Hope it will get better..., the 'current system' in the industry needs to be reconstructed ...ease their burdens Ofc fans who forgot idols are humans too , high expectations and all those hates.. they're Humans like everyone else. Let everyone be happy and peaceful.
It hurts badly when the person who gave you joy and cheered you up in most difficult time left so soon😭 I'm extremely devastated hearing your passing moonbin, i may not know you outside your idol life but I wish you to find happiness, no more pain💔 I love you, sleep tight our moonbin.
Even if you don't stan Astro, their personalities, brotherhood, talent and peaceful fandom was something that everyone admired and it bring every fandom together. Rip Moonbinie 😥✨
Astro was one of the first groups I started liking when I got into kpop. His face is everywhere in kpop news and my timeline in twitter but I still have a hard time truly letting it sink in. I look at the pictures and videos posted and I find myself tearing up randomly many times, but it just doesn't feel real. Seeing those moments of him captured on film forever and knowing there will never be no more.
You put exactly how I’ve been feeling into words. My brain has just been trying to pretend it’s not real. And then random times of the day it just hits me that he’s actually gone and it takes all my strength to not start crying right then and there. These last couple of hours have been utter hell and I wish I could wake up and see him have a new post on weverse or smth
That's exactly how I feel. I've been in devastation and denial all day. I didn't go more than 5 minutes without crying. I even almost threw up. I just pray for his friends, family, members, and supporters to have peace. He was my bias and it was my first time experiencing smt like this. It's a feeling I never want to experience again
Joohoney was really trying not to cry at the end, he's literally devastated. And Miyeon too, she looks so sad. Who wouldn't be? I am not an Aroha but this news really broke my heart. I've never seen Moonbin not smiling. He always had that beautiful bright smile on his face, but it was probably not real.. He was loved by so many people. Even though it's almost impossible, I hope everyone will be okay. Rest in peace Moonbin, you will forever be loved and remembered by everyone ❤
Both of them probably cried lots before and after this. Monsta X was quite close with Astro so I don't think it was right of Mnet to get Jooheon to deliver this news. I can't imagine the amount of pain Jooheon must be feeling to be informing and sharing condolences about his own friend's passing. Miyeon too looked like she would burst into tears any second. Idk how they went through this while recording when here I am crying for the third or fourth time while hearing his name and seeing his pictures. I wasn't even a very big fan but was still emotionally attached to him and Astro. I can't even imagine the pain and suffering his family especially his sister Sua, friends especially his childhood friend SinB, Chanwoo & Seungkwan, Astro members and Arohas must be going through. Hope Moonbin is in a better place now ♥️.
Those smiles were probably real but that doesn't mean that he didn't have other things going on. Many people find joy in their work even if they have other things going on.
@@epifanny yes of course. What I meant is, it is said that people who suffer the most tend to smile the most, maybe he was one those people. Sure, there were times when he was happy, but maybe some of those times he was just hiding his true feelings. Who knows... 😞
I can feel the pain in Jooheon's words and voice. He has known Moonbin for so long and is close with him so can't even measure how much pain he got when he found out what happened to Binnie 💔 Fly high and Rest well Moonbin 🕊
Behind every smile that he gave us lies a pain that we failed to understand, I still can't believe he left us.... Even knowing that we love him so much, he left, why moonbin why? He hid his pain so nicely that we all failed to see it.... For not even one second I thought he was going through some hard times.... Why it's always the sunshines of the group has to go through a lot.... Edit: I just wanna know the reason behind his sudden death, whatever the reason was we can't change the fact that he left us.... He is not with us anymore and that hurts... I can't- if it's health problem like sudden heart attack because of over working, it can happen, and it happened with a lot of people then it's a straight up warning for kpop industry
@@mei1568 they might do an autop$y, because they found no evidence of foul play. One person (maybe the manager?) said it looks like sewerslide and the whole kpop fandom took it and ran with it. Honestly, I’m hoping it was an underlying health issue but we never know. I hope they do the autop$y, but it’s not my place. May he rest peacefully.
Few months ago Monsta X and Moonbin with Sanha were chilling on stage together. Can’t believe this happened to us.. hope all members are okay now. Hope someone can hug Minhyuk in military 😭
I know it is hard but life still has to go on. Also I think it is a good thing though...especially them being able to talk about it publicly. That helps probably in the grieving period....also for the fans.
@@Niki91-HR 🙁yea I am glad they were able to talk about it but it’s sad to see them like this I rlly hope they’re a little better now since the camera in their faces might have given a lot of pressure..🙁
@@notminghao I fortunately never experienced this situation and hopefully never will but I think all of them will be fine again. But you probably know the saying that time heals all wounds. They will for sure miss him forever but they will be ok again. Look at SHINee. They are surely missing Jonghyun every day but they are doing fine as far as we know. I know what you mean though. It was for sure difficult for them to do the show but on the other hand maybe it was for the best. To have something to do and occupy your mind a little bit. I guess it helps when they are all together as well and giving each other some sort of strength. Joohoney really looked sad ...but I cant imagine how hard it is for the Astro members.
