As a Malaysian Malay🇲🇾, I feel sad because we could have a wonderful leader like Lee Kuan Yew in Malaysia. With his visionary leadership, I believe that we (Malaysia and Singapore as one country) could be a great regional power. But history is history. 🥲 I feel happy for the prosperity and advancement in Singapore. I hope the people are more happy and less stress over there. Sending lots of love to our brother across the causeway. Happy 58th Birthday Singapore! Majulah Singapura ❤️🇸🇬
It is surprised to see that our Malaysian Malay friend has this opinion too~! If every Malaysian (regardless what races) has the same thought like you, we definitely already be the developed country and fight with first-class country such as Japan in Asia or even the top of the world, due to our multiracial, multi-languages, multi-religious, rich natural resources, no any serious natural disaster and many others... But just like what you said, history is history... Let us just hope that our beloved country Malaysia 🇲🇾 will be more developed and advanced in the following years instead of going backwards... And our country as well as currency can compete with Singapore in the day we can see!
According to my maternal grandmother, the last straw that pushes the entire family to migrate from Malaysia to Singapore was the fact that she heard a lot of rumours that the Malays were targeting all the Chinese families around her hometown in Pontian and would seek them out and massacre their family so my maternal grandmother decided to move to Singapore as she thought that Singapore had a large Chinese population and she would be safer to seek refuge there in the year 1964.
Even until now the Malaysia Chinese still don't believe the Malaysia Malay.. You see now the latest news.. They want the Malay to take back the power.. That's why they won't success even they got natural resources.. 🤣🤣🤣
@@MIB-3 we wouldn’t know what happened to those in Malaysia after they migrated but we know for sure right before Singapore’s independence the relationship between the Chinese and Malay were the worst during 1964 which coincides with what my maternal grandmother said about racial tensions forcing them to migrate to Singapore. Btw, I’m a Singaporean thanks to my grandparents! 🥰
Thank you BKK for sharing the sad historical events on the eve of SG National Day, the events reminded us of being forced to go for independence suddenly as a small island without any natural resources. SG ppl will always stay united regardless of race and religion forever as we pledged to uphold of what we achieved for the past 58 years.
@@BBKNetwork two country&asian ni world.2 the emperors. The agong/emperors. Of inmalay. Yang di pertuan-agong pada/from malaysiani. Naruhito/emperor. From japani/jepuni. And. The King/rulers&9/state and 9-kings/royal to 1 next to new the emperors. Pahang/state/negeri. Now new emperor. From malaysia. We win. Monarchy in world.only msia. Just proud. me/we respect too.
That is something no one will ever know. Maybe if we had not been kicked out, LKY’s PAP might win the Federal Election and fulfilled his version of Malaya. How powerful that Malaya will be today is something we can only imagine.
@@taleliew1it means it is put in or authorised-contents, by the victors. Similarly for encyclopaedia n Wikipedia or dictionaries etc or similar, the input is done n from the authorised-contents. Who then authorised the contents ?? Of course human beings,right?? So who is the one on earth, to do such ? We know wiki was editted too, especially on definition of vaccines n it's related matters eg. some professional/experts CVs was editted or 👀👁️🧐🫢🤑💰
It was a blessing that Sg left Malaysia in 1965. Through the 58 years, Sg achieved a in one united people / nation regardless of race, language or religion, Sg also built a democratic society based in justice and equality and it achieved happiness, progress and prosperity for its people and country. Founder PM Lee Kuan Yew pledged on 09 Aug 1965 night that Singapore will survive! He achieved it in his life time and even surpassed his promises will flying colours! Through these 58 years Msia’s regress it’s GDP and GDP per Capita went southwards because according to Mr Tan Teng Boo, it’s destroyed by Msia.’s 4th & 7th PM’s policies.
@@Edwin-fk4yy In return thru the 58 yrs JB gets clean portable water which u can drink directly from the tap. We also have develop a total of 17 reservoirs, sea water desalination plant, & new water.
@@leewn2319 haha, without the "raw water", sold From Johor FIRST for SG to " process" you think SG will be "so generous" to "resell" the treated water to Johor? Why SG didn't process the sea water from 1961? （so that SG PPL WONT DIE OF DEHYDRATION).BY the way, fyi, Johor oledi has its own water treatment plants, it is still getting the treated water "Resold" by SG Bcos the water agreement is still IN FORCE UNTIL 2062.
As a singaporean , I’ll need to correct the video on PAP victory in Singapore after the merger with Malaysia. The reason of victory was not due to the high Chinese population in Singapore. It was due to the vision from the leader that the voters have made their choice. It has nothing to do with race in Singapore.
马来西亚抛弃新加坡明明是个myth。actually Singaporean politicians are so hopeful of Singapore’s future, and it is a mutual separation. why must make it look like Malaya is responsible for Singapore?
not like responsible for singapore or look down for sgp politic。我只是个人会认为当初mly的政府有进行类似压迫之类的 加上种族之间的冲突才导致sgp forced退出，毕竟当时sgp属于各方面还比较没那么强大的国家去抗衡其他国家 所以我会认为是mly因为宗教问题比较强势逼迫，你们的politic可以维持的好是你们政府的能力 我只是觉得lgy的马来西亚人的理念真的很好也很可惜mly失去了一个这么坚持平等的领导人 mly领导人反而不顾情面and种族挑分。身为一个malaysian＋华人会觉得有一种同类人的惺惺相惜你们为了华人的权益这么努力 又有一点愤愤不平mly的宗教问题从之前到现在依然没有改善 。totally just a 感慨毕竟最初也是有sgp的加入才有mly的独立 之后也是因为种族哪些问题导致分裂。Singaporean Malaysian到现在人民习惯等等还是很类似 但是华人的权益却相差甚远
实话说，我看觉得我考好的原因是因为我越读越生气，太多我不赞同跟理解的点点滴滴了。打个比方: 为了确保各个种族都有公平对待以及权利，硬硬要写成 menjamin hak dan keadilan org melayu serta kaum lain. 还有中五的历史，后面bab几乎都是bumiputera读的有够闲。*我个人看法啦，有可能我打错了请谅解，已经是前年至今年年头的回忆了。btw, sej 拿到 A+ :D
excellent production, please keep it up! Regardless of the political background, the friendship between the two nation shall strive and blossom in generation to come.
