I find Deborah Lipstadt to be genius and a fascinating speaker. She has mastered her many subjects and puts huge historical events into story form that is so easy to understand. Thank you for this film!
Thank you. It's the end of Yom Kippeur-- in Israel, and in a state of being touched and inspired by the services and how it connects me to past generations, I saw this somehow on You Tube. So well said, thank you. I was thirteen years old at the time of the trial, already in Habonim, the Zionish youth organization. Two years earlier, I had happened upon something that changed my life: my father's V-mail to my mother when he was serving as a soldier in WWII. There were photo, too: piles of terribly emaciated bodies. Reading the letter, I came to understand that my father had been among the American soldiers who first came to rescue the people in concentration camps. A great shock; children did not then see photographs of the camps; grownups hushed each other so children wouldn't overhear their conversations about the Shoah. I read the diary of Anna Frank, then Habonim. So here I am, 71, 50 years in Israel, having started my own tribe...2 children, 6 grandchildren. A body of artwork often connected to what happened to my people. (www.elinoreart.com) I thank you for your important work.
God bless you Deborah Lipstadt for so eloquently telling us these stories. The Survivors had to go through unspeakable events to deliver their stories and it’s important for us to hear them and to tell them again. So that we and our children and their children never forget.
In Bulgaria, the Orthodox Church opposes the government's intentions to deport Jews, bulgarian citizens, to Poland. And he succeeds. Despite hostile legislation and persecution by the authorities, all survived. Bulgaria was an ally of Germany at that time.
At 32:28, I'm a little surprised by Dr. Lippstadt's failure to pronounce Bełżec correctly. It isn't pronounced "Bell-zec," it is more correctly pronounced "Buh-zhetz" (ł - "uh", ż = the g sound in "mirage"; and c = tz).
September 2019 . a few days ago I was naive enough to film for a man while he stood on the "Hitler" podium In Nuremburg Zeppelinfeld.After thanking me and chatting he then told me that Churchill had been a war criminal.So as Brecht says at the end of Aturo Ui " The bitch that bore him ( Hitler) is on heat again"He actually asked me if I had read David Irving which I had .Face to face with a denier- so then I went to Mauthausen.I have translated the memoirs of an Auschwitz survivor, so it felt like home.see Lipstadt on Irving and dangers for US NOW at 11 min 40 secs
Spot on. I can not add anything to the excellent and factual comments below except to say that I hope there is a day when we have open public hearings based on evidence and the rule of law.
+phil123711 UM, actually, Deborah Lipstadt iS a professor of history. She has a doctorate in European history, along with Jewish history, so that's pure bullshit.
You obviously have no idea how universities (or areas of knowledge) are organized, which makes me suspect that you've never been to one. For instance, there is no reason that someone trained as a historian couldn't teach in a Religious Studies department. Lipstadt has a masters degree and a Ph.D. in Jewish history and teaches modern Jewish history and Holocaust studies at Emory University. I'm not sure which department (or departments) she's affiliated with, but she is definitely a historian. David Irving, on the other hand, has no degree, and his claims were thoroughly discredited when he lost his libel action against Lipstadt and her publisher.
@@jasonwiley798 I am not surprised at all when native English speakers make fools of themselves displaying their lack of education and then take pride in it.
When I think of the Eichmann trial I always think of that early 1960's grainy B&W videotape, that would occasionally lose it's vertical footing, and that glass box Eichmann was forced to sit in. It is a credit to Israel that this man was brought back to stand trial, though admittedly it was a bit of a show trial; everyone knew the verdict would be guilty. Wait, I am not an Eichmann defender. Everyone knew beforehand the verdict would be guilty because this Grand Engineer of mass murder was guilty as hell.
All the censorship that the elites make about comments about this subject makes many people think that nor Deborah Lipstadt neither similar people believe in what they say. Tolerance to everyone views is esential to gain credibility. oh yes
I've read both Denying the Holocaust and History on Trial. Both are well worth the read if one is trying to suss out how deniers think and distort historical facts.
Delane The best take on racism stems from black authors who actually experience it, A rich white male have some insight on the matter, but it would all be academic. The fact Lipstadt is Jewish is great.