@@Niki91-HR Not only Astro members, but his family...close friends. I can't even imagine how hard has to be for MoonSua, and SinB....godness, those two were lifelong friends, like actual friends since childhood. SinB and MoonBin were way closer than MoonSua and MoonBIn...i know they were brother and sister but they said until Sua debuted, they weren't that close to eachother. Well due MoonBin being already in group and Sua to train 10 years... Since i can't do nothing, i really hope there is someone beside SinB and MoonSua al the time....mounrning can be critical for someone
@@K-PopGamesWithSoulMirae ok I dont know who SinB is...at least not from reading the name. 😅 Sure it is hard for his family too. Not denying that. We just talked about the idols and industry.
While I watching yesterday Mcountdown, my mother ask me what both MCs talking about, once I started to translate the first sentence, I already cry, and the heart pain made me cannot keep translate to my mom.. 😭😭
I broke down crying when I saw the news. Didn't wanna believe it was true but I found out by looking at Astro's account and the minute I started seeing the news spread everywhere my heart dropped. I couldn't breathe and started shaking really bad because he was my bias and I've loved that boy for like 4 or 5 years and knowing he's gone ripped me to pieces 💔💔 wish it wasn't true 😓🕊 moonbinie we love you sm and hope you shine the brightest in the sky tonight 🫶🏾.
You could see how heartbroken Jooheon was... trying so hard not to cry. I cried this day until I fell asleep, I still miss Bin so much, can't imagine how his friends were feeling... RIP
I'm back exactly one year later and I still cannot believe that Moonbin left us so soon. I never really was a fan of ASTRO and I never found out about Moonbin until it was too late. Yet the news still shocked me. Rest In Peace Moonbin, keep flying high.
To think of how much Moonbin's most beautiful smile brightens anyone's mood and day, of his cheerful self everywhere we see him, it's so heartbreaking to found out how much he hides how weak he is and how much he has been struggling, smiling just for us not to worry. ~ But for me (and for us) he is the strongest. He is a gem, a genuine treasure, whom I know will be in our hearts and memories forever ❤️ Shine the brightest star Moonbin! Condolences to the bereaved family and my co-Aroha 🙏
I'm not an Aroha I've just known Astro for two years and I don't watch much of their content but I don't know why my heart broke into pieces. Also the bgm at the ending with his smiling face literally made me cry. You'll always be remembered Binnie
You aint alone. I am not a fan either, casually listened to some Astro songs and here and there Moonbin or Sanha or Eunwoo would appear in things I like to watch but thats it. And still it shocked me completely. I actually couldnt really sleep last night. I guess he was just that type of person, regardless if you were a fan of his music, who captured people just by his personality and charm.
still can’t believe out moon has left us. Moonbin presence had such effects in the kpop industry. Just want to say that idols are human too. Our beloved moon has recover and will shine brighter than ever🕊️💙 Astro will always be OT5💙
I am an army, never stanned astro... But I couldn't stop crying since I heard this. Just look at those pictures.. Who is so cruel to hurt such an innocent person
April 19 when he passed away, that was 2 days ago. Look how fast the night changes, it happen pretty fast. Still can't believe that you are no longer in this world. I hope you may find peace & real happiness where ever you are right now. Still take care of your sister Sua even if she no longer see you now. All your hardwork in this world will be forever remember. Thank you for making us happy, Binnie. We will miss you. Rest well in paradise. 🥺🤍
I honestly still can’t believe it. He was such a lovely person, and is really talented. The sudden passing of his is really heartbreaking for many arohas and nonfans. Rest in peace, Moonbin. You are loved and will be remembered. 🤍
You can clearly see their sadness in their eyes.. it makes me so sad even if I don’t know Astro well. It’s just heartbreaking when a young life is cut short because of suicide. I hope he is free now. Rest in peace mate!
