Dengar keluhan Sabah, Sarawak, selamatkan Malaysia dari ‘perpisahan’
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ต.ค. 2024
- Ahli Parlimen Keningau, Jeffrey Kitingan berharap, Perdana Menteri Ismail Sabri Yaakob akan mendengar keluhan rakyat Sabah dan Sarawak bagi menyelamatkan Malaysia daripada “perpisahan”.
Laporan Lanjut: www.freemalays...
Free Malaysia Today is an independent, bi-lingual news portal with a focus on Malaysian current affairs.
Subscribe to our channel - bit.ly/2Qo08ry
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Check us out at www.freemalays...
Follow FMT on Facebook: bit.ly/2Rn6xEV
Follow FMT on Dailymotion: bit.ly/2WGITHM
Follow FMT on Twitter: bit.ly/2OCwH8a
Follow FMT on Instagram: bit.ly/2OKJbc6
Follow FMT Lifestyle on Instagram: bit.ly/39dBDbe
Follow FMT Ohsem on Instagram: bit.ly/32KIasG
Follow FMT Telegram - bit.ly/2VUfOrv
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Download FMT News App:
Google Play - bit.ly/2YSuV46
App Store - apple.co/2HNH7gZ
Huawei AppGallery - bit.ly/2D2OpNP
#FMTNews #DewanRakyat #Sabah #Sarawak
Serawak dan Sabah saudaraku Kalimantan Indonesia 💖
Singapura dan brunai.sangat pintar
Tu kerana efek sejarah ganyang malaysia, kalo tak ada sejarah tu kaya gk mungkin SG dan brunai bisa berdiri sendiri,
Yes aku orang sabah, bagi aku kedua negara tu sgt pintar
Sukarno sejak tahun 1963 menentang Singapura brunai Sabah Serawak masuk federasi malaysia
Klw masih ingat pertengahan 80an inilah menteri yg pertama cakap pasal autonomi bumiputra..tapi ditangkap oleh Mahatir dan ditelanjangkan..
actually ,PBRS is his own party before STAR ,at the time he decide fight to UMNO under TUN .So now we must stand together to looking and step forward for makes our Sabahan Great to the world.
Sebaiknya rakyat Sabah sarawak bersatu bersuara supaya keluar malaysia...nk tunggu sampai bila.
Betul2
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
Sabah serawak kluar dri malaysia 👍👍👍sabah sarawak pasti kaya macam brunei darussalam. Amin
@@awankz6584 setuju. Seperti gagasan presiden RI soekarno. Sabah dan serawak harus jadi negara sendiri sendiri. Aamiin
Dah bertahun tahun tak keluar pun.....protes n perhimpunan tak buat pun.....rasanya kurang dari 5,% je rakyat sabah n sarawak nak keluar malaysia...camne ni bro?
Keluar saja dari malaysia..kita ada hak atas negeri sendiri
Terbaik takbir sendiri spt Singapore Brunei, susah senang tanggung sendiri
PM MALAYSIA..dengar bagus2 kaluhan rahyat Sabah dan sarawak.rahyat Sabah dan tak sanggup di perbodoh bodoh kan lagi.rahyat Sabah dan Sarawak dah tahu putar belit politik karajaan Persekutuan semenanjung.sabah Sarawak ada hasil bumi sandiri juga bah.kmi pun mau maju juga.
Kenapa yg baru memerintah dipersalahkan Kenapa tak persalahkan Mahathir,Pak Lah ,Najib Dan PM yg lain .Puncanya tu hah Mahathir.,,,yg menjadi PM paling lama,Bilal keluar Msia Sabah akan dituntut Sulu Dan Filipina peranglah jadinya.Sarawak akan dituntut lndonesia malapetaka jadinya Suku2 dayak dilndonesia akan menuntut haknya,Rakyatsabah Dan Sarawak koranglah yg akan merana
Lama dah boxxx
Semoga negara sabah dan serawak.
Suaktu saat nnti.
Akn klwr dri malaysia.
Dan mnjdi negara yg untuh.
Semoga Negeri2 sperti Aceh,Riau dan kepulauan Riau mmbentuk negara keluar Indonesia dan membentuk negara melayu raya yg utuh😏😊
@@s.a.d.s.h.s.h.s.n.s.a.m aminn krn aq jg orng aceh.
Wkwkw
@@andikakangenband6119 mantul
@@s.a.d.s.h.s.h.s.n.s.a.m it tul
Semoga sabah serawak kluar dari malaydesh agar sabah serawak hidup lebih baik,untuk sabah serawak,💪merdeka.!!!@@s.a.d.s.h.s.h.s.n.s.a.m
keluar terus la tlg la banyak org sabah kluar cri rezeki semata2 sbb sna gji besar tpi bila dfkirkan sma juga malaysia??? kpa sna lain sni lain ???????
Setuju .beza sangat gaji Sabah, Sarawak dgn semananjung
@@hanafi9808 sabah 8 jam kja sna pn 8 jam sja kja tpi gji bapak besar blh bt rumah klu kja 5 tahun smpan2 terus
Saya kalau disabah banyak peluang pekerjaan gaji sama mcm di semenanjung.. apa bikin sa pegi merantau sampai belasan tahun di semenanjung. Bgus kerja di negeri sendiri. Ini sebabnya org borneo merantau. Kalau ekonomi pesat disabah ank2 borneo tidak payah la pegi jauh2 negeri org. Inilah puncanya bergabung tpi pembahagian tidak adil.. so ketinggalan arus kemajuan.. apa lgi peluang bergaji tggi.
@@rizkunrizkun3295 setuju asi .pemimpin sma rakyat ganas tpi bila cerita hak rakyat pemimpin kalah bulu tidak tau mcm mna mau bntu rakyat nya sendiri
Sa rasalah kan kalau tu kerajaan pusat sama kerajaan negeri buat undian pasal rakyat sabah&serawak bersuara memang diorang akan terkejut tidak kepuashatian tentang kemajuan 2wilayah ni. Kalau tidak percaya cuba la kerajaan pusat buat undian.. kita tolak tepi la mentri2 borneo ni yg diorang ckp menghasut rakyat sabah&sarawak. Biar diorang dgr sendiri apa keluhan rakyat 2wilayah gabungan ni. Rata semua kecewa tau ka.. tgk sa sendiri sejak sdh belasan tahun duduk di(selangor) balik kg apa saja sa boleh buat. Tiada zero. So terpaksa la sa bekerja disini.selangor balik musim perayaan sejak. Kalau tempat sendiri mcm di selangor ni kerja bergaji ok. Ingat sa gila ka mahu dtg negeri org. Itulah alasan diorang sbb penduduk sabah tidak ramai.sebab semua keluar merantau ke negeri org cari mkn. Pandai btl permainan diorg.putar belit
Jom sokong Sabah dan Sarawak merdeka jadi 2 negara...
