This type of clear crystal demonstration in any form of Indian Music can be given by only Pandit Ajoy Chakrabarty Sir 🙏🙏🙏... listening to you is itself an lifetime experience 🕉️
I just can’t believe that this precious piece has gone unnoticed by all! The comparisons demonstrated between Ghazal and Thumri is superb. আমার আবার একটা দুর্বলতা আছে, আমি কেবল একটি রাগ ‘ইমন’ নিয়েই সারাটা জীবন কাটিয়ে দিতে পারি| ইঁদুর দৌড়ের ভিড়ে না গিয়ে একেবারে ফাঁকা মাঠে একান্তে মনের ভাবটা বলে ফেলতে ইচ্ছা হল| সে অনেকদিন আগের কথা, দুর্গাপুজোর আর মাত্র একদিন বাকি, গোধুলি বেলা, বাড়ি ফিরছি| রবীন্দ্র সরোবর লেকের পাশের এক প্যান্ডেল থেকে ভেসে আসছে “গহন মায়ার ছলনা শ্রাবণের মেঘমালা...”, ভাগ্যটা ভালো ছিল, প্যান্ডেলেরই এক ব্যাক্তিকে জিজ্ঞেস করে পাশেই একটি ক্যাসেট বিক্রির দোকান পেয়ে গেলাম| ওনাকে জিজ্ঞেস করে জীবনে প্রথমবার নাম শুনি অজয় বাবুর| পরে ‘মঞ্জরী’ নামক ক্যাসেটটি কিনতে সক্ষম হয়েছিলাম| বাকিটা ইতিহাস| 🙏🙏🙏🙏
At Gazal point of view Ghulam Ali sang it better than any other Gazals singer 'At Thumri point of view you are also correct , Two different genre. Cooking same dish in different style
You are a great singer and musician, no doubt. And with your training you can get thousands of variations out of any raag, everyone knows it. But it will take you at least three births to sing it like Ghulam Ali Sahib! Your comments towards the end is rude! Ghazal singing is not about kalwati, every phrase you say comes from heart then it touches the listeners heart. I don’t think your rendition delivered a single line of this beautiful ghazal. I only heard sur-circus! My apologies if I hurt your feeling sir!
Hahahahhahahaha. Ponga pandit ji down to what he should have always been singing instead of muddying khayal waters with his decades and decades of antics and trickery. This way he might have irked Ghulam Ali sahab (the ghazal singer) a bit, though Ponga ji would have been quartered and served on the ghazal platter by GA in his sleep. But the Faustian hubris that makes Ponga think he is the next best thing after BGAK - or who knows, vanity is a weird thing, he might secretly even equate himself to the great man! - that hubris is seriously disturbing. And then to conceal it under cloak of faux politeness and faux gravitas - and to imagine that no one can see through it! - tauba.
Chorom oshikkhito and tikto manoshikotar ekta public. Nijeke bishal bodhhya bhabe . Pandit ji r nokhyer jogyo o howar jogyota nei edike .Khali youtubr e boro boro kotha. Keep on barking. Ei korei ja ektu patta paben .
Nothing compared to the great Ghulam Ali rendition of the song.. Ghazal comes from the heart and is just not getting the sur, tan technical stuff.. Over engineering beyond a limit makes it look rotten unfortunately..
Subhanallah subhanallah guru ji Allah apko salamat rakhain baray log 🙏❤️
Lots of love ❤️ mere Ustad ji Ustad Ghulam Ali Sahib ka kaam No #1 parnam ❤❤❤❤❤
This type of clear crystal demonstration in any form of Indian Music can be given by only Pandit Ajoy Chakrabarty Sir 🙏🙏🙏... listening to you is itself an lifetime experience 🕉️
Hearing this maestro is always something new to learn. May he be blessed with a long safe life.
