Ya but it's not equivalent. Brock lost some weapons, Stafford lost all weapons, there's a difference. Rams had 4 starting O-line out along with Puka, Kupp, Higbee. Brock still had Kittle and Deebo.
And who outplayed who in the 49ers camp? Sam was there and they let him go, if he is this great mvp qb why did he get outplayed by Brock?!? And injuries are big deal, a second year qb won’t over come that much. Caleb had all the talent in the world and couldn’t find a way to win a game……
In another video, Colin claimed the Viking’s roster is worse than the Bills and Ravens and I’m sitting there asking so JJ, Addison, Aaron Jones, and Hockenson are a bunch of randos?!
Darnold is missing guys and lost two games. Purdy is missing guys and lost 8 😂. But that's the same? When see the worst you'll ever see of Darnold who was in 2 horrible situations. Don't believe me? How are those teams doing now? One had the number 1 pick get benched. The other drafted 3 first rnders a second rounder and has Aaron Rodgers. Now are all those qbs bad; or is it those organizations??Those teams are still bad. Same with everyone who goes to Cleveland. Now ask yourself; Could Purdy survive that?? Honestly? Imagine him with Cleveland,Jets or Panthers? Would he be good there? We seen him this season with 2 players out and he looked just like where he was drafted. In his defense; he's better then Tua who was the 5th overall pick. Yet and still; you, the niners and Purdy has to be honest with himself. Yes I deserve to get paid but what am I without everyone? Because the min you have to let someone else go to pay him; he's gonna get exposed and relegated to backup. Virtually stealing money.
Brock, at one point, was throwing to Chris Conley, Jacob Cowing, Ricky Pearsall, and Eric Saubert, with Isaac Guerendo in the backfield. He still finished ahead of Stafford in yards, ypa, TDs, and passer rating. Colin doesnt watch film AT ALL.
Bringing up Stafford is pointless because no matter the stats. Nobody would take purdy over Stafford. And if you say you would then you need a new sport to comprehend because football is too advanced
Colin can’t let this bad Purdy take go for some reason. Purdy played fine this year. Deebo, Aiyuk, CMC, and a banged up OL are the pieces that didn’t come through this year for the 49ers.
Every result has more than one cause. What are the multiple causes of the Niners season: Special teams Execution Late contract signings O line Play calling Adjustments …. Pay him now bc it will be less than you pay him next year. We saw this w Dak. There is no other available qb that will help them win in the next three years.
@@tonygabagoolpay him now and you'll get what you deserve...a team that can't carry him... because he has all the money but lacks the talent to carry the team
I dont even like Matt Stafford, and he's objectively better than Purdy. Purdy has barely played in comparison as well. He hasnt won a superbowl, so I guess we won't really know, huh?
@@sawxpatsceltshe easily played well enough in last year's super bowl to win. The previous year he was on fire until he was injured. Who knows what would have happened if he had not been knocked out from injury, but they had a very good chance of going all the way. This year McCaffrey was basically non-existent because of injury and their top two receivers from last year were no shows.
I can't understand why so many media guys are actively trying to keep Brock Purdy from signing a contract with the 49ers. In Colin's case, it's particularly stupid: he took the 49ers to a conference championship game (got hurt during the game), to a Superbowl (in overtime against the Chiefs) and because of a great number of injuries, the 49ers don't make the playoffs the next year... and Colin pretends it's all Purdy's fault. This is pure dishonesty.
Stafford was awful without his weapons, once they got healthy he played better, you and Nick just can’t get over your rams love affair. One week they barely get 12 points against the niners and you guys say they can’t win a game in the playoffs, now you guys think they are gonna beat the Vikings. And one last thing about Stafford, how many times did he make the playoffs with the lions? It took him getting a great coach and weapons to get anywhere
Because he uses his eyes when evaluating talent. Yeah Stafford is old so he needs some OLine and a receiver but nobody on the planet is taking purdy over Stafford for a reason. And if you were it better be for the next 10 years but right now it's not close
@@thenorthernlowlight Dude stafford has not been that good this year. He is also a major gun slinger on the down side of his career. You really do not watch him play do you?
@ I do watch him play every game. I understand he's older so he's less mobile but his arm talent hasn't taken a dip at all yet plus he's arguably the last clutch qb in the league other than Mahomes. So are you sure you really watch the games or do you just look at box scores
@@thenorthernlowlight His arm talent is undeniable but his decision making is not as good. He has a ton of dropped int's as well this year. They guy has not looked good at all. Yes he is clutch but he also creates his own issues with the picks.
Purdy should be a feel good story about the last pick becoming a solid starting quarterback, but instead it’s like “he’s not THE best” and therefore doesn’t deserve to get paid and should be cut
So when Colin negotiates a new contract with Fox, he never brings up any of his past accomplishments, right? What does that have to do with the future, especially when there are hosts in his time slot - like Pat McAfee - that have better numbers? I’ll bet McAfee would love to see Colin get a contract extension. See how that works?
Let’s compare Purdy’s stats to Stafford’s this year. Purdy: 3,864 yards, 20 TD’s, 12 Ints, 96.1 passer rating, 68.0 QBR, 15 games played. Stafford: 3,762 yards, 20 TDs, 8 Ints, 93.6 passer rating, 64.9 QBR, 16 games played. You wanna talk about who the better QB is in the division? Purdy played with third stringers and a receiving core with the worst YAC and separation rate in the whole league. Stafford was undermanned at the beginning of the year but that ended week 8. Please Colin, watch the games and bring receipts when you want to talk ball.
