Whether she was sexually active or not ,for a police chief to call a 13 year old child "Characterless" makes me lose whatever little faith I have left in the police system of our country
@@ashishhembrom3905The nonchalance with which you're defending a false conclusion (in your own acceptance) of a kid to be called characterless is why the morals of society is still in ruins.
@@nemo.k.r yea, what's truly wrong with society is people putting words in others' mouth. Like you. I only said the police called her characterless because she supposedly had sexual relations with adults. Nothing more nothing less. I said word for word how and why the police called her characterless and nothing else. Take your non existent 'nonchalance' and assumed 'defenses' and shove it where the sun don't shine and maybe your head too.
The title of this case should not be called "The Aarushi Talwar Case". It should be called "Aarushi Talwar and Hemraj Banjade Case", "Aarushi and Hemraj Case" or as it is generally known as "2008 Noida Double Murder Case". Hemraj's life was also equally important.
Exactly... Some of the true crime podcasts from outside India have clearly mentioned this... Yet we Indians somewhere have a bit of casteism still left in us
I lost my 22 year old son to cancer. I did not scream or cry in front of people. My whole world ended, but I don't cry in front of people, so I can understand her not crying. Grief is an individual process.
You lost your son to cancer Nupur Talwar daughter was murdered by her own parents simple and after that they destroyed all evidence and witnesses turned hostile it’s impossible for someone to enter and kill two people and then erase all evidence after which nobody heard anything it was all pure planned Rajesh talwar said hemraj killed his daughter and tried to send the police to Nepal after which hemraj body was found on the terrace am I supposed to believe they didn’t know anything
yes how one handles grief differs from person to person....someone may not seem too affected in front of people or crying in front of people, but may be still is even more in emotional turmoil and pain than someone crying
I too have been obsessed with this case and it pains me immensely to see Aarushi never get any justice because of the incompetency of our police. If those 3 men did it, we have murderers roaming around us freely.
I don't think any outsiders have done it. Otherwise why would any outsiders take Hemraj's body to the terrace and try to hide it by covering it with a cooler lid and lock the terrace again. Obviously it was her parents.
@@yohanlobo4767if it was parents why didn't they clean the terrace footprints and hand print which was found on the terrace. Someone abruptly cut the call when Nupur called hemraj phone. If it was parents then phone must have been in their house or nearby as they didn't leave the place. Why would they take such a risk when they would have thought that police could check for hemraj phone as they were searching from him. Lastly narco tests and lie detector tests of parents were clean whereas narco tests of servants were found of conviction
This is the best coverage ever. Even in CBI there are smart people and not so smart. The police chief who gave that unconfirmed statement should have been fired or atleast be suspended..
Finally getting to this much awaited case! Leaving the truth behind, one thing that grinds my gear till today is how much the investigation was botched up by the Noida police, to the extent that digging up the truth now is too difficult and almost impossible! In my opinion, don't know whether Krishna or his friends did it or not, but Rajesh and Nupur definitely didn't do it!
i am not sure who really killed her but the worst thing about this case is how things were treated and carried about after she passed away.She was constantly berated and this was not something which was needed especially to a 13 year old and considering the fact that she might be sexually active and not investigated upon properly completely blows my mind off and deciding that she was characterless because she did stuff like that.Let's not even forget about how the police team did not even bother to collect proper evidence it was like they had not cared enough about it at all they just wanted it to be finished as soon as possible and like how the police chief did not even know her name shows how much they really cared about this case and the way they tried to point fingers at anyone they wanted to all the plausible logical theories were disregarded by the media because they wanted something that was masaledaar so ultimately a lot of things were messed up in this entire case and including the fact that the crime scene was completely botched and even if it would have had led to something important this case just remains unsolved and a huge failure of our justice system
I've heard this case from so many other crime channels. Yours is literally the best, with much more nuance, much more questions I hadn't thought about earlier (for example when Aryaan pointed out the detail about the loud air-conditioner), much more information and of course, the best narration. Looking forward to your coverage of this case was absolutely worth it.❤
Hemraj treated Arushi like his own daughter and was a very soft spoken, kind man. My house help of 19 years knows this entire clan because all Nepalis stay in touch when in India. That we too live in Noida, this is a city/state group. He confirmed that it was Krishna and the two others who did it. We approached the police but nobody was interested in listening to us because there was no direct connection with the case. Both Arushi and Hemraj didn’t deserve this tragic death. Neither did Rajesh and Nupur deserve such a shoddy treatment because the Noida police botched up the critical initial investigation. May Arushi and Hemraj find eternal peace!
My only question to you is if the outsiders killed Hemraj then why would they lock his body in upstairs and put a cooler lid to cover it so that nobody can find out that he is killed and his body is upstairs. Because the instant response of the outsider would be to immediately run away from the house. Only the parents could do this so that the police will be busy in finding Hemraj outside and when the matter cools down the parents will dispose of Hemraj's body. And the case will be closed forever stating that Hemraj ran away after killing arushi and police were not able to find him out. What a brilliant plan by her parents.
I know most people will say it was the parent's but 1. Who's blood was on the scotch bottle? 2. Who's bloody handprint was on the terrace? Also, whoever did this knew the layout of the house
I don’t know if this theory runs with the facts at hand, but what if the two murders were not committed by a single person but by different people. What if both the accused parties were at guilt. Just a random theory, but what if Hemraj was actually forcing himself on to Arushi on the said night, things got out of hand, and she banged her head on the corner of the bed and got unconscious. This led Hemraj into believing that this would leave a trace of what he tried to do if she wakes up considering she was hurt considerably. So to save himself, he killed her by slitting her throat. Then, what if the father woke up at that time and witnessed this and in a fit of rage hit Hemraj to unconsciousness. He then took him to the roof and cut his throat and came back home early in the morning so that he could pin it on the right culprit of her murder. Maybe he planned to dispose off Hemrajs body later after all the investigation was through. Maybe this wasn’t an honor killing but a revenge one. Just a thought. Still all we can do is keep guessing since not enough DNA evidence is available to determine if the blood came from 2 sources. However, this theory would justify why the toys were kept there post mortem, as a homage to their daughter in the last few grieving minutes before the case opened up the way it did.
