Honestly the live action gets hated on so much for no reason in my opinion it’s the only the Disney live action remake that is actually enjoyable and felt like it’s own thing instead of being a cash grab and I honestly do prefer the live action over the animated one.
But it didn’t do it well. There’s a difference between a different adaptation and completely ripping out the spirit of what the original was going for, which is the live action versions problem. When the story instead of Alice In Wonderland is Grownup Alice Returns To Underland, amidst the fact that a whimsical story of childish fantasy has been replaced with a serious, gritty war movie and little of the charm of the original characters has survived - and NONE of Alice who has been replaced with a block of wood - don’t you think that represents just a _bit_ of a problem?
@@jgzaz how the most hated teacher in Hogwarts turned out to actually to *CARE* for Harry Potter after all the years in Hogwarts he has been treating him :_(
It is actually confirmed that the queen in the Live action is not the queen of hearts, but the red queen who was in the same universe and was in the stories of Alice written by the original creator.
@@sridevisudhahar309 the original story has the red queen turn into a cup of tea (idk if it was tea but she transformed into something). How is it anything remotely similar to the OG work?
Life action Alice is literally one of my favorite of all time. But the cartoon, if I need to be honest, I don't remember most of it (but when I re-watch it I was not really impressed). I don't hate the original cartoon, it's just not for me. But the movie is a great as a fantasy, so yeah, I love it)
I think seeing it as a kid would have been really enjoyable (animated version) but at my age right now it was hard keeping interest through out. It was funny at times though.
@@LakiaJaiTV totally agree with you. Old one is colourful and funny for kids, but for others it's just so random, and live action is more for teens+ I think, so now everyone have the version of this story for their age)
@@LakiaJaiTV yeahhhhh, as a kid in the 80s I lost interest in the animated version and left the room. As an adult I lost interest in the live action version and walked out of the theater. I've probably walked out on 5 movies total in my life after sitting down to watch them and 2 of those happen to be Alice in Wonderland lol Go figure, because I look back on the movies fondly, I just didn't know how they ended until I watched your reactions lol
Kinda the same for me except the complete opposite. Found live action mostly forgettable besides certain instances which I just found kinda gross or easy to mock.
the live-action Alice and Wonderland is more of a "sequel" or a continuation/spin-off than an actual remake because it does tell a new story just with the same characters
Yeah, that's because the live-action is an adaptation of the second book "Alice Through The Looking Glass". In the first book everything is based in card games, in the second one it's all about chess
@@tinxstesiaobsidianThe loosest sense of "adaptation".. Dumpster fire that has little to nothing to do with Alice in Wonderland besides character names
The live action will always hold a special place in my heart idk why I just love the darker Alice tone. It’s definitely one of my favorite Alice interpretations. Maybe it’s because I love Alice Madness Returns so much and those video games.
The Queen of Hearts is in the first book 'Alice's Adventures in Wonderland' which also has the queens of Diamonds, Clubs and Spades but she's the most important Queen there. She orders everyone's heads to be off throughout the croquet game but I think in the book the king of heart secretly manages to give them a pardon, except for when the Cheshire Cat refused to pay homage to him. Same as in the animated movie they have a crazy marriage but it somehow works. The Red Queen and the White Queen are from the second book 'Through the Looking Glass and What Alice Found There', they're like chess pieces. One of them runs in the same spot for a while, the other one is always saying stuff like 'Jam yesterday and jam tomorrow but never jam today', but I can't remember which does which. There is a white king and a red king but I can't remember much about the white king, just that the red king was asleep throughout the whole story and there's a big question as to whether or not he's dreaming up Alice or Alice is dreaming up him. I think the original idea was that the queen of hearts was a hot temper kind of anger and fury jumping up and down and screeching 'off with their heads' like a spoiled child, the red queen was a colder kind of anger like a governess when she's caught her children misbehaving.
And if O remember correctly, the white queen wasn't better- her sense of justice was to imprison people because of their "future crimes" even if there's no proof that's going tk happen
I love the live action remake! It felt true to the original, but it was also a more grown up take on Alice and her problems. The cast is also amazing which is part of the reason I love it so much.
"It felt true to the original" Uh, excuse me? The live action totally MISSES the point ans escence of the original book, and Tim Burton just straight up admited he hated that book so thats why he made it TOTALLY different to the original book, are you ok???
@@skyxclouds3765 To me, it feels almost the same. The thing is that now the little girl is grown up, and the land of fantasies needs her to be what it was. I personally loved it. And also, you sounded a little bit worked up.
I remember seeing the trailer for the live action Alice in wonderland in theaters and it scared the crap outta me, but I ended up loving the movie! I especially love the Cheshire cat.
