THANK YOU! You are the first influencer to show palette finger-swap and brush-swap differences. Then you went further and showed past palette shades AND other brand's palette similarities. This information is so valuable to the general public especially for people on a fixed income or tight budget. Thank you.
Amanda does the best swatches and palette to palette comparisons!! If not for that, I would have bought ALL the cool toned palettes not realizing half of them were too similar. I go to her and ThatGirlShaeXo before I purchase ColourPop. Shae must make her eyes raw because she actually swatches and then removes each shade in the palette on her eye so you can see it perform.
Your reviews are the BEST, Amanda! Nobody reviews makeup like you do, you put so much effort and hard work into each and every one, and it shows. The Rudolph movie is such a classic, I've loved it for decades, watched it when I was a little girl, and now I watch it with my grandkids! ❤️ Your shadow swatches tell the real story, much clearer than on the Colourpop website. While I know I have these shades many times over in other palettes, the packaging here pulls at my heartstrings 🎅 plus, these are my type of shades. Would've liked a nice icy blue in there instead of all those browns, but...Those little hair clips would be a great stocking stuffer for my little granddaughter (and the lip items for my stocking!)
I love that Clarice got some of the spotlight in the collection with her bow and fur color as the lipstick. Even though she had like…3 lines or so she was my favorite character. Loved her song. Loved her lashes and blush. Looking back they could’ve thrown in a blush and some falsies as an homage to her.
Thanks for the great video, Amanda! My first thought on seeing your palette swatches on Instagram was that it would have been nice if CP would have eliminated a couple of the repetitive brown/beige/pink shades and replaced them with an icy blue shimmer and a blue matte. It would have held true to the Rudolph movie colors and would have made the palette a lot more interesting.
I really like this palette. I'm so on the fence about getting it. I've got 3 new palettes in the last 2 weeks....I think I need to chill and I do have the BH holiday palette from last year
This collection is adorable. I love the palette colors and the lipsticks, even the clips are cute. Thanks for your in depth review and swatches of everything.
I don't normally go crazy over ColourPop, but this collection has my full attention! Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer is a staple in my home around this time of the year! The packaging is festive & beautiful!!! ColourPop × Rudolph is a must have for me! I hope there is some blush included as I am still watching the vid.
The collection is super cute packaging wise but I promised myself I wouldn’t buy any makeup just because of packaging. I have the So Jaded Pallet and BH naughty pallet, so I don’t need this! Thanks so much again for the comparisons! So helpful!
I SO want to get some things from this collection but I’m sadly tight on money right now. I wasn’t too crazy about the palette colors at first but I can agree…it definitely gives off traditional Christmas vibes. I think it’s the nostalgia and the packaging that’s really dragging me in.
How similar is this palette to the mini too faced Christmas palettes this year? I really want this one but I do have both of those and they seem quite similar.
Amanda I know it’s so much work to do the comparisons and your poor arm…but I appreciate it sooooo much! You’ve saved me from buying palettes I didn’t need because ones I had were so similar…allowing me to spend my money on something else I wanted. So THANK YOU!
i appreciate you comparing this palette to the naughty palette, because that's all i have that is close enough to it. i agree with you that most people would probably just buy it because of the packaging and nostalgia.
When I first saw this I didn’t really like the color story. Although it seems perfect for the movie I didn’t think I liked it but now it has grown on me. The packing is the true highlight for me. I would totally buy this for the nostalgia!!
I got the bundle with the palette, glosses, and clips and then the lipstick and liner bundle. I have a lot of palettes that are really old that I want to replace and I LOVED the color story. Very excited for my order
Now that this is being re-released, I wanted to see what the Colourpop Queen had to say. THANK YOU for the comparisons! I much prefer the tones in the BH Naughty palette, and thankfully I own it already. Thanks for saving me money (again!).
The packaging is so cute! I love watching Rudolph around Christmas time. I’ll be passing though because I’m broke and need to buy gifts for my family. It is super cute packaging tho!