Delane So the Americans, Canadians, English, Scottish, or French forces who defeated German Fascism were not ''impartial''? Why would they all conspire to promote a false narrative? The Germans were defeated. I don't see why the need to promote a lie against Germany when they were crushed.
There was a German movie about Fritz Bauer a few years ago but it was slightly disappointing owing to a superfluous sub-plot and over-emphasis on Bauer's homosexuality. BTW, besides his investigation into Eichmann's whereabouts, he also spent several years trying to locate Joseph Mengele.
TO ALL OF YOU WHO DO NOT BELIEVE..... What kind of evidence would you accept? Would you accept the testimony of the victim(s) of the crime? I would guess that you probably would not, since you appear not to do so. Would you believe the testimony of the perpetrator of the crime? The actual words of one of the persons who ran one of the "Camps"? Or would you, like others do, say that this person's testimony was coerced or that he was tortured into saying what he did? Instead of believing the truth, from the source, you would rather believe a lie from someone who would have you believe their 'agenda'. Read the Nuremburg Trial transcripts. Read the words of those who stood trial, accused of taking part in the deaths of millions of human beings. You will find something that is quite telling in it's absence...NOT ONE OF THE DEFENDENTS DENIED THAT PEOPLE WERE SYSTEMATICALLY AND PURPOSFULLY KILLED IN THE CAMPS, only that they were following orders to do as they did. Strange that while they, the ones accused of doing the crime, do not deny the Holocaust took place, people who were not there now want to be believed when they claim it never happened. So very strange indeed.
they know it happened, its just another way for them to release their hate, antisemites have a very simple brain structure, it goes, from extreme hate (of Jews) to denial bypassing facts and truths
It's so sad to see humans who hate others without ever knowing the individuals that their hate is directed towards. I have difficulty even grasping that someone can be that way. So sad....so very sad.
Physical & Documentary evidence from uninterested sources which does exist eyewitness testimony is the worst form of evidence and you do no favours being dependant on it.
After reading her book I too had doubts about the Argentina police, or anyone else being a aware of the operation. I emailed three different authors of books about Eichman's capture, two said it could not have happened. A third said he saw a report that did say that said that MIGHT BE HAVE HAPPENED. This author said the report came from a very dubious source and couldn't be verified I have attended many lectures from Mossad members and others involved and I always ask this question and receive the same negative response with reasons why it could never have happened. Also, I met Peter Malik's son a few years ago and asked him about going after Mengele. This is the son of the man who actually grabbed Eichman that night. I asked him about if the team persued Mengele and he said Present Ben Gurion said no, he did not want two possible hangings
Primo Levi on why Jews didn't revolt: Why didn’t people rise up and rebel? Rebellion requires hope and some physical strength. Why didn’t people try to escape? Who could be missing from the morning and night roll calls if for every one missing, ten would be shot randomly and on the spot. Torture, physical and mental, is perpetrated every minute of existence.
Bomber Harris the top British fighter Pilot who led the Dresden bombing in 45 and understood the only language Hitler knew was massive force. As Bomber Harris said. "The Nazis entered this war under the rather childish delusion that they were going to bomb everyone else, and nobody was going to bomb them. At Rotterdam, London, Warsaw and half a hundred other places, they put their rather naive theory into operation. They sowed the wind, and now they are going to reap the whirlwind." Bomber Harris in 1977. I would have ordered the Dresden bombing again. Did the Nazis think they could murder millions of innocent civilians and there would be no response.
"Multitudes are made up of one, by one, by one" - very poignant! All those millions of people who never got to tell their stories. Heaven must be full of stories!
All the censorship that the elites make about comments about this subject makes many people think that nor Deborah Lipstadt neither similar people believe in what they say. Tolerance to everyone views is esential to gain credibility. yes oh yes
I’ve read an incredible amount of information on this, and I’ve even watched this lecture more than once. I do not remember hearing or reading anything about the Argentine Police following Eichmann, AND saw his capture. Now I have to research this new tidbit. 🤷♀️
All the censorship that the elites make about comments about this subject makes many people think that nor Deborah Lipstadt neither similar people believe in what they say. Tolerance to everyone views is esential to gain credibility. yes yes
She always makes the statement. The Holocaust which has the dubious distinction of being the best documented genocide in the world. Guess what Deborah, thanks to all the IDF videos and the vast footage from Palestinian victims.The Genocide of Gaza by Israel 2023/24 has the dubious distinction of being the best documented genocide in the world.