I watched the live action before the original as a kid, and i remember being so shocked that unlike all the other memories, alice didn't get married. that was the first time i realized that marriage wasn't the end of the road, and for that i really owe it to that movie. alice was THE girlboss for me without being so in your face about it. im so glad it wasn't a remake of the original but instead set after it too
Thank you omg, I remember watching this movie as a kid on repeat and it HEAVILY influenced who I am. The messages it sent really stuck with me even now as a fresh 18 year old jumping into adulthood. I’ll always cherish this movie , 💜
The first live-action Alice is my absolute favourite! The mysterious vibes, the gloom mixed with the wonder and mild nuerodivergent vibes mix perfectly. And Alice discovering her Muchness and age, perfectly matches my stage in life and inspires me in a way the second doesnt... Also, that time period of dress? *chefs kiss*
I prefer the original, but I do think the live action at least tried to stand on its own and deserves credit for that. I think it's cool that back in the day you could literally trip on acid and tell your boss about it and he'd be like 👍🏼 let's animate that. Another great video, enjoyed this format, thanks
The Live Action Alice in Wonderland isn’t really a remake, it’s a sequel, Alice is all grown up, revisiting Wonderland, and they mention Alice’s visit in the original cartoon.
Hallmark’s Alice in Wonderland 1999 is an underrated gem! It has a star studded cast and is a lot more like the animated movie in terms of the magic and whimsical feel!
I do not know if it was intentional, but I also find it interesting that Alice in that film has brunette hair. It feels like a homage to the original Alice who Lewis Carroll wrote the stories for even though he himself drew Alice with blonde hair to separate the two figures to some extent.
As much as I love Alice and grew up with this as well. I prefer Alice Liddell from Alice Madness Return more because it's dark in that wonderland. I agree the live action is a lot more entertaining than the classic movie.
And American Mcgee would have done an alice movie if all his financiers didn't jump off because of Tim burton plan to make an alice movie. It would have been so much better, but yeah...
I grew up with the original Alice, and I think of it as a prequel to the 2010 film. The original Alice was a little girl waking up from a dream of Wonderland, which she thought she created in her head, only to find out in the 2010 version that the dreams were actually memories of events that actually happened.
Disney is going to end up trying to do all live actions and honestly I’m ready for some new stuff nothing wrong with the old Disney movies I just feel like Disney wants to keep remaking the old movies by making it into live action. I feel like there running out of ideas 💡
It's sad because I'm sure there's plenty of amazing writers on their team with plenty of good ideas, but Disney simply doesn't see it as worth the effort
@@peepawfart I would love to have another 2d animation with classical music/instruments and I want a new black disney princess but I know I am asking for too much.
As an introverted little girl who spent a lot of her time just using her imagination there was something very relatable about cartoon alice that made feel very attached to the movie so I'll always prefer it in a very biased way... I remember enjoying the live action as a kid but I never became attached to that version of alice bc I couldn't really see myself in her anymore
I don’t care what anyone says, the new live action Alice in Wonderland is much better than the original, because it’s more Cryptid to the original book, also between the first new life action and the second movie, through the looking glass, I personally like the looking glass better, it’s a lot more playful with color. You should totally react to that one, I think you might like that one too
No it isn't None of the live action remakes were ever good, What makes this one different? NOTHING,"Because it's more cyptid to the original book" It really isn't. Nothing EVER beats the original
@@isislemons303 what is up with you people just refusing to accept that some people prefer a remake or sequel over the original I like the original because I prefer the darker tone to it it feels more grown up
12:40 Funny thing about Alice not being a Disney Princess, in the Kingdom Hearts games she is regarded as one of the seven princesses of heart (alongside Aurora, Belle, Jasmine, Cinderella, Snow White, and Kairi). So I guess that counts? It's the only time she's ever been recognized as a Disney princess, so I count it.
I never watched the animation as a kid. The live action, however, was a sweet part of my childhood, which makes the fact that I've watched the animation recently and it's become one of my all-time favorite movies that much weirder lol The animation just have that feeling... It's sooo unique, so magical, so free and absolutely crazy, kind of scary and a bit disturbing. It have everything I love most in a story. The live action have a place in my heart of course, but it just doesn't have the same feeling.
12:34: *laughs in Kingdom Hearts* No really, she's a Princess of Heart in that game. I LOVE the original animated movie!!!! Literally one of my hands down, all time favourite Disney movies. The live action is good, but the OG is so much better in my opinion! And this is from the Golden Age of Disney, I believe. But way back when, the original Disney movies didn't have the castle intro. They opened from literal books. Like the source material. Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Snow White, etc all do it too.
Fun fact The Queen of Hearts and The Red Queen are actually two different Queens the Queen of Hearts is based on the Card game while The Red Queen is the red chess piece if anyone didn’t know
I like the og version better because of the music. this is perfect thank you. also I wouldn't mind more classics like fantasia Hercules but also beauty and the beast live action.
I think the live action is amazing but I do prefer the animation! I think Alice in Wonderland has the potential to be expanded into a television series similar to His Dark Materials!!
