docs.google.com/document/d/1oholqKfI2MmH64sJ-KtcPEobnhjGal5l1eJE75KekfM/edit?usp=sharing Use the following Google Doc to see the cuts for yourself, then follow the instructions there.
@rennac3152 Especially the LAAT and Y wing pilots. Although, I suspect the reason that the Y-Wing pilots typically get wiped out is because each one packs a serious punch, and the show writers want space battles to be close 😅
They construct bunkers, hid their AA guns in caves so that the Republic bombers could not bomb those guns. I mean you could say why not do orbital bombardment. Well, even if they try the Geonosian could just hide in the caverns underneath the planet and wait for it to stop and then resume their defense again. The Republic have no choice but go down there and do it the hard way.
1:02 people always think about how he and his laat get blown up instantly after commenting that the bugs can’t aim but nobody ever seems to notice that in the half second of him staring out the window we (and thus he) SEE two gunships get vaporized. So he knew he was wrong before he even said it.
Cody basically saved the entire battle, if he hadn't held Point Rain for as long as he did Anakin and Ki-Adi-Mundi never would have been able to reinforce them and create a proper landing zone, trapping them all on Geonosis
The very first time I ever watched this scene, I was actually surprised that the gunships carrying Jedi were shot down, especially the one Ki-adi Mundi was in.
Worst version of D-Day for sure, the landing on Geonosis was so bad, the republic didn't have air superiority & the enemy anti air was still at their best.
The music, or lack thereof, is really what completes this scene. The way the gunfire and explosions overwhelm the soundtrack when it's playing, and dominate the scene when it's not, is definitely part of what makes this such a great battle scene.
Lol yeah, but it's a manner of speaking kinda thing, like, atheist people will still say "oh my god" and "for god's sake" even of they don't believe in it
"Good thing those bugs can't aim." You do know that they need to know mathematics at least to build these battle droids, yet alone, the Death Star itself, right?
When I look at this I wonder has the Republic learned nothing after attack of the clones. They could have easily done a bombardment then use ground forces on the surface to attack the shield generator. This would have avoided so many clone deaths
In all reality…that really wouldn’t have worked. The geonosians would have gone underground the minute that happened. And seeing as their tunnels and the droid factories were deep into the planet….they would’ve been in this fight the minute they launched a ground invasion
Basically the same thing would've happened when you give the info that Christopher here is regarding so basically even an orbital bombardment happened this still would've happened
@@SneedRemembrancer umm yeah that argument doesn’t really hold up here. It’s a desert planet. They mostly live in their cave systems. And they’re Geonosians. They don’t care. Mans roasted them with flamethrowers.
I wouldn't have even invaded the planet. If orbital bombardment didn't do it, I would have focused on blockading the planet and prevented anything from going in or leaving. Unless I missed something in legends, it doesn't look like the separatists had a presence in space to stop the Republic fleet.
Cody was my favorite part of this whole sequence Calm (relatively), collected, and taking complete charge. I feel like Cody gets overshadowed by Rex way too often
Ironic that Cody never participated in the first battle, and as soon as he got into the thick of the second one, he soon realized that Geonosis was no joke, as he saw many of his brothers die.
@@GreenNinj4 that's also why Anakin and Tarkin agreed that jedi and military should be kept separate, even tho Anakin, Ahsoka and Obi Wan were good strategists, most jedi weren't, Windu put every single tank in a line, on the border of a precipice, just for the droids to inevitably target the front one and the back one to immobilize the convoy and pin them down
Geonosis is the Middle East of Star Wars with Umbara being Vietnam! I would say Felucia possibly would be a better choice instead, but they didn't have that much in terms of coverage compared to the Umbara Arc with the 501st
Man that Johnny Bravo model and Voice is pretty good, hope you have a great Christmas holiday devilartemis and thank you for all your hard work, been a fan since the beginning.
I think that Darth Sidious didn't want the Republic to win this battle. I think once he got the tactics from the briefing, he told the Geonosians. That's why they were so prepared.
This Second Battle of Geonosis seems more challenging than the first, by how federation was able to shoot some gunships or AT TE transports before they were able to land.
4:10 anakin and Ahsoka exchange is interesting here anakin is trying to focus in the battle at hand while taking in the loss of his men as well as probably his master who is a brother to him and even takes a moment to Comfort Ahsoka at least a little to keep her head in the game. Remember, she's still a teen. Kind puts some things into perspective.
I think this battle shows the compromise. What if in the second world war there had been helicopters and they were used in battle? There would probably be many casualties even though it would be quicker to send troops to a suitable landing point.
