? Thanks!
Really helpful, thank you 😊
Which is better? Vivoactive 5 or Venu Sq 2 Music?
Thats my question too. Because I get the venusq2 music with some Headphones for around 200€ Here in Germany
Great review. Thank you
What kind of sensors can it pair with? Does it work with bike power meters?
Need a detailed comparison with Coros Pace 3
Would the epix (gen 2) be a better purchase now in 2024 even though the epix is 2 years old?
Is there any way to turn off the timeout setting? I have mine set to ALWAYS ON but it times out. I went into the timeout setting but it does not have a way to turn it off like older Garmin's.
Which one is better, vivoactive 5 & venu 3s? By the way, I am also confused why not use MIP screen
Clearly the Venu 3, but it's hard to see all differences in a good overview. It has a more modern sensor, higher quality materials and smaller bezels, which might be the most obvious changes. Yet, I'm not certain if that justifies paying more than 400 Euro.
Venu 3 is better. New HR sensor, altimeter and speaker/voice.
Is this a good watch for casual walking and jogging purposes? Or should i get a much cheaper watch? Want to track my progress thank you!
What?! I have a 4 I love it. I was sad when it seemed they moved on. I was researching so many watches and settled on 255, now I'm curious.
Vivoactive 5 is better technologically but it has some features removed that he lists at 8:38. Forerunner 255 is not a good option if you want something significantly better than that VA4
Do you see the new body battery and sleep features coming to the latest forerunners? Ty for the great review!
Any tips for GPS not working any more on the vivoactive 4s?
I’ve already tried updating, resetting and restarting both phone and watch. Also tried keeping the watching searching for gps.
I own a vivoactive 4 and while investigating the venus 3 this new vivoactive series came out. I dont get the different lines as they look too similar 🤷🏻♂️
Yesterday I received Suunto Vertical bought for 320 E. Great build quality watch. Today Amazon made me thinking as I reserved this Garmin for 225 E. Would you guys downgrade to Garmin model and save 95E? I know they are two completely different watches. I love sapphire glass and stainless steal of the Suunto. On the other hand I would love to have Garmin soft. Their functions and HR sensors are just much better.
"swipe right“ shortcut is on my Vivoactive 4 too... using it for the brightness setting... cos during the day it can be turn off
How do you have no scratches on it? Do you use a case or screen protector? I see tons of people complaining about scratches.
I was 2-year long user of VA4 and was perfectly satisfied with it, but time came to upgrade, so i am now on Fenix 7 SS, which brings me to the question; any insider info on adding Sleep Coach and Nap feature to fenix 7 range?
Not sure why they haven't added the call and text features to the thousand dollar Epix2 line-up. Would be a killer watch.
Does this track spinning?
I just got back from an open water swim and noticed the distance is recorded in feet!
Is there a setting to change it to yards?
Can you use with iPhone telephone or only Samsung
Any guess as to when there will be a Forerunner 9xx/7xx/2xx with the Elevate 5 HR sensor?
Either AMOLED or MIPS (personally would prefer MIPS).
Doesn't the 965/265 have the latest HR sensor
@@stennannope has the v4
@@stennanit has the previous, 4th gen one.
@@rabomarc damn, that is unfortunate. Though I don't know if V5 brings more accurate measurement or if ECG is the only additional feature
@@stennan I was in the market for a new watch recently (time has come to replace my ancient Fenix 5) and was seriously considering the 965 instead of Fenix series. I guess the new HR sensor was one of more important factors for going with a Fenix 7 Pro - I don’t change my gear too often so I want the new stuff when I buy it.
But actually at the moment the difference in HR sensors isn’t great, the 5th gen in testing is maybe slightly more accurate than the 4th gen but the 4th is already very good. And the ECG is not working at all as of now. For this they have to have it certified as a medical device and there is no official timeline for this. There is even a slim chance it won’t happen at all.
Can you set a heart rate alarm at a certain level.
So it doesn’t have altimeter? I can’t track ur altitude? So it’s basically is the same as venu sq 2 then?
I agree thay all those different watches are very confusing for customers. But also for Garmin. As they roll out updates to the watches, i noticed that they specs on the website are not updated timely or at all. For example, I have a Instinct 2s Solar which has Garmin pay on it, but last time i checked the website specs said it did not. A shame if that would be a deal breaker for someone.
Sir, with your experience would you choose vivoactive 5 or instinct 2in terms of features? Don't care about colorfull and touch seen.
Is there a way to set the heart rate zones. I can only change it as a % of the max heart rate, not as a actual number?
Will this watch pair with an indoor trainer? Im having trouble connecting mine to my trainer and am wondering if i would have the same issue with a venu 3 or higher watch
swimming in the pool has the automatic pause function like swim2? Is there a button for partial times?. Thanks ❤
I just bought the Venu 3 the day before this video released...just a slight upgrade from the vivoactive HR I have. :)
Can you add surfing to vivoactive 5?
What do you think in battle with venu 2 plus?