I 100% prefer the live action - it’s the movie I would put into my DVD player most as a kid and I would watch it on repeat, everything about the movie is nostalgic for me. But I really do think the movie stands well on its own and is a darker, more mature take on Alice in Wonderland, but the cartoon movie is too boring for me. The live action one is exciting and the Tim Burton aesthetic he brought to it was amazinggg
The live action has a special place in my heart. Eating Mexican candy and being with my older brother and dad and just watching the live action. Good times :)
both alice in wonderlands were my favorites as a child. i had a portable dvd player and watched tim burtons version constantly. then at my mom’s job, before i went to camp i would watch the 1951 version on vhs every morning and never got past the tea party scene 😂
When I was younger I never liked the live action much and now It’s one of my favourite Disney live actions, I’m in love with the the gloomy royal fairytale vibe about it. Just so beautifullllll
The live action is supposed to be a sequel, but everything is invented and has little to nothing to do with the Lewis Carroll novels of Alice. The animated classic on the other hand is a very good adaptation of both books.
Exactly. I think the live action is great but it's not very good adapting the Alice in Wonderland books, while the books are all about nonsense, poems, songs, riddles and games, the live action involves political issues and removes every piece of spontaneity (they even tell you the ingredients of the potion that makes you smaller), but anyway it has its charm and I really love the story line and Tim Burton's aesthetic. Both movies are masterpieces to me.
Yes, I don't hate Tim Burton but..... I think he doesn't understand the true essence of the book: The nonsense! And I'm the only one who think that the actress of Alice (I don't know her name) is very inexpressive?
For the animated Alice, I remember as a kid being so disappointed whenever the film got to the Queen part. It just got really sad and twisted, although the film is weird. For the new one, things were easier to take in, but I felt the dance at the end was overkill, but maybe that was on purpose.
Nah I never understood the hate either I enjoyed it alot I even wanted thete to be more and there was the looking glass that was amazing as well. Usually live actions are horrible and doesn't have the same feel as original but this one was amazing
I could be wrong but the problem is that in alice in wonderland, they only use her to slay the jabberwocky and in through the looking glass it's always about the mad hatter. And sometimes the mad hatter is in the centre of the movie posters instead of Alice herself.
My anser to the riddle is: A raven has black feathers and a pen is usually in black ink. They must've used the raven's feather to use it as a writing desk. Like as one of thise old timey feather quills.🧏🏾♀️💁🏾♀️🪶✒
In the Spanish dubbing of the animated classic, the translator Edmundo Santos dedicated the Alice in Wonderland song to his wife Alicia (Alice), adapting it as a poem for her 🥺
I completely forgot about the ending credits song omg, the nostalgia I got from hearing it holy shit. Honestly mood I adored the live-action. That's so cool how it's like a sequel yet still being like a remake. It's so good.
It's SO refreshing whenever somebody enjoys the Tim Burton movie as much as you do! I ADORED the Hatter as a kid, I thought he was so silly and sweet. Dude's a puppy in human form. Also, the editing for this video is *top tier!* Also I agree Avril Lavigne was a 2000s queen!
The 1999 live-action was my favorite when I was little until the 2010 version came out. I personally never really liked the animated one, I can see the appeal but it just never really did it for me I guess lol
Hell yeah, someone else who grew up on the 1999 live-action! I feel like since I was more familiar with that one as opposed to the Disney animated version it opened me up to the concepts of the 2010 one better. Well, that & the fact that I was raised on Tim Burton movies and thus already a fan of his by then. 😆💗
I was absolutely in love with both live-action movies! And this is the first time I'm seeing anyone having issue with the movie lol Maybe it's because I come from a country that didn't have its childhood shaped by a company like Disney. To be fair, I wasn't very fond of the animation for some reason. But I would die for Mia's Alice aaaaa
Alice in Wonderland is my favorite movie. I remember there was this Alice in Wonderland Disney book for children in National Bookstore that came along with an Alice Necklace. I immediately asked my parents for the book but mainly for the necklace. I absolutely loved it. I still remember the smell. I would watch the 2010 version so many times as a child filled with innocence to the point that I didn't even close my eyes when the door mouse stabbed and removed the Bandersnatch's eye ball nor during the part when Alice slayed the Jobberwocky. I wish I could watch it again. With the one from 1951, I didn't watch it as much as the 2010 during my childhood. And I got scared at the intro because of the dark color. In the present moment right now, I watch Alice in Wonderland 1951 more. I even memorized "In A Wod of My Own," the "Golden Afternoon, " and "the Walrus and the Carpenter (not perfecly)" One thing that may be a major reason of loving Alice in Wonderland is ballet class. My big sister and I took classes as children and there was this Alice in Wonderland play the ballerinas participated in including my big sister. She played one of the rabbits. Unfortunately, I was not allowed to be part of the play because I was too young. I was just part of the audience and as I watched the play knowing I'm not part, I cried so much, like the way Alice cried. The teacher said "Next Time" but I'm still waiting for "Next Time." I want to read the original "Alice Adventures in Wonderland" book along with the "Through the Looking Glass" one. This year, I got an Alice in Wonderland necklace which was a "Drink Me" bottle design. I chose it probably because I miss wearing the Alice Necklace of my childhood.