I believe that Anakin being enrolled in the military was somewhat of a good thing. Yes, he was a bit aggressive and his tactics are… questionable at the same time it helped him grow and learn about key life lessons such as grounding himself to stay in the present and not let distractions get to him. In his personal life, he was always insecure about being a Jedi Master, losing his relationship with his wife, heck he lost his mother and that pain and frustration was overwhelming. I guess that part of being angry and sad was released in his combat experience as he was able to “lash out” those feelings. It is very interesting and whenever I see him teaching Ahsoka, it makes me feel very comfortable because he is doing his best to do something good, to help Ahsoka to deal with things that he had trouble doing in his own life.
"Good Luck, General" "There's no such thing as luck." *A few moments later* "With any luck, we can meet up with Skywalker on his way to Kenobi's position."
for me Anakin was never fit to be a Jedi, he should have been something else other than Jedi or Sith. He would been a perfect general with super soldier like ability along with force
Kiadimundi was a psychopath and a hypocrite during the war. Cold and unfeeling. He told the admiral before he left "theres no such thing as luck" and in the next scene hes saying "with any luck we'll make it"
I'm not a tactical expert, but surely it would have been strategically wiser to orbitally bombard the enemy artillery positions and aircraft deployment stations before deploying the landing craft. Venators might not have been designed for it like the Imperial ones were but as was shown by the destruction of Tipoca City, they are capable of executing bombardments of ground targets.
Depending on how long into the war this happened compared to the episode they were introduced. No one can’t say that the clone with the chaingun/ rotary cannon isn’t hardcase. What proof do you have?
Why J-1 cannons didn't specifically targeting the Acclamator assault ships? On Ryloth their fire was extremely effective against this type of big troop carriers.
![Grievous Captures Eeth Koth [4K HDR] - Star Wars: The Clone Wars](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/O7lQ9_JzyW8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Grievous Captures Eeth Koth [4K HDR] - Star Wars: The Clone Wars](/img/tr.png)
![Star Wars: The Clone Wars - Hevy's death [1080p]](/img/n.gif)
docs.google.com/document/d/1oholqKfI2MmH64sJ-KtcPEobnhjGal5l1eJE75KekfM/edit?usp=sharing
Use the following Google Doc to see the cuts for yourself, then follow the instructions there.
“Good Luck, General”
“There’s no such thing as luck”
“Well screw you too, I guess”
"With any luck, we can meet up with Skywalker' on his way to Kenobi's position."
@@Lorrdd Written by Larry David
No wonder Yularen joined the Empire lol
@@-CrimsoN- The Republic reformed into the Empire, he didn't join, he stayed.
@@LorrddHe changed his mind after surviving this disaster.
"Last time I was here I was chained to a pole and attacked by several humongous monsters"
Hello there
"That sounds... entertaining."
@@fanunion913 "It was... For the Geonosians."
@@fanunion913it was, for the geonosians
*Good job.*
I feel like the clone pilots never get the recognition they deserve
As someone who was mainly running aircraft in battlefront 2 I can agree. Most don’t live long enough to complain tho
@rennac3152 Especially the LAAT and Y wing pilots. Although, I suspect the reason that the Y-Wing pilots typically get wiped out is because each one packs a serious punch, and the show writers want space battles to be close 😅
They usually dont last that long to get though
@magmaticgames easy solution, put Lucrehulks in. Those tank as much as a let's say 4 Providence Class
@magmaticgames tbf bombers are slow af compared to other fughters especially interceptors
You can definitely tell that the Geonosians learned from the first Battle of Geonosis
The Republic on the other hand...
@@ATP2555ify they were spread thin and couldn't allocate so much resources to geonosis
Well the first battle was exclusively the Droids doing the fighting. The Geonosians actually did a lot of the combat in round 2.
@@LazzieMazzie”they were spread thin” the animation budget wasn’t big enough to animate more clones lol
They construct bunkers, hid their AA guns in caves so that the Republic bombers could not bomb those guns. I mean you could say why not do orbital bombardment. Well, even if they try the Geonosian could just hide in the caverns underneath the planet and wait for it to stop and then resume their defense again. The Republic have no choice but go down there and do it the hard way.
Ki-adi started believing in luck real quick after that landing
😂😂😂
It still wasn't enough to save him during Order 66 😆
0:50 The duality of Ki-Adi-Mundi 3:43
dual like his head
@@hdwalk4071 hearts too.
Jedis. They think they are so smart.