Malaysia kicked Singapore out was one of the best thing to happen to Singapore and it's people. It was a blessing in disguise. It's like the abusive bad boyfriend kicked out the girlfriend, she thought it was difficult initially, but later she blossomed into a better life. The best Singapore could be if it did not leave Malaysia would be a second Penang, restricted their growth potential due to race and religion politics that still exists today
lol, you think a state of a country can join and leave as they like? Malaysia mps decided that Singapore should leave and they voted for Singapore to leave without asking PAP.
@@zhen86 then I corrected my analogy, the abusive boyfriend decided to leave the girlfriend, the girlfriend initially felt depressed and lost because she was very small and has no one else but then she worked hard and built a better life for herself without the control of that abusive boyfriend.
Thank you tengku for your far-sightedness that your country progress will remain stagnant for the past 5 decades… that you do not want Singapore to suffer with you as a result of your incompetence… We greatly appreciate your goodwill… without you, we won’t have this progress we have today… it would be absolute madness to imagine Singapore the extension of the the filthy dirty Johor Bahru… Let’s continue to believe what you think is right for your country and what we think is right for our country… and continue to widen the gap further… Lol
The day SG was expelled from MY was a moment of great pain for LKY, who felt that he had let his people down. At that point in time, SG had no resources and was at the mercy of MY even for drinking water. SG also had no means of defending itself as our British overlords too left us to our own fate. The next few decades were a tortuous scramble to attract investment, build up the existing meagre infrastructure, and strengthen defense.
To add, why did Malaysia had their independence earlier than Singapore is, the British had wanted to keep a string of ports starting from port Smurf to Gibraltar to Suez to Aden to Singapore and to Sydney. The British needs this shipping line to be open to obtain crude oil and many many other vital supplies for United Kingdom. When the British lost control of Suez in 1956, they have had to let the idea go. When Singapore was allowed to return to Malaysia, it was too late, the Malay extremists had the political landscape divided by RACIAL lines, from the very top, the political parties were on Racial lines alone. The late Mr Lee Kuan Yew have had wanted a Malaysian Malaysia not A Malay Malaysian. Also,the weakness in Ringgit Malaysia has got NOTHING to with us Singaporeans. We need our car to be filled 75% with petrol before we can cross the causeway, ofcause driving around scenic Malaysia, we need to top up the tank, if not we cannot continue with the beautiful journey in Malaysia. Thank you very much.
感谢Surfshark VPN带我们回顾历史上的今天
用我们的链接来下载 Surfshark VPN at
surfshark.deals/BBKNetwork
或者输入优惠码：BBKNetwork
就会获得专属优惠及免费3个月使用哦～
Jocelyn Chia watching this?
这个surfshark VPN我买了结果在中国不能用😭，只能在中国另外买“梯子”才能出来看BBK
新加坡是印度人发展的
第次看到這個頻道，挺有內容的👍🏻
(原來星馬的孩子是用簡字的⋯⋯)
@@tanzhiharng8312 您太幽默了，印度人連總人口1成都不到
As a Malaysian Malay🇲🇾, I feel sad because we could have a wonderful leader like Lee Kuan Yew in Malaysia. With his visionary leadership, I believe that we (Malaysia and Singapore as one country) could be a great regional power. But history is history. 🥲 I feel happy for the prosperity and advancement in Singapore. I hope the people are more happy and less stress over there. Sending lots of love to our brother across the causeway. Happy 58th Birthday Singapore! Majulah Singapura ❤️🇸🇬
Thank you😊🌷
It is surprised to see that our Malaysian Malay friend has this opinion too~! If every Malaysian (regardless what races) has the same thought like you, we definitely already be the developed country and fight with first-class country such as Japan in Asia or even the top of the world, due to our multiracial, multi-languages, multi-religious, rich natural resources, no any serious natural disaster and many others... But just like what you said, history is history... Let us just hope that our beloved country Malaysia 🇲🇾 will be more developed and advanced in the following years instead of going backwards... And our country as well as currency can compete with Singapore in the day we can see!
🥲
Thank you Bang
Thank you for your well wishes and open mindedness. Unfortunately, only a handful of Malaysian thinks like u
身为马来西亚人，我真的很佩服李光耀这个人物。
謝謝 有這樣的節目能讓人更了解 馬拉西亞這個國家 讓我改變看法 更能了解這美麗的地方 生活在台灣的人 其實也對這裡區域很感興趣
我最近很瘋台灣的總統選舉 好精彩
也學習很多人生哲學
@@Flyhigh920台灣政壇有點狂，還會戰學歷戰論文，這個議題來馬來西亞的話應該99%議員要下台
謝謝你對馬來西亞的贊👍美！馬來西亞的確是一個好山好水的國家。歡迎你到馬來西亞遊玩。😊
熱死了
香港人X2
身为一个马来西亚人，我很遗憾马来西亚失去了一个很有远见的人才，同时我也很庆幸新加坡脱离了马来西亚，让我可以看到新加坡如今的辉煌。如果新加坡没有脱离马来西亚，我相信新加坡一定会被马来西亚拖累，看看马来西亚那些愚蠢政客，我也不想多说什么，说多了都是泪
因为你是华人？
新加坡欢迎你与你的子孙到来。
@@甜甜圈-b1w because sgd to myr is 3.5 haha
华人在马来西亚的宪法里面算二等公民，不脱离他们华人有好日子过？到时候再整出一个印尼排华事件就惨了
@@甜甜圈-b1w不是好嗎，對我來說馬來西亞需要的是有能力的領導人，不是種族歧視的領導人，很明顯東姑阿督拉曼就是一個有點種族歧視的領導人，把只有馬來人可以當馬來西亞的首相寫進憲法這件事真的扼殺了馬來西亞的很多可能性，如果當初沒有訂下這條憲法的話，也許現在馬來西亞會是一個很好的國家，而且新加坡就可能不會被獨立出去了
History has a tendency to repeat itself. As memory fades, events from the past can become events of the present
Very good content !