Just a constructive criticism to Aishwarya.. please do not smile and laugh too much when telling such horrible and serious crime stories. It takes away the seriousness of the situation.
The criminals are still out there it brings a chill down in my spine. How the police investigated and screwed up the entire investigation. Somehow i am not surprised. Overall loved how you guys are sharing the info about the case and loved the ending.
What I don’t understand is that if the AC in their room was so loud that they couldn’t hear anything, how did Nupur hear the doorbell when Bharti rang at 6am? Something doesn’t add up
It is most likely that the compressor of window acs turn on and off every 10-30 minutes when the room reaches the temperature which is set in the thermostat. When only the fan is running you can hear sounds more clearly than when the compressor is running
A weird detail about the day of the murder is that; when the police first arrived and the forensic samples were collected Rajesh and Nupur Talwar asked the police if they were done with the sample collection and proceeded to clean the blood around Arushi and on her in a very weirdly normal routine and weirdly enough the police didn't care about it and let them do it. I mean I know they're doctors but dude that's your daughter. On the day of the murder, Ex-Prime Minister Manmohan Singh was visiting a nearby hospital so the police were more invested and interested in that which led to the shittiest investigation ever. About the Infamous Nupur Talwar interview, It was on Arushi's birthday that the interview happened and the way she reacted was neither too emotional nor too Cold it just seems soo to the point and scripted. I'm sorry for being over-enthusiastic I just love True crime and being a forensic Psychology student I can't help but go on blabbering about cases.
Amazing detailing, I was never fully aware what went on, was in class 7 when this incident happened. Kudos to both of you for such a compelling narrative.
I was 21When this happened and was so affected and watched every video and debates on this case..Rememberevery one of my friends discussing and investigating cos of the hurt this case gave us. now after 15 years still watching this case breaks me into tears
That's theory no. 3 where the killer had actually come to kill hemraj and aarushi ended up watching that happen and then the killer had no option but to kill aarushi and the fact that police and CBI always stick around with those two theories that it's either the talwars or the other 3 guys who murdered, they never actually investigated for any third person to he involved which makes it easier for the third person to get away with this murder
hey desi fam il ove that u guys covered this case. these is smth i belive in. okay guys I believe Aarushi wasn't the primary victim, it was Hemraj. Aarushi might've been the witness to either the crime or the culprit. all the theories ever made were just to put Aarushi as the primary focus, not Hemraj. just because Aarushi's body was found first in her own house and the lack of investigation led the entire case in the wrong direction. none of the theories proposed has made sense. they r full of loopholes. my theory is as follows: on the day of the murder, Hemraj was the only one acting weird and odd, he didn't have dinner also he did receive a 6-minute call from someone that day around 8 pm and the phone location was traced as being just 1km away from Talwar's house. probably the person or supposed culprit planned to meet Hemraj that day for smth serious. also during the leading days to the murders, Hemraj had once said that he was scared for his life. still, if this doesn't back up the theory, I have more to present. Hemraj's room had 2 doors one where u could entire his room without directly entering the main house and a second that opened into the main house adjacent to Aarushi's room. the person might've come to Hemraj to threaten him or smth as some glasses were found in his room. probably they started arguing and Hemraj might have suggested going to the rooftop and discussing as noise would wake up the Talwar family. they went to the rooftop and during a fit of rage amongst disagreements the culprit killed Hemraj, the blood splatters were indeed found on the rooftop signaling murder occurred there not in the house and dragged as the police believe. also, note why this is plausible cause during that time hemraj was in charge of rooftop keys during that time. now the culprit came down the stairs with blood on their hands so some of it made it to the stairs. As being frustrated and angry while coming down, probably drunk too, they might've tried to enter back to Hemraj's room and probably found Aarushi's room open. to note, her mother said that she doesn't recall shutting her door that night. the culprit might have thought that Aarushi witnessed everything, and might've killed her in sleep. there was no sexual motive, she only died because she might have witnessed, as killed in sleep hence no noise. hence parents didn't get alerted. it is noted that Aarushi's body was covered with sheets also said that when the murders tried to cover their victim's body, probably felt remorseful or wanted to give some respect to the victim, which maybe cause again Aarushi's murder was unplanned. later the culprit with anger stole Aarushi's and Hemraj's phone and rooftop keys, pulled out a bottle to drink, and entered Hemraj's washroom to cleanup also, said that more than one person used Hemraj's washroom that day. then proceeded to leave the house from the first door of Hemraj's room directly leading out of the house and latched from outside. I might be wrong sorry for my poor English guys. pls read and reply
Kinda make sense I too thought about this , it's totally a new perspective maybe this could be the ultimate truth or maybe not but this make sense more than any 2 other theories
@@ayushigautam785 thanks dude, i too came up with this rather late cause I've been through this case soo many times and this was the first time I thought this way around
@@Angelina_amber Interesting one I could say more believable one , people should open this case with a new perspective maybe we could get something new .
@@Angelina_amber I too went through this case several times but it never satisfies my soul to trust their stories Something is just hidden from our eyes .
@@ayushigautam785 i totally agree with u cause it's baffling to me that such famous case which has been covered infinite times still ends up with no answer as if people r deliberately doing this
After so many years, hearing 100's of version, came here to get actual insight and I'm left teary eyes... we fail as system, we fail as humans, we fail as basic of education and grade system in work... the vikram and napur is never going to get their daughter back....
