Honestly I think they both sound good, I can't really say one is inferior to the other on an artistic level, in part because I don't know shit about what goes into making good music, I guess if you're nostalgic to the original you're more likely to prefer it, but the remix is not bad at all, one could even argue it's better than the original in some ways, this isn't anythihg like the underwhelming Final Fantasy 10 rescoring, they actually went through the effort of making a good new rendition of the soundtrack.
I don’t agree with the Fans at this point that this Version sounds not as good as the old version both are good but both sound a little bit different. Fans should stop with this goddamn „The Old Tracks are better shit“ it’s always the same „Uuuh Nostalgic“ „It’s an opinion“ blah blah not only here, all New Tracks..But I agree that Rage Awakened has its best Version Birth by sleep with The Origin
YES! I simply can't stand the sadness that Re:CoM version brings along with all the nostalgia, even though KH2 vanilla was my first KH ever, it's like the Re:CoM version took it's place
THANK YOU. I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO FELT THIS WAY. When I saw that comment from BloodyBizkitz years ago where he basically said "This is objectively better, who needs the old soundtrack" I shed a tear next to my official soundtrack CD's
One does not remix Twilight Town, it is the perfect melody. it'll make you feel nostalgic for something you never experienced, you'll feel like you're revisiting a childhood place after many years passed even though it's your first time there. It'll make you remember what you have forgotten, feel what you have ignored. It'll give you that feeling of having someone you care about hug you without you expecting it, someone telling you that you matter when you're doubting yourself.
I don’t agree with the Fans at this point that this Version sounds not as good as the old version both are good but both sound a little bit different. Fans should stop with this goddamn „The Old Tracks are better shit“ it’s always the same „Uuuh Nostalgic“ „It’s an opinion“ blah blah not only here, all New Tracks..But I agree that Rage Awakened has its best Version Birth by sleep with The Origin
10/10 video. Whenever im in the mood to listen to the kh2 soundtrack, i always go OG. Lots of songs just sound so much better like the obviously this song, the world menu area, and Dance to the Death.
The way I never noticed the difference until now and the original just took me back to when I was six with my slim PS2 during Christmas Break 😭😭😭🥹 the power of music >>>
The guitar melody in the remix imo is amazing and really lives up to the songs namesake but then again the original is also just beautiful Couldn't say which one I prefer honestly
It's less about it being an orchestra vs midi, but more of them putting emphasis on different interments and changing the key of other like the world select map and rising tension for some odd reason
I’ve always loved the twilight town music. I was a hella young kid when I was playing KH2, the game came out in 05 I think right? I was born 02 so for as long as I could remember this tune has been with me. I loved to mess around in twilight town just so I could listen to it and relax, amazing times for sure :)
THANK YOU!!!! That's my biggest and probably only criticism of the Remix versions of KH; the soundtrack didn't need to be changed! It was all perfect as is the first time!
I felt absolutely nothing for the II.5 version, but the second the II version started playing I felt.. I don't know.. Like that moment in a game when a characters eyes sparkle.
THANK YOU! So many tracks were killed in the remakes. Absent silhouette, Desire for all that is lost and Darkness's of the Unknown are similar casualties.
I was like that with Enter the Darkness. At one point, they gave it an extra note and it sounded weird. I think it was one of the concert versions. They seemed to make it better for KH3
Funny but also nostalgia bait. You didn't let the rest of it play, which is a crisper yet still faithful rendition of the original. The undertone of original makes me think of all the short part-time jobs the gang take to earn some munny. The shaky beginning of the newer one as well as the slightly awkward version of the previous undertone, makes me think of how impatient everyone was to just head on over to the beach and make some summer memories.
Honestly I love KH as a whole, I have since my dad convinced me to get the first 1 when it came out....I did NOT want to like it but fell in love. KH 2 is my personal favorite, KH BBS second and then KH3. KH3 storywise was eh but tbh I fell in love with KH for diff reasons, gameplay, the boss fights, and just the creativity with the fights...3 was super underwhelming till crit mode and Remind/Limit cut which introduced the strongest bosses I've faced in KH but KH2 is still King.
@@kriegnes disagree, the wait/build-up between mainline installments and the hype and the trailers revealing way too much made KH3 underwhelming and disappointed many fans but it isn't a bad game in itself. I feel like people getting into the series fresh will enjoy it more than someone who played the original games on PS2 and had to wait til the PS4 for KH3
@@kriegnes Yeah I hear what you are saying, story and game overall was mid but I still enjoyed the game for what it was and the dlc remedied a lot of problems for me then again a lot of ppl didn't play the dlc compared to the main game. As someone who has been playing this series for 20 years now I can tell you that the one thing the game did right was introduce hard bosses in the dlc and that was like literally it, I'm still salty over no FF Characters in the story and no Sephiroth boss battle.