@@JeffBird86injuries are a real thing. Brock didn’t get any of his stars this season, Rams had them for a late season run. Makes a big difference playing with stars/starters vs backups in one the most talents and hardest sports in the world. No shame in a down year……but to be dogged this hard is unfair. Especially when he walked off the field with the lead against the legendary Chiefs…
@@briandittrich5640don't try to explain that to this people, they are the type of people who thinks that the QB does everything and win every game alone, the same type of people who think Brady won his 7 rings by himself
Lamar with all that talent, talented team previous to this year, this year another talented team, mvp, and chokes. Justin herbert, trevor lawrence, not done anything. And u dont talk bad bout them. But u talk down on Brock who actually did something, go to super bowl, but he doesnt deserve to be paid? Colins u said trevor is generational talent, ur wrong bout a lot of these top paid qbs. Even trash like tua got paid
2 conference championship games and multiple players in that team have had career years receiving passes from purdy. Aiyuk, Jennings, CMC, kittle all have had great seasons with purdy at QB
@@TheUndefeatedOfTheEast this was a prove it year for purdy and he failed miserably and I wouldn’t rush to pay him 🤷🏾♂️. Have you not seen how bad he was in the dolphins game the bills game the rams game. It was pretty bad
@@NicoleKendrick-mp5dq bro said deebo 😂 you mean the guy who was crying about not getting enough targets and when he got them he started dropped the ball in the endzone? And Jennings who's a WR3?
I can't believe these comments about Purdy. After one bad season, you guys are telling me he sucks. I've seen John Lynch do magic with the salary cap if you guys are worried about it.
QB Brock Purdy had EVERYBODY HURT this year...STOP IT...49ers DEFENSE GAVE UP 4 GAMES in the last 5 minutes. Take people way from anybody they will lose more...#1 Aiyuk, #1 CMC, & #1 Trent.
Its a team sport, if your best receiver and best running back are both unavailable, one man cannot "will" the team to victory, to a man, every good coach preaches team, yet Colin thinks one man can win in the NFL
Brock is a great QB - make no mistake. HOW was that guy in LA after his recweivers went down? LOSE your RB, REceivers - how do you not see this? HOW great was mahomes after injureis there?! mahomes was maCrying when he lost his tackle. 49ers were obliterated with injuries. you do NOT look at the entire pictures. NO QB in the NFL is going to win when ALL their weapons disappear.
Is everyone ignoring the fact that some of the biggest earners for the niners were the ones that contributed the least this season (deebo, aiyuk, cmc)? Purdy may not be top 5. But any smart gm would pay him over aiyuk, deebo, and cmc
I mean Joe Burrow was arguably the best QB this season and also didnt make the playoffs. Jordan Love still puzzles me why he is hyped so much and is in the playoffs🤷♂️
if the 49ers pay Brock Purdy what he's "earned", they immediately become non-contenders for a decade. the reason they were so good the past few years is B+ production from the QB position on a rookie contract and could pay big money to stars and roster fillers.
Colin loves to pick on certain QBs by pointing out how they aren't as effective without their LT and weapons. What kind of nonsense is that? What QB carries an offense without protection and weapons? For other QBs Colin uses the injuries as an excuse.
Purdy can win the nfc west that’s all that matters. He may not be the best or most talented but he can win it. If he gives the niners that chance then it’s a no brainer niners are gonna go with him.
Ummm...Wasn't SF in LAST YEAR'S Superbowl???? The NFC Conference Final the year before that??? Ever heard of the "Superbowl Hangover"??? It's a thing. Major injuries can(and usually will) derail Any quarterbacks' season. Gimme a break with this, please.
Stafford was sub par most the year. Purdy was best QB in the division literally last year. He will be the best in the division again next year… no point made by Colin there.
Stafford didn't "win" against Purdy because he was better at any point in that game. I counted at least two dropped interceptions in that game. Yet you are stumping for him. You are silly, guy.
Learn how nfl contracts work Colin. Brock won't have a big cap hit until 2028. Like Jordan Love. It's not like he is just getting a 60M cap hit next year.
I can't strand how these "analysts" have to pick a team or player they love or hate and never change their mind. Purdy can win five super bowls and coming and little Nicky will say he's below average and overpaid.
Stafford the "best QB" in that division won 3 games the year after they won the Superbowl when his team was injured and they had a harder schedule. He gets zero blame for that and Purdy is the only reason the 49ers are struggling. 😂righto champ we see right through your click bait BS.
LMAO. If Brock dont have the 3 highest paid guys injured, they could afford a O line that actually protects and 2 decent wrs (besides JJ) that can get open vs man. Get this guy a defense that can stop somebody and an O line and he doesnt need cmac, aiyuk, trent williams and 100s of millions of salary tied up in injured players
Thank Brock for a future hit in your viewership. I can barely watch Colin and Nick Wright anymore. They cannot process new information and admit they were incorrect. Afraid to realize that they are wrong, maybe it is on purpose and it is for clicks. Also if I have to hear Colin list his favorite 5 quarterbacks or talk about offensive minded coaches, I am going to puke in my mouth.
I've never seen a guy talk so much about football who knows less about football than Colin does. It's astounding how he keeps getting views for this tripe.
lol the Eagles are not hiring Belichick. Even if they fire Sirianni Howie Roseman has control of the entire roster and won’t cede power again like he did with Chip Kelly.
Actually he could tho, Stafford aging, Geno has a ceiling, Kyler is a tease. Purdy definitely can be so he should also play it out as he could have a huge bounceback year.
Colin and the rest of the hacks used to hate on baker mayfield…all day baker is overrated now Colin hates on Brock Purdy. And did Sean Mcvay pay Colin, this guy loves him,like he was kinfolk
The Niners will be back within the next two years. Some of the old guys need to go and replaced. Purdy will be winning the division again and we know he is better in the playoffs than anyone but Mahomes. He's only missed two games in two years. You're a liar and have always been wrong about Purdy. Kyle knows more about quarterbacks than you do.