CAN ANY US OR ANY OTHER COUNTRIES' MILITARY PERSONNEL/OFFICIAL DISOBEY OR NOT CARRY OUT MILITARY/HEAD OF COUNTRY'S ORDERS? IF THEY DID THEY WILL BE COUTMARTIALLED, PUNISHED, THEY ARE CONSIDERED TRAITORS. SEE ON U TUBE BENJAMIN FREEDMAN'S SPEECH @ WASHINGTON DC WILLARD HOTEL IN 1962.
Thumbs up for the enabled comment section - people on all sides have the right to be stupid, to be outspoken or even being lied to by whomesoever. (btw. the word 'historian' does not imply any degree or education to a conceived grasp of the historic method - everybody can call himself a historian ... just as any university degree signifies being excellent in that field of interest)
As I understand it, she studied political science, history, and literature. But she doesn't have a degree in history, as far as I know. When she wrote her first book she was a prof. of religion.
There was a great video of David Irving recounting his encounter with Deborah Lipstadt at Emory University. Unfortunately, I can't find it on TH-cam anymore. I think I know why: it made Professor Lipstadt look really bad.
She seems to be tossing off a lot of things I have never heard as if they were proven fact. Who helped Eichmann out of Europe, prove it. If I am being educated then do the job.
uh duh Eichmann flees Germany in 1945. Duh Eichmann shows up in South America in 1960. Er duh they have his passport under pseudonym, Italian authorities Italian passport duh
Utterly riveting and fascinating. This is going on my iPod!
I find Deborah Lipstadt to be genius and a fascinating speaker. She has mastered her many subjects and puts huge historical events into story form that is so easy to understand. Thank you for this film!
Yes she’s a terrific speaker and story teller.
*39:30** **_"genocide happens to large numbers of people, it also happens to individuals - one, by one, by one"_*
Thank you. It's the end of Yom Kippeur-- in Israel, and in a state of being touched and inspired by the services and how it connects me to past generations, I saw this somehow on You Tube. So well said, thank you. I was thirteen years old at the time of the trial, already in Habonim, the Zionish youth organization.
Two years earlier, I had happened upon something that changed my life: my father's V-mail to my mother when he was serving as a soldier in WWII. There were photo, too: piles of terribly emaciated bodies. Reading the letter, I came to understand that my father had been among the American soldiers who first came to rescue the people in concentration camps. A great shock; children did not then see photographs of the camps; grownups hushed each other so children wouldn't overhear their conversations about the Shoah.
I read the diary of Anna Frank, then Habonim.
So here I am, 71, 50 years in Israel, having started my own tribe...2 children, 6 grandchildren.
A body of artwork often connected to what happened to my people. (www.elinoreart.com)
I thank you for your important work.
Why are the comments disabled on so many of these videos about Lipstadt? What are they afraid of?
Truth, which they address as trolling.Peace
They’re afraid of their centuries long plan unraveling. But there’s no stopping it.
God bless you Deborah Lipstadt for so eloquently telling us these stories. The Survivors had to go through unspeakable events to deliver their stories and it’s important for us to hear them and to tell them again. So that we and our children and their children never forget.
stories are fiction. .
In Bulgaria, the Orthodox Church opposes the government's intentions to deport Jews, bulgarian citizens, to Poland. And he succeeds. Despite hostile legislation and persecution by the authorities, all survived. Bulgaria was an ally of Germany at that time.
At 32:28, I'm a little surprised by Dr. Lippstadt's failure to pronounce Bełżec correctly. It isn't pronounced "Bell-zec," it is more correctly pronounced "Buh-zhetz" (ł - "uh", ż = the g sound in "mirage"; and c = tz).
Polish pronunciation is a minefield. I have an English friend who speaks Polish and Japanese, he found Japanese easier to learn.