Biarkan orang sabah mengurus wilayah SABAH.....!
Biarkan orang sarawak mengurus wilayah SARAWAK....!
Sabah tu NEGARA bukan negeri...
Sarawak tu NEGARA bukan negeri..
Jom buktikan orang² Sabah dan Sarawak bisa bina negaramu...!👍👍👍👍💪💪💪
@@micanzyt8078 kita org sabah sudah bertahun lama bro di anak tirikan di Malaysia ni. Hasil minyak sabah habis disapu ke semenanjung cuma berapa percent sabah dpt. Saya setuju jg kalau sabah sarawak keluar dari Malaysia .
@@whatsgood9841 bukan semuanya kemajuan di malaya daripada sabah sarawak...cuba kau lihatnya balik....penanaman padi terbesar di malaysia?penanaman kealapa sawit di malaysia?industri perdagangan dan perindustrian di malaysia terbesar di mana?semuanya di malaya....sabah sarawak hanya membekalkan petroleum dan gas....bukannnya malya maju teruk pun ....kau tgk kat kedah,perlis,kelantan....bnyk penanman padi dan bukit penuh je lagi bro....
@@whatsgood9841 semua pi kat kl,jb dan p.p. je...lain ii cm hanat hmmmm...tapi aku sokon sabah sarawak ambil balik hak petroleum tu kembali
Kalau PEMALAS mmg tak akan maju sebuah kawasan tu. Ambil cermin dulu sebelum mulut buka!
Kaw jawa tak tahu sibuk lah sial....tu Aceh Papua dan banyak lagi nak merdeka ..tu pasal ibukota nak di tukar ke Kalimantan .tggl jawa sesorang ..🤣🤣
Sabah dan Serawak seandainya berdiri sendiri akan jadi negara yg makmur
kalo sabah sarawak berdiri sendiri, habis dong melayu di malaysia, tinggal di semenanjung di dominasi cina dan tamil, juga ras campuran jawa, minang dll.🤭 nanti bakal semakin parah kebijakan pemerintah malaysia untuk memelayukan semua orang yg ada di asia tenggara🤭.
Kalau Sabah,Sarawak nak btul2 kluar dri Malaysia mestilah seluruh rakyat Sabah,Sarawak turun ke jalan teriakkan referendum so next bawa sluruh dokumen perjanjian Sabah,Sarawak untuk kluar dari Malaysia ke majlis tinggi PBB itu baru betoll...klau cma wakil2 parlimen ugut2 negara di persidangan aiii ahli parlimen semenanjung gelitik2 ktawa je dengar sambil angkat cawan minum kopi 😎😎😎
Itulaaa usaha takde.aku bukan nk hasut.klau betul2 ss nk keluar malaysia.sepatutnya kena berani laa buat mcm apa yg bro ckp.ni takde satu pon yg buat.
Maling
Ada la 5 orang
Sabah maju jaya ..tiba masa sabah memerintah sendiri membangun sendiri +++++kesian kami rakyat sabah sarawak terkongkong macam di jajah semula 😔
Sudah merdeka masih dijajah.. 😂 Bagus queen ambil balik Sabah Sarawak.. Mata wang tinggi.. Kaya kaya kaya kaya.. Boleh pigi malaya shopping sakan mcm org brunei dan singapore.. 😜😁
@@sazalisagir147 🙂
@@sazalisagir147 betul juga kan
@@sazalisagir147 ya itu betul. Jika Sabah Sarawak pisah pasti akn kaya
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
Keluar saja dari Malaysia adalah langkah terbaik.
Langkah jahanam Ada la
Merdekaaaa
@@vladimirputin4215 jahanam untuk semenanjung, syurga untuk Sabah dan Sarawak
Keluar malaysia saja la.banyak negara besar yg dah berpisah pun masih hidup mcm soviet union sekarang dah jadi rusia saja pun hidup.taiwan pun taknak bergabung dgn china
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
MA63 Sering dilupakan....
Semoga Malaysia rakyatnya adil makmur & sejahtera. Biarlah setiap Negara mengurus urusan dalam Negaranya sendiri. Setiap Negara ada masalahnya sendiri. Semoga Allah berikan jalan keluar yg terbaik utk semua Rakyat Malaysia, aamiin🤲🤲
Tapi Malaysia ga henti2 nya nyrempet2 NKRI .. dan suka mengklaim … tapi NKRI aman2 saja ..
@@blitutbagoes2396sibuk la kau kanoha ni....urus negara sendiri....
Saya sabahan sya sokong sbh dan srwk keluar
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
@@ahmaduwais5588 pakailah bahasa melayu kau orang malaysia knpa tak pkai bahasa ibunda kau...
Senang pkai english je
@@ahmaduwais5588
You pakai bahasa sabah je, bahasa kau punya bangsa. Kau malu ke pakai bahasa kau punya negara
buat la demo....berani tak
50bilion Persekutuan Tanah Melayu,50bilion Sabah dan 50bilion Sarawak
ini baru ngam
Tak fair
@@cocomelon6589 makan babila kau
ini aku setuju
Keluar ja boleh dpt hasil 100% kalau cerdik la,lain pulau lg pn xkn sakut dgn tanah semenanjung pun,dri dlu lgi aq sokong korang keluar,mcm kami belah semenanjung kisah sangat🤣🤣
Revolution with armed struggle is the only solution to free Sabah/Sarawak out from the federation..
The People needs to Revolt.
Exactly !!! bro by hook or by crook...
People’s Power 💪👊
Wake up Sabah & Sarawak , Keluarga Malaysia palsu again , 6o years , Enough is enough .
