John Williams VS Hans Zimmer: THE SOUND OF SUPERMAN | Superman/Man Of Steel Soundtrack Mashup
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- John Williams and Hans Zimmer both wrote iconic music for superman movies. This orchestral mashup/remake featured motifs and themes from SUPERMAN (1978) & MAN OF STEEL (2013).
Music in this mashup:
-- Flight (Hans Zimmer / Man Of Steel / 2013)
-- What Are You Going To Do When You Are Not Saving The World? (Hans Zimmer / Man Of Steel / 2013)
-- Prelude and Main Title March (John Williams / Superman / 1978)
D O W N L O A D
You can download the midi/project file etc. here: bit.ly/Williams...
S O U N D L I B R A R I E S:
--Winds
Spitfire Symphonic Woodwinds
-- Brass
Cinesamples Cinebrass, Metropolis ARK 1, Spitfire Symphonic Brass, Berlin Brass
-- Percussion
Spitfire HZ Percussion, VSL, ProjectSAM True Strike, Metropolis ARK 1 & 2, NI Damage
-- Strings
Spitfire Symphonic Strings, 8Dio Adagietto, Chris Hein Guitars, CineSamples CineHarp
-- Choir
Cinesamples VoXos
-- Keys
NI The Giant
-- Synths
Zebra2
► Music arranged by Roland Mair-Gruber
S O C I A L M E D I A:
-- Official Website: bit.ly/MGroland...
-- TH-cam: bit.ly/MGroland_YT
-- Facebook: bit.ly/MGroland_FB
-- Twitter: bit.ly/MGroland_TW
-- Instagram: bit.ly/MGroland_IN
-- Tumblr: bit.ly/MGroland_Tb
If you like to purchase or license my music visit:
-- Business Contact: bit.ly/MGroland...
-- check out my gear @ kit.com/MGroland
© Music copyright 2019 by Roland Mair-Gruber
![Hans Zimmer: Man of Steel Main Theme [Extended by Gilles Nuytens]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Nutm8Nwk5xM/mqdefault.jpg)
If you want to download the Cubase project file or the midi file, check out the video description!
Thanks for the video and the files 👍
Ll
Hans zimmer= Beautiful
Jonh Williams = Classic
Hans Zimmer Zack Snyder and JunkieXL= Holy DC Trinity
@@lazerstudios9982 Yes, absolutely right 👍
John William's is Legend
@@solomona1300 even Zimmer is also legend LoL
John Williams > Hans Zimmer there will be one step between always.
I’m neutral, i think they are both amazing
That's the best way to be a fan❤
I agree both are great, and Zimmer did a fantastic job. I love his score.
But. That classic Williams Superman score. It's the standard for superhero themes. The one that you can play to anyone and it would be instantly recognizable
Both are awesome
Same
Hans Zimmer's better
Zimmers theme is "Epic" but Williams theme is "Majestic"
More or less beatiful than just epic
Zimmer - epic, his music pumps you up and gets you into the scene.
Williams - legendary, his music takes a scene and turns it into something greater
Hans Zimmer's is way better
@@MrDoom885 You're allowed your opinion
@@Syntage88 Fine let's agree to disagree
@@MrDoom885 well its your opinion and i respect that but john is better than hans since john is more emotional and hans just epicness
@@matteggsbenedictgamer5310 that doesn’t make one better than the other, I personally prefer Hans Zimmer’s theme but I respect you prefer John’s, but you can’t say one is better bc you think so
Whoever put this together married Zimmerman and Williams PERFECTLY!! GREAT JOB!
DC is greatness
DC is hope
DC is humanity
DC is philosophy
DC is life..
DC is Capitalist Organization.
Nothing more
FUCK, BEST PHRASE THAT I'VE HEARD DAMNNNN!!
I don't expect anyone other than Hans zimmer could have composed a new soundtrack which is just on par with John Williams
Zimmer is more emotional, a Superman who is discovering himself. Williams is a superman without fear and with enormous self-confidence.
Exactly. Hans Zimmer's Superman theme is telling the story.
Agreed
I disagree
Yep....
YOU ARE A MASTERMIND‼️
Williams is about Force, Presence and Power
Zimmer is about Choose, Experience and Do
For me as a 15 year old at the theater in 78 the epic sweeping John Williams’ Superman theme was magic as soon as the S flashed on the screen.Be that as it may I love the slow soft build up and then in your face Hans Zimmer theme in man of steel! Both are winners!