I can see why she doesn’t want to debate Irving and wouldn’t speak in her defence at the libel trial
cause her story is fake. . Just like that diamond eating/shitting woman? What was her name? Zisblatt?
*53:40** the only man in israels history to ever be sentenced to death*
September 2019 . a few days ago I was naive enough to film for a man while he stood on the "Hitler" podium In Nuremburg Zeppelinfeld.After thanking me and chatting he then told me that Churchill had been a war criminal.So as Brecht says at the end of Aturo Ui
" The bitch that bore him ( Hitler) is on heat again"He actually asked me if I had read David Irving which I had .Face to face with a denier- so then I went to Mauthausen.I have translated the memoirs of an Auschwitz survivor, so it felt like home.see Lipstadt on Irving and dangers for US NOW at 11 min 40 secs
Disgalon was here. \\\
Lots of sad rhetoric and make believe...
23:50
Spot on. I can not add anything to the excellent and factual comments below except to say that I hope there is a day when we have open public hearings based on evidence and the rule of law.
"rule of law" ??? Do you say those words whne you are bombing civilians in Gazsa?
Sometimes people's words and writings reveal their racism.
She's a professor in religion not history.
She got her Ph.D. in modern Jewish history.
On the other hand, Irving never earned a degree, having dropped studies twice.
+phil123711 UM, actually, Deborah Lipstadt iS a professor of history. She has a doctorate in European history, along with Jewish history, so that's pure bullshit.
You obviously have no idea how universities (or areas of knowledge) are organized, which makes me suspect that you've never been to one. For instance, there is no reason that someone trained as a historian couldn't teach in a Religious Studies department. Lipstadt has a masters degree and a Ph.D. in Jewish history and teaches modern Jewish history and Holocaust studies at Emory University. I'm not sure which department (or departments) she's affiliated with, but she is definitely a historian. David Irving, on the other hand, has no degree, and his claims were thoroughly discredited when he lost his libel action against Lipstadt and her publisher.
Who cares? Only naive people believe testimonies over science & facts..
She speaks about truth until it applies to the Palestinians.
The pronunciation is eysh-munn, not eye-kh-man.
So what
@@jasonwiley798 I am not surprised at all when native English speakers make fools of themselves displaying their lack of education and then take pride in it.
@@trijezdci4588 And I get tired of pedants who change the subject to show how smart they are.
and i suppose you don't like her Queens accent either. not everyone can speak German fluently. sowhat.
3:46 ... what about Lazar Kaganovich? Was his name well know? No? Why? lol
A well paid shill go and get a real job Deb
Eichmann was the persecuted one.
I'm going to press the dislike button now.
You seem to be a very lovely person.
Ksenobite Like you Jews do to children in the Gaza.. Or drive tractors over peace workers.. th-cam.com/video/_xluVxkbNxA/w-d-xo.html
I don't blame you .. Fake joo stories make my semite stomach churn
What about truth for Palestinians? (Silence)
This is the first time I have heard that the Argentinian govt was aware at the time of the abduction.
When I think of the Eichmann trial I always think of that early 1960's grainy B&W videotape, that would occasionally lose it's vertical footing, and that glass box Eichmann was forced to sit in. It is a credit to Israel that this man was brought back to stand trial, though admittedly it was a bit of a show trial; everyone knew the verdict would be guilty. Wait, I am not an Eichmann defender. Everyone knew beforehand the verdict would be guilty because this Grand Engineer of mass murder was guilty as hell.
What about Eichmann's assistants and Secretary, are they mass murderers also?
All the censorship that the elites make about comments about this subject makes many people think that nor Deborah Lipstadt neither similar people believe in what they say. Tolerance to everyone views is esential to gain credibility. oh yes
I've read both Denying the Holocaust and History on Trial. Both are well worth the read if one is trying to suss out how deniers think and distort historical facts.
Delane The best take on racism stems from black authors who actually experience it, A rich white male have some insight on the matter, but it would all be academic. The fact Lipstadt is Jewish is great.
Delane So the Americans, Canadians, English, Scottish, or French forces who defeated German Fascism were not ''impartial''? Why would they all conspire to promote a false narrative? The Germans were defeated. I don't see why the need to promote a lie against Germany when they were crushed.