@@jeffrey4181 Apa-apa Yang semenanjung Mau cakap Jangan percaya
Tapi tolong la apabila sabah keluar dari federasi Malaysia, sya x mau org cina yg menguasai Sabah, sya x mau sabah jadi mcm Singapore.. biar la org tempatan sabah yg berkuasa Okey.. ingat tu mungkin lagi 10 tahun Sabah akan berpisah.
setuju
Betul. Orang Melayu singapore pon kena tindas ngn cina sana... Bnyk Melayu singapore lari Malaysia.. Sye ade keluarga singapore. Sye tau lh
@@Aliv-hy7bv itu tidak akan berlaku org cina tidak akan menguasai sabah dan sarawak.kita orang tempatan sudah muak dgn politik jgn fikir duit ble membeli segalanya dan kita berhak menentukan hala tujuan kita.orang sabah dusun,bajau,murut,kadazan kedayaan,bisaya,rungus,sungai lundayeh brunai kawan² bugis sebelah tawau sandakan dan terlalu banyak bangsa di sabah kalau sy mau sebut semua tidak cukup ni komen...kalau kita semua jaga negara kita begabung tiada orang ble membawa anasir jahat buang kan segala korupsi buat kerja dengan betul kalau bersatu dengan izin Alllah kita akan berjaya jgn membezakan kaum dan agama..niat kena betul dulu baru kita berjaya
Sye berharap begitu... Sabah Sarawak tk keluar Malaysia... Sebab family saya di singapore ditindas.. Di hina😭😭😭..
Yg ni saya sokong
Sarawak kluar kita pakai dolar😍
Sudah saatnya sabah and Sarawak kembali menjadi nusantara seperti nenek moyang dulu
Bila Sabah Sarawak keluar daripada penjajahan kerajaan Malaysia maka bisa jadi Sabah Sarawak akan makmur sperti Brunei dan Singapura 😎
Lepas tu filipina akan kecam dan mengata sebahagian sabah adalah tanah filipina... lepas tu indonesia akan cuba melakukan sesuatu untuk dapat sebahagian sarawak... peruntukan ni kena tengok siapa bagi... cm sarawak sabah skrg siapa.. cm tak kata apa apa pun... tak boleh buat apa.... cm senyum je... semenanjung kata ok lah sebab cm tak bising pun..
@@angieng1776 baut apa ke Sabah dan Serawak? , pemerintah Indonesia suda terlalu berat menanggung beban 240 juta jiwa penduduk nya sampai-sampai pendapatan dan belanja negara defisit cuman buat gali lubang tutup lubang
@@angieng1776 jaga tuh mulut dasar tukang fitnah
@@fauzanilhamnabil4901 siapa akan tahu nanti... siapa kata sulu akan lepas tangan kat sebahgian sabah... siapa akan tahu arah ketentuan sesuatu negara... usa pijak kat timur tengah pun disebabkan minyak mentah..... semua negara rebut pasal laut cina selatan ni apa pasal... siapa boleh jamin demi kepentingan negara... klu indonesia tak berminat ni... pencerohan kat sarawak tak berlaku...ko tak tahu ke.... orang indonesia menceroboh kat kampung sarawak dan mengata tu tanah indonesia.... apa cerita... orang mentah dan jahil hanya akan kata oih tu tak kan berlaku ....
sabah sarawak harus keluar malaysia.
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
Mgkin sudah wkt'a Sabah dan Sarawak memisahkan diri dr Malaysia dan mmbentuk negara sendiri..
👍
buat apa nak save Malaysia sedangkan pemberian kewangan tidak sama rata.. jadi adalah lebih baik bercerai daripada terus menerus dalam Malaysia..
Betul tu,lebih² lagi sarawak,sarawak mmang slalu dapat paling sikit..sdang kan Sarawak negeri paling besar dr mana² negeri di malaysia,sbab tu sarawak mundur,sbab duit peruntukan cuma cukup² makan saja..
Harap menteri² sabah sarawak lebih bijak pandai dr segi pbangunan,sbab kalau bnyak kilang kat sabah dan sarawak,bkmungkinan besar,rakyat sabah dan sarawak senang cari kerja..tapi gaji minima kena pantau juga la,sbab gaji minima di sabah dan sarawak sgt² di bawah dr apa yg di unsur kan,lebih² lagi kene dgn majikan kedekut..
Ala macam menteri2 kau tu semuanya baik tak ada yg corrupt. Kalau negeri tu dah industrialist maju boleh lah, ni
negeri sendiri tak terjaga ada hati nak merdeka. Buat lah demo ramai2 kat jalan kalau nak merdeka sangat. 🤭
Aku tak nak cakap lebih,kalau orang Sabah Sarawak majoriti inginkan pembentukan negara sendiri tanpa ada apa2 ikatan dengan semenanjung dan mau merdeka,aku tak halang jika itu dapat membawa lebih kebaikkan kepada mereka dan buatkan mereka dapat membangun lebih dari sekarang..biar negara jadi kecik takpaa,senang sikit😂
Kalau sudh mcm ni bgus keluar lh diri malaysia apa lgi mau tunggu sndr lh rakyat sabah dan sarawak demi masa hadapan anak jati borneo
Nampaknya sudah 58 pembahagian belanjawan antara malaya , sabah dan sarawak masih lagi dibuat dengan cara yang bertentangan dengan perlembagaan persekutuan Malaysia walaupun sudah berkali kali mendapat teguran dan bantahan dari sabah dan sarawak.
Mereka orang2 yang tidak jujur dan tamak..mereka akan terus mengaut hasil bumi Sabah dan Sarawak..bala pasti akan menimpa pada orang2 yang mengambil hak orang Sabah dan Sarawak....amin.
@@jamilmanaff8463 Ala menteri2 kau tu sekarang jujur ka? Negeri sendiri pun tak terjaga. 🤭
terbaik untuk Sabah dan sarawak.
sabah dan sarawak bagian dari kalimantan yang terpisahkan.
salam cinta dari pulau kalimantan
Serawak merdeka
salam 1 dayak salam budaya.. dari Dayak KDMR sabah🙏🏻
masuklah negara india kitorang tak heran
Sabah+sarawak+kalimantan= Negara Borneo
@@kylezzz397 hahaha mana boleh kau negara indon,maksud indon kepulauan india
Yang saya tahu, Presiden Republik Indonesia Bp Soekarno marah gara gara Inggris menggabungkan Sabah dan Serawak ke Malaysia.
