슴덕은 아닌데 샤이니랑 f(x)는 유독 좋았다 또래라 그런지 특유의 분위기 덕인지 모르겠지만ㅋㅋㅋ 어쩔 땐 내 첫사랑들 같기도 하고 또 어쩔 땐 내 청춘 같기도 하고ㅋㅋㅋ 이렇게나 좋은 가수들 만날 수 있었던 것도 축복 받은 일이겠지 여전히 참 고맙고 많이 사랑해 얘들아
I loved fx since their debut and i love they are super popular in 2010s when they are in usa! It sucked kpop wasn't as big back then and fx would be big like right now but just kpop timing became big late 2010s @@Awakening_Sunshine
Amber fits right in with SHINee xDD I swear, until she sang I thought "Did Jonghyun ever wear his hair like that? No... Onew didn't either... Oh... OH! It's Amber!" xD
This was so long ago, but still fun to watch. 💜 how Amber & Minho matched their pants. They are always cute together. Especially when they sing the llama song.
It hurts!! ⚘Miss jonghyun and sulli 💐😔 No one knows how the future is ...only thing u can do is JUST SUPPORT AND LOVE ,do not pressure or mind ur own business don't butt in other's choices.🍁 🍁Don't shame others in name of criticism.🍁🍁
I miss f(shinee)..i miss this kind of collaboration within sm artist..todays sm artist would never cause it would probably end up with some stupid rumors urghh
Who is watching this? after Sulli’s suicide Jonghyun and Sulli rest in pice✨You both will be missed!! May you both finde happiness and pice, in your next life💜 #RipSulli
2 groups that sm failed to promote...shinee deserve better..and fx deserved better..its sad that fx disbanded without celebrating 10yr anniversary with their fans
![[Fx f (x)] - The first wisdom teeth @ Popular Inkigayo 130728](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kuzlTs2I8FA/mqdefault.jpg)
sm 개성의 끝판왕 두 그룹
SHINEE AND F(X) ARE MY FAVORITE GROUPS FROM SM . I REALLY MISS THIS ERA
여긴 아직 닿지않았구나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 근데 진짜 샤이니랑 에프엑스 보고싶다ㅠㅠ 다들 잘지내길 ! 언젠간 다 만나자 추억이돼줘서 고마워
sm 특유의 색채와 장르를 대표하는 보이그룹과 걸그룹의 콜라보.
슴덕은 아닌데 샤이니랑 f(x)는 유독 좋았다 또래라 그런지 특유의 분위기 덕인지 모르겠지만ㅋㅋㅋ 어쩔 땐 내 첫사랑들 같기도 하고 또 어쩔 땐 내 청춘 같기도 하고ㅋㅋㅋ 이렇게나 좋은 가수들 만날 수 있었던 것도 축복 받은 일이겠지 여전히 참 고맙고 많이 사랑해 얘들아
진심.. 스엠 색깔 뚜렷한 두 그룹인데 진짜 .. 뭐랄까 풋풋한 하이틴에 그런 .. 그립다진짜
SM doesn't have groups like SHINee and f(x)!! They are gems that cannot be duplicated!
f(x) could have been as successful as SHINee if SM hadn’t mismanaged them
I loved fx since their debut and i love they are super popular in 2010s when they are in usa! It sucked kpop wasn't as big back then and fx would be big like right now but just kpop timing became big late 2010s @@Awakening_Sunshine
Taestal's high note 😭
But SHINee feels empty without Jinki and Jonghyun... and I miss Sulli 😢
Now they’re both gone :(
guys, i know what happened, the comment was way before it, please refrain to comment anything that could be hurtful or triggering, thank you! ❤
@@theshineeworld 💚💙💚💙💚
One of the best SM group collabs. Would have been better if SHINEe was complete.
karixie at that time where was john hyun (sorry for my spelling)
Where was Jonghyun?
Indah sari nastiti He had a leg injury at the time and sat out some performances
My baby jonghyun😢😭
@@cmq23 what bout onew?
