Thanks for this video, Paul. Like a lot of people, I have seasonal flu/heavy cold; your passion for Newcastle United always makes me feel better. Great news that the owners still believe. We have to have some patience in a PSR world, but I believe that Eddie will lead us to the promised land.
American football teams being on opposite sidelines and separate tunnels allow teams to separate and calm down. It is a compliment to the league's culture that there aren't more fights in the tunnel.
as a player, player/coach and manager at Weymouth JT wore his heart on the sleeve, as well as some very dodgy white suits in the dugout! Good manager at a difficult time for our club and nice to see him doing so well now
We have Villas number, we have spanked them home and away a few times now. They aren't Top 4 squad, just an excellent manager. Once he goes Villa will go back to 8th/9th normal position
I doubt big Joe was calming anything down!!! In fact my first thought when I heard about it, was that he would be at the centre of it, mad dog my second thought
In his final step He angles his right foot back inwards to land in centre of Schar instead of pushing it further to right to avoid stepping on him. Changing trajectory = deliberate
I think Alan Shearer is trying very hard to seem unbiased on MOTD. I noticed that he keeps saying how every red card against our opponents is harsh (ie Duran and Raul Jimenez), how the other team is usually unlucky to lose, if we get a penalty Alan usually says it's very soft, or that Gordon's goal against Arsenal shouldn't have stood.
I think he was totally wrong and needs to man up instead of aligning himself with the pathetic BBC agenda , personally I think the BaBC punditry is awful 🤷♂️
Red card all day but Shearer saying his ankle went over therefore he lost control of his balance, fecking tosh, he definitely tried to go for Fabian’s head. Like you Paul I agree there is far too much hitting the floor holding their faces after the slightest of touch’s, needs sorting out
@@ToonAssassinSchär was a victim of that earlier this season of course (Southampton, Brereton Diaz), though at least he did get some hair on his nose in that instance. Horrible to see, but has been part of the game for years now unfortunately.
Just a question Bruno’s goal was disallowed as it supposedly went straight in off his arm However the replays I saw show it hit the leg of a villa defender on the way in ,is that not enough to allow the goal😂
Emerey looks like a vampire.......what? 😂😂😂 2 things that boils my piss is players faking injuries and players trying to get other players booked, be a man, stay on your feet and stop being a fanny.
all happened because Villa frustrated at being torn apart by us when they thought they would walk all over us comfortable. the best team on the the day won which was us. then add on their shanagins to get Joe sent off cos they thought they didn't deserve theirs when we knew and the officials knew it was a definite red card offence for stamping on a player
People have said the reason it happened was because Duran's left ankle give way which forces him to put his right foot down on Schar, but my argument to this is if your left ankle gives way your body mass will move to the left naturally lifting your right leg as you fall. If you look at the incident again in slow motion concentrating on the right leg you will see he moves his lower part of his leg to the left and down towards Schar. If you fall left your right leg should lift unless you make the conscious move
We do have a fantastic group spirit with the team and backroom staff, great to see. Hate players simulating. Surely it goes against "unsportsmanlike behaviour" and should be retrospectively punished by the league?!
Great video as always Paul! I have two questions: 1) I obviously recognise Keegan,Sir Bobby and Eddie in the photos behind you, but who is the fourth person? 2) Are you aware of the grammatical error in the ribbon at the bottom of the screen, ( you are watching the the The Toon Review),and also in the headline on this vid? “ Welcome to the The The Toon Review TH-cam Channel “ I noticed it a while ago and assumed it would be corrected, but perhaps no one has noticed it? Hopefully we’ve turned the corner now and the CL is a possibility 😃🤞
I think the motd opinion was just political - for me it looked like Duran took the opportunity to leave one on Schar and got caught. All the best Paul - thanks for the huge effort you put into keeping everyone updated 👍🏻
Head injuries are quite rightly high on the concerns list which should make it a high priority for the rule makers to ensure that players who feign head injuries are brought to account especially when video evidence clearly shows that the ‘victims’ quite clearly have not had any contact to their heads.
i think the decision on the stadium will tell us a lot. it has to be a new stadium to increase revenue through increased capacity/corporate, concerts and other sporting events surely? are we going to get the world class training facilities and an improved academy that actually produces players regularly for the first team or for sale. these are the things we need
Match of the day pundits stood up for villa as well over the sending off can't see the innocence of it myself the right outcome happened for me but you will get loads of them all season with different outcomes
Definitely a red, he lashed out but had second thoughts half way through. Was messy but he was trying to hurt Schar so was the correct decision. He was going to be sent of regardless. If he saw yellow for that, he would have got another. He was getting bullied and hated it so 🤷🏻♂️
I was as far away from the red card as you can be and I turned to the guy next to me and said it was a foul and then some "afters" a red card DEFO. Oh yea and a great game from the toon.