Padahal itu adalah dua kerajaan yang tidak termasuk semenanjung Malaysia.sebagaimana Brunai Darussalam
Saya juga berharap Sabah berpisah dengan persekutuan Malaysia. Sangat Mohon.. kasihan Saya melihat pemimpin Sabah dan Rakyatnya
Keluar dari malaysia,kita Sabah sarawak Unite (North Borneo)💪💪
Kalau berpisah dengan Malaysia.Serawak Akan diambil oleh Brunei Dan Sabah Akan diambil oleh Philippines semula.bodoh Punya budak. serawak Dan Sabah sorry nk berpisah dengan Malaysia
Sabah Sarawak tetap mahu menjadi rakyat malaysia Dan bangga menjadi rakyat malaysia 🇲🇾
Yes kita patut keluar dari malaysia
Im sabahan agree sabah sarawak out from malaysia
Sudah sudahlah ikut telunjuk orang Malaya..langsung tiada guna betul.sudah tiba masanya Sabah Sarawak merdeka.wahai...menteri Sabah Sarawak dengarlah keluhan rakyat.jangan sampai rakyat memberontak.
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
Mantul bang ..
1orang je nak pisah Yang lain tetap bangga menjadi rakyat malaysia 🇲🇾 Dan tidak Akan berpisah dengan Malaysia
@@vladimirputin4215 haha pendukung Israel ni orang katanya malaysia tak sokong israel
@@_z2556 bro Aku sonkong Israel kerana nenek moyang aku orang israel tapi semua tiba2 benci Israel tu la Aku support Israel 🇮🇱
Pelik jika ikhlas mempertikaikan hak sabah kenapa masih undi menyokong bajet 2022? Jangan undi dan tolak bajet ini jika benar² memperjuangkan hak sabah & serawak!!!
Semoga adil & seimbang, Salam damai dari saudara mu satu rumpun melayu di Indonesia 🤝
SABAH DAN SERAWAK MERDEKA
ACEH PALEMBANG KALIMANTAN DAH MERDEKA!!!!
Merdeka
Sarawak msk indonesia, sabah msk philiphines
Aceh Kalimantan Merdeka!!
Merdekaaa.. gaungkan seluruh negeri
Datuk,kami sabagai rekyat sabah sekira nya m63 tidak dilayan oleh menteri persekatuan atau tidak seambing peruntukan sabah dan sarawak, jangan kita tunduk kapala kepada org semananjung lagi kita berusaha sebagai mana yg kita boleh keluar daripada malaysia, kalau tidak, binatang buas memakan kita punya herta atau ternakan di Borneo & sarawak.hati2 datuk...daripada kami rakyat sabahan.
Yerlah aku pon berharap Sabah serawak keluar dari Malaysia
Amin ku doa kan semoga sabah dan sarawak merdeka dari malaysia
Salm sukses dan mkmur tuk sodara" qu yg da dsabah n serawak....kmi rakyat indonesia sllu mndoakn klian....amin
Saya orang sabah sokong sabah keluar malaysia..
Mantap bro gw dukung 🗿🤙🏻🇮🇩
@@unknown-seccnd negara kau pun negeri acheh pun tak ter urus
@@amierulnakimie6726 Indonesia tukar Ibu Negara ke Kalimantan di kepulauan borneo.. Malaysia berani ker nak pindah ibu negara ke Sarawak atau Sabah dikepulauan borneo.. Tak kan ler jawab nyer.. 😂😂😂..
@@sazalisagir147 yelah..dh jakarta nak tenggelam nak buat mcm mne🤣 yang penting sabah sarawak tetap malaysia punya
@@amierulnakimie6726 Lanun memang macam tu hak orang hak diaorang mutlak.. 😂😂😂
Sabah negeri Kami kaya banyak hasil Begitu juga saudara Kami disarawak Kami banyak hasil kaya tapi kenapa bila pembahagian bajet negeri Kami setaraf sama perils yang x ada hasil . kalau bilang perlis hasil padi sabah ada sabahrice kalau bilang kedah hasilkan kopi sabah ada tenom
Sabah dan sarawak bukan negeri
@@Mr.Crabbb negara
Sebab menteri2 kau tu bongok. Sebab tu tak maju2. 🤣
Kemerdekaan serawak dan sabah adalah hak mutlak
Tiada makna kalau merdeka dgn malaysia
Betul la tu bro.. Tapi klu bab harta Sarawak dan Sabah Hak Mutlak Malaya.. Tengok Sejarah bro.. Dulu siapa kuat dia la TAIKO.. Sejarah itu berulang lg bro.. 😂😂😂
bukan semuanya kemajuan di malaya daripada sabah sarawak...cuba kau lihatnya balik....penanaman padi terbesar di malaysia?penanaman kealapa sawit di malaysia?industri perdagangan dan perindustrian di malaysia terbesar di mana?semuanya di malaya....sabah sarawak hanya membekalkan petroleum dan gas....bukannnya malya maju teruk pun ....kau tgk kat kedah,perlis,kelantan....bnyk penanman padi dan bukit penuh je lagi bro....
tapi kalau mau keluar xpelah...keluar sajak lah apa mau buat kami rayat malaya dipersalahkan oleh kamu uran
@@ahmaduwais5588 itu la masalahnya bro...macam kau cakap semuanya disana.. Sabah Sarawak kononnya hanya penyumbang petrolium dan gas.. 2 ni saja.. Tapi dgn hasil 2 ni la dijadikan modal apa yg kau cakap tadi semua di malaya...negeri2 malaya yg mundur mcm kau cakap tu klu di Sabah ibarat Daerah saja keluasannya.. Sabah ada 20 daerah ada yg maju ada yg mundur.. Boleh katakan separuh la pembangunan seperti negeri2 malaya yg kau cakap.. Klu Perlis ibarat daerah Pitas di Sabah cuma kelebihan Perlis ada lg pembangunan kat daerah pitas mari la datang tengok kawasan paitan pitas.. 😂
remember that..
"Before it's too late..
keep that in your mind..
Menuntut kemerdekaan itu merupakan hak Warga Masyarakat Sabah dan Sarawak. Yang perlu diingat, Kemerdekaan memerlukan perjuangan dan pengorbanan yang tidak kecil... Semoga kedamaian selalu menyertai...
Benarkan Acheh,Papua merdeka
@@shamshulanuar7718 Aceh sudah tidak, karena sudah terakomodasi keinginannya, Papua masih ada organisasi Papua merdeka (OPM) yang ingin merdeka, biasalah karena ada iming" dari pihak luar.
