There is no difference of opinion when it comes to music. You can't ignore or reject a hadith nor does his justification makes sense. All the senior ullema have unified stance on such matter. Kindly look again dear akhi. May Allah give us all hidayah
"There is no difference of opinion" According to the Irish Times, "a majority of Muslims" follow the view taken by modern scholars such as Yusuf al-Qaradawi that music is forbidden "only if it leads the believer into activities that are clearly defined as prohibited, such as drinking alcohol and illicit sex".[10] Imam al-Ghazali, reported several hadith and came to the conclusion that music in and of itself is permitted, saying: "All these Ahadith are reported by al-Bukhari and singing and playing are not haram." He also references a narration from Khidr, wherein a favorable opinion of music is expressed.[30][24] According to Hussein Rashid, "contemporary scholars including Shaykh al-Azhar Mahmud Shaltut, Shaykh Yusuf Qaradawi, and Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini have all issued legal rulings that audio arts [including music] that do not encourage people to go against the faith are permitted."[31] Notable people who are regarded as having believed music is halal include Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi, Ibn al-Qaisarani, Ibn Sina, Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, Abd al-Ghani al-Nabulsi, Rumi, Ibn Rushd, and Ibn Hazm.[citation needed]
Music is not Haram, These are evidences..👇 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion to the musical sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087, sahih bukhari 5048. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. You can deny or accept it or blindly follow your sect scholars. It is upto you. For me it is clear that Maasic is Nat Haram!
@@zeeshanbinnaushadnujjoo1389 if the lyrics are good you can listen. Music helps in concentration, fighting against boredom, some background music helps even in studying. There is no evidence exists in Islam to make Music Haram. Some Salafi scholars said its haram, thats why some are following it eventho there is no Quran verse or authentic hadith.
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
@@mrweeb8533stop assuming out of him. what one does is when 2 hadiths show different point of views is we come together and understand. some music is halal some is haram depending on its content and it's purpose
Music is not Haram, These are evidences..👇 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion to the musical sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087, sahih bukhari 5048. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. You can deny or accept it or blindly follow your sect scholars. It is upto you. For me it is clear that Maasic is Nat Haram!
the reason you see nasheed alot is because its simply the sound of mouth sure its edited amplified and produced but its a safer option, for me personally i avoid it all together better be safe than sorry and thats not to mean idon't like music, i also like girls but guess what i look for a different option like marriage or avoid it all together like music.
you're right, the main reason is that one of the end times signs that dancing and singing will become common. just like the reason women didnt drive in KSA for a while, because its one of the end times signs that ladies will travel on comfortable vehicles by themselves.
@@systemicdegradationYani men love women, men love having sex, does this enjoyable part of our brain called dopamine give us halal Zina because Allah gave us this feeling? Allah tests you in many ways brother
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
Thank you. Listen the young brother and sister need music that remind us of Allah in your music do, that good for all ages may Allah bless you and your family and your talent that is a gift from our creator Allah alone bless you 😊
@@abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz9840 IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
"The heart of man has been so constituted by the Almighty that, like a flint, it contains a hidden fire which is evoked by music and harmony, and renders man beside himself with ecstasy. These harmonies are echoes of that higher world of beauty which we call the world of spirits; they remind man of his relationship to that world, and produce in him an emotion so deep and strange that he himself is powerless to explain it. The effect of music and dancing is deeper in proportion as the natures on which they act are simple and prone to emotion; they fan into a flame whatever love is already dormant in the heart, whether it be earthly and sensual, or divine and spiritual." - Imam Ghazali , Alchemy of Happiness
I never heard about this sheikh before. Brother, by consensus of scholars about the topic of Music its meant scholars that are declared as great scholars of islam. Like imam schafii imam bukhari imam alqurtubi…
Very foolish and ignorant comment, people like to use these labels when they do not agree with something even though there is ample evidence. The four major schools of thought: Hanbali, Maliki, Shafi and Hanafi all said music is haram and the Hanafi are the most strict. So were these great scholars extremists? Please make effort to gain knowledge instead of spewing this false rhetoric.
@@aussiemuslim Forget about the Scholars or the ancient people. Bring me the authentic evidence which says Music is Haram. You know clearly there is no Evidence. Islam is completed and clear. Jesus is God to christians bcoz Christian Scholars said so. There is no Priesthood in Islam. So even if all the humans said its haram, its never gonna be Haram until ALLAH say so. That's Islam, its the religion of ALLAH not any Jahiloons. So do not make anything Haram in Islam without evidence from ALLAH. If you do so, you will go to bloody Hell burn the hell out of you. Do not be a Jahil. Abu Jahil said the same, our forefathers did this, so we are doing it.
@@aussiemuslim * It is not mandatory to follow those 4 imams. Even the veryfying scholars of Shafi'e and Maliki Madhabs said many things contrary to the opinion of Imam Shafi'e. For example, shaving beard is not considered Haram in Shafie and Maliki Madhab, thats the official fiqh of those 2 madhabs. But the imams said its Haram. Likewise many things, like the rulings of ablution. And those 4 imams are not prophets of ALLAH. Moreover 100 of imams had the opinion that music not Haram like Imam Gazzali, Imam Ibn Huzm, etc. * Christians believe Jesus is God, bcoz their scholars said so. If they Go to hell then you'd also go to hell for following scholars blindly. * Abu Jahal said the same to the Prophet SA, "our forefathers believed like this, so we're believing like that". and ALLAH asked them in Quran, "Where's the evidence from ALLAH?" * In Islam we need clear evidence to make anything Haram. No authentic evidence from Hadith exists and No Quran verse exists to make Music Haram. * Bukhari hadith 5590 is not authentic, its a hanged hadis or un-numbered hadis in Bukhari bcoz the reporter got no connection to the Prophet SA. Also its not a direct statement. * There are almost 50 sahih Bukhari ultra authentic hadis exists which say prophet SA allowed Music, even compared Quran recitation of Abu Musa to the rhythmic sound of Mizmar(flute). Prophet SA even invited wedding singers to a wedding function. So Stop Following Scholars. You did the same when you were a Christian, you are doing the same still. No change! Be a Muslim who follow the truth, do not be an extreme Scholar Worshipper who haramise everything. Salafism is clearly a deviation. Islam is not a Monastic mosque religion. You dont have to have the beard of Abu Jahal or a Rabbi to be a Muslim. People should not fear you when they see you. ALLAH made everything clear, nothing Missed . Alhamdulillah!