I love this launch! Rudolph has been my daughter’s favorite song since she was teeny tiny! The nostalgia of that pushed me over the edge on this collection! 🦌 Can’t wait for it! Your affiliate code did work for this collection! 🎉
Adorable. I was tempted to buy the entire collection but restrained myself and picked up the eye shadow and the Rudolf (red) lipstick and lip liner. I just discovered your channel, and wish I had found out about the discount code sooner! Excellent review. Thanks.
I am a new subscriber, and I am just falling in love with your videos! You are always super through and specific, and you think of everything when it comes to your reviews, swatches, etc. Thank you for all of your videos and hard work!
I bought myself the whole collection cause it's so cute and I loved Rudolph so much as a kid. I also bought the Rudolph and nightmare before christmas collections for some friends and some smaller sets for gifts for other people, too. It's such a good gift idea.
Thank you for this! i STILL have my 2017 ALL I SEE IS MAGIC Palette! One of their greatest Christmas collections. Will you also do the Roaring Hearts collection as well
Very much appreciate the thorough review! This collection is absolutely adorable and I'm definitely thinking about picking up the pallette as a gift. However, I do have one gripe with it: where are Yukon Cornelius and his dogs?! Missed opportunities for further adorable products there.
I tried using your code for the Mandalorian collection and I was so annoyed when yours didn't work, but some other big content creator's code worked. I'm out here trying to support the smaller people 😔
I think it was because her code was currently working for 20% off, because of her favorites collection. Now that that promo has ended, hopefully her 10% off works again!
I want this palette so bad. It's adorable and perfect for Christmas! ❤️ Edited to say Wow! I have the BH Naughty palette and didn't realize how close the shades are. I may not need this but love the movie so I still might get it lol.
Oh man, I did NOT know it was so close to the naughty palette 😫. Oh well, now I’ll have both and just love the packaging anyway 🤷🏻♀️. I picked up the gloss trio for my daughters stocking too!
Thank you for the palette similarities. Cause while I love Rudolph, I have that BH palette that I can use. I will probably have to get a lip set though.
I just see Kylie's Freddy Krueger palette in different packaging. lol. To be fair tho, I thought the Freddy palette was more Christmas-y than horror. This looks like a nice neutral palette w a pop of color... but I have all those neutrals in other CP palettes and have reds from Oden's Eye's Red Dragon and Hummingbird palettes and greens from the BH Pistachio palette. Looks like a good gift for someone just getting into makeup or someone who doesn't wear color often but loves Christmas stuff. I watched that movie a lot as a kid too... but I'm not attached to it. I did appreciate that Hermey the elf wanted to be a dentist tho. Such a grown-up decision! I'm surprised there is no blue in this palette - that's the color I remember the most from the movie.
Amanda, I doubt it is "MINT" likely peppermint or candy cane scented. I love all the mints and am quite a connoisseur. Mint is better for the summer, think mint julep. While the sweet peppermint candy cane scent is definitely a winter scent. I so love the old school Rudolph claymation. I used to drive my Grinch family nuts cuz all I wanted every year was to watch my Rudolph claymation VHS 📼 but those humbugs didn't want to watch. I am gonna have to buy the DVD this year. 🦌
I really liked the palette colour story. However, I already have "So Jaded", so I don't think I need this. Anyway, thank you so much for the swatches and comparisons. 😌
This is so precious! I only wish it had dropped sooner, don’t think I’ll be able to get this before Christmas (I’m in Norway) EDIT: I went ahead and ordered anyway - thanks so much for the code, Amanda!
i always watch your new reviews even if im not interested in the collection, but this one got me! i picked up the palette & clarice lip mask -- used your code of course 😘 thanks for always having such thorough reviews & swatches! xoxo, megan
I really think they did a great job with carrying out the theme, but i have no interest in anything in this collection. (I don't buy makeup that looks like children's toys, even if i adore the IP that the collection is centered around...although, i COULD buy the palette and just depot the singles into a plain empty palette...hmmmmmm now i'm tempted lol) I wonder if the lip liner and lipstick shades are available in the regular CP line...any idea if these shades are close to other CP shades? I think both lip sets are really pretty for the holiday season.