Sama seperti Timor Leste, ketika sudah diberikan merdeka... Eh sekarang minta balik ingin kembali ke pangkuan NKRI... Hehehe...
Besok Indonesia/Nusantara... akan jadi MERCUSUAR DUNIA, sehingga tidak menutup kemungkinan ada negara/wilayah yang berkeinginan bergabung dengan Indonesia.
Tanda" sudah nampak, tinggal menunggu Satrio Piningit saja... Hehehe...
Gais kita jgn ikutcampu r urusan ttangga
@@happyfeet5229 berani jamin ga, kalau tetangga ribut kita tidak kena dampaknya...kondisi aman saja tetangga berani memindahkan batas negaranya...
@@inyomansukrawinaya2332 bro Indonesia Kalo command gaduh jadinya
three partners in malaysia, one partner get 10 times the development budget, one partner get 1/10, the last place is sarawak! Poorest state who still blindly support this Barisan Nasional…. Orang Sarawak…. Bangun dari tidur la…..
The People of Sabah and Sarawak has already woken up.. its Just the Menteri "Representing the People" are the ones that are still asleep.. afraid to voice against the Government because of risk to losing their Position
Rakyat harus bangkit dan desak keluar dari gabungan Malaysia..
Wahai pemimpin Sabah dan Sarawak dengarlah keluhan rakyat kita, sudah 58 tahun Sabah dan Sarawak bergabung dgn Malaya menjadi Malaysia, Malaya masih tidak adil, masih mengingkari MA63.Mari Sabah dan Sarawak bangkitlah..
@@MeinGoobbyXInot afraid, selfish, want to keep their own position
Klu kecewa kenapa KO mshdokong Umno?
Semua itu butuh waktu, definisi adil juga bukan berarti 50:50 tapi di lihat siapa yg paling butuh. Saya bukan orang Malaysia tapi melihat berita ini jadi teringat akan nasib warga Papua dimana pembangunan disana bisa mulai membaik setelah menunggu kurang lebih 75th setelah Indonesia merdeka. Sebelumnya di sini juga hanya berpusat di pulau Jawa saja sementara yg lain seperti anak tiri tapi itu cerita lama, kalo sekarang Alhamdulillah sudah merata.
Bro, pak Kitingan juga paham kale, soal adil itu bukan berarti 50:50. Pak Kitingan itu penduduk asli Kalimantan ato disebut suku Dayak, politisi kawakan, dia pasti paham apa itu adil dan apa itu nggak adil bagi pembangunan Sabah dan Sarawak.
Jangan disamain ,beda lah, sok tau
Adil itu seimbang,siapa yg hasilnya banyak dapat banyak ,siapa yg hasilnya sikit dpat sikit ,
SELAIN SOEKARNO DAN JOKOWIDODO ,, ITU PEMIMPIN PENTINGKAN DIRI KELUARGA ,, YG 3 PEMIMPIN INI TAK MASUK
HARTO DAN BEYE ,, KLU MAU TAU TELUSURI FAKTANYA
brisik orang indo g usah ikut campur... tinggal ton ton j
Sabah Sarawak Will be independence
Merdeka
Msk indonesia n philiphines
Bagus sgt ka Malaya terhadap Sabah dan Sarawak?
setuju
@@danielxander3204 bagus sangat ka malaya terhadap sabah dan sarawak???
Saya beharap sangat2 mimpi ku menjadi kenyataan suatu hari nanti sarawak akan keluar dari malaysia.biar anak cucuku dapat menikmati hasil dari negerinya sendiri biarpun sedikit.#AGI IDUP AGI NGELABAN💪
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
Aku orng semenanjung pon harap sangt impian ko tercapai.supaya tiada lagi sengketa antara negeri2 tanah melayu dan negeri borneo.
Ape ke bende kau ni 😐 lupa ke Sape yng Ciptakan Sarawak 😐,Lupa ke susah senang,Tetap Akan bersama,lagipun betul ke kau Sarawak?Ape kate kau je keluar dari Sarawak,Sesuai sangat tu,Bina Negara sendiri,lupa ke Family Sarawak?? Beria naw kau ni,
@@senmturu uji d datai gai mnua srawak kito d kban q mri pla d sbning mmit,ni nmu nka d sdar dh nya nmu d bkani pmrinsa kmi.tok sg kah anak sarawak mpu.kpa tkut.kmi ndang syau k mnua kmi srwak.sg ngai bknsi ngau org bkai.mnua bkai ulih mnsang kmi ka mnsang bka org.nmu d bngka.
@@alienyan2540 Iban Sarawak ka
Jangan main ungutan Dan amaran,terus keluar sja Dari gabungan malaysia.lama lagi Kita tidak keluar , banyak lagi kerugian Kita Sabah Sarawak,
Kembalikan hak sabah sarawak tu syarat untuk sabah dan sarawak kekal dlm Malaysia
Sabah dn sarawak patut keluar
Karana ibukota Indonesia sudah sah pindah ke Kalimantan Tiimur, jangan sampai rakyat Sabah minta ibukota Malaysia pindah ke Serawak ! Nanti bisa 'viral' diseluruh dunia kalau di Pulau Kalimantan ada 3 ibukota Negara Melayu : Brunei, Indonesia dan Malaysia...
bubarkan malesia
@@nshahida3003 baca sejarah timur Leste jng cakap je tp otak kosong ,saya tinggal di aceh kamu bicara tong kosong nyaring bunyinya
@@nshahida3003 negara kau saja belum merdeka bro dari Inggris pakta loh masa merdeka di kasih masa merdeka tiap tahun bayar upeti masa merdeka masih di bawah kaki Inggris pakta loh silahkan cek perjanjian raja raja kalian denggan ratu Yahudi Elizabet di perjanjian Manila .Tokyo dan London bukti pakta
hha iya jg sih...harus lah kita dukung sabah dan serawak merdekeeeh
Saya bangga sama negara saya Indonesia yang penting mah Indonesia aman tentram damai dan juga pembangunan bukan hanya di pulau Jawa saja saat ini keseluruhan merata dan sama rata Alhamdulillah semoga makin maju tuk Indonesia karena saya orang Indonesia 😊
Ape yg dorg xnk bagi sabah sarawak bnyk?Aq semenanjung pon pelik laa,dah banyak kot pembangunan kat sini, fokuskan jela kat sabah srwk dari fokus kat org semenanjung yg xreti bersyukur ni
Semangat sabah dn serawak masa depan kalian d tangan kaum muda sabah serawak sendiri 👍👍👍
kami tak paksa sabah sarawak masuk malaysia
@@gonam7306 kami? Siapa kamu?🧠...
