OWK:It's over Anakin I have the high ground AS:No,(anakin use the force to move the lava to Kenobi)now u have the lava ground OWK:thats enough, pls let me live
When obi said palpatine is evil, he should of said that “you remember qui gon?” Anakin would say “yes” and then obi will be like “well palpatine hired earth maul to kill him, me, padme and everyone else and you just join him” that will hit his heart and make him change his mind
If obi wan mentioned Anakins mother it may have hardened Anakins heart. "How dare you mention my mother! I should have freed her. The Jedi kept me from her" Or something similar I guess.
For me it was a KFC ad and a woman just screamed, “shut up and take my money!”. Mind you, I was eating and not watching the screen so what I heard was, “ Obi Wan, turning Anakin’s gaze from the lava, stated SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY. “. I was truly confused until I looked at the screen.
@@xavierlauzac5922 I mean, he killed the younglings personally and helped sack the Jedi Temple with the Clones. He also very directly lead to the death of Mace Windu and countless other Jedi. How exactly he is redeemable?
@@xavierlauzac5922 Just because he *was* redeemed doesn't mean he *earned* a redemption. I mean, hell, he was literally complicit in the destruction of Alderaan and the monstrous rule of the Empire.
i honestly think anakin would more realistically retire from being a jedi because i feel like he would never be able to forgive himself for what he did and he would just focus on his family and let padme be the breadwinner
@@mynt4153 The Jedi would not think about that bc they didnt even teach the younglings about the Sith at that point. The Sith were jsut a myth at this point and that is part of why they were blind sided by them being amongst them.
@@SolZaer the sixth were not a myth to them they knew that the sixth were real.. Yoda in the clone wars even went to korriban to the grave of a old powerful with lord.. so they were far from myth to the jedi
@@mynt4153 The grandmaster of the Order and the High Council clearly knew. But it was mentioned that they didn't teach the Sith to the younglings. The Sith were an ancient enemy. It would be like the Mongols suddenly took over and destroyed America. Americans know of the Mongols but the Mongols are not known to be a threat. An ancient subdued enemy of the past. Dark side users were around but the Sith was very specific.
Everyone is talking about the Marvel "what if" series but I really feel like there could be more what if situations in Star wars, Anakin turning being the most different to the story line. I hope they consider something like it
Quarantine has me watching Star Wars fan fictions from three years ago Edit: I know I will lose likes for this but thanks for all the likes it would be greatly appreciated if you subbed to my channel and showed support. I have been trying to hit 150 subs for weeks so if you want to, go ahead. If not, I still thank you very much!!
The pause when Anakin was willing to talk was Anakin reaching out one last time to try to connect deeply with Obi Wan. I think Anakin, were any of this real life and not a script, didn’t want to be a Sith he was backed into a corner and desperate to save Padmè. Obi was knew, Anakin knew that Obi Wañ knew so it could’ve been possible to bring Akakin back to the light.
Anakin was just saying what he thought might convince Mace W. to let Palpatine live. He wasn't concerned about what the Jedi way was or wasn't at that moment, but only saving the life of the person he thought could save his wife Padme.
You're 100% right, it was very easy for Obi Wan to convince him back to the light and I feel like the only reason it played out like this was because they need Anakin to become Darth Vader in the storyline. I think that ignoring the original movies, Anakin could switch back and it would still stand by itself as an amazing storyline.
Anakin: from my perspective, the Jedi are evil! Obi Wan: do you hear yourself? Palpatine’s lightsaber is red! Anakin: oh shit, you’re right. Aight, let’s just head out. Wait what about the younglings I murdered? Obi wan: eh, let’s just... pretend that never happened. Anakin: alright. DIRECTED BY GEORGE LUCAS
Obi Wan: “Yoooo....we forgot to tell you, those were just droids. We installed them to see how prospective jedi masters teach padawans. You actually didn’t kill anyone bro.”
What's so interesting is that Anakin did explicitly say to Padme that he was willing to overthrow the Chancellor. Obi Wan was actually hidden nearby in the ship and could have very well overhead him say that. Obi Wan knows the Chancellor is the Sith lord that turned Anakin and could have taken this opportunity to string along Anakin into overthrowing him. He could have sensed that Yoda might not take him out alone and that him and Anakin together could have taken him out. Even if Anakin had the wrong reasons in mind, it doesn't really matter as long as they take the Chancellor out of the picture. There definitely was a possibility for Obi Wan to play along with Anakin for a time even if he knew he was on the wrong path. Obi Wan didn't have to turn Anakin back to reason right now. After all, who know how Anakin would have turned after taking out this very evil influence on him?! Maybe he, with the help of yoda AND Padme would have been able to sober up Anakin after the fact without the Chancellor around?! Why not try it instead of outright killing Anakin?! One could argue this would have been the smarter play from Obi Wan, straight up. And that could have happened regardless of Obi Wan's thoughts on the the Jedi council. Obi Wan could have been totally faithful to the Jedi and not convinced by Anakin's take one bit, he could completely refuse the Dark Side, and STILL this would have been the smarter play.
It sucks but we cant do anything but accept it. Obi Wan was supposed to be wise but it had to happen that way for plot. Anakin just hard to turn even though it couldve been prevented.
It wasn't slow enough imo. He went from "it's not the Jedi way!" to slaughtering kids five minutes later. That was far too rushed for me. Not believable. I'd have liked it better if they'd emphasized his internal conflict. He could have killed the adult Jedi out of his desire for order and tried to hide the younglings out of his desire for justice. Then you could have had the troops find and kill the kids later, causing him anguish and guilt that accelerates his fall. Episodes II and III both would have benefitted from being 20 minutes longer. Yeah, yeah, I know people don't like long movies, but I don't like rushed stories that make no sense.
@@jasonbaird1645 He was slowly losing trust for the Jedi and has used the Dark Side before. He truly believed that this was the only way to save Padme.
@@Zak-bv4qm Not arguing your point but like Jason above said, the story could have been improved had they further elaborated on Anakins inner conflict, even if it were just a few minutes of him and Palpatine arguing over slaughtering younglings because 'every jedi except you must have been in on this plan' Anakin could have argued that the younglings couldn't have been aware of this & somehow Palpatine manipulates him to go through with it instead of instantly being like 'OK i agree'
This. This is perfection. It brings a tear to my eye honestly. For Anakin’s sake first and foremost, this is was what I’m always thinking about when I watch the Mustafar scenes. Star Wars is truly a tragedy.