时间已经证明了一切啊... 大马太种族主义，别人过得很好很富有，我们很羡慕。
不需要吃着自己碗里看着别人碗里 马来西亚和新加坡发展方向完全不一样 你在享受着马来西亚低竞争的消费 生活无忧无虑 然后看着新加坡赚新币 可是你如果看过每个在组屋楼下的老人家 你又想起在马来西亚养老是多幸福
原来很辛福。继续辛福下去呀。
要记住，要学会爱国国家才会变得越来越好，你看看新加坡的人民就是爱国，中国的人民也非常爱国，所以他们的国家才会越来越好，马来西亚也一样，不管国家对我们华人怎么样，首先要学会爱自己的国家，不要诋毁自己国家，总是说自己国家什么什么不好，这样就会变得更不好，要说自己的国家好，要爱国国家才会越来越好😁😁😁
做 贡献吧。 我只能说 又爱又恨 哈哈 (∩_∩) " I help u " " u help me " 😅
@@偷师学徒你拿真心爱马来西亚，但马来西亚永远看你是二等公民。交一样的税，拿不一样的福利。大学名额固打制，土著房屋固打制，IPO固定土著配额与优先权，土著优先经营权，30％土著公司持股等等，一堆福利都是你拿不到的。
According to my maternal grandmother, the last straw that pushes the entire family to migrate from Malaysia to Singapore was the fact that she heard a lot of rumours that the Malays were targeting all the Chinese families around her hometown in Pontian and would seek them out and massacre their family so my maternal grandmother decided to move to Singapore as she thought that Singapore had a large Chinese population and she would be safer to seek refuge there in the year 1964.
Even until now the Malaysia Chinese still don't believe the Malaysia Malay.. You see now the latest news.. They want the Malay to take back the power.. That's why they won't success even they got natural resources.. 🤣🤣🤣
All are welcome lah
@@MIB-3you think at that time you have social media to tell you what the actual fact?
@@MIB-3 we wouldn’t know what happened to those in Malaysia after they migrated but we know for sure right before Singapore’s independence the relationship between the Chinese and Malay were the worst during 1964 which coincides with what my maternal grandmother said about racial tensions forcing them to migrate to Singapore. Btw, I’m a Singaporean thanks to my grandparents! 🥰
I remember that Indonesia slaughtered Chinese several times, and I also saw pictures of Indonesians eating Chinese children
非常爱看许嘉雯的主持 💕
马新一家亲 🇲🇾🇸🇬
愿 马新友谊长存 各自安好 再创辉煌✨
在这里祝新加坡五十八岁独立国庆日快乐🎂
新加坡曾经是大马的一份子是一段无法抹去的历史，不过很庆幸的是两国没有因为这段历史而断了连接，双方在这几十年互相提供经济资源，人力资源给予对方，使大家在不足之处可以得到充足。虽然两国几十年来曾经因为一些事情有了矛盾，但是最终还是放下来，持续与对方合作。大马人和新加坡人是永远的好朋友，好兄弟，新马友谊不会改变🇲🇾 🇸🇬
也祝新加坡58周年国庆日快乐🇸🇬🎉
没有必要抹灭吧。两边人都不觉得这有什么。分手后还是朋友。
@@cancanjaker1620 有的国家要是和邻国有这段的历史，作风早就不同了
@@ys723 新马跟其他地方不同。大大方方的承认，历史清清楚楚。其他地方就像是离婚，财产孩子争不停的。
@@ys723哈哈哈哈哈哈 我知道你在说哪国
🇲🇾🇸🇬🤝
真的非常感谢bbk所报道这些我们不为人知的故事。作为一位04年且关注政治的年轻人我其实感到非常担心因为我发现目前一部分的年轻人并不关心我们国家的变化，当然也有很多年轻人一直持续关注政治，但只有少数这样的年轻人还是不够的，我们年轻人一代手上的每一票都是制胜关键，我们的思想和我们行动都很重要，如果我们不现在拼搏和关注要更待何时？一个国家的发展并不只有政府在改变，我们人民的行动和思想都应该随着时间和时代的变化做出改变。我也很感谢我中学时期的补习历史老师，是这位老师告知我们，学习历史spm考历史不仅仅是为了应付考试，我们更应该知道事情的本质。说实话当我在中国抖音上看到有些马来西亚华人所说的一些言论其实叶间接暴露了我们国家的教育体系出现了问题，因为极少人知道这段历史背后的本质。所以无论是年轻人，成年人甚至是uncle auntie，行动起来！为了国家更好的发展！
已故李光耀先生一直是我的偶像。我覺得新加坡人都會感到慶幸有這麼一位領導。
这里有2个点加以补充
1. 当时新马合并的目的是为了解除新加坡产品进入马来亚的关税。但是合并之后关税并没有解除。
2. 李光耀的哭并不是新加坡独立没有资源，很难生存。而是他未能实现“马来西亚人的马来西亚”。他认为自己鼓动了一批人去为这个目标奋斗，是因为在马来西亚里的新加坡，人口比利还有的拼一回。但是如果新马分家，这个梦想由于人口结构悬殊而变得遥不可及。他认为新加坡一旦离开了马来西亚，将陷这批“志同道合的有识之仕”们于不易。
那只说明当时的李光耀对伊斯兰文化是缺乏了解的，华人在马来西亚来说就是异教徒，异教徒和伊斯兰教徒能融合在一起吗？尤其在伊斯兰徒在当地占主导地位时。纵观伊斯兰教的历史，没有。因为一神教天然具有强烈的排他性所致。看看马来西亚法律，是不是这样？
新加坡人民行動黨最好的領導人是吳慶瑞，他是檳城人！ 所以才會有必須要合併，一起打拼的理想！
懂什麽叫鰐魚的眼淚嗎？人家一早就打算獨立的，只是直接獨立不可能，就加入馬來西亞
Thank you BKK for sharing the sad historical events on the eve of SG National Day, the events reminded us of being forced to go for independence suddenly as a small island without any natural resources. SG ppl will always stay united regardless of race and religion forever as we pledged to uphold of what we achieved for the past 58 years.
身为一个大马人 我很庆幸我们没有害到新加坡跟我们一样落后
不是没有害，马来西亚多个首相时不时的都想害新加坡只害不成反而害了自己而已。哈哈
🤣🤣
真的，我看的时候觉得幸好我们没有弄到别人，不然都没有这么好的一个国家
其实很多马来西亚的华人都在新加坡政府部门担任高职位。
@@chenghuilai9275 你忘了马来西亚除了一直用水课题威胁新加坡，之后又禁止沙石出口到新加坡想阻止新加坡须要的建设发展，但整个东南亚除了新加坡谁须要向马来西亚买，这不是断了自己的财路，后来又禁止鸡出口到新加坡但新加坡可以向很多国家买结果还是害了自己的鸡农。请问如何变得更好？
新馬本一家 兩邊都share著共同的歷史，文化，語言，甚至是體驗 和 親人。
血濃於水的感情，祝馬來西亞的兄弟姐妹們身體健康 萬事如意.