I strongly believe that her parents killed her, but there is no conclusive evidence because the initial police investigation was not done properly.Reason: If someone from outside had killed Hemraj, why would they hide his body upstairs and cover it with the cooler lid? Only the parents would do this so the police would keep searching for Hemraj outside. When things calmed down, the parents could dispose of Hemraj's body.Additionally, when Aarushi's mom called Hemraj's phone in the morning, it was immediately disconnected and then switched off. The investigation showed the phone was within the area of the murder scene, meaning someone inside the house turned it off. Since Aarushi and Hemraj were already dead, only Aarushi's father could have done this.I am not challenging the CBI's investigation, but these two points clearly indicate that her parents are the real killers.The reason why they killed her can be anything. Possible scenarios include:Aarushi's father got into a heated argument with Hemraj and accidentally killed him. Aarushi witnessed this, and they felt they had no choice but to kill her too, as it would be difficult to convince a 14-year-old to stay quiet.Aarushi may have discovered something incriminating, such as wife-swapping, and threatened to tell her grandparents. Her father then threw her against a wall, causing a fatal head injury. Hemraj saw this, so he was killed too.In most cases, a killer would eliminate any witnesses, no matter who they are. It might have been easier to convince the wife not to tell anyone.
The mother looks guilty as anything. She even appeared to be smirking. It really feels like she felt she should punish her daughter for being sexually active.
This case is very similar to jon bennett ramsey , i guess it will be a mystery forever with many theories with lack of evidence which has been missed during the first day ,
Why was aishwariya smiling when she was saying her teacher lived in that building as if it was some myth or legend and not the gruesome murder of a 13 year old 😒
My questions are where is Aarushi's cellphone? Where is Hemrajs's phone? Who picked up the call? These phones can be tracked or the last location they pinged from can also be checked
My god, such production and such less subs ain’t doing the justice, you guys have become my favourite crime story tellers after the legend shams tahir khan!!
I have been in houses where the air conditioner is so noisy you don't know anything happening beyond the room. On top of that when you are also at night....i can totally believe it
You people should research more 1. Head injury was anti mortem and throat slit was post mortem for both the victims. 2. Dr Talwar offered money to the police to bring back Hemraj and that indicates misleading the investigation. 3. The magnitude of PR including a movie has been done in this case along with the teams of elite lawyers speaks for itself.
Its so scary to think that all the podcasts or many of the cases where the guilty are living free somewhere or around us, we having no idea about them 🤔
Damn you two are soooo awesome this is almost 8-months ago. I use to come after work hoping and play one your podcast. with a coffee. So interesting didn't see any new content up to now. need more guys.
One of the most tragic cases for which I always wait for any update. Where the culprit has escaped so easily. The part where Aarushi was an easy girl isnt true, I guess. I was living in Delhi when this murder happened. Never heard such a thing. In any case, never have a male help living in the house, esp if there is a young girl.
Why do I feel the mother has something to do? May didn’t kill her but atleast knows something! Weird enough she was there at the night to fix wifi, one detail that stands out to me is she wasn’t crying (I know people react to traumas in different ways) but standing there and seeing your daughter without crying or even trying to know if there is any way to save her, lastly the interview trying to fake tears and weird calmness she has, as if she knows what exactly happened!
I had never heard about this case before but that's probably because I am not Indian. So great job on covering this case and catering to ur round the world audience :)
If I could ask god anything, I have two questions for him. 1: Who killed Aarushi Talwar? 2: Why did Justin broke up with Selena? Guess we wont know the answer to either.
Guys loved hearing it from you. I think you didnt go into detail with some of the aspects. I watched this case by another true crime youtuber bella fiori and she went into a lot more details
I live in Jalvayu Vihar, a few houses away from Aarushi’s. The original old doors that are here act as noise cancellation. It’s highly likely they didn’t hear anything. Plus it’s a type-6 flat. It’s not tiny :p .
@@taanuuu4911 yes, I recently visited it due to a personal reason. Nothing weird or scary. I hope her soul rests in peace. My puppy’s friend’s mom and dad lived there (husband and wife and 3 cute dogs). Nothing weird about it. They have also planted a tree in her loving memory. I strongly feel the parents were not involved. If you want to understand the almost stoic reactions of the parents, you need to know the environment they lived in.
@@charujoshi_ i also feel that parents r not involved.. but surely they know something dark about that night that they r hiding from this world.. but at the same time i believe they r not murderers.. they dont deserve to be bullied nd defamed like this..
@@charujoshi_ i have another kind of attachment with this case.. i feel nostolgic when i see arushi face.. there is something that attracts me towards this case again nd again.. i too want to visit that flat nd i want to meet arushi's parents personally... i have burning desire to know what happens at that night..
@@taanuuu4911 they don’t live there anymore. (: I am sure they are dying to know what exactly happened to her that night . This case is intriguing indeed.
This case isn't that complicated as much as it seems. It's just a lot of negligence from so many parts and seems like some people just didn't want to solve the case either. i mean bro everyone can see what the officials are missing but why can't they. Everyone just seems to ignore so many things from the very start. And a little bit seriousness could have solved the case ig.
I just discovered u guys on Spotify and to say I'm in love is an understatement also I have to mention as a native English speaker I was floored by your English vocabulary! Keep up the good work! ✨
This is extremely poorly researched. There is an actual documentary that gets into the details of why Krishna's narco-test results were not admissible (spoiler alert: there was coercion involved). This just looks like you watched the movie Talwar and did none of your own research
There is a 4-part documentary on Disney Hotstar IIRC. I watched it some 3-4 years ago. It goes into much more detail than this. Also, I am convinced that the parents (read the dad) did it. There are things which don't make sense otherwise. Watch that documentary closely to understand what I mean.
There was a recent video on parents after their acquital..they have become spiritual after the incident and said initially they weren't..there is a guilt feeling in their statements how much ever they appear normal.. still wondering what actually happened..so many versions, movies ..wish the childs soul gets justice
It's honestly so unsettling how you guys talk about literal crimes, the way Aishwarya was smiling while talking about the death of this 13 year old, like it's some myth or legend, so apathetic, really.
@@confusedboy01 which is about real people. Imagine if one of these cases were about someone close to you sir? You wouldn't call it professionalism then.
It’s something very unsettling and off-putting how y’all approach these issues. The sly smiles by Aishwarya or the almost giddy childish excitement shown by Aryan leave a bad taste in my mouth. Very insensitive.