The prequels are a tragedy of good turning evil and the widening paradoxical chasm of good and evil in man. The original trilogy is a hopeful mythology of evil turning good and the reconciliation of the paradoxes of good and evil in man. Yin and Yang. Then Disney came along and said "nah fuck that, 99% of Star Wars is now decanonized. Fuck you."
The chances of him turning were VERY small. One chance is when in the phantom menace snaking met padme. Another is what you said, qui gon dying to darth maul. Another is what darth plagious had, the power to keep others alive if he had wanted. Another is palpating remembering that and telling anakin. Another (wow) is anakin loving padme so much that he did whatever he could do to save her. Another is that he had to turn to the dark side to get this power. Another is anakin getting to where mace windu and palpatine were before mace killed him, of course anakin killed mace and he turned, but all of these put together is absurd
Darth Jar Jar would have turned to the dark side because, he wasn't able to become Senator of the Galactic Senate of the Republic, because Padme did not die.
@@winstonchurchill7822 Not necessarily true. If the person in charge of the sequel trilogy actually gave a shit, they'd hire competent writers, directors, etc while making good plot decisions. If an invested fan was in charge of the movies, they'd certainly be many times greater than they ended up, that's just a fact.
I liked 7 and 8, would give them a 8.5 The episode 9... A 6.0, good battles, great effects, but lazy writing, seriously, how a payed profissional writer write: "Somehow palpatine returned"
I believe this is very accurate, and very likely what would’ve happened in this scenario. This would’ve truly brought balance to the force and to Anikan himself.
Jedi Council (Obi-Wan and Yoda in the weird red chairs in the tower): You’re forgiven. Anakin: Yay! Obi-Wan: Obviously, you’re expelled. Anakin: Aaww Yoda: But send you to prison, we will not. Anakin: So...can I live with my wife and children on Naboo then? Yoda: Desire them to be Jedi you do not? Anakin: I kind of just want them to be children. They can decide what path to follow. It’s the thing I never had. Obi-Wan, shooting his hand up: I CALL GODFATHER! Yoda: AGREED IT SHOULD BE ME WE DID! Obi-Wan: Snooze you lose old man!
Well, on the brightside, even he's expelled he didn't became Darth Vader and and prevent the Jedi from being completely extinct. Most of all, even if the galaxy ever need a Sith to emerge, it doesn't have to be Anakin anymore.
This is so beautiful. This is what makes the prequels beautiful. The pain that brought Anakin to the Dark side could have been used to soften his heart and bring him balance. I was inspired by this, oddly enough, because unlike the new Disney movies, this is real life, this is what all people struggle with inside their hearts and souls.
the godwins law of star wars - every discussion will eventualy bring up prequal rants in pokemon, it's dexit or the BDSP controversy, in minecraft its phantoms, etc.
@@firestrikeriii5043 well its true. Every star wars discussion devolves into ranting about the prequels (granted the prequels arent that great although TLJ was goat)
Great job with the writing for this! I could feel every moment of excitement and the relief at the separate parts and had goosebumps in the intense moments! Truly have heard or read much else like it.
Killing the younglings at the temple would have guaranteed Anakin some serious sentence, if not straight from the Jedi council at least from the state. He basically killed Mace Windu too, a jedi master and a member of the council.
The Emperor was still the Chancellor of the Republic and being a Sith wasn't illegal. So attempting to kill the Chancellor was treason, so I think the entire jedi order would be in some hot water with the state. Especially given the Emperor was the Senate at this point.
John Wells yeah I agree that being a Sith was evil, but controlling two major states and manipulating them into war that caused millions of deaths for your own power is illegal, but the only problem is did the Jedi or anyone know of Palpatines deep influence
That was kind of a chaotic day. The public wouldn't necessarily ever know all the details. Who actually knew the facts? Yoda and Obi-Wan saw the footage, Obi-Wan told Padme. The clone troopers who helped Vader would know. Maybe they would be "retired" early; maybe they could be ignored or blackmailed since they took part in the atrocities. But really, if Yoda, Obi-Wan, and Padme are all willing to move on, Anakin probably returns to his position. Otherwise, Anakin just disappears into the galaxy, either with his wife or not depending on whether she forgave him.
This reminded me; you know how Endgame completely retconned many aspects of the MCU, like Guardians? This Star Wars ending means the original trilogy wouldn’t have happened!
This is what makes Star Wars so good. The whole time watching ROTS you KNOW Anakin’s fate but you can’t stop but hope that this becomes the canon story line. It’s so good but so damn frustrating!
Yea, Anakin has. Unless I mistake the scene, there's a point where all of them (Anakin, Obi and whoever else) are leaving on a ship when Maul attacks. Qui Gon holds him off and then they escape Maul. Or maybe I'm forgetting something...
Honestly i believe they would give him a second chance because they know what the dark side is capable of and what it does to people, just as Revan has turned and redeemed himself. Why cant Anakin?
i am deeply convinced the force has more of an affect on jedi emotions than normal people. it's like it echos inside them, provoking emotions and thoughts that would otherwise be alien to them. i think when a jedi falls to the dark side, the force, powered by powerful negative emotions, forms an echo chamber around them that changes their thoughts, makes them more reactive. this would explain how fallen jedi can change personality so quickly, and do unimaginable things when not too long ago they were good people. perhaps that is why the jedi determined that emotion is dangerous.
Yeah this is why the Jedi are expected to follow a strict code in which they can’t form attachments. They know that a force user is much more susceptible to evil than a normal person because of the pull from the dark side.
@@zacharykim5596 yes i hate to be a party pooper and btw what you said would be hilarious and litt but obi wan literally was on higher ground than anakin so even tho palpatine is on the ground its the same level ground obi and ani would be standing on in front of him
10:05 I thought both Sidious and Plagueis played really fast and loose with the rule of 2, the former never allowing himself to be challenged after killing his master in his sleep, and the latter thinking that his apprentice would never challenge him and they'd rule together.
Hey everyone, hope you enjoy this compiled Fan-Fiction. :)
Enjoy!!