Football is all about opinions some say it was done say it wasn't a red 🤷♂️ but at the end of the day the ref seen it as a red and Villa got smoked..!!! Get over it AVFC
Villa fan here randomly, personally before the game i thought it was gonna be a hard game and that scoring first was big if we were gonna take something from the game. So Gordons banger took the Man City Draw smirk off my face lol. In my opinion Newcastle/Eddie Howe had a pretty good way to mitigate Rogers. Since Rogers so is strong and doesnt go down easy, you can actually foul him harder than normal players, grab and pull clothing harder and a second longer and even though Rogers still wont go down, just slowing him down helps everyone else get in position. Dark Arts master class from Newcastle today. Duran Red? Well, I always think that there is the rules and then there is the discussion. I can see why its a red by the rules, I just think that if we could get every ref decision right in every game, that this would not even be a yellow. But Thats the game and while frustrating, cant really hate Newcastle for getting away with selling it as a team. On the other hand, calling Rogers pathetic for responding to a foul by drawing attention to it is basically double speak. Newcastle used their whole team to over sell what I bet didnt leave a red mark on Schar to get the Red, then turn around and attack Rogers for doing what Newcastle is doing back to them. 10 v 11, vs a Dark Arts team, I bet Emery Told Rogers he needed to go down more because the ref wouldnt get yellows if he stayed standing. So go ahead and call Rogers "Pathetic" for going to the ground after getting hit in the face while Newcastle gets away with everything, but be aware that Oil State club banter isnt going anywhere, and if you can succeed in the Premier League by buying the Refs thats good for you, but youll never get any success in European Comps because Newcastle players are Dirty and Pathetic and take advantage of the Oil Clubs buying the Premier Refs.
@@wdg6478 Hey you know what, I thought Villa at Newcastle was gonna be very hard to win. And Im a huge Isak fan. I'm just pointing out that throwing stones from a glass house will result in increased banter towards things you as fans cant control. Gl rest of your season, I think Newcastle top 4 higher chance than Villa right now, but Villa 5th would be perfect.
@@TonyODOnnell-tt8gh Glad you had a laugh mate, I was worried my comment would only be appreciated by people who dont consider a few paragraphs labour.
I'm a Newcastle fan at first I thought definitely a red card but when I watched it again on motd I think his left ankle folded over and he couldn't control his right leg so not so sure after seeing it in slo mo🤔
Some of the comments read like a Viz letter 😂 'i think i saw Duran pull a knife and make a slashing movement towards Schar before he took a baseball bat out of his sock and clubbed him over the head' ....... i didn't think it was a red and if that were given against us i'd be fuming. It was clumsy and he was off balance but nowhere near as bad as some make out
Fair enough Jason Tyndall is his mate and long term partner but even EH must admit he would start a fight if he was alone in a phone box and we are being totally biased if we don’t admit that
Duran looks down at fabs head then throws his foot down towards where hes looking, if thats not blatently intentional i dont know what is. Lucky he only hit his back or that could of been nasty
I don't know what Alan Shearer was talking about on MOTD regarding the sending off. I understand Duran went over on his left ankle, but he didn't have to stud Schar. Alan trying to be diplomatic as usual and just comes off sounding like a pratt.