If I'm GM Lynch I'm definitely signing Purdy to a 5 year deal. No question about it. Teams and fans give up on their franchise QBs waaaaay too soon. Purdy has had one of the best first 3 years from a QB I've seen. Not just team winning but statistically. This season is his worst. He'll get better. Look at Mayfield and Darnold. If the Jets and the Browns just would have got really good HC's they'd be in the playoffs!: Another thing, Shanahan has made some poor firings and he's not making himself accountable to the Niners situation. He's lost the locker room they're not playing for him....for now.
Yeah after the first Rams game Colin says “I’d sign him” “oh yeah I’d sign him” lol he has zero credibility. Brock Purdy is Colin’s cash cow. Every one of his vids have Brock in them they have 5x as many views.
Brock is an outstanding quarterback, top 10-15 when he is at his best, you can win with that. But the price has to be fair. It’s pretty much been proven at this point that he is a second-half turnover machine who isn’t able to elevate the team when circumstances aren’t ideal. I wouldn’t pay $40 million or more for that. I would pay him, but that number would start with a 3, otherwise you just get into the cousins debacle all over again. They were able to support the Brock early because they weren’t paying him, but if they can’t support him, he’s not going to bring them wins. It’s pretty much proven at this point. Pay him, but don’t pay him more than $35 million annually. he’s not in that range of “special” that deserves $50 million. Otherwise, you’re crippling your team. Just a thought, obviously I don’t make the decisions in San Fran, but there’s history to look at.
He's top 10 easily with healthy skill players. You cant pay top salaries to every position and have them injured and then expect your qb to not be paid. This guy has been eating ramen noodles for 3 years. He'll be 52-55 million and they'll redo Trents, CMACs and Deebo's contract to get ready to trade release deebo and aiyuk by end of next yr.
If you can only support a quarterback if you're paying him less than a million, then you can't afford to pay him anything. Bottom line is this, of the top 10 paid qbs, 9 make over $50 million a year. In two years, Brock has more playoff wins than 8 of those 10. And I reject the idea that this year is a good measure of the 49ers going forward. People try to say "Brock isn't the same without his weapons." But people didn't acknowledge that the 49ers didn't go from excellent starters to good starters. They want from excellent starters to backups at running back, receiver, and offensive line. Then add the injuries and life events on defense There are only so many starters you can lose, while also hiring a bad defensive coordinator before you have no chance.
@ that’s the problem, I can’t have a quarterback back be top 10 “if he has great skill positions”, then pay him $50mil, if he can’t string together wins despite not having those players. You’re right, he was throwing to backups, but my point is if he can’t elevate the team when he’s got next to nothing, I can’t justify paying him $50m, because then he’ll never have those great players around him, although based on how SF operates, they’ll most certainly give him a big deal.
Can we please have about twenty more videos of Colin telling us how 49ers shouldn't pay Purdy? I mean, maybe 20 isn't enough. Maybe a hundred more. It almost feels like he lost a bet and is now trying to convince everyone he won. He sounds like a QB elitist. "Oh now. Purdy can't be good because he's a seventh rounder." How many Super Bowls will he have to win to have you finally lay off the dude. How about this stat: QB's who got paid recently: Dak, Jones, Lawrence, Tua, Kyler....Purdy has more playoff wins than all of these highly paid QB's COMBINED! But, sure, let's throw Purdy to the curb.......
Man Bill doing what he wants. Thats what 70 plus people do. Bill please contact me to work for you. Listen he coach one year with his staff at UNC. Get close to all of the college talent. Know who they are and their stories. Go back to the league with his staff working together for a year. When you in college coaching you know about Freshmen in HS that are phenoms and you get paid to watch them play. So thats 7 years of watching athletes play in one season coaching college. Cause you got to factor in the transfer portal and the amount of years guys play in college now. Bill takes all that knowledge with him in the draft room with his GM and they run amuck. Meanwhile he starts giving Brady intel for the Raiders organization in the draft room. To get prepared for his arrival. Owe and his job is to watch his opponents game film during the season correct? Well thats knowledge in the NFL draft room next year. He playing chess. These suckas playin checkas.
i've never hated Purdy, no dog in the fight... I've been an underdog fan and the Mr. Irrelevant thing is awesome to me, but people gotta square this circle when defending Purdy's worth as a top paid QB: we all acknowledge his drop in play is because of injuries around him AKA missing elite players that he had been surrounded by in years past... well what do you think the team will look like for years moving forward after raising Brock's cap hit over $50M? that means less elite talent around him, just like this year... _then_ what happens when _that_ less talented cast they can afford starts getting injured lol Brock will be the most irrelevant $50-60M QB in the league
@@joekaiser3311 it's really not that simple at all, and that still doesn't address the obvious inconsistencies in his personal play on his own side of the ball and again, you think they're gonna afford all this elite defensive talent if they have to pay Brock like a top QB, and pay to try and surround him with as much talent and protection as possible to mask his averageness as a QB? like yeah, he's either not gonna have good weapons and protection, or he's not gonna have a good defense to bail them out... that's the point, you can't have it all like they have when you pay a QB that much, and with an elite roster suffering some injuries he struggled so what's he gonna look like in coming years when a more mediocre roster starts getting injured over the course of a season? and their defense was actually almost Top 5 in total yards and yards per play against, but were near the bottom in scoring defense while Purdy's turnover rate increased and he was sacked at a higher rate despite being pressured at a lower rate than last season.... so maybe you're actually arguing against your own point here🤔🤔
@@mattcarberry368so you're just reading back stats that you looked up. I'm positive you didn't watch many niner games this past year. The o-line is awful for pass pro and the defense is terrible. They cant stop anything or put any pressure on opposing QB. They double bosa and just pick the defense apart week after week. The shananhan offense needs a competent runner but when that runner can catch passes it takes them to another level. They had injuries to all 3 of their RB this year so they became 1 dimensional and easy to prepare for, despite that, purdy still put up very good numbers. Letting purdy go is stupid. His contract is a product of what the market has paid the position. He shouldn't be a top paid guy but he deserves a new contract based off the resume he accumulated in the league this far.