Star Wars Theory Keep up the fantastic work brother; I look forward to your work everyday. God bless and may the Force be with you.
Star Wars Theory Great Video M8 🍇
Star Wars Theory what if Mace let Palpatine live in revenge of the sith
Star Wars Theory Have you made this video before? I remember everything!..
Star Wars Theory Can somebody open both sith and jedi olocrons at the same time?
Anakin: *turns to the light*
The Younglings: bruh
TomTom651 yes
TomTom651 “maybe this child murderer isn’t so bad after all”
Mystery nerd
“maybe the dude who helped erase the peacekeepers of the galaxy and murdered children might not be so bad ya know”
Younglings be like: really?
The Younglings: say sike right now
Anakin: *goes on murderous rampage in the Jedi Temple*
Jedi Council: It’s cool, just don’t do it again please.
I'm dead lmaoooo
Do that again and we'll have to shut down the youth cetre.
Don't forget you also killed our only black Jedi
@@hoomanontheinternet3239 your killing me🤣😂
Joseph Bobowicz now I am regretting the Jedi code
Kenobi: its over anakin I have the high ground
Anakin: You're right I should return to the Light
DIRECTED BY
GEORGE LUCAS
Anakin: *jumps to the left, right or away*
Kenobi: "Oh. Why did I think jumping over me was your only option?"
OWK:It's over Anakin I have the high ground
AS:No,(anakin use the force to move the lava to Kenobi)now u have the lava ground
OWK:thats enough, pls let me live
WRITTEN*
ftfy
@@joshuaalestre2182 It's Obi-wan. Not Obi One.
have you heard of these 2 powerful jedi named "obi wand kenobi"? or Panakin side crawler?
When obi said palpatine is evil, he should of said that “you remember qui gon?” Anakin would say “yes” and then obi will be like “well palpatine hired earth maul to kill him, me, padme and everyone else and you just join him” that will hit his heart and make him change his mind
EARTH MAUL
@@realperson-zx3ex with the power of a thousend rocks,i give you
E A R T H M A U L
Earth fire san---
Anakin: *ignites his blade* earth fire and what?
Maul Earthbends Toph
@@mynt4153 Captain Pl----- Maul!!!
Anakin: *Resumes life in the Order and hunts down evil despite his crimes*
Yoda: "Thin fucking ice, you are on."
No Yoda would say thin fucking ice, you on, *repeat
@@samuraikiller922 "thin ice, you are on young Skywalker, thin fucking ice"
He would say thin fucking ice, on you are
It would be sooooo funny to hear yoda swear
Yoda's line cracks me up, lmao
If obi wan mentioned Anakins mother it may have hardened Anakins heart.
"How dare you mention my mother! I should have freed her. The Jedi kept me from her"
Or something similar I guess.
Obi wan kenobi :He likes sand my boi
a second later: palpatine is DED not big surprise
Jadiel Perez hahahahahahahahhahaha omg fucking *hilarious*
@@nobodyatall2649 I'm sure it ended well for my apprentice at the second death star
@Paradoxical Nightmare She had a second, Hispanic son?
,,It is never too late to change"
Also the jedi when anyone even mentions the dark side : [Your free trial of existance has ended].
Obi-Wan: Please Anakin. Come back!
Anakin: Ok.
Younglings: WHAT THE F-
DIRECTED BY GEORGE LUCAS
🤣🤣
😂 LoL😂
@@legobrothers534 no one care fucker
😂😂
TRUE
Anakin in heaven.
The younglings-“how the f**k did he get here”
Why would the younglings be there?
@@dylanbarton4889 anakin killed them, you should watch more star wars
@@basher1904.5 no. I meant why would the younglings be in heaven? Those vile specimens will be in the other place lol
@@dylanbarton4889 they're Children tho
@@thelonelyduck2823 they are secret sith lords
Anakin: Kills young children and the 2nd strongest Jedi Master
Yoda: Wrong it was but do it again, please do not.
Hey, The shit yoda did in ‘nam and while on Ketamine makes anakin’s kiddy killing look like a joke
Pelinal Whitestrake true, Yoda’s one to talk. That and he killed Dr. Phil on live television
@@ndhickson3599 He WHAT?!
Sir Clone-boi “Get what you fucking deserve, you do!”
Compared to the songs of Whitestrake, well... the only thing comparable to Whitestrake is, the Death Star.
"Anakin, chancellor Palipine is evil!"
"Oh Shet u rite fam my bad"
*credits roll*
Scrapbox-TF2 and more lol😂😂😂
PublicExecutionsTo TheLGBTCommunity go to jail and stay there
Scrapbox-TF2 and more 😂😂😂😂😂
palpapain XD
Directed by George Lucas
Anakin: kills defenseless 5 year olds AND the master of the order
Yoda: “No big deal just don’t do it again.”
"Big deal not is, again to do it you are not allowed!""
LOL
Relatable
@@n00bplays36 A more correct one would be "Big deal it is not, again do it not"
@@lifeoflonexia496 Yup
i’ve never had better ad timing.💀🤣
“ obi wan, turning anakin’s gaze from the lava, stated-“
“WINTER WEATHER IS APON US-“
Straight up I fucking laughed so hard I had a similar ad
Not too sure about that one obi wan
Mine said “are you someone I can trust”
For me it was a KFC ad and a woman just screamed, “shut up and take my money!”.
Mind you, I was eating and not watching the screen so what I heard was, “ Obi Wan, turning Anakin’s gaze from the lava, stated SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY. “. I was truly confused until I looked at the screen.
Your comment has 69 likes
I want to like this but I shouldn't.
Obi-wan: Anakin the chancellor is ugly, do you want to look like that?!
Anakin: Ew, no, yucky!
DIRECTED BY
GEORGE LUCAS
D i a v o l o .
@@user-tq6fx7tl7e XD
Lol i was in tears till i saw this 😂
Lol
"Anakin was like a moldable clay."
Because he hadn't been fired yet.
But they would have had to cut most of the product...
His budget was cut
1 1 Good GOOD
damnit lmao
Jesus Christ. imma need you to do me a favor after that pun. do you own a toaster?
Anakin: **kills literally everyone**
Also Anakin: sorry
Jedi: oh ok
He wasn’t irredeemable.