AussieMuslim, Hahahha..! “All the 4 imams” , this is what all the Neo Salafies say! And yet these Salafies do not follow these Madhabs or Imams. They deny all of them, and follow their sect leaders like Shaikh ibn Uthaymeen, Ibn Baz. You were a Christian who followed the Scholars blindly, it’s a shame you are still doing the same even as a Muslim. A Muslim is a truth seeker, a Muslim cannot follow any Scholars blindly bcoz there is a verse in Quran which says against Scholar-hood. Muslims are those who rely mainly on the revelation from God. It is clear that there is no restrictions against Music in Quran or in Hadis. And you know that, that’s why you are bringing Scholars into the discussion.
@@DonDiiiii of course we have to bring scholars in to the discussion, they are the successors of the Prophet ﷺ. Abu Darda reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The scholars are the successors of the prophets. Verily, the prophets do not pass on gold and silver coins, but rather they only impart knowledge.” Source: Musnad al-Bazzār 10/68 Grade: Salih (good) according to Al-Bazzār عَنْ أَبِي الدَّرْدَاءِ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُ قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ الْعُلَمَاءُ خُلَفَاءُ الأَنْبِيَاءِ إِنَّ الأَنْبِيَاءَ لَمْ يُوَرِّثُوا دِينَارًا وَلا دِرْهَمًا إِنَّمَا وَرَّثُوا الْعِلْمَ 10/68 البحر الزخار بمسند البزار 10/68 المحدث البزار خلاصة حكم المحدث إسناده صالح في البحر الزخار If we do not take knowledge from the scholars then we can only follow our own logic in interpreting the Qur'an and hadith, which would only leade us astray. Hence why there are misguided sects and those who claim to only follow the Qur'an and not the sunnah. May Allah protect us and guide us to the straight path.
There’s levels to piety, and if you can give up all music for the sake of Allah guaranteed there is a reward waiting for you. If the music has haram subject matter it is clearly haram. I think if it doesn’t have idle or nonsensical speech, for example claiming your love can move mountains are something far fetched. I personally think the best position is to has the intention to move away from music and pray that Allah helps you to do it.
Salam Alikum my brother, Allah has united us as brothers in faith, alhamduliLah for it. My brother, There would always be a diffence of opinion if you consider an argument based on falsehood to be an honest opinion and a considerable one. What they are trying to do is to keep you away from the Quran, the companions explanation of its verses, and from the Hadiths of our beloved prophet peace and blessings be upon him. Then, replace this with their understanding based on their desires. This is a honest naseeha, we’re all in this together for now, in the hereafter, every soul, for what it has earned, will be retained. May Allah guide us to what He is pleased with.
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 Duff is allowed because the prophet peace and blessings be upon him said so. Other instruments are forbidden because he also said so. Simple as that.
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 Relax brother. It was narrated that Muhammad bin Hatib said: "The Messenger of Allah said: 'What differentiates between the lawful and the unlawful is the Duff, and the voice (singing) for the wedding.'" Sunan an-Nasa'i 3369 Grade: Hasan (Darussalam)
The problem here is, just beacause you listen to some music, it doesn't mean you can't read Quran, if you addicted to music that's your own issue, literlly anything can took you away from Quran if you addicted with it, theres also Music which using word Quran, so how does that took you away from Quran?
This list is sourced from Al-Azhar fatawa, from Shawkani’s Nayl al-Awtar, from the article by Imam Yahya Ederer, and from fatwa by Sheikh Abdullah Bin Yusuf al-Judai (see section I): · Abdullah bin Jafar bin Abi Talib (al-Aqd al-Fareed 6/12) · Imam ibn Hazm (Al-Muhallah) · Imam Abu Talib al-Makki (Qut al-Qulub) · Imam Abu Hamed al-Ghazali (Ihya ulum ad-din) · Imam al-Shawkani (Ibtal dawa al-Ijmaa ala mutlaq al-Sama) · Imam Abdul-Ghani al-Nablusi (Idaahat al-Dalalaat fee sama al-alaat) · Sultan al-Ulema al-Iz ibn Abdul-Salam (Rislat al-Sama) · Al-Qadi Ibn Qutaiba al-Daynoor (al-Rukhsah fi al-Sama) · Imam Ibn Tahir al-Qaisirani (al-Sama) · Imam al-Thahabi (al-Rukhsah fil-Ghinaa wa al-Turb) · Qadi Abu Bakr Ibn Al-Arabi al-Makki (Ahkam al-Quran) · Sheikh Yusuf al-Majishun (#3399 ibn al-Khuthayma) · Sheikh al-Islam Ibn Daqiq al-Id (Iqtinas al-Sawanih) · Grand Imam of al-Azhar Jad Ali jad al-Haqq (fatwa #3280) · Grand Sheikh of al-Azhar Mahmud Al-Shaltut (pg. 375 fatawa) · Mufassir Abu al-Faraj al-Isfahani (Kitab al-Aghani) · Qadi Al-Mawardi (Kitab Aadab al-Dunya w'al-Din) · Ibn Khaldun, Chief Maliki Qadi of Cairo, and historian (Muqaddimah, chapter 5, section 31) · Abu al-Mawahib al-Shadhli (Farh al-Asma bi Rakhs al-Sima) · Taj al-Din al-Fakihani (quoted in Nayl al-Awtar) · Al-Rawiani (cited in Dar al-Ifta Missriyya fatwa #7000) · Abu Mansur al-Bughdadi (cited in Dar al-Ifta Missriyya fatwa #7000) · Abd al-Ghani al-Rafii (cited in Dar al-Ifta Missriyya fatwa #7000) · Imām 'Ezz al-Din ibn 'abd al-Salām (Al-Tag wa al-Ikli) · Imam Abu Bakr Al Adfawi (quoted in Nayl al-Awtar) · Abul Mahasin Al Ruyani (quoted in Nayl al-Awtar) · Abu Mansur Al Fawrani (quoted in Nayl al-Awtar) · Minhal ibn Amr al-Asadi al-Kufi (cited by Imam Ahmad in his son’s book Jarh wa Ta'adeel) · Al-Sheikh ibn al-Qammah (quoted in Farh al-Asma bi Rokhs al-Sima) · Imam al-Haramayn (al-Nihaya, also quoted in Nayl al-Awtar)
Stop covering your eyes and your ears, and be open minded. Proof is being presented to you and you are turning away. Do you think Allah would forget to mention that music is haram in the Qur'an? No, Allah does not forget. People lie to make the lives of the Muslims harder, with the intention of diverting Muslims away from Islam. If such a big thing would land you in Hell, it would certainly be written in the Qur'an. So no, music is NOT haram.
