Am I the only one who thinks she does a great job? Well it's not like the studio version, you can hear the emotion in her voice, making up for the faults. And not to mention this is her first live performance. She must've been really nervous and she still managed to do so well.
yeah, there's a great raw energy behind her vocals in this performance. it sounds more unfiltered that way, and i love hearing that rough emotionality in a live performance, whether or not it's exactly like the original song.
I dont get it. How can you NOT like this? Aya Hirano is 1) SUPER cute 2) Has a great voice and 3) SHe's playing the guitar! I have seen the chord progression cause I wanted to learn it. It is the most INSANE thing I've ever seen. No joke. Why do haters hate? 'God Knows' That was a bad pun, I'm sorry
Am I like the only one that noticed she had likely just learnt how to play this on a Rhythm guitar? She had to keep looking at her finger placement. That was likely what was effecting her voice.
Ya know, I don't give a crap what Aya does in her personal life. She's talented, beautiful, and I could listen to her music all day. Just cause she sleeps with her band members doesn't make her a bad person. Aya's one of those people who truly deserves better treatment than some people give her. Your fans love you, Aya, for who you are. We support you all the way. Also, welcome back to the seiyuu and music business!
God has blessed her in her performance, she's also a fellow Christian, I assume. In the bonus features of The Melancholy Of Haruhi Suzumiya, she's playing a church hymn on the piano and is also wearing a cross so it makes perfect sense to me. She's so adorable and very friendly! God bless her! God KNOWS!!
when someone sings live, it ALWAYS sounds different then it does in a recording studio. Bleach219 is right, being in front of hundreds of people is REALLY stressful. give her a break, she still does it better than any of us would.
Wow so this is a real idol, huh? I thought they were just urban legends in anime lol. A nice breath of tranquility rushes down my spine knowing I'm not as crazed an anime maniac as I thought. I can feel the essence of Kanon Nakagawa flowing through her :3
Although she does singing jobs, her main works is voice acting. She became quite famous after landing the role of voicing Haruhi Suzumiya. She also used to voice Lucy from Fairy tail.
That vibrato is from being tired and and trying to force herself to breathe when her chest is burning for singing nonstop for 30 to 45 minutes at super high energy.
People...she's playing a guitar while singing in real time. It's not like most usa singers who have a recording that sings for them while they dance and just move their lips.
i love how in japan everyone is quiet when someone is up onstage and is singing when inn america everyone is screaming and yelling. But i can't complain becuase iv been to alot of great american concerts :3
also the anime version was produced in a recording studio. = no nerves = no competing with crowd noise = no competing with band in bg = being able to hear yourself
the best thing about this is that even haruhi's voice actress is hot. and Aya Hirano could EASILY pull off a real life look-alike of Haruhi. which would be just awsome cause not only would she look like her and be hot, but also sound like her, unlike so many other voice actors who look nothing like who they are voicing
@Santazclausz It´s in Japan. About 60 miles from Hiroshima. (also if your from europe it´s about 150km from hiroshima) From Hiroshima you just need to walk/drive to west. About 250 miles from tokyo (500km) Does that help.
At least I can infer that she was really singing and that band was really playing. I wasn't particularly blown away by that, but if I'm ever in Japan and they're playing in the same town I'm in, or if they come to Denver, hell I'll buy tickets.
![[涼宮ハルヒの激奏][最強パレパレード][Live]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P3QHR8uxaqk/mqdefault.jpg)
客なんて関係ねぇ
私の歌をか聞けって感じが
俺は好きだな、
手を抜かずに全力でやってるように見える。これはこれで良い。
Am I the only one who thinks she does a great job? Well it's not like the studio version, you can hear the emotion in her voice, making up for the faults. And not to mention this is her first live performance. She must've been really nervous and she still managed to do so well.
Tsuntaku agreed
monogatari fan , i see!
Well ugh her voice is too forceful
yeah, there's a great raw energy behind her vocals in this performance. it sounds more unfiltered that way, and i love hearing that rough emotionality in a live performance, whether or not it's exactly like the original song.
For me it's good from beginning to the end.
ビブラートの癖が凄い（千鳥）
コナちぃず ワロタww
やのちん。 ワロタにwつけんな
no entiendo nada .
Pero buena esa
7チャン ワロタにwつけちゃダメなの？
7チャン 草にwがダメだったんじゃない？
もとはネタコメだから
I dont get it. How can you NOT like this? Aya Hirano is 1) SUPER cute 2) Has a great voice and 3) SHe's playing the guitar! I have seen the chord progression cause I wanted to learn it. It is the most INSANE thing I've ever seen. No joke.
Why do haters hate? 'God Knows'
That was a bad pun, I'm sorry
なんか最初から中盤までう～んって感じだったけど「傷跡なぞるー！」で鳥肌立ったから高評価
Clicked this on a whim. I do not know what she's singing, but this sounds amazing.