@@xavierlauzac5922 I mean, he killed the younglings personally and helped sack the Jedi Temple with the Clones. He also very directly lead to the death of Mace Windu and countless other Jedi. How exactly he is redeemable?
Isabelle Grimes watch episode VI.
@@xavierlauzac5922 Just because he *was* redeemed doesn't mean he *earned* a redemption. I mean, hell, he was literally complicit in the destruction of Alderaan and the monstrous rule of the Empire.
Isabelle Grimes so? It was a legitimate redemption, and it was worthy of becoming a force ghost.
When Anikin said “I should of known the Jedi were trying to take over!”
Obi wan should of said “so you joined someone else’s plan to take over?”
No
@@firestrikeriii5043 yes?
*have
Anakin:yes no shaddup
*Anakin returns to the temple where everyone is just dead*
"Sorry y'all, I had a change of heart, but I'm back again!"
Anakin walks up to the children's corpses: I know i kind killed y'all so you are kinda sorta dead, but we good right?
Sooo, now that Master Windu is dead, I suppose there's an empty spot for a new master?
@@kapitan19969838 master windu didnt die after he got force lightninged of the building
@@shadesofbla5k141 I too like to think that, I really do
Mace probably survived after he fell out the Windu.
If this man made “Revenge of The Sith” the movie would be Insane
Anakin Skywalker Would you still look like a National Lampoon’s Turkey?
Hey yo so are you like a ghost who possessed a computer or what
Anakin Skywalker anakin, I mean uhh darth Vader did the complete the assassination
um who are you
@@orlandorivas3689 so how's life as a force ghost.
i honestly think anakin would more realistically retire from being a jedi because i feel like he would never be able to forgive himself for what he did and he would just focus on his family and let padme be the breadwinner
Ehhh I mean revan did worse and still was redeemed..... same with meetra surik
He already wanted to leave at that point so yea he would go do other things.
@@mynt4153 The Jedi would not think about that bc they didnt even teach the younglings about the Sith at that point. The Sith were jsut a myth at this point and that is part of why they were blind sided by them being amongst them.
@@SolZaer the sixth were not a myth to them they knew that the sixth were real.. Yoda in the clone wars even went to korriban to the grave of a old powerful with lord.. so they were far from myth to the jedi
@@mynt4153 The grandmaster of the Order and the High Council clearly knew. But it was mentioned that they didn't teach the Sith to the younglings. The Sith were an ancient enemy. It would be like the Mongols suddenly took over and destroyed America. Americans know of the Mongols but the Mongols are not known to be a threat. An ancient subdued enemy of the past. Dark side users were around but the Sith was very specific.
Everyone is talking about the Marvel "what if" series but I really feel like there could be more what if situations in Star wars, Anakin turning being the most different to the story line. I hope they consider something like it
THANK YOU, finally someone else is talking about something like this
THIS
A Star Wars What If... series with 1hr episodes would be awesome. As long as done by similar team. Not Sequels peoples haha
Quarantine has me watching Star Wars fan fictions from three years ago
Edit: I know I will lose likes for this but thanks for all the likes it would be greatly appreciated if you subbed to my channel and showed support. I have been trying to hit 150 subs for weeks so if you want to, go ahead. If not, I still thank you very much!!
Same I have no idea what my life has come to
SAME MY BROTHER
Yep
Same
Me *reads star wars and halo crossover fanfics from 9 years ago
What if while floating down the lava river, Anakin and Obi-wan continued to argue and fell off the lava waterfall and both died
Well uhh I think maybe all Jedi would be dead and darth sidious would train Luke or Leia
I like it
still a happier ending
Lava fall
@@ardientetatts30 Another happy landing
Yeah obi-wan was literally the negotiator, he could’ve done this
Robb Stark I guess the negotiations were short
They’re called aggressive negotiations for a reason
General Greivous : No
Obi Wan : Yes
Greivous : Ah Yes the Negotiator
I only think qui gon can convince him back
Robb Stark ah the negotiator
The pause when Anakin was willing to talk was Anakin reaching out one last time to try to connect deeply with Obi Wan. I think Anakin, were any of this real life and not a script, didn’t want to be a Sith he was backed into a corner and desperate to save Padmè. Obi was knew, Anakin knew that Obi Wañ knew so it could’ve been possible to bring Akakin back to the light.
He looked up at obi wan and said... Ad: GET DISCOUNTED PIZZA AT DOMINOS THIS WEEKEND ONLY
I actually burst out laughing when my add popped up. Took me a second to realize what was happening.
Oohh!😂
This happened to me except it was a Capital One ad with Samuel L Jackson. MACE WINDU IN THE ADVERTS!!!
Impulse same!!
Impulse....and obi wan said..... ill have the double pepperoni and a side of garlic bread 🥖...... lol😂😂
Anakin when he returns to the temple:
"We were bad, but now we're good"
"Killing children in your neighborhood!"
@@broski9938
"I feel really bad, I got turned
Might do it again probably not"
And if by it you mean the younglings, was it worth it no it wasn't.
@@GonkGonkGonk doesnt rhyme
We were good, but then we were bad, but now we’re good again
“DON’T TRY IT.”
“Oh. Ok Master, sorry about that..”
*DIRECTED BY*
*GEORGE LUCAS*
Stolen
Stolen
*"Your new empire??"*
"You're right. This is stupid."
*Directed by George Lucas*
Anakin: turns to dark side to save padme
Also anakin: chokes her to death
He didn’t choke her to death, just to the point of being unconscious.
@@ryandepp7640 🙄
@discontinued account stop. Just stop
he chock her bc he thought she came so obi wan could kill him
My life not yours :/
*Palpatine dies and Snoke arises in the theory*
People who’ve seen episode 9: wait that’s illegal
Palpatine created Snoke what if we went back in time told them this
Enemy Like What?
R/ihadastroke Enemy Like
But Palpatine died and Snoke arose anyways. Episode IX just showed how he made that possible... Even if the explanation is "eh".
Sans the skeleton so true
Anakin to Mace Windu: "No! It's not the jedi way!"
(Later on)
Palpatine: "Go kill a buttload of jedi, and children, ok."
Anakin: "Alrighty!"
Anakin
@@1716jazz thanks
He was darth Vader by then
After Mace Windu, Anakin was sure that the Jedi were corrupt and wanted to get rid of the corruption.