Assalamualaikum my dear brother. Are you trying to say the music of today, mainstream pop is halal? I know where you're coming from and I do follow the opinion music is haram however I don't believe you can say mainstream pop music is halal at all when they indulge about details about such actions which are vulgar. والله اعلم
no quran never says music is prohibited but instead "IDLE TALES" , IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
I think everyone should start From basic all over again to understand where music started from . Muslims should learn The origin of Adam and Hawas arrival and about their offsprings and how' lies, murder, burial , zina etc all started. Youe will find the answer there for music as well. There are prophets series you can watch one TH-cam and it will all make sense very easy . I still listen to beats ( just beats with no lyrics) 🫤 and i pray that' i can One Day give it up fully . Took me a while to give up music with lyrics. Now' Just stuck to beats and drums . Ill try to to give that up as well unless I am marchlng to filistin . I make sure I listen to Quran More then music and making suree my Quran time is much longer than any beats or music. Slowly all my favorite music starting to sound distorted and kinda hating them. Really hope im almost there to quit it for Good . Please keep me in your duahs that I can stop All the wrong doings 🤲. And ill keep you All in my Duahs for the same .
i think you did the opposite, musical instrument are all haram except maybe the daff but singing is debated between scholars so try something like nasheed which most of it has only mouth sounds. ur on the right track brother (as in trying to leave music) keep it up.
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED f=in 19th century
So stick to religious songs and drums and not listening to rapers and dancing with Belly dancers and Al other instruments. If he allowed that type singing and instrument than that' was the limit .
We have bigger fish to fry people. Our brothers and sisters are being slaughtered right now in Gaza. Come back to this point, once we deal with the more important matters at hand.
i'm worried for you brother, if your source of money is music... even if lets say music isn't haram (though you do base your opinion on one person's word ) i've seen the hadiths about haram money.. it has MAJOR consequences unlike listening to music. please revise your opinions mate. save yourself
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
just because the daff is allowed doesn't mean all other instruments are halal. You have to understand that in none of the four schools of thought is there any permissibility for music. Moreover, Wahhabism did not even start until the end of the 17th century, and Imam Ghazali is not someone from whom everyone takes knowledge, aside from Ashari and Sufi followers.
@@maiwandnawabi3577 first of all i am a sufi follower . imam ghazali is one of the most recogonised and respected scholar and a philosopher of all times . Show me one hadith where prophet says "only daff is halal" , just because daff was allowed dosent mean duff is the only instruement allowed . if insruments are to be prohibited why in those hadith prophet didnt adviced to stop them but he instead listned which technicaly makes it even sunnah to listen !
@@maiwandnawabi3577 Abdullah bin al-Zubair used to keep women playing guitars (lutes) and singing in his presence. (Idahaat al-Dalalat al-Nablusi 96)There is no disagreement about the Ibrahim bin Sa’d bin Abdul Rahman bin Awf listening to songs with guitars (al-Sama’ Ibn Tahir 63)
@@maiwandnawabi3577 Those who say it is permissible include Zahiri, Maliki, Hanbali, and Shafi scholars and they criticize every single one of these Hadith as Daeef. The Great Muhaddith Abul Fadl Ibn Tahir comments that not even a single LETTER from these Hadith are Sahih. He also says in his book on the permissibility of music that there is no dispute between the people of Madinah that musical instruments were permissible and that the Zahiri Scholars unanimously held this view as well. Ibn Arabi the Great Maliki Qadi and Scholar in his Kitab Al Ahkam says there is not even a single Sahih Hadith that prohibits music. The Great Scholar Ibn Hazm says any Hadith prohibiting music cannot be traced back to the Prophet PBUH, they can only be traced back to other than the Prophet PBUH The Great Maliki Scholar Al Fakihani says I do not know of any evidence from the Quran or Sahih Hadith that show that music is haram. The Great Scholar Imam Al Haramayn reports that the Great Sahabi Abdullah Ibn Zubayr owned many singing and dancing girls who would sing and dance for him. The Great Historian Abul Faraj Al Isfahani transmits from the Great Sahabi and Poet of the Prophet, Hasan Ibn Thabit that he would listen to music. The Great Muhaddith Imam Abu Bakr Al Adfawi transmits from the legendary “Fifth Khalifa Rashidun” Umar Ibn Abdul Aziz that he would listen to music before he became a Khalifa. He also said there is no dispute between the people of Madinah that the Qadi of Madinah Ibrahim Ibn Saad would listen to music and said it is permissible. Ibn Samani says that Tawus Ibn Kaysan the Great Tabieen student of the Great Sahabi and legendary Mufassir Ibn Abbas said that music is permissible. The Great Shafi Scholar Abul Mahasin Al Ruyani transmits from Qafaal that the Maliki Madhab ruled that music, instruments, and singing were permissible, Abu Mansur Al Fawrani transmits this from the legendary Founder of the Maliki Madhab Imam Malik as well. The Great Shafi Scholar Abu Talib Al Makki in his book Qut Al Qulub says the Great Muhaddith Manhal Ibn Amr would listen to musical instruments in his palace. All in all, at best Music is permissible and at worst it is a matter of a difference of opinion among scholars. But it cannot be deemed categorically Haram.