I like Hans Zimmer's score. It's so hopeful, unique and emotional. The S in Superman's suit means Hope and this theme sounds very emotionally hopeful to me. Williams score is just legendary but is more about the just and super part of Superman to me, but I do love that it has a playful kidish feel to it where every child can get exited listening to it. Zimmer's version is more of the inner, emotional part of Superman instead of his outer Superhero side of him
Hans Zimmer's Superman theme is beautiful and full of inspiration
kkkkk you are a stupid, normal song
I really love both, John William’s Superman theme is EPIC, but Hanz Zimmer’s “Flight” gets me every time! Put that together with Henry Cavill’s interpretation of the scene, it’s just MAGNIFICENT! 🥹💙❤️
Hans Zimmers interpretation is perfect for the modern era. John Williams version will always be a classic. They are both perfect in their own right.
All do respect to Han Zimmer is a musical genius but John Williams is a God
Hans has the edge, both have special places in my heart for different reasons
.
This is even more awesome since allegedly Cavill signed on to do more Superman movies today!!(🤞🤞🤞hope it's true)
John Williams = CLASSIC
I am big fan of hans zimmer since of my childhood best music director in the world
nope.
frost1977
They’re all good in my opinion
😂😂😂😂
You probably don't Even understand what music director means
I agree with him. His music is very relaxing and gets me pumped for the movie
4:38 that chord transition is very uplifting
Zimmer's version make us feel how Superman feels
And Williams version make us know how we feel about superman's heroicness.
Personally I love MoS music.
woooow !! this mashup comes really from Krypton, heroic and iconic !!
“You see I’m both Clark Kent and Superman, not because I have to be... now... because I choose to be”
John Williams describe Superman *"From Our Eyes/prespective"* hero that saves everybody and the day
Hans Zimmer describe Superman *"From Superman's Prespective"* the things he had to endure, learn to control yet not let emotion be in the way, the hardship of being accepted by Human etc
My interest in film scores began with Hans Zimmer's "Flight." It is a love letter to the character and brings a majestic, otherworldly feel. John Williams's score is a beautiful melody that I believe is recognized by everyone on this planet at this point, and I sure hope people think the same of Hans Zimmer.
They are different but love them both. No comic book character has 2 epic soundtracks except Superman.
I honestly think that the two versions of the same story says more about us then it does the Character of Superman. This age (the 2020s) is depressing and self obsessed, darker than any other time in my life. There is a sorrow... in this time, like we have lost and are in decline. The beginning ... the ancient civilization of Krypton, the sense of loss in the music is profound. You can understand where a civilization and culture is by the stories it tells itself. We are in our decline. Superman lives and dies in just two movies.
The music of John Williams was and is thrilling and joyful, exciting. Fun movie, youthful .. a time when we were, as a nation and culture, at the pinnacle of our progress, hope and optimism. These two movies gives us insight to what is happening within our own culture... the 1960s- 80s were a period of turning outward. Now this generation is turned inwards.
The Man of Steel theme is beautiful, but there is no competition as to which theme is superior. The original John Williams Superman theme will forever be the best of the two, and the greatest superhero theme of all time.
The difference between a Zimmer score and a Williams score is this...
A Zimmer score paints a tapestry of color, emotion, and energy that perfectly compliments the film for which it was scored.
A Williams score is the living force (pun intended) without which, the story could not be told. It is EVERY character, and the cast member with more lines than the hero.
A symbol of hope and justice....
Now combine both themes. What a master piece
John Williams theme portrays Superman as a true American hero who can do no wrong while Han Zimmer captures the POWER that is the kryoptonian Kal El
All due respect to Hans Zimmer I like his stuff I really do. And his Superman song is really good and it should have a place in the movie. What did John Williams score is the Superman song. It's what most people think of when they think of Superman. Zack Snyder was a moron for not including it.
Not anymore. Yes, it’s a classic, but when people hear the man of steel theme now , people get pumped and know Superman is in the room. The classic is good, but MoS just gives that vibe that Superman isn’t really human, and that he came from another planet.
@@PadmeGaveMeHIV bro you can still see people Taking the Man of Steel trailer and putting the John Williams theme over it. Same thing with the Superman CW Show. The John Williams theme is simply iconic.
@@PadmeGaveMeHIV th-cam.com/video/ZuGyUBJpg-U/w-d-xo.html . Watch this video. It's amazing.
Good job. I enjoyed it so much I was surprised that it ended.
In my humble opinion anytime I've heard a mashup of these two different themes the John Williams went always dominates the room every single time it doesn't really matter what piece they play it could be the Krypton theme song or it could be Superman's theme song it always dominates what Hans Zimmerman came up with for the Man of Steel always in fact the man of steals music just sounds like generic action music that would be played between the cues that John Williams actually wrote
wow.
usually in comment sections comparing themes you see bickering and people taking sides, but...what is this? people are actually enjoying what both these themes represent and are appreciating both of them?
whoa.
Yep. Superman, whether it's Reeves or Cavill, just bring out the best in others no matter the decade or medium.