Yes definitely a red card for villa player and the villa player rolling around like he was shot by a sniper is rediculas it’s disgusting for me we definitely deserve the 3 points and if it was the other way they would be going daft but we got the result and that’s what matters for me
I was more irritated at Jones post shove display, not so much the dive. Petulantly whingeing about how they're hard done by and Joelinton should be sent off to balance the other red card. Right up there with clowns from big clubs falling over in the box thinking they are entitled to penalty opportunities to save a result ala PSG
For me saying it and doing it are two different things they need to show it this window even if its future stars show ambition we are 4th if we fall off are chairman is guilty of neglect
Paul I might be really wrong but I think I seen you driving past me today in Newbiggin by the sea, if it wasn’t you it was a genetic copy or something 😂
They should have given him a yellow card for simulating. He didn't get hit in the face but claimed he did, they need to stamp this out in football as the youngsters think its ok to do this type of cheating. Thought this game was played by men, we are very quick to condem the refs for getting things wrong and the players exaccerbate this issue. There's no difference between this and diving in the box, so they should carry a yellow card. If you got hit in the face you can call to the linesman and we have VAR so anything malicious will be seen.
Jhon Duran red card 100% the right decision with the studs on Schar back could have seriously injured him in the process and what he did in the aftermath having a tantrum throwing his water bottle could have seriously hurt a footballer or a fan Really Bafflingly disappointing to hear Shearer comments on MOTD saying it wasn't a red card propably trying to appease Lineker and the main BBC bosses Stay safe Paul 👍⚫⚪
Refs should send off players acting to get other players sent , I watched and Joelington did not touch the guys face, Rogers should go into acting, he should be ashamed of his actions
Keith Hackett has said Red Card 🤷🏻♂️, he slipped on his left foot because he stood on Schar. Shearer needs to park his Red Media BS, it’s getting tiresome now, as Tindal says 🤫
So Tindall called Emery "dracula"? and that is funny? It may be funny to many, perhaps, but I would suggest it is a school boy tactic and I would expect more of that from somebody in leadership. Of course Donald Trump made name-calling presidential, so perhaps I am wrong. What do you think, Shrek?
Seems a lot of away managers get rather upset at St James' Park, long may it continue !
Thanks for this video, Paul. Like a lot of people, I have seasonal flu/heavy cold; your passion for Newcastle United always makes me feel better. Great news that the owners still believe. We have to have some patience in a PSR world, but I believe that Eddie will lead us to the promised land.
So Villa got batterd off the pitch also lol
We have mad Dog and Joelinton plus Dan Burn.
😂😂
Mad dog Tindal is a Geordie 🖤🤍
Credit for DUBRAVKA standing up for his mate schät
American football teams being on opposite sidelines and separate tunnels allow teams to separate and calm down. It is a compliment to the league's culture that there aren't more fights in the tunnel.
Great video as always Paul. Best channel on tube for N U F C content .
Dracula? I'm creased 🤣🤣🤣
Love Jason so much haha how can you not
Dermot Gallagher said on ref watch he thought it was a red
Like to think it was tindall v 19
@@desmondcurrie6479 😂😂😂😂 probably was, he’s not called “Mad dog” for nothing 😂😂😂
great news roundup. thanks mate ❤
101% right Paul.
as a player, player/coach and manager at Weymouth JT wore his heart on the sleeve, as well as some very dodgy white suits in the dugout! Good manager at a difficult time for our club and nice to see him doing so well now
I love it when you say, ‘I’m not being biased here’ , and you proceed to be biased.
I love it! I love your unbridled biased passion.
Keep it up.
Clear red
Duran needs a extra game ban for kicking that bottle thats dissent
We have Villas number, we have spanked them home and away a few times now. They aren't Top 4 squad, just an excellent manager. Once he goes Villa will go back to 8th/9th normal position
I hope big Joe & Dan were calming it down because they are 2 lads I wouldn’t be on the wrong side of of them 2
I doubt big Joe was calming anything down!!! In fact my first thought when I heard about it, was that he would be at the centre of it, mad dog my second thought
@ If that’s the case brother it wouldn’t be a surprise to any of us lot 🤣🤣🥊🥊🥊🥊
In his final step He angles his right foot back inwards to land in centre of Schar instead of pushing it further to right to avoid stepping on him. Changing trajectory = deliberate
I'm glad pif are still pushing. And also glad they reliase this is going to be a long road with psr and are in all the way🖤🤍
I think Alan Shearer is trying very hard to seem unbiased on MOTD. I noticed that he keeps saying how every red card against our opponents is harsh (ie Duran and Raul Jimenez), how the other team is usually unlucky to lose, if we get a penalty Alan usually says it's very soft, or that Gordon's goal against Arsenal shouldn't have stood.
