Tina S - Moonlight Sonata (3rd Movement) REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Tina S Fans....Ludwig van Beethoven Fans....FEELIN' YOU!!! Making her debut on the channel, we have Tina S with her rendition of the 3rd Movement of Ludwig van Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata. How's this one gonna go? Only one way to find out...
Come on in, enjoy the show...I'll see you inside.
Scoring System Guide
10 = Perfection (Unobtainable)
9.0 - 9.9 = Awesome, Amazing
8.0 - 8.9 = Great
7.0 - 7.9 = Really Good
6.0 - 6.9 = Pretty Good
5.0 - 5.9 = O.k.
4.0 - 4.9 = Not So Good
3.0 - 3.9 = Pretty Bad
2.0 - 2.9 = Really Bad
1.0 - 1.9 = Horrible, Awful
0.0 - 0.9 = A Travesty, An Affront To Nature
Link to Original Video Here:
• Ludwig van Beethoven -...
My Twitter: / bassist4aw
My Instagram (I've just started learning how to use it): / davidheretic666
My Patreon Page, where you can view ALL the videos I try to post that TH-cam is forced to block, can be found here:
www.patreon.co...
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. I have no intent on claiming this music for my own, I'm simply reacting to the video and giving my constructive criticism and feedback. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
![THIS WAS INSANITY! Ludwig van Beethoven - Moonlight Sonata ( 3rd Movement ) Tina S Cover [REACTION!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Y4XyukLZRgk/mqdefault.jpg)
Hey there fellow commentators the 9.2 is because she is a 'virtuoso' Hence perfection. It just two flubs although minor they are there. Yet he does not take anything away from her exceptional skills. David is very fair and reasonable for this score. Perfection of play is hard to do live. He recognises her absolute god like ability. Humble and fair in my opinion. She is one of the best players out there and he agrees. He respects her more for the live performance.
She’s such a beast!
I have to disappoint you that even professors who specialize in classical music have watched the video several times and also in slow motion and they say that it is played absolutely flawlessly.
I don't know how you can even say that.
9.2 score sounds right...on a scale of 0 - 9.1
This comment had me dying 😂
For real!
SHut up
She's one of a kind, but sadly she's stopped playing for sake of furthering her education. I hope one day she comes back with all her might!
Ελπίζουμε.....
i dont think she is not gonna touch a guitar again relax even when she studying whatever she needs to learn as far as theory goes i think she did or at least she can perform it.....i mean what students do you know that they are working like company bosses.....
What?! I heard she's working at the Paris Starbucks!
What a dumb broad. Who needs an edumacashion when you can truly shred.
@@sadnairepsn I think you are totally wrong about her being dumb, she studys law...
Someone actually counted the number of notes she played in this 6-minute performance, and she AVERAGED 7 notes per second for the entire 6 minutes!!
That was me. Glad to know I have a fan. LOL
Yep! If i remember correctly it was 2540 notes over the course of about 6 min 8 sec for an average of 7.08 notes per second.... lightning fingers mcgee is she
@@gabrielstratton1775 Awesome!!
Anyone who is able to hear the little mistakes that were in there also has the capacity to understand just how good she is......
Thats more than i tap
i can click my mouse for 6 Clicks/sec And thats my avg
Ludwig would be stunned.
Seriously.
Thousands of hours of dedication to pull this off.
Bless her.
Kel and rich reacted to this. Kel is a professional concert pianist. And has played this a lot. She claims that Tina didn't miss a note.
It’s a bit of a pointless claim because she is playing an arrangement for piano and not the original piano score.
That's like a zillion notes she flew through in 6 minutes. Amazing performance, and *of course* there were some small errors. As The Man LvB Himself said, "To play a wrong note is insignificant; to play without passion is inexcusable".
Tina S new band, Spin Twice. New EP available September 1, 2023
After watching her play, I finally gathered all the motivation I needed to pursue a career in accounting.
I was listening to you Dave at the start and thought......hold Tina's beer Dave you are about to be mind blown
Imagine, folks, The Who in their prime, inviting this Girl on stage. She plays this piece. And before she finishes, Pete Townsend would not only crush his Guitar, he would be crushed to!!!
Tina S and Keith Moon, just thinking of it, my computer blew up ^^
At the time of her recording that video she was 16 or 17 years old!