@@gonam7306 jangan jadi bodoh kalau jadi orang ya,
@@NorthBorneo-yg9eg saya orang malaysia
@@NorthBorneo-yg9eg sabah serawak 🤣🤣🤣🤣👎👎
Ayoh anak2 Sabah dan anak2 Sarawak pikir2kanlah masa lalu masa sekarang masa2mendatang dan masa seterusnya yg diwarisi nenek moyang yg di tinggalkan KPD kita timba ilmu bersungguh2 agar generasi muda mendatang tidak keciwa di urus dng baik dan diatur tersusun dengan baik adilsaksama
Tidak pernah ada sejarah dlm Malaysia Menteri Kewangan di lantik dari Sabah dan Sarawak semenjal penubuhan Malaysia.Apa motif nya
Kalau tak layak, takde la dilantik. Buktikan dlu kelayakan dan pencapaian. Simple. Ni tak, banyak kes pemimpin katak silompat katak dan rasuah ada la. Cer kamu check kekayaan pemimpin sabah sarawak. Taib mahmud, musa aman dan lain2.
I'm agree with this Sarawak and Sabah must 'berpisah' and I can't say it wrong but its facts that Kerajaan Semenanjung is *TIDAK ADIL* dan dengan ini rakyat dari Sarawak dan Sabah sudah matang dengan situasi zaman kini Malaysia. As Sarawakian I saw ramai yang mau undi PSB kerana PSB adalah satu2 nya Parti terakhir Sarawakian untuk merdeka lagi. Acctually Sarawak are Already talk about this a long time ago and Masa Sarawak mau dipersatukan dengan kerajaan Malaya orang2 Sarawak atau *Dayak* membantah kerana mereka tau ini tidak boleh berlaku dan Sarawak pada masa itu di mana Dayak wants to make own Country NOT 'dipersatukan' after i heard this peruntukan I'm sad but its normal for Sarawakian because we already feel it already long time. Sarawak is not rich but 'dirompak' oleh kerajaan persekutuan sbb SEE pembangunan persekutuan semenanjung are better than Sarawak and Sabah. AND we are not 'KOYAK' but its True. If you come here you'll see by yours eye how is our 'CITY' and 'ROAD' and our 'INTERNET'. Thats all I'm writing this beacause I was real Sarawakian.
Agree with you ,we need to change this
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
Semoga saudara" qu di Sabah dan Serawak sehat selalu
Tetap semangaaaat
Semangat apa kalau kerajaan malaya menjajah sabah.. Puii
@@smokey5570 dah tu kau suruh la kerajaan sabah berambus,macam bangang je duit sewa dkt filipina tu kau smbung bayar,kau ingt Malaysia tak bayar ke dekat filipina pasal sabah,sabah ni Tanah sewaan nk tk nk kena bayar,bila suruh jadi orang filipina kau tak nk pulak bebal
sabah state constitution..not fair,org semenanjung tak boleh purchase tanah disabah..org sabah boleh beli tanah di semenanjung...ITU ADIL DAN SAKSAMA???
Sabah & Serawak Bisa Maju dan Makmur Jika Keluar Dari Malaysia....
Amiiin semoga sabah sarawak bisa mengatur negara nya sendiri
Tunggu apa lg, smpai bila mau bergantung sma persekutuan??
Salah tu..bukan bergantung..sampai bila sabah sarawak mau kasi suap persekutuan..tu baru betul
Thats true....sabah & sarawak di anak tirikan👍👍🔥
sabah dan sarawak lebih baik keluar dari malaysia buat apa tunggu lagi . sabah dan sarawak hanya di perbodohkan oleh semananjung sehaja . menteri sabah tidak sedar lagi kah
Asean gk akan setuju.. Terutama indonesia dan singapura yg menghormati kedaulatan malaysia.
SELAMAT DATANG SABAH DAN SARAWAK KE INDONESIA😁
SSKM itu yg terbaik, boleh hidup sendiri bah sabahan sarawakian
Bravo Serawak, bravo Sabah .
SEHARUSNYA RAKYAT SABAH DAN SERAWAK KELUAR DR FEDERASI MALAYSIA UNTUK MENENTUKAN NASIB SENDIRI UNTUK MERDEKA SEPENUHNYA.
DAN ACEH PALEMBANG KALIMANTAN PERLU KELUAR DARI INDONESIA UNTUK MERDEKA DAN JAJAH SELURUH INDONESIA!!!!
@@vladimirputin4215 maaf mas ,gagal paham,
Inilah pejuang sabah Paling bnyak lompat parti
Kuar je, semenanjung jauh lbh kaya, xde oil pun, korg kuar, mskkn trus ke indonesia n philiphines
Asean bersatu...
Bergabung saja sama Indonesia 👍
Jefri down waste time at Parliament... Its time for Sabah Borneo Independence..
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
KAMI INDONESIA DUKUNG SABAH SERAWAK KELUAR DR MALAYSIA.. MALAYSIA TRALU MNGUTAMAKAN SEMENANJUNG DAN SUMBER DAYA SABAH SERAWAK CUMAN DIKURAS MEREKA..TANPA MEMBANGUN SARAWAK SABAH...
HORAS SYALOM
merdeka aceh,papua,sumtra bro.....dahlah bunuh sultan ii melayu kesian rakyat sumatra ada darah bansawan tttpi dibunuh jawa dan soekarno menjadi melayu tiada identiti sultan tdk masuk ke malaya ttpi masuk kedalm indonesia laknatullah
aceh merdeka aceh merdeka aceh merdeka aceh merdeka aceh merdeka aceh merdeka
Sayapun sokong Sabah keluar
Malaysia...
Sabah dan sarawak harusnya merseka dari penjajah malaysia
Sabas sabahan serawakin tukar saja kerajaan itu jalan yg terbaik,bungkus kan saja kerajaan BN dan UMNO.
sarawak not serawak.....indo ii masuk cmpur hal xhabis ii
Kalau sabah/Sarawak mau di perhatikan, jangan sokong parti Semananjong.
Sabah anak tiri,sarawak anak angkat,semananjung anak kandung
SABAH & SERAWAK itu negara merdeka, bukan negeri di persekutuan malaysia.