@@heartlessangelrdk I agree, feels wrong to have a mainline KH game without FF characters (outside of DLC) and a Sephiroth boss fight, I feel like if Critical Mode and Limit Cut (perhaps done a bit more elegantly) was released with the main game then it'd be a whole different story. Also it would be nice if Disney let Nomura fulfill his vision for Arendelle
@@ryapowa Yeah and like I understand that the FF characters are not the main focus of the game but (incoming bad analogy) its like that ep of Spongebob with the pickles "You forgot the pickles!" The pickles aren't the main focus of the Krabby Patty but it adds to the overall experience and vibe. Same thing applies here, it adds to the experience and we were used to having FF served up with our Kingdom Hearts so when ppl tell you that FF was not needed for KH 3, you remind them of those pickles from Spongebob lol.
Not me getting teary over a literal meme video, this is more evidence of the chokehold these games do and will always have on me, ugh, this song especially is just a suckerpunch right to the tenderest part of my heart 😢
They are pretty similar but personally I find the 2.5 remix to be better, feels more musically complex and keeps u interested with the timing of those notes
I think about 75% of the songs in the ReMixes are improvements across the board, but god damn certain OG tracks really hit. I think the thing that the Remixes lack is the hard hitting percussion of the OG, as well as making a few tracks too busy. Other than that I really appreciate how good the organic instrumentation sounds, it works so well for most tracks.
This is how feel about the darkness of the unknown. The remix added the loudest drums ever and completely drowned out the other instruments, whereas the original was much more balanced.
Biggest offender imo is Organization XIII. I like the remaster version, but the original captures a better feel. Remaster makes them a lot more mysterious by having the chorus start from the get go, but the original has a lot more of a depressing undertone in its opening. There's a lot of empty space between the piano notes that isn't filled by the background noise of the chorus that conveys a somber and melancholic, yet foreboding presence, which fits the organization a lot more.
@@daseal1479 I wish I shared the sentiment. For me its not even a "both are good, but I prefer this version more" I actively dislike the remix version. I feel it loses a lot of its original meaning in the remix version. Its more on the second part than anything else tho. I liked being able to hear all the instrument in tandem, when you get to the Dragon part all I hear is *DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA!* And I'm like Geezs dude, I can't even hear the song anymore. I guess I just prefer the more simplistic version more, the Remix is trying to do too much for me.
Wow, I thought I was the only one who felt this way towards the new songs, I still love them but I have been listening to the OGs for years and years even when final mix was around for a long time. I felt like a lot of songs got better HD orchestration in the Final mix versions but they are also softer, like take the Hollow Bastion song in Kh1, listen to final mix first, then the original. The original sounds cooler and more intimidating and in your face. The final mix makes it a lot softer and quieter.
I agree. I get it that they're trynna make a different variant of it, but to remake something out of an already perfect masterpiece is hard
@AT Productions ahh so that explains the guitar riffs. but her work on XV slaps tho
@@HoppoTheWhale “but”? there is no but with yoko. None
@@HoppoTheWhale You say that as if Yoko Shimomura didn't also create the original.
Honestly I think they both sound good, I can't really say one is inferior to the other on an artistic level, in part because I don't know shit about what goes into making good music, I guess if you're nostalgic to the original you're more likely to prefer it, but the remix is not bad at all, one could even argue it's better than the original in some ways, this isn't anythihg like the underwhelming Final Fantasy 10 rescoring, they actually went through the effort of making a good new rendition of the soundtrack.
I barely play kingdom hearts only part 3, but whats the songs called on this vid?
Fun fact, the sound programmer for KH1 and KH2 played the Saxophone for both Traverse Town and Twilight Town for the PS2 sequenced music.
:0 whats the sound programmers name?
Source?
There is no saxophone in Twilight Town. It's an Oboe.
@@regulardog495 It's actually a soprano saxophone apparently.
Both are great. I have no problem if people like one more than the other but, for me that grew up playing kh2, OG Lazy Afternoons just hits different
fr
frfr
frfrfr
Exactly I would literally just walk around twilight town when I was a kid listening to this on the ps2 after school
I don’t agree with the Fans at this point that this Version sounds not as good as the old version both are good but both sound a little bit different. Fans should stop with this goddamn „The Old Tracks are better shit“ it’s always the same „Uuuh Nostalgic“ „It’s an opinion“ blah blah not only here, all New Tracks..But I agree that Rage Awakened has its best Version Birth by sleep with The Origin
Honestly, they both have the same vibe and they both share a place in my heart
darkness
@@osriocesar within darkness
@@darkthunder301 awaits you
SUBMIT!