That is freaking talent! (My opinion)
Tina's Subconscious: Ok, conscious brain. I got this. Go take a break for 6 minutes or so.
David. Great reaction. The best I have heard from nearly anyone else on TH-cam. You say real musical comments about her technique and performance. Like you, I learned this on piano many years ago, so have some idea of the technical demands. And I also like how closely you listened. I hear what you call "flubs", the variations of tone and rhythm, things that could happen another (cleaner) way, and do within this performance, as many sections are repeated. Musicians are not after perfection, they are after expression. To convey emotion you make yourself vulnerable, you take risks to say something new, something real. If you do this you will always "make mistakes". Perfection is about playing it safe, being anxiously cautious. Perfection is not a goal. Sublime expression is. People often confuse talent and giftedness in the comments (not you). Talent is the ability and willingness to practice many hours to develop one's gifts. Talent is long perseverance. No one who plays this way hasn't spent countless hours playing/practicing. Period. Tina S is the real deal. A joy to watch and to listen to. Glad I came across your reaction. Thanks.
FEELIN' YOU Leroy!!! Couldn't have said it better myself. Thank you for the kind words too I really appreciate them.
On a scale of one to ten, I would have given her eleven... hands down..
Your music reaction is perhaps the most cogent I've been able to stumble across on YT. Amazing guitarist and excellent analysis. Thank you for the perspective. Edit: Subscribed.
FEELIN' YOU Jarred!!! Thank you for the compliment, I do my best for the viewers as you all deserve nothing less than the best from me. Welcome to The Fanbase, glad to have you among us.
I'm subscribing in the hope you react to more Tina Setkic. You must have been scoring her on a scale of 1-9! She is classically trained.
She does a fantastic cover of Dr. Viossy's arrangement here!!! Something few in the world could hope to accomplish!! To compare how well she did, check out Dr. Viossy's version!!
Really impressed with this reaction! Just subscribed. Watched many reactors with varying degrees of expertise view this. It was obvious throughout, you knew exactly what "should" be played in the next few seconds and were waiting, not just listening, followed by subtle little nods when she scored! Enjoyed this!
This performance is, in a word ..... Joy!
David I will wage my next pay that Joe Satriani would be IMPRESSED by her and blown away, she is AMAZING! I'm watching the orig link once this React is over.
Vai was Very Impressed and shared Her For the love of God video!
Glad you mentioned the sweep picking - most reactors don't. This whole piece is insane, but the sweep picking near the end absolutely blew my mind!
God Almighty has gifted this lady beyond us mere mortals compression. I am not worthy,
I was laughing and kept saying oh my God because the amount of talent she possess is other Worldly.
Completely blown away. I hope to hear more from Tina. 😳 did I mention blown away?
I see you were as impressed by that sudden burst of sweep picking as I was. That was special. OK, you mentioned it. And I don't think anybody was doubting her doing this live. Miming to this and getting the fingering right would be totally impossible.
Following her since her debuts, i don't remember nobody talking about faking.
I can play the first movement on the piano. I'm currently learning this 3rd movement. The first page isn't so hard.
...After rehearsing for around a year.
Watch her right hand on her cover of Through the Fire and Flames. It was a few years earlier than this but it gives an idea of the speed she was capable of around the age of 15. She was 17 here.
I'll need a link so I watch the correct video
🤯.... Every guitarist would be mesmerized.
You all the way up until 2:35- “Idk if this is even gonna be worth it.”
Also you at 2:40-“………..I take it all back😳”
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Proud of how far you’re coming with this!! Love watching and seeing you in your element! 🖤
Hello David, on this last Christmas day i wish you and your wife a very great time !
Tina is a great talent and i love to see and hear her play, for me she is one of the very best ! Greatings and love from germany ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
I totally agree that the tiny little things are what make it more impressive, she is amazing.
SCORE 10 .... It new & fresh 🔥🔥🔥
This guy says can you imagine what she's gonna be in like 10 years...She's gonna be back on her Planet, cause she's not from the Earth...
I loved how your eyebrows climbed to your hairline when she started playing, lol
Who was?
The first Rocker: JS Bach.
The first Metalhead: Beethoven.
Tina S never ceases to amaze. She did a great cover of Steve Vai's For the Love of God, that Steve Vai himself praised. It's not a fast song, which actually makes it harder, as the tone, the bends, and the trem bar usage will easily make any mistakes more apparent. It's the one video she has where she is deep into the music and is very expressive. Her cover of Dragonforce's Into the Fire and Flames when she was two years younger than she was here is also a jaw dropping performance.