Delane YEs, I've read articles and oral history testimony. I actually went to the court building in Nuremberg.
hey pretty boy@@troyruss4112
@@wovokanarchy Lipstadt could use a good anarchist... of course, after his sex change is completed.
There was a German movie about Fritz Bauer a few years ago but it was slightly disappointing owing to a superfluous sub-plot and over-emphasis on Bauer's homosexuality. BTW, besides his investigation into Eichmann's whereabouts, he also spent several years trying to locate Joseph Mengele.
TO ALL OF YOU WHO DO NOT BELIEVE..... What kind of evidence would you accept? Would you accept the testimony of the victim(s) of the crime? I would guess that you probably would not, since you appear not to do so. Would you believe the testimony of the perpetrator of the crime? The actual words of one of the persons who ran one of the "Camps"? Or would you, like others do, say that this person's testimony was coerced or that he was tortured into saying what he did? Instead of believing the truth, from the source, you would rather believe a lie from someone who would have you believe their 'agenda'.
Read the Nuremburg Trial transcripts. Read the words of those who stood trial, accused of taking part in the deaths of millions of human beings. You will find something that is quite telling in it's absence...NOT ONE OF THE DEFENDENTS DENIED THAT PEOPLE WERE SYSTEMATICALLY AND PURPOSFULLY KILLED IN THE CAMPS, only that they were following orders to do as they did.
Strange that while they, the ones accused of doing the crime, do not deny the Holocaust took place, people who were not there now want to be believed when they claim it never happened. So very strange indeed.
they know it happened, its just another way for them to release their hate, antisemites have a very simple brain structure, it goes, from extreme hate (of Jews) to denial bypassing facts and truths
It's so sad to see humans who hate others without ever knowing the individuals that their hate is directed towards. I have difficulty even grasping that someone can be that way. So sad....so very sad.
Sad
I stole this for my files thanks!
Physical & Documentary evidence from uninterested sources which does exist eyewitness testimony is the worst form of evidence and you do no favours being dependant on it.
After reading her book I too had doubts about the Argentina police, or anyone else being a aware of the operation.
I emailed three different authors of books about Eichman's capture, two said it could not have happened. A third said he saw a report that did say that said that MIGHT BE HAVE HAPPENED. This author said the report came from a very dubious source and couldn't be verified
I have attended many lectures from Mossad members and others involved and I always ask this question and receive the same negative response with reasons why it could never have happened.
Also, I met Peter Malik's son a few years ago and asked him about going after Mengele. This is the son of the man who actually grabbed Eichman that night. I asked him about if the team persued Mengele and he said Present Ben Gurion said no, he did not want two possible hangings
Primo Levi on why Jews didn't revolt: Why didn’t people rise up and rebel? Rebellion requires hope and some physical strength. Why didn’t people try to escape? Who could be missing from the morning and night roll calls if for every one missing, ten would be shot randomly and on the spot. Torture, physical and mental, is perpetrated every minute of existence.
Bomber Harris the top British fighter Pilot who led the Dresden bombing in 45 and understood the only language Hitler knew was massive force.
As Bomber Harris said.
"The Nazis entered this war under the rather childish delusion that they were going to bomb everyone else, and nobody was going to bomb them. At Rotterdam, London, Warsaw and half a hundred other places, they put their rather naive theory into operation. They sowed the wind, and now they are going to reap the whirlwind."
Bomber Harris in 1977. I would have ordered the Dresden bombing again.
Did the Nazis think they could murder millions of innocent civilians and there would be no response.
Have you heard about the Warsaw ghetto uprising,and death camp revolts? They did rebel, but it was a hopeless if heroic effort.
"Multitudes are made up of one, by one, by one" - very poignant! All those millions of people who never got to tell their stories. Heaven must be full of stories!
All the censorship that the elites make about comments about this subject makes many people think that nor Deborah Lipstadt neither similar people believe in what they say. Tolerance to everyone views is esential to gain credibility. yes oh yes
A Mercedes Benz plant! Why am I not surprised?