I don’t think that’s the case he just says it as it is
I think he was totally wrong and needs to man up instead of aligning himself with the pathetic BBC agenda , personally I think the BaBC punditry is awful 🤷♂️
he works for the BBC, enough said
Yeah that's true! It's like shearer scared of backing Newcastle now? 😢 😮
@@danhedley2253nah he toes the bbc agenda who are his paymasters ..
Red card all day but Shearer saying his ankle went over therefore he lost control of his balance, fecking tosh, he definitely tried to go for Fabian’s head. Like you Paul I agree there is far too much hitting the floor holding their faces after the slightest of touch’s, needs sorting out
💯 agree with this. Retrospective bans for fake facial injuries need to happen.
@@ToonAssassinSchär was a victim of that earlier this season of course (Southampton, Brereton Diaz), though at least he did get some hair on his nose in that instance. Horrible to see, but has been part of the game for years now unfortunately.
As a nufc fan I would be disappointed if Duran was sent of for us but Morgan Rogers should win a oscar
Great result for Newcastle utd i watched tge game at my local pub as for my team we drew away to Wimbledon
Abdukodir Khusanov ( C B )looks the real deal seen him play this man is gold dust
Just a question Bruno’s goal was disallowed as it supposedly went straight in off his arm
However the replays I saw show it hit the leg of a villa defender on the way in ,is that not enough to allow the goal😂
Emerey looks like a vampire.......what? 😂😂😂 2 things that boils my piss is players faking injuries and players trying to get other players booked, be a man, stay on your feet and stop being a fanny.
I agree exactly. When I was a kid and started playing football my old boy told me never show the opposition player he's hurt you even if he has.
Dracula masks for the next Villa game are a must. 🤣😂🤣
all happened because Villa frustrated at being torn apart by us when they thought they would walk all over us comfortable. the best team on the the day won which was us. then add on their shanagins to get Joe sent off cos they thought they didn't deserve theirs when we knew and the officials knew it was a definite red card offence for stamping on a player
Paul my top same as yours has Mad Dog 2 on the back his Passion is all newcastle
Could’ve been 5 or 6 EASY!’ Bruno’s disallowed goal, was a BLIDDY joke man!!!
People have said the reason it happened was because Duran's left ankle give way which forces him to put his right foot down on Schar, but my argument to this is if your left ankle gives way your body mass will move to the left naturally lifting your right leg as you fall. If you look at the incident again in slow motion concentrating on the right leg you will see he moves his lower part of his leg to the left and down towards Schar. If you fall left your right leg should lift unless you make the conscious move
We do have a fantastic group spirit with the team and backroom staff, great to see. Hate players simulating. Surely it goes against "unsportsmanlike behaviour" and should be retrospectively punished by the league?!
Great video as always Paul! I have two questions: 1) I obviously recognise Keegan,Sir Bobby and Eddie in the photos behind you, but who is the fourth person? 2) Are you aware of the grammatical error in the ribbon at the bottom of the screen, ( you are watching the the The Toon Review),and also in the headline on this vid? “ Welcome to the The The Toon Review TH-cam Channel “
I noticed it a while ago and assumed it would be corrected, but perhaps no one has noticed it?
Hopefully we’ve turned the corner now and the CL is a possibility 😃🤞
A former co-host who sadly passed away … affectionally known as The Duke of Northumberland
@@kendo5862 Thanks for that ! Have a great 2025!
I think the motd opinion was just political - for me it looked like Duran took the opportunity to leave one on Schar and got caught.
All the best Paul - thanks for the huge effort you put into keeping everyone updated 👍🏻
For me thats not a red card, but very happy with the 3 points. #HWTL
He deliberately moves his foot to the left! The Villa appeal was rejected too. Definitely meant that
Head injuries are quite rightly high on the concerns list which should make it a high priority for the rule makers to ensure that players who feign head injuries are brought to account especially when video evidence clearly shows that the ‘victims’ quite clearly have not had any contact to their heads.