Huguansiou Datuk,biar kah tu malaysia,mari kita keluar malaysia sabah sarawak0
SABAH N SERAWAK ALL THE BEST FOR YOU.BE YOURSELF..BRAVO
Semoga Masy Serawak dan Sabah sehat2 selalu dan bahagia.... 🙏🙏🙏🙏
sabah sarawak penyumbang terbesar kerajaan tapi baget 2022, sabah sarawak dipinggirkan. pemimpin yg tidak adil
Lol this comes from someone that do not understand how the economy works. First of all, Peninsular Malaysia has industries, all major industries that Malaysia has at the moment are located in the Peninsular, except logging, and that is if you want to assume that timber logging is a major industry of Malaysia. Electrical and electronics is here, automotive is here, tourism is mostly here, medical tourism is definitely here, construction is here, rubber glove is here, finance and banking is here, retail trade is here, export processing is here. Even if you think that we don’t have a lot of oil (which we actually do, as much as you do), refineries here are much bigger than those in Sarawak or Sabah. Kertih, Port Dickson, Melaka, and now Pengerang, are much bigger refineries than Bintulu. Yes, we will lose a lot, but we will be fine because of the industries that are here. We will adjust to the drop in revenue. And Petronas will still own and operate those oil fields and refineries that it currently operates, even if Sabah and/or Sarawak left. If Sabah and/or Sarawak wants to takeover the fields from Petronas, it has to pay reparations. It is not like you can simply, oh we are now independent, now give back our oil fields.
East Malaysia has oil and wood natural resources - for now - but peninsular Malaysia has industry, population and it’s associated commerce, road and rail and shipping ties with the rest of SE Asia and the world.
People generate economy as much as exports, and with ~7-8M in Sabah and Sarawak, it isn’t enough to create a self-perpetuating economy (which requires around 20-22M people)
While petroleum is the number one export, there are still significant contributions by copper, tin and palm oil. Those three together exceed oil/gas and then there’s the economy of just being a country - roads, bridges, scho9ls,m hospitals, tourism, housing, cars, transport, all generate jobs and add to ‘the economy’ and for Sabah and Sarawak to go their own way, you would lose all the benefits of federalisation and have to pay for everything yourself.
Thinking that Borneo is where all the resources are is just wrong. By far the greatest part of the Malaysian economy is generated in peninsular Malaysia.
Michael Tang has explained in length what might happen to Sarawak and Peninsular had the former leaves the Federation, which in most cases, I agree.
But I also want to point out that the possibility of any members of the Federation to leave is for it to be kicked out of the Federation, like how Singapore was kicked out in 1965. For each members to leave, secession is not an option under the Federal Constitution. Before anyone with any clouts could mobilize to get Sarawak out of Malaysia, the Malaysian government would have already come down hard on them. Although Internal Security Act is no longer there, the government can still use SOSMA, and like what happens now, Emergency Ordinance and curtail freedom of movements and association in the state.
However, assuming that Sarawak or Sabah did leave the Federation, besides what Michael Tang has already said, I also think that Sarawak or Sabah will fall into a state of chaos and civil war. This is because the Dayak (including Ibans) in Sarawak would want to be the controlling power in the newly independent state, while the Malays (including Melanau) would want to retain the power they currently hold. The Malay-Melanau is just the second largest ethnic group in Sarawak, behind the Iban, but they control the politics and government of the state. Even if civil war did not happen immediately, how long before a charismatic Dayak leader could incite an uprising?
This is not something that will never happen, because it has happened. Remember that Dayak Uprising was the reason for the Sultanate of Brunei to relinquish control over Sarawak to James Brooke in the early 19th century, that led to the creation of the White Rajahnate of Sarawak? Brunei was a powerful thalassocracy then that ruled the entire northern half of the island of Borneo, but because its power was only concentrated in Brunei town, the Dayak Uprising caused major havoc in the state then, that the Sultanate had to procure assistance from a European adventurer to quell the rebellion.
If that happens, the Malay-Melanau ruling class would have first tried to quell the rebellion themselves without asking for interventions by any other countries. But the fledgling Sarawak State Army would have also be divided because some of the soldiers might switch side and join the rebellion, as they too are Dayaks. So the army would be divided, and civil war would ensue. The interiors would be the first that the government would lose control over as the Dayaks would have already secured these areas. The police forces too will be divided along ethnic lines. Of course there will be those who are willing to stay loyal to the government, but if a charismatic Dayak leader were to lead a rebellion, many would be enamored and join the cause.
First, the government will try to secure Kuching, as it is the state’s capital. While this could be achieved easily, but if the state does not secure strategic corridors fast, the rebellion would be too big for the state to quell on its own.
The most strategic corridor would be between Kuching and Miri, the coastal areas between these two cities must be secured by the state for it to stand. Dayak rebels would know this too and start attacking army and police posts within this corridor. While Kuching is the largest city and capital of Sarawak, Miri is arguably the economic heartbeat of the state, as it is the hub for oil and gas production in the state.
This is where what is left of Malaysia, or Malaya, would step in, as even with Sarawak being an independent nation, the oil and gas fields offshore Miri and the infrastructure onshore in Bintulu and others are still owned by Petronas. Contracts do not simply become invalid just because a region or state suddenly find themselves independent. That is why the Johor - Singapore Water Agreement is still in force, 50 years after the split. It was also why for 30 years after Malaya’s independence, the biggest landowner was still Guthrie, then a British corporation. So in this case, Petronas, being the national oil company of Malaysia and its successor state in the case of a dissolution of the Federation, will still have a major interest in Sarawak. The successor government of Malaysia will, whether the government of Sarawak likes it or not, interfere in the chaos. Furthermore, Malaysia might still retain their armed force bases in Sarawak, because again, agreements do not automatically become nullified once a state or region becomes independent. Malaysia maintained a naval base in Singapore for several years after the latter’s independence, and Britain maintained their airforce bases in Malaysia after our independence.
Malaysia, having the more powerful armed forces than the fledgling sovereign state of Sarawak, will be able to secure Miri and Bintulu and many strategic positions in the state, whereby Petronas’ infrastructure are located. Even the British and the Dutch government might interfere, because of Royal Dutch Shell’s presence in the state’s oil and gas industry. The British might work together with Malaysia to secure their economic interests in Sarawak, to the detriment of the state’s government. Brunei too might get involved, because they would not want the rebellion to spill over into their territories.