Goddd have been wanting you guys to cover this case ever since I've heard you first time because I knew only your narration can do full justice to this case and the conspiracies around it. I haven't listened it yet but I can confirm it in advance that am gonna love it. Thankyou for this again! Also aryaan and Aishwarya can you pls wish me luck for my 10th boards, your wishes could really help me nail my board exams ❤
I most probably assume that the Talwars were both high functioning ASPD people, and thus were behaving in a very controlled and calculated way. They did IT.
I love the interactions and between Aishwarya and aaryan .. and the way every single detail has been entailed in this podcast!!. Keep up the research ❤️
i have read and watched different versions of this case from reading hundreds of articles to watching the movie then listening to diff news channel and then podcast never in those times i believed the theory that the parents killed arushi talwar until i listened to the hatel parekh case, now i cannot unsee the similarities it feels like i finally found a closure to this case for myself through your podcast.
Leave about bell..but hw was the door closed from inside ...ok..we all know that door was closed from outside as shown in film..but how was it closed from inside ..when the murderer left home ..the door should be closed from outside . but how it is possible that it was closed from inside ..only parents can close from inside right ..or the murderer while leaving the house must have woken up the father and said "ok im leaving pl close the door"😂😂😂
@@saimanaspathapadu1299Pay attention to the diagram of the house shown in the beginning. The inner most door was only latched from the outside.. Hemant's house was accessible by the out most door directly. There are three doors.
Its not like they would cry or be sad through out. Doesn't mean they are being unempathetic. While discussing about a story for an hour long...at some point one will laugh. That's just what it is. Just being logical not bring supportive of their actions.
Its not her parents...it was someone Hemraj knew...the killer's target was Hemraj and not Arushi...but somehow Arushi could have heard a commotion coming from Hemraj's room, so she walked towards the living room, saw the killer or witnessed the crime..the killer then had no choice but to kill her too..murder weapon was a kukri used by Nepalese people
Doesn’t make sense tbh, hemraj wasn’t a big shot , he was just a house helper, if someone wanted to kill him why would they took the risk to kill him inside talwar’s house when they can caught him off guard anywhere else!
Maybe the men drinking got into an argument and try to do something to Hemraj. Aarushi would have been murdered as she would have been the only witness.
@@Anu20810you are saying exactly what happened in movie.....i think its talwars who killed.... When her mother saw body.. She immediately said hemraj did...... And how door locked from inside... When killer left the house....
Did the CBI ever track the phone locations using tower ? This could have been crucial in solving the case. Why was it disconnected etc etc. At least some information could have been found.
I've read through alot on this case and to my point, this case is a weird case where both the sides of the story have some points which make the other one to be the murdered and that's what makes this such a unique case that no one can ever confidently say if it was the talwars or someone else !! That last statement that someone today roams freely and knows what exactly happened that night in aarushi's room is so freak !!!
Heard so many versions of this story but you guys have made this so informative!!
Thank you Meghana ❤️
they are insensitive .. worst video
Whether she was sexually active or not ,for a police chief to call a 13 year old child "Characterless" makes me lose whatever little faith I have left in the police system of our country
And the fact that they called her characterless in the context of her possibly getting raped by adults is so disgusting
@aditishenai4440 huh? They concluded, be it falsely, that it was not rape though. Thats why they called her characterless. Buddy pay attention.
@@ashishhembrom3905The nonchalance with which you're defending a false conclusion (in your own acceptance) of a kid to be called characterless is why the morals of society is still in ruins.
@@nemo.k.r yea, what's truly wrong with society is people putting words in others' mouth. Like you. I only said the police called her characterless because she supposedly had sexual relations with adults. Nothing more nothing less. I said word for word how and why the police called her characterless and nothing else. Take your non existent 'nonchalance' and assumed 'defenses' and shove it where the sun don't shine and maybe your head too.
That's typical boomer misogyny and victim blaming for you.
The title of this case should not be called "The Aarushi Talwar Case". It should be called "Aarushi Talwar and Hemraj Banjade Case", "Aarushi and Hemraj Case" or as it is generally known as "2008 Noida Double Murder Case". Hemraj's life was also equally important.
Womp womp
Not really though 😂
Exactly... Some of the true crime podcasts from outside India have clearly mentioned this... Yet we Indians somewhere have a bit of casteism still left in us
@@rara-wg3qs wait is hemraj the lower caste?
@@ashishhembrom3905 yes
I lost my 22 year old son to cancer. I did not scream or cry in front of people. My whole world ended, but I don't cry in front of people, so I can understand her not crying. Grief is an individual process.
You lost your son to cancer Nupur Talwar daughter was murdered by her own parents simple and after that they destroyed all evidence and witnesses turned hostile it’s impossible for someone to enter and kill two people and then erase all evidence after which nobody heard anything it was all pure planned Rajesh talwar said hemraj killed his daughter and tried to send the police to Nepal after which hemraj body was found on the terrace am I supposed to believe they didn’t know anything
You have prepared yourself. But a sudden shock is a different thing altogether
yes how one handles grief differs from person to person....someone may not seem too affected in front of people or crying in front of people, but may be still is even more in emotional turmoil and pain than someone crying
They didnt hear the murder.
But they heard the maid ringing the bell next morning.
I have heard probably hundreds of covers of this case....but never with this precision....such a great work..
See SR pay explanation
There's no perfect crime, only imperfect investigation.
I too have been obsessed with this case and it pains me immensely to see Aarushi never get any justice because of the incompetency of our police. If those 3 men did it, we have murderers roaming around us freely.
And possible rapists too
U guys are dumb it’s the parents who did it!
I don't think any outsiders have done it.
Otherwise why would any outsiders take Hemraj's body to the terrace and try to hide it by covering it with a cooler lid and lock the terrace again.
Obviously it was her parents.