진짜 샤이니도 에프엑스도 여전히 최고야
Amber fits right in with SHINee xDD I swear, until she sang I thought "Did Jonghyun ever wear his hair like that? No... Onew didn't either... Oh... OH! It's Amber!" xD
Once Jonghyun joked that the way he did his hair made him look like Amber 😂
me too lmao i paused the video to try to figure out who that is then realized when she sang lol
어렸을때 좋아하던 가수들 너무 뭉클하네
Out of all SM's collaborations, f(SHINee) are the cutest and the most matched. 💙
可惜的是鐘鉉與雪利已經不在世上了！她他們都在天上當天使👼🏻🙆🏻♂️
This is hurt to see now
:")
:(
A lot😢😢
Right
😭😭
2023 still vibing ❤️ sulli 😭
I wish fx was still active , Shinee and them have so much in common.. it would be iconic if they collaborated in 2023 😭
이런 무대가 있었구나... 다들 풋풋하고 너무 예쁘다
1:27 ย้อนกลับมาดูช็อตนี้ทีไรก็หยุดยิ้มไม่ได้ตลอด><
จังหวะคีย์แอบมองแทมินคือน่ารักมาก มองด้วยสายตาเอ็นดูวว55
진리야 너무 사랑스럽다..
왜 각각 그룹에서 한명씩 세상을 떠나야 했을까....안타깝다.
THIS MADE MY DAY. If this was a real group of 5 boys and 5 girls YOU BEST KNOW I WOULD BE THEIR NUMBER ONE FAN. #f(shinee)
When I become a Kpop star I'm gonna be in a group with boys and girls 😉 look forward to it. ... (Jk I wish)
Kxel Lol. It might happen tho
@@kxel9871 how are you now lol ?
Wish boy groups and girl groups did these kind of collabs now
Literally what I was about to say like imagine if NCT and aespa or SKZ and ITZY did something like this😭
종현 설리 생각하면 눈물부터난다
Fave brother sister group
And both of the group have to lost their members😢
Omg sad :((
9년 전이라는게 더 충격적이다 벌써.....
The fact that two of these angels are up in heaven now 😔😭
😔😔
Miss it when kpop was like this..... now we barely get news of idols interacting without crazy fans intervening with their opinions.
언제쯤 두 그룹이 함께하는 무대를 볼 수 있는 건지..
maybe never
2020 still watching... Missing Jong Hyun and Sulli ❣️
설리야 웃는 모습이 이렇게이쁜데.. 다시볼수가 없어 너무 슬프다
I really want to see f(shinee) again 😭😭😭
내가 제일 사랑하는 두 그룹
Bring me back to those days please
I'm busting into tears I used to watch this when I was 12 and this just makes me so happy
2000년대 후반갬성이.. 최고임.. 다같이 즐김.
지금은 너무 노래던 애들이던 상업적이라 싫음
This was so long ago, but still fun to watch.
💜 how Amber & Minho matched their pants. They are always cute together. Especially when they sing the llama song.
They look so cute..
Stages like this will be missed!
i miss jonghyun and sulli :(
넘 좋아서 눈물 난다...ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
It hurts!! ⚘Miss jonghyun and sulli 💐😔
No one knows how the future is ...only thing u can do is JUST SUPPORT AND LOVE ,do not pressure or mind ur own business don't butt in other's choices.🍁
🍁Don't shame others in name of criticism.🍁🍁
I miss them together, it hurt the fact that we could not see 10 of them together again
Best collaboration f (shinee ) forever
Sulli looks so cute here. One of my favorite collab performances ever.
보고싶다 진짜
I miss f(shinee)..i miss this kind of collaboration within sm artist..todays sm artist would never cause it would probably end up with some stupid rumors urghh
*HELLO* angel & guardian of heaven Sulli & Jonghyun 😇😇
온유랑 종현이가 없어서 아쉽지만 샤이니 함수 넘 상큼하다❤
왜 없어요?
For a moment I thought Amber was Jonghyun😅💚
I'm crying and fangirling like crazy at the same time
Sulli so pretty and cute :)
사랑스럽다 진리야
알고리즘 뜰때까지 존버
두그룹이 합동무대하는걸 너무 보고싶다
We see them smiling just for us, but deep down in the heart two of them, its a terrible feeling
They were so young and cute! Miss their innocence!