The narrative about Belichick bailing on UNC and going right back to the NFL is a complete and absolute non-story and I'm tired of analysts and commentators even mentioning it. It's complete nonsense, just admit it already!
"No ome will take you serious.." Colin you earn your living by speaking. That being so , please learn how to speak the Rnglish language correctl;y. - No one will take you seriously.
Colin This is what I’ve been trying to tell my 49er friends for months and they just don’t get it. We’ve seen Purdy’s ceiling , It’s very finite. He’s not a guy that can do more with less.
I’m not a Niners fan by any means I think Purdy is a solid QB but he is injury prone if they are going to sign him they absolutely need to sign another decent back up they can possibly be a starter and them compete for the number 1 spot. Niners should not pay a ridiculous amount for Purdy if so then simply let him go
Everybody talking about Brock… Shanahan couldn’t get it done with Matt Ryan, Jimmy G, Sam Darnold, and now, Brock Purdy. Dig a little deeper past the shiny early stuff. What’s the bigger, real issue?
Best part of the Tua signing as a Bills fan was all the stuff Fins fans talked about how Bills fans are actually scared of Tua if we said Miami shouldn’t pay him. Because of injuries, size, weak arm, lack of mobility, lack of off script play making ability and his record in big games. And literally everyone of those things impacted how Miamis season went.
He loves not thinking about how they had leads but the defense gave up those leads and also the Oline ranked middle of pack. Brock needs like 3 rings to ever get over these remarks.
Check out and subscribe to The Herd on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@theherd
Colin is turing me into a Brock Purdy fan.
Wasn’t Stafford struggling without puka and coop? 🤔
That's when they were losing all there games and then they come back and the rams go on a winning streak to close the season.
yes he was trash the last few weeks. The defense bailed him out though.
Last time I checked stafford had a ring
Shhh Colin doesn't like valid points.
Ya but it's not equivalent. Brock lost some weapons, Stafford lost all weapons, there's a difference. Rams had 4 starting O-line out along with Puka, Kupp, Higbee. Brock still had Kittle and Deebo.
The way Colin talks about Brock Purdy I assume Purdy showed up to pick up Colin’s daughter with his hat on backwards
And dumped her like Lance.
Hat on backwards, shirtless, tattoos on 100%of his body,
Funny how Colin says you can't pay Purdy based on what you've done, but you couldn't shovel enough money at Russel Wilson.
I mean Russ was inarguably much more talented than purdy 😂
The steelers need to move on from Russell i agree
Ion know why these fools just don't want purdy getting paid. A healthy SF will always be a SB contender with brock
@@nassiglutt6587 the 49ers made it to the Super Bowl and multiple NFC championships with Jimmy Garoppolo and less talent on their team
Because Russell Wilson was a great quarterback at some point Brock Purdy has always been average
This argument can be made against Sam Arnold with that offense but Colin would never…. Hypocritical
And who outplayed who in the 49ers camp? Sam was there and they let him go, if he is this great mvp qb why did he get outplayed by Brock?!? And injuries are big deal, a second year qb won’t over come that much. Caleb had all the talent in the world and couldn’t find a way to win a game……
Exactly. Cowherd praises Darnold’s talent disregarding everything he has around him but criticizes Purdy’s talent because of the talent around him.
Sam Darnold turned in a PUMKIN vs DETRIOT...with Probowl players
In another video, Colin claimed the Viking’s roster is worse than the Bills and Ravens and I’m sitting there asking so JJ, Addison, Aaron Jones, and Hockenson are a bunch of randos?!
Darnold is missing guys and lost two games.
Purdy is missing guys and lost 8 😂. But that's the same?
When see the worst you'll ever see of Darnold who was in 2 horrible situations.
Don't believe me? How are those teams doing now? One had the number 1 pick get benched. The other drafted 3 first rnders a second rounder and has Aaron Rodgers. Now are all those qbs bad; or is it those organizations??Those teams are still bad. Same with everyone who goes to Cleveland.
Now ask yourself; Could Purdy survive that?? Honestly? Imagine him with Cleveland,Jets or Panthers? Would he be good there? We seen him this season with 2 players out and he looked just like where he was drafted. In his defense; he's better then Tua who was the 5th overall pick. Yet and still; you, the niners and Purdy has to be honest with himself. Yes I deserve to get paid but what am I without everyone? Because the min you have to let someone else go to pay him; he's gonna get exposed and relegated to backup. Virtually stealing money.
Brock, at one point, was throwing to Chris Conley, Jacob Cowing, Ricky Pearsall, and Eric Saubert, with Isaac Guerendo in the backfield. He still finished ahead of Stafford in yards, ypa, TDs, and passer rating. Colin doesnt watch film AT ALL.
BINGO. The best WR this year was Jennings and he is a #3 wr, lol.
Colin still remembers 3-4 years ago when Stafford won a Super B. & still holds him as the best.
Stafford is washed
@@Honestly__now Have you watched football this season?
Bringing up Stafford is pointless because no matter the stats. Nobody would take purdy over Stafford. And if you say you would then you need a new sport to comprehend because football is too advanced
Oh, stop, Cowherd. You were riding Trey Lance for so long you forgot that Brock is an actual good QB.
Colin can’t let this bad Purdy take go for some reason. Purdy played fine this year. Deebo, Aiyuk, CMC, and a banged up OL are the pieces that didn’t come through this year for the 49ers.
Not good enough to pay 50 or 40 million
@@cnb3388he's not a bus driver. If you are going to pay him m he's needs ti be a driver
@@cnb3388He was trash
@@richardoracin2655- he did great with what he had to work with. Who’s your team?