I always liked the live action movie because of the plot and the action I enjoyed your reaction video, I never knew Alice was so funny and your reactions to her cracked me up 😂😂😂😂
Why choose? I love both of them so much! I have a great lot of affection for either Alice Move for various reasons, but I could watch either and never get bored!
I love the live-action Alice in wonderland because it reminds me of Alice: Madness Returns. Both have the eerie, creepy and dark aesthetics that the original book conveyed, although Madness Returns was far more chaotic. It’s understandable that people dislike the live-action due to plot holes and all, but compared to Disney’s current live-action catastrophes, Alice In Wonderlands live-action is true cinema next to the Cinderella live-action of Disney’s.
This original was created by Lewis Carroll and Disney made it into a movie. I like both honestly the story of Alice is interesting and the concept behind wonderland is as well.
Which movie do you like better? 👀
Thanks for watching ❤️
I like both
live action, no doubt
Live action so underrated
Live action for me
I loved the 1985 live action Alice in wonderland lots of classic actors
Honestly the live action gets hated on so much for no reason in my opinion it’s the only the Disney live action remake that is actually enjoyable and felt like it’s own thing instead of being a cash grab and I honestly do prefer the live action over the animated one.
Yeah it didn’t really follow the same formula of the other live actions with them being verbatim to the originals.
But it didn’t do it well.
There’s a difference between a different adaptation and completely ripping out the spirit of what the original was going for, which is the live action versions problem. When the story instead of Alice In Wonderland is Grownup Alice Returns To Underland, amidst the fact that a whimsical story of childish fantasy has been replaced with a serious, gritty war movie and little of the charm of the original characters has survived - and NONE of Alice who has been replaced with a block of wood - don’t you think that represents just a _bit_ of a problem?
@@Longshanks1690 Yeah it does but I think the second movie helped it a bit though.
@@Longshanks1690 No.
If many, especially the majority, hates a movie, it's not likely it would be for "no reason".
RIP Alan Rickman, he was the Blue Caterpillar
We will be missed… ALWAYS.
always /*
Always...
Alan Rickman was Severus Snape too...
...the bravest man who ever lived.
@@LazyOldFusspot_3428 hence the "always" but yes
He was amazing
@@jgzaz how the most hated teacher in Hogwarts turned out to actually to *CARE* for Harry Potter after all the years in Hogwarts he has been treating him :_(
It is actually confirmed that the queen in the Live action is not the queen of hearts, but the red queen who was in the same universe and was in the stories of Alice written by the original creator.
Ohh 😮 really I wondered why the names were different
@@LakiaJaiTV yh, also i love your videos! Keep doing what you love!
She has a whole backstory as well
Yes! I think the movie follows the original story in its own way, I think it's pretty good!
@@sridevisudhahar309 the original story has the red queen turn into a cup of tea (idk if it was tea but she transformed into something).
How is it anything remotely similar to the OG work?
Life action Alice is literally one of my favorite of all time. But the cartoon, if I need to be honest, I don't remember most of it (but when I re-watch it I was not really impressed). I don't hate the original cartoon, it's just not for me. But the movie is a great as a fantasy, so yeah, I love it)
I think seeing it as a kid would have been really enjoyable (animated version) but at my age right now it was hard keeping interest through out. It was funny at times though.
@@LakiaJaiTV totally agree with you. Old one is colourful and funny for kids, but for others it's just so random, and live action is more for teens+ I think, so now everyone have the version of this story for their age)
@@LakiaJaiTV yeahhhhh, as a kid in the 80s I lost interest in the animated version and left the room. As an adult I lost interest in the live action version and walked out of the theater. I've probably walked out on 5 movies total in my life after sitting down to watch them and 2 of those happen to be Alice in Wonderland lol Go figure, because I look back on the movies fondly, I just didn't know how they ended until I watched your reactions lol
Kinda the same for me except the complete opposite. Found live action mostly forgettable besides certain instances which I just found kinda gross or easy to mock.
@@ma.2089 How so? The live action was definitely incredible and added so much depth.
the live-action Alice and Wonderland is more of a "sequel" or a continuation/spin-off than an actual remake because it does tell a new story just with the same characters
Yeah, that's because the live-action is an adaptation of the second book "Alice Through The Looking Glass". In the first book everything is based in card games, in the second one it's all about chess
@@tinxstesiaobsidianThe loosest sense of "adaptation"..
Dumpster fire that has little to nothing to do with Alice in Wonderland besides character names
The live action will always hold a special place in my heart idk why I just love the darker Alice tone. It’s definitely one of my favorite Alice interpretations. Maybe it’s because I love Alice Madness Returns so much and those video games.
Lmao I remember watching this in 3D
The Queen of Hearts is in the first book 'Alice's Adventures in Wonderland' which also has the queens of Diamonds, Clubs and Spades but she's the most important Queen there. She orders everyone's heads to be off throughout the croquet game but I think in the book the king of heart secretly manages to give them a pardon, except for when the Cheshire Cat refused to pay homage to him. Same as in the animated movie they have a crazy marriage but it somehow works.
