“If i lose it all” - I love the reference to "Rumbling". It's Art. Overall - the Rumbling is from Eren's point of view while the Under the Tree is from Mikasa's. Those songs are as important to the story as all the other things. 🔥 🔥 🔥
Oh, now that you mention it, it does sound similar to Call Your Name (which Mikasa's image song No Matter Where You Are is based on). Not sure if it's the exact same melody but certainly close.
@edgarsilva8030 not saying you're wrong but I've never heard anyone say that. Why would you associate that melody with Mikasa over anyone else. I feel like the melody is more significant to Eren or Ymir.
@@BobTheism "she lost her brother a month ago" "she said she gave all her love to me" "we dreamt a new house, some place to be at peace" "But things changed, suddenly. I lost my dream in this disaster" "I'm crying, missing my lover" Come on man, it does apply to several characters since it has a couple different pov's and it's ambiguous enough in some parts, but after the last episode you can't tell me that this doesn't sound an awful lot like Mikasa's pov. It's been considered her theme in the fandom for years and even more after the ending came out.
After the release of the first film, the song "Under the Tree" started playing at the end, my heart shrank and marinated in anticipation. You know everything. You've already read the manga in ongoing. Just waiting to relive it and singing "Under the Tree". This song has stuck in my head for these months. I'll even say this, at this moment "Under the tree" immediately comes to mind at the mention of AoT.
This entire track just brings me to tears. Im a massive AOT fan anyway but this song is just so beautiful. It brilliantly captures the feeling of the final chapters in my opinion. When that final episode comes out on the 4th of November I will be in tears for weeks man on god.
I mean, I understand that everyone loves attack on titan, but everyone talks and reacts to under the tree and the rumbling, however the whole album is a masterpiece, I hope people listen to the rest of the album, because for my is the album of the year, definitely not to be missed. SIM deserves more recognition for his work.
Great job. SiM has also written the opening for the latest season of Kengan Ashura. The song is called Red. The ending theme belongs to Band Maid, the song is Shambles. SiM and Band Maid share production label, Pony Canyon. I would be delighted to hear some collaboration or even a shared concert. Thanks for the analysis!
The only reactor I watch where I actually like the pausing, the way you explain stuff at a level understood by everyone (all the layers etc. the way the music actually moves and progresses) and explaining them in terms where people like me, would understand when you then replay and go through it again is quality as you begin to hear it, understand it and appreciate what's actually being played even more.
Oh, this song feels so good, I love how it shows feelings soo well, this song, as well as many others, enhance the story of my anime and that's the best sort of music there is 🥰❤️ P.D. I just noticed the "You're free!" scream here sounds JUST like on The Rumbling at the end of the TV Version where it says "I'm just here to... BREAK FREE!" (that "Break Free" being in a scream as well) so I like that bit of conection between the two songs ❤️
15:37 this is in rumbling too form my knowledge We could say rumbling is eren talking bat everything and under tree is mikasa replying to him saying he doesn’t need to hold this burden on this own and the lyric if I lose it all links the both songs
AOT Ops and eps are all classic!! The last pair: rumbling and under the tree just echoing each others. Can’t wait to see how well it adapted the manga this coming November!!
Love the juxtaposition between the sections where Mikasa is pleading with Eren to stop and let her help and Eren shutting her out ("YOURE FREE" "I'm telling you theres no need to talk".) About to make me cry all over again lol
I'm never this early to anything but I think it's kinda lucky I'm so early because I wanted to comment on a song I'd love to see Tony do! Which is Ruler of my heart by vivinos, there's so much going on in that song and I think it would be up his alley from some of the videos I've seen!
Ayyy, nice to hear that you're on Team Eren as well! I feel like most people don't understand just how nuanced of a character he is, but considering how you intricately break down music, it makes sense that you'd get it. Also loved your thoughts on this one! Your comments on the bridge being warm were really interesting, because it's something I feel like I was sorta picking up on while not fully grasping. To be honest, watching your videos has made me appreciate little details in music so much more, so thanks for that!