@@yohanlobo4767if it was parents why didn't they clean the terrace footprints and hand print which was found on the terrace. Someone abruptly cut the call when Nupur called hemraj phone. If it was parents then phone must have been in their house or nearby as they didn't leave the place. Why would they take such a risk when they would have thought that police could check for hemraj phone as they were searching from him. Lastly narco tests and lie detector tests of parents were clean whereas narco tests of servants were found of conviction
The way you’ve covered this case is just incredible! You deserve a Netflix show asap. Aishwarya seems to have improved in terms of narration.
Okay what?! You guys only have 40k subs? Been binging your channel all day. Going to send it to everyone I know!
This is the best coverage ever. Even in CBI there are smart people and not so smart. The police chief who gave that unconfirmed statement should have been fired or atleast be suspended..
I've been waiting for you guys to cover this one !!! Finallyyy
Finally getting to this much awaited case! Leaving the truth behind, one thing that grinds my gear till today is how much the investigation was botched up by the Noida police, to the extent that digging up the truth now is too difficult and almost impossible! In my opinion, don't know whether Krishna or his friends did it or not, but Rajesh and Nupur definitely didn't do it!
If that's so y were they reluctant to open the terrace gate n y were they so eager to clean the house n cremate
i am not sure who really killed her but the worst thing about this case is how things were treated and carried about after she passed away.She was constantly berated and this was not something which was needed especially to a 13 year old and considering the fact that she might be sexually active and not investigated upon properly completely blows my mind off and deciding that she was characterless because she did stuff like that.Let's not even forget about how the police team did not even bother to collect proper evidence it was like they had not cared enough about it at all they just wanted it to be finished as soon as possible and like how the police chief did not even know her name shows how much they really cared about this case and the way they tried to point fingers at anyone they wanted to all the plausible logical theories were disregarded by the media because they wanted something that was masaledaar so ultimately a lot of things were messed up in this entire case and including the fact that the crime scene was completely botched and even if it would have had led to something important this case just remains unsolved and a huge failure of our justice system
I've heard this case from so many other crime channels. Yours is literally the best, with much more nuance, much more questions I hadn't thought about earlier (for example when Aryaan pointed out the detail about the loud air-conditioner), much more information and of course, the best narration. Looking forward to your coverage of this case was absolutely worth it.❤
You guys Rock! Much logical and better analysis than even established crime news channels. All the best!
Love yalls set up!!!
Hope u grow more successful IA and create ur own netflix show!!!
Hemraj treated Arushi like his own daughter and was a very soft spoken, kind man. My house help of 19 years knows this entire clan because all Nepalis stay in touch when in India. That we too live in Noida, this is a city/state group. He confirmed that it was Krishna and the two others who did it. We approached the police but nobody was interested in listening to us because there was no direct connection with the case.
Both Arushi and Hemraj didn’t deserve this tragic death. Neither did Rajesh and Nupur deserve such a shoddy treatment because the Noida police botched up the critical initial investigation. May Arushi and Hemraj find eternal peace!
Who's Krishna? And other two?
Yes,other 3
Who other two ?
Krishna, raj Kumar and other guy. If these helpers killed, why were they saved by police. Looks like it became more like police vs cbi ego scuffle
My only question to you is if the outsiders killed Hemraj then why would they lock his body in upstairs and put a cooler lid to cover it so that nobody can find out that he is killed and his body is upstairs.
Because the instant response of the outsider would be to immediately run away from the house. Only the parents could do this so that the police will be busy in finding Hemraj outside and when the matter cools down the parents will dispose of Hemraj's body. And the case will be closed forever stating that Hemraj ran away after killing arushi and police were not able to find him out.
What a brilliant plan by her parents.
33:14 How did Nupur hear the doorbell ringing??
Good detail when they couldn’t hear anything that happened that night but could hear doorbell. Was their food spiked ?
it maybe because it was morning and usually ac is off at that point of time
The houshelp ringed the bell many times and waiting outside for a while (remember)
as always, top notch narration
Well said at the end, an absolute horrific crime with no answers which really annoys me too!
guys, you created such a good channel i run out of words in praising you
I know most people will say it was the parent's but 1. Who's blood was on the scotch bottle? 2. Who's bloody handprint was on the terrace? Also, whoever did this knew the layout of the house
Been waiting for this one for sooooo long!!!!
Desi Crime Podcast>>>>Board exams😂
I am more interested in the case than studying physics
@@koushikidasbarman160us moment
Lol. I thought I was the only one.
@@sreyan5266 same 😅😂
Can't agree more 😂
I found you guys by chance and I loved the podcast! Good job xx
45:59 The last sentence 😂😂 especially the tone in which it was said OG 😂
I love your podcasts a lot!! You guys are phenomenal. I can't get access to your Spotify podcasts as it's restricted for my country 😭!!
Which country?
I don’t know if this theory runs with the facts at hand, but what if the two murders were not committed by a single person but by different people. What if both the accused parties were at guilt. Just a random theory, but what if Hemraj was actually forcing himself on to Arushi on the said night, things got out of hand, and she banged her head on the corner of the bed and got unconscious. This led Hemraj into believing that this would leave a trace of what he tried to do if she wakes up considering she was hurt considerably. So to save himself, he killed her by slitting her throat. Then, what if the father woke up at that time and witnessed this and in a fit of rage hit Hemraj to unconsciousness. He then took him to the roof and cut his throat and came back home early in the morning so that he could pin it on the right culprit of her murder. Maybe he planned to dispose off Hemrajs body later after all the investigation was through. Maybe this wasn’t an honor killing but a revenge one. Just a thought. Still all we can do is keep guessing since not enough DNA evidence is available to determine if the blood came from 2 sources. However, this theory would justify why the toys were kept there post mortem, as a homage to their daughter in the last few grieving minutes before the case opened up the way it did.
Just a constructive criticism to Aishwarya.. please do not smile and laugh too much when telling such horrible and serious crime stories. It takes away the seriousness of the situation.
Lol
The case that made me start listening and watching crime podcast and stories
Aishwarya's last "fuck you" was just. ICONIC. ❤
The criminals are still out there it brings a chill down in my spine. How the police investigated and screwed up the entire investigation. Somehow i am not surprised.