這個主題很好！😍希望可以繼續做下去🎉
你是中共派来的吗？
做墨酱像靠北"一家亲".
哪有血浓于水，利益罢了，美国建国十三州没有感念英王皇恩，台湾也不会因为同文同种而要统一😂
@@vtex-s9h 是人有能力有实力都想独霸一方，给你军队给你资金 你也想分裂一个地区来当王拉 哈哈
现在甚至更多亲人去那边了 哈哈哈哈
「對種族主義的零容忍」，雖然我是東馬砂拉越的，我好希望整個大馬趕緊迎來這一天。
馬哈迪的「馬來人無能」論述實在是讓人無法接受和理解，華人文化有優勢也不應該立法形成對抗。
這個絆腳石不僅只是會對經濟發展形成負面影響，還永遠沒辦法讓馬來西亞除了食物以外的軟實力（電影、娛樂業、藝術人文教育等）得到充分發展。
我一個哲學系畢業的好困擾，搞不好某一天就往BBK投履歷了呢（欸嘿，半認真，你們考慮一下
这里概述的是Stephen Kalong Ningkan尝试使砂拉越脱离马来西亚独立的关键事件:
Stephen Kalong Ningkan是砂拉越于1963年加入马来西亚联邦后,首位砂拉越首席部长。他是一位伊班族民族主义者。
1966年,他发起了砂拉越脱离马来西亚的运动,因为对砂拉越加入马来西亚的条款和条件感到不满。
他声称,砂拉越加入马来西亚时,并没有放弃其自决权,依然保留追求独立的法律权利。
他的运动获得了一些民众支持,因为许多人觉得砂拉越的利益在联邦政府里代表性不足。
但是,时任首相东古·阿卜杜勒·拉赫曼领导的联邦政府采取了严厉措施,在1966年对砂拉越宣布进入紧急状态,并解除Stephen Kalong Ningkan的首席部长职务。
在Ningkan被移除权力之后,脱离马来西亚的运动也平息下来。砂拉越依然是马来西亚的13个州属之一。
1966年之后,Ningkan继续参与政治,但在1997年去世之前,没有再次积极推动砂拉越独立。
总之,Ningkan在60年代短暂且无果地尝试过争取砂拉越独立,但砂拉越仍然是马来西亚的一部分。他是重要的政治人物,代表了砂拉越的民族主义诉求和权利。
@@KTH424
你說的是馬來西亞日1963年9月16日？說實話，這種假設性問題有點難以回答。
我高中畢業以前也是一個地緣意識強烈的砂拉越人，對這片土地的資源被不均勻分配給整個馬來西亞發展其實有很大的不滿。
但若是按照當下的局勢，砂拉越被共產黨執政，甚至說是被印尼或汶萊吞併的可能性也不是沒有。
我相信無論是怎樣，只要不是砂拉越獨立成立民主且廉潔的政府，和現況其實不會差太多。因為比起資金都外流馬來亞的發展之外，更多的是貪污腐敗的政府而導致的人民貧困。
至於為什麼放棄支持地緣政治，是在大學裡修過「世界正義」這堂課，做了很多思辨。
我認為不僅僅是地緣思考有太多漏洞，而就現在來看，「砂拉越人的砂拉越」只是一個GPS遊說民眾不支持在野黨的一個論述工具。
在我看來，獨立自主仍然有其價值，但絕對不是現在能做到的事。
我們還是專注把整個馬來西亞發展起來吧，不然民智未開的社會裡，民主什麼也做不到。
@@ChretseCYJ但是观察全世界，好像穆斯林国家是没办法把国家弄好的，像马来西亚有之前这些成就，也仅仅是因为它们允许华人寄居在上面而已
馬來人智慧與才能不足，個性懶散又貪婪，卻掌控政府不放，該國上至政治高層下至基層公務員，幾乎都是馬來人，難怪貨幣貶值，經濟漸漸衰退，除非讓華人執政還有變好的機會，否則等資源枯竭，馬來西亞就成為貧窮國家，新加坡因華人執政才變那麼好，好在沒與馬來西亞合併為一國，否則就沒今天的榮景。
@@寅炠wah.. Sedap mengata orang Melayu ye
没办法改变过去 只希望未来大家都安好
愿 新马友谊长存
别掉入仇恨陷阱 朋友多一点还是比较好
心存善念 尽力而为
祝新马两国 共同进步
兩邊并不是朋友，是家人.
家人 就應該互相幫忙 一起奮鬥
祝福兩邊的兄弟姐妹們 要團結 不要被外國勢力影響.
@@kazama600I really pretty Malaysian chinese. 加油，greeting from a Singaporean.
@@kazama600家你媽
说得好
祝两国万岁!
非常喜欢BBK团队的叙事方式。幸苦了！建议BBK做一个References/Bibliography文章目录，帮助观众弄清文献的来源与出处来保证文献内容的专业性。谢谢。
在說明欄有列明。
辛苦，不是“幸苦”
@@Michelle-xy5ck🤭😂
May both countries maintain good relationship with each other. Happy 58th birthday to Singapore.
我非常感谢bbk的历史课。从西马老师讲我们马来西亚的历史课本是马来人的storybook，我好像明白了
謝謝BBK為我們製作這部影片！
但有一點小小的私心就是希望可以把影片做得更詳細，更長一點 因為根本看不夠啊XDD
🎉好哦 还在探索中 怕太长太细节会闷 我们再试试看
@@BBKNetwork two country&asian ni world.2 the emperors. The agong/emperors. Of inmalay. Yang di pertuan-agong pada/from malaysiani. Naruhito/emperor. From japani/jepuni. And. The King/rulers&9/state and 9-kings/royal to 1 next to new the emperors. Pahang/state/negeri. Now new emperor. From malaysia. We win. Monarchy in world.only msia. Just proud. me/we respect too.