@@dencamp6685*Jedi
Most hypocritical Jedi
The sound design on the Y-Wing bombing run is top tier
JU87 Stuka siren
It kinda sounds like a real life ju 87 Stuka dive bomber
@Ziaulhaq Qadri it is they sampled it and I love it
Yep
@@ziaulhaqqadri8389hyena sounded more like stuka
1:02 people always think about how he and his laat get blown up instantly after commenting that the bugs can’t aim but nobody ever seems to notice that in the half second of him staring out the window we (and thus he) SEE two gunships get vaporized. So he knew he was wrong before he even said it.
I was looking for this comment 😂
A morale boost to your fellow soldiers goes a long way.
My man was just trying to lighten the mood
You know what we all came here for:
1:06
“Good thing those bugs cant aim*
Famous last words
"Good thing those bugs can't aim."
- Man who was shot down by bugs
Cody basically saved the entire battle, if he hadn't held Point Rain for as long as he did Anakin and Ki-Adi-Mundi never would have been able to reinforce them and create a proper landing zone, trapping them all on Geonosis
I'm pretty sure he earned his Marshall Commander title as a result of this battle
@@magmaticgamesWasn’t he born into the rank? As a CC?
@@beanaye5433very few clone commanders are marshal commanders. Cody, Bly, Bacara, Neyo, Gree, Appo were the only marshal commanders
@bwc-chvd no they weren't. There are several, they're just not all named or known to us.
@@bwc-chvd every clone in command of a corps was labeled as marshal commander, those are the only named ones in canon
1:08 ABSOLUTELY NEVER SAY THAT IF THERE ISN'T A NAMED CLONE OR JEDI ON BOARD
Well, in his defense, Obi-Wan's, Anakin's and Ki Adi's gunship were also shot down 😂
Geonosis es el segundo lugar con más tumbas jedi de la galaxia 😅😅ni siendo un lord sith tienes asegurado la vida ahi😅😅
Second Battle of Geonosis: **Exists**
Clones: Ah sh*t, here we go again
random clone: "im safe im with the main cast"
its the 2nd battle of geonosis: still gets shot down
@@rethinker167 Blud went "ka-boom!" instead of saying "ka-chow!"💀💀💀
The very first time I ever watched this scene, I was actually surprised that the gunships carrying Jedi were shot down, especially the one Ki-adi Mundi was in.
For me this was the D-Day for the clones.
Yes
And Umbara was their Vietnam
@@ElysiumCreator and Kamino was their Stalingrad
Worst version of D-Day for sure, the landing on Geonosis was so bad, the republic didn't have air superiority & the enemy anti air was still at their best.
I heard it was inspired by D-Day, so there's that.
1:07 omfg i cant bro- THAT WASNT EVEN A SECOND! 😂
0:32 those Y-Wings with their aggresive engine sounds. I can't get enough of those ships.
2:21 "Copy that Commander! Have fun down there." Mf you still have to make it back to the ship through all of that flak and the interceptors!
"Good thing those bugs cant aim"
- Famous last words
We’ll be right back.
The Vietnam war but its the Gulf War but its Operation Market Garden but eventually it's the battle of Okinawa and the Wild West
Vietnam would be Umbara
Finally someone who actually knows conflicts other than vietnam and d-day
The music, or lack thereof, is really what completes this scene. The way the gunfire and explosions overwhelm the soundtrack when it's playing, and dominate the scene when it's not, is definitely part of what makes this such a great battle scene.
Ki Adi Mundi: There is no such thing as luck
some time later...
Mundi: With any LUCK we'll hook up with skywalker
This line has always SERIOUSLY annoyed me haha
Lol yeah, but it's a manner of speaking kinda thing, like, atheist people will still say "oh my god" and "for god's sake" even of they don't believe in it
Lmao I can’t stand that man. Bro made all of the bad recommendations in the prequel movies too. I enjoyed watching him get bodied by baccara
the hypocrisy of the Jedi has no bounds
@@victortillas1143 Foolish Jedi absolutely destroyed with BLASTERS and HIS OWN TROOPS.
"Good thing those bugs can't aim."
You do know that they need to know mathematics at least to build these battle droids, yet alone, the Death Star itself, right?
Cody must of had back surgery after carrying the whole invasion
For realll
That one clone should’ve said , “ I was wrong ! “ , when they got shot down
If he was alive
clone: good thing those bugs cant aim 1 milesecent later dies
When I look at this I wonder has the Republic learned nothing after attack of the clones. They could have easily done a bombardment then use ground forces on the surface to attack the shield generator. This would have avoided so many clone deaths
Jedi find it immoral to orbitally bombard a planet
Any actual republic commander would have just glassed the place
In all reality…that really wouldn’t have worked. The geonosians would have gone underground the minute that happened. And seeing as their tunnels and the droid factories were deep into the planet….they would’ve been in this fight the minute they launched a ground invasion
Basically the same thing would've happened when you give the info that Christopher here is regarding so basically even an orbital bombardment happened this still would've happened
@@SneedRemembrancer umm yeah that argument doesn’t really hold up here. It’s a desert planet. They mostly live in their cave systems. And they’re Geonosians. They don’t care. Mans roasted them with flamethrowers.