The band is so underrated, but they definitely cover good songs. If your time is free, I’d suggest to check out their song “RED”, another song made for an Anime and it goes HARD.
Love all your reactions and breakdowns, man, especially for this anime, my top all time. P.s. Im surprised you haven't gotten more requests for Vogel im Kafig, the full original version, after all this time.
Team Eren babyy. Great break down. I'm actually a sucker for violin notes in rock songs, really helps land the hard rock and growls softly back to underlying flow.
recently (earlier today as of writing) finished binging Ya Boy Kongming! season 1 and wanted to recommend some of the songs being- Im Still Alive Today by 96neko/kuroneko (an insert song) Chiki Chiki Ban Ban by Queendom (the OP) Feeling Good composed by Mitsuyuki Miyake and Genki Hibino
Love your breakdowns. Especially the AoT ones. Side note, I thought about your channel when I heard this random song the other day. Ever thought about listening to the Bad Apple cover by RichaadEB? It's originally from a bullet hell and the song seems up your alley.
I am absolutely not against you paying the bills, and if my comment is preventing that from happening i will gladly remove it, I was more making a point that most sponsored earbuds I have tried have been of very subpar quality such as raycon, with them being blown out with bass with no top end to speak of. I am absolutely biased in distrusting sponsorships since they have taken advantage of me many times in the past, I am just very skeptical. Again if you want me to remove this comment please ask and I will do so, I really do love your videos and when I have the money to spare, I will join your patreon.
@@DrumRollTonyReacts I’ll leave it up and do better in the future, apologies. It was a fucked up thing for me to say and an opinion you didn’t ask for, you didn’t deserve that, I’m sorry man.
Team Eren? Oh boy... Don't get me wrong, dude's one of my favorite characters of all time, but he's straight up mass murderer. Dude committed massacre. It's hard to be on his side. Especially when you see his friends trying so desparately to stop him!
team yeager? letsgo, everyone in my friend group is a yeagerist too, love these reactions/breakdowns that can take a 4.5 minute video and make it 16 minutes : D love this song, i get so focused on one or two layers that the rest are deaf to me unless i watch something like this or play it back a ton and try my darnedest
Pick up a pair of 3ANC wireless earbuds - Use my link for 10% off
status.co/DrumRollTony
“If i lose it all” - I love the reference to "Rumbling". It's Art. Overall - the Rumbling is from Eren's point of view while the Under the Tree is from Mikasa's. Those songs are as important to the story as all the other things. 🔥 🔥 🔥
@ieathumansoulsUnfortunately Armin doesn't have an opening for him
@@ZhynzillaHe did have his part in this song. He was asking Eren to stop. They'll figure out the rest and shoulder his sins together with him.
Na this not true cause it shows armin perspective in this song as well.
The show itself is from Armin's point
Hearing Mikasa basically beg Eren to stop, trying to tell him that she'll still love him and protect him no matter the cost, it's heartbreaking.
That's what happens when you are absolutely in love, but have no rizz
*Mikasa trying to explain that The Rumbling won’t end up happening again if Eren stops now*
@@mersadthehuman callate
@@mersadthehumanshe did in fact have rizz but she just failed to confess
@@Kemalist0008 you just explained not having rizz lmfaoo
“Let me shoulder your sins together.”
Hits so hard man… chills every time.
This is gonna be so much better once it’s finished
People may not call it love and we wont be blessed 😢😢😢😢
That's my fav line, it hits me everytime too.
dont tell me this is who i think it is
if i lose it all i'll be waiting under the tree.
@@ilsrzz135 It just may be😭😭
Just want to point out that the last bridge it's using Mikasa's theme. Sounds so good.
And what's that Mikasa theme???? From all I know of aot OST, there's no such thing as "Mikasa' theme" by Sawano Hiroyuki.
@@DanoCDA it's not official named liked that but it's associated by fans and here in this case as this song it's told in Mikasa's perspective
Oh, now that you mention it, it does sound similar to Call Your Name (which Mikasa's image song No Matter Where You Are is based on). Not sure if it's the exact same melody but certainly close.