新加坡国庆日快乐！！
我们新加坡与马来西亚本就一家亲，虽然因为政治原因分家，但不可否认的是我们有着共同历史和文化。
希望你们大马未来会越来越好！
we are family
感谢新加坡给了无数大马人多一条出路，无论是一流的教育还是优渥的工作机会。
@thsiah...也感谢大马人耒新加坡工作and prosperous the country in a way. Specifically thanks those Malaysian nurses that work in our hospitals. 🫡
你应该感谢马来人，没有他们就没有1对3， 没有1对3就没有优渥的工作机会
@zhifong-gan Nah.... should thank those 'capable ' leaders dat take care of the country.
@@limbehh8494他／她也许是马来人吧！所以才会有这种想发！
對，也感謝馬來西亞願意售賣水源，糧食，電力給新加坡否則，新加坡真的會餓死。
As a Singaporean, separating from Malaysia was the best thing that happened to us.
You are right. You are right.
Yup! Heng-ah!
As a Malaysian, you're right!
That is something no one will ever know. Maybe if we had not been kicked out, LKY’s PAP might win the Federal Election and fulfilled his version of Malaya. How powerful that Malaya will be today is something we can only imagine.
@@jermel85fully agreed. Our Malaysian chinese will be better treated but most importantly Malaysian n Singaporean will be united n prosperous. 🇸🇬 🇲🇾
马来西亚和新加坡之间的关系经历过一些波折，有时候可能会出现误解和矛盾。然而，两国之间也有合作和友好的一面，包括经济、文化等方面的交流👍
Jocelyn Chia 我們新加坡人也不喜歡她，因為破壞我們兩國之間的感情。
🇸🇬🇲🇾🤝
你是説工程吗。
其实在新加坡每年国庆只看到新加坡版的分手故事，很庆幸也能聆听马来西亚版的故事。
英国首相丘吉尔（Winston Churchhill）有一句名言：History is written by the victors. 历史不外乎就是胜利一方所主导的故事，后辈在研究的时候很难保持客观评价。
Agree.
这句话是这样理解的吗？
As for Wikipedia n more others, ,the owners are also human beings, similar to victors....
@@taleliew1it means it is put in or authorised-contents, by the victors. Similarly for encyclopaedia n Wikipedia or dictionaries etc or similar, the input is done n from the authorised-contents. Who then authorised the contents ?? Of course human beings,right?? So who is the one on earth, to do such ? We know wiki was editted too, especially on definition of vaccines n it's related matters eg. some professional/experts CVs was editted or 👀👁️🧐🫢🤑💰
英国对新马的历史分析最中立
我也感激新加坡雇主給我工作機會. 也感激新加坡政府的效率和經濟看到前途發展.
嗯，这一期历史课做得很好👍🏻 从你们开始的青涩到现在，的确进步了很多，加油。
新加坡生日快乐🎉🎉欢迎常来马来西亚吃肉骨茶❤
对新山人来说新加坡是像是我们的"第二个家"
我们的童年是第8频道，okto, channel 5 (绳之以法，灵异怪谈yyds)，每个周末早上的乐乐窝，还有周六晚上的百倍千倍。
小学会唱majulah singapura & "建国配套陪你到老"~
假期时会到新加坡探望亲戚，去那里的图书馆，动物园。长大了不少人也到那里工作，以前我的爸爸天天来回，辛苦他了❤
这是一段非常非常非常棒的历史课。BBK团队，谢谢你们，幸苦了。
Thank you Malaysia for disowning Singapore. The best thing to ever happen in hindsight. Happy Birthday to my homeland Singapore 🇸🇬!
身为00后的我太喜欢这个节目的类型
真的如标题所说 我们需要了解马来西亚虽重要但新一代都不懂的历史
身为一个了解两国历史的中五生, 很高兴能看到BBK纠正课本的内容
It was a blessing that Sg left Malaysia in 1965. Through the 58 years, Sg achieved a in one united people / nation regardless of race, language or religion, Sg also built a democratic society based in justice and equality and it achieved happiness, progress and prosperity for its people and country. Founder PM Lee Kuan Yew pledged on 09 Aug 1965 night that Singapore will survive! He achieved it in his life time and even surpassed his promises will flying colours! Through these 58 years Msia’s regress it’s GDP and GDP per Capita went southwards because according to Mr Tan Teng Boo, it’s destroyed by Msia.’s 4th & 7th PM’s policies.
I thought we should turn 64 years old, instead of 58.
@@seangoh120658 years from 09/8/1965 independence as a true sovereign country. Majulah Singapura! Happy Birthday Singapore! 🇸🇬🇸🇬🇸🇬🎂🎊🎊🎉🎉🍾️🍾️
Of course SG "survived", with continued reliance of water and other essentials from MY since 1961.
@@Edwin-fk4yy In return thru the 58 yrs JB gets clean portable water which u can drink directly from the tap. We also have develop a total of 17 reservoirs, sea water desalination plant, & new water.
@@leewn2319 haha, without the "raw water", sold From Johor FIRST for SG to " process" you think SG will be "so generous" to "resell" the treated water to Johor? Why SG didn't process the sea water from 1961? （so that SG PPL WONT DIE OF DEHYDRATION).BY the way, fyi, Johor oledi has its own water treatment plants, it is still getting the treated water "Resold" by SG Bcos the water agreement is still IN FORCE UNTIL 2062.
已经大爱了bbk network 2年了！谢谢你们用心的创作 ❤️ 身为一个00后 真的对马来西亚的政治有了一个全新的认识 谢谢bbk network ✨
当时李光耀是哭成泪人来独立新加坡的，但是回头看我们也很庆幸
感谢分享，有一点须补充：新加坡在1959年就从英国手中获得自制了，与大马水供条约是在1961年签订的而不是1965年独立以后。
新加坡与大马因天时地利因素结合，却因人和因素分离看似可惜却冥冥之中已然注定。
再说，历史是由赢家们述写的，小篇所讲述的也只是挖开冰山角下的多一公尺，还有许多不为人知的人事物也只能让那些勇于追问探索加上附有一定智慧的人士再细心揣摩了。
祝新加坡生日快乐，Happy birthday Singapore! 🎉🎂🎁
As a singaporean , I’ll need to correct the video on PAP victory in Singapore after the merger with Malaysia. The reason of victory was not due to the high Chinese population in Singapore. It was due to the vision from the leader that the voters have made their choice. It has nothing to do with race in Singapore.