@@darkthunder301 lmao I love KH community
This is such a god tier meme both versions are perfect and I wouldn’t have them any other way*except I would all the remixes are amazing*
Jesus loves you
@@scrubbingdoubles8585 where did that come from
@@beepbooper5201 he just wanted to let you know bro
Honestly, Re:CoM is my favorite version of it. The harmonica really puts the "Lazy" in Lazy afternoon.
Omg finally someone who acknowledges how good Re:CoM's Lazy Afternoons is 😭💙
Yes, it's also my favorite :D
YES! I simply can't stand the sadness that Re:CoM version brings along with all the nostalgia, even though KH2 vanilla was my first KH ever, it's like the Re:CoM version took it's place
I forgot that was different! I'm crying from nostalgia 😢. Thank you for reminding me of that masterpiece of a game.
Your comment propmted me to look that version up, and I'm glad I did.
I could only tell the difference because I’ve been listening to lazy afternoons a bit too much lately
THANK YOU. I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO FELT THIS WAY. When I saw that comment from BloodyBizkitz years ago where he basically said "This is objectively better, who needs the old soundtrack" I shed a tear next to my official soundtrack CD's
As someone who learned the originals on piano and guitar, trust me when I say you aren't alone in being disappointed at this song especially.
Finally someone came out here and said the truth. KH2's OST is perfection. it has the greatest Lazy Afternoons.
One does not remix Twilight Town, it is the perfect melody.
it'll make you feel nostalgic for something you never experienced, you'll feel like you're revisiting a childhood place after many years passed even though it's your first time there. It'll make you remember what you have forgotten, feel what you have ignored. It'll give you that feeling of having someone you care about hug you without you expecting it, someone telling you that you matter when you're doubting yourself.
I love comments like these. It comes from a personal place, yet we all relate with what you're saying on some level. Thanks
its like the mood of august, when its still summer but you have the lingering feeling that vacation will be over soon... oh. wait.
Chills 😢
I don’t agree with the Fans at this point that this Version sounds not as good as the old version both are good but both sound a little bit different. Fans should stop with this goddamn „The Old Tracks are better shit“ it’s always the same „Uuuh Nostalgic“ „It’s an opinion“ blah blah not only here, all New Tracks..But I agree that Rage Awakened has its best Version Birth by sleep with The Origin
10/10 video. Whenever im in the mood to listen to the kh2 soundtrack, i always go OG. Lots of songs just sound so much better like the obviously this song, the world menu area, and Dance to the Death.
I'm gonna cry....the original is just....chef's kiss
I love both, but this was hilarious!
The way I never noticed the difference until now and the original just took me back to when I was six with my slim PS2 during Christmas Break 😭😭😭🥹 the power of music >>>
Lazy afternoons is such a great piece. Makes me feel like I am home, and my friends are just around the corner.
We will never see the old KH2 style ever again. We all have grown up
The guitar melody in the remix imo is amazing and really lives up to the songs namesake but then again the original is also just beautiful
Couldn't say which one I prefer honestly
I’d say the remake cause it has more guitar and clarinet more soul into it
I KNEW IT WAS DIFFERENT. FOR YEARS I wondered if I was crazy.
I just started playing 1.5 for the first time the other day and couldn't get over the change to Destiny Islands theme song.
there's just something special about those MIDIs, man
It's less about it being an orchestra vs midi, but more of them putting emphasis on different interments and changing the key of other like the world select map and rising tension for some odd reason
I’ve always loved the twilight town music. I was a hella young kid when I was playing KH2, the game came out in 05 I think right? I was born 02 so for as long as I could remember this tune has been with me. I loved to mess around in twilight town just so I could listen to it and relax, amazing times for sure :)
The wrong notes meme perfectly encapsulates how I feel about most of the 2.5 soundtrack.
THANK YOU!!!! That's my biggest and probably only criticism of the Remix versions of KH; the soundtrack didn't need to be changed! It was all perfect as is the first time!
Hm-hm, I much rather prefer the way 2.5 does it. Adding that extra guitar melody makes it actually sound like a lazy afternoon for me
The strings just absolutely ascend me.