The Red Queen and the White Queen are from the second book 'Through the Looking Glass and What Alice Found There', they're like chess pieces. One of them runs in the same spot for a while, the other one is always saying stuff like 'Jam yesterday and jam tomorrow but never jam today', but I can't remember which does which. There is a white king and a red king but I can't remember much about the white king, just that the red king was asleep throughout the whole story and there's a big question as to whether or not he's dreaming up Alice or Alice is dreaming up him.
I think the original idea was that the queen of hearts was a hot temper kind of anger and fury jumping up and down and screeching 'off with their heads' like a spoiled child, the red queen was a colder kind of anger like a governess when she's caught her children misbehaving.
And if O remember correctly, the white queen wasn't better- her sense of justice was to imprison people because of their "future crimes" even if there's no proof that's going tk happen
The White Queen was the jam tomorrow and jam yesterday but never jam today Lady.
I personally prefer the original! It’s my favorite Disney classic.
Yes. The live action is not bad, but WTF "Alice in armor with a sword" ? Alice is supposed to be a little girl, not Red Sonja ! Not a dragon slayer !
@@Daniel24724 well i mean its supposed to be her grown up not the little girl she was when she first went there
@@xoxo.eliiii So, it isn't an adaptation, it's a sequel. The title should be : "Return in Wonderland" .. or ... "Alice 2 : the mission". 😁
@@Daniel24724 yes!! i agree but i guess they thought Alice in wonderland was better….
Agree but it's not personal preference. It's simply waaaaaay better than Tim's boring reading of Alice. 😏
I have literally not laughed so hard in hard in a loooong time, you had me crying. The whole oyster bit is my new life. Thank you.
Lollll with lacrimosa in the background. I died
I’m late, but equally as weak 🤣
I love the live action remake! It felt true to the original, but it was also a more grown up take on Alice and her problems. The cast is also amazing which is part of the reason I love it so much.
"It felt true to the original" Uh, excuse me?
The live action totally MISSES the point ans escence of the original book, and Tim Burton just straight up admited he hated that book so thats why he made it TOTALLY different to the original book, are you ok???
@@skyxclouds3765
To me, it feels almost the same. The thing is that now the little girl is grown up, and the land of fantasies needs her to be what it was.
I personally loved it.
And also, you sounded a little bit worked up.
@@skyxclouds3765 it’s a movie why are you getting worked up on someone’s personal feelings towards the movie
I love the part where Alice cried, knowing that she wasnt getting anywhere. This was the pinnacle of Alice's character
I remember seeing the trailer for the live action Alice in wonderland in theaters and it scared the crap outta me, but I ended up loving the movie! I especially love the Cheshire cat.
I watched the live action before the original as a kid, and i remember being so shocked that unlike all the other memories, alice didn't get married. that was the first time i realized that marriage wasn't the end of the road, and for that i really owe it to that movie. alice was THE girlboss for me without being so in your face about it. im so glad it wasn't a remake of the original but instead set after it too
Thank you omg, I remember watching this movie as a kid on repeat and it HEAVILY influenced who I am. The messages it sent really stuck with me even now as a fresh 18 year old jumping into adulthood. I’ll always cherish this movie , 💜
GIRL HOW CAN IT HAVE BEEN 11 MONTHS SINCE THE CORALINE VIDEO?!?! THATS LITERALLY WHEN I DISCOVERED YOUR CHANNEL WTF?!?!
I know right lol
@@LakiaJaiTV istg this year has gone TOO fast 😭💖💕
For real!! That's how I found her channel too
The first live-action Alice is my absolute favourite! The mysterious vibes, the gloom mixed with the wonder and mild nuerodivergent vibes mix perfectly. And Alice discovering her Muchness and age, perfectly matches my stage in life and inspires me in a way the second doesnt... Also, that time period of dress? *chefs kiss*
I prefer the original, but I do think the live action at least tried to stand on its own and deserves credit for that. I think it's cool that back in the day you could literally trip on acid and tell your boss about it and he'd be like 👍🏼 let's animate that. Another great video, enjoyed this format, thanks
Same
The Live Action Alice in Wonderland isn’t really a remake, it’s a sequel, Alice is all grown up, revisiting Wonderland, and they mention Alice’s visit in the original cartoon.
Well.... Explain to everyone why absolem return to his worm form 😒
omg the 2003 live action peter pan is sooooo good it’s one of the best live actions i’ve ever seen for an adaption of an animated movie.
The original Alice in Wonderland felt like a fever dream tbh 😂
I think that was the point
that's the point lol
That was the point it wasnt supposed to make sense
that's the point genius
Hallmark’s Alice in Wonderland 1999 is an underrated gem! It has a star studded cast and is a lot more like the animated movie in terms of the magic and whimsical feel!
I do not know if it was intentional, but I also find it interesting that Alice in that film has brunette hair. It feels like a homage to the original Alice who Lewis Carroll wrote the stories for even though he himself drew Alice with blonde hair to separate the two figures to some extent.