Not sure? Consult Rabbi Shlomo? maybe he can clear things up for you
I’ve read an incredible amount of information on this, and I’ve even watched this lecture more than once. I do not remember hearing or reading anything about the Argentine Police following Eichmann, AND saw his capture. Now I have to research this new tidbit. 🤷♀️
No Argen
No Argentina police knew anything about the operation. Ms. Lipstadt has been criticized heavily by her peers.
All the censorship that the elites make about comments about this subject makes many people think that nor Deborah Lipstadt neither similar people believe in what they say. Tolerance to everyone views is esential to gain credibility. yes yes
A great talk. Her evaluation of Arendt is critical but fair.
She always makes the statement. The Holocaust which has the dubious distinction of being the best documented genocide in the world. Guess what Deborah, thanks to all the IDF videos and the vast footage from Palestinian victims.The Genocide of Gaza by Israel 2023/24 has the dubious distinction of being the best documented genocide in the world.
This woman should be encouraged to emigrate to the ancestral homeland loyal American citizens have financed for her and her kind.
I cried a lot. Breathless cries.
Do you also cry for Palestinians?
Den of vipers
Relax woman…talk slower
zog
CAN ANY US OR ANY OTHER COUNTRIES' MILITARY PERSONNEL/OFFICIAL DISOBEY OR NOT CARRY OUT MILITARY/HEAD OF COUNTRY'S ORDERS?
IF THEY DID THEY WILL BE COUTMARTIALLED, PUNISHED, THEY ARE CONSIDERED TRAITORS.
SEE ON U TUBE BENJAMIN FREEDMAN'S SPEECH @ WASHINGTON DC WILLARD HOTEL IN 1962.
BOOMER LOCK ACTIVATED
Ms Lipstadt, maliciously conceals disclosure her credibility is nought
Why Aydolf?
Thumbs up for the enabled comment section - people on all sides have the right to be stupid, to be outspoken or even being lied to by whomesoever.
(btw. the word 'historian' does not imply any degree or education to a conceived grasp of the historic method - everybody can call himself a historian ... just as any university degree signifies being excellent in that field of interest)
She's not a historian.
Reichsfuehrer Nivea Creme
I thought she was a theologian.
Jack Black You may be right. I only know she is a lesbian and will be portrayed as a hero in the movie they are making.
+Reichsfuehrer Nivea Creme She IS a historian. And, a damn fine one.
As I understand it, she studied political science, history, and literature. But she doesn't have a degree in history, as far as I know. When she wrote her first book she was a prof. of religion.
+Reichsfuehrer Nivea Creme You are not a human, but shit
Wonderful compassionate intelligent Madame. Enlightening. Thank you for posting on YT
It doesn't surprise me the amount of naive people who would believe false testimonies over science & facts..
Dr. Mengele played marbles with my balls after he slit my nut sack open.
I know, right? Holocaust deniers are wild
@@SpoopySquidFred Leuchter
Why does this video have so many dislikes?
Holocaust deniers, probably.
@@adielstephenson2929 People who dislike Israel and Israels history of human rights violations and war crimes most likely
There was a great video of David Irving recounting his encounter with Deborah Lipstadt at Emory University. Unfortunately, I can't find it on TH-cam anymore. I think I know why: it made Professor Lipstadt look really bad.
I could listen and learn from Deborah all day! Thank you for posting!
of course you could. you've been drinking the same cool-aid since birth
I guess its all in the name
She seems to be tossing off a lot of things I have never heard as if they were proven fact. Who helped Eichmann out of Europe, prove it. If I am being educated then do the job.
Catholics helped Eichmann, the pagans
uh duh Eichmann flees Germany in 1945. Duh Eichmann shows up in South America in 1960. Er duh they have his passport under pseudonym, Italian authorities Italian passport duh
Nokomarie The Jews were shipped off by the allies to create Israel. Read Underground Palestine a book that was once banned..
@@ozking842 Do you mean Underground to Palestine, by IF Stone?
When drunk I could almost confuse her with Rachel Weisz; when sober, with Prince Harry.
Eichmann was Jewish.
She is a paradox and a hippocrite as she has no compunction about labelling individuals racist without ever having spoken to them.
Q - how can you tell Deborah Lipstadt's lying?
A - she moves her lips.