let sing like church, even I like music I know thats wrong. its sways your feeling. better acknowledge wrong things rather burry them like it's not wrong and thats just from one man statement
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
I really wonder what these people who are infeding with this are inspired. Do they really doubt the ban on this? Or do they face a lack of faith and determination? If you are still in doubt about the ban on listening to music and musical instruments, let him absorb the following evidence. Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): 'And among the people there are those who sell vain talk to wander from the Way of Allah without knowledge.'( Soerat Loeqmaan: 6) The majority of the Qur'anic exes agree that vain talk in this verse refers to singing. The companion Ibnoe Mascoed has said in response to this verse: 'By Allah, besides Whom is no other god, this is indeed singing.' After which he repeated this three times. Also, the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: 'There will certainly be people among my community who will allow fornication, silk (for men), alcohol and musical instruments.' (al-Boekhaari) The Prophet (peace be upon him) abhorred these people because they would declare musical instruments that are forbidden allowed. He equated this with declaring alcohol and fornication allowed. There are also many other traditions in the Sunan- books and the Musnad of Imam Ahmad that indicate the prohibition of music and the provision of a terrible punishment to those who declare and are guilty of music allowed. A true believer needs no more than one correct proof to omit a forbidden case. SO ALHAMDILILLAH ITS HARAAM!!!
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
As the great Imam Ibn Hazm al-Zahiri wrote: “There is no indication in the wording of this hadith that this warning is tied to listening to musical instruments, nor that it is about singing girls. The apparent meaning of the hadith is that the warning is for their making khamr lawful by giving it a different name. We do not base our religion on conjecture (i.e. by claiming that the punishment is also because of the musical instruments or singing girls).” [12]
"The heart of man has been so constituted by the Almighty that, like a flint, it contains a hidden fire which is evoked by music and harmony, and renders man beside himself with ecstasy. These harmonies are echoes of that higher world of beauty which we call the world of spirits; they remind man of his relationship to that world, and produce in him an emotion so deep and strange that he himself is powerless to explain it. The effect of music and dancing is deeper in proportion as the natures on which they act are simple and prone to emotion; they fan into a flame whatever love is already dormant in the heart, whether it be earthly and sensual, or divine and spiritual." - Imam Ghazali , Alchemy of Happiness
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 who is this Imam??? Are you dump? The Quran and the sunnah clarify cristal clear that Music is haraam! Of you dont accept it then you Go! Alhamdulillah! Music is shaytaan and only the people that follow shaytaan are crying!! Follow the big scholars!! Shaykh al uthaymeen, shaykh bin baz, shaykh al bani and so on. All are big scholars!!
@@KoraanSoennahSalafiyyah show me the evidence akhi show me . IMAM GHAZALI is a greatest scholar and a philosopher of all time , imam ibn HAZM was one of the greatest scholar who has created the 4th madhab (called zahiri) and both of them allowed the use of music as there is no clear evidence to prohibit it
Assalamualaikum Shadi Akhi I do enjoy & appreciate your music, your music help me to stay humble and remember who I am . May Allah continue to bless you to keep making music. Shqran
@@SKA-76 Book 28, Number 5610: Sa'd reported Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) as saying : It is better for the belly of any one of you to be stuffed with pus rather than to stuff (one's mind) with poetry.
@@SKA-76 Sahih al-Bukhari 6154 Narrated Ibn `Umar: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "It is better for a man to fill the inside of his body with pus than to fill it with poetry." Sahih al-Bukhari 6154 Book 78, Hadith 180
Sahih al-Bukhari 6154 Narrated Ibn `Umar: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "It is better for a man to fill the inside of his body with pus than to fill it with poetry." Sahih al-Bukhari 6154 Book 78, Hadith 180
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
m.th-cam.com/video/bql-tCz-QWM/w-d-xo.html&pp=ygUjSXMgbXVzaWMgaGFyYW0gYWJkdXIgUmFobWFuIGhhc3NhbiA%3D For those that are sincere and not just following their desires , we all listen to abit of drizzy here n there. But it's from our weakness. It's sad that brothers be picking and choosing anything. Let everyone know that not every difference is a valid difference. For example : a man comes to a women's and said let's get married and the women said I can't there's conditions. He replies don't worry we don't need a mahram according to the hanafi school And we don't need a mahr according to an opinion attributed to imam shafiee (not the relied upon one) And imam Malik said in an opinion attributed to him it's okay without two witnesses. (Not the relied upon one) Then they both go to hotel and do zina based off these opinions. Hence why I urge you brothers to be sincere and not just run with any opinion that comes your way Barakallah hu feek
Yes i agree with u music is'nt haram in our book quran but always respect quran when u play it and dont listen music in the same time
There is no difference of opinion when it comes to music. You can't ignore or reject a hadith nor does his justification makes sense. All the senior ullema have unified stance on such matter. Kindly look again dear akhi. May Allah give us all hidayah
The problem here can we just believe any hadith like that?
"There is no difference of opinion"
According to the Irish Times, "a majority of Muslims" follow the view taken by modern scholars such as Yusuf al-Qaradawi that music is forbidden "only if it leads the believer into activities that are clearly defined as prohibited, such as drinking alcohol and illicit sex".[10]
Imam al-Ghazali, reported several hadith and came to the conclusion that music in and of itself is permitted, saying: "All these Ahadith are reported by al-Bukhari and singing and playing are not haram." He also references a narration from Khidr, wherein a favorable opinion of music is expressed.[30][24]
According to Hussein Rashid, "contemporary scholars including Shaykh al-Azhar Mahmud Shaltut, Shaykh Yusuf Qaradawi, and Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini have all issued legal rulings that audio arts [including music] that do not encourage people to go against the faith are permitted."[31] Notable people who are regarded as having believed music is halal include Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi, Ibn al-Qaisarani, Ibn Sina, Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, Abd al-Ghani al-Nabulsi, Rumi, Ibn Rushd, and Ibn Hazm.[citation needed]
Music is not Haram, These are evidences..👇
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion to the musical sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087, sahih bukhari 5048.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
You can deny or accept it or blindly follow your sect scholars. It is upto you.
For me it is clear that Maasic is Nat Haram!
Can i make to listening music songs drive car?
@@zeeshanbinnaushadnujjoo1389 if the lyrics are good you can listen.
Music helps in concentration, fighting against boredom, some background music helps even in studying.
There is no evidence exists in Islam to make Music Haram.
Some Salafi scholars said its haram, thats why some are following it eventho there is no Quran verse or authentic hadith.