Another power broker would be the Sarawakian Chinese. It is not a secret that there are a lot of powerful Sarawakian Chinese gangs operating in the state. The Malay-Melanau are basically controlling Sarawak in cooperation with the Chinese
Walau pun saya rakyat dari borneo saya tetap berdoa moga malaysia dapat pm yang bagus dan saya ni memang banyak dengar orang cakap keluar malaysia sebab ekonomi tapi bagi saya dah hidup selesa walau pun keadaan kat sini teruk pun dah cukup.
Jadi dengar lah wahai rakyat walau ekonomi seteruk mana ingat bersyukur lah apa yang kita dapat okey.
negeri paling besar tp dpt bajet paling kecil,sgt menyedihkan...
Utk selasaikan masalah ini ttg na63 rujuklah diberitish dan pbb,klu diperlimen malaya samapi kiamatpun tdk dpt selasai
Siapakah setuju kalo Sabah dan Serawak terbebas dri cengkraman Semenanjung Malaysia dan membangun negara kedaulatan sendiri menjadi *Dayaksia* ???😁😁😁
Comment down below~
Malaysia juara dunia nanti tengok lah
Kalau Sabah Sarawak keluar
Kristian yestot
SABAH SARAWAK KELUAR MALAYSIA
Dari pada dianak tirikan terus menerus oleh kerajaan ... Pisah + Merdeka adalah jalan tengah yg elok & terbaik betul tak ...?
"Sabah + Sarawak Merdekaaa ...!!!" 👈❤❤❤
Tak ada pemimpin yg berani mcm Ton Nan dah di Swk ni. Pemimpin yg ada peluang memimpin tu guna lah kuasa yg ada memperjuangkan hak negeri kita. Org akan kenang & menghargai kita selama-lamanya kalau kita mampu membuat satu perubahan utk rakyat.
Semenanjung dpt RM67 billion tp Sabah Sarawak dpt cuma RM10 billion? Tak adil! Saya sbg warga Semenanjung pun TAK setuju. Tak adil buat Borneo
Semenanjung ada 11negeri. Cuba bahagikan. Sebab tu kot camtu. Kira sama rata la gamaknya. Atau... Depend pada ramainya penduduk dan aktiviti ekonomi. Ntah la
@@nshahida3003 masa bntuk malaysia dlu..sabah sarawak ni rakan kongsi..bukan negeri..baik pecahkan sabah jd 12 negeri dan sarawak pun sma..budak2 boleh la nak tipu bnda mcm ti
Terbaik DSP Dr Jeffrey
Teruskan perjuangan membela nasib rakyat Sabah dan Sarawak.
Klu bukan kita siapa lg, klu bukan sekarang bila lagi.
Syabas tahniah.
Sabah dan serawak hrs berani dan berJUANG untuk merdeka
@@WALLET888 woi ko mesti orang indon nak Sabah serawak berpisah dengan Malaysia ko budak Kau tak tau apa yang Akan terjadi.boleh menjadi peperangan Philippines Dan Sabah untuk ambik Sabah semula . serawak Pula Akan diambil oleh Brunei
itu jelah modal orang politik sabah sarawak. yg penyokong sibuk nak keluar sana sini.. kau dengan orang politik sabah sarawak memang tak maju...patutlah sabah sarawak lambat maju...
Sepatutnya sabah dan sarawak dikembalikan pada British,, baru maju ..british lah maju
Bagusnya berdiri kesultanan melayu raya, seluruh nusantara bersatu dalam satu negara .
Kan, apa daya British dah berjaya buat negara boneka di nusantara.
Sumatera dan semenanjung yg paryt bersatu,mcm srivijaya,,dua2 betol2 serumpon,,jawa dayak sume ni mmg dh rumpon jauh sikit
@@ziadelsissy3088 bangla dekat lagi kan?
Buku sejarah kat sana tak tulis ke? Kan m'sia sendiri yang buat kesah. Sejak ianya ditubuhkan, kerena jumlah melayu terlalu sedikit berbanding bangsa china dan India time tu, maka bangsa2 nusantara lain dan pribumi yang ada kat m'sia dianggap sebagai melayu selama ia Islam demi politic.
And yes, Indo bukan cuma melayu, dan m'sia sebenarnya bukan negri melayu karena ada banyak cina dan india, juga orang asli dan dayak.
@@andrewcoongoro bangla rumpon rohingya bangang,,jawa mmg jauh sikit dr melayu dari minang,,
yeah hidupkan Kepulauan Nusatrera ( Malay archieplago)
Negara Sabah dan Sarawak banyak membantu Malaya harap Malaya ada kesedaran berterima kasih Negara Sabah dan Sarawak
Punya jauh beza dia tu bajet..mmng tdk adill...
Semoga sulu bijak tidak memanfaatkan permasalahan ini yang terjadi di malaysia..smoga malaysia tetap berdaulat dan bersatu..salam dari indonesia
freedom sabah srawak...dari BANGLASIA
kau nak aku ejek sabah dengan sarawak tak
Semua ni sejak pemetintahan Mahathir tapi Tak dipersalahkan ,Kenapa kerajaan terkini ,semasa PH isu ni tak timbul pon
Semoga Malaysia bisa menyelesaikan dengan baik urusan dalam negerinya sendiri ...... Salam dan Doa dari Jakarta.
Selesaikan senang ja merdeka sarawak sabah..
Sabah Sarawak itu lebih bahagia Masuk NKRI 🤣🤣🤣 Bebas kemana-mana pun. 🤣🤣🤣 pergi Bali boleh, pergi Papua boleh, pergi Jakarta sangat mudah, pergi Aceh pun sangat boleh, pergi Papua Sekalipu bolehlah 🤣🤣🤣 Indonesia Kaya. 🤣🤣🤣
Buat apa lam-lama di Malaysia 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@SudirmanMendrofa betul kita bangga jadi orang Indonesia karena sekarang sama rata Alhamdulillah mudah mudahan Indonesia ku makin maju amin
Sembang kari kau indo,rakyat sendiri banyak susah,ape lagi nk dapat kerja,mata wang pon rendah
@@SudirmanMendrofarakyat Sabah Sarawak tak nak pakai rupiah...ringgit pun payah nie lagi rupiah😂..jadi kampung lah jawabnya