I wouldn't have even invaded the planet. If orbital bombardment didn't do it, I would have focused on blockading the planet and prevented anything from going in or leaving. Unless I missed something in legends, it doesn't look like the separatists had a presence in space to stop the Republic fleet.
Gosh I loved this arc! I go back to it for comfort.
Wonder if Cody’s back is still sore from carrying the whole invasion
“There’s No such thing as luck”
“With any luck we can meet up with Skywalker”😀
Cody was my favorite part of this whole sequence
Calm (relatively), collected, and taking complete charge. I feel like Cody gets overshadowed by Rex way too often
He was a beast during this battle
Ironic that Cody never participated in the first battle, and as soon as he got into the thick of the second one, he soon realized that Geonosis was no joke, as he saw many of his brothers die.
The guy was like(good thing those bugs cant aim) next thing happened the guy was hanging at the back of the ship
And they called this a kids show
Well, Child-soldiers exist
So I guess war is a kid game
What kind of attack strategy is sending in your drop ships before the bombers clear out the AA 😂😂😂
Why would you send your bombers in when there's AA? They'll get shot down all the same
The jedi had no idea about war which is why the strategies are flawed. Also, keep in mind that Palpatine wanted the war to keep going for some time.
That’s the point of the series, showing the republic’s war blunders
@@GreenNinj4 that's also why Anakin and Tarkin agreed that jedi and military should be kept separate, even tho Anakin, Ahsoka and Obi Wan were good strategists, most jedi weren't, Windu put every single tank in a line, on the border of a precipice, just for the droids to inevitably target the front one and the back one to immobilize the convoy and pin them down
I don’t think you watched this episode, because before they send out the gunships, there is a scene where they send out bombers first
The number one strat to use when you have guns. Charge
"There's no such thing as luck"
Later: "With any luck we'll meet up with Skywalker on his way to Kenobi."
Ki adi mundi: there is no such thing as luck
2 seconds later
“With any luck…”
Geonosis is the Middle East of Star Wars with Umbara being Vietnam! I would say Felucia possibly would be a better choice instead, but they didn't have that much in terms of coverage compared to the Umbara Arc with the 501st
Umbara is US Vietnam, Felucia is French Vietnam.
“Good thing those bugs can’t aim”
💀💀💀💀
Apperently this took inspiration from D-Day (June 6, 1944) and movies like 'Saving Private Ryan'.
Man this show really put the "WAR" in "STAR WARS". I can't believe they where allowed to air this, but thank god they did!
“Good thing those bugs cant aim.” Two seconds later they get blowed up💀
"Good thing those buys can't aim"
*Explodes
Man that Johnny Bravo model and Voice is pretty good, hope you have a great Christmas holiday devilartemis and thank you for all your hard work, been a fan since the beginning.
That is the equivalent of the battle of Normandy
this whole sequence looks fantastic
I think that Darth Sidious didn't want the Republic to win this battle. I think once he got the tactics from the briefing, he told the Geonosians. That's why they were so prepared.
Cody was really a remarkable leader in battle not your average tactical commander
This makes Operation Market Garden look like the Anglo-Zanzibar War.
Best battle in SW hands down. So much great action, all of the idiots who still refuse to watch clone wars miss out on peak SW.
Umbarans would like a word with you
Jesus, the first invasion of Klendathu went down smoother than this
😂😂😂it's an ugly planet a bug planet ...
“Good thing those bugs can’t aim!”
Oh my sweet summer child
The D-Day of Star Wars: The Clone Wars
This Second Battle of Geonosis seems more challenging than the first, by how federation was able to shoot some gunships or AT TE transports before they were able to land.
bet this gave rex flash back to when he was just shiny troopers sent into the meat grinder on this planet
“Good thing those bugs can’t aim”
POV: reinforcements arriving from the termind front to assist in the 2nd invasion of Malevelon creek
4:10 anakin and Ahsoka exchange is interesting here anakin is trying to focus in the battle at hand while taking in the loss of his men as well as probably his master who is a brother to him and even takes a moment to Comfort Ahsoka at least a little to keep her head in the game. Remember, she's still a teen. Kind puts some things into perspective.
Does anyone notice the same Jedi that said “there is no such thing as luck” also said “with any luck we’ll meet up with skywalker”?