I felt absolutely nothing for the II.5 version, but the second the II version started playing I felt.. I don't know.. Like that moment in a game when a characters eyes sparkle.
OG Lazy Afternoons >>>
I love how Squidward is throwing away the clarinet like he is throwing away KH 2.5
For me, nothing can beat the GBA versions of these songs. CoM was my first KH game and has a special place in my life
Gba?
@@geoffreyhogueison5551 really?
Honestly they're both perfectly fine. They match the tone and feeling of the world.
Tbh, they both sound amazing
This so true! 😆
They seriously should either keep it the same or allow you to switch to the original version.
No
@@xblade149 why?
They should do like the developers did for spyro reignited, give us a choice to switch to the original soundtrack if desired.
They are so self aware that the OG version was playing during a KH3 cutscene where Sora looks at the mirror of Namine's bedroom, hitting way harder
Someone definitely noticed
I went back to listen to the scene, and it sounds like the 2.5 version to me.
th-cam.com/video/_eCT4oMAsDE/w-d-xo.html
THANK YOU! So many tracks were killed in the remakes. Absent silhouette, Desire for all that is lost and Darkness's of the Unknown are similar casualties.
I was like that with Enter the Darkness. At one point, they gave it an extra note and it sounded weird. I think it was one of the concert versions. They seemed to make it better for KH3
I don't really mind when both versions make me wanna cry
That theme hits me in feels too hard.
Just hearing this song brought back some precious childhood memories of mine
Yoko Shimomura still the Goat at music
Such a god tier meme😭😭😭 Og lazy afternoons is so goated
I thought it was nostalgia or I was losing my marbles but they did change it huh
I didn't even catch what song this was supposed to be until I managed to hear the hilariously drowned vibraphone. Take that as you will.
these are my favorite kinds of memes lmaooo these lil kingdom hearts song ones
Funny but also nostalgia bait. You didn't let the rest of it play, which is a crisper yet still faithful rendition of the original. The undertone of original makes me think of all the short part-time jobs the gang take to earn some munny. The shaky beginning of the newer one as well as the slightly awkward version of the previous undertone, makes me think of how impatient everyone was to just head on over to the beach and make some summer memories.
I never felt something so hard in my soul so bad
Literally the only thing I'm glad they fixed was the Pirates of the Caribbean theme
I will forever and always miss the original I noticed right away
I can't believe I almost didn't watch this video. Well done.
Honestly. And the right way of doing it just makes it feel much more nostalgic and beautiful.
Lazy afternoons is perfection to me man
My brain just automatically replaced the remixed version with the original when playing.
Best video I’ve seen in a long time haha
Some things are simply best left untouched.
We DEFINITELY NEED more memes like this!!!!
2 soundtrack just touches my soul in a different way than everything else in the world
best goddamn youtube video on the platform
And then kingdom hearts 3 came in with a real orchestra
This is genius I always liked the og lazy afternoon
Honestly I love KH as a whole, I have since my dad convinced me to get the first 1 when it came out....I did NOT want to like it but fell in love. KH 2 is my personal favorite, KH BBS second and then KH3. KH3 storywise was eh but tbh I fell in love with KH for diff reasons, gameplay, the boss fights, and just the creativity with the fights...3 was super underwhelming till crit mode and Remind/Limit cut which introduced the strongest bosses I've faced in KH but KH2 is still King.
lmao what? kh3 destroyed this series.
@@kriegnes disagree, the wait/build-up between mainline installments and the hype and the trailers revealing way too much made KH3 underwhelming and disappointed many fans but it isn't a bad game in itself. I feel like people getting into the series fresh will enjoy it more than someone who played the original games on PS2 and had to wait til the PS4 for KH3
@@kriegnes Yeah I hear what you are saying, story and game overall was mid but I still enjoyed the game for what it was and the dlc remedied a lot of problems for me then again a lot of ppl didn't play the dlc compared to the main game. As someone who has been playing this series for 20 years now I can tell you that the one thing the game did right was introduce hard bosses in the dlc and that was like literally it, I'm still salty over no FF Characters in the story and no Sephiroth boss battle.
@@heartlessangelrdk I agree, feels wrong to have a mainline KH game without FF characters (outside of DLC) and a Sephiroth boss fight, I feel like if Critical Mode and Limit Cut (perhaps done a bit more elegantly) was released with the main game then it'd be a whole different story. Also it would be nice if Disney let Nomura fulfill his vision for Arendelle
@@ryapowa Yeah and like I understand that the FF characters are not the main focus of the game but (incoming bad analogy) its like that ep of Spongebob with the pickles "You forgot the pickles!" The pickles aren't the main focus of the Krabby Patty but it adds to the overall experience and vibe. Same thing applies here, it adds to the experience and we were used to having FF served up with our Kingdom Hearts so when ppl tell you that FF was not needed for KH 3, you remind them of those pickles from Spongebob lol.