It’s so cute and I maybe would’ve bought if it was vegan! I know at one point Colourpop said they were going to transition to being vegan, but lately all the palettes have had carmine. I hope that changes in the future!
I am thinking, (haha) tht they probably made the palette so basic with a few holiday colrs to make it giftable. i gave my sister a palette last year with color in it, and she is a makeup person, and she was like, what am I supposed to do with this, lol. She , and as many as seem to like all the Tarte palettes that come out, don't some to like color in their palettes, but would love the cute theme. That is just my guess anyway. I can't believe I am saying this, but this set makes me want to use barettes and wear red lipstick!! Who am I???? I sadly can't afford the palette, having too much I already own, and I only am allowing myself 1 special palette purchase if I find one because I usually have to miss out on holiday releases and sales for myself, but promised myself 1 this year. Not that I don't have every color ever made probably, but i am still a budget buyer. I wish there could have been an xtra eye palette that was all pretty colors (probably would have had glitter tho- speaking of which, I am grateful they made everything safe enough to gift to young girls if they wanted!!) but that is just me. Makes me think I may try the Nomad one for the colorful purpose! Thankyou so much for showing these!! Many blessings!
![แฉกลโกงงานวัด 2024 [ โกงมั้ยครับ ep.106 ] | DOM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/taC5dpP3HXA/mqdefault.jpg)
THANK YOU! You are the first influencer to show palette finger-swap and brush-swap differences. Then you went further and showed past palette shades AND other brand's palette similarities. This information is so valuable to the general public especially for people on a fixed income or tight budget. Thank you.
Amanda does the best swatches and palette to palette comparisons!! If not for that, I would have bought ALL the cool toned palettes not realizing half of them were too similar. I go to her and ThatGirlShaeXo before I purchase ColourPop. Shae must make her eyes raw because she actually swatches and then removes each shade in the palette on her eye so you can see it perform.
This collection is so cute. Definitely pulling on the nostalgia heartstrings!
Your reviews are the BEST, Amanda! Nobody reviews makeup like you do, you put so much effort and hard work into each and every one, and it shows. The Rudolph movie is such a classic, I've loved it for decades, watched it when I was a little girl, and now I watch it with my grandkids! ❤️ Your shadow swatches tell the real story, much clearer than on the Colourpop website. While I know I have these shades many times over in other palettes, the packaging here pulls at my heartstrings 🎅 plus, these are my type of shades. Would've liked a nice icy blue in there instead of all those browns, but...Those little hair clips would be a great stocking stuffer for my little granddaughter (and the lip items for my stocking!)
I am so jazzed about the color story of the palette. I love neutrals and these neutrals are interesting.
I love that Clarice got some of the spotlight in the collection with her bow and fur color as the lipstick. Even though she had like…3 lines or so she was my favorite character. Loved her song. Loved her lashes and blush. Looking back they could’ve thrown in a blush and some falsies as an homage to her.
Thanks for the great video, Amanda! My first thought on seeing your palette swatches on Instagram was that it would have been nice if CP would have eliminated a couple of the repetitive brown/beige/pink shades and replaced them with an icy blue shimmer and a blue matte. It would have held true to the Rudolph movie colors and would have made the palette a lot more interesting.
I really like this palette. I'm so on the fence about getting it. I've got 3 new palettes in the last 2 weeks....I think I need to chill and I do have the BH holiday palette from last year
Just ordered through your link and used your code! Thank you so much!! This was my very favorite Christmas movie as a kid :)
This collection is adorable. I love the palette colors and the lipsticks, even the clips are cute. Thanks for your in depth review and swatches of everything.
I know I can always count on you to be the first with reviews and swatches! I need this collection! 🥰❤️
I don't normally go crazy over ColourPop, but this collection has my full attention! Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer is a staple in my home around this time of the year! The packaging is festive & beautiful!!! ColourPop × Rudolph is a must have for me! I hope there is some blush included as I am still watching the vid.