Whoah! Legit na live gyud! Those were the days~ RIP Jonghyun and Sulli. ❤❤❤
크리스탈 너무 귀엽다ㅠㅠ
Jonghyun and Sully 😢😇😇
Came back here cuz life is hard these days 😊🤍
Who is watching this? after Sulli’s suicide
Jonghyun and Sulli rest in pice✨You both will be missed!!
May you both finde happiness and pice, in your next life💜
#RipSulli
Hurt much Sulli 😢💔
Dont forget Goo Hara toooo :,(
don’t use her death for likes
I love SHINee and F(x)!!😍😍😍💜💜💜💜
Jonghyung sulli ,,, i don't wanna say goodbay
*Jonghyun
i've been searching for this video in HD for years, thank you sbs for re uploading
여긴 아직 닿지않았구나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 근데 진짜 샤이니선배님이랑 에프엑스선배님 보고싶다ㅠㅠ 다들 잘지내길 ! 언젠간 다 만나자 추억이돼줘서 고마워
설리 얼굴 미쳤어
남매그룹 너무 이뻐서 눈물나네 ㅠㅠ
Está colaboración es simplemente hermosa
OMG Taestal's high note😍
I miss this moment
I miss this kpop vibes😭💕
Miss them
MIN STAL! ❤❤❤
when minho was still a fetus
And Taemin 😅
my 2nd gen heart is living for this 💖💖
2 groups that sm failed to promote...shinee deserve better..and fx deserved better..its sad that fx disbanded without celebrating 10yr anniversary with their fans
Omg love so much them f(x) and Shinee and so much Miss them
SM entertainment only have best audition ...never failure even after 2018 it will continue😉
남매그룹 케미 쩔었지 ㅠ
my KRYSTAL 💗 MINHO!!!
MinStal
I so love Fx n SHINee collaboration
This beat always makes me feel excited
I need their collaboration again
I LOVE MINHO . AMBER AND MINHO RAPPING TOGETHER WAS AWESOME. I LOVE U MINHO😘😄
My fav collaboration ❤️
Minho and Krystal so ciu
pretty victoria! good job!
아이 예뻐
F(shinee) 💜💎
저때도 두명이 빠졌었구나 지금도 두명 빠졌잖아 ㅠㅠㅠ 설리 웃는 모습이 귀엽고 예쁜데 그곳에선 편안해요?? 그리고 군에 가 있는 멤버는 3명 ㅠㅠ 샤이니 완전체 빨리 보고싶다 ㅠㅠ
f(x)도 그렇지만 샤이니도 완전체는 더이상 못나오죠...한명이 설리보다 2년정도 먼저 가버려서...
@@ljs3872 나머지 네명은 사람도 아닌가요?? 왜 못나와요?? 한명 빠진 상태에서 앨범도 냈는데요!! 샤이니 완전체 컴백 했었다구요!!!!!!
@@또치딸기 더이상은 완전체가 아니죠 종현이 설리보다 2년 정도 먼저 갔는데 그 논리로 따지면 에프엑스도 카라도 나머지 멤버로만 컴백해도 완전체라는 개소리를 지껄이는거랑 같음ㅇㅇ
@@ljs3872 나머지 네명 진기랑 기범이랑 민호랑 태민이는 샤이니가 아닌가요?? 샤이니를 좋아하는 샤월들도 완천체라고 해요 샤이니랑 에프엑스랑 같나요??
@@또치딸기 그럼 스크린샷 찍어서 증거물로 올려봐요 그리고 나머지 네명은 멤버가 아니라는 소릴 한적이 없는데 왜 지랄이죠? 눈이 삐꾸이신가?
My 1st k pop idol .. times where kpop is growing popularity ..
It herts my heart that sulli and jonghyun I love you I hope I see u one day 💔😭 I hope that y'all are always happy
Omg i miss this era 😭😭
oncr upon a time...
SUJU×SNSD
SHINEE×F (x)
but now..we barely see a collab like these anymore😣
0:50 missing you lots, bb 💕
I'm so impressed by f(x) they sang live on a song that isn't even theirs
2021 still miss f(SHINee)🥺💜💎
Jonghyun I will miss you
Still missing you guys
Now Kim JongHyun and Sulli both past away soo sad :(
😭😭😭💔
TaeMin이랑 Krystal잘 어울리는데♥♥
I need time capsule 😭 miss sulli and Jonghyun 😭miss SHINee and Fx