Sia John Williams e Hans Zimmer sono bravissimi, con le loro colonne sonore hanno regalato tante emozioni. Sono stati tutte e due dei grandi maestri con le loro colonne sonore dei film di Superman, e anche dei altri bei film, ancora più belli e emozionanti grazie a questi due maestri. Ciao.
I love them both and rather than picking sides I actually think this mashup is the best version we've ever gotten and ever will
This is better, I love this
(This is beautiful and badass)
I hope this is the new Superman theme, this should be the opening credits from Man of Steel 2
MAN OF STEEL ❤
Simplesmente memórias fa minha infância.
This F*****g gold! I always told myself that if Snyder's superman did a musical piece like for a scene, I would totally lose my shit!!!
When people say Hans zimmers score is forgettable, it’s really not
Hans rakes me on an emotional ride everytime i hear it
Superman Dawn of Hope!!!!!!
but damn do they sound good together!!
John william. Classic
I was going to comment on which score I liked the most etc. Instead I’ve got to say this is one killer mash up you did, I’ve listened to a good amount of the zimmer/Williams mash ups and this one was by far the best. Excellent work, really took me back to the original feel and Into the modern.
You can't beat the power and emotion of the original.
I love them both so much.
John's theme is more like American
but Hans Zimmer's theme is more provoking that's why i lik that more
Hans Zimmer score makes me feel like I'm superman myself
I get that John Williams’ theme is iconic and what people think of when they think of Superman, but I prefer Hans Zimmer’s theme. It’s more hopeful, inspiring, and powerful to me
Exactly I agree with you. "Flight" theme made by Hans zimmer is the best in my opinion.
Ok but the John Williams theme is what Superman is as a person
@@JodaroKujo What does that even mean
Amazing job on this mix. Both pieces are amazing.
There are several versions of this mashup. The one I like best has the red Superman emblem on a grey rock wall background. Listen to it.
John William theme will always be the best superman theme. ALWAYS.
JW's march is the best movie theme ever made
Love both
Awesome vid. My one critique would have been to pull out some opacity on the music graphics.
Can't beat the John Williams Superman theme! It's more heroic, optimistic a theme of HOPE, and easily recognisable.
Las 2 versiones muy buenas ya q cada una tiene su tiempo saludos y muy buena mezcla. Congratulations.
Superman: I got you Miss
Lois: you got me? Who’s got you?
Only John Williams for me!
John Williams = GOAT PERIOD!
you cant compare it really because the style of the music is a completely different one. The old Superman was more heroic in the classic sense, and a little less serious. So a march like John Williams one wouldnt have fit the new Film but fits perfectly for the 78` Film.
Kick wonderwoman Love Superman
Bruh.... so good, can I please use this for a video edit?
Yes, my covers may be reused under certain circumstances: Please be sure to mention that this IS a cover and that the copyright holder are the composers, not me. Also be aware that possible incomes will be shared with Zimmer/Williams and please link this video in your description or name the source in your video. thanks!
Roland Mair-Gruber - Composer thanks i will!
john williams score is more superman than any of the actors. It is superman. Zimmer sets atmopshere, Willams creates one of the greatest leitmotifs ever made effectively embodying superman at the highest level.
If they still have plans on making a Man of Steel 2 (with Henry Cavill returning as Superman), this should be the opening credits from the film, this should be the new Superman theme
2:08
I love this Part.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏epic!!!!!!
El temazo de John Williams me parece mítico, épico y merecedor de varios Oscar's 🤩
Creo que debería ser seña de cada película nueva de Superman que hacen 👏👏👏
Nop . El de williams es mas epico.
Where can we see this vid without the music nodes!????
#Masterpiece
Great job !
the one and only...REEVE+WILLIAMS.
I really like John Williams but Hans Zimmer makes it kinda emotional
John Williams
I like hanz zimmer theme but damn jhon Williams version is God
Which one?The answer is a little bit complicated. JW Superman theme is awsome, and fit better for that film. Make the scenes more greater.
So which is the better movie soundtrack, the answer is: JW Superman theme, but....
HZ soundtrack is brilliant. I never sit and listening JW theme, just for relaxing...But i do with MoS soundtrack. I mean MoS soundtrack much better if i want to listening without the film. So this is why complicated the answer.
Zimmer have a most powerfull and Epic sound, but williams still the best
4:14
Superman is John Williams
As much as I like both, I personally prefer Zimmer's. It gives a feeling of power and mystery to Superman that imo William's didn't.
But Thats the thing superman isnt mysterious hes an open book
@@mak3yasmiil3 Who's? Snyder's Man of Steel is darker, flawed, and much stronger than many we've seen before and Zimmer's theme reflects that.
I suppose nuance could work in place of mystery but Snyder's Superman isn't as much of an open book as other versions.