Hiya Paul,I compare Unai Emry to Robbie Fowler, because he looks like him,this is Choppy 😆😆
Rodgers must have been watching Steven Taylor's portrayal of a sniper victim against Villa a few years back.
i think the decision on the stadium will tell us a lot. it has to be a new stadium to increase revenue through increased capacity/corporate, concerts and other sporting events surely? are we going to get the world class training facilities and an improved academy that actually produces players regularly for the first team or for sale. these are the things we need
Why people bother to dive when we have var and instant replays
No shame mate! It’s embarrassing
Yeah but they need to punish the blatant cheaters.
It must have been started by villa as always
Match of the day pundits stood up for villa as well over the sending off can't see the innocence of it myself the right outcome happened for me but you will get loads of them all season with different outcomes
Definitely a red, he lashed out but had second thoughts half way through. Was messy but he was trying to hurt Schar so was the correct decision. He was going to be sent of regardless. If he saw yellow for that, he would have got another. He was getting bullied and hated it so 🤷🏻♂️
Def a Red
I was as far away from the red card as you can be and I turned to the guy next to me and said it was a foul and then some "afters" a red card DEFO. Oh yea and a great game from the toon.
Cash of Villa should have had two yellows for his tackles on Gordon
Mad dog
Honorary Geordie
🏴🏳️🏴🏳️🏴🏳️
Football is all about opinions some say it was done say it wasn't a red 🤷♂️ but at the end of the day the ref seen it as a red and Villa got smoked..!!! Get over it AVFC
Villa fan here randomly, personally before the game i thought it was gonna be a hard game and that scoring first was big if we were gonna take something from the game. So Gordons banger took the Man City Draw smirk off my face lol.
In my opinion Newcastle/Eddie Howe had a pretty good way to mitigate Rogers. Since Rogers so is strong and doesnt go down easy, you can actually foul him harder than normal players, grab and pull clothing harder and a second longer and even though Rogers still wont go down, just slowing him down helps everyone else get in position. Dark Arts master class from Newcastle today.
Duran Red? Well, I always think that there is the rules and then there is the discussion. I can see why its a red by the rules, I just think that if we could get every ref decision right in every game, that this would not even be a yellow. But Thats the game and while frustrating, cant really hate Newcastle for getting away with selling it as a team.
On the other hand, calling Rogers pathetic for responding to a foul by drawing attention to it is basically double speak. Newcastle used their whole team to over sell what I bet didnt leave a red mark on Schar to get the Red, then turn around and attack Rogers for doing what Newcastle is doing back to them. 10 v 11, vs a Dark Arts team, I bet Emery Told Rogers he needed to go down more because the ref wouldnt get yellows if he stayed standing.
So go ahead and call Rogers "Pathetic" for going to the ground after getting hit in the face while Newcastle gets away with everything, but be aware that Oil State club banter isnt going anywhere, and if you can succeed in the Premier League by buying the Refs thats good for you, but youll never get any success in European Comps because Newcastle players are Dirty and Pathetic and take advantage of the Oil Clubs buying the Premier Refs.
😂😂😂😂 we’re just better than you
Sad sack 😂
@@wdg6478 Hey you know what, I thought Villa at Newcastle was gonna be very hard to win. And Im a huge Isak fan. I'm just pointing out that throwing stones from a glass house will result in increased banter towards things you as fans cant control.
Gl rest of your season, I think Newcastle top 4 higher chance than Villa right now, but Villa 5th would be perfect.
That's a lot of, blah, blah, blah...
😳/🤪/😂
@@TonyODOnnell-tt8gh Glad you had a laugh mate, I was worried my comment would only be appreciated by people who dont consider a few paragraphs labour.
It was a sending off
so more talk from are owners about what they going to do let's just hope in 2025 fans will Actually see some of this talk come into Reality
I'm a Newcastle fan at first I thought definitely a red card but when I watched it again on motd I think his left ankle folded over and he couldn't control his right leg so not so sure after seeing it in slo mo🤔
Buying the Airport?
No pen for me to be fair he was going over on his left ankle.
Some of the comments read like a Viz letter 😂 'i think i saw Duran pull a knife and make a slashing movement towards Schar before he took a baseball bat out of his sock and clubbed him over the head' ....... i didn't think it was a red and if that were given against us i'd be fuming. It was clumsy and he was off balance but nowhere near as bad as some make out
Tindal tried to give Dracula a clove. Dracula didnt like it 😂
FA ARE LOOKING INTO US NOW SURPRISE
The same FA allowed the Arsenal camp to go on for weeks about their feeling of injustices (Toon v Arsenal). without bringing them to account.