I never buy palettes anymore, but watching your videos and swatches inspire me to copy the colours story or part of it with my singles :)
The collection is super cute packaging wise but I promised myself I wouldn’t buy any makeup just because of packaging. I have the So Jaded Pallet and BH naughty pallet, so I don’t need this! Thanks so much again for the comparisons! So helpful!
The packaging for this collection is so cute! I normally don't go for the Christmas themed palettes and collections but this one really stands out.
Picked up an eye and lip bundle and your code worked. Thank you!
I SO want to get some things from this collection but I’m sadly tight on money right now. I wasn’t too crazy about the palette colors at first but I can agree…it definitely gives off traditional Christmas vibes. I think it’s the nostalgia and the packaging that’s really dragging me in.
How similar is this palette to the mini too faced Christmas palettes this year? I really want this one but I do have both of those and they seem quite similar.
I love your videos because you are always so honest about the products and your personal preferences. Cheers from Brasil. 😊💕
Amanda I know it’s so much work to do the comparisons and your poor arm…but I appreciate it sooooo much! You’ve saved me from buying palettes I didn’t need because ones I had were so similar…allowing me to spend my money on something else I wanted. So THANK YOU!
i appreciate you comparing this palette to the naughty palette, because that's all i have that is close enough to it. i agree with you that most people would probably just buy it because of the packaging and nostalgia.
Everything in this collection sings this 1969 baby’s name. Thanks for the sneak peek!
Oh my holly jolly heart is singing looking at this collection ♥️💚♥️💚
Seriously nostalgic and super cute.
Would love to get this and break it up into individual gifts- it’s so adorable 😍🎄
I'm always so grateful for your videos because they always help me to choose what to buy or not ♡ Thanks for the hard work!
I pulled the trigger on the pallet and lip kits. I am so excited to receive them and try them out. So adorable so perfect.
I actually LOVE the palette it’s so pretty 🤩!! And I love the red lipstick! The clips are cute but I already have lots of Christmas hair accessories.
When I first saw this I didn’t really like the color story. Although it seems perfect for the movie I didn’t think I liked it but now it has grown on me. The packing is the true highlight for me. I would totally buy this for the nostalgia!!
I like the eyeshadow palette most of all out of this collection.
You really make me save my money with the comparisons! So thank you 🤣
I got the bundle with the palette, glosses, and clips and then the lipstick and liner bundle. I have a lot of palettes that are really old that I want to replace and I LOVED the color story. Very excited for my order
Now that this is being re-released, I wanted to see what the Colourpop Queen had to say. THANK YOU for the comparisons! I much prefer the tones in the BH Naughty palette, and thankfully I own it already. Thanks for saving me money (again!).
The packaging is so cute! I love watching Rudolph around Christmas time. I’ll be passing though because I’m broke and need to buy gifts for my family. It is super cute packaging tho!
So adorable! I picked up the hair clip/ lip balm/ bath bomb set for my 10 year old daughter’s stocking. And the palette for me 🙃
This collection isn’t exactly my speed but I wanted to say how much I appreciate your hard work on your swatch videos! They are so helpful!
I love this launch! Rudolph has been my daughter’s favorite song since she was teeny tiny! The nostalgia of that pushed me over the edge on this collection! 🦌 Can’t wait for it!
Your affiliate code did work for this collection! 🎉
So nostalgic!
This is so cute and one of my all time favorite Christmas shows since childhood. I have to get something!
I actually love that color story!
Adorable. I was tempted to buy the entire collection but restrained myself and picked up the eye shadow and the Rudolf (red) lipstick and lip liner. I just discovered your channel, and wish I had found out about the discount code sooner! Excellent review. Thanks.
I really like the color story in this collection
Like it so much better now that I see the color story! The packaging is on point and I love it most of all! Not the best reason to buy more makeup.
I am a new subscriber, and I am just falling in love with your videos! You are always super through and specific, and you think of everything when it comes to your reviews, swatches, etc. Thank you for all of your videos and hard work!
Amanda's affiliate code worked for me! For anyone who was wondering if it would work.
This is so cute getting the eye palette.