#restorethesnyderverse
although Williams is a classic, man Zimmer's is so Epic and more grandiose lmao
Zimmer
Espero que não seja essa, apesar de uma boa produção, ainda não tem o tamanho do Superman...
I was, am and forever will be a massive fan of Williams' Superman Theme but it is a bit dated for my taste. Zimmer's score is what I prefer for Superman. Zimmer's music tells the story of Clark Kent and his destiny to become Superman, not because he has to but because he chooses to. It's more personal.
Williams' music is more majestic but that music is more about how people perceive him and not his story, it's more victorious and is about the Spirit of Superman. Whereas, Zimmer's score makes you feel the absolute strength of Superman.
Hans Zimmer score is okay, but is comparatively minimalist, and much more somber for a hero who is defined by his optimism and compassion. The John Williams score is as inspiring as Superman himself. It's joyful, playful, full of wonder and triumph.
Totally agree.
I like Hans but.... John just has it for me
Shame they couldn't of used both in the film as a nod to the original
I’ve got to admitt it.. I prefere the Zimmer version
Seriously i dont want to pick a side
There is NO comparison!!!
Superman is John Williams and John Williams is Superman!!!
After and over forty years
john Williams music still has a divine appeal to intiar world and almost every human on the planet knows and can sing the theme knowing for who it is written !!!
At the same time Zimmer music it's already forgotten....
In any case you can't remember it and certainly you can NOT sing it....
I'm fan of Zimmers old themes Gladiator, Crimson Tide, The Rock,, Black Rain. etc.
As he was getting older his music lost the strong momentum and for the last ten, fifteen years his soundtracks are not entirely his.... because there are other composers working and sign with him....
Last but not least Zimmer himself stated that he was wasn't able to overcome the Masterpiece of Williams Superman!
John Williams has the title of the Mozart of the Cinema music and he is considered Unique Genius and rightfully earned his place among the immortals of Classic Music!!!
Sorry but the classics is not able to get beaten by anything.
I say it's a draw! Both are epic!!
Thinks its a little sad you uses Williams score so little. But to be honest. I might have accepted Hans Zimmer if he did some nod to John in the music. Because sorry. Hans Zimmers theme isnt iconic, its just bomabastic and slow with lots of rythmical drum-patterns. You can really see how much more intricate John Williams theme is in this video. Its not that much long notes or slow. It happens something all the time.
I think it a reason why people LIkes Hans Zimmers more, because its easier to listen to. It sounds more like popmusic that people allready listen to. John Williams sounds and is more advance in its writing. More parts that do things. I Honestly think for many people thats not used to listen to this kinda music prefer the one they dont have to listen that closely too.
true.
William's Superman is more intricate and variations throughout leading to a better climax and end, Zimmer's is kind of "flat" by comparison.
Rookie Tiger no Hans Zimmer is more “pop” like. Most of his song are four chord or two chord song just like pop songs.
Also William's Superman theme sounds more exciting, Zimmer's kind of feels somewhat depressing.
Wrong. *Immensely wrong.*
What are you smoking my dude? Darker sure, but depressing?
Zimmer's music is not depressing. His music is EPIC. IT GIVES ME GOOSEBUMPS.
@@jimmyjamdrops7326 WTF, i think you only have heard the cd release of the soundtrack. The official theatrical version was leaked online, and it's NOT dark at all.
Sound's awful sorry not only is it to synthesize its to jarring and no matter how you try and make the hans zimmer version sound good it will never ever beat the John Williams original score masterpiece for this iconic character and that's was just one of their biggest problem with the man of steel taking away the classic iconic signature theme and replacing it with a crap version that just don't belong. It's like taking the classic iconic star wars theme and again replacing it with a completely new score with all the other new star wars film they made in the past boy there would be a uproar even thinking of doing it so Why would superman be any different.
Because there was no love or care and that's why people wasn't all that keen of the man of steel and the fact how dark tone the film was with it story and how serious it was having no humor or even colour that popped out from the custom. Hopefully man of steel 2 will be a much more of a marvel type film Quality along with the iconic theme going forward and with some charm along with it like a captain america the first avenger or a wonder women vibe. This is what people expect from a superman film NOT BEING BORED TO DEATH till some action set pieces starts. Having no humour in-between or no Clark kent moments just bogs down the film because they wanted to do a serious side to him and that made superman less charming and likable.
Why cavill had a tough time trying to do superman he couldn't bring him out to the surface like a reeve style did all because of the tone and dark story vibe it had going with it. So maybe this time round they will do some sort of John Williams Hans Zimmer mashup soundtrack but they need to do a real good job of it or just go with the classic iconic only that would be my preference.
Poor Hans Zimmer ! 2 notes every 5 seconds, versus John Williams who kills the game off with only a few bars of music ! 😅