ビブラートの破壊力
Am I like the only one that noticed she had likely just learnt how to play this on a Rhythm guitar? She had to keep looking at her finger placement. That was likely what was effecting her voice.
yes, and this make her looks so cute.. know what i mean?
Ya know, I don't give a crap what Aya does in her personal life. She's talented, beautiful, and I could listen to her music all day. Just cause she sleeps with her band members doesn't make her a bad person. Aya's one of those people who truly deserves better treatment than some people give her.
Your fans love you, Aya, for who you are. We support you all the way.
Also, welcome back to the seiyuu and music business!
かぁわぁいたぁぁぁぁあ↑(!?)
笑ったww
ハーフ歌大好き 草
歌だけに集中してる訳じゃないし、こんなスタミナ使うんだから
、音程ずれても仕方ないと思うけど
たしかに
無理矢理かけまくる
ビブラートは
ちょっとアレですね。。。
God has blessed her in her performance, she's also a fellow Christian, I assume. In the bonus features of The Melancholy Of Haruhi Suzumiya, she's playing a church hymn on the piano and is also wearing a cross so it makes perfect sense to me. She's so adorable and very friendly! God bless her! God KNOWS!!
„she's also a fellow Christian, I assume“
dude…wtf
このGod knows...は涼宮ハルヒではなく、平野綾のGod knows...だね
プライベートの問題でアーティストを否定するのは悲しいな……。作品は作品として判断しないと、勿体なくないかな？
God Knows this song Rocks!!!
Hirano Aya actually playing the guitar.
Respect.
i love aya hirano so much....i love her voice...
ちゃんと歌ってくれてるからそれだけでもいい
when someone sings live, it ALWAYS sounds different then it does in a recording studio. Bleach219 is right, being in front of hundreds of people is REALLY stressful. give her a break, she still does it better than any of us would.
Hahaha love that the glow sticks were all synchronized
もう少しビブラート抑えた方がいいwwww
when she is singing live i feel my ears burst, but when i just hear her i can't stop listening
Wow so this is a real idol, huh? I thought they were just urban legends in anime lol. A nice breath of tranquility rushes down my spine knowing I'm not as crazed an anime maniac as I thought. I can feel the essence of Kanon Nakagawa flowing through her :3
Although she does singing jobs, her main works is voice acting. She became quite famous after landing the role of voicing Haruhi Suzumiya. She also used to voice Lucy from Fairy tail.
批判してる奴可哀想だな。
ハルヒの声優がギター持ってgodknows歌い始めるってとんでもない事だったんだぞ。
ライブアライブ観て現場行った奴にしか分からん感動があった。
↗↘↗↘↗↘↗↘↗↘
such a fierce tremolo
Ayaちゃん最高！！
コメントから当時アニメを見ていた人かどうかわかってしまう
Still hear it
Aya es la mejor!! la amo.
I was in the second row on the far right side so I had an amazing view of this Goddess
Best Song Ever !!!!!!!!!
これでもなんかいいなーと思う。
シーンがちゃんと脳内再生されるから。
ビブラートの事はオブラートに包もうぜ…(？)
Ryo Wada ビ〜ブ〜ラ〜ト⤴か〜け〜す〜ぎ〜⤵︎
Ryo Wada 包んでやったぜ！(｀･ω･´)ｼｬｷｰﾝ
the melancholy of haruhi suzumiya is good i wish there will be season 3, is it weird for me that I enjoy the endless 8?
待って、久々に見たけど…
最初の気持ち悪いのビブラート出そうとしてたの？
平野綾の他の曲…ビブラートなんて入ってないもんな…
The amount of vibration in her voice is too darn high that's why I give it a 9/10
この人ビブラート調整出来てない
坂田銅時 それ
坂田銅時 それ！いらないとこでもやっちゃってる
坂田銅時 u amen hermano
このビブラート普通と思ってたらまぁやばいぞ……
รักน่ะค่ะaya จุ๊ปๆๆ เนื้อหาดีมากๆๆ ช๊อบชอบ
Should've been wearing a bunnygirl costume
+ yellow ribbon
Man, I really would like that! :'/
She is Haruhi, there is a difference betwen studio version and live concert version. Btw she is the voice actress for Haruhi. Facts are fun.
今度音楽の授業でこれ歌う
คนดูนี่เค้า เป็นน้ำหนึีงใจเดียวกันจริงๆ คนละสไตล์กับบ้านเราเลย ต่างคนต่างชูอะไรก็ไม่รุ 55
why is her voice trembaling is it because she playing her instrument or is its vibration? either way this is beast!!!!!!!!!!!!
she's trying too hard to j-rock
+Samuel Sain Thanks so much
I think people are not realizing the major difference between singing in a ecording studio, where it was done for the anime, and singing live
She sounds more like Konata from Lucky Star singing Haruhi's song.