Overall loved how you guys are sharing the info about the case and loved the ending.
sorry but aaryan looks lika a meme material in the thumbnail 😭
This channel deserves more popularity 🤞
What I don’t understand is that if the AC in their room was so loud that they couldn’t hear anything, how did Nupur hear the doorbell when Bharti rang at 6am? Something doesn’t add up
It is most likely that the compressor of window acs turn on and off every 10-30 minutes when the room reaches the temperature which is set in the thermostat. When only the fan is running you can hear sounds more clearly than when the compressor is running
A weird detail about the day of the murder is that; when the police first arrived and the forensic samples were collected Rajesh and Nupur Talwar asked the police if they were done with the sample collection and proceeded to clean the blood around Arushi and on her in a very weirdly normal routine and weirdly enough the police didn't care about it and let them do it. I mean I know they're doctors but dude that's your daughter. On the day of the murder, Ex-Prime Minister Manmohan Singh was visiting a nearby hospital so the police were more invested and interested in that which led to the shittiest investigation ever. About the Infamous Nupur Talwar interview, It was on Arushi's birthday that the interview happened and the way she reacted was neither too emotional nor too Cold it just seems soo to the point and scripted. I'm sorry for being over-enthusiastic I just love True crime and being a forensic Psychology student I can't help but go on blabbering about cases.
Amazing detailing, I was never fully aware what went on, was in class 7 when this incident happened. Kudos to both of you for such a compelling narrative.
I was 21When this happened and was so affected and watched every video and debates on this case..Rememberevery one of my friends discussing and investigating cos of the hurt this case gave us.
now after 15 years still watching this case breaks me into tears
What if aarushi was never meant to be killed ?
That's theory no. 3 where the killer had actually come to kill hemraj and aarushi ended up watching that happen and then the killer had no option but to kill aarushi and the fact that police and CBI always stick around with those two theories that it's either the talwars or the other 3 guys who murdered, they never actually investigated for any third person to he involved which makes it easier for the third person to get away with this murder
@rishabjain1479 exactly. This is probably a very straight forward case that fucked up when the evidence got destroyed
Your podcasts are like the favourite series you binge on while snacking on your favourite food 🥹
hey desi fam il ove that u guys covered this case. these is smth i belive in. okay guys I believe Aarushi wasn't the primary victim, it was Hemraj. Aarushi might've been the witness to either the crime or the culprit. all the theories ever made were just to put Aarushi as the primary focus, not Hemraj. just because Aarushi's body was found first in her own house and the lack of investigation led the entire case in the wrong direction. none of the theories proposed has made sense. they r full of loopholes. my theory is as follows:
on the day of the murder, Hemraj was the only one acting weird and odd, he didn't have dinner also he did receive a 6-minute call from someone that day around 8 pm and the phone location was traced as being just 1km away from Talwar's house. probably the person or supposed culprit planned to meet Hemraj that day for smth serious. also during the leading days to the murders, Hemraj had once said that he was scared for his life. still, if this doesn't back up the theory, I have more to present. Hemraj's room had 2 doors one where u could entire his room without directly entering the main house and a second that opened into the main house adjacent to Aarushi's room. the person might've come to Hemraj to threaten him or smth as some glasses were found in his room. probably they started arguing and Hemraj might have suggested going to the rooftop and discussing as noise would wake up the Talwar family. they went to the rooftop and during a fit of rage amongst disagreements the culprit killed Hemraj, the blood splatters were indeed found on the rooftop signaling murder occurred there not in the house and dragged as the police believe. also, note why this is plausible cause during that time hemraj was in charge of rooftop keys during that time. now the culprit came down the stairs with blood on their hands so some of it made it to the stairs. As being frustrated and angry while coming down, probably drunk too, they might've tried to enter back to Hemraj's room and probably found Aarushi's room open. to note, her mother said that she doesn't recall shutting her door that night. the culprit might have thought that Aarushi witnessed everything, and might've killed her in sleep. there was no sexual motive, she only died because she might have witnessed, as killed in sleep hence no noise. hence parents didn't get alerted. it is noted that Aarushi's body was covered with sheets also said that when the murders tried to cover their victim's body, probably felt remorseful or wanted to give some respect to the victim, which maybe cause again Aarushi's murder was unplanned. later the culprit with anger stole Aarushi's and Hemraj's phone and rooftop keys, pulled out a bottle to drink, and entered Hemraj's washroom to cleanup also, said that more than one person used Hemraj's washroom that day. then proceeded to leave the house from the first door of Hemraj's room directly leading out of the house and latched from outside. I might be wrong sorry for my poor English guys. pls read and reply
Kinda make sense I too thought about this , it's totally a new perspective maybe this could be the ultimate truth or maybe not but this make sense more than any 2 other theories
@@ayushigautam785 thanks dude, i too came up with this rather late cause I've been through this case soo many times and this was the first time I thought this way around
@@Angelina_amber Interesting one I could say more believable one , people should open this case with a new perspective maybe we could get something new .
@@Angelina_amber I too went through this case several times but it never satisfies my soul to trust their stories Something is just hidden from our eyes .
@@ayushigautam785 i totally agree with u cause it's baffling to me that such famous case which has been covered infinite times still ends up with no answer as if people r deliberately doing this
After so many years, hearing 100's of version, came here to get actual insight and I'm left teary eyes... we fail as system, we fail as humans, we fail as basic of education and grade system in work... the vikram and napur is never going to get their daughter back....