@edgarsilva8030 not saying you're wrong but I've never heard anyone say that. Why would you associate that melody with Mikasa over anyone else. I feel like the melody is more significant to Eren or Ymir.
@@BobTheism "she lost her brother a month ago" "she said she gave all her love to me" "we dreamt a new house, some place to be at peace" "But things changed, suddenly. I lost my dream in this disaster" "I'm crying, missing my lover"
Come on man, it does apply to several characters since it has a couple different pov's and it's ambiguous enough in some parts, but after the last episode you can't tell me that this doesn't sound an awful lot like Mikasa's pov. It's been considered her theme in the fandom for years and even more after the ending came out.
This song hits different after watching the final episode
After the release of the first film, the song "Under the Tree" started playing at the end, my heart shrank and marinated in anticipation. You know everything. You've already read the manga in ongoing. Just waiting to relive it and singing "Under the Tree". This song has stuck in my head for these months. I'll even say this, at this moment "Under the tree" immediately comes to mind at the mention of AoT.
This entire track just brings me to tears. Im a massive AOT fan anyway but this song is just so beautiful. It brilliantly captures the feeling of the final chapters in my opinion. When that final episode comes out on the 4th of November I will be in tears for weeks man on god.
139 wont be adapted. Dont make me write a long comment again.
@@isacrifice0oh it will 100%, I’m hyped
@@gon3x904 Yeah same. The rumbling will be 100% 👍
@@isacrifice0 me when I cope:
@@gon3x904 me when I like the worst ending for aot:
I mean, I understand that everyone loves attack on titan, but everyone talks and reacts to under the tree and the rumbling, however the whole album is a masterpiece, I hope people listen to the rest of the album, because for my is the album of the year, definitely not to be missed. SIM deserves more recognition for his work.
*their work
@@peanutbutterdox5456 You understood right? Well that's it. Enough to communicate without it being my main language. Thank you for the correction.
@@angelwynss5309 your welcome?
The little nod back to The Rumbling at the end of the bridge with the “if I lose it all” line is the icing on top of this absolutely delicious cake
13:12 nice reference to the rumbling song in that part. "if i lose it all"
fun fact where it says " if i lose it all" is from rumbling song
Great job. SiM has also written the opening for the latest season of Kengan Ashura. The song is called Red. The ending theme belongs to Band Maid, the song is Shambles. SiM and Band Maid share production label, Pony Canyon. I would be delighted to hear some collaboration or even a shared concert. Thanks for the analysis!
As someone who is obsessed with AoT, the lyrics are my main focus. I loved this ED so much that I learned it before the episode even aired 😅
The only reactor I watch where I actually like the pausing, the way you explain stuff at a level understood by everyone (all the layers etc. the way the music actually moves and progresses) and explaining them in terms where people like me, would understand when you then replay and go through it again is quality as you begin to hear it, understand it and appreciate what's actually being played even more.
I love the contrast of you being all happy and enjoying the song with all the people dying in the video.
Oh, this song feels so good, I love how it shows feelings soo well, this song, as well as many others, enhance the story of my anime and that's the best sort of music there is 🥰❤️
P.D. I just noticed the "You're free!" scream here sounds JUST like on The Rumbling at the end of the TV Version where it says "I'm just here to... BREAK FREE!" (that "Break Free" being in a scream as well) so I like that bit of conection between the two songs ❤️
It’s “Beware” lol
@@zombiejager9735 Technically yes, but honestly i see no problem with either interpretation, they both fit very well.
6:00 Bro whyyy😭😂 I was vibing so hard there xD
The OVA Lost Girls 3 is quite a big one to watch before the final episode comes out, I think it would increase your enjoyment of that.
I'm just picturing Tony running "in the neighborhood" and wanting to hear the cars to stay safe. But he's running like Scott from Austin Powers.
Bwawawa
15:37 this is in rumbling too form my knowledge
We could say rumbling is eren talking bat everything and under tree is mikasa replying to him saying he doesn’t need to hold this burden on this own and the lyric if I lose it all links the both songs
AOT Ops and eps are all classic!! The last pair: rumbling and under the tree just echoing each others. Can’t wait to see how well it adapted the manga this coming November!!