Jason can sit with the posh mice in the stands🤣
Tunnel barny on PPV!
Did not one of you lads comment, that he did look like drakula 😂??
Why so many in the tunnel. Just those playing, manager and coach only there.
Fair enough Jason Tyndall is his mate and long term partner but even EH must admit he would start a fight if he was alone in a phone box and we are being totally biased if we don’t admit that
Eddies enforcer, we love him lol
He's class...
Dracula 🤣🤣🤣
Duran looks down at fabs head then throws his foot down towards where hes looking, if thats not blatently intentional i dont know what is. Lucky he only hit his back or that could of been nasty
"A lot of passion at half time" Are You talking neck biting ha
I couldn't believe MOTD. I feel like I'm on crazy pills! Are they blind?
I don't know what Alan Shearer was talking about on MOTD regarding the sending off. I understand Duran went over on his left ankle, but he didn't have to stud Schar. Alan trying to be diplomatic as usual and just comes off sounding like a pratt.
Since Ollie Watkins gave that arrogant interview when villa battered us in April
2023 , we have done a number on Villa .Thanks Ollie 😂😂
Yes definitely a red card for villa player and the villa player rolling around like he was shot by a sniper is rediculas it’s disgusting for me we definitely deserve the 3 points and if it was the other way they would be going daft but we got the result and that’s what matters for me
I was more irritated at Jones post shove display, not so much the dive. Petulantly whingeing about how they're hard done by and Joelinton should be sent off to balance the other red card.
Right up there with clowns from big clubs falling over in the box thinking they are entitled to penalty opportunities to save a result ala PSG
For me saying it and doing it are two different things they need to show it this window even if its future stars show ambition we are 4th if we fall off are chairman is guilty of neglect
Paul I might be really wrong but I think I seen you driving past me today in Newbiggin by the sea, if it wasn’t you it was a genetic copy or something 😂
Jt is like that outside of football pure anger issues.
If it was fans clashing there would be hell on but cos it's overpaid players and staff it's just a big laugh 🤔
Surprised shearer said it wasn't a sending off.
flopping has gotten so out of control in all levels of Football/soccer. it's just ridiculous.
MOTD opinions are usually dictated by what Lineker thinks, once he thinks it wasnt a red I expect no one would disagree with him.
They should have given him a yellow card for simulating. He didn't get hit in the face but claimed he did, they need to stamp this out in football as the youngsters think its ok to do this type of cheating. Thought this game was played by men, we are very quick to condem the refs for getting things wrong and the players exaccerbate this issue. There's no difference between this and diving in the box, so they should carry a yellow card. If you got hit in the face you can call to the linesman and we have VAR so anything malicious will be seen.
Jhon Duran red card 100% the right decision with the studs on Schar back could have seriously injured him in the process and what he did in the aftermath having a tantrum throwing his water bottle could have seriously hurt a footballer or a fan
Really Bafflingly disappointing to hear Shearer comments on MOTD saying it wasn't a red card propably trying to appease Lineker and the main BBC bosses
Stay safe Paul 👍⚫⚪
Refs should send off players acting to get other players sent , I watched and Joelington did not touch the guys face, Rogers should go into acting, he should be ashamed of his actions
Keith Hackett has said Red Card 🤷🏻♂️, he slipped on his left foot because he stood on Schar. Shearer needs to park his Red Media BS, it’s getting tiresome now, as Tindal says 🤫
Tindel needs to pipe down. Just do his job.
So Tindall called Emery "dracula"? and that is funny? It may be funny to many, perhaps, but I would suggest it is a school boy tactic and I would expect more of that from somebody in leadership. Of course Donald Trump made name-calling presidential, so perhaps I am wrong. What do you think, Shrek?
Shearer says it isn't a red card; if Roy Keane did that to Shearer would he be happy? Tosser!
Was a definite red card simple as that
Both clubs will be charged
Anyone who thinks that classes as a stamp. Is 100% a little girl
I have a soft spot for Newcastle BUT Jason is the only garbage at Newcastle,I remember him shushing Klopp,then lost to 10 men at home to Liverpool
@Paul
Any truth Tomori coming in on a loan?
Dracula