Life is so unpredictable. Couldn't believe that we have to address him in the past tense from now on. I'm mourning over his loss but his beautiful smile is assuring me that he's fine over there. You must have been through much so now *RIP MOONBIN!* Hope we meet again one day!
he used to be such a bubbly person, it really makes u question everything and every other idol's smiles. may he rest in peace and i hope this never happens again from the bottom of my heart.
moonie became the brightest star among stars in the sky i still couldnt compose my self i still cant believe i wont hear your sweet voice your laugh and giggles but still thank you for existing in this world i will miss your smile your giggles
it was like a bolt in the sky.. You left a big sadness shared by all. i may have never met you, but i had tears in my eyes..knowing you have gone... your smile and cheekiness would be always in my memory.. another star gone to heaven..shine brigth Moonbin RIP young soul
They sound absolutely heartbroken. I hope that our moonbin will fly high and be at peace rather than pain. Everyone, let’s protect our idols. They dont deserve the hate we give
His news shocked me to the core, although I'm not a fan of Astro but I love their music, but watching this made tear up a lot, condolences and prayers to his family, especially his sister Moon Sua, friends and Astro members🕊🕊🤍🤍❤❤🫂🫂🫂
My condolences to every Aroha out there. Also sending my love to Moonbinnie's family, his friends and members. And also to Jooheon and Miyeon, sorry that Mnet made them put on a show on the day of Moonbin's passing. I know Jooheon was his friend. it must have been so hard for him. Rest peacefully.
I can't help crying. I know he shouldn't be remembered because of his decease but astro was one of the first kpop groups I knew and those news hit me so hard. Rest well Moonbin.
This is so heartbreaking, I can’t control my tears. I’m still in disbelief… I hope he’s resting well and that he’s in a better place. You will be remembered forever Moonbin 🕊️
MBB are here for you AROHA🥺 Bin-ah always had the best smiles and never failed to make those around him laugh. I loved watching him grow as an artist and wanted so badly to see his next ten years. We all did. He is beautiful moon in the starry sky now. May he find peace and rest knowing he was loved, will continue to be loved
Im so happy that they are finally talking about it.... somehow... its still much work do in this industry... there are too many people with the same dream and most of them suffering.. firs tthey don't have enough work then if they get famouse at all its far too much work. Please treat your artists with respect as fans. Remember you never know what someone if going through we only know what people want to show.
이렇게 빨리 떠났지만 미소와 무대를 볼 수 없지만 고마웠어요 삼가고인의 명복을 빕니다 저는 오빠가 최애라서 너무 행복했고 아로하라서 행복했어요 이제는 걱정, 불안 다 버리고 편히 쉬쉬기를 바랄게요 많이 고마웠어요 가족들, 멤버들, 팬들이 마음정리하는데 시간이 오래 걸리겠지만 이제는 푹쉬세요 잠시나마 웃는모습을 보여주셔셔 감사하고 오빠의 아픔이 너무나 컸단걸 안좋은 선택을 했다는 것도 너무 팬으로서 마음이 아파요 최애라서 태어나줘서 데뷔해주셔서 진짜 고마웠어요 잘가요 일찍 별이 되어버렸지만 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Смотрю и все равно не могу поверить, что все это реальность. Только недавно он выступал, несколько дней назад выложил тикток. Он такой улыбчивый, тёплый, яркий... как это больно. Надеюсь, что теперь он действительно счастлив и обрёл покой.
Boys are always believed to be strong, non-expressing, and hiding emotions. I think that is what Moonbin had been going through, suppressing emotions and suddenly taking this step out of depression.😔 I really wish I could be the one to help him get out of this sadness, but it's too late now.😢😭 May Sua and Moonbin's family and friends receive the strength and courage to get through this time. All I am worried about is what feelings Sua would be going through! 😔😔 Rest In Peace, Moon Bin. We love you.
Notice how it's always idols with big smiles. It is true,that big smiles hide the sadness inside. 😢 I am so sad for him. I wish we could turn back the time and save him. 💔🕊
I really hope the members of Shinee, Kara, and FX are helping Astro through this traumatic and difficult time in their lives. They must understand what it is like to have gone through this and to have had it happen so publicly. I can’t imagine what it’s like to to mourn someone in the public eye. I hope Astro take as long as they need to heal and mourn Moonbin, we don’t care how long they stay on break, just know that the fans will be here when you’re able to return.