I bought myself the whole collection cause it's so cute and I loved Rudolph so much as a kid. I also bought the Rudolph and nightmare before christmas collections for some friends and some smaller sets for gifts for other people, too. It's such a good gift idea.
Wonderful Video! Any chance we'll get a tutorial with this one or 3 looks- one palette??? Love your content!
I bought the palette and the peppermint bundle this morning and your code worked!
Im gonna have to get the hair clips foe my daughters. Too cute 🥰
I like the shade selection of the eyeshadow palette. Red & Green, what could be more Christmassy? I'd be surprised if this doesn't sell out quickly.
Hi Amanda. Just love your channel. Your so informative. I can tell you love cosmetics. Take care..thank you.
Totally buying this for the packaging and nostalgia. Couldn’t wait to watch this special every year ❤️❤️❤️. And will do so this year
I bought the palette,highlighter and the nude lipstick!
Used your code on a couple of products from this collection! :)
Love your reviews! Thanks for getting this one up so quickly....I def want those lip products!!😊
Thank you for this! i STILL have my 2017 ALL I SEE IS MAGIC Palette! One of their greatest Christmas collections. Will you also do the Roaring Hearts collection as well
Very much appreciate the thorough review! This collection is absolutely adorable and I'm definitely thinking about picking up the pallette as a gift. However, I do have one gripe with it: where are Yukon Cornelius and his dogs?! Missed opportunities for further adorable products there.
I tried using your code for the Mandalorian collection and I was so annoyed when yours didn't work, but some other big content creator's code worked. I'm out here trying to support the smaller people 😔
I think it was because her code was currently working for 20% off, because of her favorites collection. Now that that promo has ended, hopefully her 10% off works again!
Codes do work!!!!! I didn’t buy the entire collection. But I was able to use your code!
Another awesome, thorough review. ❤️💚
I want this palette so bad. It's adorable and perfect for Christmas! ❤️ Edited to say Wow! I have the BH Naughty palette and didn't realize how close the shades are. I may not need this but love the movie so I still might get it lol.
Ordered the palette this morning, and your code worked!
I’m so excited about this launch!
Why does the full collection not come with the sol products? Like the body shimmer and the bath bomb?!
Will you be reviewing Of Quartz and the holiday collection exclusive to Ulta?
It's super cute! Do I need it? Nope. But it certainly hits the nostalgia mark!
Geeze, thank you so much. I hate mint and would have been so upset if I bought the whole set and didn't know.
Oh man, I did NOT know it was so close to the naughty palette 😫. Oh well, now I’ll have both and just love the packaging anyway 🤷🏻♀️. I picked up the gloss trio for my daughters stocking too!
Oh yes I was waiting for your review, even though I already bought some. I used your code as always!
Thank you for the palette similarities. Cause while I love Rudolph, I have that BH palette that I can use. I will probably have to get a lip set though.
I just see Kylie's Freddy Krueger palette in different packaging. lol. To be fair tho, I thought the Freddy palette was more Christmas-y than horror. This looks like a nice neutral palette w a pop of color... but I have all those neutrals in other CP palettes and have reds from Oden's Eye's Red Dragon and Hummingbird palettes and greens from the BH Pistachio palette. Looks like a good gift for someone just getting into makeup or someone who doesn't wear color often but loves Christmas stuff.
I watched that movie a lot as a kid too... but I'm not attached to it. I did appreciate that Hermey the elf wanted to be a dentist tho. Such a grown-up decision! I'm surprised there is no blue in this palette - that's the color I remember the most from the movie.
I'm tempted to buy the palette! It does seem like there are a lot of similarities to the Emily Edit The Wants palette. I'd love to see a comparison!
The packaging of everything is so good! I don't think any of the colors / color stories are pulling me in though.
Good afternoon Amanda!! Excited to hear your thoughts 😊 Thank you for the video ❤🎄
If you had to recommend only one, would you pick the lip scrub or the lip mask?
Amanda, I doubt it is "MINT" likely peppermint or candy cane scented. I love all the mints and am quite a connoisseur. Mint is better for the summer, think mint julep. While the sweet peppermint candy cane scent is definitely a winter scent.