I love the quality of your videos. please posts more clone wars and the bad batch with their phase 2 armor. its my favorite
1:08 Clone: Good thing those bugs can’t aim 💥 AHHHHHHH!
You would think they would send out fighters as CAP to secure the landing and achieve air superiority with those acclamators in the rear
they were spread thin across the galaxy
This was like sending blackhawks into Baghdad airspace (2003) before clearing them out lmao
I think this battle shows the compromise. What if in the second world war there had been helicopters and they were used in battle? There would probably be many casualties even though it would be quicker to send troops to a suitable landing point.
"Good thing those bugs can't aim!" (IMMEDIATELY GETS SHOT DOWN)
Ki Adi Mundi: “There is no such thing as LUCK”
Ki Adi 3 minutes later: “With any LUCK, we can meet up with Skywalker on his way to Kenobi’s position”
0:51
3:43
Forgetting his own lack of wisdom there, eh?
I believe that Anakin being enrolled in the military was somewhat of a good thing. Yes, he was a bit aggressive and his tactics are… questionable at the same time it helped him grow and learn about key life lessons such as grounding himself to stay in the present and not let distractions get to him. In his personal life, he was always insecure about being a Jedi Master, losing his relationship with his wife, heck he lost his mother and that pain and frustration was overwhelming. I guess that part of being angry and sad was released in his combat experience as he was able to “lash out” those feelings. It is very interesting and whenever I see him teaching Ahsoka, it makes me feel very comfortable because he is doing his best to do something good, to help Ahsoka to deal with things that he had trouble doing in his own life.
So they didn’t bother to escort the gunships with any fighters? Or at the very least clear the airspace?
If Cody was at the first battle of geonosis, there wouldn’t have been a second
1:54 you can see anakin decapitate a geonosian
It’s ironic that the Geonosions both built the Death Star and- as ferocious and ruthless as they are- also made the case militarily for its necessity.
The clone wars logic. Cutting bugs in half is fine but not humans...
If you mean maul he’s not a human and he’s powerful in the dark side of the force
"Take em out!"
*AHHHHHHHH-*
I would really love to see some of these episodes remastered and brought up to the visual quality of the last season and the bad batch.
Star wars: D-Day
Fr
More like: "Operation Mercury, with two pounds of Deathsticks."
"Good Luck, General"
"There's no such thing as luck."
*A few moments later*
"With any luck, we can meet up with Skywalker on his way to Kenobi's position."
I like how they never deploy with fighter cover
the geonosians had so much firepower that even the main characters + jedi plot armour couldn't save them from getting severely injured
for me Anakin was never fit to be a Jedi, he should have been something else other than Jedi or Sith. He would been a perfect general with super soldier like ability along with force
I suddenly gained consciousness and welp there are no main characters on this LAAT
Rex and 501st in a long ass fire fight
Whoever was responsible for reconnaissance definitely did a pretty bad job... In the name of bloody good episode for the show.
I wonder what happened to the Clone Trooper pilots that landed those LAATs were used as barricades along with the ATTEs.
Kiadimundi was a psychopath and a hypocrite during the war. Cold and unfeeling. He told the admiral before he left "theres no such thing as luck" and in the next scene hes saying "with any luck we'll make it"
2:58 BRACE YOURSELVES!!!!!
Yeah 1:47
It’s a machine gun !
1:18 how come only some 501st have blue paint while others and just white
I'm not a tactical expert, but surely it would have been strategically wiser to orbitally bombard the enemy artillery positions and aircraft deployment stations before deploying the landing craft. Venators might not have been designed for it like the Imperial ones were but as was shown by the destruction of Tipoca City, they are capable of executing bombardments of ground targets.
is it just me or is the machine gunner at 1:48 and 3:48 really similar to the one at the start of Saving Private Ryan
The star wars version of "Black hawk down" and "a bridge to far"
Dont get me wrong,i love this series,but if they did a live action remake of this ,i would be hyped.this is Band of Brothers level of awesome
0:49 who is this?
Admiral Yularen
This really showed how hellish the Clone Wars truly was.
I love Star Wars!!!!!!!!!
0:48 and 3:42
Depending on how long into the war this happened compared to the episode they were introduced. No one can’t say that the clone with the chaingun/ rotary cannon isn’t hardcase. What proof do you have?
The clone pilots are the most expendable because the rarely survive crashes they don’t really eject until the siege of mandolore
Why J-1 cannons didn't specifically targeting the Acclamator assault ships? On Ryloth their fire was extremely effective against this type of big troop carriers.
Unless the cannon is out range