I told my mom that Moonbin is my bias and he was dead. And she ask me why did he die?And what happen with him? i told her he suicide and i start crying, then she hugs me and comforts me really well. She said she knew i'm a big fan of Kpop so she understanded my feeling. And she hope Moonbin flies high and have a great new life with new world. Arohas all around the world will remember your bright smile, your aegyo, your voice and everything abt you. We all always and forever keep you in our memories and heart too🤍Our Moonbin oppa you tired for a long time and now you can rest. You should remember that we always stay by your side because we're your Arohas for Astro🫀💖
Mcs really had such a difficult time. They worked hard. It hurts so much... Jooheon, I know this was too difficult. You lost a friend. I'm so sorry you had to go through this
This is such a devastating news, like I barely know what he’s like but his smile is the brightest smile I’ve ever seen in any male idol ever that it is unthinkable that he’d be gone so young
It’s so sad to hear this I never heard about moonbin but yet awail ago I was seeing how talented loving he was it’s realy sad 😢 my condolences to the family and friends and also the fans
His passing really... It seems like it shocked all of us... Even when i am not an Astro fan, (though i liked them and their music) i am still in denial. It's a real tragedy to say the least! R. I. P. Moonbin.. i really really hope that you are in a better place... God bless you all. I wish all the best to his family and friends and anyone who is struggling right now. 🙏 If you think there is no way out, you are wrong. There is always another way, a better way. Please talk to someone. Someone out there wants to listen and be there for you! Please don't give up your hope, because it CAN be different. And likewise, someone out there needs YOU right now. Go and listen. ❤
Moonbin was with arohas when we need him but when he needed us the most we weren't there for him it's killing me inside we weren't there for him I'm so sorry Binnie hope your happy up there
![[C.C] Key and Taeyeon think of the beautiful memory with Jonghyun #SHINEE #KEY](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vad27IQEVYo/mqdefault.jpg)
They really look sad, especially jooheon, he sounds devastated. Hope we can all be strong
As a Monbebe I have seen how close Monsta X and Seventeen members are to Astro so I'm not surprised at all if they are affected by the news
@MOONBIN DESERVED IT WHY ARE U HATING?? What is wrong with the people like you sick minded
@MOONBIN DESERVED IT you deserved it instead of moonbin
@MOONBIN DESERVED IT ......... disgusting
Ofcourse he is ASTRO and monstax are very close friends
Few years back they couln’t even say these stuff publicly bc they weren’t allowed to😢 i’m glad that they are openly expressing their emotions
Hope it will get better..., the 'current system' in the industry needs to be reconstructed ...ease their burdens
Ofc fans who forgot idols are humans too , high expectations and all those hates.. they're Humans like everyone else.
Let everyone be happy and peaceful.
Blackpink next
@@kitt-chu7596 a part of the problem is us fans
When ladies code accident happened, they did the same as well. This was back in 2014. How time flies wow
@@playboybts89204 stfu for real can you guys help me report this mf… these stuff happens bc y’all exist
look at the sadness in jooheon's eyes 😔
He does look like he's had or is having a fit of crying done.
You can tell he was crying and is trying his best not to breakdown again 😞
is jooheon the mc and were he friends with moonbin?
@@jm-zf8wfyes he is astro and Monsta X really close to each other
@@jm-zf8wfyes they did participate in variety shows together and visit each others room in music shows
It hurts badly when the person who gave you joy and cheered you up in most difficult time left so soon😭 I'm extremely devastated hearing your passing moonbin, i may not know you outside your idol life but I wish you to find happiness, no more pain💔 I love you, sleep tight our moonbin.
Very very hurts
@MOONBIN DESERVED IT you deserve it too,so...
@MOONBIN DESERVED ITf*off
M still not believing that he passed away .
In last show he promised he'll come back ,
" Your lie in April" 😭😭😭🥀
@MOONBIN DESERVED IT is that supposed to be funny?
Everyone, if you got Aroha's friend, give them a hug today...
Basically my classmate who was scrolling through Twitter and found out the news and broke down rip
I got no one I m dying alone. I m blank. I m having panic attacks since the night
@@solihaqadri184 Same here.... No one to share what he was for me....
@@solihaqadri184 me too. ill pray for you. we can get through this loss together, sweet aroha
I can’t give my friend a hug because we hardly have time to meet our friends group
Even if you don't stan Astro, their personalities, brotherhood, talent and peaceful fandom was something that everyone admired and it bring every fandom together. Rip Moonbinie 😥✨
The puffiness under his eyes 🥺☹️
Astro was one of the first groups I started liking when I got into kpop. His face is everywhere in kpop news and my timeline in twitter but I still have a hard time truly letting it sink in. I look at the pictures and videos posted and I find myself tearing up randomly many times, but it just doesn't feel real. Seeing those moments of him captured on film forever and knowing there will never be no more.
I feel the same...
You put exactly how I’ve been feeling into words. My brain has just been trying to pretend it’s not real. And then random times of the day it just hits me that he’s actually gone and it takes all my strength to not start crying right then and there. These last couple of hours have been utter hell and I wish I could wake up and see him have a new post on weverse or smth
Same…
That's exactly how I feel. I've been in devastation and denial all day. I didn't go more than 5 minutes without crying. I even almost threw up. I just pray for his friends, family, members, and supporters to have peace. He was my bias and it was my first time experiencing smt like this. It's a feeling I never want to experience again
I fell for astro cus of moonbin for 2 years 😔
Joohoney was really trying not to cry at the end, he's literally devastated. And Miyeon too, she looks so sad. Who wouldn't be? I am not an Aroha but this news really broke my heart. I've never seen Moonbin not smiling. He always had that beautiful bright smile on his face, but it was probably not real.. He was loved by so many people. Even though it's almost impossible, I hope everyone will be okay. Rest in peace Moonbin, you will forever be loved and remembered by everyone ❤
Both of them probably cried lots before and after this. Monsta X was quite close with Astro so I don't think it was right of Mnet to get Jooheon to deliver this news. I can't imagine the amount of pain Jooheon must be feeling to be informing and sharing condolences about his own friend's passing. Miyeon too looked like she would burst into tears any second. Idk how they went through this while recording when here I am crying for the third or fourth time while hearing his name and seeing his pictures. I wasn't even a very big fan but was still emotionally attached to him and Astro. I can't even imagine the pain and suffering his family especially his sister Sua, friends especially his childhood friend SinB, Chanwoo & Seungkwan, Astro members and Arohas must be going through. Hope Moonbin is in a better place now ♥️.