This is why Colin cowterd isn't a GM
Every result has more than one cause. What are the multiple causes of the Niners season:
Special teams
Execution
Late contract signings
O line
Play calling
Adjustments
….
Pay him now bc it will be less than you pay him next year. We saw this w Dak. There is no other available qb that will help them win in the next three years.
@@tonygabagoolpay him now and you'll get what you deserve...a team that can't carry him... because he has all the money but lacks the talent to carry the team
Purdy IS the best QB in his division. Pundits still hold his draft position against him. He can win the Super Bowl and still be called mediocre.
I dont even like Matt Stafford, and he's objectively better than Purdy. Purdy has barely played in comparison as well. He hasnt won a superbowl, so I guess we won't really know, huh?
@@sawxpatsceltsstafford is way pst his prime. Purdy is a better qb
Yup they will say he didn’t do it his coach did even if he was to win Super Bowl mvp.
@@sawxpatsceltshe easily played well enough in last year's super bowl to win. The previous year he was on fire until he was injured. Who knows what would have happened if he had not been knocked out from injury, but they had a very good chance of going all the way. This year McCaffrey was basically non-existent because of injury and their top two receivers from last year were no shows.
Brock is closer to 4th than 1st in the division
I can't understand why so many media guys are actively trying to keep Brock Purdy from signing a contract with the 49ers. In Colin's case, it's particularly stupid: he took the 49ers to a conference championship game (got hurt during the game), to a Superbowl (in overtime against the Chiefs) and because of a great number of injuries, the 49ers don't make the playoffs the next year... and Colin pretends it's all Purdy's fault.
This is pure dishonesty.
"Particularly stupid" is what the media yaks about and practice every day.
Brock will sign a friendly deal for both parties and will have continued success.
@@OGP4321 u don’t know that
While Colin's new USC crush will be a bust. He's too short and has no composure - a dinker and dunker at best.
I wouldn't be surprised. Brock seems like a level-headed guy who knows his own needs to succeed in the league and maximize his long term earnings
Lol are you his agent? What are your sources - trust me bro
Purdy will get a huge payday or someone else will pick him up for one. He's seen what Cousins got paid.
Stafford was awful without his weapons, once they got healthy he played better, you and Nick just can’t get over your rams love affair. One week they barely get 12 points against the niners and you guys say they can’t win a game in the playoffs, now you guys think they are gonna beat the Vikings. And one last thing about Stafford, how many times did he make the playoffs with the lions? It took him getting a great coach and weapons to get anywhere
Yep. Funny how they hold that against Brock but fail to say that Stafford went to a team that went to a SB right before he got there.
Because he uses his eyes when evaluating talent. Yeah Stafford is old so he needs some OLine and a receiver but nobody on the planet is taking purdy over Stafford for a reason. And if you were it better be for the next 10 years but right now it's not close
@@thenorthernlowlight Dude stafford has not been that good this year. He is also a major gun slinger on the down side of his career. You really do not watch him play do you?
@ I do watch him play every game. I understand he's older so he's less mobile but his arm talent hasn't taken a dip at all yet plus he's arguably the last clutch qb in the league other than Mahomes. So are you sure you really watch the games or do you just look at box scores
@@thenorthernlowlight His arm talent is undeniable but his decision making is not as good. He has a ton of dropped int's as well this year. They guy has not looked good at all. Yes he is clutch but he also creates his own issues with the picks.
Purdy should be a feel good story about the last pick becoming a solid starting quarterback, but instead it’s like “he’s not THE best” and therefore doesn’t deserve to get paid and should be cut
So when Colin negotiates a new contract with Fox, he never brings up any of his past accomplishments, right? What does that have to do with the future, especially when there are hosts in his time slot - like Pat McAfee - that have better numbers? I’ll bet McAfee would love to see Colin get a contract extension. See how that works?
2:57 WHAT DID HE SAY?? 😂😂
That didn’t sound to well
Ham and egger lol
@ I know what he said lol. It just sounded bad lol.
Let’s compare Purdy’s stats to Stafford’s this year.
Purdy:
3,864 yards, 20 TD’s, 12 Ints, 96.1 passer rating, 68.0 QBR, 15 games played.
Stafford:
3,762 yards, 20 TDs, 8 Ints, 93.6 passer rating, 64.9 QBR, 16 games played.
You wanna talk about who the better QB is in the division? Purdy played with third stringers and a receiving core with the worst YAC and separation rate in the whole league.
Stafford was undermanned at the beginning of the year but that ended week 8.
Please Colin, watch the games and bring receipts when you want to talk ball.
Stafford made the playoffs Purdy didn’t
Literally, they're dogging him so hard but it's a horrible take.
The stats are nice and all that but San Francisco is 6-11 and the Rams are 10-7 and in the playoffs.
@@JeffBird86injuries are a real thing. Brock didn’t get any of his stars this season, Rams had them for a late season run. Makes a big difference playing with stars/starters vs backups in one the most talents and hardest sports in the world. No shame in a down year……but to be dogged this hard is unfair. Especially when he walked off the field with the lead against the legendary Chiefs…
@@briandittrich5640don't try to explain that to this people, they are the type of people who thinks that the QB does everything and win every game alone, the same type of people who think Brady won his 7 rings by himself
Oh Colin please…remember his take on Baker! Waaaaayyyyyy off!
Lamar with all that talent, talented team previous to this year, this year another talented team, mvp, and chokes. Justin herbert, trevor lawrence, not done anything. And u dont talk bad bout them. But u talk down on Brock who actually did something, go to super bowl, but he doesnt deserve to be paid? Colins u said trevor is generational talent, ur wrong bout a lot of these top paid qbs. Even trash like tua got paid
Have you watched Stafford lmao past month he’s been the worst qb in the division by far
Purdy still have a better resume than 80% of the new contracts given out lately
Because he went to the superbowl and lost?