As much as I love Alice and grew up with this as well. I prefer Alice Liddell from Alice Madness Return more because it's dark in that wonderland. I agree the live action is a lot more entertaining than the classic movie.
Omg Alice the madness returns was somthing crazy. Made a cosplay on her hysteria mode😂
And American Mcgee would have done an alice movie if all his financiers didn't jump off because of Tim burton plan to make an alice movie. It would have been so much better, but yeah...
Agreed! Alice in Madness Returns is literally the coolest version of her to exist imo
Alice Madness Returns is *chefs kiss*
Live action ISN'T more entertaining than the classic movie
There are multiple answers to the riddle “ why is a raven like a writing desk?” I happen to like “ because they both have inky quills.”
I grew up with the original Alice, and I think of it as a prequel to the 2010 film. The original Alice was a little girl waking up from a dream of Wonderland, which she thought she created in her head, only to find out in the 2010 version that the dreams were actually memories of events that actually happened.
Disney is going to end up trying to do all live actions and honestly I’m ready for some new stuff nothing wrong with the old Disney movies I just feel like Disney wants to keep remaking the old movies by making it into live action. I feel like there running out of ideas 💡
I love that you’re doing the old movies and I love your channel ❤️and the way you edit you seem like such a fun person to be friend with 😊
@Jimin is My Bias they touched Hercules. Their writing the story right now. 😁
It's sad because I'm sure there's plenty of amazing writers on their team with plenty of good ideas, but Disney simply doesn't see it as worth the effort
@@peepawfart I would love to have another 2d animation with classical music/instruments and I want a new black disney princess but I know I am asking for too much.
As an introverted little girl who spent a lot of her time just using her imagination there was something very relatable about cartoon alice that made feel very attached to the movie so I'll always prefer it in a very biased way... I remember enjoying the live action as a kid but I never became attached to that version of alice bc I couldn't really see myself in her anymore
I don’t care what anyone says, the new live action Alice in Wonderland is much better than the original, because it’s more Cryptid to the original book, also between the first new life action and the second movie, through the looking glass, I personally like the looking glass better, it’s a lot more playful with color. You should totally react to that one, I think you might like that one too
No it isn't None of the live action remakes were ever good, What makes this one different? NOTHING,"Because it's more cyptid to the original book" It really isn't. Nothing EVER beats the original
@@isislemons303 what is up with you people just refusing to accept that some people prefer a remake or sequel over the original I like the original because I prefer the darker tone to it it feels more grown up
Because Tim Burton doesn't understand the true message of the book. The nonsense message.
WTH with the prophecy arc?
12:40 Funny thing about Alice not being a Disney Princess, in the Kingdom Hearts games she is regarded as one of the seven princesses of heart (alongside Aurora, Belle, Jasmine, Cinderella, Snow White, and Kairi). So I guess that counts? It's the only time she's ever been recognized as a Disney princess, so I count it.
I never watched the animation as a kid. The live action, however, was a sweet part of my childhood, which makes the fact that I've watched the animation recently and it's become one of my all-time favorite movies that much weirder lol
The animation just have that feeling... It's sooo unique, so magical, so free and absolutely crazy, kind of scary and a bit disturbing. It have everything I love most in a story. The live action have a place in my heart of course, but it just doesn't have the same feeling.
Dinah is my all-time favorite Disney cat in the entire Disney universe! She's so pretty in red.
12:34: *laughs in Kingdom Hearts*
No really, she's a Princess of Heart in that game.
I LOVE the original animated movie!!!! Literally one of my hands down, all time favourite Disney movies. The live action is good, but the OG is so much better in my opinion!
And this is from the Golden Age of Disney, I believe. But way back when, the original Disney movies didn't have the castle intro. They opened from literal books. Like the source material. Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Snow White, etc all do it too.
YES
@@dangosandlemons ah......a fellow person of taste, I see. 😁😂🤣
I like your profile picture.
In what way is the original better? Or are you just blinded by nostalgia?
@@seandalo That just their opinion if they like the original better than that's ok
@@seandalo Plot-wise and humor, it's a lot more fun
Perfect timing. I’m absolutely obsessed with your content. 🤩❤️
Thank you 😊
Fun fact The Queen of Hearts and The Red Queen are actually two different Queens the Queen of Hearts is based on the Card game while The Red Queen is the red chess piece if anyone didn’t know
12:08 And that's what set me on a lifelong prejudice against mustard.
I like the og version better because of the music. this is perfect thank you.
also I wouldn't mind more classics like fantasia Hercules but also beauty and the beast live action.
The cast in live action is just so great! Very fun to watch.
No Johnny Depp sucks as the Mad Hatter
I think the costumes from the second one are fabulous, and the plot from the 1st is better
I remember watching the live action Alice in wonderland, my two favorite characters was the mad hatter and the Cheshire cat, I like them 🙂❤
“Will you be my wife?”