Anakin was just saying what he thought might convince Mace W. to let Palpatine live. He wasn't concerned about what the Jedi way was or wasn't at that moment, but only saving the life of the person he thought could save his wife Padme.
You're 100% right, it was very easy for Obi Wan to convince him back to the light and I feel like the only reason it played out like this was because they need Anakin to become Darth Vader in the storyline. I think that ignoring the original movies, Anakin could switch back and it would still stand by itself as an amazing storyline.
If you ignore the originals and consider Anakin's temperament, he would have killed Palpatine when he revealed himself as a sith lord.
I guess this is how the prequels would play out if they were made first.
Me watching this after rise of sky walker knowing palpatine made snoke:
*sad hopeless sigh*
Snoke was created before Episode III.
Oh I didn’t know that. Thanks Xavier
@@1ksubscriberswithnovideos736 you should have done what this video tells you to do!
B. Arthur Setyawan what do you think I was tryna do
Ayo bruh
Anakin: from my perspective, the Jedi are evil!
Obi Wan: do you hear yourself? Palpatine’s lightsaber is red!
Anakin: oh shit, you’re right. Aight, let’s just head out. Wait what about the younglings I murdered?
Obi wan: eh, let’s just... pretend that never happened.
Anakin: alright.
DIRECTED BY GEORGE LUCAS
Boom 420
Rian Johnson
When george lucas is high af while directing star wars😂
Obi Wan: “Yoooo....we forgot to tell you, those were just droids. We installed them to see how prospective jedi masters teach padawans. You actually didn’t kill anyone bro.”
@Ihsan Azmi yep sounds like a ending that would happen but it is a lot harder to turn someone to a different side
Anakin: can I be a Jedi again
Council: Totally it’s not like you killed a bunch of 9 year olds
RIP misc. PewDiePie fans
No
Council:......*silent because there all dead bodies on the ground*
Anakin: ill take that as a yes
Council: we dont like kids anyway.
Council: Here be a master so you don't kill someone again
no non no 5 year olds
What's so interesting is that Anakin did explicitly say to Padme that he was willing to overthrow the Chancellor. Obi Wan was actually hidden nearby in the ship and could have very well overhead him say that. Obi Wan knows the Chancellor is the Sith lord that turned Anakin and could have taken this opportunity to string along Anakin into overthrowing him. He could have sensed that Yoda might not take him out alone and that him and Anakin together could have taken him out. Even if Anakin had the wrong reasons in mind, it doesn't really matter as long as they take the Chancellor out of the picture. There definitely was a possibility for Obi Wan to play along with Anakin for a time even if he knew he was on the wrong path. Obi Wan didn't have to turn Anakin back to reason right now. After all, who know how Anakin would have turned after taking out this very evil influence on him?! Maybe he, with the help of yoda AND Padme would have been able to sober up Anakin after the fact without the Chancellor around?! Why not try it instead of outright killing Anakin?! One could argue this would have been the smarter play from Obi Wan, straight up. And that could have happened regardless of Obi Wan's thoughts on the the Jedi council. Obi Wan could have been totally faithful to the Jedi and not convinced by Anakin's take one bit, he could completely refuse the Dark Side, and STILL this would have been the smarter play.
It sucks but we cant do anything but accept it. Obi Wan was supposed to be wise but it had to happen that way for plot. Anakin just hard to turn even though it couldve been prevented.
This video basically made me the chosen one I killed palapatine and I turned anakin back to he light
Obi-Wan Kenobi nice avatar
And then the Easter bunny slapped you
@@ryandelia3 lol thats the old Lego star wars game avatar 😂
Ada Gonzalez that is why it 's so good
Anakin Skywalker I don’t like sand
Anakin: Turns to the light side
Anakin like 2 minutes later: Well, back to the dark
Anakin 2 more minutes later: Nevermind, Obi Wan is injured
Is prepared to kill o I wan
Then like noope
I really wish this is how it ended it’s so sad to watch anakin slowly turn evil throughout the movie
It wasn't slow enough imo. He went from "it's not the Jedi way!" to slaughtering kids five minutes later. That was far too rushed for me. Not believable. I'd have liked it better if they'd emphasized his internal conflict. He could have killed the adult Jedi out of his desire for order and tried to hide the younglings out of his desire for justice. Then you could have had the troops find and kill the kids later, causing him anguish and guilt that accelerates his fall. Episodes II and III both would have benefitted from being 20 minutes longer. Yeah, yeah, I know people don't like long movies, but I don't like rushed stories that make no sense.
@@jasonbaird1645 He was slowly losing trust for the Jedi and has used the Dark Side before. He truly believed that this was the only way to save Padme.
@@Zak-bv4qm Not arguing your point but like Jason above said, the story could have been improved had they further elaborated on Anakins inner conflict, even if it were just a few minutes of him and Palpatine arguing over slaughtering younglings because 'every jedi except you must have been in on this plan' Anakin could have argued that the younglings couldn't have been aware of this & somehow Palpatine manipulates him to go through with it instead of instantly being like 'OK i agree'
Bark Lord of the Sith watch the clone wars. It shows his descent over 7 seasons
Preston Collins
season 7 the ending is crazy idk if you’ve seen it yet but it’s crazy
This. This is perfection. It brings a tear to my eye honestly. For Anakin’s sake first and foremost, this is was what I’m always thinking about when I watch the Mustafar scenes. Star Wars is truly a tragedy.
The prequels are a tragedy of good turning evil and the widening paradoxical chasm of good and evil in man. The original trilogy is a hopeful mythology of evil turning good and the reconciliation of the paradoxes of good and evil in man. Yin and Yang.
Then Disney came along and said "nah fuck that, 99% of Star Wars is now decanonized. Fuck you."
Yes! As it was meant to be. It was always supposed to be the tragedy of Darth Vader.
@@mikeexits that's why George Lucas is the creator of Star wars.