2 conference championship games and multiple players in that team have had career years receiving passes from purdy. Aiyuk, Jennings, CMC, kittle all have had great seasons with purdy at QB
@@TheUndefeatedOfTheEast this was a prove it year for purdy and he failed miserably and I wouldn’t rush to pay him 🤷🏾♂️. Have you not seen how bad he was in the dolphins game the bills game the rams game. It was pretty bad
@@TheUndefeatedOfTheEast and everybody has injuries that’s not really a excuse anymore. He had Deebo and Kittle all year and Jennings
@@NicoleKendrick-mp5dq bro said deebo 😂 you mean the guy who was crying about not getting enough targets and when he got them he started dropped the ball in the endzone?
And Jennings who's a WR3?
I can't believe these comments about Purdy. After one bad season, you guys are telling me he sucks. I've seen John Lynch do magic with the salary cap if you guys are worried about it.
He's an average QB with a great roster and nothing more. Top 12-15 kind of guy.
The funny thing is his season wasn't that bad hahaha. The team was bad for sure, but what can you expect with 4 stringers starting for you.
@@dogmd7 His numbers prove you wrong, but keep trying.
Colin Cowherd next year after Purdy produces an outstanding season: "I've always liked him, always said so".
Brock is good with Kyle system, he won't be any better than Alex Smith, Jimmy g, so if he go to another team he is done
QB Brock Purdy had EVERYBODY HURT this year...STOP IT...49ers DEFENSE GAVE UP 4 GAMES in the last 5 minutes. Take people way from anybody they will lose more...#1 Aiyuk, #1 CMC, & #1 Trent.
Its a team sport, if your best receiver and best running back are both unavailable, one man cannot "will" the team to victory, to a man, every good coach preaches team, yet Colin thinks one man can win in the NFL
Just goes to show that all of Colin's knowledge can fit on the head of a pin.
Hasn't Colin been saying Brady hates BB for the last 4 years lmao? If that's true, why is Brady reaching out to him ?
All of Colin's research was done watching that biased documentary. Then refers to that as his "sources"
"I wonder if Brock had trunky midwestern legs like his boy Darnold, if he would finally get off his back?"
Brock is a great QB - make no mistake. HOW was that guy in LA after his recweivers went down? LOSE your RB, REceivers - how do you not see this? HOW great was mahomes after injureis there?!
mahomes was maCrying when he lost his tackle. 49ers were obliterated with injuries. you do NOT look at the entire pictures. NO QB in the NFL is going to win when ALL their weapons disappear.
Colin spearheading the pay Sam Darnold campaign like he’s getting a cut when they do but thinks Purdy doesn’t even deserve a career lol
Is everyone ignoring the fact that some of the biggest earners for the niners were the ones that contributed the least this season (deebo, aiyuk, cmc)?
Purdy may not be top 5. But any smart gm would pay him over aiyuk, deebo, and cmc
Lot of the games were lost by the kicker. Not because of our QB
I mean Joe Burrow was arguably the best QB this season and also didnt make the playoffs. Jordan Love still puzzles me why he is hyped so much and is in the playoffs🤷♂️
The Raiders are the worst team in the AFC West. That will continue into next year. Stay In UNC Bill.
Did Colin dirty in that thumbnail
Serious O face 😂😂😂😂
if the 49ers pay Brock Purdy what he's "earned", they immediately become non-contenders for a decade. the reason they were so good the past few years is B+ production from the QB position on a rookie contract and could pay big money to stars and roster fillers.
Great takes!
Colin loves to pick on certain QBs by pointing out how they aren't as effective without their LT and weapons. What kind of nonsense is that? What QB carries an offense without protection and weapons? For other QBs Colin uses the injuries as an excuse.
Brock Purdy was still top 10 in multiple categories without the "avengers" that people claim carry him.
So far Purdy's floor is Darnold's ceiling.
Colin week 3. I would sign him! Week 17 I would not sign him. Who are you going to get to replace Brock?
Purdy can win the nfc west that’s all that matters. He may not be the best or most talented but he can win it. If he gives the niners that chance then it’s a no brainer niners are gonna go with him.
Purdy has a lot to prove next season & theres going to be a lot of pressure. But purdy > dak. Just saying
Ummm...Wasn't SF in LAST YEAR'S Superbowl???? The NFC Conference Final the year before that???
Ever heard of the "Superbowl Hangover"??? It's a thing.
Major injuries can(and usually will) derail Any quarterbacks' season.
Gimme a break with this, please.
Stafford was sub par most the year. Purdy was best QB in the division literally last year. He will be the best in the division again next year… no point made by Colin there.
Stafford didn't "win" against Purdy because he was better at any point in that game. I counted at least two dropped interceptions in that game. Yet you are stumping for him. You are silly, guy.
This will not age well
I used to like Colin when he was with ESPN. Nowadays he just a hot takes guy. I guess it’s just how it’s done to be noticed amongst the likes.
Learn how nfl contracts work Colin. Brock won't have a big cap hit until 2028. Like Jordan Love. It's not like he is just getting a 60M cap hit next year.
I can't strand how these "analysts" have to pick a team or player they love or hate and never change their mind. Purdy can win five super bowls and coming and little Nicky will say he's below average and overpaid.
Stafford the "best QB" in that division won 3 games the year after they won the Superbowl when his team was injured and they had a harder schedule.
He gets zero blame for that and Purdy is the only reason the 49ers are struggling. 😂righto champ we see right through your click bait BS.