“Absolutely not”
I just died 😂
I think the live action is amazing but I do prefer the animation! I think Alice in Wonderland has the potential to be expanded into a television series similar to His Dark Materials!!
I 100% prefer the live action - it’s the movie I would put into my DVD player most as a kid and I would watch it on repeat, everything about the movie is nostalgic for me. But I really do think the movie stands well on its own and is a darker, more mature take on Alice in Wonderland, but the cartoon movie is too boring for me. The live action one is exciting and the Tim Burton aesthetic he brought to it was amazinggg
I have the live action Alice In Wonderland on DVD, and it’s literally my favorite live action adaptation movie from Disney!!!!
The live action has a special place in my heart. Eating Mexican candy and being with my older brother and dad and just watching the live action. Good times :)
both alice in wonderlands were my favorites as a child. i had a portable dvd player and watched tim burtons version constantly. then at my mom’s job, before i went to camp i would watch the 1951 version on vhs every morning and never got past the tea party scene 😂
When I was younger I never liked the live action much and now It’s one of my favourite Disney live actions, I’m in love with the the gloomy royal fairytale vibe about it. Just so beautifullllll
Alice in Wonderland is the only story I know that can get away with the "it was all a dream" thing.
How a raven is like a writing desk is that they both can make a note.
23:00: not her laughing at the exact same time with the hare and the mouse HAD ME DEAD!!😂😂😂😂😭😭😭😭
The live action is supposed to be a sequel, but everything is invented and has little to nothing to do with the Lewis Carroll novels of Alice. The animated classic on the other hand is a very good adaptation of both books.
Exactly. I think the live action is great but it's not very good adapting the Alice in Wonderland books, while the books are all about nonsense, poems, songs, riddles and games, the live action involves political issues and removes every piece of spontaneity (they even tell you the ingredients of the potion that makes you smaller), but anyway it has its charm and I really love the story line and Tim Burton's aesthetic. Both movies are masterpieces to me.
Yes, I don't hate Tim Burton but..... I think he doesn't understand the true essence of the book: The nonsense!
And I'm the only one who think that the actress of Alice (I don't know her name) is very inexpressive?
For the animated Alice, I remember as a kid being so disappointed whenever the film got to the Queen part. It just got really sad and twisted, although the film is weird. For the new one, things were easier to take in, but I felt the dance at the end was overkill, but maybe that was on purpose.
Do Cruella and 101 Dalmatians next!
Which version of 101 dalmations? Cartoon or live action
This was a cool concept reacting to the animated and then the live action at the same time. You should do more like that. I liked this!
34:55 Labyrinth! Watch Labyrinth!
“Should you need us…?” 🦉🔮🍑
Fun fact: That famous line from The Mad Hatter.
Why is a Raven like a Writing Desk?
Well, Lewis Carol didn't know himself.
Alice in wonderland was my entire childhood!!! This movie shaped the way I saw the world and how I imagined it
Nah I never understood the hate either I enjoyed it alot I even wanted thete to be more and there was the looking glass that was amazing as well. Usually live actions are horrible and doesn't have the same feel as original but this one was amazing
I could be wrong but the problem is that in alice in wonderland, they only use her to slay the jabberwocky and in through the looking glass it's always about the mad hatter. And sometimes the mad hatter is in the centre of the movie posters instead of Alice herself.
I love this channel omg
My anser to the riddle is:
A raven has black feathers and a pen is usually in black ink. They must've used the raven's feather to use it as a writing desk. Like as one of thise old timey feather quills.🧏🏾♀️💁🏾♀️🪶✒
Honestly to me the best live action remake was peter pan 2003 i just loved it
30:37 "even the dog's in a relationship" honestly I felt that 😂
the fact that she’s reacting to all the movies I love ❤️ this is my whole childhood, sis passed the vibe check.
Its so great that she loves Johnny Depp he is amazing.
13:22 fun fact: That Hooray right there was from the voice actor of Mickey Mouse.
"Okayyyy footwork armwork legwork" BYE LMAO 😭
It’s July now after Jonny Drop’s trial and her comment got me 😂😅
In the Spanish dubbing of the animated classic, the translator Edmundo Santos dedicated the Alice in Wonderland song to his wife Alicia (Alice), adapting it as a poem for her 🥺
I completely forgot about the ending credits song omg, the nostalgia I got from hearing it holy shit. Honestly mood I adored the live-action. That's so cool how it's like a sequel yet still being like a remake. It's so good.
The live action slaps and Johnny Depp omggg
It's SO refreshing whenever somebody enjoys the Tim Burton movie as much as you do! I ADORED the Hatter as a kid, I thought he was so silly and sweet. Dude's a puppy in human form. Also, the editing for this video is *top tier!* Also I agree Avril Lavigne was a 2000s queen!
I definitely think the live-action version is better, though the animated one has a special place in my heart.