If qui gon were still alive anakin never would’ve turned
Qui gon wouldve never let the republic get so big
@SP - 06BL - Tecumseh PS (1258) the force needed him to die to balance the force
The chances of him turning were VERY small. One chance is when in the phantom menace snaking met padme. Another is what you said, qui gon dying to darth maul. Another is what darth plagious had, the power to keep others alive if he had wanted. Another is palpating remembering that and telling anakin. Another (wow) is anakin loving padme so much that he did whatever he could do to save her. Another is that he had to turn to the dark side to get this power. Another is anakin getting to where mace windu and palpatine were before mace killed him, of course anakin killed mace and he turned, but all of these put together is absurd
Devan Devan Everyone says this but never why
He would’ve never even been a padawan since obi wan would’ve still just been a young Jedi knight with his master
Obi Wan: Come back to the light side.
Anakin: I shouldn’t.
Obi Wan: Dew it!
Anakin: Ok
easy to convice anakin
Hahahahah
Pretty sure in the first two trilogies no one ever referred to the good side of the force as the light side.
Lol.
No, coming back to the light side isn't really the Sith way. We crave for power, and we get power.
Next Video: “What if MACE didn’t fly out the WINDU”
Your not funny
oh my god
lol
@@xpdaysx6561 lol, who asked?
@@xpdaysx6561 You're* and it was clever
They both smiled at each other... THEN HE WAS FLUNG 50 FEET IN THE AIR WITH BLOOD EVERYWHERE... like wtf lmao
XD
That sounded awesome
The. “Obi wan said” .... an ad happens and the first words were “lets get ready to rumble”
KeyBoard Dave OMG SAME XD
KeyBoard Dave but it was just an ad for some restaurant and there was only music
I got a Kellogg’s ad that started with COCKADOODLEDOO
KeyBoard Dave same 🤣 haha
I got "And Obi-Wan said....Hey guys! Head's up! Everything you've been told about shampoo and conditioner is a sham."
The new threat after the Skywalker kids: "Mesa is Darth Jar Jar!"
TheThunderguardian I’m crying
You do know Jar Jar died but the scene got cut out in the Phantom Menace?
Yousa in biiiig trouble now!
Darth Jar Jar would have turned to the dark side because, he wasn't able to become Senator of the Galactic Senate of the Republic, because Padme did not die.
Oof
SWT: “Both covered in sweat and char marks, he said”
Ad: “GOLD FISH FLAVOUR BLASTED!!”
Lol
I got an ad for a collage
Wither Skeleton mhm
I got that ad on video
mine was just "what the hell!"
That little snip of Snoke at the end made him 1000% more important than he actually was in Canon
Too bad in canon Snoke was a failed clone of Palpatine
Obi-Wan: "Anakin you're bipolar"
Anakin: "I know I need meds"
What if the High Ground had the High Ground
The Ultimate Force
Better yet what of anakin had the high ground which would have the high ground morraly and physically
How about this: Obi-Wan had the high ground that had the high ground. That's an unstoppable combination
The high ground always has the high ground because it’s the high ground
Then it'll be a mountain and their would be no logical reason to fight such a force, might as well surrender
Imagine if Ahsoka was there with Obi-Wan to try to convice Anakin to return to the light.
finally someone who knows how to write ahsoka's name correctly
I guess so, lol. I often see people spell her name: "Asohka" or "Asokha".
or ashoka
Imagine if anakin killed Ahsoka
@@incognito7334 star wars: rebels
Finally one where he didn’t die. This was a really good one. Great job.
If this guy had written 7, 8 and 9 they would have been amazing
People who say stuff like this only solidify the fact that you want romanticized and cliche stuff.
@@winstonchurchill7822 Not necessarily true.
If the person in charge of the sequel trilogy actually gave a shit, they'd hire competent writers, directors, etc while making good plot decisions. If an invested fan was in charge of the movies, they'd certainly be many times greater than they ended up, that's just a fact.
@@lawenda2099 if there was a fan up top. The sequels would be grandmaster luke being the most op shit ever Wrecking any enemies in front of him.
I liked 7 and 8, would give them a 8.5
The episode 9...
A 6.0, good battles, great effects, but lazy writing, seriously, how a payed profissional writer write:
"Somehow palpatine returned"
yes
*Anakin goes back to Coruscant*
Anakin: So umm, I killed alot of younglings and jedis like you but, im back...Ok lets get back to work
It wasn't lot it was like a thousand? I think
Anakin Skywalker You think? What, you lost count on the first 500? 😂
@@anakinskywalker4143 a thousand would be the total that died at the hands of you and order 66 together
emperor palpatine of the imperial Senate hewwo senate, i are ur beegest fen, u moo-st bee ashamed of Anakin skywalker
@@gingerfann67 u r literlly a kid
Anakin reached down to touch his shoulder when *OBI WAN WAS LAUNCHED 50 FEET IN THE AIR*
Obi-Wan didn't want to risk being on an even ground with him.
I'm so sorry ^^
Wow! This was a surprisingly engaging “what-if” scenario. You most certainly have a knack for these. I’m most certainly subscribing to your channel.
Obi Wan: Anakin, Palpatine is evil!
Anakin: Well duh he’s a politician.
Obi Wan : But so is Padme! NO, not all politician are wrinkly and have yellow teeth, Anakin.
But they probably are all evil.
Exept for Padme. (Don't insult her if you don't wanna die by the hands of her OP husband.)
Alexplaysminc .-. Lol this was hilarious
Obi-Wan: Isn’t your wife one too?
Anakin: So was Satine.
Obi-Wan: ...
Anakin: Oh right. Low blow.
Obi-Wan: At least I didn’t choke mine.
Obi wan: Padme is still alive so come back.
Anakin: OK
The end
I ruined 169 likes
Ok
*Directed by George Lucas*
No you need me a call 📞 or call
What is the musics name at 1:10?
Obi Wan: *explaining how palpatine is evi-*
*gets immediately struck down*
That actually seems quite likely, given how angry and emotional Anakin was
@@AndrewMRoots Anakin was out for blood lol, he fights so aggresively, Kenobi was on the defensive the whole fight.
@@animepussy8356 He probably would have won if Obi-Wan hasn't.. you know
@@AndrewMRoots dismembered him? Haha
@@animepussy8356 Yeah but if he hadn't had the high ground I really think Anakin/Vader would've won
I believe this is very accurate, and very likely what would’ve happened in this scenario. This would’ve truly brought balance to the force and to Anikan himself.