But it is also true that the cities in Malaysia with high Chinese population develop better than other cities
That's the conclusion you get if you think with a Malaysian mentality (race based)
谢谢你们的付出才能让我们的后代们有迹可循的了解历史
谢谢 BBK. 小小更正: 新加坡立法议会第一次选举是在1955年。李光耀的PAP在1955选举只有3席。第1任领导是 David Marshall, 只是当时称首席部长（Chief Minister). 到1959年第二次大选是PAP胜出组新加坡自治政府才称总理 (Prime Minister). 如此李光耀是第一任总理。
马来西亚当年抛弃新加坡感觉真的有点残忍 一个总理要多无助才会当众流泪
不过新加坡真的很不容易 走到现在的经济 社会风气 都领先大马🥺
新加坡国庆日快乐
有可能是要新加坡跪着回来求合，毕竟当时没有人认为一个连水的不够的小岛能生存下去。结果成就了新加坡奇迹，也成就了政治伟人，李光耀。
马来西亚抛弃新加坡明明是个myth。actually Singaporean politicians are so hopeful of Singapore’s future, and it is a mutual separation. why must make it look like Malaya is responsible for Singapore?
not like responsible for singapore or look down for sgp politic。我只是个人会认为当初mly的政府有进行类似压迫之类的 加上种族之间的冲突才导致sgp forced退出，毕竟当时sgp属于各方面还比较没那么强大的国家去抗衡其他国家 所以我会认为是mly因为宗教问题比较强势逼迫，你们的politic可以维持的好是你们政府的能力 我只是觉得lgy的马来西亚人的理念真的很好也很可惜mly失去了一个这么坚持平等的领导人 mly领导人反而不顾情面and种族挑分。身为一个malaysian＋华人会觉得有一种同类人的惺惺相惜你们为了华人的权益这么努力 又有一点愤愤不平mly的宗教问题从之前到现在依然没有改善 。totally just a 感慨毕竟最初也是有sgp的加入才有mly的独立 之后也是因为种族哪些问题导致分裂。Singaporean Malaysian到现在人民习惯等等还是很类似 但是华人的权益却相差甚远
新加坡融入马来西亚后，在新加坡的中国籍人都变成了马来西亚人。
新加坡独立后，这些“马来西亚人”又变成了新加坡人。
所以当时没有中国人变成新加坡人
而是马来西亚人变成新加坡人
所以如果新加坡有事也只能回归马来西亚（ 与中国没有关系）
@@ct9245 與中國當然有關係，那個時候毛澤東向整個東南亞輸出革命，寮國、柬埔寨都被搞掉了，印尼差一點赤化。馬來人忌憚華人的一個重要原因就是中共。畢竟中共搞統戰，面向的是全球華人
嘉雯很有大将之风，讲得真棒！连梗都完美呈现！🤣
有人问我要怎样考好sejarah 其实当你明白了整个完整故事脉络的时候 再读回你的课本时就很自然得心应手了
确实是这样，我去年spm也是这样，就是把看新闻和看历史影片成为一种习惯，结果spm拿了A
那么刚好去年历史的考题就是问新加坡的问题，也许我回答得不错拿到B+😂
@@ys723 原来你是去年SPM的考生，你的每次留言都很成熟👍
实话说，我看觉得我考好的原因是因为我越读越生气，太多我不赞同跟理解的点点滴滴了。打个比方: 为了确保各个种族都有公平对待以及权利，硬硬要写成 menjamin hak dan keadilan org melayu serta kaum lain. 还有中五的历史，后面bab几乎都是bumiputera读的有够闲。*我个人看法啦，有可能我打错了请谅解，已经是前年至今年年头的回忆了。btw, sej 拿到 A+ :D
@@hhb3978 每个人的方法不同吧，其实如果对历史真的有兴趣，你会发现其实里头的人物是很有趣的，比如讲rosli dhoby刺杀事件，当年他跟rukun 13党员精心策划，选在时任Sarawak gabenor Duncan Stewart来访sibu时，由队友兼首脑之一的morshidi sidek上前要求合照，到最后dhoby突然冲上前刺死Stewart, 结果是到最后dhoby判死刑，虽然说有争议因为dhoby当年还未满18岁，不过英国人直接不鸟照样处死他
excellent production, please keep it up! Regardless of the political background, the friendship between the two nation shall strive and blossom in generation to come.
Friendship can. But if they want to like china ki siao "one malaysia"/"belong to msia". Then no way.
谢谢你们非常简单额要，有趣幽默的讲述了新马分家的历史。加油咯！😊
住在新加坡旁边新山的我们更加看到严重的对比。过得去的生活去到新加坡也是需要除与3·3。加上看到新加坡錢幣幾乎主宰我们的经济迈向，非常确定我们理解种族差异的问题之大。
新加坡 是幸運的！選了一位明君。LKY is smart and with Integrity ❤
当然啦！新加坡是他的私产。敢和他作对，就会被禁声抹黑，用内安法无审收监，不然让你失业破产。伪民主，实独裁。不如说马来西亚是庆幸的。呃，觉得有些人会不以为然。但，至少马来西亚土著应该很欣慰东姑当年把LKY踢掉是对的。
只有封建思想才会期待明君
”選“？你覺得新加坡選民有的”選擇“嗎？早期的選舉，PAP都是在提名日開始就已經“當了政府”，無需等選票開箱。但是，我認同李光耀是位有能力的領袖。但是自從他不在后，新加坡政府就開始變了。支持率開始下滑，看看過去3屆大選成績就能知道。（如果不是GRC制度和選區劃分制度不公）PAP老早就已經失去國會3份2議席。
無可否認 新加坡人真有福氣！
想当年，新加坡被马来西亚踢出去的时候，什么都没有，一穷二白的小岛. 结果现在，亚洲金融中心，国际大都市，发达国家
马来西亚当年一开始有天然资源，有全方面发展潜力. 结果现在，种族政策，固打制，还處於发展中国家，政客勾心斗角还要面对宗教政策影响，东海岸更是因此落后没发展，重点是＂新币1：3马币＂。。。
其實種族問題不是馬來西亞現況的根本，我們曾經有過強大的經濟
主要原因是因為馬哈迪對經濟的理解確實不如李光耀， 在97年金融風暴來臨之前沒有辦法產業轉型，再加上風暴過後原本經濟狀況還好的時候維持的貪汙體制直接導致經濟無法復甦
3.4了我人在新加坡了，之前还有3.45
還處於發展中國家 這句是廢話
幾乎全世界都還是
因為待在發展中 是有好處拿的🤔
要记住，要学会爱国国家才会变得越来越好，你看看新加坡的人民就是爱国，中国的人民也非常爱国，所以他们的国家才会越来越好，马来西亚也一样，不管国家对我们华人怎么样，首先要学会爱自己的国家，不要诋毁自己国家，总是说自己国家什么什么不好，这样就会变得更不好，要说自己的国家好，要爱国国家才会越来越好😁😁😁
@@偷师学徒 不懂得批判自己國家也是不好的吧.....