I strongly believe that her parents killed her, but there is no conclusive evidence because the initial police investigation was not done properly.Reason: If someone from outside had killed Hemraj, why would they hide his body upstairs and cover it with the cooler lid? Only the parents would do this so the police would keep searching for Hemraj outside. When things calmed down, the parents could dispose of Hemraj's body.Additionally, when Aarushi's mom called Hemraj's phone in the morning, it was immediately disconnected and then switched off. The investigation showed the phone was within the area of the murder scene, meaning someone inside the house turned it off. Since Aarushi and Hemraj were already dead, only Aarushi's father could have done this.I am not challenging the CBI's investigation, but these two points clearly indicate that her parents are the real killers.The reason why they killed her can be anything. Possible scenarios include:Aarushi's father got into a heated argument with Hemraj and accidentally killed him. Aarushi witnessed this, and they felt they had no choice but to kill her too, as it would be difficult to convince a 14-year-old to stay quiet.Aarushi may have discovered something incriminating, such as wife-swapping, and threatened to tell her grandparents. Her father then threw her against a wall, causing a fatal head injury. Hemraj saw this, so he was killed too.In most cases, a killer would eliminate any witnesses, no matter who they are. It might have been easier to convince the wife not to tell anyone.
Wow totally amazed by the level of details you know despite all the coverage. Kudos to you and your team.
The mother looks guilty as anything. She even appeared to be smirking. It really feels like she felt she should punish her daughter for being sexually active.
I have loved Your podcasts since the very start. But this one particularly was a Crazily LIT, one hell of an episode 🔥
Its dinner time, lets open TH-cam. Oh it's the Delhi Crime guys lessgooo
This case is very similar to jon bennett ramsey , i guess it will be a mystery forever with many theories with lack of evidence which has been missed during the first day ,
Why was aishwariya smiling when she was saying her teacher lived in that building as if it was some myth or legend and not the gruesome murder of a 13 year old 😒
My questions are where is Aarushi's cellphone? Where is Hemrajs's phone? Who picked up the call? These phones can be tracked or the last location they pinged from can also be checked
My god, such production and such less subs ain’t doing the justice, you guys have become my favourite crime story tellers after the legend shams tahir khan!!
You guys narrated the film
Before watching this video I read an article last year and got to the conclusion that the mother was the murderer.
Explain how ?
I have been in houses where the air conditioner is so noisy you don't know anything happening beyond the room. On top of that when you are also at night....i can totally believe it
You people should research more
1. Head injury was anti mortem and throat slit was post mortem for both the victims.
2. Dr Talwar offered money to the police to bring back Hemraj and that indicates misleading the investigation.
3. The magnitude of PR including a movie has been done in this case along with the teams of elite lawyers speaks for itself.
Its so scary to think that all the podcasts or many of the cases where the guilty are living free somewhere or around us, we having no idea about them 🤔
I'm supposed to be studying chem for boards, but Desi crime podcast is so much better 🕺🏻🕺🏻
(btw the merch is so fire 🔥)
Bhai same 😂
Holy fuck. Today is 24th May and this video just popped in my recommendations. RIP. I do not want any supernatural signs.
Damn you two are soooo awesome this is almost 8-months ago. I use to come after work hoping and play one your podcast.
with a coffee. So interesting didn't see any new content up to now. need more guys.
One of the most tragic cases for which I always wait for any update. Where the culprit has escaped so easily. The part where Aarushi was an easy girl isnt true, I guess. I was living in Delhi when this murder happened. Never heard such a thing. In any case, never have a male help living in the house, esp if there is a young girl.
Why do I feel the mother has something to do? May didn’t kill her but atleast knows something! Weird enough she was there at the night to fix wifi, one detail that stands out to me is she wasn’t crying (I know people react to traumas in different ways) but standing there and seeing your daughter without crying or even trying to know if there is any way to save her, lastly the interview trying to fake tears and weird calmness she has, as if she knows what exactly happened!
I had never heard about this case before but that's probably because I am not Indian. So great job on covering this case and catering to ur round the world audience :)
I am totally confused and sad with this case. Such a tragedy.
Well all the ac's were like that in early 2000's .. the compressors were different.
The ending was everything.
If I could ask god anything, I have two questions for him.
1: Who killed Aarushi Talwar?
2: Why did Justin broke up with Selena?
Guess we wont know the answer to either.
😂😂😂
YOU ARE SO PEAK OF TRUE CRIME
Guys loved hearing it from you. I think you didnt go into detail with some of the aspects. I watched this case by another true crime youtuber bella fiori and she went into a lot more details
You just seem to be narrating the whole script of Talvar film. 😂
I live in Jalvayu Vihar, a few houses away from Aarushi’s. The original old doors that are here act as noise cancellation. It’s highly likely they didn’t hear anything. Plus it’s a type-6 flat. It’s not tiny :p .
Have u seen arushi's house L 32?... do u find anything scary or weird in this house
@@taanuuu4911 yes, I recently visited it due to a personal reason. Nothing weird or scary. I hope her soul rests in peace. My puppy’s friend’s mom and dad lived there (husband and wife and 3 cute dogs). Nothing weird about it. They have also planted a tree in her loving memory. I strongly feel the parents were not involved. If you want to understand the almost stoic reactions of the parents, you need to know the environment they lived in.
@@charujoshi_ i also feel that parents r not involved.. but surely they know something dark about that night that they r hiding from this world.. but at the same time i believe they r not murderers.. they dont deserve to be bullied nd defamed like this..
@@charujoshi_ i have another kind of attachment with this case.. i feel nostolgic when i see arushi face.. there is something that attracts me towards this case again nd again.. i too want to visit that flat nd i want to meet arushi's parents personally... i have burning desire to know what happens at that night..
@@taanuuu4911 they don’t live there anymore. (: I am sure they are dying to know what exactly happened to her that night . This case is intriguing indeed.
10:14 his reaction 😂😂
This case isn't that complicated as much as it seems. It's just a lot of negligence from so many parts and seems like some people just didn't want to solve the case either. i mean bro everyone can see what the officials are missing but why can't they. Everyone just seems to ignore so many things from the very start. And a little bit seriousness could have solved the case ig.
What are your views on the pov of talwar movie directed by Meghna Gulzar. If anyone has watched?
Would absolutely love to hear your opinion on the Sheena Bora case especially with the debacle that was Indrani Mukherjee’s documentary.
I just discovered u guys on Spotify and to say I'm in love is an understatement also I have to mention as a native English speaker I was floored by your English vocabulary! Keep up the good work! ✨
This is extremely poorly researched. There is an actual documentary that gets into the details of why Krishna's narco-test results were not admissible (spoiler alert: there was coercion involved). This just looks like you watched the movie Talwar and did none of your own research
what's the documentary called?