Love the juxtaposition between the sections where Mikasa is pleading with Eren to stop and let her help and Eren shutting her out ("YOURE FREE" "I'm telling you theres no need to talk".) About to make me cry all over again lol
The clean vocal section of "Why of why" on top of the guitars sounds SO MUCH like one of the vocalists from SikTh
10:03 in my understanding this part is eren replying to mikasa and the other scouts
Glad you enjoyed the full version. I'll be sad when AOT is over. It's wild to remember the anime has been around since 2013. 10 years! Holy cow.
Honestly, I was taken by the lyrics the whole time so I missed a lot of the layers haha
came back to this on a whim and had missed when you called out the bass part during the bridge and jeez thats an awesome part
16:43 my dude giving Eldians PTSD again 😂
im not a huge fan of reaction content but your content just hits different to me. thanks man
The bridge referencing The Rumbling OP was the icing on the cake!
full version gives me goosebumps
11:11 its like a musical earthquake, almost like a rumbling
I have no words to describe how much I'll miss this anime, and how amazing it is. What a masterpiece
I'm never this early to anything but I think it's kinda lucky I'm so early because I wanted to comment on a song I'd love to see Tony do!
Which is Ruler of my heart by vivinos, there's so much going on in that song and I think it would be up his alley from some of the videos I've seen!
This song is beautiful especially the lyrics, when eren and mikasa are talking this song is amazing
"It's like musical earthquake"
I love how Tony loves the series so much he's like "f waiting to do a reaction. I need it NOW". And didn't do a reaction on the patron either
Ay nice, i was hoping youre gonna do a re-react to this one!
Ayyy, nice to hear that you're on Team Eren as well! I feel like most people don't understand just how nuanced of a character he is, but considering how you intricately break down music, it makes sense that you'd get it. Also loved your thoughts on this one! Your comments on the bridge being warm were really interesting, because it's something I feel like I was sorta picking up on while not fully grasping. To be honest, watching your videos has made me appreciate little details in music so much more, so thanks for that!
Thank you for your thoughts! I love this song so much, it makes me tear up. ✨🤍✨
The band is so underrated, but they definitely cover good songs. If your time is free, I’d suggest to check out their song “RED”, another song made for an Anime and it goes HARD.
They just released a whole new album, would be a good time to get to know the band too
@@lucasliu4010 I’ve known the band since the rumbling and I stick with them and they became my top 3 artist I listen to repeatedly
i love how you have to turn up the reverb just to say his name
Emotional song!
Am I the only one who feels like it turns into the ninjago opening at 12:46
Tony, are you ready to witness this once in a lifetime masterpiece series finale coming Nov. 4th?
✅️
A perfect song for AOT
ovas are must watch
You should consider checking out The Rumbling Orchestra version by Sim. Would love to see your reaction to it.
omg that version was so good
Hey man, love the vid, when's the full op reactions coming back? Stopped right before the best one!!
What do you mean
Oooooo you mean AoT op full. Got ya, sorry. My brain went fuzzy for a second
hopefully we will get shi-ki ost reaction someday. its really good ost from vampire focused series. an absolute banger
Love you review
Love all your reactions and breakdowns, man, especially for this anime, my top all time.
P.s. Im surprised you haven't gotten more requests for Vogel im Kafig, the full original version, after all this time.
Banger, hoping they play that for a specific scene in the last ep, idk if you’ve read the manga so im not sayin anythin
LOVE THIS SONG 🎉
I'm so happy that you are also Team Yeager and is not afraid to say it. The best music reactor!
love seeing a more technical musician geek out and spell out parts of the song for us normies
Right on time
Team Eren babyy. Great break down. I'm actually a sucker for violin notes in rock songs, really helps land the hard rock and growls softly back to underlying flow.