我是一名中五的學生。BBK的這個系列，讓我明白了歷史課本中那麼重要的一環（還沒學習到這裡XD）......希望BBK能夠推出更多這個系列的影片，感謝❤
hehe 很可惜历史课本不会记载这段细节的往事
Is the textbook you're studying in Mandarin or Malay?
sejarah老师说新加坡比我们先进是因为有港口和适合的地理 我在想他们水都要和马来西亚买 我们资源比别人好 但走得比人家落后很多很多😅
Excellent work. Loved the analyses that takes into account potential biases and historical sensitivities. Looking forward to more content!
蛮短一下 不过不错 蛮应景 因为明天新加坡国庆日
住在新加坡将多年我最喜欢的就是 我的钱包电话放桌上都不用怕
（以下开放给我们去过新加坡的malaysia人来称赞一下新加坡，给他们开心一下啦 😂
哈哈哈哈感谢新加坡一直蓬勃发展，让马来西亚有可以参考的方向😆Singapore boleh
我非常喜欢听历史故事，继续来多一点这样的内容。谢谢😊
不錯的歷史解釋，至少不會讓大家意識到新加坡的獨立並不是單方面的因素。然後如果新加坡當年妥協繼續留在馬來西亞，現在的新加坡是不可能出現的。另外也不要有覺得新加坡獨立後就會強盛的意識，當年的國際情勢下，一個那麼小的國家是不會被相信能成功的。新加坡是真的很另類，李光耀是真的很特別。
另外也不要覺得馬來西亞會沉淪，從來沒有一個多元種族的國家可以和平共榮那麼多年，看看歐洲那些多族群的國家分類多厲害。馬來西亞是真的很成功了，只是還需要繼續努力耕耘創造更好的未來。
Malaysia kicked Singapore out was one of the best thing to happen to Singapore and it's people. It was a blessing in disguise. It's like the abusive bad boyfriend kicked out the girlfriend, she thought it was difficult initially, but later she blossomed into a better life. The best Singapore could be if it did not leave Malaysia would be a second Penang, restricted their growth potential due to race and religion politics that still exists today
lol, you think a state of a country can join and leave as they like? Malaysia mps decided that Singapore should leave and they voted for Singapore to leave without asking PAP.
@@zhen86 then I corrected my analogy, the abusive boyfriend decided to leave the girlfriend, the girlfriend initially felt depressed and lost because she was very small and has no one else but then she worked hard and built a better life for herself without the control of that abusive boyfriend.
They are being expelled not leave, just so you know
正因为多数华人的离开，才让马来西亚的政要分子为所欲为。如果李光耀先生成为马来西亚总理，马来西亚还会这样吗？也许那个包含新加坡的马来西亚更加耀眼也许会爆发内战，总之被驱离是一个折中的选项。
rip penang
90年代小时候一进woodlands就马上可以感觉到新加坡完全不同，十分美丽十分发达，规划非常好。至今我们wawasan2020也达不成，永远只能羡慕他们努力建国的成果。虽然很抱歉但是我们的大族群真的很不行，永远都只在乎自己利益，不会看大局。
比起卢卡斯，更喜欢嘉雯的讲解，口齿清晰流利，说话一说就通，继续支持这个节目
谢谢大马的朋友制作这么好的纪录片 🤗
你们这个的影片我最喜欢。 加油 做多点这样的片。影片的制作也非常一流
Thank you tengku for your far-sightedness that your country progress will remain stagnant for the past 5 decades… that you do not want Singapore to suffer with you as a result of your incompetence…
We greatly appreciate your goodwill… without you, we won’t have this progress we have today… it would be absolute madness to imagine Singapore the extension of the the filthy dirty Johor Bahru…
Let’s continue to believe what you think is right for your country and what we think is right for our country… and continue to widen the gap further…
Lol
这个节目我喜欢😊
我觉得下一个topic可以讲一讲关于叶亚来开辟吉隆坡的历史(现在的sejarah课本都没有提到叶亚来对开辟吉隆坡的贡献，就是放一个名字罢了)
这样的专题报导很棒👍🏻
謝謝！
谢谢！
不错。比学校讲的历史还要真实。希望有续集
根据李光耀的回忆录，新年分家的决定早已经国会通过之前由东姑决定了，甚至事前都没有照会英国人。新加坡是全世界最后知道这个决定，可以想象当时他们的惊慌失措。
嘉雯这一集表现出色👍👍👍👏👏👏
我香港人，喜歡BBK這個（課本不會教的歷史）這個單元！最震撼是看513那集！可以認識南洋社會歷史
聽說到目前為止，還是有不少的馬來族，認為當初是老李有意要脫離馬來西亞的，說老李就是一個背叛者，到目前一提起當年的脫離，都對老李恨到不行。
如果BBK能對以上一說，也做出一集節目，那就真的感激不盡了，tyvm。
老李才不是背叛者，人家也不想离开马来西亚。事实证明，这个是必然发生的。
新加坡和马来西亚在一起也并不会像如今发展这么好。肯定先优先发展本地资源。独立后新加坡没什么资源，难以生存下去才迫不得已实行英语教育吸引外资而国外资本给新加坡带来的巨大发展潜力。
The day SG was expelled from MY was a moment of great pain for LKY, who felt that he had let his people down. At that point in time, SG had no resources and was at the mercy of MY even for drinking water. SG also had no means of defending itself as our British overlords too left us to our own fate. The next few decades were a tortuous scramble to attract investment, build up the existing meagre infrastructure, and strengthen defense.
