I would highly appreciate if you support my work financially: PayPal: www.paypal.me/filmanalyse Patreon: www.patreon.com/wolfgangmschmitt Wolfgang M. Schmitt V&R-Bank Neuwied - Linz IBAN: DE29 5745 0120 0130 7858 43 BIC: MALADE51NWD
The ending is abrupt and quite violent. Great acting performance. Well thought out plot structure. Brilliant achievement by the director, who had his ups and downs in his work but didn't actually have a really weak film.
Excellent, torough analysis which unveils all the feelings we could have had since we first saw the movie in 1959 (in France, we were great admirers, more than the American audiences)
Great video herr schmitt, i just finished watching vertigo and found myself wanting more hence i found your analysis which i a 100% agree with and appreciate. Watching rear window previously i recoginze it being a good movie but the feelings throughout and after watching vertigo really solidify it as masterpiece of art in my opinion. Are you familiar with other movies that might resemble vertigo. Thank you and i would love to see your channel grow
Here’s my take. The opening sequence is the key. The gutter is breaking away from the building and clearly isn’t going to hold. Scotty grip fails and he also falls to his death, just like his colleague. A shocking tragedy, for sure. The rest of the movie focuses on Scotty’s spirit who has not accepted his own physical death. The other characters are also dead and have their own unresolved spiritual issues that relate to manner of their deaths, jealousy, love lost, murder and suicide. The musical score by Bernard Hermann is so perfectly crafted and compelling in describing this spirit world that I listened to it nonstop for weeks.
Plausibility kills it. Like many of Hitch's films. But he was an expert at getting us to suspend our beliefs. SPOILERS: Expecting us to believe a guy would pre-arrange the strangling of his wife atop a bell tower in public, throw her off, screaming. And then walk back down the stairwell and walk away, all WITH your accomplice, completely un-noticed by anyone? Relying on a nervous breakdown is a lot to invest in.
I saw Kane once in a revival theater and more recently on television. I can see it's a huge film but would have to see it a few more times to really judge. Incomplete ranking.
Quite superficial as far as the human relationships are concerent, it just remains the suspense aspect (does the mon R. Burr killed his wife and sliced her?)
It ain't even the fiftieth best movie of all time. It's hilarious how conformity works. It topped the Sight And Sound poll (once) and now you've got self-appointed "experts" all over the net pretending to be cinefiles, doing their impressions of film critics (whom everyone supposedly hates, lol), parroting what they've heard. Pathetic. Vertigo isn't even the best film of 1959, much less of all time, it isn't even Hitchcock's best film of the 50s, or best film with Jimmy Stewart. It's a cool little movie, I like Vertigo, love that he went "weird", love the look of it, but give me a break, "best of all time". You go into Vertigo thinking you're seeing the "best of all time", you're going to be disappointed.
Thats your opinion and you're welcome to it, but many legendary directors think otherwise and I suspect they know more about film making than you do.😂🤡
I would highly appreciate if you support my work financially:
PayPal: www.paypal.me/filmanalyse
Patreon: www.patreon.com/wolfgangmschmitt
Wolfgang M. Schmitt
V&R-Bank Neuwied - Linz
IBAN: DE29 5745 0120 0130 7858 43
BIC: MALADE51NWD
Wonder if you heard my lp released in france early eighties
bro wearing a suit and begging for money online? come on bruh.
The ending is abrupt and quite violent. Great acting performance. Well thought out plot structure. Brilliant achievement by the director, who had his ups and downs in his work but didn't actually have a really weak film.
Excellent, torough analysis which unveils all the feelings we could have had since we first saw the movie in 1959 (in France, we were great admirers, more than the American audiences)
Great analysis!
Great video herr schmitt, i just finished watching vertigo and found myself wanting more hence i found your analysis which i a 100% agree with and appreciate. Watching rear window previously i recoginze it being a good movie but the feelings throughout and after watching vertigo really solidify it as masterpiece of art in my opinion. Are you familiar with other movies that might resemble vertigo. Thank you and i would love to see your channel grow
There are none that resemble Vertigo!
great analysis. this makes me sad i fell asleep during the Vertigo class in my hitchcock class. Not too sad but like :/
Thoughtful analysis.
Here’s my take. The opening sequence is the key. The gutter is breaking away from the building and clearly isn’t going to hold. Scotty grip fails and he also falls to his death, just like his colleague. A shocking tragedy, for sure.
The rest of the movie focuses on Scotty’s spirit who has not accepted his own physical death. The other characters are also dead and have their own unresolved spiritual issues that relate to manner of their deaths, jealousy, love lost, murder and suicide.
The musical score by Bernard Hermann is so perfectly crafted and compelling in describing this spirit world that I listened to it nonstop for weeks.
NONSENSE !
Vertigo is Hitchcock's masterpiece. Flawless.
Plausibility kills it. Like many of Hitch's films. But he was an expert at getting us to suspend our beliefs.
SPOILERS:
Expecting us to believe a guy would pre-arrange the strangling of his wife atop a bell tower in public, throw her off, screaming. And then walk back down the stairwell and walk away, all WITH your accomplice, completely un-noticed by anyone? Relying on a nervous breakdown is a lot to invest in.
Definitely " VERTIGO " ❤NUMBER 1 FILM IN HISTORY 👍
What about Citizen Kane??!!
I saw Kane once in a revival theater and more recently on television. I can see it's a huge film but would have to see it a few more times to really judge. Incomplete ranking.
CRAP
@@Richard-st8ds clearly you haven’t seen citizen kane 😏
I just broke a 30 year relation, I can relate. Thanks
????????What do you mean by that?
🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱
"Frenzy" has a bit of nudity in it.
i am farting for you
Rear Window > Vertigo
They are both great what makes you say that if i may ask
Quite superficial as far as the human relationships are concerent, it just remains the suspense aspect (does the mon R. Burr killed his wife and sliced her?)
First!
no it's not.
It ain't even the fiftieth best movie of all time. It's hilarious how conformity works. It topped the Sight And Sound poll (once) and now you've got self-appointed "experts" all over the net pretending to be cinefiles, doing their impressions of film critics (whom everyone supposedly hates, lol), parroting what they've heard. Pathetic. Vertigo isn't even the best film of 1959, much less of all time, it isn't even Hitchcock's best film of the 50s, or best film with Jimmy Stewart. It's a cool little movie, I like Vertigo, love that he went "weird", love the look of it, but give me a break, "best of all time". You go into Vertigo thinking you're seeing the "best of all time", you're going to be disappointed.
SO, GO BACK TO THE BLUES BROTHERS AND ENJOY IT THE REST OF YOUR MEDIOCRE LIFE
Thats your opinion and you're welcome to it, but many legendary directors think otherwise and I suspect they know more about film making than you do.😂🤡
@@taxpayer_revolt Let me guess: you're a couch potato in a dopey suburb with a three-digit a month cable bill. 🤣
Ich finde den Film richtig anstrengend und unfassbar langweilig
Dann musst du weiter Transformers Filme schauen.
HA !HA! HA! @@stuntmanbob90