"For The Love Of God" is actually one of my favorite Steve Vai songs, because it does slow down and gives us listeners a chance to hear what he's REALLY doing, rather than slamming 128 notes into a single measure making the guitar sound like an angry bee.
Both songs are already in the que, added your name to the requesters.
@@THEDavidHeretic still waiting on your reaction to "For The Love Of God" keep up the GREAT work 🤘
@@davidyerkey7425 Uhhhhhh....I did a reaction to it awhile back.
@@THEDavidHeretic hmmm, couldn't find it on your Playlist...
And no one seen her since years. No news. So many of us wait for her and what she became with a guitar.
Wow, now I would love to see her and Hal-Ca from Asterism go at it in a battle. The Fire Dept would be on standby as they would surely ignite the guitars they were playing. Talent like this you can't teach yet she clearly works her butt off with her gifts and that is really impressive!!!
Hal-Ca+Tina S+MISA+Haruna= The female super group of all time.
She amazing good wow
And she doesn't miss a single note. The bog mindles!
We love and miss you Tina you can be guitarist for any band you want so I pray you come back and pick your band and make history girl your the best
Just a simply note. There are only a couple people in this world of over 8 billion that can play a guitar like this and I am thinking she holds the number 1 spot. I could be wrong and there maybe someone else out there hidden amongst the crowd. Excellent review.
Bravo for Tina S!
May we start standing up to APPLAUD already? WOW TALENTED lady, holy F$%K!!! I only WISH I could do that!
I NEED to go back and rewatch this! I am more into watching her THAN I am the music and the music is killer metal'ed up! I'm into classical as well and this MAY be my favorite Beethoven piece covered by someone!
In an interview, Tina S stated that she rehearses the song until she gets a so-called muscle memory. That's why he doesn't have to look at the neck of the guitar.
That’s the same for any musician surely. It’s all muscle memory.
Its quite Nice to know that beethoven became deaf HE COMPOSES USING HIS MEMORY
I am going to call her technique flicking not picking , if you watch slow and close, you can see where shes actually flicking the pick outward not down or upward its very very unique may be the first time I ever seen that done.
I agree that one take stuff...it was somethig🤯...it was already (maby) 20th time I listened it ....every time that same reaction🤯🤯🤯🤘
She hasn't put out a video in several years. Rumor is, she quit TH-cam to concentrate on college. She was 17 in this video.
That seems to be the most consistent story.
You must listen to her other videos on TH-cam. What is left of your mind, after this, will be blown completely.
Got a few in the que
I totally agree it was live. I've watched this video countless times And I know exactly what little flub you're talking about. She's got other songs you should check out too
❤ I really really enjoyed ur reaction ;-)
FEELIN' YOU Michael!!!
Love the Blazing Saddles intro.
HARRUMPH!!!
Why do I always get a warped one
@@kevinwilliams1421 Because...the affairs of State, must take precedence, over the affairs of State.
@@THEDavidHeretic you Teutonic.....twat
Dang!She's awesome!
Yeah she is
Roy Clark would approve of her right hand technique.
Just your expresion, she blew your socks of.
Same goes for me.
Should check out her channel, she does other stuff as well
I always equate a great guitarists by how little their picking hand moves, sometimes they look like their hand is barely moving and it's such a hard thing to master, no wasted movement
Tina S. is a shredder extraordinaire.
Love this song! I grew up playing on the piano.
Tina S and The Dooo needs to happen.
What's The Doo?
@@THEDavidHeretic u wot m8. You don't know The Doo? Boomers really need to check out upcoming talent. You guys are missing a lot on the good stuff.
Beethoven would have been super proud
Oh yes more than likely
Watched more than one of her videos and this girl is fucking brutal
She won the world guitar championship back in 2018. Check it out may be off on year. See early vids it tells what she one
She was 17 in that video
First reaction when someone hear flops. SHE IS GODESSSS of guitar.
you should check out her cover of Steve Vai for the love of god
A music Teacher say after this video:She don't miss any note of this sonata.
Shes a awesome guitarist she does all the best guitarists out there
If you are giving her 9.2, then you would probably give Vai, Van Halen, etc., etc., an 8.3. Wake up. No one in the world can even come close to her.