Those smiles were probably real but that doesn't mean that he didn't have other things going on. Many people find joy in their work even if they have other things going on.
@@epifanny yes of course. What I meant is, it is said that people who suffer the most tend to smile the most, maybe he was one those people. Sure, there were times when he was happy, but maybe some of those times he was just hiding his true feelings. Who knows... 😞
Miyeon face and voice looks like she have been crying.And Jooheon look sad and tired. RIP MoonBin, your legacy will never be forgotten
Miyeon looks like she's fighting tears. R.I.P Moonbin
I can feel and see the emptiness in their eyes
I can feel the pain in Jooheon's words and voice. He has known Moonbin for so long and is close with him so can't even measure how much pain he got when he found out what happened to Binnie 💔
Fly high and Rest well Moonbin 🕊
Behind every smile that he gave us lies a pain that we failed to understand, I still can't believe he left us.... Even knowing that we love him so much, he left, why moonbin why?
He hid his pain so nicely that we all failed to see it.... For not even one second I thought he was going through some hard times.... Why it's always the sunshines of the group has to go through a lot....
Edit: I just wanna know the reason behind his sudden death, whatever the reason was we can't change the fact that he left us.... He is not with us anymore and that hurts... I can't- if it's health problem like sudden heart attack because of over working, it can happen, and it happened with a lot of people then it's a straight up warning for kpop industry
We didn’t fail to realize anything he just hid really well that we didn’t see it
Was it confirmed that it was sui€id€ tho?
@@mei1568 it still has to reveal, the police didn't found any foul play or something, by looking it that looks like he- I'm sorry I can't-
@@caratheadarmy I don't know honestly... So much pain, no matter what caused him leaving this world😭 let's just hope he's resting in peace now 🕊️
@@mei1568 they might do an autop$y, because they found no evidence of foul play. One person (maybe the manager?) said it looks like sewerslide and the whole kpop fandom took it and ran with it. Honestly, I’m hoping it was an underlying health issue but we never know. I hope they do the autop$y, but it’s not my place. May he rest peacefully.
Few months ago Monsta X and Moonbin with Sanha were chilling on stage together. Can’t believe this happened to us.. hope all members are okay now. Hope someone can hug Minhyuk in military 😭
I’m glad they are allowed to openly do this now even tho it’s hard :(.
It’s sad how they still had to do this while being heartbroken..
I know it is hard but life still has to go on.
Also I think it is a good thing though...especially them being able to talk about it publicly. That helps probably in the grieving period....also for the fans.
@@Niki91-HR 🙁yea I am glad they were able to talk about it but it’s sad to see them like this I rlly hope they’re a little better now since the camera in their faces might have given a lot of pressure..🙁
@@notminghao I fortunately never experienced this situation and hopefully never will but I think all of them will be fine again. But you probably know the saying that time heals all wounds. They will for sure miss him forever but they will be ok again. Look at SHINee. They are surely missing Jonghyun every day but they are doing fine as far as we know.
I know what you mean though. It was for sure difficult for them to do the show but on the other hand maybe it was for the best. To have something to do and occupy your mind a little bit.
I guess it helps when they are all together as well and giving each other some sort of strength.
Joohoney really looked sad ...but I cant imagine how hard it is for the Astro members.
@@Niki91-HR Not only Astro members, but his family...close friends. I can't even imagine how hard has to be for MoonSua, and SinB....godness, those two were lifelong friends, like actual friends since childhood. SinB and MoonBin were way closer than MoonSua and MoonBIn...i know they were brother and sister but they said until Sua debuted, they weren't that close to eachother. Well due MoonBin being already in group and Sua to train 10 years...
Since i can't do nothing, i really hope there is someone beside SinB and MoonSua al the time....mounrning can be critical for someone
@@K-PopGamesWithSoulMirae ok I dont know who SinB is...at least not from reading the name. 😅
Sure it is hard for his family too. Not denying that. We just talked about the idols and industry.