Also narco tests are not admissible in courts
There is a 4-part documentary on Disney Hotstar IIRC. I watched it some 3-4 years ago. It goes into much more detail than this. Also, I am convinced that the parents (read the dad) did it. There are things which don't make sense otherwise. Watch that documentary closely to understand what I mean.
There was a recent video on parents after their acquital..they have become spiritual after the incident and said initially they weren't..there is a guilt feeling in their statements how much ever they appear normal.. still wondering what actually happened..so many versions, movies ..wish the childs soul gets justice
It's honestly so unsettling how you guys talk about literal crimes, the way Aishwarya was smiling while talking about the death of this 13 year old, like it's some myth or legend, so apathetic, really.
Same thoughts!
Same thoughts!
Same! I’ve binged watched almost all their videos and how casually their approach these topics is APPALLING!
That is what we call professionalism, they can't wail while reciting the cas e 🙄
@@confusedboy01 which is about real people. Imagine if one of these cases were about someone close to you sir? You wouldn't call it professionalism then.
It’s something very unsettling and off-putting how y’all approach these issues. The sly smiles by Aishwarya or the almost giddy childish excitement shown by Aryan leave a bad taste in my mouth. Very insensitive.
Indeed .. shameless they are
@@meshram5how does that make them shameless?
Goddd have been wanting you guys to cover this case ever since I've heard you first time because I knew only your narration can do full justice to this case and the conspiracies around it. I haven't listened it yet but I can confirm it in advance that am gonna love it. Thankyou for this again! Also aryaan and Aishwarya can you pls wish me luck for my 10th boards, your wishes could really help me nail my board exams ❤
The ending 😂😂😂 good one
I most probably assume that the Talwars were both high functioning ASPD people, and thus were behaving in a very controlled and calculated way.
They did IT.
What about Arushi’s private parts being cleaned by disinfectants that was the major reason for the Talwars to be the main suspects
alcohol bottle used to wipe away fingerprints
Closing with an 'f' is an absolute'Some
You guys level of assessment and language to present it is of high quality
I love the interactions and between Aishwarya and aaryan .. and the way every single detail has been entailed in this podcast!!. Keep up the research ❤️
Yayyyy
i have read and watched different versions of this case from reading hundreds of articles to watching the movie then listening to diff news channel and then podcast never in those times i believed the theory that the parents killed arushi talwar until i listened to the hatel parekh case, now i cannot unsee the similarities it feels like i finally found a closure to this case for myself through your podcast.
Whats with hatel parekh case??
@@Astral-zn2vs give it a listen you will love that episode
@@Astral-zn2vs a very sensational case in the early 90s. Its on Google difficult to explain here.
If the ac is so loud, how did nupur talwar hear the door bell rang by the housekeeper
She will say she was sleeping at the timer and she's a deep sleeper and she just happens to be awake at the time
Leave about bell..but hw was the door closed from inside ...ok..we all know that door was closed from outside as shown in film..but how was it closed from inside ..when the murderer left home ..the door should be closed from outside . but how it is possible that it was closed from inside ..only parents can close from inside right ..or the murderer while leaving the house must have woken up the father and said "ok im leaving pl close the door"😂😂😂
@@saimanaspathapadu1299 true..
@@saimanaspathapadu1299Pay attention to the diagram of the house shown in the beginning. The inner most door was only latched from the outside.. Hemant's house was accessible by the out most door directly. There are three doors.
@@saachishetti2939 if inner most door was latched from outside how can that lady open it and talk to the servant and say that I will throw the key 🤣🤣
btw I think in the Nupur Talwar interview , it was revealed by the reporter that she did cry but off camera
nah here's the sub....great content..
Everyone know parents are killers...! But still people blame innocent servants...
I dnt understand why you guys are giggling while sharing the detail about a murder..show some empathy
Exactly my thought
Its not like they would cry or be sad through out. Doesn't mean they are being unempathetic. While discussing about a story for an hour long...at some point one will laugh. That's just what it is. Just being logical not bring supportive of their actions.
Immature..
@@pearlskis9741The same thought I have
hey guys jz loved it the narration i wanted u to do on jolly joseph case
They actually covered it prior
where
@@palviika8712
Its not her parents...it was someone Hemraj knew...the killer's target was Hemraj and not Arushi...but somehow Arushi could have heard a commotion coming from Hemraj's room, so she walked towards the living room, saw the killer or witnessed the crime..the killer then had no choice but to kill her too..murder weapon was a kukri used by Nepalese people
Doesn’t make sense tbh, hemraj wasn’t a big shot , he was just a house helper, if someone wanted to kill him why would they took the risk to kill him inside talwar’s house when they can caught him off guard anywhere else!
Maybe the men drinking got into an argument and try to do something to Hemraj. Aarushi would have been murdered as she would have been the only witness.
@@Anu20810you are saying exactly what happened in movie.....i think its talwars who killed.... When her mother saw body.. She immediately said hemraj did...... And how door locked from inside... When killer left the house....
I think harajes friends got drank & assaulted Aruhi, & then killed her n haraj, as he was the witness because they did not want to get caught.
@@AK-xj2di yea than they take rajesh body to terrace... How these friends have keys🤣
10 days to my tenth boards and this is what I'm doing 💀
10th boards are easy
19:17 is a mood
As a fellow Swiftie, so true
Aishwarya you telling the story in so precise manner, it was great. thanks for sharing.
Why didn't police try to trace mobile phones on the first place?
Did the CBI ever track the phone locations using tower ? This could have been crucial in solving the case. Why was it disconnected etc etc. At least some information could have been found.
I've read through alot on this case and to my point, this case is a weird case where both the sides of the story have some points which make the other one to be the murdered and that's what makes this such a unique case that no one can ever confidently say if it was the talwars or someone else !!
That last statement that someone today roams freely and knows what exactly happened that night in aarushi's room is so freak !!!