LMAO. If Brock dont have the 3 highest paid guys injured, they could afford a O line that actually protects and 2 decent wrs (besides JJ) that can get open vs man. Get this guy a defense that can stop somebody and an O line and he doesnt need cmac, aiyuk, trent williams and 100s of millions of salary tied up in injured players
Thank Brock for a future hit in your viewership. I can barely watch Colin and Nick Wright anymore. They cannot process new information and admit they were incorrect. Afraid to realize that they are wrong, maybe it is on purpose and it is for clicks. Also if I have to hear Colin list his favorite 5 quarterbacks or talk about offensive minded coaches, I am going to puke in my mouth.
Oh Colin. Can you be any more of a hater? That wasn't a question.
I've never seen a guy talk so much about football who knows less about football than Colin does. It's astounding how he keeps getting views for this tripe.
lol the Eagles are not hiring Belichick. Even if they fire Sirianni Howie Roseman has control of the entire roster and won’t cede power again like he did with Chip Kelly.
Actually he could tho, Stafford aging, Geno has a ceiling, Kyler is a tease. Purdy definitely can be so he should also play it out as he could have a huge bounceback year.
😂
@@Leeski916purdy is already the best QB in that division and it isn't really a discussion
@@TheUndefeatedOfTheEast It’s Stafford
Colin and the rest of the hacks used to hate on baker mayfield…all day baker is overrated now Colin hates on Brock Purdy. And did Sean Mcvay pay Colin, this guy loves him,like he was kinfolk
The Niners will be back within the next two years. Some of the old guys need to go and replaced. Purdy will be winning the division again and we know he is better in the playoffs than anyone but Mahomes. He's only missed two games in two years. You're a liar and have always been wrong about Purdy. Kyle knows more about quarterbacks than you do.
If I'm GM Lynch I'm definitely signing Purdy to a 5 year deal. No question about it. Teams and fans give up on their franchise QBs waaaaay too soon. Purdy has had one of the best first 3 years from a QB I've seen. Not just team winning but statistically. This season is his worst. He'll get better. Look at Mayfield and Darnold. If the Jets and the Browns just would have got really good HC's they'd be in the playoffs!: Another thing, Shanahan has made some poor firings and he's not making himself accountable to the Niners situation. He's lost the locker room they're not playing for him....for now.
Yeah after the first Rams game Colin says “I’d sign him” “oh yeah I’d sign him” lol he has zero credibility. Brock Purdy is Colin’s cash cow. Every one of his vids have Brock in them they have 5x as many views.
Seems like Bill gets along just fine with the young kids
HE IS SO MEAN TO BROCK 🥺
So if it's "not about what he's done" why pay ANYONE who's contract is up?
Brock Purdy isn't the guy, but the 49ers will be dumb enough to give him a huge contract anyway.
Colin reminds me of WW2 German generals yrs of military school just to learn how to hold a knife and fork!!
Hmmm bengals have burrow they have missed the playoffs twice. What is he even talking about at this point
Brock is an outstanding quarterback, top 10-15 when he is at his best, you can win with that. But the price has to be fair. It’s pretty much been proven at this point that he is a second-half turnover machine who isn’t able to elevate the team when circumstances aren’t ideal. I wouldn’t pay $40 million or more for that. I would pay him, but that number would start with a 3, otherwise you just get into the cousins debacle all over again. They were able to support the Brock early because they weren’t paying him, but if they can’t support him, he’s not going to bring them wins. It’s pretty much proven at this point. Pay him, but don’t pay him more than $35 million annually. he’s not in that range of “special” that deserves $50 million. Otherwise, you’re crippling your team.
Just a thought, obviously I don’t make the decisions in San Fran, but there’s history to look at.
Good toVery Good, definitely not OUTSTANDING
Top 10-15 is accurate. Top 10-15 is not outstanding at the Pro level.
He's top 10 easily with healthy skill players. You cant pay top salaries to every position and have them injured and then expect your qb to not be paid. This guy has been eating ramen noodles for 3 years. He'll be 52-55 million and they'll redo Trents, CMACs and Deebo's contract to get ready to trade release deebo and aiyuk by end of next yr.
If you can only support a quarterback if you're paying him less than a million, then you can't afford to pay him anything.
Bottom line is this, of the top 10 paid qbs, 9 make over $50 million a year. In two years, Brock has more playoff wins than 8 of those 10.
And I reject the idea that this year is a good measure of the 49ers going forward. People try to say "Brock isn't the same without his weapons."
But people didn't acknowledge that the 49ers didn't go from excellent starters to good starters. They want from excellent starters to backups at running back, receiver, and offensive line. Then add the injuries and life events on defense There are only so many starters you can lose, while also hiring a bad defensive coordinator before you have no chance.
@ that’s the problem, I can’t have a quarterback back be top 10 “if he has great skill positions”, then pay him $50mil, if he can’t string together wins despite not having those players.
You’re right, he was throwing to backups, but my point is if he can’t elevate the team when he’s got next to nothing, I can’t justify paying him $50m, because then he’ll never have those great players around him, although based on how SF operates, they’ll most certainly give him a big deal.
Can we please have about twenty more videos of Colin telling us how 49ers shouldn't pay Purdy? I mean, maybe 20 isn't enough. Maybe a hundred more. It almost feels like he lost a bet and is now trying to convince everyone he won. He sounds like a QB elitist. "Oh now. Purdy can't be good because he's a seventh rounder." How many Super Bowls will he have to win to have you finally lay off the dude. How about this stat: QB's who got paid recently: Dak, Jones, Lawrence, Tua, Kyler....Purdy has more playoff wins than all of these highly paid QB's COMBINED! But, sure, let's throw Purdy to the curb.......