Bless you, Joohoney, repect that they could do this 🖤
While I watching yesterday Mcountdown, my mother ask me what both MCs talking about, once I started to translate the first sentence, I already cry, and the heart pain made me cannot keep translate to my mom.. 😭😭
I broke down crying when I saw the news. Didn't wanna believe it was true but I found out by looking at Astro's account and the minute I started seeing the news spread everywhere my heart dropped. I couldn't breathe and started shaking really bad because he was my bias and I've loved that boy for like 4 or 5 years and knowing he's gone ripped me to pieces 💔💔 wish it wasn't true 😓🕊 moonbinie we love you sm and hope you shine the brightest in the sky tonight 🫶🏾.
Hahahah 😂😂
@@LisaGaming117 What's so funny about that?
You could see how heartbroken Jooheon was... trying so hard not to cry. I cried this day until I fell asleep, I still miss Bin so much, can't imagine how his friends were feeling... RIP
I don't know why his passing deeply saddens me when I only know him casually. RIP Moonbin I hope you are at peace wherever you are.
Ahh Jooheon looks.he has been crying already and is devastated 😢😢,
Still can’t believe that the boy with the biggest brightest purest smile has left this world 😢😢
Jooheon was visibly hurt.. he is truly devastated by this news by his eyes and face u can understand..
I'm back exactly one year later and I still cannot believe that Moonbin left us so soon. I never really was a fan of ASTRO and I never found out about Moonbin until it was too late. Yet the news still shocked me. Rest In Peace Moonbin, keep flying high.
MONSTA X ERA MUY BUENOS AMIGOS CON MOONBIN. QUE TRISTEZA, DESCANSA EN PAZ.
When ever I rewatch this video I always get teary eyed
To think of how much Moonbin's most beautiful smile brightens anyone's mood and day, of his cheerful self everywhere we see him, it's so heartbreaking to found out how much he hides how weak he is and how much he has been struggling, smiling just for us not to worry. ~ But for me (and for us) he is the strongest. He is a gem, a genuine treasure, whom I know will be in our hearts and memories forever ❤️
Shine the brightest star Moonbin!
Condolences to the bereaved family and my co-Aroha 🙏
Se les ve a los dos como si hubieran llorado mucho 😭
Sii tienen cansaditos los ojos 😢
Obvio no van a estar sonrientes o felices
I'm not an Aroha I've just known Astro for two years and I don't watch much of their content but I don't know why my heart broke into pieces. Also the bgm at the ending with his smiling face literally made me cry. You'll always be remembered Binnie
You aint alone. I am not a fan either, casually listened to some Astro songs and here and there Moonbin or Sanha or Eunwoo would appear in things I like to watch but thats it. And still it shocked me completely. I actually couldnt really sleep last night.
I guess he was just that type of person, regardless if you were a fan of his music, who captured people just by his personality and charm.
You can tell he'd been crying prior to this
Jooheon looks like he cried and was about to cry at any moment :( my heart goes out to everyone who was affected by this sudden news
still can’t believe out moon has left us. Moonbin presence had such effects in the kpop industry. Just want to say that idols are human too. Our beloved moon has recover and will shine brighter than ever🕊️💙 Astro will always be OT5💙
U can see it on Jooheon’s face, Monsta X and ASTRO were friends, I can tell he’s hurting, I’m gonna miss Moonbin sm..
rest in peace to our moonbin. fly high, sweet one 🤍🩵
주헌님이랑 친하지 않았나..? 표정에,말투에 담긴 슬픔이 화면 밖까지 전해져서 더더 맘이 저릿해집니다.빈아 너의 선택이 후회 남지 않길 진심으로 바래,
Me duele ver a Joohoney así y lamento el dolor que estan sintiendo todos... Un fuerte abrazo a todas las Aroha 🫂.
Por que? El conocia a moonbin?
@@meljisweet sí, todos los integrantes de Monsta X eran amigos de él 😔...
you don't need to be a fan to be completely heartbroken by this, fly high angel
till this day i cant believe that he is gone its honestly heartbreaking :((((((((
Both look so sad, but the guy looks so devastated. His eyes and dark circles easily tell. This is so heartbreaking 😭😭😭😭
monsta x was friends with Moonbin look at Jooheon's swollen eyes. I can't believe they made him go live even after what happened
Rest in peace Moonbin 😭🕊️
I am an army, never stanned astro... But I couldn't stop crying since I heard this. Just look at those pictures.. Who is so cruel to hurt such an innocent person
Same.. I'm just crying since I heard the news 🥺🥺
April 19 when he passed away, that was 2 days ago. Look how fast the night changes, it happen pretty fast. Still can't believe that you are no longer in this world. I hope you may find peace & real happiness where ever you are right now. Still take care of your sister Sua even if she no longer see you now. All your hardwork in this world will be forever remember. Thank you for making us happy, Binnie. We will miss you. Rest well in paradise. 🥺🤍
I honestly still can’t believe it. He was such a lovely person, and is really talented. The sudden passing of his is really heartbreaking for many arohas and nonfans. Rest in peace, Moonbin. You are loved and will be remembered. 🤍
You can clearly see their sadness in their eyes.. it makes me so sad even if I don’t know Astro well. It’s just heartbreaking when a young life is cut short because of suicide. I hope he is free now. Rest in peace mate!