Red def might fav song from this album by Sim
recently (earlier today as of writing) finished binging Ya Boy Kongming! season 1 and wanted to recommend some of the songs
being-
Im Still Alive Today by 96neko/kuroneko (an insert song)
Chiki Chiki Ban Ban by Queendom (the OP)
Feeling Good composed by Mitsuyuki Miyake and Genki Hibino
11:54 bro I ain't even hear the piano in the background it took me like 3 times to actually hear it 😭
Subbed watching the upper video next
On one hand, Tony being team jaegar isn't surprising. on the other hand, how could you...
6:00 😂
😅😅😅😅
Love your breakdowns. Especially the AoT ones.
Side note, I thought about your channel when I heard this random song the other day. Ever thought about listening to the Bad Apple cover by RichaadEB? It's originally from a bullet hell and the song seems up your alley.
Wouldn't it make sense to do the original Bad Apple first?
Easily the best reactor, love the indepth review.
Just saw them live in boston it was great! you should also react to their song Red made for the kengan ashura season 2 op
16:40 YESSS1 The only right answer >:D
ado droped new song!
Fellow yeagerist LETS GOOOO
Please react to The Rumbling Orchestra Version from SiM as well! It‘s so good 🥹🙈👌🏼
Should also listen to SIM -RED from Kengan Ashura
You should watch OVA "No regrets" about Levi
Are you all caught up on the show itself?
I am
He said it at the end of the video
But why u dont have aot on ur patreon :(? I wanna become a member
TATAKAE!
Can anyone tell me how to find his aot episode reactions, I cant find them on TH-cam?
Hey tony can we see ur reaction for final episode?
I beg you: Do a song by The Aristocrats
I'm team armin even if it's ideelistic
Aot music is 🔥 and so I sim
I wasn't able to sit still the entire song the first time I watched the 2 min version, and now it's gotten worse because of the full one.
yo do friday night funkin! specifically ectospasm on apocalypse mode from the retrospecter mod?
how come you didnt react to AOT on your patreon but all these other animes?
Because I watched it before I created the patreon
You know hes in the sponsorship just for the money cuz he goes back to his studio cans
Do you think I take my studio headphones, ... that plug in... to the gym?😅😅😅😅😅 Also, are you against creators being able to pay their bills??
@@DrumRollTonyReacts fair
I am absolutely not against you paying the bills, and if my comment is preventing that from happening i will gladly remove it, I was more making a point that most sponsored earbuds I have tried have been of very subpar quality such as raycon, with them being blown out with bass with no top end to speak of.
I am absolutely biased in distrusting sponsorships since they have taken advantage of me many times in the past, I am just very skeptical. Again if you want me to remove this comment please ask and I will do so, I really do love your videos and when I have the money to spare, I will join your patreon.
@JoeMama-sl8ux Your original comment was just massively rude and pointless. Leave it up for all to see
@@DrumRollTonyReacts I’ll leave it up and do better in the future, apologies. It was a fucked up thing for me to say and an opinion you didn’t ask for, you didn’t deserve that, I’m sorry man.
This vid in my opinion would have been better how you did the beatbo one. With a whole reaction to the song. Dunno what your overall feedback was.
GL.
This material is actual song content tho. I have to navigate copyright and fair use. You can't just play a song front to back on TH-cam and think that's somehow ok. You are asking for a copyright ©️ strike
Team Eren? Oh boy... Don't get me wrong, dude's one of my favorite characters of all time, but he's straight up mass murderer. Dude committed massacre. It's hard to be on his side. Especially when you see his friends trying so desparately to stop him!
And he's Eren's boi?! Instant like lol
team yeager? letsgo, everyone in my friend group is a yeagerist too, love these reactions/breakdowns that can take a 4.5 minute video and make it 16 minutes : D love this song, i get so focused on one or two layers that the rest are deaf to me unless i watch something like this or play it back a ton and try my darnedest
#TeamErenYeager
Had to leave a like after he said hes team eren
TEAM EREN LOL THE WAY YOU SAID IT HAHAHA BUT I AGREE!!
FR!!
Happy to call myself a Yeagerist 🫡
Team Eren! 👏🏼👏🏼
Team eren got you a like
Team Eren! 🔥