@@Ripaldo99 yea i know but i don't believe people said listening music is haram
Doesn't matter music can still mess with your brain even uthman ibn Farooq talks about it.
This is the video that talks about it if you want proof.
th-cam.com/video/Q1CzaTe-e1o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=wSN7nNRaxMS7Q-2W
Music is haram lad just accept it and flood your heart with Quran instead
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 bro calm down. I know you listen to Spotify 10 hours a day but only duff is allowed not anything else.
No. 100s of Hadis are there which shows music is not haram.
@@mrweeb8533stop assuming out of him. what one does is when 2 hadiths show different point of views is we come together and understand. some music is halal some is haram depending on its content and it's purpose
Music is not Haram, These are evidences..👇
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion to the musical sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087, sahih bukhari 5048.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
You can deny or accept it or blindly follow your sect scholars. It is upto you.
For me it is clear that Maasic is Nat Haram!
the reason you see nasheed alot is because its simply the sound of mouth sure its edited amplified and produced but its a safer option, for me personally i avoid it all together better be safe than sorry and thats not to mean idon't like music, i also like girls but guess what i look for a different option like marriage or avoid it all together like music.
you're right, the main reason is that one of the end times signs that dancing and singing will become common. just like the reason women didnt drive in KSA for a while, because its one of the end times signs that ladies will travel on comfortable vehicles by themselves.
Music is actually haram because it changes your mood, it give a artificial happiness or sadness, similar to drugs but to a lesser extent.
And Allah gave us the part in our brains that appreciates music for fun?😂
@@systemicdegradationYani men love women, men love having sex, does this enjoyable part of our brain called dopamine give us halal Zina because Allah gave us this feeling?
Allah tests you in many ways brother
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
Where’s your proof? And whats wrong with a bit of mode boosting?
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 Bro no such thing as "WAHABISM" and I'm Sunni
Thank you. Listen the young brother and sister need music that remind us of Allah in your music do, that good for all ages may Allah bless you and your family and your talent that is a gift from our creator Allah alone bless you 😊
Music is haram mate
@@abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz9840 IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
"The heart of man has been so constituted by the Almighty that, like a flint, it contains a hidden fire which is evoked by music and harmony, and renders man beside himself with ecstasy. These harmonies are echoes of that higher world of beauty which we call the world of spirits; they remind man of his relationship to that world, and produce in him an emotion so deep and strange that he himself is powerless to explain it. The effect of music and dancing is deeper in proportion as the natures on which they act are simple and prone to emotion; they fan into a flame whatever love is already dormant in the heart, whether it be earthly and sensual, or divine and spiritual." - Imam Ghazali , Alchemy of Happiness
I never heard about this sheikh before.
Brother, by consensus of scholars about the topic of Music its meant scholars that are declared as great scholars of islam. Like imam schafii imam bukhari imam alqurtubi…
Imam al-Qurtubi said there is Ijma'ah that music is haram. Fear allah.
Mainstream music can be Haram for one too many obvious reasons..but why would Allah forbid something that improves brain health? Like watsupp wit dat?
May ALLAH ﷻ guide you
May God open your heart to Islam
Music is Not Haram!
We worship ALLAH not the Scholars!
Music is haram for Neo Salafies and Wahabies not for Muslims.
Very foolish and ignorant comment, people like to use these labels when they do not agree with something even though there is ample evidence. The four major schools of thought: Hanbali, Maliki, Shafi and Hanafi all said music is haram and the Hanafi are the most strict. So were these great scholars extremists? Please make effort to gain knowledge instead of spewing this false rhetoric.
@@aussiemuslim Forget about the Scholars or the ancient people.
Bring me the authentic evidence which says Music is Haram.
You know clearly there is no Evidence.
Islam is completed and clear.
Jesus is God to christians bcoz Christian Scholars said so.
There is no Priesthood in Islam.
So even if all the humans said its haram, its never gonna be Haram until ALLAH say so.
That's Islam, its the religion of ALLAH not any Jahiloons.
So do not make anything Haram in Islam without evidence from ALLAH. If you do so, you will go to bloody Hell burn the hell out of you.
Do not be a Jahil. Abu Jahil said the same, our forefathers did this, so we are doing it.
@@aussiemuslim
* It is not mandatory to follow those 4 imams. Even the veryfying scholars of Shafi'e and Maliki Madhabs said many things contrary to the opinion of Imam Shafi'e. For example, shaving beard is not considered Haram in Shafie and Maliki Madhab, thats the official fiqh of those 2 madhabs. But the imams said its Haram. Likewise many things, like the rulings of ablution.
And those 4 imams are not prophets of ALLAH.
Moreover 100 of imams had the opinion that music not Haram like Imam Gazzali, Imam Ibn Huzm, etc.
* Christians believe Jesus is God, bcoz their scholars said so. If they Go to hell then you'd also go to hell for following scholars blindly.
* Abu Jahal said the same to the Prophet SA, "our forefathers believed like this, so we're believing like that".
and ALLAH asked them in Quran, "Where's the evidence from ALLAH?"
* In Islam we need clear evidence to make anything Haram. No authentic evidence from Hadith exists and No Quran verse exists to make Music Haram.
* Bukhari hadith 5590 is not authentic, its a hanged hadis or un-numbered hadis in Bukhari bcoz the reporter got no connection to the Prophet SA. Also its not a direct statement.
* There are almost 50 sahih Bukhari ultra authentic hadis exists which say prophet SA allowed Music, even compared Quran recitation of Abu Musa to the rhythmic sound of Mizmar(flute).
Prophet SA even invited wedding singers to a wedding function.
So Stop Following Scholars. You did the same when you were a Christian, you are doing the same still. No change!
Be a Muslim who follow the truth, do not be an extreme Scholar Worshipper who haramise everything.
Salafism is clearly a deviation. Islam is not a Monastic mosque religion.
You dont have to have the beard of Abu Jahal or a Rabbi to be a Muslim. People should not fear you when they see you.
ALLAH made everything clear, nothing Missed . Alhamdulillah!
AussieMuslim, Hahahha..!
“All the 4 imams” , this is what all the Neo Salafies say!