If Obi Wan had just let Padme talk she would have turned him back
Padre "come back with me and help raise our children, and in six weeks we can try for another kid or have fun trying 😉😎"
@ted37846 yes
I agree
MisterGaming yes.. but then the Original Triologie didn’t happen xD That’s why it’s bad making prequels after the „Original“ Story
yeah, god Obi Wan you screw everything up.
This whole thing in a nutshell:
Your not you when your hungry, have a snickers
😂😂
Ha
69 nice
😂
Better?
And then Obi Wan said... Ad: You won't last 5 seconds playing this game
Mine said, "Hi. I need you to do me a favor."
Mine was like a banking ad
I feel like Disney should make an alternate universe movie where this happens. I would definitely pay to watch that.
If they were to make a movie about this, it would be an animated one
Knowing Disney, it's a real possibility, a what if series, if you will.
Me too
Jedi Council (Obi-Wan and Yoda in the weird red chairs in the tower): You’re forgiven.
Anakin: Yay!
Obi-Wan: Obviously, you’re expelled.
Anakin: Aaww
Yoda: But send you to prison, we will not.
Anakin: So...can I live with my wife and children on Naboo then?
Yoda: Desire them to be Jedi you do not?
Anakin: I kind of just want them to be children. They can decide what path to follow. It’s the thing I never had.
Obi-Wan, shooting his hand up: I CALL GODFATHER!
Yoda: AGREED IT SHOULD BE ME WE DID!
Obi-Wan: Snooze you lose old man!
Well, on the brightside, even he's expelled he didn't became Darth Vader and and prevent the Jedi from being completely extinct. Most of all, even if the galaxy ever need a Sith to emerge, it doesn't have to be Anakin anymore.
“Both sweating and burnt with char marks, he said-“
“With metro and the new iPhone SE, you rule”
Goddamn it ads
It was google pixel 4a for me
I have adblock....
If you live in South Carolina
I’M JAMIE HARRISON
It was the "you don't have to be a pilot to be in the Air Force." Either way, good advice.
“Both sweating and burnt with char marks, he said-“
_“DON'T OVERPAY FOR BEST BUY! WIKIBUY CAN SAVE YOU MONEY!”_
This is so beautiful. This is what makes the prequels beautiful. The pain that brought Anakin to the Dark side could have been used to soften his heart and bring him balance. I was inspired by this, oddly enough, because unlike the new Disney movies, this is real life, this is what all people struggle with inside their hearts and souls.
Yes, exactly. Everyone has an internal conflict with light and dark in them.
@@jordanelza8806 Most people use their dark side unfortunately :(
the godwins law of star wars - every discussion will eventualy bring up prequal rants
in pokemon, it's dexit or the BDSP controversy, in minecraft its phantoms, etc.
@@kamikazesenpai21 Na
@@firestrikeriii5043 well its true. Every star wars discussion devolves into ranting about the prequels (granted the prequels arent that great although TLJ was goat)
Anakin:turns
Palpatine: threatened padme
Anakin: haha dark side go brrrrrrrr
They should make movies of alternative realities in Star Wars - change my mind
As long as the mouse does not direct it I will be okay with that idea.
That would be too much movie and kinda a waste of timr
Disney + anthology series
Maxi Rupitsch or comics
I would love to see that
I'd love to see this turned into an alternate universe comic
You just gave me an idea
@@Dead-head what idea
@@slackershrub8923 i now wanna make this into a comic
@@Dead-head go for it, bro
Could’ve been a thing if they didn’t destroy the multiverse in rebels
Great job with the writing for this! I could feel every moment of excitement and the relief at the separate parts and had goosebumps in the intense moments! Truly have heard or read much else like it.
In reality I would have just yeeted them into the lava.
hahahhahahaha
Sheev Palpatine well hello mister senate
Oh god 😂
Nah... Windu almost killed you...
He us to dangerous to be kept alive!
“Both covered in sweat and burnt char marks, he said ‘LETS PLAY RAID, SHADOW LEGENDS’”
EXACTLY
' you want a free voucher? use honey.'
"WHATEVER YOU SAY, CANT HOLD ME BACK"
Don't know why you're singing bud but, ok
While I read “why you’re singing bud" the shrek characters on my TV started dancing
Download now for free
ITS OVER SENATE I HAVE THE HIGH GROUND!
Obi Wan Kenobi lul
Oh shet
IT'S* OVER,* SENATE,* I HAVE THE HIGH GROUND!
ftfy
Hello there
@AᴅᴀᴘᴛɪᴠE Gaming, Vlogs & Basketball that's because He's Obi Wan
turning to obi wan he said:
*toyota ad plays*
"wow look at these great car rates!"
Killing the younglings at the temple would have guaranteed Anakin some serious sentence, if not straight from the Jedi council at least from the state. He basically killed Mace Windu too, a jedi master and a member of the council.
The Emperor was still the Chancellor of the Republic and being a Sith wasn't illegal. So attempting to kill the Chancellor was treason, so I think the entire jedi order would be in some hot water with the state. Especially given the Emperor was the Senate at this point.
John Wells yeah I agree that being a Sith was evil, but controlling two major states and manipulating them into war that caused millions of deaths for your own power is illegal, but the only problem is did the Jedi or anyone know of Palpatines deep influence
This all began 1000 years ago with the Rusaan Reformation
That was kind of a chaotic day. The public wouldn't necessarily ever know all the details. Who actually knew the facts? Yoda and Obi-Wan saw the footage, Obi-Wan told Padme. The clone troopers who helped Vader would know. Maybe they would be "retired" early; maybe they could be ignored or blackmailed since they took part in the atrocities.
But really, if Yoda, Obi-Wan, and Padme are all willing to move on, Anakin probably returns to his position. Otherwise, Anakin just disappears into the galaxy, either with his wife or not depending on whether she forgave him.
Obi Wan: "You were supposed to destroy the Sith not join them!"
Anakin: "Oh shit your right, yeah I am gonna go back to the light side."
DIRECTED BY GEORGE LUCAS
BAAAM BAMMM BAM BAM BAM BAAAAAM
Obi Wan ; "You were supposed to join the Sith not destroy them!