感谢PAP当年到马来半岛参选且赢得一个席位，今天我们才有DAP这个选项
不然大家可能要从MCA或是Gelakan之间做选择了 XD
别忘了有牛头党
謝謝BBK 製作，可以讓我孩子知道為何新加坡和大馬會分家。
真的很感激bbk network总是做这种很有意义内容，让我们更了解马来西亚
新加坡的繁荣,带动了大馬华人的生活,谢谢👍👍👍
所以6十多年过去了～ 币值翻3倍是人家新加坡一直在进步有大格局～ 马来西亚就原地踏步还被政客弄退步
只單單用貨幣强勢標準就說一個國家有“大進步”。那，科威特的貨幣對新元是1對4.3啊所以，新加坡也是“原地踏步”？你真的非常膚淺，你去回顧1971年爲什麽馬來西亞，單方面退出Currency Interchangeability Agreement (1967)才來評論。
谢谢bbk让我重拾对历史的热爱
新马一家亲🇲🇾🇸🇬 我小时候觉得新马两地的人是互相讨厌的 长辈常常说新加坡的不好 比如新加坡人很骄傲之类的
但是长大后 我来到新加坡 遇到一个当地的taxi司机 他对我很热情 他老婆也是马来西亚人 他说：“新马一家亲 新加坡和马来西亚就像是一个国家”
庆幸我们没有因为历史上的分裂而互相仇恨
普通的老百姓都应该这样的，除了一些比较激进的网民会比较不友善。我有很多大马的朋友但是我最看不惯就是很多大马算民爱在介绍新加坡的视频那里攻击新加坡的食物和酸言酸语那样。不懂为什么一定要这样，几乎每个社交媒体的video，post都看到他们那样。
马来西亚的酸民喷子至今还是如此。。
这就是我喜欢BBK 的原因，希望你们继续创造更多优质的内容 ！ 加油！
很喜欢这个系列，历史课本没有教你的事。支持你们做下去。
Thank you! A totally unbiased presentation of history. Excellent attempt to walk the fine line! Thank you Again!
To add, why did Malaysia had their independence earlier than Singapore is, the British had wanted to keep a string of ports starting from port Smurf to Gibraltar to Suez to Aden to Singapore and to Sydney. The British needs this shipping line to be open to obtain crude oil and many many other vital supplies for United Kingdom. When the British lost control of Suez in 1956, they have had to let the idea go. When Singapore was allowed to return to Malaysia, it was too late, the Malay extremists had the political landscape divided by RACIAL lines, from the very top, the political parties were on Racial lines alone. The late Mr Lee Kuan Yew have had wanted a Malaysian Malaysia not A Malay Malaysian. Also,the weakness in Ringgit Malaysia has got NOTHING to with us Singaporeans. We need our car to be filled 75% with petrol before we can cross the causeway, ofcause driving around scenic Malaysia, we need to top up the tank, if not we cannot continue with the beautiful journey in Malaysia. Thank you very much.
這一集嘉雯講解的很棒哦
新加坡好,马来西亚也很好。大家一起加油吧！❤
支持bbk继续做出这么有quality的content 🤍
In Singapore, the system is based on Meritocracy.
In Malaysia, the system is based on Bumiputra policy.
马来西亚为什么与新加坡分手？
原因很简单
因为新加坡那时候的政治局势（人民行动党）足以威胁马来亚的政治
以及马来人和华人人口的问题
我們是不是應該捫心自問，為什麼所有穆斯林人口可觀的國家地區都與動亂扯上關係，沒有例外？
一句到位“忌才上位”
种族宗教至上，选贤与能排外。
@@giant108 文萊有嗎？
@@giant108对，哪怕是我们中国国内的新疆也是
谢谢李光耀做出正确的决定 让我们马来西亚人可以赚3倍😂
人民行动党如果拿下国会首相就是李光耀
李光耀是没得选好吗
不对不对 ，是那个 126投票的人，加上之后马来西亚退出马币，新币和文莱币可以共用的协议，当时那有人怕新币带来劣势而提议退，的确退后马币的确有高过新币，但不持久过后马币开始掉掉到现在这个汇率了
@@20kaka07 有可能吗？
@@zhisinlee2687 有啊，那时李光耀很强势，说话和做事一流，你有听过他的马来语演讲吗？
希望大马的政坛能摆脱种族和宗教色彩，迈向马来西亚人的马来西亚。如果当时Tunku Abdul Rahman相信和支持这个理念，想必有大面积土地、多人口和天然资源的马来西亚肯定早就超越新加坡了。
If only LKY is in charge....
Thanks
Well done BBK , excellent piece 👏
新加坡国庆日快乐！！！🇸🇬🎉🎉
期待有一天能够移居到新加坡❤️
谢谢你。❤
痛苦无人知
“移居”后，然後周末開車回去柔佛添”廉價汽油“？飆車？
@@Edwin-fk4yy 这和想要移居新加坡的人一点关系都没有好不好
加油！欢迎你来！
Tomorrow is Singapore's 58th birthday. Happy birthday Singapore!
李光耀是一個非常有能力的領袖，新加坡有今天他功不可沒
没想到不止新闻说得好 历史也说得好 期待继续说历史🎉
真的很棒！加油BBK!
好詳細的影片。想不到印尼在這裏面好像也扮演着某種角色，希望會出一集講講大馬跟印尼的關係。
嘿嘿嘿嘿，大马跟印尼的关系很精彩的。比如konfrontasi时候就有印尼特工潜入马来西亚
@@socrates2111 那馬來西亞也有暗地影響過印尼嗎
合并之前是Malaya ，新加坡和马来西亚合并之后就加了Singapore “ Si ” 英文字母就变成了 Malaysia.
Over here n today... I want to wish 马耒西亚人的马来西亚国庆日快乐🎉 Greeting from a Singaporean. 🇸🇬 🇲🇾 together we prosperous. 發ah !!!
最后那一part MY SG各有各的好， SG有发展蓬勃的先进生活， 而MY有轻松自在的老年生活 赞啦
那段话是李光耀的声音吧？突然间很想他，比想我ah gong还想他1:03
😢😢😢
Good summary! 大马还是很多优点，Nasi lemah 是不一样的。