On a scale of 1-10, I gave it 20!
I would argue for a 9.6 but then again, I'm no guitar viruoso, or even a decent amateur guitarist................ still appreciate your overall viewpoints
Try out her version of "For the love of God" by Steve Vai. :-) It`s worth it!
Tina S once said that she is learning a song in the way a gamer does to perfectly play games, with the muscular memory. There comes a point where every movement is purely reflex - the fingers know exactly where to go and what to do even et those speeds where you don't have the time to even THINK about it :D I think this statement tells us alot, and it's definitively an approach that the older generations (not used to consoles and gamepads) cannot really understand.
It's all about muscle memory, which comes about from hours and hours of repetitive practice.
Anyone who has played a musical instrument knows this, no offence. You don’t need to have played consoles and games to get it. Any piano player is familiar with this phenomenon.
It looks like a Octopuss is playing with 8 fingers on each hand. WOW!!!
10.2 on 10 for me!!!!
I bet if old Ludwig was alive his jaw would be on the floor.
She reminded me of a young Matt Rach, but a better guitarist then he was at that age.
She is not the best female guitar player in the world. She is simply the best guitar player in the world. Where is she????????????????????????????
Criticism should be just like you say. Spotting errors should also be like this, I saw one myself (the one you mentioned) ... Even Mark Martel in his own performance of "Bohemian Rhapsody" talks about it (if you haven't seen it, I really recommend it),
btw. Tina S. is really brilliant.
I assume for a 10 out of 10 she would have had to perform that piece while doing a headstand in lotus pose...just kidding.
I got your point.
But I´m nevertheless convinced nobody is able to top that performance while playing the 3rd movement of the Moonlight sonata on guitar...just saying..especially no 17 year old person.
Yep.
I love how visually you see little emotion on her face yet in all her
music that all drains into the guitar pulling you in making you part of
her emotion. Love all her music. Thanks for the reaction video! You
should do a reaction video for " In A Gadda Da Vida" by " Iron
Butterfly" (17 minute version from 1968) Psychedelic Music Classic. You
will love it. :)
I'm very familiar with that song and that performance, so unfortunately I can't do an honest reaction to it.
@@THEDavidHeretic thats ok. It will always be a great song though. Thanks for responding to my post. :)
@@tintin9274 No worries Tintin thank you for watching
tina s is best lol eate your heart out MR j hendexxxxxxxxxxxx
tina s... most bad ass guitarist lady ever... voted best guitarist i think was 2014....
once you go tina you never go back...
how old 17 almost 18
picking... but did you see pinky....
from what ive heard voted best in 2014
dad owns a studio,... shes currently in law school.... but when she hits... watch... the world will scream like the beatles
live recording... watch face at the end... OMFG!!!!!!!!!!
You need to check out Tina S covers of - For The Love Of God and Arpeggios From Hell.
She covers most of the guitarist that you mentioned, but she does it with a yawn. Check out Laura Cox, another French guitarist. She's not a prodigy but plays great rock n roll. Great reaction video by the way.
Juliette Valduriez (aka Juliette Jade) too. The French really know how to chuck out awesome lady guitarists!
FYI this is a Dr Viossy cover. He did the translation for guitar a few years before Tina played it, she played his version, and he never got the credit.
Moreover she kinda stopped her carreer at 18, probably for her studies. I hope she will finally return and have a carreer she deserves. Maybe doesn't she feel like anymore.
About Viossy: That 😎
@@Kloashut He's a Boss
Honestly, she's probably bored lol
@@tranquilized13 she has suffered from a lot of trolling so....maybe. 😞
@@0ParisFrance Yes, indeed. I meant that the TH-cam reactors always watch her cover without knowing it is Viossy's work. I did not intend to say that she stole his work without geeving him credit.
The best who ever held a guitar Check out her playing on dragonforce. Cant wait to listen to hear you play this piece. Maybe you remember it now.
This is what 10.000 Hours of work look and sound like.
Oh at least that many....probably more
lol she's top tier elite so she might actually be at around 30,000........no kidding lol.
Also she shows that classical is metal lol
I play the 1812 Overture on the Spoons-any takers?