And yet these Salafies do not follow these Madhabs or Imams. They deny all of them, and follow their sect leaders like Shaikh ibn Uthaymeen, Ibn Baz.
You were a Christian who followed the Scholars blindly, it’s a shame you are still doing the same even as a Muslim.
A Muslim is a truth seeker, a Muslim cannot follow any Scholars blindly bcoz there is a verse in Quran which says against Scholar-hood.
Muslims are those who rely mainly on the revelation from God.
It is clear that there is no restrictions against Music in Quran or in Hadis. And you know that, that’s why you are bringing Scholars into the discussion.
@@DonDiiiii of course we have to bring scholars in to the discussion, they are the successors of the Prophet ﷺ.
Abu Darda reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The scholars are the successors of the prophets. Verily, the prophets do not pass on gold and silver coins, but rather they only impart knowledge.”
Source: Musnad al-Bazzār 10/68
Grade: Salih (good) according to Al-Bazzār
عَنْ أَبِي الدَّرْدَاءِ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُ قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ الْعُلَمَاءُ خُلَفَاءُ الأَنْبِيَاءِ إِنَّ الأَنْبِيَاءَ لَمْ يُوَرِّثُوا دِينَارًا وَلا دِرْهَمًا إِنَّمَا وَرَّثُوا الْعِلْمَ
10/68 البحر الزخار بمسند البزار
10/68 المحدث البزار خلاصة حكم المحدث إسناده صالح في البحر الزخار
If we do not take knowledge from the scholars then we can only follow our own logic in interpreting the Qur'an and hadith, which would only leade us astray. Hence why there are misguided sects and those who claim to only follow the Qur'an and not the sunnah. May Allah protect us and guide us to the straight path.
Any music that encourages what is forbidden or the ones that control emotions are haram
Why are you having a background music while your singing
There’s levels to piety, and if you can give up all music for the sake of Allah guaranteed there is a reward waiting for you. If the music has haram subject matter it is clearly haram. I think if it doesn’t have idle or nonsensical speech, for example claiming your love can move mountains are something far fetched. I personally think the best position is to has the intention to move away from music and pray that Allah helps you to do it.
Is breathing haram??
😂😂😂
Salam Alikum my brother, Allah has united us as brothers in faith, alhamduliLah for it. My brother, There would always be a diffence of opinion if you consider an argument based on falsehood to be an honest opinion and a considerable one. What they are trying to do is to keep you away from the Quran, the companions explanation of its verses, and from the Hadiths of our beloved prophet peace and blessings be upon him. Then, replace this with their understanding based on their desires. This is a honest naseeha, we’re all in this together for now, in the hereafter, every soul, for what it has earned, will be retained. May Allah guide us to what He is pleased with.
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 Duff is allowed because the prophet peace and blessings be upon him said so. Other instruments are forbidden because he also said so. Simple as that.
@@adoenpaix show me one hadith where he says ONLY DUFF IS ALLOWED and REST ALL INSTRUMENTS ARE PROHIBITED
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 Relax brother.
It was narrated that Muhammad bin Hatib said: "The Messenger of Allah said: 'What differentiates between the lawful and the unlawful is the Duff, and the voice (singing) for the wedding.'"
Sunan an-Nasa'i 3369
Grade: Hasan (Darussalam)
The problem here is, just beacause you listen to some music, it doesn't mean you can't read Quran, if you addicted to music that's your own issue, literlly anything can took you away from Quran if you addicted with it, theres also Music which using word Quran, so how does that took you away from Quran?
This list is sourced from Al-Azhar fatawa, from Shawkani’s Nayl al-Awtar, from the article by Imam Yahya Ederer, and from fatwa by Sheikh Abdullah Bin Yusuf al-Judai (see section I):
· Abdullah bin Jafar bin Abi Talib (al-Aqd al-Fareed 6/12)
· Imam ibn Hazm (Al-Muhallah)
· Imam Abu Talib al-Makki (Qut al-Qulub)
· Imam Abu Hamed al-Ghazali (Ihya ulum ad-din)
· Imam al-Shawkani (Ibtal dawa al-Ijmaa ala mutlaq al-Sama)
· Imam Abdul-Ghani al-Nablusi (Idaahat al-Dalalaat fee sama al-alaat)
· Sultan al-Ulema al-Iz ibn Abdul-Salam (Rislat al-Sama)
· Al-Qadi Ibn Qutaiba al-Daynoor (al-Rukhsah fi al-Sama)
· Imam Ibn Tahir al-Qaisirani (al-Sama)
· Imam al-Thahabi (al-Rukhsah fil-Ghinaa wa al-Turb)
· Qadi Abu Bakr Ibn Al-Arabi al-Makki (Ahkam al-Quran)
· Sheikh Yusuf al-Majishun (#3399 ibn al-Khuthayma)
· Sheikh al-Islam Ibn Daqiq al-Id (Iqtinas al-Sawanih)
· Grand Imam of al-Azhar Jad Ali jad al-Haqq (fatwa #3280)
· Grand Sheikh of al-Azhar Mahmud Al-Shaltut (pg. 375 fatawa)
· Mufassir Abu al-Faraj al-Isfahani (Kitab al-Aghani)
· Qadi Al-Mawardi (Kitab Aadab al-Dunya w'al-Din)
· Ibn Khaldun, Chief Maliki Qadi of Cairo, and historian (Muqaddimah, chapter 5, section 31)
· Abu al-Mawahib al-Shadhli (Farh al-Asma bi Rakhs al-Sima)
· Taj al-Din al-Fakihani (quoted in Nayl al-Awtar)
· Al-Rawiani (cited in Dar al-Ifta Missriyya fatwa #7000)
· Abu Mansur al-Bughdadi (cited in Dar al-Ifta Missriyya fatwa #7000)
· Abd al-Ghani al-Rafii (cited in Dar al-Ifta Missriyya fatwa #7000)
· Imām 'Ezz al-Din ibn 'abd al-Salām (Al-Tag wa al-Ikli)
· Imam Abu Bakr Al Adfawi (quoted in Nayl al-Awtar)
· Abul Mahasin Al Ruyani (quoted in Nayl al-Awtar)
· Abu Mansur Al Fawrani (quoted in Nayl al-Awtar)
· Minhal ibn Amr al-Asadi al-Kufi (cited by Imam Ahmad in his son’s book Jarh wa Ta'adeel)
· Al-Sheikh ibn al-Qammah (quoted in Farh al-Asma bi Rokhs al-Sima)
· Imam al-Haramayn (al-Nihaya, also quoted in Nayl al-Awtar)
Have you ever went to a mausq and herd music..yes it's harom
There's no part 1 part 2, the short answer is it's haram and the long one is also it's haram
Stop covering your eyes and your ears, and be open minded.