I just can’t believe that this precious piece has gone unnoticed by all! The comparisons demonstrated between Ghazal and Thumri is superb. আমার আবার একটা দুর্বলতা আছে, আমি কেবল একটি রাগ ‘ইমন’ নিয়েই সারাটা জীবন কাটিয়ে দিতে পারি| ইঁদুর দৌড়ের ভিড়ে না গিয়ে একেবারে ফাঁকা মাঠে একান্তে মনের ভাবটা বলে ফেলতে ইচ্ছা হল|
সে অনেকদিন আগের কথা, দুর্গাপুজোর আর মাত্র একদিন বাকি, গোধুলি বেলা, বাড়ি ফিরছি| রবীন্দ্র সরোবর লেকের পাশের এক প্যান্ডেল থেকে ভেসে আসছে “গহন মায়ার ছলনা শ্রাবণের মেঘমালা...”, ভাগ্যটা ভালো ছিল, প্যান্ডেলেরই এক ব্যাক্তিকে জিজ্ঞেস করে পাশেই একটি ক্যাসেট বিক্রির দোকান পেয়ে গেলাম| ওনাকে জিজ্ঞেস করে জীবনে প্রথমবার নাম শুনি অজয় বাবুর| পরে ‘মঞ্জরী’ নামক ক্যাসেটটি কিনতে সক্ষম হয়েছিলাম| বাকিটা ইতিহাস| 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Brother! Raag yaman freak here..... can't describe in words
Pronam guruji, gazol gaicen, gazal and tumrir modhe gaykir different sikiecen
guruji namaskar 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Lots of love from Odisha
Khob valo laglo
What these 9 stinky dislike fingers are doing here? Get out before touching that dislike figure if you don’t embrace this Devine rendition.
Ultimate
Kya baat h great explanation
Pranam guru jee I am watching from Nepal 🇳🇵 🇳🇵🙏🙏🙏
Great, I am Nepali too.
guruji🧡🧡🧡 swayam prabhu gaa rahe hai.
Beautiful 👍
Sadar parnaam Gurudev ❤️🙏🏻
Pranam guruji🙏🙏🙏
This is first time listening. I am fortunate to listen
Pranam guruji
স্যার আপনি দীর্ঘ অতিদীর্ঘজীবী হোন! বাংলা ধন্য ভারত ধন্য আপনাকে পেয়ে।🙏🙏🙏
Pronam guru ji 🙏
Jai ho 🙏🙏🙌🙌
Thank you so much sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏we learn many more thing..
sir, thanks for lesson..
sat shri akal guru ji
Ghulam ali also sung beautifully
Awesome
Guruji pronam, raga yeamon, ghajal, different ghajal & thumri
At Gazal point of view Ghulam Ali sang it better than any other Gazals singer 'At Thumri point of view you are also correct , Two different genre.
Cooking same dish in different style
🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏻🙏🏼🙏🏽
🙏🏻🙏🏻🌹🌹
🙏🙏🙏
You are a great singer and musician, no doubt. And with your training you can get thousands of variations out of any raag, everyone knows it. But it will take you at least three births to sing it like Ghulam Ali Sahib! Your comments towards the end is rude! Ghazal singing is not about kalwati, every phrase you say comes from heart then it touches the listeners heart. I don’t think your rendition delivered a single line of this beautiful ghazal. I only heard sur-circus!
My apologies if I hurt your feeling sir!
Dilwalo ka dil gayab tha yaha..wo to Ghulam Ali sahb hi laa sakte hai...
Hahahahhahahaha. Ponga pandit ji down to what he should have always been singing instead of muddying khayal waters with his decades and decades of antics and trickery. This way he might have irked Ghulam Ali sahab (the ghazal singer) a bit, though Ponga ji would have been quartered and served on the ghazal platter by GA in his sleep.
But the Faustian hubris that makes Ponga think he is the next best thing after BGAK - or who knows, vanity is a weird thing, he might secretly even equate himself to the great man! - that hubris is seriously disturbing. And then to conceal it under cloak of faux politeness and faux gravitas - and to imagine that no one can see through it! - tauba.
Haha... jealous of him🤣🤣🤣tum to kch nahi kr skte..
I share your feelings
Chorom oshikkhito and tikto manoshikotar ekta public. Nijeke bishal bodhhya bhabe . Pandit ji r nokhyer jogyo o howar jogyota nei edike .Khali youtubr e boro boro kotha. Keep on barking. Ei korei ja ektu patta paben .
Nothing compared to the great Ghulam Ali rendition of the song.. Ghazal comes from the heart and is just not getting the sur, tan technical stuff.. Over engineering beyond a limit makes it look rotten unfortunately..
Don't u have the brains to understand this is not a typical ghazal rendition?
🙏🙏🌹🌹
🙏🙏🙏🙏