Daichi82 It kinda makes sense seeing how Konata is a fan of Haruhi
aya!! ganbatte !~!!! release aya museum soon :) i cant wait to hear it!!! and start singing again!!!~
なんか違う…
出だしから鳥肌でたー
Amazing! Aya is so cute... (*_*)
ไทยทั่วโลก เกือบทุกคลิปเลย (มาจาก Maboy 55)
にしおかすみこ
ちょっと似ててワロタw
really putting that vibrato when she sings...
ギターかっこよすぎやろｗｗ
That vibrato is from being tired and and trying to force herself to breathe when her chest is burning for singing nonstop for 30 to 45 minutes at super high energy.
音外しすぎてて原曲とかけ離れてたのが残念。
I agree, it was so awesome! I was like 5 rows from the front too!
крутотень же ;)
236 people got erased from existence by Haruhi, then forced into another dimension by Nagato.
ギターうますぎやろ、、、
This is the voice actor for Haruhi, so she sang the song in the anime.
君の声は本当に可愛いな!
どうしたwwww
DO YOON KIM それな
+isobe hirohito 多分外国人の方が頑張って日本語でコメしたのかと
People...she's playing a guitar while singing in real time. It's not like most usa singers who have a recording that sings for them while they dance and just move their lips.
It's actually not that bad :)
Haruhi Suzumiya brought me here ;-; I love it. xD
ビブラートしつつキーずれるwww
i love how in japan everyone is quiet when someone is up onstage and is singing when inn america everyone is screaming and yelling. But i can't complain becuase iv been to alot of great american concerts :3
ド派手な演歌
Wow, while I was listening to this I ran into someone on a completely unrelated forum named "Aya Hirano". She really is god o.o watching over me ;).
May'n聴いた後にこれは…
それは禁句w
@Regul0n she is also the voice of Lucy Heartfilla from Fairy Tail.
i think shes Nervous
Japan is kicking ass these days! Music, Anime, Samsung!
アニメのほうがいいわｗｗｗｗ
確かに。それはちょっと分かる
パン人間 ギター弾いてるししょうがないんじゃない？
アニメと現実は違うからな
アニメで音もガチガチの観るより やっぱライヴが一番いい！感動した（T T
緊張してるんだよ
เจ๋ง เสียงดีมากคร๊าฟ ^w^ เหมียวๆ
かわいいのにロング似合わないな…にしおかすみこに見えてしまう
also the anime version was produced in a recording studio.
= no nerves
= no competing with crowd noise
= no competing with band in bg
= being able to hear yourself
ビブラートうざすぎわろた
後付け加えると色々音程ずれててカラオケで採点されたら酷そう。ビブラートは神レベルだと思うけど(数的に)
闇の底王、全敗の弱者 ワロタwwww
ギター弾くのに一杯一杯で音程外しまくりな感じ？
ビブラートは、他のコメにある様に美輪明宏が憑依してると思いたいｗ
てか、ハンチング帽のギタリストが下手で…(。-`ω´-)ﾝｰ
the best thing about this is that even haruhi's voice actress is hot. and Aya Hirano could EASILY pull off a real life look-alike of Haruhi.
which would be just awsome cause not only would she look like her and be hot, but also sound like her, unlike so many other voice actors who look nothing like who they are voicing
この人、何かやらかしたの？
the vibration on her voice...
なんでもかんでもビブラートかければいいってもんじゃないんですぞ
Those guys all wearing multiple shirts to play a gig, they must be nuts ;<
I adore this song though :D
緊張で声震えてるとかじゃないん？w
崖っぷちの上のポニョ すごい震えとるやんww
喉だけ痙攣しとるんやろwww
I know she's the voice actress for haruhi, just remember, Haruhi was also performing live, and for the first time. Jokes are also fun.
緊張とギタボで歌がね…リードはしかたない、プロでもけっこう難しいらしいし、それ弾くのがプロなんだけどね笑
本当に可愛い！！！
音楽評論家多くてワロタ
日本音楽界の未来は安泰だな
@Santazclausz It´s in Japan. About 60 miles from Hiroshima. (also if your from europe it´s about 150km from hiroshima) From Hiroshima you just need to walk/drive to west.
About 250 miles from tokyo (500km)
Does that help.
歌以前に演奏陣がひでぇ. . .
At least I can infer that she was really singing and that band was really playing. I wasn't particularly blown away by that, but if I'm ever in Japan and they're playing in the same town I'm in, or if they come to Denver, hell I'll buy tickets.
THE BASSIST DID NOTHING WRONG
Unas de mis canciones favoritas es God Knows
ไหนใครคนไทยยกมือหน่อย 0/
ผมคับ
0/ หนุด้วย
+Paktanat Nantipak 0/
+Paktanat Nantipak 0/
เช่นกันครับ
I do not know better.
See "God knows" Live ... or watch the anime ...
I LOVE THIS THEME!
ビブラートwww
her voice tho... awesome