Poor Jooheon. I'm amazed he was able to stay composed.
The sorrow on Jooheon's face says it all 🥺
While watching this I cried so much, I can’t even explain. May he rest in peace 🕊️😭
Life is so unpredictable. Couldn't believe that we have to address him in the past tense from now on. I'm mourning over his loss but his beautiful smile is assuring me that he's fine over there. You must have been through much so now *RIP MOONBIN!* Hope we meet again one day!
Questo ragazzo aveva diritto di vivere la propria vita 💗💗💗
주헌이 울음을 머금는 게 보이네 동고동락했던 동료가 떠나간 기분이 어떨지 감히 상상조차 할 수 없는데 다들 마음 잘 추스리길 바랍니다...
he used to be such a bubbly person, it really makes u question everything and every other idol's smiles. may he rest in peace and i hope this never happens again from the bottom of my heart.
he had the biggest most beautiful smile, I don’t understand 😭😭may he rest in peace🕊️
moonie became the brightest star among stars in the sky i still couldnt compose my self i still cant believe i wont hear your sweet voice your laugh and giggles but still thank you for existing in this world i will miss your smile your giggles
it was like a bolt in the sky.. You left a big sadness shared by all.
i may have never met you, but i had tears in my eyes..knowing you have gone... your smile and cheekiness would be always in my memory..
another star gone to heaven..shine brigth Moonbin
RIP young soul
They sound absolutely heartbroken. I hope that our moonbin will fly high and be at peace rather than pain. Everyone, let’s protect our idols. They dont deserve the hate we give
His news shocked me to the core, although I'm not a fan of Astro but I love their music, but watching this made tear up a lot, condolences and prayers to his family, especially his sister Moon Sua, friends and Astro members🕊🕊🤍🤍❤❤🫂🫂🫂
My condolences to every Aroha out there. Also sending my love to Moonbinnie's family, his friends and members. And also to Jooheon and Miyeon, sorry that Mnet made them put on a show on the day of Moonbin's passing. I know Jooheon was his friend. it must have been so hard for him. Rest peacefully.
I can't help crying. I know he shouldn't be remembered because of his decease but astro was one of the first kpop groups I knew and those news hit me so hard. Rest well Moonbin.
It still feels surreal even now
This is so heartbreaking, I can’t control my tears. I’m still in disbelief… I hope he’s resting well and that he’s in a better place. You will be remembered forever Moonbin 🕊️
MBB are here for you AROHA🥺 Bin-ah always had the best smiles and never failed to make those around him laugh. I loved watching him grow as an artist and wanted so badly to see his next ten years. We all did. He is beautiful moon in the starry sky now. May he find peace and rest knowing he was loved, will continue to be loved
Im so happy that they are finally talking about it.... somehow... its still much work do in this industry... there are too many people with the same dream and most of them suffering.. firs tthey don't have enough work then if they get famouse at all its far too much work. Please treat your artists with respect as fans. Remember you never know what someone if going through we only know what people want to show.
눈물이 멈추질 않네요 ~
이렇게 빨리 떠났지만 미소와 무대를 볼 수 없지만 고마웠어요 삼가고인의 명복을 빕니다 저는 오빠가 최애라서 너무 행복했고 아로하라서 행복했어요 이제는 걱정, 불안 다 버리고 편히 쉬쉬기를 바랄게요 많이 고마웠어요 가족들, 멤버들, 팬들이 마음정리하는데 시간이 오래 걸리겠지만 이제는 푹쉬세요 잠시나마 웃는모습을 보여주셔셔 감사하고 오빠의 아픔이 너무나 컸단걸 안좋은 선택을 했다는 것도 너무 팬으로서 마음이 아파요 최애라서 태어나줘서 데뷔해주셔서 진짜 고마웠어요 잘가요 일찍 별이 되어버렸지만 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Awww Joohoney it must of been so hard for him to keep working and say those words on stage😭😭😭
Such a beautiful smile and gone forever. I was heartbroken when I saw this yesterday
Смотрю и все равно не могу поверить, что все это реальность. Только недавно он выступал, несколько дней назад выложил тикток. Он такой улыбчивый, тёплый, яркий... как это больно. Надеюсь, что теперь он действительно счастлив и обрёл покой.