XD
@@danielabellachioma9480 when obi wan pulls out an uno reverso card😂
When a random guy makes a better scene than a billion dollar company
@@krytonson better than the sequels for sure
How dare you slate the high ground
@@krytonson wtf do you mean no? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Well they couldn’t do that because it wouldn’t follow the storyline
@@krytonson ❄️❄️❄️
Nobody:
Palpatine: The daaark sieeeede
The should do a “ what if “ series like they’re doing with Marvel
Yeah that’s star wars infinity
we don't need that! We've already got it, you're watching it
YES, just YES
This reminded me; you know how Endgame completely retconned many aspects of the MCU, like Guardians? This Star Wars ending means the original trilogy wouldn’t have happened!
Pikaia Gracilens it doesn’t necessarily have to be cannon. It’s just what if not we changed our mind
I have a theory.... Anakin is Darth Vader
Really? That seems a little far fetched don't you think? I hope that isn't added into canon, that is the WORST theory that I've seen.
Owen Dixon I'm the World's Greatest detective, and even I find this stupid. Dafuq. they have nothing in common.
Owen Dixon I have another theory..........Darth Plagieus is Jar Jar Binks
Owen Dixon i have a theory:Ben Solo is Kylo Ren
Owen Dixon i have another theory.. rey is chewbacca's daughter.. 😆
This is what makes Star Wars so good. The whole time watching ROTS you KNOW Anakin’s fate but you can’t stop but hope that this becomes the canon story line. It’s so good but so damn frustrating!
Obi wan: it’s over Anakin, I have the high ground.
Anakin: *accepts defeat “yes master”
@Máté M. perfection
I love how we all just forgive anakin for killing the younglings
It would be the only sensible thing to do.
@@xavierlauzac5922 how?
@@solis2528 would you rather kill him and be a murderer?
@@ladynebulawolf4180 nah just put him to jail
@@ladynebulawolf4180 woodchipper go BrRrRrR
What if Obi wan died to Maul but Qui gon survived and killed Maul
Ozzy he did that
He did!? My bad.
Ozzy he did that by Qui Gon training Anakin instead
Yea, Anakin has. Unless I mistake the scene, there's a point where all of them (Anakin, Obi and whoever else) are leaving on a ship when Maul attacks. Qui Gon holds him off and then they escape Maul. Or maybe I'm forgetting something...
Ozzy he already made that it's called what if qui gin trained anakin
I reckon if Obi wan just told Anakin he loved him BEFORE he cut him, everything would be alright.
If that would've happen the original trilogy would not exist
True
Sure, he just helped kill all jedi and kids, everything is alright :-)
“I loved you Anakin!”
“Wait you’re gay too?”
Written and directed by
GEORGE LUCAS
Honestly i believe they would give him a second chance because they know what the dark side is capable of and what it does to people, just as Revan has turned and redeemed himself. Why cant Anakin?
You'll never know how I got so many likes
Hi friends of Matt the destroyer
nice
One sith, two sith, red sith, blue sith
Clever
Damn
Sabers are red
The Death Star is spherical
Down goes the Jedi Council
Rise, the Empirical
Palpatine arrives and sees Obi-Wan “You turned him against me!”
Yes
Yea.... and?
@@palalavis ahaha imagine Obi-Wan saying that while they're leaving
@@claudius3359 😂
"you have done that yourself"
i am deeply convinced the force has more of an affect on jedi emotions than normal people. it's like it echos inside them, provoking emotions and thoughts that would otherwise be alien to them. i think when a jedi falls to the dark side, the force, powered by powerful negative emotions, forms an echo chamber around them that changes their thoughts, makes them more reactive. this would explain how fallen jedi can change personality so quickly, and do unimaginable things when not too long ago they were good people. perhaps that is why the jedi determined that emotion is dangerous.
I've always thought this as well
I never thought about it like that, it's pretty cool and makes alot of sense
Yeah this is why the Jedi are expected to follow a strict code in which they can’t form attachments. They know that a force user is much more susceptible to evil than a normal person because of the pull from the dark side.
Ahhh yes, that it… the echos… hmmm Kreia reaches
Anakin had a habbit of masscaring people though.
if anakin returned he would've got a purple lightsaber probably
No He Would Have Got A partially bled Indigo Lightsaber
Luke be like: they were gonna name me Jin what the hell
Luke got his name from George Lucas's last name.
He was gonna be named after alcohol
Actually would be named after qui gon jinn
If I were gonna name Luke I'd call him jizz
Nope Jin skywalker won’t do thank god he wasn’t named Jin
“Covered in charmarks, he said”-
“Verizon 5G is here, with the unprecedented performance of ultra wideband.”
I know so annoying
“Covered in charmarks, he said”- “Do you want a Reese’s? *kissy noises* ok, we’ll stop. JUST KIDDING! Not sorry! Reese’s.”
I got an ad the same time too
@@lexiibrexii5289 same lmao
Just get adblocker
Looking into his face, he said: "The perks of buying online with Clearly"
Ad came up at the perfect moment, and it was seamless.
this sounds like an audiobook. this is so good!
Random person: “So who’s your husband”
Padme: “A dude who killed about 65 children”
I simply make videos why not 66 kids
bold of you to assume it was only 65 children.
Elite Clone kid Why not 69
John Kennedy what about 67?
Lachlan Jacke5 what about 68??
2:24
Also his eyes don’t turn Sith yellow until he says “I HATE YOU!” to Obi Wan
Nah he doesnt it when he kills the trade federation before obi one fight
I mean i guess he was not fully consumed by the dark side and he did get his limbs cut off because of Obi Wan
Mr SoLiDz x yeah but then they turn back when he starts crying
It could just be an oversight tbh
Yea his eyes were already sixth yellow when he killed the trade federation
This would be incredible, but
If this was true, the high ground meme would have never be real
Jimmyn19 or if obi wan and Anakin fought Palpatine and both said: “it’s over Palpatine, WE have the high ground!”
@@zacharykim5596 dude.... that would be insane !
@@zacharykim5596 yes i hate to be a party pooper and btw what you said would be hilarious and litt but obi wan literally was on higher ground than anakin so even tho palpatine is on the ground its the same level ground obi and ani would be standing on in front of him
Now THAT is a tragedy
A small price for salvation 🤷♂️
10:05 I thought both Sidious and Plagueis played really fast and loose with the rule of 2, the former never allowing himself to be challenged after killing his master in his sleep, and the latter thinking that his apprentice would never challenge him and they'd rule together.