The 1999 live-action was my favorite when I was little until the 2010 version came out. I personally never really liked the animated one, I can see the appeal but it just never really did it for me I guess lol
Hell yeah, someone else who grew up on the 1999 live-action! I feel like since I was more familiar with that one as opposed to the Disney animated version it opened me up to the concepts of the 2010 one better. Well, that & the fact that I was raised on Tim Burton movies and thus already a fan of his by then. 😆💗
Kind of same, though I grew up on the 1993 live action instead xD
I was absolutely in love with both live-action movies! And this is the first time I'm seeing anyone having issue with the movie lol Maybe it's because I come from a country that didn't have its childhood shaped by a company like Disney. To be fair, I wasn't very fond of the animation for some reason. But I would die for Mia's Alice aaaaa
I'm SCREAMING at the opening of this video. Once again you dont miss with your videos. My dog and I are thriving today
Why is a raven is like a writing desk?
Because it can produce a few notes
That’s according to the author of Alice in Wonderland ❤️ ♠️ ♣️♦️
OH MY GOD THE ALICE IN WONDERLMAD MOVIES ARE LITERALLY MY RELIGION I LOVE THIS SO MUCHH AAA. Thanks you for making this video!!
Alice in Wonderland is my favorite movie. I remember there was this Alice in Wonderland Disney book for children in National Bookstore that came along with an Alice Necklace. I immediately asked my parents for the book but mainly for the necklace. I absolutely loved it. I still remember the smell. I would watch the 2010 version so many times as a child filled with innocence to the point that I didn't even close my eyes when the door mouse stabbed and removed the Bandersnatch's eye ball nor during the part when Alice slayed the Jobberwocky. I wish I could watch it again. With the one from 1951, I didn't watch it as much as the 2010 during my childhood. And I got scared at the intro because of the dark color. In the present moment right now, I watch Alice in Wonderland 1951 more. I even memorized "In A Wod of My Own," the "Golden Afternoon, " and "the Walrus and the Carpenter (not perfecly)"
One thing that may be a major reason of loving Alice in Wonderland is ballet class. My big sister and I took classes as children and there was this Alice in Wonderland play the ballerinas participated in including my big sister. She played one of the rabbits. Unfortunately, I was not allowed to be part of the play because I was too young. I was just part of the audience and as I watched the play knowing I'm not part, I cried so much, like the way Alice cried. The teacher said "Next Time" but I'm still waiting for "Next Time." I want to read the original "Alice Adventures in Wonderland" book along with the "Through the Looking Glass" one. This year, I got an Alice in Wonderland necklace which was a "Drink Me" bottle design. I chose it probably because I miss wearing the Alice Necklace of my childhood.
Another great reaction as always!!! Can't wait for more THE 100 videos!!! :) :) :)
I didn't realise for ages that in the animated movie the Cheshire Cat was singing the opening verse of the 'Jabberwocky' song
I always liked the live action movie because of the plot and the action
I enjoyed your reaction video, I never knew Alice was so funny and your reactions to her cracked me up 😂😂😂😂
GIRL! YOU HAVE A WONDERFUL SINGING VOICE!
Now we need a Cinderella Animated vs. Cinderella Live Action!! It's another one of those that I feel like the live action was done better ❤
it wasn't the live action is ALWAYS terrible
@Isis Lemons you mean for just kids/Disney movies or just in general??because that statement is wrong both ways😭😭
i love that you included a memory verse 🤎.
I enjoy a TH-camr whose videos make me laugh. You made a laugh a couple of times. Subscribed!
the live action movie was my a big part of my childhood. to this day, i still really want a Bandersnatch
Your reactions and edits made the movies so much better! Hilarious!
Why choose? I love both of them so much! I have a great lot of affection for either Alice Move for various reasons, but I could watch either and never get bored!
i grew up watching the one from the 50s but i never saw the new one i do like that it's more of a sequel
Yuuuuus I just need more of your videos so I can play them while I paint
I know why a Raven is like a writing desk... Because one is never backwards and one is always four words....
Loving your editing and overall vibe!
the music in the live action is so beautiful to me......i really loved it as a kid
TIM BURTON’S ALICE IN THE WONDERLAND IS SO GOOD
I love the live-action Alice in wonderland because it reminds me of Alice: Madness Returns. Both have the eerie, creepy and dark aesthetics that the original book conveyed, although Madness Returns was far more chaotic.
It’s understandable that people dislike the live-action due to plot holes and all, but compared to Disney’s current live-action catastrophes, Alice In Wonderlands live-action is true cinema next to the Cinderella live-action of Disney’s.
This original was created by Lewis Carroll and Disney made it into a movie. I like both honestly the story of Alice is interesting and the concept behind wonderland is as well.
Fun fact, the mock turtle, and the Griffin used to be in this film, but they were put out of the film
I got out of school early so here I am hey bestie
Hey bestie 😝
@@LakiaJaiTV loving the video so far u always cheer me up also my birthday was last Saturday had a good time
That moment you realize that the live action one is technically a sequel, and not a remake.
thank you for taking us down this rabbit hole
*the place is burning down** "awe he's so cute" lol same girl