Man Bill doing what he wants. Thats what 70 plus people do. Bill please contact me to work for you. Listen he coach one year with his staff at UNC. Get close to all of the college talent. Know who they are and their stories. Go back to the league with his staff working together for a year. When you in college coaching you know about Freshmen in HS that are phenoms and you get paid to watch them play. So thats 7 years of watching athletes play in one season coaching college. Cause you got to factor in the transfer portal and the amount of years guys play in college now. Bill takes all that knowledge with him in the draft room with his GM and they run amuck. Meanwhile he starts giving Brady intel for the Raiders organization in the draft room. To get prepared for his arrival. Owe and his job is to watch his opponents game film during the season correct? Well thats knowledge in the NFL draft room next year. He playing chess. These suckas playin checkas.
i've never hated Purdy, no dog in the fight... I've been an underdog fan and the Mr. Irrelevant thing is awesome to me, but people gotta square this circle when defending Purdy's worth as a top paid QB: we all acknowledge his drop in play is because of injuries around him AKA missing elite players that he had been surrounded by in years past... well what do you think the team will look like for years moving forward after raising Brock's cap hit over $50M? that means less elite talent around him, just like this year... _then_ what happens when _that_ less talented cast they can afford starts getting injured lol Brock will be the most irrelevant $50-60M QB in the league
his defense was terrible this year and they had the worst special teams in the league. With out that they would be in the playoffs this year.
@@joekaiser3311 it's really not that simple at all, and that still doesn't address the obvious inconsistencies in his personal play on his own side of the ball
and again, you think they're gonna afford all this elite defensive talent if they have to pay Brock like a top QB, and pay to try and surround him with as much talent and protection as possible to mask his averageness as a QB? like yeah, he's either not gonna have good weapons and protection, or he's not gonna have a good defense to bail them out... that's the point, you can't have it all like they have when you pay a QB that much, and with an elite roster suffering some injuries he struggled so what's he gonna look like in coming years when a more mediocre roster starts getting injured over the course of a season?
and their defense was actually almost Top 5 in total yards and yards per play against, but were near the bottom in scoring defense while Purdy's turnover rate increased and he was sacked at a higher rate despite being pressured at a lower rate than last season.... so maybe you're actually arguing against your own point here🤔🤔
@@mattcarberry368so you're just reading back stats that you looked up. I'm positive you didn't watch many niner games this past year. The o-line is awful for pass pro and the defense is terrible. They cant stop anything or put any pressure on opposing QB. They double bosa and just pick the defense apart week after week. The shananhan offense needs a competent runner but when that runner can catch passes it takes them to another level. They had injuries to all 3 of their RB this year so they became 1 dimensional and easy to prepare for, despite that, purdy still put up very good numbers. Letting purdy go is stupid. His contract is a product of what the market has paid the position. He shouldn't be a top paid guy but he deserves a new contract based off the resume he accumulated in the league this far.
He’s getting paid regardless whether u like it or not like it’s not the deep Colin
He’s only right about Tua and Jones.
Ur wrong here man. Like ur takes. Not this one
You pay a QB 50 mill or more on the basis that you believe he can get you to a super bowl. Purdy is proven. No dislike will erase that.
The team got Purdy to the superbowl. He's a solid piece, but just a piece.
@richardoracin2655 I'm a Niners fan and I agree.
Good god this click bait trash is insane
Your closed palm technique is goated Colin salute 🫡
YOUR Absolute Bias HATE Toward's BROCK PURDY is In INSANE Too ME. 🤯🤯🤯🙈
“The 8 teams that won their division…all had the same quarterback. First time I think I’ve seen that” Colin says that every year lmaooo
How many homes has Deion been to during his time at Colorado?
I’m sure Bill be fine
The narrative about Belichick bailing on UNC and going right back to the NFL is a complete and absolute non-story and I'm tired of analysts and commentators even mentioning it. It's complete nonsense, just admit it already!
Send Purdy to the Jets
Brock Purdy is the type of guy you can win with on a budget with your spend on the rest of the roster, not vice versa.
"No ome will take you serious.." Colin you earn your living by speaking. That being so , please learn how to speak the Rnglish language correctl;y. - No one will take you seriously.
Colin
This is what I’ve been trying to tell my 49er friends for months and they just don’t get it.
We’ve seen Purdy’s ceiling , It’s very finite. He’s not a guy that can do more with less.
That goes for every team in the nfl. Cmon.
As a Rams fan, I truly hope the 49ers sign Purdy to the largest deal ever 😂
Colin is a bad analyst and always has been.
I’m not a Niners fan by any means I think Purdy is a solid QB but he is injury prone if they are going to sign him they absolutely need to sign another decent back up they can possibly be a starter and them compete for the number 1 spot. Niners should not pay a ridiculous amount for Purdy if so then simply let him go
Everybody talking about Brock… Shanahan couldn’t get it done with Matt Ryan, Jimmy G, Sam Darnold, and now, Brock Purdy. Dig a little deeper past the shiny early stuff. What’s the bigger, real issue?
Best part of the Tua signing as a Bills fan was all the stuff Fins fans talked about how Bills fans are actually scared of Tua if we said Miami shouldn’t pay him.
Because of injuries, size, weak arm, lack of mobility, lack of off script play making ability and his record in big games.
And literally everyone of those things impacted how Miamis season went.
💯 on Purdy
Colin, thats why you in radio business, and not a GM!! 👎🏼
He loves not thinking about how they had leads but the defense gave up those leads and also the Oline ranked middle of pack. Brock needs like 3 rings to ever get over these remarks.
Make no mistake, Bill was only great because he had Tom, he was horrible when Tom left. You know this Collin, come on
All you have to do is look at the Patriots now. They have no talent... Belicheck left that franchise an absolute tire fire.
According to last year and the year before that being the best QB doesn't matter for what the Niners do.
I wish I had a passer rating that only paid my $16 mill a year
Colin’s right not many good players played at UNC if you ignore the best defensive player ever to play the game.
Tom Brady stop trying to undermine BILL B the Atlanta Falcons will regret not hiring Bill as general Manager & Coach
So Goff is fine with Detroit giving him 52M?
Watch Purdy shut him up next season