Ngl thumbnail made me think it was dearly beloved before I realized that's Twilight Town theme
Then the remixes pull out the Pirates theme and the OG just sits wordless
All remastered games should allow you the options to use the original music.
Spongebob was a savage back then, and it was a joy to watch
In didnt notice the difference. Kh2 ver lives rent free in my head. 👏
Not me getting teary over a literal meme video, this is more evidence of the chokehold these games do and will always have on me, ugh, this song especially is just a suckerpunch right to the tenderest part of my heart 😢
I knew something sounded different, but I haven't booted up my PS2 in so long that I wasn't sure
Counterargument: He's A Pirate.
I think the Re:CoM version is underrated.
the Harmonica there fits perfect
Didn't even know anything was changed
This was actually nice. The original was better but they're both really great for what they were.
i never even realized the difference until now.
it was the first thing i noticed when it came out! i was like "they've changed it :(("
Me has hecho despertar recuerdos de mi infancia.
god that old music hits hard.
Name of the song?
They are pretty similar but personally I find the 2.5 remix to be better, feels more musically complex and keeps u interested with the timing of those notes
That's a respectable opinion. That's exactly the reason I prefer the original, interestingly enough.
I think about 75% of the songs in the ReMixes are improvements across the board, but god damn certain OG tracks really hit.
I think the thing that the Remixes lack is the hard hitting percussion of the OG, as well as making a few tracks too busy. Other than that I really appreciate how good the organic instrumentation sounds, it works so well for most tracks.
I have played both versions so much that I didn't even notice there was a musical difference
man i havent played the original since i first owned it this just blew my mind
I love this a little too much
Usually I always prefer the HD versions but you opened my eyes on this one...
at least we can all agree that yoko shimomura is a goddess regardless
Lazy afternoons is so perfect for the end of summer vacation feel.
You don’t notice it until someone points it out to you. Now I can’t un-hear it.
I still argue that kh2 has the BEST video game soundtrack of all time
Thank you! This has always bothered me about the HD version...
Honestly, I love both.
Beautyful sirs beautyful
yo that gave me chills and flaahbacks i teardown
Then you get to Port Royal, and Spongebob and Squidward switch roles.
This is how feel about the darkness of the unknown. The remix added the loudest drums ever and completely drowned out the other instruments, whereas the original was much more balanced.
See, and I VASTLY prefer the remake, where it's tough for me to even return the old version. They all have their place in my eyes though.
That's what I love from the remix, the song makes xemnas feel so menacing, easly my top 3 songs from KH
Biggest offender imo is Organization XIII. I like the remaster version, but the original captures a better feel. Remaster makes them a lot more mysterious by having the chorus start from the get go, but the original has a lot more of a depressing undertone in its opening. There's a lot of empty space between the piano notes that isn't filled by the background noise of the chorus that conveys a somber and melancholic, yet foreboding presence, which fits the organization a lot more.
@@daseal1479
I wish I shared the sentiment. For me its not even a "both are good, but I prefer this version more" I actively dislike the remix version. I feel it loses a lot of its original meaning in the remix version. Its more on the second part than anything else tho. I liked being able to hear all the instrument in tandem, when you get to the Dragon part all I hear is *DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA! DAA!* And I'm like Geezs dude, I can't even hear the song anymore. I guess I just prefer the more simplistic version more, the Remix is trying to do too much for me.
@@GamerKonata You get it. Original Organization XIII is peak.
song of my childhood
Wow, I thought I was the only one who felt this way towards the new songs, I still love them but I have been listening to the OGs for years and years even when final mix was around for a long time. I felt like a lot of songs got better HD orchestration in the Final mix versions but they are also softer, like take the Hollow Bastion song in Kh1, listen to final mix first, then the original. The original sounds cooler and more intimidating and in your face. The final mix makes it a lot softer and quieter.
Didn't even know I was missing out on this superior version
True, the Original is such a banger.
Made me smile and laugh, great video
I don't know I got tired of the standard KH2 version much quicker on loop than the other
KH II.5: “This is nice”
KH II: (relaxed sigh) “peace”
This is beyond accurate
I didnt even realize till I watched this...
Make changes the Kingdom Hearts 2 OST show to us that some people don't know the definition of perfection... ❤