I don't know whether you've heard of Taj Farrant before, but if you haven't, you might check out his channel on TH-cam. In particular, look at "Taj Farrant Shreds With The Master"
Haven't heard of him before, I'll need a link so I watch the correct video
@@THEDavidHeretic th-cam.com/video/KzcU7MVbvXM/w-d-xo.html
@@squatchsquatch808 Added to the que
She picks exactly like John Petrucci. I saw her pick hand and immediately called her Petruccshe
Of course you're gonna do one or two or even a few small mistakes on a piece like this, even though you might have practiced it a 1,000 times.. perhaps once in a while you can play something like this absolutely perfectly, but the chance of that happening on a recording is pretty freaking slim. Even the greatest guitar player ever is not a robot. We're human :)
Exactly.
That blown me away when that video came in to the TH-cam. Tina S is a legend. 🤘 Look next Anton Oparin ... 8 year old guitar Virtuoso 2 (this time -11 year old) th-cam.com/video/IEpenKOuG60/w-d-xo.htmlsi=hJlUWzcQxierV9QF
Tina is what you would call a prodigy, she started at 4 on classical guitar and gradually improved over the years, there's a video of her from earliest to last on her channel. After this video she stopped posting to attend college, there is no information if she will come back. She was also subjected to constant abuse in the comments sections where people constantly said she wasn't playing these videos live. She also covered Steve Vai's For the Love of God - th-cam.com/video/nJi8iSpzq9I/w-d-xo.html and Malmsteen - Arpeggios From Hell - th-cam.com/video/1B4pZBmI_gU/w-d-xo.html
Added to the que
Wow, Wow, Wow !! From France: This is a bad, very bad news :
"Tina had an accident in 2017 and could no longer perform like a virtuoso.
In September 2020, she entered the Évry business school in the south of Paris, where her family lives. She joined the Télécom SudParis section as an engineering student. Her photo is in the school's Facebook and Instagram group photo, the last person on the right. Her sister Léa is also on the picture, for those who know her!
Alas Tina died in December 2020. "
R.I.P. 😢😢😢
The accident and death are fake rumours started by a troll known as YT Investigation (now T.S. Management). The school information is believed to be correct.
@@johnhawkins_twa I am French , Yes you are right this troll is also a psychopathic French this YT investigation is a crazy stalker he was banished from Tina’s Youtude channel and for revenge he harasses Tina everywhere or he little . Text translated by Google
@@thierryrebillard6432 Thank you for that info. I didn't know he was banned. Please take note that he just changed his name to T. S. Management in a blatant attempt to look like Tina's management team.
@@johnhawkins_twa He is a dangerous psychopath specializing in the change of nickname , this Frenchman has been harassing Tina for years and he dares to say that Tina died while it is a lie , Tina lives in Evry in the south of Paris and is in a very famous engineering school in France.
Tina no longer produces on TH-cam because of this kind of crazy.... she always plays with her brother Sacha and her sister Léa who is in the same school as her. They are gifted children especially in mathematics while the parents are only employees. Text translated by Google and signed by a Frenchman www.vigierguitars.com/fr/artistes-list-fr/?staff-page-no=3
I've listened to 30 or 40 other reactors and you're the only pne who said there were mistakes . One of the reactors is a classify tra
classically trained pianist who has played this piece and she stated that Tina didn't miss a note .I'm afraid I'm going to have to take her word over yours
Thanks a lot (!), David, for posting this reaction video. Which is, at least for me, by far the most insightful and authentic of the by now quite numerous reaction videos to Tina S's astonishing Beethoven performance.
As a hobby piano player actually coming from the classical side of music and cherishing the Moonlight Sonata as one of my favourite pieces (if not played too sentimentally), I enjoyed her metal version very much and had lots of fun with it. Her - and Dr Viossy's (who started this whole thing and produced the backgrund sound) - performances actually kind of "confirmed" a teasingly provocative statement of mine a few years ago too a friend: "Metal? Paaahh, invented by Beethoven as well!" ...I was indeed referring to the 3rd movement of the Moonlight, performed on the piano by Glenn Gould at least as breathtakingly as by Tina S on the guitar:
th-cam.com/video/DVZqAbbkdgw/w-d-xo.html
All the best to everybody in these challenging times!
she reminds me so much of Jimmy Hendrix when I first saw him!
Shame is she just up and vanished. Amazing talent and she hasn't done any videos in years. I remember hearing a teacher opened the channel for her and when she stopped going to classes the videos stopped.