Boys are always believed to be strong, non-expressing, and hiding emotions. I think that is what Moonbin had been going through, suppressing emotions and suddenly taking this step out of depression.😔
I really wish I could be the one to help him get out of this sadness, but it's too late now.😢😭
May Sua and Moonbin's family and friends receive the strength and courage to get through this time. All I am worried about is what feelings Sua would be going through! 😔😔
Rest In Peace, Moon Bin. We love you.
I was not a follower of Astro, but I loved Moon Bin and Moon Sua's adorable sibling relationship. I am really broken right now😔😭
jooheon's eyes are red from crying
Everyone was feeling broke fr. Even today i'm still refusing he's gone. It's hard but keep trying to accept it. 💔
Notice how it's always idols with big smiles. It is true,that big smiles hide the sadness inside. 😢 I am so sad for him. I wish we could turn back the time and save him. 💔🕊
I really hope the members of Shinee, Kara, and FX are helping Astro through this traumatic and difficult time in their lives. They must understand what it is like to have gone through this and to have had it happen so publicly. I can’t imagine what it’s like to to mourn someone in the public eye. I hope Astro take as long as they need to heal and mourn Moonbin, we don’t care how long they stay on break, just know that the fans will be here when you’re able to return.
Till now from yesterday,I have no appetite,, I cannot sleep ,,, I’m extremely sad & heartbroken
They both were trying so hard not to cry😢
I told my mom that Moonbin is my bias and he was dead. And she ask me why did he die?And what happen with him? i told her he suicide and i start crying, then she hugs me and comforts me really well. She said she knew i'm a big fan of Kpop so she understanded my feeling. And she hope Moonbin flies high and have a great new life with new world. Arohas all around the world will remember your bright smile, your aegyo, your voice and everything abt you. We all always and forever keep you in our memories and heart too🤍Our Moonbin oppa you tired for a long time and now you can rest. You should remember that we always stay by your side because we're your Arohas for Astro🫀💖
Mcs really had such a difficult time. They worked hard. It hurts so much... Jooheon, I know this was too difficult. You lost a friend. I'm so sorry you had to go through this
My heart goes out to all of you at countdown. Pray you'll find healing 🙏😢❤
I cried watching this. I can't imagine the pain Bin went through. Rest in paradise MoonBin. Forever loved but never forgotten. Fly high. 🕊
This is such a devastating news, like I barely know what he’s like but his smile is the brightest smile I’ve ever seen in any male idol ever that it is unthinkable that he’d be gone so young
Knowing that Miyeon is really bubbly she looks really sad like ive never seen her like that before
Wow not 1 tear in sight on stage. I would be 😢& I don’t even know him. May he rest in peace 🙏🤍🕯️🕊️
They both looked like they were gonna start crying. 😢
I watched this Live online. It was really sad even though I don't speak Korean. Thanks for the subtitles.
It’s so sad to hear this I never heard about moonbin but yet awail ago I was seeing how talented loving he was it’s realy sad 😢 my condolences to the family and friends and also the fans
Somehow this STILL doesn't feel real....
How could someone with such a bright, bright smile just be.... Gone?
Habibi I’m crying
my condolences to his family, may he rest in peace ❤
Jooheon's eyes.... Just like mine...i can't stop crying.. Moonbin-sshi my dear bias rest in peace .. We will love and remember you forever ❤️💐
May his soul rest in peace 😭 I miss him so much ❤️
All of them look so sad I'm crying 😭
im not crying you are. R.I.P we will love you forever.💖😣😖
His passing really... It seems like it shocked all of us...
Even when i am not an Astro fan, (though i liked them and their music) i am still in denial.
It's a real tragedy to say the least!
R. I. P. Moonbin.. i really really hope that you are in a better place... God bless you all.
I wish all the best to his family and friends and anyone who is struggling right now. 🙏
If you think there is no way out, you are wrong. There is always another way, a better way. Please talk to someone.
Someone out there wants to listen and be there for you! Please don't give up your hope, because it CAN be different.
And likewise, someone out there needs YOU right now. Go and listen. ❤
Why can't i stop crying😔its really devastating
Rest in peace moonbin you beautiful man ❤️💜❤️💜❤️💜❤️🇬🇧
Today is the saddest day since I've been into kpop. Jesus Christ, my heart hurts so much. I will miss you Moon 🌙 bin. We love you. Thank you.
Moonbin was with arohas when we need him but when he needed us the most we weren't there for him it's killing me inside we weren't there for him I'm so sorry Binnie hope your happy up there
I just burst into tears. I love you Monnbin and R.I.P angel. You will forever live on in Arohas heart.
missing him so so much 💔 he'll forever be remembered :(( rest well binnie 🫂