I so love the old school Rudolph claymation. I used to drive my Grinch family nuts cuz all I wanted every year was to watch my Rudolph claymation VHS 📼 but those humbugs didn't want to watch. I am gonna have to buy the DVD this year. 🦌
totally unrelated, but I'm really hoping colourpop does a Witcher collection xD i mean, they did the mandalorian...
I really liked the palette colour story. However, I already have "So Jaded", so I don't think I need this. Anyway, thank you so much for the swatches and comparisons. 😌
I picked up the palette and the Mandalorian palette and mirror. I was able to use your discount code on both 🥳
This is so precious! I only wish it had dropped sooner, don’t think I’ll be able to get this before Christmas (I’m in Norway)
EDIT: I went ahead and ordered anyway - thanks so much for the code, Amanda!
i always watch your new reviews even if im not interested in the collection, but this one got me! i picked up the palette & clarice lip mask -- used your code of course 😘 thanks for always having such thorough reviews & swatches! xoxo, megan
Thanks for posting so quickly! I wonder if the hair clips have a materials list; what is the fluff made of?
I ordered as soon as it opened. They really got me with the packaging on this one 😆
This collection is super cute, but it's an easy pass for me. I really appreciate your review and comparisons.
Did anyone see updates if this will be at Ulta?
This is the first collection that I’ve wanted everything. I plan on getting the collection soon (hoping it doesn’t sell out🤞🏻)
I dont care for anything in this collection but I want the hair clips so bad!
I used another creator’s code so they do work. I bought the 2 lipsticks and the palette. This collection is so cute. 🙂 🧑🎄 ❄️
I really think they did a great job with carrying out the theme, but i have no interest in anything in this collection. (I don't buy makeup that looks like children's toys, even if i adore the IP that the collection is centered around...although, i COULD buy the palette and just depot the singles into a plain empty palette...hmmmmmm now i'm tempted lol) I wonder if the lip liner and lipstick shades are available in the regular CP line...any idea if these shades are close to other CP shades? I think both lip sets are really pretty for the holiday season.
Your code worked on this collection
Thank you for all the swatches but was hoping you would talk me out of the lippies with some comparisons. Lol
It’s so cute and I maybe would’ve bought if it was vegan! I know at one point Colourpop said they were going to transition to being vegan, but lately all the palettes have had carmine. I hope that changes in the future!
I can’t find the drop on the website 🤔
It doesn’t launch until 10a Pacific. That’s 1pm Eastern.
It will launch in about 12 minutes! 10am pst, 12pm cst, 1pm est.
It’s there now.
It's adorable but not really my thing. I'll be happy with my It's a Mood ☺
I am thinking, (haha) tht they probably made the palette so basic with a few holiday colrs to make it giftable. i gave my sister a palette last year with color in it, and she is a makeup person, and she was like, what am I supposed to do with this, lol. She , and as many as seem to like all the Tarte palettes that come out, don't some to like color in their palettes, but would love the cute theme. That is just my guess anyway. I can't believe I am saying this, but this set makes me want to use barettes and wear red lipstick!! Who am I???? I sadly can't afford the palette, having too much I already own, and I only am allowing myself 1 special palette purchase if I find one because I usually have to miss out on holiday releases and sales for myself, but promised myself 1 this year. Not that I don't have every color ever made probably, but i am still a budget buyer. I wish there could have been an xtra eye palette that was all pretty colors (probably would have had glitter tho- speaking of which, I am grateful they made everything safe enough to gift to young girls if they wanted!!) but that is just me. Makes me think I may try the Nomad one for the colorful purpose! Thankyou so much for showing these!! Many blessings!
The packaging couldn’t be cuter but don’t think I’ll bother getting anything. It would make good gifts but too neutral for me.
Packaging is cute af but I don't get Christmas vibes from this color story at all, more like springtime
If anyone complains about the color selections are Grinches and just need to move along to another brand. Bah humbugs!!!
I ordered my palette today.
That palette is cute, but just too redundant with so many other palettes.
❤
Bah humbug but the colors are pretty