Proof is being presented to you and you are turning away.
Do you think Allah would forget to mention that music is haram in the Qur'an? No, Allah does not forget.
People lie to make the lives of the Muslims harder, with the intention of diverting Muslims away from Islam.
If such a big thing would land you in Hell, it would certainly be written in the Qur'an.
So no, music is NOT haram.
@@SKA-76Bukari 5590
Do you have any idea how many poets did Muhammad neutralize on his lifetime ❓️😂
Assalamualaikum my dear brother.
Are you trying to say the music of today, mainstream pop is halal? I know where you're coming from and I do follow the opinion music is haram however I don't believe you can say mainstream pop music is halal at all when they indulge about details about such actions which are vulgar.
والله اعلم
Walaikum Salaam. I'm saying that music that enjoins good and forbids bad is halal.
A Muslim friend of mine once said that the Quran is very clear, but how come scholars disagree on many things?
no quran never says music is prohibited but instead "IDLE TALES" , IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 listen brother. Go search on Google difference between music and instrument and come back to me
@@adnaanmuhammed8784Only duff is halal
@@shwanmirza9306 show me one verse in quran or one hadith where prophet (pbuh) says "except duff all are prohibited"
Always best to play it safe nevertheless.
I think everyone should start From basic all over again to understand where music started from . Muslims should learn The origin of Adam and Hawas arrival and about their offsprings and how' lies, murder, burial , zina etc all started. Youe will find the answer there for music as well. There are prophets series you can watch one TH-cam and it will all make sense very easy . I still listen to beats ( just beats with no lyrics) 🫤 and i pray that' i can One Day give it up fully . Took me a while to give up music with lyrics. Now' Just stuck to beats and drums . Ill try to to give that up as well unless I am marchlng to filistin . I make sure I listen to Quran More then music and making suree my Quran time is much longer than any beats or music. Slowly all my favorite music starting to sound distorted and kinda hating them. Really hope im almost there to quit it for Good . Please keep me in your duahs that I can stop All the wrong doings 🤲. And ill keep you All in my Duahs for the same .
i think you did the opposite, musical instrument are all haram except maybe the daff but singing is debated between scholars so try something like nasheed which most of it has only mouth sounds. ur on the right track brother (as in trying to leave music) keep it up.
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED f=in 19th century
So stick to religious songs and drums and not listening to rapers and dancing with Belly dancers and Al other instruments. If he allowed that type singing and instrument than that' was the limit .
We have bigger fish to fry people.
Our brothers and sisters are being slaughtered right now in Gaza.
Come back to this point, once we deal with the more important matters at hand.
😂 Even poetries are also haram in Islam ☪️
Do you have any idea how many poets did Muhammad neutralize on his lifetime ❓️😂
Of course it's harom
i'm worried for you brother, if your source of money is music... even if lets say music isn't haram (though you do base your opinion on one person's word ) i've seen the hadiths about haram money.. it has MAJOR consequences unlike listening to music. please revise your opinions mate. save yourself
You can’t reject a Hadith because so called scholar of yours whose qualifications known said so
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
just because the daff is allowed doesn't mean all other instruments are halal. You have to understand that in none of the four schools of thought is there any permissibility for music. Moreover, Wahhabism did not even start until the end of the 17th century, and Imam Ghazali is not someone from whom everyone takes knowledge, aside from Ashari and Sufi followers.
@@maiwandnawabi3577 first of all i am a sufi follower . imam ghazali is one of the most recogonised and respected scholar and a philosopher of all times . Show me one hadith where prophet says "only daff is halal" , just because daff was allowed dosent mean duff is the only instruement allowed . if insruments are to be prohibited why in those hadith prophet didnt adviced to stop them but he instead listned which technicaly makes it even sunnah to listen !
@@maiwandnawabi3577 Abdullah bin al-Zubair used to keep women playing guitars (lutes) and singing in his presence. (Idahaat al-Dalalat al-Nablusi 96)There is no disagreement about the Ibrahim bin Sa’d bin Abdul Rahman bin Awf listening to songs with guitars (al-Sama’ Ibn Tahir 63)
@@maiwandnawabi3577 Those who say it is permissible include Zahiri, Maliki, Hanbali, and Shafi scholars and they criticize every single one of these Hadith as Daeef.
The Great Muhaddith Abul Fadl Ibn Tahir comments that not even a single LETTER from these Hadith are Sahih.
He also says in his book on the permissibility of music that there is no dispute between the people of Madinah that musical instruments were permissible and that the Zahiri Scholars unanimously held this view as well.
Ibn Arabi the Great Maliki Qadi and Scholar in his Kitab Al Ahkam says there is not even a single Sahih Hadith that prohibits music.
The Great Scholar Ibn Hazm says any Hadith prohibiting music cannot be traced back to the Prophet PBUH, they can only be traced back to other than the Prophet PBUH
The Great Maliki Scholar Al Fakihani says I do not know of any evidence from the Quran or Sahih Hadith that show that music is haram.
The Great Scholar Imam Al Haramayn reports that the Great Sahabi Abdullah Ibn Zubayr owned many singing and dancing girls who would sing and dance for him.
The Great Historian Abul Faraj Al Isfahani transmits from the Great Sahabi and Poet of the Prophet, Hasan Ibn Thabit that he would listen to music.
The Great Muhaddith Imam Abu Bakr Al Adfawi transmits from the legendary “Fifth Khalifa Rashidun” Umar Ibn Abdul Aziz that he would listen to music before he became a Khalifa.
He also said there is no dispute between the people of Madinah that the Qadi of Madinah Ibrahim Ibn Saad would listen to music and said it is permissible.
Ibn Samani says that Tawus Ibn Kaysan the Great Tabieen student of the Great Sahabi and legendary Mufassir Ibn Abbas said that music is permissible.
The Great Shafi Scholar Abul Mahasin Al Ruyani transmits from Qafaal that the Maliki Madhab ruled that music, instruments, and singing were permissible, Abu Mansur Al Fawrani transmits this from the legendary Founder of the Maliki Madhab Imam Malik as well.
The Great Shafi Scholar Abu Talib Al Makki in his book Qut Al Qulub says the Great Muhaddith Manhal Ibn Amr would listen to musical instruments in his palace.
All in all, at best Music is permissible and at worst it is a matter of a difference of opinion among scholars. But it cannot be deemed categorically Haram.
let sing like church, even I like music I know thats wrong. its sways your feeling.
better acknowledge wrong things rather burry them like it's not wrong
and thats just from one man statement
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 just sing bro even I like music... I recognize that as toxification of feeling. you can too.
I really wonder what these people who are infeding with this are inspired. Do they really doubt the ban on this? Or do they face a lack of faith and determination? If you are still in doubt about the ban on listening to music and musical instruments, let him absorb the following evidence. Allah says (interpretation of the meaning):
'And among the people there are those who sell vain talk to wander from the Way of Allah without knowledge.'( Soerat Loeqmaan: 6)
The majority of the Qur'anic exes agree that vain talk in this verse refers to singing. The companion Ibnoe Mascoed has said in response to this verse: 'By Allah, besides Whom is no other god, this is indeed singing.' After which he repeated this three times.
Also, the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: 'There will certainly be people among my community who will allow fornication, silk (for men), alcohol and musical instruments.'
(al-Boekhaari)
The Prophet (peace be upon him) abhorred these people because they would declare musical instruments that are forbidden allowed. He equated this with declaring alcohol and fornication allowed. There are also many other traditions in the Sunan- books and the Musnad of Imam Ahmad that indicate the prohibition of music and the provision of a terrible punishment to those who declare and are guilty of music allowed. A true believer needs no more than one correct proof to omit a forbidden case.
SO ALHAMDILILLAH ITS HARAAM!!!
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
As the great Imam Ibn Hazm al-Zahiri wrote:
“There is no indication in the wording of this hadith that this warning is tied to listening to musical instruments, nor that it is about singing girls. The apparent meaning of the hadith is that the warning is for their making khamr lawful by giving it a different name. We do not base our religion on conjecture (i.e. by claiming that the punishment is also because of the musical instruments or singing girls).” [12]
"The heart of man has been so constituted by the Almighty that, like a flint, it contains a hidden fire which is evoked by music and harmony, and renders man beside himself with ecstasy. These harmonies are echoes of that higher world of beauty which we call the world of spirits; they remind man of his relationship to that world, and produce in him an emotion so deep and strange that he himself is powerless to explain it. The effect of music and dancing is deeper in proportion as the natures on which they act are simple and prone to emotion; they fan into a flame whatever love is already dormant in the heart, whether it be earthly and sensual, or divine and spiritual." - Imam Ghazali , Alchemy of Happiness
@@adnaanmuhammed8784 who is this Imam??? Are you dump? The Quran and the sunnah clarify cristal clear that Music is haraam! Of you dont accept it then you Go! Alhamdulillah! Music is shaytaan and only the people that follow shaytaan are crying!! Follow the big scholars!! Shaykh al uthaymeen, shaykh bin baz, shaykh al bani and so on. All are big scholars!!
@@KoraanSoennahSalafiyyah show me the evidence akhi show me . IMAM GHAZALI is a greatest scholar and a philosopher of all time , imam ibn HAZM was one of the greatest scholar who has created the 4th madhab (called zahiri) and both of them allowed the use of music as there is no clear evidence to prohibit it
Just bogus. Musical instruments are haram. Full stop
Assalamualaikum
Shadi Akhi I do enjoy & appreciate your music, your music help me to stay humble and remember who I am . May Allah continue to bless you to keep making music. Shqran
Walaikum Salaam, Alhamdulillah
😂 Even poetries are also haram in Islam ☪️
Better than worshipping a man or cow 😂😂
According to whom? You can not just make such statements without providing reference.
@@SKA-76 Book 28, Number 5610:
Sa'd reported Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) as saying : It is better for the belly of any one of you to be stuffed with pus rather than to stuff (one's mind) with poetry.
@@SKA-76 Sahih al-Bukhari 6154
Narrated Ibn `Umar:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "It is better for a man to fill the inside of his body with pus than to fill it with poetry."
Sahih al-Bukhari 6154
Book 78, Hadith 180
Sahih al-Bukhari 6154
Narrated Ibn `Umar:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "It is better for a man to fill the inside of his body with pus than to fill it with poetry."
Sahih al-Bukhari 6154
Book 78, Hadith 180
Akhi who is this sh what's his aqeedah upon the salafus saalih?
IF MUSIC IS HARAM THEN WHY DID IMAM GHAZALI , IBN HAZM ALLOWED IT? why did PROPHET HIMSELF ALLOWED THE USE OF MUSIC IN 2 OTHER RECORDER HADITH WHERE HE ALLOWED THE PLAYIN OF DUFF instead he could stop and advice to not use music ever again ALL THE SCHOLARS DURING ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE ALLOWED ITS USAGE UNTILL WAHABISM RISED in 19th century
m.th-cam.com/video/bql-tCz-QWM/w-d-xo.html&pp=ygUjSXMgbXVzaWMgaGFyYW0gYWJkdXIgUmFobWFuIGhhc3NhbiA%3D
For those that are sincere and not just following their desires , we all listen to abit of drizzy here n there. But it's from our weakness. It's sad that brothers be picking and choosing anything.
Let everyone know that not every difference is a valid difference.
For example : a man comes to a women's and said let's get married and the women said I can't there's conditions.
He replies don't worry we don't need a mahram according to the hanafi school
And we don't need a mahr according to an opinion attributed to imam shafiee (not the relied upon one)
And imam Malik said in an opinion attributed to him it's okay without two witnesses. (Not the relied upon one)
Then they both go to hotel and do zina based off these opinions. Hence why I urge you brothers to be sincere and not just run with any opinion that comes your way
Barakallah hu feek